r/kpopthoughts • • Oct 10 '21

Shitpost “People who listen to K-Pop are so evil! Why would you support such a horrible industry?!”

Says Corine, age 18 this past July after watching Black Widow on Disney + just a day after Scarlett Johansson’s lawsuit announcement, typing this from her newly bought iPhone which was made by young people in a sweatshop China who are severely underpaid, while blasting her J-Pop playlist.

619 Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 10 '21

Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read.

Oh, and you can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

305

u/mayonnaise_mf Oct 10 '21

while also listening to american artists on her spotify

247

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

As they listen to Taylor Swift who literally had all her music taken from her and now needs to re-record the music she wrote. Or even listening to any Sony artist after what the company did to Ke$ha.

183

u/nctzenhours Xiaojun‘s eyebrows Oct 10 '21

The American / western in general entertainment industry is just as fucked as the Korean one. It’s not exclusive to Korea or Asia, it’s an entertainment industry thing.

The kpop industry is just more open about it I guess

159

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21 edited Oct 10 '21

Whenever I see articles about “the dark side of kpop” I can’t help but think a small motivation of those articles come from a place of racism. The dark sides of entertainment are never really spoken about unless it’s about foreign industries who just so happen to pick up an audience in the west. And it’s always spoken with such arrogant “look America isn’t as bad as them” undertones.

When slum dog millionaire came out there was a rising Bollywood interest in the US and the amount of “the dark side of Bollywood” articles that came out were ridiculous.

43

u/RosieOtter Oct 10 '21

I completely agree! It also gives me vibes of "these stupid little girls who listen to it don't have a clue" like yes we fucking do? Especially older kpop fans who've been here a while. Kinda figured that out when our idols kept killing/attempting to kill themselves. Not to mention the OBVIOUS racism and misogyny in the industry. It just comes off as so patronizing bc its a thing that typically teen girls like and ANYTHING they like MUST be bad in some way.

2

u/joys_red_dress Swipe swipe swipe 😜 Oct 26 '21

I always feel the same almost like they want the narrative of, "Oh look America is cool and calm and we know what HUMAN RIGHTS are and these people are in ever so poor conditions how can someone be so cruel!!! 😢 " while no one knows what they are up to because they hide everything they can and the amount of misinformation they probably would put out and I seriously don't see why they try things like you still have tons of people who love Hollywood. Don't get me started on the way they view men who shave and clean themselves like they call them feminine as if that's bad and see them as "gay" which also shows the casual homophobia tossed around in the west even when I say it in my country I like kpop people see it as 'gay' and honestly what does it mean to be gay? Please elaborate on what you mean. Also tbh the west don't have the most interesting things it's just redone over and over till I take my eyes out and honestly it feels boring like the west is meh but I'm talking about the american industry specifically.

15

u/lovelysweetangel89 ♫You Make Me Feel Special♫ Oct 10 '21

I remember that too, how convenient is it when a foreign media gets popular, suddenly there's articles or videos talking about the dark side of it's industry as if the American industry is that better.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

Slum dog millionaire would be the only Indian movie they watched.

-4

u/KitakatZ101 Oct 10 '21

I think that’s more because there have been quite a few movies about the dark side of Hollywood and articles. At least with Americans were familiar with it. When their is interest in something people also want to know the dark shit

33

u/GrillMaster3 Are you all paparazzi? Oct 10 '21

Sure there is, but you don’t see people getting shamed for supporting Hollywood despite the ridiculous amount of literal criminals running around unhindered. If I say “I just watched the Wolf of Wall Street” nobody’s going to say “What? You watched the movie that made Margot Robbie uncomfortable to film? With Leonardo DiCaprio, a known creep who’s incredibly rude to his staff?” There’s definitely more of an interest in shaming people for the flaws with foreign industries than there is in shaming people for the flaws of Hollywood.

2

u/KitakatZ101 Oct 10 '21

Woidy Allen

13

u/GrillMaster3 Are you all paparazzi? Oct 10 '21

Woody Allen is a known creep that operates mostly unhindered in Hollywood, yes. He also has dozens of celebrities that have said they’d happily work with him despite this. And there is shockingly little done to actually criticize the things he makes/made, and he’s still a superstar with a career.

