r/kpopthoughts • • Oct 16 '21

Girl Groups Reveluvs have every right to be mad at Joy

Joy has gotten criticism for a while thanks to her infrequent posting on Bubble and recently she didn't post for almost a month.

Bubble is a paid service but if you want to cancel it you'll lose money,the only way you can get a refund is if the idol you're subscribed to doesn't post in a month.

So what does Joy do?Makes a post on the last day before refunds are possible for the fans.

If she's busy and couldn'd be bothered she could've just not posted on that last last day since she's probably aware that fans weren't happy and i totally understand fans anger after her post because it feels like you were robbed of your money.

1.1k Upvotes

202 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 16 '21

Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read.

Oh, and you can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

17

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

tbh i don't think joy made the decision to post on that last day but rather whatever company is behind it, i don't think she would have posted unless someone told her to lol, but i do get the frustration of not getting any content from a paid subscription. i remember this happening with another idol! there should be some sort of scheduling feature so if they are busy they can still give out content /:

23

u/resetjk Oct 16 '21

The only person fans can feel anger and frustration towards is Joy,they paid for her posts and she disappointed them not only by not posting for a long time but in the end stealing a chance they had for a refund

0

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

[deleted]

8

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

i mean if she wasn't posting all this time why would she have it in the back of the head to post before time runs out, i'm sure she has other things to do. if almost 100% of profits go to the artist, how is bubble running? even if she is a senior there are still people higher up than her that oversee the bigger things. she's not gonna go broke just because some people got a refund, if that makes sense? someone must have reminded her to post before the end of the billing month

35

u/anterogradeamnesia resident erigom, exol 🐻🐶🍭 Oct 16 '21

Not on anyone's side here but recently, Kyungsoo shared a picture (you can scroll to the top of the thread for the actual photo) of what he sees on Bubble, and it appears that he gets a notification when it's been more than 7 days since he's last used it. So I think there is a strong possibility that artists are notified/encouraged to log into the app after a certain period of inactivity.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

ah that makes much more sense

12

u/lowelled Oct 16 '21

It became something of a scandal in SK. I saw a post trending on the Qoo where fans were complaining saying she 'must be too busy texting her boyfriend to text fans.' She probably only updated it because of those complaints.

701

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 16 '21

I don't think updating bubble is that hard anyway. I don't use it but from what I've seen, idols tend to write some random boring lukewarm text like "think of me" or "work hard today" or "the weather is nice" and maybe post a photo of the sky and that's it. There's really no reason why an idol wouldn't update their bubble no matter how busy they are.

Edit: grammar

322

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

I read people are also mad becuase when she does update, its the same as her instagram, which she updates pretty much daily.

119

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

She hasn’t updated her Instagram much over the past month except to post advert posts.

84

u/lowelled Oct 16 '21

I saw someone say she put up 90 ads in the past month. Is that true? It's hard to believe - it seems super high.

104

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

If they’re counting each photo for an ad, then maybe 90 is right, but if we’re counting by actual post, she’s posted only 7 times in the past month with 5 being ads and 1 being the post after she was called out by netizens. She really has not been active in Instagram since she started filming.

16

u/tyongyoil Oct 16 '21

What is she filming?

56

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

She has a drama that’s coming up in November. She’s one of the three main leads. She also has her weekly filming for TV Animal Farm which she’s an MC for.

60

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

Why is the picture of the sky and "the weather is nice" so accurate 🤣 I got tempted so many times to try bubble but I'm not here for it if they post the typical generic messages.

128

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

Chaeryeong always messages on there I love her even if it's just boring stuff it's cute that she always makes sure to say hi every day 😭😭💗

73

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

well Chaery is the cutest in itzy that aside though out of all the itzy members she just gives off the vibe I like the most

38

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

I love them all, they're my 3rd fave overall group (like out of who I stan I consider them an "ult") but in particular chaery is just such a sweetheart. They all are but I feel like she's just another level of adorable kindness

20

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

It is this cute, savage, kind, and loveable all in one

28

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

People really pay for this huh 💀

207

u/GoForthandProsper1 Oct 16 '21

Sounds like a scam and an easy way for celebrities to make a quick buck off fans.

Perfect for Kpop idols.

590

u/LoveCutiesCookie Oct 16 '21

her posting on the last day so people dont get a refund is a really bad look...

178

u/Relevant_Compote_818 Oct 17 '21

It is but at the same time she is probably required to post at least once a month by sm for that reason, I can’t imagine they’d be ok with her not doing so unless she had an actual reason. But still the very last day doesn’t look good, she should’ve gotten it out the way earlier in the month

60

u/The_Red_Curtain 엑소 Oct 17 '21

All the money from bubble supposedly goes to the artist themself and not their company (although I feel like bubble must take some share) so I don't think SM cares one way or the other. There are other SM artists who don't even have bubble.

304

u/San7129 Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 16 '21

Wow i didnt know she posted only on the last day. That certainly is a bad look.

Like, people already criticize those who dont use it regularly as it is, why would you fan the flames even more by doing smthg that would make it seem like you really are trying to rob your fans from their money (refunds)? Whether it was solely her choice or someone made her do it, its incredibly stupid

298

u/Newhereimo Blue Turquoise Oct 16 '21

I never heard of bubble before this but reading this post really make me feel so bad for the fans. If it wasn't a paid platform like say... weverse, idols could literally post in a year and there wouldn't be a problem but doing this sort of thing in a paid platform is really not cool. Not only fans are literally giving their money to hear from their idols but they get same old posts from idols and in joy's case, she posted last day of the month and there goes the fans money. Idols should really try to be more understanding of how it is difficult for a lot of us to pay for some stuff but don't get anything in return.

31

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

Same.

I'm also hearing abt the platform for the first time and I'm genuinely confused.

This sounds so bad. Whoever came up with the idea 😬

5

u/denver_rose Oct 17 '21

The thing that appeals to me is that you can send messages to your idol & they do read them. But you can only send up to 3 messages per idol post, and for the first 2 months you only get 30 characters.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

I also feel bad for the idols who are forced by mgt contract to do this --- they probably have little enough time to themselves without worrying about making worth-it plans for their fans

150

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

I've subscribed to a few idols. Even they post daily, it still feels underwhelming.

There is also this weird message length restriction that newer subscribers can't send messages longer than 30 characters. You have to stay a long term subscriber to be able to send something that actually makes sense. Even if a message is sent the chance to get read is little (understandable, it must be a wall full of text on their side).

