r/kpopthoughts • • Oct 17 '21

Thought I think it'd be good for the kpop community to normalize interactions between men and women.

Heteronormativity is a disease and I'm going to talk about why and how it'd be great if there was a change within the Kpop community about this.

By the way, this post is heavily inspired by what happened to Taehyung (BTS) not long ago, this man was seen standing next to a woman and now he's suddenly dating her.

First of all let me be clear, I do not have delusions of dating K-pop idols, so I really don't care about their dating life, if they want to date someone or not is none of my business as well as their sexuality, it isn't any of my business who they're attracted to.

With that out of the way I think it'd be amazing to see idols having comfortable, healthy interactions with people of the opposite sex without people immediately jumping into conclusions that they are dating, why? Well, it'd be a great example for the community since being friends with someone from the opposite gender can be very enriching and it also helps normalizing the fact that men and women do not only look interact with each other to "have babies" if you know what I mean... (Having that mentality is problematic on itself, but that's a conversation for another day)

Also I think it'll help with the misogynistic nature of Kpop stans because the amount of underserved and downright ridiculous hatred I've seen some girl groups receive because one of the members interacted with a male idol which made his fans feel some type of way is embarrassing.

And before you run to the comments to write about how "This is only a K-fan issue, western fans are more open minded" I'm going to tell you to stop wasting your time because you know that isn't true at all.

I'm not Korean and I don't speak or read Korean which makes my chances of interacting with the K-fandom of an artist I like VERY low and let me tell you all the weird, cringe worthy posts I've seen of fans of a certain group being jealous of a woman interacting with their faves (I mostly follow boy groups so I haven't experienced the other side) have been made by international, a.k.a "Western stans".

From people getting literal anxiety attacks because "What if X group appears with a girl in their new music video?!" to people who got genuinely upset (and yes this wasn't a joke) because Beomgyu (TXT) was standing 3 meters apart from a girl who was part of the TXT staff, and before you ask no, they weren't even interacting.

In fact, recently I saw rumors being made up about Yuna (Itzy) and Sunghoon (Enhypen) because Itzy got a win on music bank and they bowed at each other which obviously means they're dating -> Yes, I'm being sarcastic.

And obviously the consequences of this are incredibly awkward moments between people who might even be friends in real life but can't interact at all because they might find themselves wrapped up in a dating scandal, in fact, this reminds me a lot of Jungkook (BTS) who's fans liked to spread the narrative that "omg kookie can't talk to women" while also thinking he was a "playboy" (make it make sense) when in reality his school classmates said he was very friendly towards girls and quite close to many in his class, but ofc he can't do that while he's being filmed because any, even the most minuscule interaction Jeon Jungkook has with a woman means they're doing the dirty.

Idols, no matter if they're as popular as BTS or not, don't want to be involved in scandals and if that takes not interacting with any single person of the opposite gender ever while the cameras are rolling they won't and I'm so tired of it.

So please let them interact, let them be human beings, work on your insecurities and stop projecting on people you don't know.

Also, let's normalize men and women being friends, it's very healthy, I recommend it.

185 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '21

Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read.

Oh, and you can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

33

u/ebi_tempura Oct 17 '21

Yes this is something that really needs to be normalised especially since cross-group interactions between idols is becoming more rare, which I can only assume is partly due to groups these days opting to produce group specific variety content online, rather than previously where we had more cross group interactions on television variety programs.

Also I agree on the statement that international fans are not as open minded as they like to portray themselves as, and joining Twitter really opened my eyes to that. As a bts fan I've noticed that whenever a member interacts with a female longer than usual, my timeline is flooded with tweets saying "his photocard is sleeping on the couch tonight" or "welcome home cheater" which really disturbs me. There was also a time some fans actually managed to trend "Ed Sheeran best boy" in retaliation to them seemingly finding a female interviewer attractive??

They all claim that they're just joking and to not take it seriously, but honestly if they were truly as open minded as they like to claim, there should never have been a need to even make or participate in these "jokes" in the first place. To me it just looks like these fans are trying to pass off their true feelings of jealousy and pettiness as jokes.

These so called "jokes" only contribute to the fact that the fandom will always direct more attention than necessary to any interaction they have with a female, thus only hurting the idea of normalising male and female interactions. So if any of these fans truly were joking, then they're certainly not helping any of these idols feel safe with publically displaying any real male-female relationships, romantic or not.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

Totally agree, also, those "Jokes" are usually not jokes haha.

