r/kpopthoughts • u/Dependent_Row_4280 • Oct 17 '21
Girl Groups We finally got the aespa encore
Here to everyone that was angry and everything we finally got the encore and see how they slayed their mics were on and they were hitting those notes also the cute interaction between itzy and aespa sure the backing track was really loud I have no idea why its like they were fighting to over power it BUT we could still hear them.
EDIT: I heard its better with earphones winter and giselle for the right and karina and ningning for the left which is why I think it took them so long to release
EDIT 2: Why are people bashing them now cause of the backing track this was meant to be a happy post music core usually has loud backing track swatching this video and you can hear their vocals
EDIT 3: Isn't there a lock me tag the comments are nasty rn
58
Oct 17 '21
i swear i thought this would shut people up but no one is ever satisfied like
28
u/Dependent_Row_4280 Oct 17 '21
exactly like its always something
31
Oct 17 '21
its an obssession at this point ive never seen so many non fans begging for one it was embarrassing watching them complain when it was uploaded late go get a hobby fr
31
u/IcyRelationship5805 Oct 17 '21
I don’t get it why does everyone want these girls to suck so bad like they debuted after spending years of their childhood training that too from SM, most SM groups have amazing vocals so obviously the vocals in Aespa are gonna be amazing and yall sitting behind your computer watching their every move to see if they make a small mistake so y’all can criticize them for it.
17
u/SeriousConversation8 Oct 17 '21
It's always like that for aespa anyways aespa kept winning haters kept losing. They will attend inkigayo next week and it's predicted they will won so another encore coming through. Inkigayo doesn't use backtrack
28
u/miyaonigiri Oct 17 '21
i feel like the only reason why some people wanted aespa's encore is to criticize the fuck out of it. idk what mbc or sm is up to with that full volume backing track but the girls can clearly sing
28
u/iska_bkhyn Oct 17 '21
the full volume backtrack is actually mbc's fault they always put a bact track on the encore stages (not as loud as this one tho but yeah they do put loud backtracks)
12
Oct 17 '21
exactly they were gonna criticize it no matter what so also I'm sorry but no amount of autotune can make a bad singer a good singer they are sm vocalists
8
26
u/not-the-em-dash Oct 17 '21
I feel bad that aespa’s first live encore became this controversial. First it was late and now we have the super loud MR that’s making people question how much the girls are singing. I think you can definitely here them in most parts, and they’re singing well overall, but they’re straining to be heard a lot of times too (especially Winter). I hope they still have music show performances next week outside of Music Core and we can finally let this non-issue issue rest.
13
u/Dependent_Row_4280 Oct 17 '21
Exactly and the comments on this post are on fire I just wanted to praise them and it turned out like this sigh
13
u/Reasonable_Nebula604 Oct 17 '21
Controversial on Reddit because as far as I can see most Korean fans are fine with it.
10
u/not-the-em-dash Oct 17 '21
True, when I was checking the YouTube comments, Korean fans were happy.
154
157
u/grapholalia Oct 17 '21
i know everyone's upset about the backing track but can we just talk about how ryujin started dancing the savage dance before she left the stage? lol that made me smile so big.
67
u/Nicofatpad Oct 17 '21
The rest of Itzy was probably hesitant to interact with Aespa too much maybe cuz of their companies being strict. But I love that Ryujin doesn’t care and then Yeji follows along too
21
u/grapholalia Oct 17 '21
Agreed! It was such a cute little moment and I could tell that Itzy was pretty proud of aespa for their win.
80
u/MotorInvestigator0 Oct 17 '21
Winter was NOT silenced. The backtrack was way too loud but I could hear the girls clearly in the parts that mattered, they can SING.
73
u/Nicofatpad Oct 17 '21
There was a comment in Korean that translated to “Winter and Ningning sound like they’re competing with each other in a Karaoke room. Meanwhile, Karina and Giselle are competing in Show me the money”
2
u/gopoleen Oct 17 '21
...is that a good thing?
18
u/Nicofatpad Oct 17 '21
Yeah
0
u/gopoleen Oct 17 '21
Oh. Ok. Usually comparing a professional singer to a karaoke singer is not a good thing.
1
190
Oct 17 '21
The backing track is loud af but Winter's voice prevailed 😭
55
u/___von Oct 17 '21
I was so amazed at Winter’s loudness??? Wow, her adlib at the end was loud AF and i love it.