I got replied a few times though from Nayeon, Yeji and Ryujin.

65

u/magnolia9795 Oct 16 '21

just out of curiousity since I don't really know how it works - how do you know if they've replied to what you've said and not thousands of others. Is there a special feature?

84

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

You don’t know actually. Sometimes you might ask a specific question and they answer it, so it’s fair to assume that they were replying to you.

58

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

Based on the feels /:p

I don't think there's such a feature. Idols can send message with your name but it's actually an @ all message.

The times I felt were direct replies, I said something specific like their interaction with another idol, or a variety show they went to, how do they like a TV show, and it didn't feel they were replying to others.

53

u/buttholesRbeautiful Oct 16 '21

There's the y/n (your name) feature that's commonly used where it'll put your name in their message to make it look like they're talking directly to you, but it actually does the same to every subscriber.

However, they can also copy-paste your exact message and username into their message to actually respond directly to you if they want. I remember Twice having a field day with that when they figured out how to do it a while ago lol

37

u/elswheeler i must praise loona on the internet Oct 17 '21

sometimes twice members copy messages and reply to them, i think that’s how they “reply”, or just like someone else said, they actually type the nickname of the person they’re replying to (even though this one’s a little bit confusing since the app automatically adds your name on the message the idol sends)

8

u/SevereChocolate5647 Oct 17 '21

You don't know for sure, but depending on what you sent you can usually make an educated guess that they were replying to you. I've had it happen once that it seemed like I got a direct response, probably because I said I was going to bed when it was afternoon for them, and they were like 'your day is done already?' lol.

169

u/Alarmed-Ad-543 Oct 16 '21

She should have really waited till the month is up so everyone can get a refund. Now it seems like she posted only because she doesn't want to give back the money...

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

[deleted]

41

u/The_Red_Curtain 엑소 Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21

Companies don't have any part in individual idols bubble, all the bubble royalties go to the idol and Dear U the company. SM gets money if you join the group fanclub in bubble but all of their groups fanclub memberships are closed for the year.

5

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 17 '21

I’ve heard this from fans, but I haven’t actually seen an article where they say this. The only article I found about Bubble/Lysn’s income says that it grew a ton because of Bubble and it’s been a boon for SM.

15

u/The_Red_Curtain 엑소 Oct 17 '21

I bet SM must get a cut but that's split with JYP and the other companies that have more minor stakes. I really don't think they care enough to force Joy in particular to send messages or participate in the service, just one idol group member who probably isn't among the top 20 most profitable members in their company (through Bubble where boygroup members usually have way more subscribers), isn't worth ordering to message at the last day and then initiating yet another "scandal."

Like if all their artists dropped out in unison I'm sure they'd have something to say to them, but just Joy letting fans get their refunds would be a lot less trouble for them than what's happened now and has netizens up in arms.

-1

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 17 '21

Yeah, I definitely don't think SM would force her, but I wouldn't be surprised if her manager told her, "Hey, netizens are angry about you not posting. Maybe do something about that today."

I just don't think we can assume that she didn't want to let the fans get their refund. It honestly could've been an overreaction on her part after hearing about all the negative articles, and she thought that she had to update to make fans happy. Netizens were up in arms before she updated and they're up in arms after she updated.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

[deleted]

17

u/The_Red_Curtain 엑소 Oct 17 '21

because sending like three text messages a week saying "sweet dreams" isn't much. It's significantly less work than filming a CF or doing a photoshoot, it certainly doesn't hinder getting those other opportunities either. Sehun and D.O. were messaging the whole time they were filming their respective drama and films, it's just a few seconds out of their day for what I imagine is a pretty good paycheck.

141

u/noona-neomu-yeppeo Iridescent Turquoise Oct 16 '21

i agree with another commenter that no matter how much you think bubble is a wasteful purchase, what she did reflects badly regardless

if you’re too busy to use the service, fair enough but what she did is find a loophole. i’d be mad too.

these people chose to support joy through this app and if she can’t update then either post more or let people have their refund

29

u/fuckitjm Oct 16 '21

Omg that actually sucks😬

275

u/leafysummers My propaganda is ✨enchanted✨ Oct 16 '21

This is why I don't like Bubble generally and have no interest in it at all.

There are obviously idols who don't seem that interested in the service, but they can't refuse it and thus we get situations like this where idol doesn't want this, company is pushing this communication to avoid refunds, and fans are left unsatisfied.

I know people are going to reply all defending the platform and that it "needs to be a paid service because..."no it doesn't, but the platform just sounds unreasonable to me.

122

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

But I've heard there are other SM idols who have later closed thier bubbles, so if shes not interested I'm sure she can do the same.

19

u/leafysummers My propaganda is ✨enchanted✨ Oct 16 '21

Can you tell me who these idols are?

Red Velvet is still one of SM's biggest groups, I doubt they can.

110

u/L_OXE Oct 16 '21

I think Ryeowook of Super Junior closed his

91

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

I dont have bubble myself but I hear heechul closed a while ago, cant find info for any others since I'd have to download it to check.

From what I've read, the 100% of profits from the individual bubble accounts go to each group member.

72

u/BoredEra Oct 16 '21

Pretty sure no company will agree to launch something like this and get nothing in return though

11

u/optimistlyricist Oct 16 '21

I just need clarification, did you read that the artist themselves get 100% of the profits from Bubble? Meaning SM gets nothing?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

[deleted]

37

u/KuriboShoeMario Oct 16 '21

This could be heavily tilted towards the idol, in fact that is likely how it is presented by companies to the idols to sell them on the idea. They say, for example, "you post on social media anyway, do it on this paid service and you get 90% of what you bring in and we'll only take a measly 10%" and the idols go wow 90/10 that's amazing and the company does exactly nothing (except maybe remind an idol to make a post once a month) and still makes money off the idol. No matter what the split is, it's passive income for the company. They do squat and make money, they love it, which is why they push it so hard.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '21

Hello /u/CheesecakeThat153. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/Heedictated Oct 17 '21

From what I saw it's mostly individual Super Junior members (cmiiw). It's hard to judge whether RV could follow their examples since the seniority/leverage/freedom is quite different, but on the other hand there are such examples so some may argue that SM does not really care that much (which I kinda doubt but anyways).

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21

Same. And the translations are so bad. I just rely on big accounts on Twitter to post and translate

VLIVE chat is free and translations are ok and it’s not laggy. Yuju from gfriend was on it today and we got a lot of messages.

