r/kpopthoughts • • Oct 07 '21

Awards + Achievements Enhypen, a group that isn't even a year old recorded 910,000 pre orders… This is amazing.

I feel like a proud mother for some reason, the babies of HYBE are going strong and we're here to support them.

Isn't it crazy? what took some groups literal years Enhypen did in… 10 months.

910.000 pre orders… I'm at a loss of words right now.

I remember speculating, predicting with a couple of people here how Enhypen were going to get a CRAZY amount of sales because the hype for the comeback was crazy and it got even crazier when the feat with Yeonjun was announced.

I...

Congratulations Enhypen, you did that.

Edit: Just because some of you don't know how to act and can't enjoy one post without making it a competition, yes, TXT are doing great, thanks for asking.

525 Upvotes

117 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 07 '21

Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read.

Oh, and you can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

142

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

Wow, wasn't aware of these insane stats. Good for them, man. I genuinely loved Drunk Dazed, the kids did a grand job with the delivery, plus the whole MV was something else. Vampires and possibly werewolves, count my Twilight loving ass in. Even as just a casual listener, I hear their songs quite often. Their creative direction is pretty impressive as well, the aesthetics and designs I saw online must make that physical copy worth owning.

17

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

100% agree, Enha are bringing something new to the table in my opinion and it's great to see their efforts paying off like this.

72

u/Legitimate-Taro-398 bangtan always and forever. Oct 07 '21

They did that. My boys fucking did that. I'm so proud. 😭

6

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

Me too!

67

u/flawedconstellation you know you got that home, home, home, home 🎶 Oct 07 '21

its actually a little crazy to think... i think only EXO before have recorded a million sales so quickly? bts only hit that number after their school trilogy and HYYH and even Wings - 3/4 years. seventeen hit 750k sales in 2019, 4 years after debut. nct dream have been around since 2016 but only just hit that range. nct too - 2016 debut, yet 2020 they hit that mark. yet enhypen... i'm shocked, i didn't know how massive of a fandom they have behind them. curious how the final sales number will turn out

57

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

HYBE groups sell incredibly well, I actually was looking at this chart and Enhypen… Not even a year old, NOT EVEN A YEAR OLD AND THEY'RE THERE.

25

u/flawedconstellation you know you got that home, home, home, home 🎶 Oct 07 '21

i wonder, whenever pledis' boy group debuts, will they sell as well bc of the double-whammy of HYBE & SVT's juniors? if sm puts out a brand new bg, will they also sell as well as quickly? ik aespa are absolutely demolishing the sales game - which makes me realize just how impactful the company you're under & who your seniors are can be. and of course, your own talent to carry, but a good dose of connections, if you will. that's crazy :O

54

u/Pavan_250497 Oct 07 '21

You've left out the most important thing out of all...... U need to get a recognisable hit on which people r drooling over...... Enhypen had that with fever, that's why they have such a big market right now..... Company connections can't take u to a millions sales alone......

23

u/prathi20 Oct 07 '21

I'd say drunk dazed too....

38

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

They also had massive predebut fanbase due to iland. That won't be the case for other bgs if they don't have survival show/predebut activities

35

u/NavyBlue_525 Oct 07 '21

But if you compare B:DO preorders (350k) to B:DC (450k) and then D:D (910k), even though it's a full album Fever really is one of the biggest reason of their huge growth.

18

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

Yes I don't deny that, fever is the queen. but without predebut fandom they wouldn't have reaching this far so fast

18

u/Pavan_250497 Oct 07 '21

Yup that too... Survival show benefits seem to be taken for granted tbh...... Groups not of survival shows need a lot of time to establish a fandom like what these survival show groups have even pre debut.....

6

u/flawedconstellation you know you got that home, home, home, home 🎶 Oct 07 '21

for sure! but at the same time, even Anti-Romantic was a hit, as was After School, both in the same way & through the same platform (tiktok) as Fever, yet the groups haven't blown up since the same way, right? there's definitely a little something extra for Enhypen that's helping them, something in their survival show beginnings & all the successful groups around them, and of course, their ability to pull off these concepts & songs

30

u/Jaydani7 Oct 07 '21

The fans they attract though does not just become casual listeners, at least from what I've observed. No matter which era you become an Engene (pre-debut/I-land, debut, B:C), Enha just makes you become a dedicated fan.