23

u/foreverwarrenpeace Oct 17 '21

I always find it funny when people always assume hetero interactions means that idols are dating cause if anything I would assume that it’s possible that maybe one of the parties is queer and probably feels more comfortable with the other gender lol

11

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

Exactly! also isn't that assuming a stranger's sexuality as well?

Let's say you insinuate something is going on between two people of the same gender, the common response by stans would be to "ship them ironically" like "lmao yeah I know it's not real but they're cute together, let's not assume" but fans love to assume when it comes to straight people they aren't even sure if they are straight.

I've seen hetero ships with 0 interactions be treated as real things just because it's a hetero ship and by the way I'm not saying shipping and assuming someone else's sexuality is okay, it's just the double standard is insane.

4

u/foreverwarrenpeace Oct 17 '21

I agree that’s why we shouldn’t assume things in general because either way your assumption can be wrong. After all we don’t know them or anything

17

u/TaeReact Oct 17 '21

if anything I would assume that it’s possible that maybe one of the parties is queer and probably feels more comfortable with the other gender lol

I mean that's can be problematic too, like how everyone assumes Taeyeon and Key are gay just because they're besties

1

u/foreverwarrenpeace Oct 17 '21

I don’t think anyone is assuming Taeyeon is gay lol but yeah, maybe Key

5

u/TaeReact Oct 17 '21

You'd be surprised. People have been making assumptions about Taeyeon being gay (bisexual) since like 2008. They also misgender her. It's been the cause of a lot of drama in the fandom...

2

u/foreverwarrenpeace Oct 17 '21

Lol what??? In all of my years I’m kpop I’ve never heard of this at all. Maybe I just missed it. I’m surprised to hear this

6

u/TaeReact Oct 17 '21

I'm surprised you haven't tbh, the TaeNy shippers were always loud and annoying about it since the girls used to say they were husband and wife. Then it turned into this weird twisted thing about "gay Taeyeon being hopelessly in love with straight Tiffany". In fact I think it started as early as 2007 because she was supportive of lgbtq since predebut (and had some comments in the early days like saying she "confessed" to a girl or that she once sang for someone she liked and that it wasn't a guy.)

People even on reddit used to talk about how her depression might be because she was in the closet which is kinda problematic all on its own, to believe there must be something like behind it for someone to be depressed..

1

u/foreverwarrenpeace Oct 17 '21

Omg thank you for all the is info! I’ve been into kpop since 2013 and this really is news to me!! I was never in GG so maybe that’s why but wow, this is all so new to me

21

u/BLBOSS Oct 17 '21

GOT7 and Twice used to have so many fun interactions together and were all obviously good friends with one another.

Speaking of Jungkook, I'll always remember that one fancam from some award show where Jackson (I think) is asking Dahyun to pass him a blanket (or something) and Jungkook and J-hope are in the same shot with deers-frozen-in-the-headlight looks on their faces as if to say "....are they allowed to be doing this?!"

It was sort of funny but also kind of sad at the same time.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21

I don't keep up with BTS that much anymore tbh, but I did a few years ago where the whole "Jungkook can't talk to women, he's so shy uwu" thing was at it's peak and it was sad, truly sad, not because I really thought he couldn't talk to women but because I knew he didn't do it because of his fanbase, he's either portrayed as a super shy baby boy or a playboy with 0 impulse control, he'll f*** any woman he comes in contact with.

86

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

platonic! relationships! exist!

52

u/Available_Ad9555 Oct 17 '21

It is like key and taeyeon they have been friends for so long that if now they are seen hugging or on a date no one would speculate they are dating so I get what you mean.

If it was moe normalised and kpop stans were used to seeing it then they'd stop speculting but with male and female idols being unable to even mention each others names or be seen talking once it does happens speculations of dating pops up

19

u/randomseocb lino 4th gen fishboy Oct 17 '21

i agree so much with all that you said especially the first sentence and the last sentence and like i only know one group who doesn't get dating rumors or doesn't get fans enraged because of mentioning artists of the opposite sex and i know a lot of groups so that says much

1

u/myeyeswentdark Oct 17 '21

What group do you have in mind?

3

u/sketchy_potatoe sniffs mint choco Oct 17 '21

maybe shinee?

1

u/randomseocb lino 4th gen fishboy Oct 17 '21

i thought about skz but shinee can be included too hehe

0

u/sketchy_potatoe sniffs mint choco Oct 17 '21

i think they still get shipped sm, maybe less for chan tho

1

u/randomseocb lino 4th gen fishboy Oct 17 '21

i mean i dont see them get shipped with other idols, i see them get shipped with each other and what ships do you see?