55

u/Hungry-Magazine-2543 the 'k' in kpop is for kwangya Oct 16 '21

she needs to learn from her idol chenle /j

16

u/StalkerPoetess Oct 17 '21

Honestly Chenle is so worth the subscription. He wasn't that active when he had his radio show but now that he doesn't have where to rant and vent live anymore, he moved to bbl and is going absolutely bonkers lol.

And then there is the opposite example of Jaemin who was hella active and used to send literal letters and late night vids of him cooking but then he got so much stupid hate and mockery on it that he just stopped updating as much and became one of the least active members overall. I'm forever mad that he literally had to ask people to not send nasty messages.

4

u/No-Assumption-2747 Oct 20 '21

LMAO I remember once a Chenle fan account on instagram was trying to tell their followers about the bubble messages he sent and translate them but then gave up because it was too much work

71

u/Inevitable-Badger330 Oct 16 '21

I saw people telling others to stop “acting entitled” and I was confused cuz considering the fact that bubble is subscription service you pay for (some have said it’s $3.99 every month or so but maybe it depends where you are from I’m not sure) and if the idol doesn’t update for a while then essentially your money is lining whoever’s pockets for basically nothing in return which isn’t cool especially since we’re in a pandemic so yeah I’d be entitled to what I’m owed lol. Gonna guess those people don’t even have a bubble account so ofc they’d get all defensive + joy posting on the last day where you could get a refund if the person you’re subbed to hasn’t updated in a minute is a horrible look, you could argue that it’s a coincidence but it also looks additionally bad that she probably only updated after getting called out. Either way, people have a right to be mad and joy isn’t the first idol I’ve seen be called out for doing this stuff to fans, it comes off like a scam even if that’s not the intention.

126

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

posting on the last day so the fans aren’t able to get a refund is fucked up and no amount of “fans don’t HAVE to pay for bubble!1!1” will convince me otherwise.

51

u/L_OXE Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 16 '21

I don't know how bubble works so genuinely curious, does subscription run for the same period for all subscribers? Cause typically subscriptions aren't like that so meaning different people would have different end dates right? Unless they all run for the same period then how can she know which day is the last day

Edit: grammar

57

u/wandaaaaaaaaaa 🏴‍☠️ Oct 16 '21

Cmiiw but I think the indivual subscriptions don't all start at the same time bc you can start yours anytime. I think the 'timer' for that month for refunds starts at the last message from the artist, so maybe all subscribers are eligible for a refund if they were subcribing before that last message? 😅

17

u/L_OXE Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 16 '21

Thats what I think too, they can't all be have same start date (so can't have same end date).

Sorry I didn't get the timer part. Do you think the eligible date for refund will be the same for everyone if its based on the artist last message? Thanks

Just read the article about it apparently it had been one month since she posted so I get what you mean by the last message

EDIT: Added last paragraph

16

u/Eeellie Oct 17 '21

this reminds me of a fan telling jae not to post so they can get a refund lol

2

u/Ebony_Coco ONEUS ZB1 ALD1 XLOV TNX ONEPACT ATEEZ WEI VERIVERY Oct 20 '21

lmao

2

u/nicoleeemusic98 Oct 29 '21

Ngl feel kinda bad for that one cause it was obvious they were partially joking and even censored his name but other fans tagging him to it led him to seeing it

43

u/scorpiussss Oct 16 '21

I mean people are right to be mad. If she doesn't want to post everyday, then she can close her profile

52

u/TheKillerMatt Oct 16 '21

And then people like to complain when fans post the bubble messages on Twitter lol. Feel bad for the Joy fans that paid tho, must suck to waste all that money for nothing

119

u/New-Moon78 Oct 16 '21

Either way the anger is justified towards JOY because Bubble is a pay service, if it wasn't a pay service JOY wouldn't get backlash

133

u/BoredEra Oct 16 '21

Bubble shouldn’t even be a thing anyway. Why do they make fans pay for something like that? And worse, it’s payment for each individual members

25

u/hombrx Oct 16 '21

I don't know about other groups, but at least mine you can buy packs or the whole group, for example. It's a little cheaper than paying individually. I pay it because I choose to and I'm satisfied (I get selcas, drawings, fun chats, warm chats, sometimes videos, etc). And before you choose someone, you already know (or search) at this point how much or which member answer the most.

3

u/BoredEra Oct 16 '21

Oh I didn’t know there was an option like that. Do you get bubble for all the members of the group?

17

u/hombrx Oct 16 '21

Each individual bubble cost US$4, but with the whole pack of 8 it cost US$26 (I pay for 5, US$16). You get their individual bubble and yes, in my case, three of them write daily and two of them like once per week lol but always at least once per week all of them. Lee Know is known for writing daily for the past 4 months, I don't have his bubble but he's hilarious and very sweet, so I think is worth buying his chat haha

49

u/Newhereimo Blue Turquoise Oct 16 '21

Tbh i didn't even know this type of app even exist. Like who tf ask fans to pay for idols to post the same sht they post on free social media?

70

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 17 '21

Not every idol just reposts stuff on their bbl though.

TWICE Momo uses her bubble to acknowledge fanarts from other flatforms.

Usually, she just uploads a fan art on her bubble then asks for credits or who the creator of the art is.

Jeongyeon recently posted that she tried a game(mobile, I think) that's been created by her fans.

I would also like to add that other members are also active(maybe not as much as the other) on bbl

7

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

ok.... I wasn't sold on this but since momo is my favourite idol.......

34

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 17 '21

I'm not subscribed for Bubble but I'm a member of a discord server that does translations for TWICE's members bubble messages.

I think its unfair to lump them to the generalization that idols only reposts boring stuff on their bubble chat

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

[deleted]

9

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

It was fine as it is before. 1 subscription per group. But some greedy bastards came with the idea of making 1 bubble channel for a group member

16

u/elswheeler i must praise loona on the internet Oct 17 '21

it’s more of a “private” conversation for you and your fav, like a text conversation; they come on there and talk about their day, send music/movie/show recs, selfies, videos… etc. it’s not reposts from social media, it’s like getting a text from a friend, kind of. felix from stray kids once told his bubble chat that he was constipated lol

11

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

They don't post it on free social media though That's The Point but there are lots of ppl who repost it and stuff. But sometimes the accounts get taken down

23

u/BoredEra Oct 16 '21

Exactly. I mean, I understand it’s business and all, but this is too much. They can maybe get away if that subscription is per group, but it’s per member

8

u/Away_Yard Oct 17 '21

Bubble is not a novel idea. In US, influencers/ content creators/celebs (along the lines of influencers) also seem to have subscription text messaging now. Seems to work like bubble. Only thing is they are probably not “forced “ into it like idols. Idol is kind of a multifaceted job. With boom of social media, it became inevitable that (social media) influencer became part of their job

62

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

No one is “making fans pay”. It’s a choice. I pay for Bubble despite not knowing how often the idol I’m subscribing to is going to post.

