r/kpopthoughts • • Oct 21 '21

Question A question for Girl Group stans, what boy groups are Girl Group Stan friendly?

Let me elaborate.

My little sister is a girl group stan, it's really hard for her to like a boygroup and her community of friends who are interested in Kpop are also girl group stans, one day we were all having a conversation and I asked, what are some boy groups girl group stans like?

The answer is always the same: Seventeen or TXT.

In fact, my sister is a MoaCarat :3

So, I decided to ask here to see what the reddit Girl Group Stan community has to say about this, what groups do you guys consider girl group stan friendly and why?

99 Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 21 '21

Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read.

Oh, and you can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

50

u/Light_A_Fish Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21

I've seen Astro being recommended with topics like this so you can check them out (´︶`)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Any song recommendation?

20

u/Light_A_Fish Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21

Woo, I'll try so hopefully you like them!

After Midnight

All Night

Baby

Breathless

Confession

Crazy Sexy Cool

HIDE&SEEK

Also, Pentagon have songs that seems like what you're looking for so I'll have them here too!

DO or NOT

HAPPINESS

Humph!

Pretty Pretty

Round 1

Round 2

Shine

Also, B1A4 have some very upbeat songs from what I know so hopefully they'll fit what you want!

BABY GOOD NIGHT

BANA (I don't think this is an official song but it's cute so I had to) (Also, Bana is B1A4's Fandom name)

Beautiful Target

O.K

Only Learned Bad Things

SOLO DAY

What's Happening?

(I'm not sure if these are exactly what you would want but hopefully everything here fits what you wanted! And hope it's well-received and liked!!)

Edit: Wanted to add some more groups such as BTOB and ONF but I think others can do that for me

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Thank you for the list!

3

u/Light_A_Fish Oct 21 '21

No problem!!

Though I'm not, like, a dedicated fan where I follow them - I've only casually listened to them, personally, these are some of my favorites haha so I do hope you and your sister like them somewhat (´︶`)

5

u/Zoshi2200 Oct 21 '21

I would like to add Blue flame from Astro.

5

u/Light_A_Fish Oct 21 '21

Oh my, I can't believe I forgot about Blue Flame!! I remember listening it so much when it came out! It's so good!!

42

u/Nmey54 Oct 21 '21

Oneus-i don't think i've ever disliked any of their songs,even the more typical boy group songs like TBONTB and No diggity but i like all RBW groups so far

Snuper-i love Sweetune and the songs they produced for 9Muses and Kara so i ended up loving Snuper and their retro songs

5

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Oneus? that's interesting… I like their music as well.

Snuper, that group… I never heard of, I might give them a listen.

11

u/Nmey54 Oct 21 '21

Give Platonic love a listen,imo the best retro song in kpop

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I will!

7

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Funny you mentioned No Diggity because that song always gave me gg vibes. Like I hope one day someone makes a mashup of No Diggity and a Blackpink song. I think they’d compliment each other well

I think also aside from their discography, Oneus also covers gg songs/chreos as frequent as they do bgs. And they always do a good job with the choreos and respect them.

7

u/Cultural-Ad4546 Oct 21 '21

I know quite a few tomoons that are gg fans too but have one exception for bgs which is ONEUS, so I think there’s something different with oneus songs

113

u/OwlsWithHats Oct 21 '21

As an SNSD fan I've always liked SHINee, their fandom is also the only SM bg fandom I haven't seen shit on the female idols in SM (generally speaking.)

27

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Shinee! they're really great and also super likable imo.

14

u/coolofmetotry hype boy Oct 21 '21

i was going to answer SHINee as well. good vocals, the members have GG friends all over the industry.

31

u/prnth_y girls generation's horsehair weave Oct 21 '21

CIX is also a popular choice among gg stans. I'd recommend Movie Star.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

CIX are amazing!

30

u/pornypete r/GFRIEND | Yuju | Hoppipolla | ADORA | g.o.d Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21

I listen mainly to girl groups. My favorite boy groups are Astro, Seventeen, E’last, g.o.d and Super Junior.

Edit: And BTOB! How did I forget!