54
u/Kristalian Oct 17 '21
It's not a backtrack, it's the full AR lol
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
29
u/hoemanynow Oct 17 '21
are you being obtuse on purpose lol
you can clearly see it in the fancam version and hear her in the MR removed
are you just lying, thinking people won't fact check you or?? genuinely confused
61
u/___von Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
Ningning did it in one breathe wtf? Are you deaf or what? If you are forgive me, but it was very clear in my speakers even if there was an AR backtrack, the isolation was clear af.
Edit: lol the downvotes, 😂😂
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
34
u/___von Oct 17 '21
She did it here, i put on my airpods as well and it was clear with isolation. You also watch the MR removed and it was clear. If you watch the fancam ver, the backtrack becomes even more duller and you can hear their sound more.
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
18
u/Greedy_Internal7496 Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
this isn't even about the mr removed, it's obvious she sang the whole bit*, she even extended it a bit and she finalized with a different vowel placement than the recorded versions, it's very very clear lmao
26
u/___von Oct 17 '21
LMAO.
That is not at all my fault why YOU can’t hear it even on fancam version, but it’s very clear on the fancam 💀
MR removed literally caught up Karina singing “MYs we love you” before you come up with “it’s not real”-argument.
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
6
u/___von Oct 17 '21
Yea MR remove can add in words that aren’t there like literally 15minutes after the encore was posted, you mean?
→ More replies (0)11
u/TypicalYoungBoi Oct 17 '21
Bro, watch a MR removed video then. She clearly did the whole note. Dim wits trying to drag aespa's talents. Why don't you go support your faves or sth.
36
u/not-the-em-dash Oct 17 '21
She did though?
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
39
u/___von Oct 17 '21
This man has the audacity to complain when people say they’re a hater but just look at this comment LMAO. Please block aespa keyword in your account, you seem to be losing hairs bc of them.
1
Oct 17 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '21
Hello /u/Sylvaincks. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
16
u/Aityjtjjdhm Oct 17 '21
Fans will obviously hype their faves why are you so bothered with that? Lmao
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
33
u/Aityjtjjdhm Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
Uhm first of all ningning doesn’t have to prove anything to you or anyone else and if some fans think she’s as good as those other main vocalist what’s your business with that?? You can just ignore them instead of trying to put down NingNing who’s only 18 years old and a rookie, people like you annoy me so much,you only watch the girls just to find a reason to criticize them? Embarrassing
10
Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
17
u/___von Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
You mean this? You also blatantly ignored Ningning supported several C#5s just to push ur narrative.
You literally are so condescending on that thread and no, Taeyeon don’t support D5s with “ease”. She supports it with quite a lot of concentration. She even had a moment where in she regressed during Twinkle era and most of her 5th octave notes were strained a lot.
Edit: she already bounced back from that, she’s really good and I love Taeyeon, please.
3
u/SubjectRiver Oct 17 '21
But yes, keep up with “supporting with ease”.
Yes please do because Taeyeon absolutely supports D5s with "ease". How are you gonna discredit her when she's the most proven live singer out of all of them?
3
u/___von Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
I re-read my statement on this again and the problem may have been context and my sentence structure in here 😭 I don’t mean to discredit her, heck she’s my favorite korean vocalist even if you put her beside my other faves like Sohyang, Hyolyn, Ailee, i’d still pick her sound.
Come on now, Taeyeon isn’t an easy vocalist in a sense of her sounding like she’s not trying at all. Taeyeon is the opposite of “ease” she goes full sound on her belts. Ease in general is like a spectrum in singing, you either sing with ease and lose power, or vice versa.
→ More replies (0)1
u/serowajin Oct 17 '21
This is hilarious. Bringing up Taeyeon trying to diminish her skills as a vocalist just to defend you own faves, acting like she struggles with D5s and then making a bunch of lameass backpeddling about the definition of "ease" when her fans called you out lmao
-1
u/TaeReact Oct 17 '21
Have you watched her live concerts? Taeyeon does support D5s with ease, no need to downplay her skills just because you're fighting for your girlies. 😅
6
u/___von Oct 17 '21
Oh! please make no mistake. Taeyeon’s D5 are immaculate, but ease is not a word i use for consistent. Taeyeon is very consistent these days, tbh. Ease however is what I associate with Wendy’s D5s, more like her own technique leans towards ease and Taeyeon’s towards sounding resonant! It’s not at all a drag or negative.
→ More replies (0)0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
13
u/___von Oct 17 '21
I’m not… discrediting Taeyeon? But ease is not the word, but her D5s are immaculate nevertheless. Literally there were C5s in that cover that was supported, uhm? Anyways, whatever.