28

u/BoredEra Oct 16 '21

Yes, no one is forced to pay, but they need to subscribe in order to use the app. And because they paid for it, some fans feel the entitlement to be upset or dissatisfied when the artist they subscribed to don’t post often.

19

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

You don’t need to pay to use the Lysn app itself, and sometimes the idols will interact with fans in the public message board. You need to pay if you want to get Bubble messages from the idol directly. I get being angry about not getting what you subscribed for, but it’s not right to say fans are being forced.

21

u/BoredEra Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 16 '21

Yeah I know about lsyn. And I didn’t really say “forced” it’s more like if they want to use the bubble service, then they need to pay for it. I have nothing against Joy or any artists in the platform. Hell, I like Joy and RV. And I’m upset she’s getting backlash because iirc this is the only month she’s been irregular in using bubble because she’s extremely busy with her drama/mc scheds.

What I’m saying is, because fans are paying for a service, they are expecting frequent updates. It’s no problem if all fans understand the idol’s availability to post, but clearly not all do. So they get upset- which won’t happen if the platform is free.

2

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

Thanks for clarifying your point. When you said “making fans pay” I interpreted it as you saying that fans were being compelled to pay for the service.

15

u/BoredEra Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 16 '21

Lol no. Every one has the right to spend their money however they want. My issue is with the companies who can’t stop with the unnecessary paid subscriptions for the otherwise free (and commitment-free) communication between the artists and fans

16

u/magnolia9795 Oct 16 '21

I agree - platforms like weverse are free to use and there are still regular social media. Its just a very exploitative way and companies know some fans are willing to pay so of course they'll try to profit.

6

u/BoredEra Oct 16 '21

Exactly! It’s just capitalism at its finest. At least on a free platform, the fans can’t get mad if the artists don’t post regularly

8

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

In defense of Bubble, I started subscribing to it because I heard that majority of the profits go to the artists. Yes, it’s capitalism, but I feel like people should pay for fan service because it’s a reminder that it’s not a real relationship. Of course, if you have this kind of situation, shit hits the fan, because then fans have a legitimate gripe, but overall, I like that idols are getting something clear-cut from messaging their fans.

28

u/caratleslie Deureotda nwatda haji gamjeongui loop Oct 17 '21

Yeah, the anger is justified. That's messed up.

25

u/myaccount208 Oct 17 '21

Times like these i'm grateful i have groups in weverse and not bubble.

18

u/apartiedeme Oct 17 '21

Have right to be mad at Joy, yes. Blaming her relationship, no.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

I heard about her not posting but I didn't realize she did that part, posting right before refunds... yeah that's kinda fucked up lmao

12

u/tracey_nguyen27 Oct 16 '21

this is not a good look....

16

u/katara98 Oct 17 '21

A lot of people saying "SM must be forcing her" which does not help her case at all...you mean to say all her posts are forced and not genuine which is not a good look.

0

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 17 '21

Her posts were genuine and, before, they tended to be pretty emotional because Joy’s like that. She got a lot of negative comments from being that way, and she even mentioned it on Bubble one time that she’s afraid of how people would interpret what she says. It’s possible that she now feels more compelled to do Bubble than before.

11

u/The_Red_Curtain 엑소 Oct 17 '21

Overall, I like bubble and I like that I'm directly supporting my favorite artists. I only pay for EXO though, and they actually did cool things specifically on Bubble. D.O. and Kai both initially announced their albums were finished on Bubble first and D.O. of course had his Bubble mini-concert when he was posting voice clips while in quarantine. And I did get a direct response from Sehun once too which was cool, and Xiumin updates often whereas he basically never updates instagram.

However, if I was paying and they just never updated at all then I would be salty. When you pay their is literally the promise that the idols will be using the platform so I don't think it's wrong to feel entitled to something. If an idol doesn't want to use Bubble that's perfectly fine, but something like this does strike me as particularly callous.

I honestly don't think SM cares if their idols use Bubble or not as multiple other artists of theirs don't use it and SM makes very little, if anything from it. I think Joy just wanted the money so she sent the message at the last possible moment. Yeah she's filming but D.O. and Sehun were too and they messaged weekly, like sending "sweet dreams" every once in awhile is an extremely low bar.

0

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 17 '21

Joy got called out for not posting. I don’t think it’s fair to assume she posted for the money.

62

u/DefinitelyNotALeak IU & (G)I-DLE || NewJeans | NMIXX | æspa Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 16 '21

I'll be blunt, but some people in the kpop sphere really have to learn it the hard way, just don't use your money for worthless things. It's a life skill anyone has to develop, develop it now.

edit:

So what does Joy do?Makes a post on the last day before refunds are possible for the fans.

I can almost guarantee that she simply doesn't care about the platform, then gets some messages from SM or someone connected to that platform to post something. It's obviously in their best interest to not refund money, so they'll make sure they don't have to do it.
Instead of 'being mad at joy', realize that the product is worthless and don't spend your money that way. That's the actual thing you should do. Now is it questionable to put out a service like this and don't offer much of anything? Absolutely, but there is nothing you can do about it other than not using it. Your money, your choice.

17

u/elswheeler i must praise loona on the internet Oct 17 '21

to be honest, i feel like this wouldn’t be an issue if only companies allowed idols to not use bubble if they don’t like to use it/don’t want to use it… it seems like joy doesn’t feel comfortable using bubble anymore so sm/lysn should just suspend her service and refund fans and that’s it. keeping her on a service that she isn’t enjoying anymore and have fans paying every month for little to no messages is tiring, and i bet the rest of the members use the app more than her. imo it’ll be better for her and luvies subscribed to her bubble to just suspend it already. fans can show their support and love in many other ways and she’ll feel less obligated and therefore more confortable

29

u/Professional-Rule219 Oct 17 '21

a bunch of super junior members dropped out of bubble, if she wants to, she can do the same.