-33

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Super Junior? really? even with how sexist they've been? are you a man by any chance?

7

u/Anonymous33- Oct 21 '21

I think this user likes super junior’s music more. Idk what’s the matter of super junior being called sexist but I believe that their music has nothing to with their personalities: for eg: Chris brown, his music is really good but we all know his character and personality and also Justin beiber, millions of people love his music even though there are many evidences of his ableism. No can deny that their music is top tier. Maybe that’s what super junior is for many people?

8

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I respect that but I personally can't do such separation, I don't listen to the people you mentioned for the same reason also, since we're talking about GG stans I don't often see Super Junior's name being mentioned because of the same thing, I hope that's understandable.

3

u/Anonymous33- Oct 21 '21

Yes yes I understand. I do understand that some people don’t want to listen a musician’s work if their character is bad or something that’s considered bad? Among fans and it’s totally okay and understandable

25

u/tooleyloo Oct 21 '21

Whether this commenter is a man or not, or knew about SJ being sexist or not—you asking “are you a man by any chance” is also sexist OP. It’s a rude generalization. And sheesh, the whole tone of your reply was just kinda mean…

18

u/pornypete r/GFRIEND | Yuju | Hoppipolla | ADORA | g.o.d Oct 21 '21

No clue about what they've said or done. But their music is really good.

36

u/ShelteredHomeschool Snow dream under the sky Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21

I feel like this thread doesn't mention NCT Dream enough so I will make it my responsibility to put them here. /s

No but really, Seventeen are my ults and after that I got hooked onto txt for awhile but then ggs happened, I now mainly stan g-idle, aespa, svt, and nct dream. Now it maybe hard for some to understand why nct dream is gg stan friendly especially when one look on stan twt you would see girlfriend stans, but their discography will and would make you feel like a disney princess.

My fave picks from nct dream for gg stans are:

Irreplaceable, We go up, Candle light, My first and last, Fireflies,

I also kind of feel like I'm very safe with them??? Most bgs are definitely fun and lively but with grps like svt, txt, and dream, they're the kind that feels soft and feels very friendly, the kind that welcomes you without much intent for romantic relationships (idk what im saying here ;-;).

(Why am i downvoted? Now I'm sad 😢)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Hi love! my sister also said she feels "safe" with TXT and SVT so I definitely get what you mean, she doesn't stan NCT dream but she does like Renjun a lot so I get what you're saying!

7

u/ShelteredHomeschool Snow dream under the sky Oct 21 '21

Oml really?? My renjun biased heart💚

46

u/witchytragedy Oct 21 '21

I guess with TXT it's something to do with the whimsy fairytale-like music/theme they used to have? I'm not sure what I said even makes sense but a gg stan friend of mine really enjoyed the whole magical boys thing they had going on.

Personally Shinee, NCT Dream and Ab6ix could be gg stan friendly?

18

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I definitely see that, it might also have to do with the fandom itself being girl group friendly? idk honestly but every time I see TXT interacting with girl groups/girls in the industry it's always hyped and MOAs always want a collab (it has happened with Chungha, StayC, Itzy, etc)

10

u/tulipbunnys nct dream Oct 21 '21

i’ve seen lots of people become “dreamaespa” fans, for both nct dream & aespa

32

u/groointhepark Oct 21 '21

I came right in the comments to say that many gg stan mutuals of mine seem to mostly have Seventeen and/or TXT as their preferred boy group but you'd already said that yourself 😂

I myself am also in GG stan + BTS circles so I often see those stans but that could be confirmation bias on my part. Shinee pops up amongst gg stans frequently too!

11

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

BTS are really cool, I like their dreamy like songs like Serendipity, Mikrokosmos, Euphoria and Magic Shop or Home.

4

u/95emink Hybe HQ window cleaner Oct 21 '21

Yup, that would be all my ults

10

u/paulfauvelfrost Oct 21 '21

i was solely a gg stan back then like i would refuse to listen to bgs but seventeen changed that and now i listen to them and the boyz as well

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

The Boyz are really cool!

