r/kpopthoughts • BM make it bang • Oct 10 '21

Merchandise + Marketing Gaon vs Hanteo: a pocket guide

There’s been some discussion and confusion, so for anyone who doesnt know, I figured a post wouldnt go amiss.

The two main physical album sale charts in Korea are Gaon and Hanteo charts. They both get used in equal frequency, but both display distinct infromation about an album. To break it down:

GAON

Gaon reports on the shipments from DISTRIBUTOR to RETAILERS. So these count how many albums gaon-certified retailers have bought to sell. These are stock albums, and reflect how many albums are expected to be sold as time goes on.

The gaon number will ALWAYS be higher than the Hanteo number, as stores can’t sell albums that never left the manufacturer.

Companies like SM, JYP and YG DO NOT report their own numbers to Gaon. Gaon collects the numbers independent from the company.

Gaon is used in several award shows, like GDA’s in the album sales statistics.

Gaon also has other charts, such as digital charts, but in this case we are talking about the album physical sales chart.

Gaon is used rather than Hanteo because not every store is Hanteo-certified, so a margin of albums go un-reported on Hanteo, while Gaon reflects how many albums have definitively left the manufacturer to enter circulation.

HANTEO

Hanteo essentially reports albums in hand from retail sales, plus a calculated amount from Hanteo’s system.

Hanteo tends to be lower, as it doesn’t count albums left for stock sale, and those individual albums are bought as time passes.

Hanteo sometimes takes a while to count between someone buying and album and the album being registered, as the shops have to either physically hand the album to a customer or ship the album, so often stores ship out weeks later during a busy season, and those albums bought weeks before don’t count for the chart until they are in a box and marked as “shipped”

Hanteo is what weekly music shows use, such as Music Bank and Mcountdown.

BOTH systems are build with an margin of error, as most things are.

For a visual; take a store like Choice Music. The items on their shelves reflect the Gaon chart. The items you buy are then reflected on the Hanteo chart. This only goes for certified sellers. Small stores or resell shops like ebay have to buy from a seller to begin with, so those albums usually already counted to the Hanteo chart.

The gap on Gaon and Hanteo reflects a variety of things; how much stock stores want on hand, how many albums ended up unreported through non-hanteo affiliated stores, etc. Both have their benefits and drawbacks, and both are used for distinctly different purposes.

Hope that helps anyone confused!

EDIT: u/dietscda had this great addition:“just to add on to your point, there are only approximately 90 stores worldwide that are affiliated with hanteo. i see a lot of kpop fans in the u.s. buy albums from barnes & noble and from amazon sellers and these albums are not reflected on hanteo, but they do count toward gaon. this could easily be the case in other international countries as well.”

216 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 10 '21

Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read.

Oh, and you can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

64

u/dietscda Oct 10 '21

just to add on to your point, there are only approximately 90 stores worldwide that are affiliated with hanteo. i see a lot of kpop fans in the u.s. buy albums from barnes & noble and from amazon sellers and these albums are not reflected on hanteo, but they do count toward gaon. this could easily be the case in other international countries as well.

18

u/loudchoice BM make it bang Oct 10 '21

100% correct! Would you mind if I added that to my main post as an edit?

8

u/dietscda Oct 10 '21

nope! i don't mind at all :)

-10

u/plushie_dreams Oct 10 '21

Not sure about B&N, but Amazon purchases definitely do count towards Hanteo. Why would you say it was 100% correct without bothering to verify?

11

u/loudchoice BM make it bang Oct 10 '21 edited Oct 10 '21

Depends on the amazon sellers. You linked an official seller. That counts. Meanwhile other sellers that arent from the official distributors that ARE hanteo family do not count.

So SOME amazon sales count- those from distributors that are affiliated with Hanteo. However, anything that’s not does not count- which is a bulk of amazon sellers.

If you look at the link you sent the one you sent is official. The 16 other sellers amazon links under the product are not.