14

u/vivianlight Aqua Pearl Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 16 '21

It's late to night so I'll look for more informations tomorrow, I hope this isn't completely true because it would be very sad tbh... I think that letting people get a refund would have been the most nice thing to do, it's very mean of her. Yes there are contracts I guess, but I doubt she doesn't know all of this, so at least (if she couldn't wait a full month and let the fans have a refund) she should have posted a picture of the sky or something a couple of times per month, that's it. No matter how in my opinion the service is stupid, celebrities exist because of fans, doing the bare minimum should be... The bare minimum lol.

29

u/QuirkyPlatform1476 Oct 16 '21

She definitely knows about this. It’s bad financial news for the company to give refunds so it’s deliberate that she posted when she did

12

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

My question is whether idols are even aware of the refund policy. Joy was called out by netizens like the day before, so it made sense for her to post something the day after it happened. Maybe she hadn’t realized that it’s been a month since she’d last posted. She has basically been off social media for the most part and only posts adverts on Instagram which she’s pretty much contractually obligated to do. I can understand thinking that she was thoughtless about Bubble, but I also don’t think she meant to harm her fans since she’s the most sensitive RV member to fan criticism and she’s also the one with the most recent scandal. She absolutely has zero motivation to alienate people further.

0

u/iijatajkii Oct 18 '21

I mean with that logic she’s kind of contractor obligated to post on bubble too tho?

31

u/xnnxnxnn Blue Turquoise Oct 16 '21

Honestly both sides are valid. Joy might be busy or have her own reasons for not answering and fans are entitled to what they pay. I know a month is a long period of time but still at least you will get your money back. Also let’s be clear if someones knows that joy doesn’t answer frequent it wouldn’t be logical to send her and expect her to magically answer their message.

71

u/IcyRelationship5805 Oct 16 '21

She wouldn’t have gotten hate if she didn’t upload on the last day of the month tho, I doubt she did it unknowingly.

3

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

I don’t think it’s fair to assume what Joy was thinking when she posted. It could be that she knew she hadn’t posted in a month, or she could’ve been responding to all the negative articles about her not posting, or it could be something else entirely. It’s unfair to assume her motivation, but I agree that it’s a bad look regardless of motive.

25

u/KuriboShoeMario Oct 16 '21

I think, if she's someone who is already infrequent, the reality is she probably forgot and one of her watchers at SM (SM watches everything their idols do) probably realized she hadn't made one and told her to make one. It doesn't stop it from looking bad but I don't think this is Joy being malicious.

14

u/Amper_bam Oct 16 '21

She didn’t post until the very last day before possible refunds??? Oh now, that’s just damn fcking petty and childish. That’s just a big f-ck you to her fans then.

15

u/Silver-Command348 Oct 16 '21

Weverse continually looking like the better platform

3

u/PhoenixHusky Oct 18 '21

I believe they actually get an alert to post or the refund thing happens lol, I think it was winwin from nct/wayv who talked about it after he had been alerted by the system twice in 2 months or something.

And while I get the wanting a refund, I don't get why people would remain subscribed to someone with little to no activity then.

Anyway, they all go "have you eaten?" all the time lol

3

u/heejinsoyoung Oct 22 '21

The way that bubble works is just one big scam i swear. It doesnt surprise me thatan idol would eventually use the loophole of just posting a day before the month ended.

3

u/d-2lover Oct 30 '21

joy has a life, family, friends, a drama to shoot, an idol career to manage, music to record, other social media accs to manage, personal commitments, etc etc. if you don't like her not posting on Bubble until the last minute because her company probably forced her to given the 1mth refund policy, just don't buy a Bubble subscription to RV going forward. i have trouble replying to people and I'm a nobody with about 20% the workload she has - so yes, it's easy quick & simple to update, and that's exactly why it doesn't happen lol. she has more important things to focus on. fans have all the right to be disappointed, but trashing on her because of it is weird & shows a disconnect from idols' reality.

34

u/Opia_lunaris Oct 16 '21

Eh, yeah, it's definitely a frustrating situation but we also gotta be responsible with how we spent our money. Bubble is probably one of the most useless apps on the face of this planet- this is not news to anyone, and I hope people see now that it's time to cut their losses. Even if they don't get back the money for 1 month, they'll save money in the long run.

29

u/4evertrapped Oct 16 '21

I feel like this comment is just blaming the victim. Like if you buy an album and the album sucks, would you say to a fan that they should haven been responsible for their money? Both the album and the app is a service that a fan buys to support their artists. If you think the app is a useless service then it is still the artist's fault for being a part of that service. If the artists are a part of it, they should atleast provide the service fully.

76

u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 16 '21

If you pre-order an album before even a track list is released by a group and it ends up being terrible, you are 100% responsible for spending your money on something you know nothing about. Who else is to blame if you risk your money on something without any knowledge on an item?

Similarly, if you are disappointed by an idol’s inactivity on bubble and feel the subscription is wasteful, just unsubscribe. You can get updates on Twitter anyway, and you can always subscribe to someone else under the same ticket subscription if the idol isn’t posting as often as you like

You literally are the only person responsible for where you spend your own money. If you don’t like a service, ask for a refund, don’t continue spending money on something you’re not enjoying

42

u/romancevelvet Oct 16 '21

blaming the victim

victim of what.

also if you buy an album and it sucks, you arent a victim, you just made a bad purchase. if the product itself came as it was advertised -- in a good state and time....tough luck that you dont like it. this is not the best comparison.

0

u/happylittlepandas Oct 18 '21

I agree with you. If the album sucks and you don’t like it, don’t buy any future albums the artists make….

10

u/DefinitelyNotALeak IU & (G)I-DLE || NewJeans | NMIXX | æspa Oct 16 '21

Like if you buy an album and the album sucks, would you say to a fan that they should haven been responsible for their money?

Yes actually! The album is the album, it's value is mostly subjective and even if we talk about 'objective flaws' in the music, where most people would agree it 'sucks', you certainly didn't have to buy it.
Where it's different is when the product itself is 'broken' in some way, say you buy an album but some songs don't play at all, items are missing or whatever. That's when there is a "victim" (in the broadest sense of the word).
Outside of that, it's on the consumer to be a little smarter, which doesn't mean one cannot criticize the product ofc.

10

u/Newhereimo Blue Turquoise Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 16 '21

I think they meant that people should also try to use their money carefully. Buying albums and playing for the songs is totally different from paying for an idol to post something they already do on insta, twitter and thousands of other apps. The reason companies and idols take advantage of the fans is because of people like you who throw ur money but blame the idols for not doing sht when we all know that most people in this world are just money hungry and that will keep happening. First it was joy then another idol will pull up this sht so the fans should learn their lesson and just not pay? It's not hard. Anyways, I know that the company and joy are also at fault for not posting when fans are literally paying them.