16

u/vivianlight Aqua Pearl Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21

Yes, Seventeen is always one of the first answers, I don't know why but I myself am interested in them too (even if I'm not properly a carat I even follow their subreddit so I can be informed of new music or main activities). TXT a popular answer too. My favourite bg is SHINee though and usually Taemin is popular as a soloist as well (probably because he has always talked a lot about his inspiration from female artists, female dancers are used well in his choreographies and so on) and the other members quite appreciated too. I would suggest them. In general the fandom is quite nice to female artists as well (I'm not saying that the others necessarily aren't but I hope you get it, I just think shawols are usually nice). I recently got into Astro as well and I think their music could fit as well as their concepts, and maybe ONF (Popping is so good!) too?

I noticed that who doesn't follow bgs could be quite interested in kband though. For example I really like Onewe and The Rose (The Rose are currently enlisted).

6

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Oh definitely, my sister loves both, The Rose and OneWe as well.

31

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

The answer is always the same: Seventeen or TXT

Yea, and I honestly don't know why that's always the answer.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I wonder what makes those two groups Girl Group stan friendly, it's really cool tbh <3 but I wish I had an explanation for it.

5

u/No-Pie2181 Oct 22 '21

Someone made a quite detailed post on this abt Seventeen

40

u/shoelacehips Oct 21 '21

I'm not sure about TXT but Seventeen's traditional freshteen concepts have been a bit aligned more towards 'girl group music'. They debuted when a lot of boy groups were doing darker/hip-hop music with a very bright, fresh concept that was more focused on melodies and harmonies. Even some of their choreography can seem more 'traditionally feminine' in the sense that they emphasise hand/arm movements and creating a picture from their positioning. I could easily imagine Pretty U or Oh My or Aju Nice being songs by bright girl groups, like Twice or Oh My Girl, or even WJSN, Weeekly or Stayc.

They also covered a lot of girl group songs early in their career and kept the dances as close or identical to the original choreography, without making it look like they're mocking girl group dancing, which sometimes some male idols can do so. A lot of girl groups also covered their songs or are fans of Seventeen, which also helps the girl group fans if they want to check on them. Off the top of my head, I can think of Twice, Mamamoo, Gfriend, Oh My Girl, Dreamcatcher all doing at least one Seventeen cover.

A lot of Carats are girl group fans, but they tend to have more variety in the type of girl group sound they like.

18

u/CameraLarge4749 Oct 21 '21

It's their concept and also the fact that in seventeen's case is that whenever they cover a gg songs they are always really respectful there is no overreacting or mocking they enjoy the performance from begining to end. Also a lot of the members are gg stan Dino is hard core fan of a pink seungkwan is obsess with wonder girls so I feel like this makes the gg stans see that they have a lot in common

9

u/Dramatic-Silence Oct 21 '21

Hmm, it's hard to say without knowing what they enjoy about gg. If its aesthetic mvs and concept photos I'd say A.C.E. I would't say all their music could fit a gg style as of now( I do want gg to go harder sometimes). I'd recommend Take Me Higher Note: 5th Chan was with UNB during this release And Higher

Another option is OnlyOneOf, even tho their current situation saddens me. Vocal wise its really soothing. My favorites are: dOra maar, questiOn mark, and tear of gOd

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I like ACE's aesthetics but my sister told me one of their members was seen making misogynistic remarks during a reality show he was in, which was kind of shitty tbh, I hope he educated himself and grew from that.

OnlyOneOf! I've heard about them and I like their music, I'll listen to the recommendations, thank you <3 oh also, what is their situation?

11

u/RRedFlower Oct 21 '21

It seems like there is a misunderstanding, so I'll explain. I'm assuming, your sister was talking about this clip? Because this is what blew up a few monts ago, after some Orbits couldn't stand the fact that Choice wanted to vote for A.C.E instead of Loona in The Show pre-voting and decided to use this clip against A.C.E. The thing is, people were trying to create an issue out of the remarks about destroying/killing the girls team made by the first 2 people in the clip. But these guys are not even A.C.E members. And Byeongkwan didn't say anything you wouldn't hear during a competition. You can even see him saying he'd like to compete with the girls team again in the future later in the episode, after the boys team lost. So, all Byeongkwan did was seeing the girls as rivals, there is nothing misogynistic about it. Like I said, this blew up recently years later, to the point where the company had to address the issue, not only protecting their artists, but also calling out the programm for their malicious editing that benefited to no one. You can read their statement here. I'd also like to add that Byeongkwan has previously expessed his respect towards girl groups very clearly.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Oh I'm glad to know it was all a misunderstanding! thank you for the info!

