r/kpopthoughts • u/Dependent_Row_4280 • Oct 20 '21
Discussion Between charting really well or selling really well why do you think idols prefer?
This was just a thought i had I my head after seeing a post about 4th gen sales do you think idols prefer charting well over selling well and if so why do you think so personally I think they'd want sales since that brings in more money I mean selling well means you have a good strong fandom. I know that's not all music is about but we all know it does matter a bit
What do you think?
122
u/kaguraa Oct 20 '21
charting well because it gives you cf deals, attend popular shows, get invites to perform at concerts/festivals and makes you popular among the gp, which will help you long-term when you eventually starts individual activities.
18
u/notalotofoptions Oct 20 '21
Agree. Most musicians don’t make that much from album sales and streaming. The bulk of their income is touring, merch, and sponsorship.
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 20 '21
Hello /u/notalotofoptions. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
4
u/Ok_Present_8373 Oct 20 '21
That's true but selling well gets you the most money. Essentially charting gets you recognized and popularity. But selling, gets you the real money.
2
u/plushie_dreams Oct 20 '21
High album sales mean you've got a lot of dedicated fans who will attend your concerts and buy your merch, and concert tours bring in so much money, more so than most CF deals. Once the pandemic really dies down, 4th gen bgs will start touring and they will certainly make more money than groups like OMG, a domestically popular 3rd gen group which charts well but has modest album sales.
Album sales >>>> charing well
75
44
u/ivegotaqueso 🍒🌼🆎6️⃣ℹ️❎🌸🍒 Oct 20 '21 edited Oct 20 '21
Whatever puts more money in their pockets. Usually this means charting well since charting can lead to well-paying opportunities and brand sponsors.
Zico doesn’t sell well (his highest physical album sales was around 35k) but he charts well and he’s doing very well for himself.
Charting well also means more Koreans are probably going to attend your domestic concerts too, although concerts are moot right now due to Covid.
However album sales are tremendously high, higher than ever before, so this might also mean more opportunities touring to bigger crowds overseas, although usually those opportunities are in other countries where the international fans are. Which is also still a closed road to most groups due Covid. Although who knows if the 2022 concerts are still game on.
12
u/StayvilleResident8 Oct 20 '21
Hmm I think it depends on what their perception of being an idol is and what their goals are overall. Like what aspect of being an idol do they want to focus on? There are some people who become idols because they think it's an easier gateway to acting. There's some who truly love music and the music making process. Theres some who just love performing... and im pretty sure there's some who like the attention. The list goes on. I think it's totally okay to change objectives throughout their career because even in regular jobs, no one is going to keep the same goal the whole time. Of course, it would be good to chart well AND have high sales, but charting well would be useless if you only want to make music and perform and high sales would be useless if you want to gain general public recognition. Either way, both bring in money so I'm sure groups would be thankful for either.
Also, charting well and high sales are complementary. If you're high on charts, more people are exposed to your music and might be inclined to buy an album but that could go away in an instant if you come out with a "bad" song. It seems very short term. If you have high sales due to strong fandom, people are gonna wonder why and check out your music. I think high sales is more long term for music than charting well. High sales is also an indicator for possible revenue from tours. Charting well for a song can bring in money in the short run but if that next song isn't as good and you fall off the charts, it becomes unstable.
Personally, if I were an idol, I'd prefer high album sales. Just my personality alone, I don't think I could be cut out for TV appearances and cf deals. But some people love that.
10
u/NarglesChaserRaven Oct 20 '21
The most profitable thing would be to be able to have a concert and be able to fill up the stadiums. That's what I think. Because, if k-pop has taught me anything it's that charting definitely brings a lot of brand deals and exposure but GP support is very unreliable. Also, SK really has a terrible obsession with artist and their image and what constitutes as good. People can do anything minor and have their careers ruined. So yeah, i think they might prefer to have dedicated fans who would stick with them no matter what and pay for their concerts and albums and merch or everything else.
29
u/monet-lilies Oct 20 '21
Personally, I’d pick selling well. My rationale is that selling well is evidence of a strong fandom, a strong fandom means you can tour, you can release merch that will be bought - there is a sense of stability in that the fandom won’t simply collapse tomorrow (barring some horrible scandal or crazy mishap) and so you’ll have steady income. Charting is simply too volatile. Momoland had a sensational song with BboomBboom in 2018 and they were the GG everyone was talking about at the time, but it turned out to be a one hit wonder, and I’m not sure that it’s done much to launch their career. You could chart extraordinarily well with one song and not find the same success ever again in your career. I’m not a risk taker in general, so my pick would be selling well.
I’m wracking my brains to think of groups who chart well but don’t sell well. The GGs that chart well consistently, also sell well consistently. I feel like the trends have changed wherein any KPop group thats charting well, also sells very well too now (upwards of 100k). Exceptions might be the mega digital monsters like IU and AKMU (I don’t know their album sale numbers).