→ More replies (0)-2
u/Famous_Ad_4542 Oct 17 '21
ning has never did any of her high notes live.. like the little song in the teaser they all had at debut.. it was super high but when she sings it live it was no where near the teaser at all
80
84
u/icyfirework Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
MBC / Music Core just uploaded a fan cam and I think you can kinda hear them better!
10
87
u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 17 '21
I am ecstatic!!!
The backing track was still way too loud (👀 @ whoever made that decision) but I’m so proud
Winter and NingNing were showing that they are THE vocalists, they were SINGING 😭😭 I love this for them
19
Oct 17 '21
Winter especially jumps on any opportunity to show off her vocals and I love her for that. They know they don’t get a lot of chances to actually sing so whenever they do they make sure to slay.
13
u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 17 '21
Winter always makes sure that nobody has an opportunity to say she can’t sing, because she can’t just sing, she can SING
She’s such a special talent, every time she opens her mouth I’m just like “Yes, Minjeong! Show off your voice girl!”
16
u/Liiisi Oct 17 '21
a weird choice when the girls didnt need it ... at all!
31
u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 17 '21
100%
I love that Winter just completely disregarded the backing track and just sang her heart out. She sounded amazing!
15
u/Liiisi Oct 17 '21
Winter did not come to play
Its been a while since i've been this interested in a new group but damn this whole promotion build up and release has been so so good
5
u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 17 '21
I feel the exact same. I wasn’t sure if I would vibe with the group pre-debut because I was a fan of the MMC girls but now, I love them
I’m so excited to watch them grow and improve and show off more and more in the future!
And I’m kinda loving the lore haha
98
u/harpaperrr Oct 17 '21
The backtrack is so loud 😭 Black Mamba purposely sabotaging their first encore stage😤 Nevertheless, my girls did a great job. Now haters can stay on their lane
59
u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 17 '21
MBC is an anagram for Black Mamba Corp. 👀
39
u/harpaperrr Oct 17 '21
The lore gets deeper🤭
28
u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 17 '21
The SMCU is bigger than expected
25
u/cultured_vulture SNSD is my ult Oct 17 '21
Oh no nævis do something!!!
21
u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 17 '21
We’re gonna need another sacrifice asap
93
u/Sector_Sufficient Oct 17 '21
Backing track was freaking loud. Didn't realise encore stage has that loud of a backing track these days
58
u/confusednrad Oct 17 '21
i think it’s just for this music show because other encores from music core have backtrack as well
1
u/Sector_Sufficient Oct 17 '21
Hmm maybe, the last time I watched a Mucore encore was back when Blackpink was promoting. Couldn't recall that it was this loud.
24
u/confusednrad Oct 17 '21
well go watch more recent ones… why would i lie about this 😭
14
u/Sector_Sufficient Oct 17 '21
Yep, I just watched NCT Sticker encore, didn't seem as loud as this one unfortunately (or fortunately for NCT).
Oh well, they will have more chance in the future to showcase anyway. Best of luck to them
7
u/Think_Valuable_8910 Oct 17 '21
If you watch the fancam version you can hear them much better https://youtu.be/1y_4_JZ29c8
46
u/red_280 That tick that tick tick bomb Oct 17 '21
Backing track was loud but Winter's voice was louder. She was belting out those notes like her life depended on it.
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
5
u/SilentKunZ Oct 17 '21
And sounded bad because of it?There's no way that her belt at the end of the song would sound that bad had she not been straining to be louder
what, she sounded exactly same as in studio version
5
u/red_280 That tick that tick tick bomb Oct 17 '21
I think her vocals were fine, she hit the notes and everything but they were very loud and saturated in a way that didn't register well on the venue's sound system. Hell of a way to prove that you're singing for real at least.
3
Oct 17 '21
Yeah, even as a MY I had hoped to listen to any other encore stage than MuCore’s. On top of their usual BG vocals, they amped it up for this encore too… sad. The encore with the MR removed is fantastic though!
57
u/Friendisaster Oct 17 '21
they wrong as hell for lowering the girls’ mics and turning up the backtrack volume. although it was hard to hear them, they do sound good!
72
u/reveldream Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
the comment section is already filled with Koreans comments… i guess EVERYONE is waiting
edit: hearing it with an earphone was so good omg… did they isolate the vocal audio on purpose????