22

u/4evertrapped Oct 16 '21

I understand where you are coming from, that fans should grow some common sense. But I think we can both agree the the fault is mostly with the artist for being so money-hungry in the first place. You mentioned that most people in the world are money-hungry and that is true, but that doesn't take away from the fact that being money-hungry is bad. So yes the fans should gain common sense and understand that artists are not the be all, end all. But the majority of the fault is on the artist.

lol i guess i just feel really strongly about this. sry for the rant

1

u/Newhereimo Blue Turquoise Oct 16 '21

No i agree. You are right that it's the fault of the majority who want to earn as much as possible by any means, it's wrong but tbh we can't really change it. We can only complain but money is something which is just so important in this world that most even want to take advantage of other people and pull some sht. It's the same with companies and idols...we can't really change it so for our own sake we should try to not give them any of our money.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

[deleted]

11

u/elswheeler i must praise loona on the internet Oct 17 '21

i don’t think parents would spend on something like that 😭😭 bubble is a monthly subscription so it’s mostly fans that have a somewhat stable income and find the app interesting

13

u/sma68 Oct 16 '21

Not a reveluv but thats such a crappy thing to do to your fans

8

u/rainykg Oct 17 '21

this is why weverse is better.

6

u/Sovereign-Over-All Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 17 '21

Agreed. Bubble already has a refund policy if an artist doesn't make a post for a month. I don't think it would've been a big deal if she didn't make a post and let fans get their money back.

I don't really know why some people are blaming fans?? It's a paid service. Of course fans have the right to be angry when they can't get a refund.

6

u/Manlla Oct 17 '21

ooh yikes, didn't know she did the last day trick

10

u/aridnie Oct 16 '21

Honestly the staff probably made her send messages. It’s very unlikely Joy made a conscientious decision to post on the very last day. She definitely knows the rules. But SM is the one who’s going to enforce something like this.

I agree it’s still a sucky thing to do to fans (I’m subscribed to Joy’s bbl) who pay and deserve that refund. Red Velvet isn’t the best at bbl messages and I used to subscribe to all 5, but because they use it so infrequently, I only subscribe to my bias (Joy) now. Compared to the NCT members I subscribe to, it’s a lot more fun.

14

u/army__mali RV | Heize | æspa | NCT | itzy Oct 17 '21

This is so interesting because when jaehyun does this exact thing, people find it hilarious and endearing. When joy does it, it’s worthy of criticism. Personally I think they’re BOTH worthy of criticism, it’s kinda shitty to do it on the very last day of the month. The contrast in fan reactions is crazy though.

26

u/Professional-Rule219 Oct 17 '21

Jaehyun sent 29 messages, meanwhile Joy sent 0. It's not the same at all...

0

u/army__mali RV | Heize | æspa | NCT | itzy Oct 17 '21

I don’t know how many he sends but nctzens joke a lot about how jaehyun sends his once a month bubble to fulfill the requirement and never sends anything again. He used to send a lot less, but suddenly a couple months ago he had to adhere to this once a month rule. I agree it’s not the exact same situation because I doubt he sent one on the very last day, but they’re comparable.

14

u/juno563 you’re my home 🌻 Oct 17 '21

Did the same thing happen with Jaehyun as well? This is the first time I’m hearing of it. If the reactions really were that drastically different, that’s really baffling…

And tbh I think the arguments on both sides are valid. I love Joy, but evidently it looks really tactless to send a message on the last day before fans can get a refund, and the fans who were affected do have the right to feel angry (though I suspect management may have had a hand in making her post at least at the last minute). On the other hand, I also dislike the idea of paid services like Bubble and making it an obligation for idols to update constantly on it. I feel like it’d be much better for both fans and idols if these paid services didn’t exist. The only real benefitors are the companies that earn money through them.

4

u/juwaria91 Oct 17 '21

I feel like the Sf9 members talk on it really well. Rowoon doesn’t have one which is best because he’s always so busy he’ll never be on - he barely posts anywhere else and on Instagram he posts pics of the sky 🙄 like thanks mate - nice to see what the Korean sky looks like 😂😂

2

u/mikrokosmosmoonchild Oct 19 '21 edited Oct 19 '21

Edit: actually - after reading other people’s comments, I take it back. It sounds like Joy used to bubble more but then got backlash from her responses. Taemin from SHINee also had a few instances where his bubbles were misinterpreted, or him sharing his emotions was met with pretty intense backlash, and he responded by talking about being more careful. It was really sad. I’m going to choose to believe Joy is working through it and trying, and sometimes that means when a deadline approaches, she tries her best to meet it.

My old post -

I wonder if she has a chunk of fans who can vibe with her barebones approach lol. I’m old enough to not care about bubble for the most part, and really do see it as a way that I am directly paying an artist I care about without siphoning it through their entertainment company. I am lucky that the members I subscribe to are super diligent and enjoy using bubble, but I’m going to be honest lol - I have a backlog of messages I haven’t checked from them because I don’t care that much lol

8

u/Kotaac Oct 16 '21

Lmao who pays for this stuff when u can jus read it on Twitter

3

u/happylittlepandas Oct 18 '21

Just cancel the subscription then. No one is forcing you to continue to pour money into it.

1

u/silkpearls Nov 01 '21

youd lose money if you do that lmao.

1

u/happylittlepandas Nov 01 '21

Why? Do you have to pay for a year subscription?

2

u/Sister_Winter Oct 17 '21

Tbh it sounds like she doesn't want to do it at all and is contractually obligated or something.

0

u/MoomooBlinksOnce If you didn't check Heart of Woman yet you're missing out bad Oct 17 '21

As an employee she does as she's told. So that's misdirected anger.

3

u/resetjk Oct 18 '21

As an employee she isn't forced to post or even use the app,many SM idols don't post or simply don't have it at all so why would she be a special case?

Fans have every right to be mad after she scammed them of a refund by finding a loophole

-9

u/nctzenhours Xiaojun‘s eyebrows Oct 16 '21

Idk if I’m the only one but I personally can’t get behind it at all. Joy is not obligated to post frequently on Bubble, fans are the ones who made the decision to subscribe

78

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

I kind of get what you mean but, they got sold a service, not constant posts but some level of interaction with thier idol not normally available. But form what I've read, not only is she not posting, but what she is posting tends to be copied from her instagram. And they cant get thier money back unless she doesnt post for a month.