-2

u/KitakatZ101 Oct 10 '21

His last movie was quietly released with no promotion

8

u/GrillMaster3 Are you all paparazzi? Oct 10 '21

You’re glazing over the part where he still produced and released the movie.

→ More replies (0)

12

u/loverofloquats Oct 10 '21

Michael Jackson warned us that Sony was the devil 20 years ago. He wasn't joking.

I can't believe the animal that did those things to Kesha is still working. I believe her 100% and believe it is way worse than she has ever admitted.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21

I never followed the case too closely, but I remember the photos that went semi-viral on tumblr of the absolute devastation on her face when it was ruled she had to remain under contract. My heart breaks for her.

2

u/loverofloquats Oct 11 '21

That is so sad to hear. :(

136

u/DuctTapeSloth Oct 10 '21

There is no point in people making that statement. It’s impossible in today’s world, unless you are an unconnected tribe, to use or consume guilt free ethically sourced things/entertainment. From food to tech to entertainment ALL has a dark seeded underbelly.

122

u/animeprofilepicture Oct 10 '21

the funny thing is there’s just as much corruption/monopoly/industry planting etc. in the western music industry it’s just that people don’t care. plus it’s easy for them to point fingers at kpop because a lot of people don’t know anything about it they’re just xenophobic

41

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

In North America, there is a sense of "freedom" -- so people believe that the artists have the freedom to make their own choices, despite their management companies, while Korean artists are tightly controlled. Maybe with the Britney Spears situation coming to light, people here will realize that North American artists are controlled just as much by their management.

3

u/JusticeRhino Oct 11 '21

The control in a lot of US based music is less overt and name/likeness/lifestyle clause-y like Kpop. However the financial control is soul crushing. A standard model is that the record company loans the artists the money to record albums and make music videos. Paying all that back is where the profits go from record sales and touring merch. It would break your heart to know what a tiny percentage of sales makes it’s way back to artists. Yay! Freedom.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21

True. However, Disney stars in North America are tightly controlled in their lifestyle and image. I imagine their experiences are very similar to Kpop idols.

2

u/JusticeRhino Oct 11 '21

That makes sense

95

u/SnooHabits6066 Boom Shakalaka Oct 10 '21

They don’t even need to listen to J-Pop, it could very well have been Justin Bieber.

41

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

I got in the most hilarious Twitter slapfight the other day with a dude who kept telling me that "eleven year-olds are signing contracts that strip them of their autonomy". And also said that I was wrong when I explained that the wide majority of K-Pop artists have writing credits and a say in their concept and direction. But he couldn't name a single company or group to use as an example.

The best part was when he said "I'm not calling the idols 11 when did I say that by shit I'm talking about the trainees" and I got to show him a screenshot of his own tweet saying "Idols are 11 they are exploiting kids yes this happens accept it i know it's harsh but it's true."

Anyhow I just think its funny when they act like we don't care about how awful the industry is? Despite the fact that we're way more educated on what these companies do and constantly, endlessly talk shit about even the most minor things a company does that affects our idols. Tastes like mansplaining but with a dash of racist stereotypes about East-Asians and a side of "won't somebody please think of the children?!"

70

u/pieluvr65 Oct 10 '21

While wearing clothes from shein

26

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

Whilst wearing fashion Nova and streaming an artist who promotes fashion Nova.

68

u/-gyuwu- “you aint in the game, youre just cheerleaders” Oct 10 '21

duh as if disney and hollywood is any better. imagine being that narrow minded XD

18

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21 edited Oct 10 '21

I encourage everyone who says this to watch [THIS] (https://youtu.be/vxj9rogBPi0) video also the [first] (https://youtu.be/bn0gmu_m-os) one but I feel the second one is better In actually getting to the heart of it. Actually everyone should watch this tbh.