(Such as TheProductsHub, I-Deals store, Green Orbit, ImportCds, Dearborn-music, and so on and so forth)

1

u/omgthenerve Oct 10 '21

It's interesting that the "Ships from and sold by Amazon.com" version of ITZY's Crazy in Love says that it counts towards Hanteo. Amazon is not listed as a Hanteo certified retailer, so I always assumed purchases would only count towards Billboard, unless you were buying from a 3rd party Kpop store selling on Amazon that specifically says it counts towards Hanteo. I wonder if there's somehow a difference depending on how the albums are distributed? I bought both of my Sticker albums from Amazon and it doesn't say in the description that it counts for Hanteo: Sticky Ver. and Jewel Case

17

u/dietscda Oct 10 '21 edited Oct 10 '21

hi, i meant to say that not all amazon sellers count toward hanteo. just like with ebay, some albums will come from hanteo certified stores, while many others will not.

someone also just let me know that bts’ butter album at barnes & noble did actually count toward hanteo, but that seems to be the exception and not the norm. for example, the listings for itzy’s crazy in love (which is listed as a best-seller), aespa’s savage, and nct127’s sticker do not indicate that the album sales count toward hanteo like butter’s listing does on the barnes & noble website.

edit: fixed example

-2

u/plushie_dreams Oct 10 '21

It seems odd that only BTS's Butter would count towards Hanteo on the same platform. B&N is not like Amazon, where you have multiple vendors selling their products. It's just B&N. And I don't think ANY eBay purchases count towards Hanteo.

6

u/dietscda Oct 10 '21

i would agree with you but butter’s listing on b&n states that the album counts toward hanteo & gaon but not billboard, which is another exception because albums from that store pretty much always count for billboard.

i have bought kpop albums from the ebay store “goods-store01” and in the description of the albums i bought from them, they state that the albums count toward hanteo.

0

u/plushie_dreams Oct 10 '21

Butter only has 2 songs so it can't really count as an album for BB.

4

u/dietscda Oct 10 '21

which might explain why an exception was made for hanteo

1

u/plushie_dreams Oct 10 '21

Oh how does Hanteo define an album?

9

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

Thank you for this breakdown! Out of curiosity, which of the numbers (Gaon vs Hanteo) would be closer to the number of albums that the company receives revenue from? So basically, does the company receive money from all the albums they send to retailers to sell, or only for the albums which have been bought by customers?

17

u/loudchoice BM make it bang Oct 10 '21

I’m fairly certain they get revenue from the number purchased from the manufacturer! Since the other copies are sitting on shelves at retailers who bought them!

I’m like 99% certain of that.

Retailers do sometimes send albums back though if they overstocked, so as long as the albums are out in circulation or on shelves the company has sold them and got the profit!

8

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

Ahh that makes sense, thank you! I guess that means the Gaon number would be closer to the number of albums that the company receives revenue from?

3

u/parkjichuu Oct 10 '21

hey! just wanna give a heads up that you’re formatting kind of messed up. it looks like this right now. i checked both on my phone and computer.

5

u/loudchoice BM make it bang Oct 10 '21

i actually just noticed this and got out of my nice warm bed to fix it 🥲 thank you for the catch though!!

3

u/parkjichuu Oct 10 '21

sure thing :)

47

u/Long_Ad_8714 Oct 10 '21

Thanks OP for this. Certain people in this sub just assuming and accusing certain artists for the difference between the charts. Its like they have a vendetta against them. Like guys just chill, it’s not that deep, just enjoy and celebrate successes.

7

u/astrahightower nct | tbz | zb1 Oct 10 '21 edited Oct 10 '21

Exactly this. I never get why people are so intent are intensely investigating the difference for groups they don’t even follow/stan. Like what’s the point? Why? Just let the fans celebrate their successes….and you can investigate your own group if you care that much. It’s really not that deep.

5

u/Long_Ad_8714 Oct 10 '21

Exactly! That’s the thing, they are not even their fans and wants to completely undermine the group. Why?? Are you that bitter?? You know what they say “behind every successful person lies a pack of haters” let’s be positive and celebrate our faves successes! 😊

9

u/Squish_94 Oct 10 '21

Thanks for the explanation! I never understand what people are on about when they talk about Gaon vs Hanteo sales and don't care enough to put the effort in to find out for myself lol.

34

u/Edgar763 Oct 10 '21

Companies like SM, JYP and YG DO NOT report their own numbers to Gaon. Gaon collects the numbers independent from the company.

Impossible, certain users told me SM controls Gaon and is lying with no consecuences.