To me it's like buying a skirt but before you can wear it, it falls apart and when you take it back they wont give you a refund. I'd be mad too.

26

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

I’ve been subscribed to Joy’s Bubble for a year, and I don’t think her posts are copied from Instagram. She does post a few photos on Instagram after she posts them on Bubble, but she usually gives more context and talks more about her feelings in Bubble.

Joy is also in a weird position in terms of Bubble usage, because a lot of anti-Joy Reveluvs kind of mocked her for sharing too much of her personal feelings on Bubble. She would sometimes get super serious, and those messages delved more deeply into her thoughts/feelings than the messages of other members.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

Thanks for the extra context, it really helps having someone who has the service giving a bit more info.

But I got to ask, there are anti joy reveluvs? Also how dedicated are they to subscribe to her just to be her anti? People are weird.

10

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

Yeah, pretty much each member has antis who are fans of the other members. The fandom is pretty toxic that way. I don’t think the antis were subscribed, but people posted about her Bubble messages at that time and she was mocked for them. The reason why Joyfuls think she knows about antis mocking her is because there was one time she said something to the effect of “If I tell you how I feel, will you take it negatively?”

6

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

Jesus christ. I heard alot of reveluvs became solo's during the hiatus for Wendy's health but I had no idea it was that bad. Thanks for letting me know.

7

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

Yeah, Joy’s also being blamed by some fans for the short Queendom promotions because they somewhat coincided with her filming. The fandom is very tiring to say the least.

41

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

Fans make the decision to subscribe because they expect to get the thing they paid for, so if they're not getting it the frustration is understandable. If you pay for a service you expect to recieve the service, don't you?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '21

Why do people even buy bubble? /gen

1

u/Foreign-Avocado4916 Oct 21 '21

Hi agree, people pay just yo talk with their idol. And if the idol do things like this. Fans will became angry.

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 21 '21

Hello /u/Foreign-Avocado4916. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/ClothesBulky941 Aqua Frost Oct 26 '21

i feel this struggle, i pay money for the site, i have to be treated fairly as a customer. it is like you buying a product and when you come home it is empty, i have every right to be mad as a customer. i spend money for it. well for anyone you can purchase aespa’s they message about 50 messages a day lol i purchase snsd’s for a month and they are not even half of what karina sends me in a night

-5

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

I feel like she’d be criticized either way. There were articles being spread around that were calling her out for not posting anything on Bubble, so it made sense for her to post something. Since she did post, people are angry that they can’t get a refund, but if she’d posted a bit earlier than the refund date, the situation would’ve been the same anyway.

33

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

True but i think she should have posted after the month deadline, so the fans who wanted the refund could get it becuase why people are getting mad is now it seems like she posted just before the refund date so she can keep that money.

If she posted a bit before the refund date people would still flame her, but it wouldnt gain as much traction becuase it wouldnt have gotten so close to the refund and many idols dont seem to post frequently.

2

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

I don’t think it’s fair to assume that she was motivated by the money. She could’ve been, of course, but the timing also coincided with her being flamed by fans in Korea, so posting something right away might have felt necessary. Who knows if she even remembered that fans could get a refund if she hadn’t posted by October 15th? Like that’s an important policy for fans, but I wouldn’t be surprised if she’d forgotten about that.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

All the stories include the date saying they have 1 more day before they can get a refund. I wasn't assuming she was money motivated, my point was that she should have waited becuase there is no way it would look good to post at that time and that's how she would look to everyone, no matter the truth.

-4

u/__fujiko Oct 16 '21

I don't know why you're getting downvoted. I completely agree. It's literally stated that the idols schedule has to be considered when signing up. Joy has been busy as fuck. You MIGHT get something from it and that's always been the case. She probably thought "oh no I don't want my fans to be upset with me," posted and is STILL getting backlash. Annoying tbh.

1

u/jei1220 Oct 17 '21

Can someone explain Bubble to me? I've heard about it but Idk the rule and how they work. Are they like fancafe or weverse? Whatsapp??

1

u/Electrical_Fan3344 Oct 17 '21

The posting a message on the last day bit is pretty bad…other than that though, if it’s a chore to idols it’s better that they don’t post instead of forcing it. Fans can just unsubscribe and get someone’s bubble that’s better

0

u/2510linoring Oct 17 '21

paying for the bubble of an idol who doesn't care about it is just wasting your money. why do people pay for it if they know the idol hates that app lmao buy yourself a burger or something with that money

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21

the sense of entitlement is absurd

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21

Lmao what?? The whole point of having a subscription is that Idols DO post so where’s the entitlement in that?

If she’s too busy to do that she shouldn’t offer it to her fans. Or worse, take their chance for a refund away.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21

Giving money for a service that isn’t guaranteed to exist is risky therefore no one forced anyone to do it(least we expect). It wasn’t a secret as well.

Idk if she was forced to answer on the very last day or not I can’t say it in her place. She might’ve been busy to the point of not even having the time to breath or she could not want too which isn’t a crime since bubble isn’t her invention.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21

Y’all do everything BUT hold grown ass Idols accountable huh? 😭

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21

What a horrid accusation… dw I don’t owe any of them my life for me not to hold them acc but the thing is this could’ve been easily prevented if ppl knew better than paying a dubious app to talk to famous strangers that most likely don’t care abt speaking to a bunch of excited strangers

Im saying this for their good, im not putting celebrities on any kind of pedestal, on the contrary.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21

But still Joy was in the wrong here? That’s OP’s whole point? This just feels like you’re victim blaming people instead of addressing what she did.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Im just not surprised at all that this happened, of course none of this is right.

-13

u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 16 '21

Based on the last few days I wouldn’t be surprised if SM and Joy decided to suspend Joy’s bubble based on all the hate she’s receiving over a service nobody is obliged to pay for

It’s really not hard to unsubscribe if you’re not satisfied with her service, and it’s also not hard to swap Joy out for another more active member

How does the refund even work anyway? Is it a set day in the month that SM have decided to refund subscribers? I say this because most people’s subscriptions are not renewed on the same day; so how can it be claimed that she did this on purpose to block refunds?

50

u/Ebony_Coco ONEUS ZB1 ALD1 XLOV TNX ONEPACT ATEEZ WEI VERIVERY Oct 16 '21

"It’s really not hard to unsubscribe if you’re not satisfied with her service"

If they unsubscribe, they won't get a refund. The only way they could have received a refund is if Joy hadn't made a post for a month. Once Joy's month-long deadline was about to end. she made a post. Now, if her fans unsubscribe, they will not get a refund.