I think that's also a big factor to their growth. The fast growing very dedicated fandom.

38

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

Also the fact that all enhypen members are Stan attractors, there's not 1 member who overshadows others in popularity. It's almost evenly spread out.

24

u/Jaydani7 Oct 07 '21

It also helps that we get individual contents that are catered to the members interest, no one gets left behind. We can all see them shine individually.

8

u/flawedconstellation you know you got that home, home, home, home 🎶 Oct 07 '21

is it actually? they're from a survival show so I'd expect the opposite, actually, for one or two more popular trainees to eclipse the others. but that's very unique & cool if so!

36

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

Yes surprisingly it is very evenly spread out. Part of it is enhypen are all very good looking with individual images and unique personalities so every member kind of has their own audience that they attract.

23

u/Key-Needleworker-452 Oct 07 '21

Ah this is so true! It really feels like they attract different audiences on their own and bring them all together as a group, which is amazing to think about

35

u/prathi20 Oct 07 '21

Fever was huge in the SEA countries and it's still going stable on spotify. Its daily streams are a greater than thunderous and loser lover(the biggest 4the gen groups right now), with 500k daily streams while it's literally more than 5 months old. Their monthly listeners also speak for themselves. People do love their music.

So yeah fever was a big push to enhypen and they are incredible performers.

Coming from survival show helped them initially but drunk dazed and fever kinda nailed it for them i guess. More than even engenes could imagine. And drunk dazed was very much liked in kpop.

24

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

I think it's just what we call the "it-factor".

18

u/Pavan_250497 Oct 07 '21

Txt blew up a loot after their chaos chapter freeze album which I can personally vouch for coz I've been a fan since runaway era and part of that is also coz of anti romantic going viral ...... One major thing to notice is that anti romantic was never promoted unlike fever so maybe that's where the difference....... Their repackage album almost has close to equal sales as their full length album which is crazy coz they have only 2 extra songs......

I'm not sure about weeekly situation ur saying tho coz I thought they were doing faar better than before nd that's due to after school going viral..... Although the comparisons for weeekly to boy groups is not accurate coz the ball is in different courts for both groups.....

12

u/flawedconstellation you know you got that home, home, home, home 🎶 Oct 07 '21

good points about promoting fever and the full length album things! you're definitely right on those. as for weeekly, i mean their growth proportion, if you will, hasn't been as consistent. and that's probably just bc they're a girl group - you need multiple consistent hits to get the same security boy groups can get after just 1 solid cb bc they'd have instantly gained fans from that

13

u/tiredpandax3 One day MOA Bong grew on my head Oct 07 '21

I totally agree with you about the promotion part too. I'm also a fan that's been following since the beginning, and I really saw the change this year since Freeze. Suddenly everyone around me is interested in TXT too. And I think having promotion/performance really helps, take the recent concert for example. 20cm was already a popular song within the fandom, but the fact that they added choreo to it and performed it again on the concert blew the song up again. I believe Anti-romantic could've been able to do very well had BH chose to promote it in stead of Magic, not saying Magic is bad, but it doesn't appeal to as much people as compared to Anti-romantic.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

[deleted]

13

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

They legit hit 4.7M peak monthly listeners with just their first comeback on Spotify and those are unique listeners alone.

wait that many??? do u have the stats so i could see?

18

u/prathi20 Oct 07 '21

4.7m monthly listeners and the fastest kpop group to do so on spotify here you go

9

u/Jaydani7 Oct 07 '21

Oh I didn't see this. Thanks for linking it up. Will edit my comment.

10

u/Jaydani7 Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

Here. To be more specific, their new peak is at 4,696,822 as of spotify's latest update last Sept 1.

Edit: It's 4.7M as of September 4.

7

u/prathi20 Oct 07 '21

Its 4.7m it's TRUE they reached exactly 4.7m once

6

u/Jaydani7 Oct 07 '21

They probably did. And maybe I just didn't see it.

I looked up on Enhypen charts on twt and the link I added was the closest thing I could see to 4.7M.

If you have the link to that, please feel free to link it here.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

[deleted]

12

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

and this was recorded last month. they're crazy!!