5

u/lovelysweetangel89 ♫You Make Me Feel Special♫ Oct 10 '21

I feel sad that those have low views, while outdated, orientalist, sensationalist videos about kpop darkside have millions of views.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

Don’t worry I found the videos bc of a “dark side of kpop” video. These videos are actually getting shared a lot in the comment sections of these videos so I’m sure more people who actually care will watch them.

4

u/lovelysweetangel89 ♫You Make Me Feel Special♫ Oct 10 '21

I'm sorta glad to see that, props to the kpop fans posting it. :)

13

u/Kpoopfan Oct 10 '21

People like this are so bloody annoying. Every industry in the world is like this, but people love talking and writing about the dark side of Kpop.

33

u/ohkinchana Aqua Lake Oct 10 '21

… while wearing her Made in China clothing and eating a hamburger.

10

u/TimVdV Oct 10 '21

The stuff that child actresses turned stars like Selena Gomez, Miley Cyrus, Zendaya, Ariana Grande etc have gone through with Disney and Nickelodeon is just as bad as any kpop trainee.

Or even what Doja Cat or Cardi B have said recently that they’re overworked, tired and have anxiety but that they’re labels keep pushing them to work and do more shows, records etc

Western music industry is just as bad.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

I literally know someone who has questioned me "how can you call yourself a feminist when you watch those sexualizing videos everyday" multiple times.

6

u/illachrymableness Heng:garae supremacy Oct 10 '21

i've genuinely never met anyone who makes my brain hurt the way people like that hurt my brain. i would rather stand being cancelled by big fandoms on twt than have to talk to someone who thinks like this. the mental gymnastics that they do to show "tHe dArKeR sIdE oF kPoP" is astounding.

like these people im convinced don't know about context clues. because half the shit they mention are the same shit western idols do. they see western celebrities who go through hardship as determined, but when its a kpop idol goes through hardship all of the sudden its "unethical & the dark side."

like they're people. they want kpop idols to be human, but the moment they are, they twist it to fit their narrative that kpop is bad and the industry is bad.

they don't care, they never do. they do whatever they want to try and prove that kpop bad and you should feel bad for supporting it and they're right. even though they watch hollywood movies as if hollywood isn't infested with corporations and crimes.

6

u/starfire_112 Oct 10 '21

What's wrong with J-pop?

16

u/Shiny_stars_09 Aqua Frost Oct 10 '21

The industry also similar to kpop in that they ban idols from dating. And there was a case of an idol who was caught dating and had to shave her head and apologise to fans

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-21299324

35

u/cherrycoloured shinee/loona/svt/f(x)/chungha/zb1 Oct 10 '21

minami minegishi, the idol who shaved her head, chose to do that on her own. actually, akb48s management was pissed that she shaved her head, bc ofc buzzcuts are not very idol-like, and made her wear wigs until her hair grew out to her ears. normally, when an idol is caught dating, they just have to apologize, and are demoted for a little bit. shaving your head is a very traditional japanese way of apologizing, but no idol had ever done it before or since, even when caught doing something actually bad.

the jpop idol scene is not great, but id rather ppl focus on the actual issues, than this sensationalist "akb48 made a girl shave her head for dating!!" headline thats not even true.

6

u/lovelysweetangel89 ♫You Make Me Feel Special♫ Oct 10 '21

This, i was a jpop stan at the time and as a AKB48 fan, thank you for correcting people on this. The amount of missinfo about this incident, including people saying she was kicked out the group (which is false, she was the longest lasting member of the group.) is astounding af.

3

u/lovelysweetangel89 ♫You Make Me Feel Special♫ Oct 10 '21

Jpop does gets the dark side treatment a lot, especially when it comes to minami minegishi incident and a few other things, i was a jpop stan at the time and i can't tell folks how many times i get the, "omg jpop groups make thier idols shave thier heads" stuff, neverminded the fact she did it herself and the folks were pissed that she did it.

But you are right tho at folks hypocrisy when it comes to this topic tho, those stupid ass anti-kpop documentaries are the main reason why folks think shit like this. The articles and documentary videos are always sensationalized, and sometimes even outdated or basically wrong info presented as facts.