1

u/sketchy_potatoe sniffs mint choco Oct 18 '21

minnie from gidle and hyunjin, karina and hyunjin, but these aren't that popular which is good.

1

u/YnieWho Oct 18 '21

I saw there were couple of Chan x Lisa from BP shippers for like a second about a year ago but surprisingly all these ships including the Hyunjin ones mostly tend to come from the gg stans instead of stays. Even then the ships are basically invisible unless you really go look for them. Stay shippers are heavy on the lgbtq+ agenda, hahaha.

1

u/randomseocb lino 4th gen fishboy Oct 17 '21

ohh it's skz

14

u/ryujinslove Oct 17 '21

I saw people call Yuna the most misogynistic words ever and tag it as “I don’t hate her but-“ Kpop stans really can’t stand their idol interacting with women can they. Also the fact that Yuna has been going through this since 2019.

11

u/PirateArtemis Oct 17 '21

Definitely. I think kpop has helped normalise male affectionate friendships but it does bug me how few opposite gender friendships there are. That's the nice thing about people like Jackson and his female friends, it's loving yet platonic and accepted. We need more like that!

5

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

SM artists seems to just interact with each other without caring lol

4

u/PrincessZaiross you know what it is AnNYeOngHasEyO Oct 17 '21

I believe most stans who act like men and women can’t be friends are most likely immature kids/teens who look up to their idols and act very possessive. And we all know the smallest dog barks the loudest. All in all it’s a business strategy of companies to market their idols like bf/gf material. No wonder that especially young fans are so eagerly obsessed with the bf/gf image for their idol and think on the rare occasion when their idols meet a person of opposite gender, it means they are dating. I only recently found out that this was such a big deal for Kpop stans. Whenever I see my favs interact with women e.g. BamBam/ Youngjae with Seulgi on her show, Jinyoung with his fellow actresses, BamBam being besties with Lisa, I never heard fans talking ill about the women or concluding a romantic relationship, but rather hyping them both up for having amazing friendships. I agree that more idol interactions should be like this. It’s so much healthier and more fun to see idols interact freely with each other and don’t restrict them like they live in a girls/boys community only.

1

u/Muted_Amphibian_9325 Teal Oct 17 '21

Yes yes preach

Ps. Although what happend about that beomgyu incident though if I may ask ??

5

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21

It's really the silliest thing, I don't have any tweets or "evidence" to show because it was indeed ridiculous BUT I will try my best to describe the situation to you.

TXT have something like a variety show that is called Talk X Today, this show isn't meant to be funny or anything (They have TO-DO for that, another show that comes out weekly) it simply is like a Vlog/a day in my life type of thing, anyways, in a Talk X Today the members of Tubatu were in their dance practice room rehearsing for their latest comeback and a female staff was seen 3 seconds on the same frame as Beomgyu, that's it, they weren't interacting, they weren't looking at each other, they just happened to be in the same frame, 3 meters apart for like 3 seconds.

That simple "interaction" made fans jealous enough they started posting about it, it was embarrassing.

4

u/useles-converter-bot Oct 17 '21

3 meters is the same as 6.0 'Logitech Wireless Keyboard K350s' laid widthwise by each other.

2

u/Newhereimo Blue Turquoise Oct 17 '21

Netz are so weird, they think whenever a girl and a guy are together they are thinking about screwing the other. Like wtf? Men and women can be friends without making everything romantic, platonic relationships exist and tbh it's unrealistic that everytime a guy or girl meets the other they have sex in mind. Like no? It's not the only thing that exists in this world and it's weird af how people make a big issue out of it. Both men and women have literally been livin' with each other since they came on earth but still in the fcking 21st century, we say "omg look they are dating" if we find both genders hanging out together.

2

u/isakami02 Iridescent Turquoise Oct 18 '21

i agree with this and i feel so dumb because sometimes i get delusions and my brain might have annoying intrusive thoughts when i see them together even if i don't want to and i agree with this post but i need help bc i get these things my brain is telling me even though i don't agree with it (my brain) someone help me 😭😭😭

1

u/isakami02 Iridescent Turquoise Oct 18 '21 edited Oct 18 '21

isk if i explained that right but i get like a stomach jump when i see them together even if i don't want to and i feel really really guilty and bad about it but i need someone to help me or to talk to abt this because my intrusive thoughts get bad