31

u/92sn Oct 10 '21

Fyi, companies do sometimes overshipping their albums. SM especially known for this because previously their artists always have album got some returns as gaon usually gonna update their number like at end of year i think.

14

u/plushie_dreams Oct 10 '21

I thought pre-orders came from the vendors themselves, which they estimate based on a group's popularity. Even NCT's older albums are selling very well these days, so you can tell they have a ton of momentum---hence, the very high Gaon number. I have a hard time believing SM would go around telling stores how many albums they should order. And anyway it's only been a few weeks since NCT 127's release so people should stop losing their heads over this.

21

u/Edgar763 Oct 10 '21

You are aware that the shipping isn't just a thing SM can do because they felt like it right? It's something done because there is a certain demand on stores for it since they are the ones who ask for an amount of albums. Overshipping happens when that amount from the stores doesn't sell like they expected and sometimes they return some albums. That said, on the 5 years NCT has been around, with the release of a lot of albums (being 3 units now and with yearly projects too) I'm yet to see a single update of their numbers because albums had been returned, so I don't understand this obsession of acting like SM overshipping is something that often happens when I have only heard this problem about some EXO albums. Even then, overshipping can happen as stores expect to sell more than they do, but my comment is more about those saying how SM can just blatantly lie about the numbers or do shady practices and not only Gaon will be like "Ok" but the industry won't move a finger about it.

-10

u/92sn Oct 10 '21

Because their artists have history having returns and SM themselves also have being exposed for manipulating the album sales for billboard charting. . Thats probably why people have trust issues for SM. They have show they have history about absolutely obsess in charting to the point manipulating their number. I am not saying they do this again. But yeah thats why some people dont trust them much.

18

u/Edgar763 Oct 10 '21 edited Oct 10 '21

You are comparing a US focused debut from a US focused group they made where Capitol participated, when bundles were a lot easier to use to inflate numbers and where the debut album wasn't oficially released on Korea until months later to a normal korean release. The Billboard situation is really expeculation since the sources are a twt user screenshot and this article saying "someone contacted me, trust me", I mean, if true it's sketchy but even Billboard made an article about it putting emphasis on the bundles. Anyways, I get what you mean but I don't think SM has any interesting on wasting a ton of money on shit like this just for the bragging when they are literally at their highest point as a company right now even without actual concerts happening, not to mention that if instead of 2,2M sales it was 1,6M or so it would had been impressive anyways as their last full album on the first month had sold around 750k. Do people know how expensive it would be to create/buy 500/600k albums to not receive any benefit? I don't think it's worth it at all.

1

u/femoore56 Oct 10 '21 edited Oct 10 '21

SM never overship EXO's albums. EXO is not like other easy kpop groups. EXO has a lot of dating scandals, members losses that's the reason, I need yall to stop thinking about EXO the same way yall do with current kpop groups. EXO is a older group, has older type fandom

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

[deleted]

29

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21 edited Oct 10 '21

a source(it shows red velvet, exo and twice over the years 2013 to 2017.

For context the stock is put on the shelves. If it expires (goes past shelf life the company can either pay to keep it on the shelf, return it or deny the return and the retail er can do as it pleases with the merchandise. Which is still a loss.

7

u/92sn Oct 10 '21

I remember one of it was exo. There also other SM artists. I cant remember who. I saw that kind of data around 2017-2019 i think.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21 edited Oct 10 '21

Official sales in Amazon, Target, I think walmart too do count to Hanteo. You can read it in the description of the album. That’s how it is for BTS. I won’t imagine it’s different from group to group.

15

u/loudchoice BM make it bang Oct 10 '21

Amazon depends on the seller.

AMAZON themselves arent the main seller. Some companies distribute on amazon officially and those count. Others are sold through secondhand shops that have amazon accounts, and those shops are not affiliated with hanteo and dont reflect.

You gotta check the “sold by:” info on amazon to see what counts and what doesnt

Thinks marked “Sold by: amazon” or “sold by: [Hanteo certified distributor]” generally count. Things that say “Sold by: [random music store]” generally seem to not count.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

Actually it is only bts where I have seen any official documentation. It even specificied that only bts(maybe big hit) had their distributor certified. Many Amazon companies on Amazon lie about certification to boost their sales.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 10 '21

Hello /u/Spiritual_Ad_3890. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.