7

u/Dramatic-Silence Oct 21 '21

Hmm, I wonder what member and what show, if they could tell you, could you let me know?

Get ready for a list of stuff: with OnlyOneOf the leader and main vocalist apparently decided to leave the group. Which by itself is not a problem, but the company's actions following is concerning.

They blacklisted his name, Love/Park Jisung, from fancafe and suspending people who referred to him or commenting on his old posts. Blacklisted name from emails, instant return. Didn't post the departure statement anywhere other than the fancafe(this is important cause they previously released notices on twitter as well). Didn't publicly confirm it when it hit 3rd party news sites. Rushed a rebranding, rushed a single release that even the composer said it was rushed. Haphazardly cropped Love out of pfps and banners. Never rescheduled the fansign they promised they would do in the departure statement.

Speculation: Seemingly forbade his name being mentioned by the other members during youtube lives; people say this due to lives were Love is mentioned doesn't get reuploaded and the members seem to have a radio-silence period aftewards.

Unconfirmed: but seems adjacent, Love was featured as a backing vocals on a song by a producer friend that was scheduled to be released last month. The fanbase found out, and all promo for the song was deleted from sns. The song was released on time, but was removed about 24hrs later from streaming sites.

Tl;dr: Good artists, deeply involved in the creation of music, awful company that was has done questionable stuff before this that will be too long to list here (I got a ~10pg doc recording this🙃)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Ofc, no problem, I asked and she told me the show is MixNine and the member was Byeongkwan.

And what is happening to OnlyOneOf sounds so shady and sketchy, I wish these companies provided fans with information (which I believe is the right thing to do) instead of acting like someone simply doesn't exist anymore… I hope the issue gets resolved soon.

4

u/Dramatic-Silence Oct 21 '21

Ah, anything from competition shows I take with a grain of salt. I don't watch those types of shows, but I don't recall anything from him or the other members thats really questionable in other content, but I'm willing to be wrong. Recent activities makes me think if this exchange did occur as stated (like not bad editing/translation), they've definitely grown.

With OnlyOneOf this started August 2... still ongoing. Its sad because he trained so long to debut(7years iirc and family against it), so its sad regardless. But its more frustrating cause we don't know if he wants to live a private life... so we could stop yelling at the company and using his name/image... or if he's still in the company and has a job, times are rough

8

u/Witterson 다같이 외쳐보자 지구는 하나다 Oct 21 '21

Pretty sure OP is talking about the Choice-Orbit drama that happened this past summer when a clip from MixNine was taken out of context to try and make Byeongkwan look bad because Choice wanted to vote for A.C.E on The Show.

3

u/Dramatic-Silence Oct 21 '21

Ah, I hope that's the case. I wasn't real active on kpop net-spaces until more recently, and even then I actively try to avoid unsourced drama.

Tbh it would've been odd he was tapped to be a host on ASC if that was something true hanging on him

4

u/InsolentCat Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21

Huh, I didn't know about the ace thing. I googled, and apparently during mixnine in a live when asked to guess what gifts would someone's sister like, they said designer bags? It caused backlash, and the company said they are taking classes on feminism to educate themselves.

As for OnlyOneOf, their leader and main vocalist Love left the group some time ago without warning, and fans still don't have any news from him.

12

u/kaguraa Oct 21 '21

definitely exo. i know a lot of gg stans often check out exo group music or soloist music because they tend to be vocal-heavy with good instrumentals

5

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

EXO's discography is incredible, my sister is a former EXO-L.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Astro & Enhypen!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Enha? that's a first, I personally really like them but the GG stans I know didn't really like their latest release.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I mean people have different preferences, but my friends and I really like their new stuff since it's so much fun!

