r/kpopthoughts • u/GiannaS13 • Oct 19 '21
Question What do companies get by debuting really young idols?
I've been wondering this since I saw the new Pnation group but why do companies debut such young idols? Because I can't see the sense not even from a business point of view. By law won't those idols need to work less? I know after a certain hour they can't be in award shows/events, so they need to leave and hide backstage until the event is over so they can go home with the rest of the group. They also need to attend school, so is fewer hours for the idol to practice or to attend shows.
I know the big majority debut while still in school but they are usually out in 1 or 2 years, but if you have a really young idol then is YEARS before they are free.
And the age gap within the group isn't weird for certain concepts? Okay, I do know this doesn't stop anything since we had Hyuna doing sexy moves while being underage but is a different time since then. People are talking about this a lot more, social media has a lot more impact than it did back then.
In the Pnation group the ages are: 19, 19, 17, 17, 16, 12. So even when half the group is legal age the maknae will still be too young. I know there are ppl that won't mind but it would be sooo weird seeing them doing a mature/sexy concept. Even just seeing the picture of the group as is now is already weird for me bc the age gap is just so obvious.
Also, won't this age gap affect the dynamic of the group? I mean is not an impossible thing for a 19 yo person and a 12 yo to get along but I doubt they will ever be super close friends as a 19 and a 17 would. People usually have close friends that are close to their age.
Another thing that is huge for kpop idols is fanservice, but what fanservice can a literal child do?
So does anyone has an explanation? Cause I just don't understand why a company would want to do that, it just seems more cons than pros.
23
u/xnnxnxnn Blue Turquoise Oct 19 '21
They probably get idols to stay longer under their groups specially male idols. Also fans love seeing their idols grow. For pnation new group, companies dgaf about the dynamics plus who knows they might actually go well. Overall it is the perception that “younger the better” in the industry. The real problem in my opinion the 12yo trained for at least a year or so , why did their parents leave them audition at a young age? At the end pnation , while got some dirt on their part, they didn’t force the boy in.
8
u/NewSill Oct 20 '21
12 is definitely extreme but I'll leave that for other people to debate.
Just want to point out Treasure have similar structure in term of age gap and I haven't seen they have any problem so far. The oldest is 99 and youngest, Junghwan, is 05 (6 years compared to 7 years in this case) and they hit it off like family. Their relationship wouldn't be like close friends but they could still be close.
For schools, it probably depends on companies but YG really try as much as they can to give them school time. One time the youngest has to go to school during the filming of Idol League. It definitely is a hard life. You would see Junghwan carried books everywhere they goes for filming close to his exam. But it's not that you are off the hook after high school either. Some idols do university as well.
This is how a child do fan service (please don't take this seriously) but I do agree with you though that sexy concept would be too much.
2
u/tafattsbarn ♡ cloudy sky, clear air ♡ Oct 20 '21
I believe TREASURE did face some controversy when releaseing 'MMM' due to the age gap and having young members though, did they not?
3
u/NewSill Oct 20 '21
Definitely for having minors do that concept, especially when they put Junghwan as center /facepalm.
8
u/agentarianna Oct 20 '21
for girls additional time before society sexistly decides they are "too old" especially for cute concepts
for boys additional time before enlistment halts momentum. You have to be BIG for you/your group to survive an enlistment hiatus with a sustainable fanbase. Kpop fans are easily distracted and decently apt to move on to the next shiny group or from kpop altogether if the content stream dies due to military hiatus (or frankly any hiatus) meaning your fanbase has to be big enough to survive say 25 percent of your fans leaving and still be profitable and that is easier if you have more time to establish your group.
7
u/aalalaland GFRIEND I VIVIZ I BTS I Le Sserafim Oct 20 '21 edited Oct 20 '21
I mean, going to school doesn’t mean doing well in school. I’m pretty sure Jungkook once tweeted about getting a 4/100 on a math test lol. I think once you’re in idol, they kinda treat you like a student on an athletic scholarship in America and just like…let you pass.
5
Oct 20 '21
Literally makes no sense to debut a 12 year old. I’m aware of young teens being trainees but this is a different league of exposure/judgement and shouldn’t even happen.
4
u/MidgetDevil Oct 20 '21
I'm thinking time before enlistment. Take NCT as an example. Dream and 127 debuted in the same year. Taeil has to enlist in 2 years. He's the main vocalist, and by the time he comes back, other members need to enlist. The oldest member who has to enlist in Dream isn't due for 8 years. That's a lot of time of career building/stabilization.
7
3
u/niclaswwe Multistan for better health Oct 20 '21
The earlier they debut the faster they earn the company money, it's that sad and simple.
1
u/nanana94 Oct 20 '21
from a video i've watched, they say younger trainees are easier to manipulate.
0
Oct 20 '21
[deleted]
3
u/Alienne52 Oct 20 '21
At least for NCT Dream Jisung, his unit was not that much older than him and they were marketed for their age. They were also supposed to have this graduation system to have members exit the unit once they became adults. Of course I still don’t think idols should debut this early but if they do, NCT Dream was a better way, in theory at least.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 19 '21
Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read.
Oh, and you can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.