21
Oct 17 '21
It's probably why it took so long lol they were isolating the vocals to make it easier to hear
23
u/niclaswwe Multistan for better health Oct 17 '21
The aetzy interactions were gold!
Also hell yeah, the girls sound incredible live, hoping that SM will give them more opportunity to show off their live vocals in the future!
43
u/WrongdoerOptimal9207 Blue Turquoise Oct 17 '21
Im sure ryujin and karina are besties
29
u/red_280 That tick that tick tick bomb Oct 17 '21
Ryujin's stanky face while singing along to Savage with aespa right there has got to be the peak of her SM fangirl career. We've sure come a long way from that Next Level cover they did on their live.
50
Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
Finally, their first æncore 😭😭 After almost a year of waiting for a performance where they actually sing live. I'm in tears.
They sound so good, as expected! The backing track was so loud that you need to listen to the encore with earphones/headphones in full volume.
Also, we got ætzy interactions! 💞
Notes:
Left ear - Giselle and WinterRight ear - Karina and Ningning
They fixed the audio and now you can hear aespa from both sides of your earphones/headphones.
32
u/pengsoosblackswan Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
Winter's voice can be really distinguished! Also, shy cutie Yeji joined them when she saw Ryujin😆
Question: In encores, they usually play the instrumental version, right? In this case, do companies have a say whether which version of the song should be played? Edit: or how loud the accompanying backtrack is. I realized some mucore encores do have backtracks but it was not overpowering.
29
1
Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '21
Hello /u/yuumelle. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
25
u/Megan235 Oct 17 '21
They sound good, but why is the backing track even there???
I thought for encores they usually play pure instrumentals...
30
u/Think_Valuable_8910 Oct 17 '21
Music Core doesn’t usually play the instrumentals I think, but if you want to hear them better I’d recommend watching the fancam version https://youtu.be/1y_4_JZ29c8
12
u/miyaonigiri Oct 17 '21
music core seems to use backing tracks instead of instrumentals but dear god they were usually not that loud
64
u/confusednrad Oct 17 '21
before anyone drags them for singing with loud backtrack, music core is at fault… they do it with every artist. cause i know people are gonna say sm is trying to save their image cause they can’t sing or some bs
20
u/TypicalYoungBoi Oct 17 '21
You could tell at some points, the girls were trying their best to outsing (in terms of volume) the backtrack. T T
•
26
u/concom10 Oct 17 '21
Everyone seems confused about the backtrack like dont you all know Music core plays the song for every single encore?
13
u/idiosyncraticat14 Oct 17 '21
I think this is a make-or-break point for Aespa to prove their talents given the amount of hype and success that they've achieved. For me, they did not disappoint at all. Even Karina the rapper has a good voice. Winter and Ninging are on another level, they're the Wendy x Seulgi and Jessica x Taeyeon of their groups.
17
Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
They finally have an encore stage, even though the backtrack is a little bit loud but I could still hear their live vocals and they sounded pretty good!
Edit: Ppl shld watch the fancam version of the encore which was uploaded later on. The live vocals were clearer there.
6
u/skywalkerated Oct 17 '21
They sound so good!!! Hopefully they lessen/remove the backtrack in their future performances though
31
u/FuriousKale Oct 17 '21
Some of y'all are hella thirsty for mistakes and crying about the backing track like you never knew it depends on the show how loud and prominent it will be during encores.
18
u/leggoitzy Oct 17 '21
Woohoo finally! Really wanted this one cause it's the only Aetzy interaction we'll see for a while. And it was good.
I don't even mind the backtrack that they're fighting to sing over.
17
u/akoishida Oct 17 '21
the fact that most of the comments in the video are korean really shows aespa’s reach. we don’t see that much nowadays
12
u/soul_attractor Oct 17 '21
Now who the hell turned up the volume for the backtrack 🥴🥴🥴 but anyways the girls sound amazing and more encores to come! 😁😁
4
u/-tenyong- sticker apologist, nct/wayv ♡ superm ♡ aespa Oct 17 '21
Hi hi!! fellow My here. Please join the r/aespa general chat if you're interested. We'd love to discuss more about aespa as much as we want and have more engagement there. So lmk if you want to be added. Thank you <3
4
u/Famous_Ad_4542 Oct 17 '21
i'm sick and tired of people not acknowledging winters skills as a singer.. their argument is shes only a lead nings the main!! wahhh..
yet she was hand picked to be the producers protege for a reason.. she clearly did the best here and did the full studio version effortlessly
10
Oct 17 '21
I could hear their voices fine with headphones and MR removed also exists. The girls sounded great honestly, I don't know why people keep doubting SM vocals every time
18
u/SilentKunZ Oct 17 '21
Oh my god Winter's voice was the loudest. She effortleslly sang all these high notes. The real ace.