Joy basically made it so her fans cannot unsubscribe from her Bubble without still having to pay her for a service she didn't do until the very last minute only so she could keep their money.

-10

u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 16 '21

I just mean the people that are continually unhappy with her inactivity, why continue to be subscribed to Joy’s bubble if by her not being active it feels like a financial burden or unsatisfactory as a consumer

If the refund is based on her last active date and not your subscription renewal, you could just not pay for another month and get your updates elsewhere. It’s fine being disgruntled that the refund was stopped but the hate towards Joy is stupid

4

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

Yeah, I think this would be the best course of action. I feel bad because around this time last year, fans had so much appreciation for her for interacting with fans in a unique way through Bubble. She had a TV show report competition thing, and she really read through the fans’ submissions. I think it’s really a function of her being busy and just not really caring about social media right now. She barely updates her Instagram even.

7

u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 16 '21

I read somewhere that she got a lot of hate and was mocked for being open with her fans on Bubble, and based on Ryeowook’s experience, I wouldn’t be surprised if Joy antis subscribed just to send her hate

She could also just be very busy and have a lot of things going on rn and like you said, updating social media could be the last thing on her mind

In my experience, when I was subscribed to Taeil he posted once in the 3 months I was subscribed so I switched to Taeyong instead. Same happened with Chenle. I’ve heard that they’re a lot more active now but I would never think to 1) throw hate or 2) be angry at them for being inactive. I just got over it and subscribed to another person I’m also a fan of using the same ticket

I just don’t logically see how hating or getting angry at an idol for not posting would result in you getting what you want. If anything Joy would want to avoid any further hate and would either post more (so they’ve bullied her into posting) or suspend her bubble (bullied off of the platform). Either way, it’s not a good outcome

11

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 16 '21

Aside from her drama, I’m also wondering if she got a lot of angry messages after her dating news came out. Before that, she was fairly consistent with her Bubble messages. I get why fans are frustrated, but if you’re a fan, I feel like you should also be understanding when it comes to your idol. Joy wasn’t like this before, so it might be important to think about her context and what’s happened. It’s just not fair that some people are saying that she doesn’t appreciate fans or even implying that she’s exploiting them by not letting them get a refund. I really hope she’s not getting hate through Bubble, but yeah, who knows really…

9

u/irishornornirish We are at the tram stop; are you the tram that stops? Oct 16 '21

That was an underlying thought I had too… Like what if she got a lot of comments on bubble about her relationship that made her uncomfortable using the service

It’s one of those things that we may never know

But I feel like Joy, and a lot of other idols, are entitled to disconnect every now and again and turn off from social media. It doesn’t mean that they don’t care about their fans, it just means they’re busy with their own lives. And if fans don’t like it, there’s nothing stopping them from unsubscribing

2

u/not-the-em-dash Oct 16 '21

Agreed. I wish that was a possibility. I know others have stopped using Bubble altogether, but maybe Joy doesn’t necessarily want to do that especially since RV is such a small group. A Bubble hiatus would be very much warranted instead.

-7

u/caramaas Oct 16 '21 edited Oct 17 '21

idk. if joy is known for not using bubble, then why subscribe for 1 post a month and purposefully lose your money? instagram is free and she's more active there anyway.

i take it people would rather be mad at joy than to consider the possibility that they can actually decide to not pay for something they are not happy with.

-2

u/Away_Yard Oct 17 '21

For job that relies on the love of your fans she needs to do more. Watching she show off her wealth sometimes ticks me off. I know there are humble celebrities and her personality from interviews makes her seem nice and friendly but that contrast with displaying wealth sometimes rubs me the wrong way? Influence culture maybe

-2

u/nctzenhours Xiaojun‘s eyebrows Oct 17 '21

I don’t see any issues with it. She worked hard to get where she is now. I‘d flex too if I were her

-15

u/Mercylic I am the ghost from OK!+ Oct 16 '21

I mean no one is forced to subscribe. If you are not getting your moneys worth, then why do you keep spending your money on it anyway? Just unsubscribe, it's not that hard to do.

33

u/sunshinias ✨Seungmin 4th gen it boy✨ Oct 16 '21

I'm convinced some of you don't actually read the post. The problem is that unsubscribing still causes you to lose money for that subscription period, unless the idol hasn't posted for a month. Maybe these people complaining were planning to unsubscribe - it's still fair to want a refund too when they didn't receive the service they payed for.

If Joy doesn't want to use bubble, fine. In the future people will know not to subscribe to her. But when she chooses not to use it for almost an entire month, only to post on the very last day before fans would receive a very valid refund, it's hard not to believe that it was done intentionally so the they wouldn't be able to get it. And that is why she's being criticized.

-4

u/Rayesafan Oct 16 '21

I know very little about this, but I’m wondering if it’s the platform’s fault. Maybe stiff-arming her into posting?

And it’s just a crummy platform to have these rules.

8

u/Amper_bam Oct 17 '21

No it’s not the platform’s fault. She posted on the very last day before refunds so that she can keep fans’ money. That’s a pretty fcked up move on her part.

-1

u/Rayesafan Oct 17 '21

I guess I should ask who gets the money? If the platform gets the money, I could see them encouraging her to post. If she gets the money, then I see it why she would want to post.

Like how youtube changes the incentivizing of ad revenues. The content creators have some part of it, but it's YouTube being greedy.

It looks like SM is the head of the service. Do they get the money? Or does Joy get it? I guess I'm saying that it might not have been her initial choice. Perhaps it was SM's? (Or someone in the company in charge.)

Where I think I'd be frustrated at Joy is that she didn't post before the month's end. She should know that she wouldn't be allowed to let x amount of fans get refunds. So, she should give the fans a little more.

1

u/Amper_bam Oct 17 '21

I believe SM gets the money, and Joy gets some of it, similar to Youtube. However, you’re right that most fans are frustrated because she didn’t post until the month’s end.

1

u/Rayesafan Oct 17 '21

That makes sense.

-14

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

Is it right for them to put the blame on someone other than themselves though?

-45

u/hahahoha Oct 16 '21

gained new respect for Joy

-8

u/-tenyong- sticker apologist, nct/wayv ♡ superm ♡ aespa Oct 17 '21

Don't pay for it then. Bubble is weird istg