28
u/flawedconstellation you know you got that home, home, home, home 🎶 Oct 20 '21
AKMU don't pull sales much, their debut album Play is their highest selling to date, and everything else hasn't sold as well. But they chart insanely well and can pull crowds like nobody's business. When they released their album Sailing, they did random busking in SoKor and so many ppl came that there wasn't enough space in the park anymore. But as you said, they're definitely a rare exception, most acts won't have that sort of experience.
10
u/monet-lilies Oct 20 '21
Thanks for the insight on that. AKMU are just monsters in terms of the streams they pull and are beloved throughout the nation and their shows are always packed. Definitely GP darlings and an exceptional case!
9
u/NewSill Oct 20 '21
I would say chart and not because of Cf deals. Think of them as a Korean, you would want to be recognized in your country isn't it?
2
u/92sn Oct 20 '21
Ikr. People here seem not really realize why some idols prefer charting well. Its asian thing to get recognized n make parents proud. Charting well is direct way to make parents proud as the parents would be proud to see their sons/daughters music played everywhere.
7
u/Devoidoxatom Oct 20 '21
Consistently charting well would probably be better. People like IU, Akmu, Zico, Lee Hi, Epik High etc.. always chart well so it's not as 'volatile' as people make it out to be. They seem to be more well regarded tbh, in shows etc..
6
u/NobelBangwool Oct 20 '21
Selling is where the money's at, but charting means and leads to increased popularity. So it comes down to what they value.
3
u/Late_Measurement838 It’s Ni-Ki. Not Niki or Nikki or Nicky or Nicki. 😒 Oct 20 '21
Whatever makes them more money/gives them more opportunities to make money.
3
u/ahater Oct 20 '21
selling, what really brings them money is selling, because streaming apps dont pay sht to the artists
5
4
u/Powerful-Avocado-674 Oct 20 '21
I think charting well for many of the reasons that were already listed. I think one example of charting well would be brave girls how their song jumped back onto the charts and now they're more famous than they ever were.
Also, now CDs are slowly becoming more outdated so naturally I think number of physical album sales is going to matter less and less. Not to mention the increasing popularity of music streaming like spotify, apple music and even youtube music
2
Oct 20 '21
I think it depends on their pride. I think the ones being idols just for money and some perks wouldn’t mind selling well and just living off a devoted fandom, and the money that comes from that. But if they care more about the music I would think they’d want to see their songs charting well more
2
u/Electronic-Tea-4686 Oct 20 '21
I think idols would want to be recognized in their own country, so probably charting. Also, charting helps them win awards.
I wonder what companies prefer. Would they rather have their groups sell well or chart well?
2
Oct 20 '21
Charting well, because popularity with the gp gives you more tours and brand deals which bring in more money than sales.
2
u/jenifmagal Oct 20 '21
that depends on the idol. there are idols that seem to prefer a big fanbase over being successful with the gp, while others don't. i think i'd want a bit of both. i'd find a hit song more validating, bc my song's being listened to by people who have no reason to lie about liking it, but i'd also be sad if i didn't have at least a decent fanbase bc i'd just feel like i'm good but not good enough
4
u/DooOooT-dOOoOOt Sub to r/MarkLee Oct 20 '21
Charting well. For girl groups it'a obviously charting but I know boy group fans might think otherwise but my ult group, NCT Dream, always said they check on charts often and it was clear they cared about charting more than selling. (And they sold 2M pure albums btw which was a SM artist record.)
1
u/Still-Map-6797 Oct 20 '21
I remember when Ridin hit #4 or #3 (?) on Melon chart, they are so happy especially Jisung.
1
u/DooOooT-dOOoOOt Sub to r/MarkLee Oct 20 '21
Yeah, they cried from happiness when WGU charted well too.
3
u/92sn Oct 20 '21
Charting well. Nothing really can win over when your family can feel it your music actually play everywhere. Its asian thing. With charting well, the artist can get cf deal. Same like songs being played everywhere, this time the artists face gonna be everywhere. Charting well also help building individual brand reputation thus help once the idols want to do solo career. Making family proud with the artists music actually really famous would probably make the artists feel more proud n satisfied compared to just selling well. Its not a bad thing just having selling well, but dont you guys notice how many idols always mention their goal n hope is to make their family, parents proud? I am sure most of them actually prefer charting well so that their family know them doing well n being famous.
2
u/halcyon_summer Oct 20 '21
Personally, if I were an idol, I prefer charting well. Ideally, this means that more people, fans and non fans alike, are listening to my song. The more audience I attract, the more gig I have outside my music. It has a long term benefit too. Just look at IU. Her singles are really charting well even without promotion, because the GP already has her back.
I could also look at the possibility of charting well might mean more people may buy the album (digitally and physically).
1
u/_would_you_rather_ Oct 20 '21
Selling can keep an act afloat then they have nothing else going on. But CFs and Korean festivals is there the money at, and this depends solely on charts. International tours are nowhere as profitable because they demand big investments and carry a big finacial risk. In conclusion, charts are better overall, but if your nugu group makes negative digits, buy albums instead of complaining they are getting "mistreated" because no one wants to invest into unprofitable project. Something like that.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 20 '21
Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read.
Oh, and you can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.