4

u/ataraxiias Oct 21 '21

unpopular opinion because they are kind of very boy-group-y, but i considered myself strictly a girlgroup stan until i checked out ateez. if your sister has a big appreciation for good and impactful stage performances, they might be worth checking out. that probably won't be the case if all she wants out of her kpop groups is amazing pop songs and intricate choreography, nct or enhypen could be better choices if that's what sells a group for her.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

She doesn’t like Ateez but thank you.

1

u/ataraxiias Oct 22 '21

i saw nct dream were recommended under this post too. how did that go?

9

u/Anonymous33- Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21

Since you’ve already mentioned svt and txt, ig stray kids and got7 are one among the major groups gg stans like?

Edit: hold up, why am I getting downvoted for mentioning stray kids and got7 liked among gg stans? What am I missing ? God these fans 😂😂💀

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I… I'm not so sure about the last two ngl.

3

u/Anonymous33- Oct 21 '21

Even I’m not sure, that’s why I mentioned “ig” but I’ve seen many once who are fans of stray kids and got7 since both these boy groups have also did cover on gg dances, I mean we have bambam and Felix who are known to be fans of gg.

5

u/Physical_Ad_6226 Oct 21 '21

Well I don’t know why you got downvoted for mentioning those groups. Both have great songs. I upvoted you so now you’re at zero instead of negative.

1

u/Affectionate_Dirt_65 Oct 23 '21

Yeah I have seen many stayblinks and staymidzys on twt

79

u/loyalpagina We are Mamamoo... oh... I am Apink Oct 21 '21

For me it’s BTOB, though my gg ults have influenced it. Mamamoo has the vocals and very lively personalities like BTOB, and Apink and BTOB are really close group friends (like a lot of Pandas found BTOB through Apink and Melodies found Apink through BTOB, same with Beast/Highlight who are also friends with the groups). Also BTOB’s music isn’t as hard or rough as other boy groups and that is also one of the reasons I stan girl groups

26

u/uzzues Oct 21 '21

BTOB! i mainly listen to girl groups and am an exo stan so i don't really keep up with all their releases/content but they're the least in-your-face kind of boy group i can think of (apart from Seventeen for most of their releases), their songs are usually more chill, vocals-heavy with very sweet and meaningful lyrics, some of their songs i like are Missing You, Movie, I'll Be Your Man (this song is pretty emo), Only One For Me and Outsider.

also I literally only know like a few songs from them and i don't recognise most members but for some reason I feel like N.Flying would be girl group stan-friendly.

26

u/starrystillness 최최차차 Oct 21 '21

ASTRO's probably a good answer. To this day, they're known as one of the aces when it comes to bright, fun, refreshing concepts. From their debut days like Hide & Seek and Breathless, to Baby and Crazy, Sexy, Cool, and this year's All Good and After Midnight.

I'd also say that SF9 might work, too? Their early tracks may have been a bit formulaic, but since Now or Never they've stepped into a classy, sleek, gentleman image. Even the sexiness of this year's Tear Drop was commented on by Sera (formerly of 9Muses) as something a girl group would do. And they've got a bunch of actors if the GG stans are in the mood for dramas/webdramas.

22

u/vivismaid Oct 21 '21

surprised nobody has said the boyz lmao back in 2019 i only stanned tbz + svt and girl groups

11

u/TimVdV Oct 21 '21

I’m a girl group stan with the only boy groups being TxT, BTS and Stray Kids

Fun fact I got into Stray Kids because I heard the NiziU girls appeared in two of their MVs and I wanted to check it out and ended up liking the songs

20

u/StalkerPoetess Oct 21 '21

I would say SHINee and NCT Dream, f(SHINee) used to be huge and the shawol fandom is very ggs friendly. Their songs are also very bright and dreamy so they're easy to listen for someone who is used to those concepts. Same with Dream music wise, they debuted young and have very age appropriate music, their debut Chewing gum was even supposed to be a Red Velvet song. Plus if you're an aespa fan you'll be welcome to nctzen spaces, the NCT sub group chat turns into an aespa one whenever they release something to the point that it almost gets as much attention as NCT stuff lol.