27
u/Aityjtjjdhm Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
People here saying you can’t hear the girls lol just put on earphones you can clearly hear them and music core encores always have the original song playing instead of instruments,they sang every note and did so good, winter’s last high note at 4:45 was especially good I had to lower the volume bcs it was too high (my good sis winter wow what was that?) listen to karina here 4:32 and then Gigi wow karina always manages to surprise me her voice was so good clear and strong,she could literally be lead vocal in any other group and she was trained as rapper not vocalist but she’s this good, Ningning did good too even though I think her mic was bit lower than the rest but she still managed to hit every note effortlessly
8
u/MoonFlamingo Oct 17 '21
Did y'all hear Winter???!! I want to see what all the people always saying they probably can't sing live are gonna say now. If the loud backtrack bothers them, there is the fancam version. Even Karina sounded so clear! Their voices sound just like their studio version. Only wish Ningning had a louder mic. SM again showing off their vocal training!
12
u/ddalgikp Oct 17 '21
there's still so many haters nitpicking everything ugh i'm so fcking tired wasting my energy on them
10
u/nnooaa_lev Oct 17 '21
The backtrack may be a little to loud, but I can hear them just fine. I honestly super impressed by Giselle
20
u/chidi45 gg enthusiast Oct 17 '21
Finally at least all the complaints can stop we have seen they can hit those notes and everything
9
2
u/gopoleen Oct 17 '21
Are they going to any other shows?
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
-3
u/gopoleen Oct 17 '21
Ok, that will be better I think. Ningning was not as impressive as I thought she would be here. Winter seems most comfortable and the only one really singing her parts fully.
11
u/Relssifille Oct 17 '21
They're really trying their best to make sure that Aespa dont get to perform fully live by making the backing track so loud 😭 Cmon bestie we know they can sing just let them do what they do best
7
u/Think_Valuable_8910 Oct 17 '21
Watch the fancam version you can hear them https://youtu.be/1y_4_JZ29c8
19
u/Aityjtjjdhm Oct 17 '21
Music core always have the backing track for their encores stop thinking too hard about it
2
u/Relssifille Oct 17 '21
Yeah it's just really loud, it wasnt that loud in another encore I saw. I was trying to make a joke lol
4
u/CrescentToast Oct 17 '21
Sorry but we have to stop promoting these channels, they do something to remove it, but at the cost of altering everything the remains, the highest end tech companies struggle with this. Not to discredit anyone's vocals but for the love of being honest please don't ever use that channel.
No matter how loud other things are, you are going to get more of their real voices without this gimmick removal than with it. Especially given there is a backing track they are in time with, you are either impacting their voices or not removing anything enough to get just live vocals, I get it the music is 'loud' but lets just enjoy what we got not give attention to these channels. <3
4
u/iomk97 Celeste Oct 17 '21
The backtrack was unexpectedly loud and because of that we couldn't hear that much and when we did it was kind of a battle .The one who stand out tho was Winter. I'm surprised of how much power she has. I thought would be otherwise and NingNing would be the one with this kind of voice.
4
u/anunaghorl Oct 17 '21
I can finally hear their voices, on a full song, that is not a cover or a snippet of their vocals hallelujah
3
Oct 17 '21
love how they make sure that you HEAR them at all costs even with that loud ass backing track
1
u/joonlite Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
Ningning was a bit disappointing, especially in the mr removed maybe she was nervous? I think Winter did well and Karina switching naevis to mys was cute lol
Edit: welp here comes the downvotes because…..?
9
u/SilentKunZ Oct 17 '21
yeah, ningning could sing better, I'm sure she was nervous, anyway she did her best!
-2
u/gopoleen Oct 17 '21
Sensitive uber fans can't take any slightly negative comment even if it's fair and honest.
2
u/rusosandkpop Oct 17 '21
At last!! I was waiting for this and I understand why people is disappointed with the loud backtrack...I hope they keep winning and we can hear them clearly in the next performances and encores.
Is this their first encore? If so, they really went for the "we are too cool to cry" route, this is the most disappointing thing for me...I really wanted them to be a young group being a mess! jajaja...also more itzy and aespa together in the future!