Don't get me started at how idol de*ths are handled by these fuckers. They almost never treat the deceased idols like humans at all and even spreading missinfo about their passings.

3

u/asianpaleboiii Oct 11 '21

This post is so based

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

I may be in the minority but I've definitely seen criticisms towards all industries :/ trust me, western media isn't getting such an easy pass either... especially with recent top stories.

2

u/ryleeesweets Oct 10 '21

the kpop industry is no less horrible than the American entertainment industry, or any capitalist industry for that matter. that's why I'll never understand people who say that stuff about kpop

3

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

These comments make me sad.

3

u/jxanne Oct 10 '21

i know what ur trying to say but u come off as so childish to defend ur own views like this. even if u were 100% right u can’t seriously think u can critically evaluate ur own opinions

1

u/MANDdanmr Oct 11 '21

The argument about “kpop darkside” is childish at the very beginning.

4

u/jxanne Oct 11 '21

but how? in what universe is it childish to point out that any big industry with big corporations always has nefarious things going on in the background. very dangerous to say it doesn’t exist solely because u like listening to the music

3

u/MANDdanmr Oct 11 '21

Calling out the “dark side” to fight for justice is good, but calling it out to ruin people’s fun, to stop people from enjoying what they love is super childish cause like you already said, it always happens. It’s the same as telling people not to live in this world because there’re criminals everywhere. In OP’s case, apparently it’s the 2nd case.

2

u/serowajin Oct 10 '21

Says everyone writing things on reddit that's owned by the CCP Tencent

2

u/mango_mochi95 Oct 10 '21

who is Corine anyways?? lol

0

u/CrescentToast Oct 10 '21

Yeah no clue what any of this is about aye

-13

u/foreverwarrenpeace Oct 10 '21

Who is even saying this tho lol

27

u/eunhadior Oct 10 '21

everyone who has a hate boner for kpop lol

0

u/foreverwarrenpeace Oct 10 '21

Yeah I don’t think I’ve ever seen anyone say people who listen to kpop are evil and I’ve been into kpop since 2012 but I guess

-24

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

Corine's actions might be wrong (also keep in mind that she might she might be doing smthg whose dangers she is unaware of) but still her last 2 words are correct.

I don't agree with her first 8 words though. Even if people know one quarter of this industry's perversity (i.e survival shows, debuting minors, sexualization right left, corruption, rigging etccccc yes I know we find them everywhere else and whatever they touch, it becomes rotten as well), some might still support what they know is evil, they'll simply choose their comfort bc it is easier than putting ourselves in other's shoes. Also we might not have enough information in order to force ourselves to wear other people's shoes😖

8

u/GrillMaster3 Are you all paparazzi? Oct 10 '21

There is literally NO entertainment or product that can be consumed ethically. Every single industry has a dark side, Hollywood is no exception, Apple is no exception, there are no exceptions. Kpop fans are, for the most part, hyperaware of the industry and what happens in it. People write petitions and start outrage when an idol’s shoe is so much as scuffed. We know what’s bad and good. This post is pointing out how people target Kpop as if we don’t know what’s wrong with it, while blindly consuming things that are JUST as bad and exploitative.

There is no ethical consumption under capitalism.

-4

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

Yeah but I wonder if not spending a dime on what isn’t vital would make things better even by 0.01%

6

u/GrillMaster3 Are you all paparazzi? Oct 10 '21

No, because then what to all the people who need the money from the “unnecessary” stuff do? In the end, there is no way to consume ANYTHING ethically. Media, electronics, food, toys, games, clothes, ANYTHING. The best we can do is try to force change (in things like Kpop this change is becoming more evident with the laws about 7 year contracts and child labor laws, plus idols being allowed to keep using their names and songs after leaving a company, etc), so driving such change in OTHER places is the best we can do because even if industries suck, people rely on them.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 10 '21

Hello /u/minaluvsyou_. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '21

[deleted]

1

u/AutoModerator Dec 29 '21

Hello /u/goldenfilm. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.