27

u/sailormoonwasmyfirst Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21

ONF!!! For many reasons

  1. from observation, a lot of Twitter fuse post exclusively ONF content + various girl groups and that’s it (I see a lot of LOONA and OMG overlap)

  2. fits people with primarily GG taste: I’ve seen multiple times, “ONF are a boy group who makes girl group music.” Not that they never make “masculine” sounding songs, but their music tends to be very melodic and they aren’t afraid to go cute, sassy and bright. I would absolutely never describe their music as industrial, heavy or harsh sounding which is what turns a lot of people off from a lot of other bgs (fairly or not) In my 4 years of Kpop fandom, I’ve liked 2 other boy groups enough to listen to their full discography (BTS and TXT who are already mentioned here). I’ve listened to MANY gg’s full discography

  3. international fandom seems to be very “multi-friendly” - generally a little more mature and people who are longtime Kpop fans. I’ve never seen any rants shaming people for buying another group’s album as I have for many groups. ONF don’t have a big enough international fanbase to be a “gateway” Kpop group, people are fans of other groups first and then ONF just swoops in and becomes their #1.

edit: OH AND ALSO!!! their producer for EVERY song is part of monotree, who are acclaimed for LOONA’s pre-2020 music and have worked with many iconic soloists and girl groups. You can really hear it in the way they write

5

u/ataraxiias Oct 21 '21

this recommendation is so on point! onf have some seriously good songs. i ult oh my girl, so i guess it rings true that miracles rock with onf. their title tracks are pure pop smash hits and i love that they've got a signature monotree sound to them. it seems to me that boy groups used to release energetic and funky bops way more often in the 2nd gen but now it's onf that's doing wonders for that niche.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I'm purely speaking for myself, because I'm sure a lot will disagree with me but the only boy group whose albums I listen to are NCT 127. I know they're seen as the most "typical" loud music, but I kinda enjoy it only when they're doing it😭😭

Also liked enhypen's first two minis, the full album didnt do much for me.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

OH MY GOD MY SISTER DIDN'T LIKE ENHYPEN'S ALBUM EITHER.

I'm an engene but I respect other people's tastes and opinions so it's okay, honestly, actually yesterday I was watching one of their stages and she was like "I really really like the boys but oh their new album is a skip for me, I'm sorry", she also told me how she didn't like that there was almost no horror in the new MV and she really likes that about Enha.

18

u/CameraLarge4749 Oct 21 '21

Your sister is right whenever I came across a gg stan it's always seventeen, TXT and I will add shinee as well

15

u/wujudaestar Oct 21 '21

pentagon, the boyz, golden child, astro, verivery.. probably oneus too

14

u/Zoshi2200 Oct 21 '21

SHINee definitely. The group itself are so supportive of the girl groups

1

u/riotouspancakes Oct 22 '21

The iconic Girl Power jersey comes to mind

(Not that that’s the only example)

7

u/nanananan02 Oct 21 '21

As a gg stan and moa i would recommend ONF !

13

u/DooOooT-dOOoOOt Sub to r/MarkLee Oct 21 '21

Tbh NCT Dream stans are usually dream + ggs myself included.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

i consider myself a girl group stan (since i listen to their songs, collect their albums, and watch their variety shows more) and the only boy groups i actively listen to are shinee, the boyz, txt, and the few odd songs from others

6

u/youngskywalker_ Gongbu hate 😡Music LIKE 😍So right now 🎶Thinkin bout chu 🎶 Oct 21 '21

i looove monsta x. nct/wayv too!

5

u/softggukie Oct 21 '21

nct dream, especially haechan and renjun are popular with gg stans

9

u/0pioh Oct 21 '21

Nct dream !!! The boys are so likeable and their concepts are so just 👌

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I’m a girl group stan but I love shinee’s onew, most of monsta x and jungkook & V from BTS. I like male idols who are both manly and cute at the same time, I don’t really find male idols who are only manly or only cute that attractive or entertaining.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I appreciate your input but I was asking about music <3

2

u/guaripolo1560 Oct 21 '21

I love Monsta X and enjoy listening to ONF, EXO, and Cravity.