15
u/SeriousConversation8 Oct 17 '21
Maybe because they already have their first win with black mamba plus this is their 4th win with savage that's why they're not that emotional.
1
u/rusosandkpop Oct 17 '21
I thought it was their second win and first encore!!
Just saw that they had first win in Inkigayo with black mamba but no encore?
Because they had no wins with next level I thought they had no wins at all....thanks for correcting me!I
1
Oct 17 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/rusosandkpop Oct 17 '21
Am I the only one who enjoy emotional first encores?
Maybe it's because is Aespa and all people was expecting to hear them sing, so to be nervous, messy and absolutely relatable in their first encore was not an option for them? Unfair!
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '21
Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read.
Oh, and you can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/itzy_thebest123 Oct 17 '21
Winter and giselle hard carrying this encore i prefer winter's voice as compared to ning ning and winter is so powerful hope we can get to see more from ningning i know she can do it
-29
u/kahimilf Oct 17 '21
How ridiculous is it that they’re basically a year old group who have yet to sing live on a music show and its supposed to be some coincidence that the encore they perform is on the only music show that plays the backtrack loud as fuck
9
u/Dependent_Row_4280 Oct 17 '21
ummm..
-8
u/kahimilf Oct 17 '21
What?
10
u/Dependent_Row_4280 Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
they are rookies and this is their first encore cut them some slack plus its cause of music core that the backing track is loud its a thing they do
-2
u/kahimilf Oct 17 '21
What other girl group went 3 comebacks without singing live?
10
u/Dependent_Row_4280 Oct 17 '21
this is their first encore??
-1
u/kahimilf Oct 17 '21
They havent once perfomed the song live, just on an encore where the music is too loud to even hear them. And every other girl group sings live whilst dancing for at least a couple of stages every comeback and sings encore with just instrumental.
10
u/Dependent_Row_4280 Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
ummm well idk why but we know they can sing plus they are going to inkigayo next week stop overanalysing
-3
u/kahimilf Oct 17 '21
Still embarrassing that havent sung whilst actually performing yet once
11
u/MotorInvestigator0 Oct 17 '21
The intensity with which you keep questioning these girls' abilities when they can clearly be heard, especially winter and ningning, over the backtrack is quite disturbing. And calling the lack of live stages embarrassing when SM has done this with all of their artists who as a matter of fact are often renowned vocalists... you will be blaming aespa for debuting in the middle of a pandemic with absolutely no audience to cheer them on soon.
Just say you dislike them.
→ More replies (0)9
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
-27
u/kahimilf Oct 17 '21
Most music shows just have instrumental, SM let them sing this one because the song is playing loud as fuck
17
u/confusednrad Oct 17 '21
what are you even on about.. keep your bitterness to yourself
-7
u/kahimilf Oct 17 '21
Are you committed to defending mediocrity
10
u/confusednrad Oct 17 '21
mediocrity? you’re the one hell bent on hating a group that clearly delivers vocally. music core always uses backtracks for their encore… and you can literally hear the girls singing over it.
0
u/kahimilf Oct 17 '21
Not a single live performance is delivering vocally? The bar is in hell
11
u/confusednrad Oct 17 '21
oh wait i remember you… we already argued about aespa a while back seems like you’re just hell bent on hating on them 🤷 well they’ll continue to be successful while you stay miserable and bitter hating on them on reddit
2
u/kahimilf Oct 17 '21
And so are u?
12
u/confusednrad Oct 17 '21
clearly not a hater… i don’t shake and sob and throw up when i see people praising them
→ More replies (0)0
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
11
u/ddalgikp Oct 17 '21
fr. they'll never be satisfied and they will just continue to find something to throw at them since they're basically close minded about aespa's talents
17
Oct 17 '21
Agree lol, haters are literally waiting to criticise Aespa's vocals by saying they are afraid to sing live lol. Like I know the backtrack might be on the louder side but I could hear them with my earphones on and they sounded good.
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '21
Hello /u/winthorr. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
12
u/Dependent_Row_4280 Oct 17 '21
it's an encore she can go offkey is she wants we all know they can sing
7
13
Oct 17 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
7
u/Think_Valuable_8910 Oct 17 '21
If you watch the fancam version it’s easier to hear them https://youtu.be/1y_4_JZ29c8
-5
0
Oct 17 '21
[deleted]
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '21
Hello /u/knetizenbooo. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
80
u/inbox789 Iridescent Turquoise Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
I'm sorry, not commenting about their vocals but can you call it a backtrack when it's basically the full song with full volume?