I don't like TXT and Seventeen lol

7

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21

You sure are different then, my sister and her friends can't stand neither Monsta X or Cravity.

They do like EXO though and don't know who ONF is.

9

u/guaripolo1560 Oct 21 '21

ONF has really good songs. Beautiful Beautiful and Popping are one of my favorite songs from them.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I might listen to them one day.

11

u/Jazzlike-Boot2714 Oct 21 '21

Agree with op. Txt and seventeen have the most gg stan friendly songs. It's easy to listen to, and very catchy hooks.

4

u/sunmiholic 2nd gen graveyard Oct 21 '21

SHINee & Nct dream.

4

u/caratleslie Deureotda nwatda haji gamjeongui loop Oct 22 '21

I agree with SVT and TXT, but I'd also add Astro and Shinee.

4

u/AlterEgoJ0627 Oct 22 '21

Seventeen is so easy for GG syans becauae of how chill the fanbase is, and you can see how respectful the boys are to women.

10

u/luvie06 Oct 21 '21

Im a girl group stan and TXT and Seventeen are the only bg that ever appealed to me

1

u/noexitmylove Monbebe in heart and soul. Oct 21 '21

My favourite boy groups are Monsta X, Cravity and P1Harmony, I'm pretty sure none of those would be considered "gg stan friendly".

Their sound isn't anywhere close to most girl groups' vibe, which is what I love about them. Groups like Seventeen and TXT overall aren't my style.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

The thing about P1Harmony for me is that a man from that group harassed a moot on twitter and I can't forget about it so it kind of ruined the group for me.

But hey Monsta X and Cravity have appeared twice in the list so maybe some GG stans do like them although not the ones I know.

4

u/noexitmylove Monbebe in heart and soul. Oct 21 '21

I see, I don't really keep up with them outside of their music. Mind telling me what it was about?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21

Keeho harassed her and other POC girls on twitter, I'm sure you can find out about it if you search "Keeho controversy" on google, he was quite graphic on what he wanted to do to them, he also made very inappropriate comments about other Kpop idols (Especially BTS Jimin) and… Apparently he said it was all a lie and that he had a "shared" account with other people who were the ones responsible of tweeting and doing that horrible stuff on his account, not him, but the victims, especially the one I had the chance of knowing on twt still to this day say it was him.

1

u/noexitmylove Monbebe in heart and soul. Oct 21 '21

Damn, thanks for the info. I'll definitely do some reading.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Welcome <3

5

u/PrincessZaiross you know what it is AnNYeOngHasEyO Oct 21 '21

Coming from someone who was originally only a girlgroup stan, I would say GOT7 is a very gg stan friendly group for multiple reasons that might not only be music related.

The members are very well-mannered. There are so many videos of Jackson making women feel safe around him. The most known ones are where he comforts Irene and performs Nunu Nana with Jessi, while they performed arm in arm he made sure not to touch her inappropriately. Jinyoung also protected Irene from creepy cameras. There was another video where a man pushed a woman and Jackson and Jinyoung both lectured him immediately not to push women. Or videos of JB and Yugyeom helping female fans who fell down in the crowd of fans. I could list multiple occasions when the members behave like absolute gentlemen. Fans even made compilations of gentleman moments for them.

They are also very close to other female idols and luckily don’t get shipped with them. BamBam is very good friend of Lisa since their childhood. Jinyoung and Jisoo had funny interactions as well when they both were hosts for Inkigayo (I love this as an Ahgablink). All of GOT7 are good friends with Mamamoo, especially Moonbyul and Wheein. BamBam and Youngjae are also very close to Minnie from G-Idle and Seulgi from RV. BB and Sunmi have sich a cute lil brother big sis energy!

Jinyoung always had accompanying actresses in his dramas and you can see in their behind the scenes how comfortable all of the women are with him.

As a woman myself, all these things really made me love the seven men even more.

Idk how old your lil sister is, but maybe she’ll like Just Right by GOT7. I’d argue it’s a universally liked song for both gg and bg stans. :)

2

u/Luffytheeternalking Oct 22 '21

I once watched jinyoung shielding Irene and was so impressed. I have a soft spot for GOT7.

1

u/PrincessZaiross you know what it is AnNYeOngHasEyO Oct 22 '21

Glad you feel that way! :) btw nice to find a fellow OP lover here

1

u/Luffytheeternalking Oct 22 '21

OP lover?? I don't understand.. .

1

u/PrincessZaiross you know what it is AnNYeOngHasEyO Oct 22 '21

One Piece

2

u/Luffytheeternalking Oct 22 '21

facepalm I was thinking it's original poster. I absolutely love one piece. What can I say we have fine tastes. One piece for the win ✌.

10

u/Dependent_Row_4280 Oct 21 '21

TXT a lot of gg stans either stan them or like them or don't hate them which is pretty good since most gg stans are "we hate men" or "all bgs are trash" there is even this saying on stan twitter "the girls and txt" or "txt honorary gg" since they are the only bg usually on charts with other 4th gen ggs

2

u/Thoughts0707 Oct 21 '21

well im a bg stan but my younger sister is a gg stan and she loves ateezs bright concepts? like dreamer, wave/illusion, answer, eternal sunshine are songs and music videos she watches on a regular basis, she also loves their bsides like take me home, utopia, all about you, celebrate, mist and such. I dont know if its helpful

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 21 '21

Hello /u/Thoughts0707. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/jungk00kaah Oct 21 '21

I would say a girl group friendly group is THE BOYZ or MCND. a good mix between refreshing concepts or more upbeat concepts.

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 21 '21

Hello /u/jungk00kaah. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Just any boy group who tends to put out rhythmic music instead of heavy drop stuff, the ones I usually check for are TXT and oneus, and recently I've been liking enhypen. Boy group bright concepts are really nice like earlier seventeen and astro stuff, I wish they did those more often. I like boy bands more though, like lucy, day6 and onewe

2

u/Icy-Resolution-5352 i - u Oct 22 '21

I'd say I'm a G girl group stan, but my two favourite boy groups are Stray Kids(I've Always liked EDM) and Day6. Maybe a factor for this was that my ult girl group is Twice and there are a few interactions between the groups, as well as content they share (like JYP Superstar)

2

u/Separate-Meringue888 Oct 22 '21

I used to only stan ggs (I still stan 11 now) and, idk I guess I just generally avoided bgs as a whole. but if I had to choose I'd say Super Junior? cuz you just HAVE to sort of like (?) heechul after so many eps of knowing bros

tbh back then I was also okay with stray kids cuz my sister stans them, and since I stan twice and itzy and especially twice interacted with skz a LOT (you just have to come across the Bang Chan x Sana cute interactions vids) I was also okay abt them

4

u/hellocherbear Iridescent Turquoise Oct 21 '21

Oneus! A gender fluid group. They rarely have uber masculine performances. They almost always perform elegant or sleek concepts.

But performance aside the members are just really feminine in general! Especially the maknae line huhu so precious.

3

u/plutojhs Oct 21 '21

I’m a girl group stan but my ult group is bts I cannot get into any boy groups no matter how hard I try but there’s just something about them which I love so much

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

I'm an atiny and I've noticed a lot of the atiny multis also stan stayc, itzy, dreamcatcher, loona, chungha, fromis, everglow etc etc. So maybe ateez? I guess it also depends on what kind of girl groups the stan in question likes. Do they like cute and fresh concepts? Or do they like dark girl crush? I imagine those who like the former would like seventeen and astro while those who like the latter would like ateez, skz, nct.

1

u/camalalastep Oct 22 '21

they're not active as a group, but Infinite songs are pretty good, I think they really have that kind of vibe a gg stan would like to hear in a song from a bg

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 22 '21

Hello /u/camalalastep. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Famous_Ad_4542 Oct 22 '21

none, i dont like any bg's

1

u/wolfgangster1817 Oct 22 '21

The Nation's Misandrists who just had a comeback earlier with an energized rock concept. Stream Rock With You, people.

1

u/Affectionate_Dirt_65 Oct 23 '21

Depends on which genre you prefer

0

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

[deleted]

12

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

My sister once told me Ateez should do more bright concepts so yeah, I get that.