10

u/Remarkable-Category4 Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

i had so many non-kpop fan friends loving fever to the point that we danced to it in p.e. class lmao and i hear it quoted to me every day so im loving it, besides enhypen, txt's releases were also a hit with the non-kpop fans friends- some of them even did the anti romantic dance on tiktok (i also hear loser=lover quoted to me everyday)

i think its pretty crazy given that most non-kpop fan ppl i know only know bts and blackpink songs but now all of them are interested in enhypen (and txt)- idk what hybe/bh is putting in their production this year but damn please do not stop, all their groups this year just nonstop releasing bangers- plus the fact that some are bsides like fever- damn.

(p.s. other than fever, loser=lover and anti romantic, i hear butter quoted to me everyday too hahahah)

7

u/SnowWhitae resident Taehyungist Oct 07 '21

Exo only sold a million with an individual album in 2017 with The War, before their Million number was including both repackages and Chinese versions

94

u/karinaluvbot Oct 07 '21

as a MY and an engene, you know my mood these days

59

u/Least_Place_5058 Oct 07 '21

2020 november rookies are killing it aespa, enhypen and stayc?! That was one hell of month lol😭😭

17

u/karinaluvbot Oct 07 '21

currently planning on stanning stayc too

33

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

2020 rookies just keep rising!!

6

u/pls_setmefree Oct 07 '21

Same!! Shoulders up in the sky.

53

u/jaydsipro Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

Congratulations to ENHYPEN! I might be wrong, but SEA countries played a really strong factor (and possibly due to the "Fever" fever) in the growth of Engene fanbase. Tiktok in SEA countries seem to play well with ENHYPEN content, with their mechandise always in demand (their photocards always priced high). Just this past week, I have seen roughly 20 users in Tiktok unboxing their newly-bought Border:Carnival Sets, not just one version, but SETS!

T/W: COVID-19

The news about the members having COVID-19 was an uproar. Our local news even reported it, and even their status about being negative after days of isolation. If you want to see the report about it, here is the link to the news report: News report

Even I myself brought their new and upcoming album. Not just the set, but the newly-announced Essential version, which I though was their push to garner 1 million pre-order sales. Again, congratulations to Enhypen! We hope for good luck in their future promotions. (Tamed-Dashed was announced as a New wave track, so I'm excited)

107

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

Aside from wanna one & X1, sales wise, there isn’t any group that really comes close to Enhypen in their debut year, it’s very impressive. The great thing for Enhypen is that unlike produce groups they are a completely permanent group, so they have much more years to continue to grow, they have an extremely bright future ahead of them.

47

u/eeeetttt123 Oct 07 '21

i genuinely think they will hit 1M sales. and next comeback, if they will get another semi viral song like fever... they could get 1.2M preorders. so crazy how they grow and it hasnt been even year.

43

u/baejaeno Oct 07 '21

As a new engene I’m so excited and regret not stanning earlier 🥺❤️

77

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

what took some groups literal years Enhypen did in… 10 months.

and they even have a song called 10 months /hj

lol but anyway same!! it's a privilege to witness their growth from the start tbh. they've gained lots of new fans on their first comeback(myself included). the lads might be celebrating rn

57

u/4thinking Oct 07 '21

That's CRAZY. I'm impressed and happy to see them flourishing. Engenes are one of the most dedicated fandoms I've ever seen, honestly

28

u/purplewinterr Oct 07 '21

i feel like a proud mother too 🤧 esp cos we witnessed them from predebut up to now…fans feel more attached because of that ig and the fact that debuted during what seems like the golden age of kpop (where a lot of ppl are becoming more interested in kpop) made their popularity grow so quickly + they’re being produced by hybe/belift and their concepts, visuals, and songs are actually amazing 🤩

27

u/NewSill Oct 07 '21

I sort of see this coming after them blowing up with Fever but didn't think it will hit 900k.

Congratulations boys!

27

u/SnowWhitae resident Taehyungist Oct 07 '21

So proud of the boys! It's been amazing to watch their growth since the beginning of I-Land and how many loyal fans they have attracted. To think at only 10 months they are this big gives me chills, I can't imagine how much bigger they might get. The marker for kpop and physical albums is also so big these days, as an older fan it's impressive to see how much they are achieving in their rookie years. The boys are a phenomenon! And their team is doing a great work attracting new fans with quality music and concepts, I can't wait to hear the full album

26

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

first aespa and now enhypen, what a great time to be a my and an engene yeah

25

u/sma68 Oct 07 '21

This is crazy considering that they're only 10 months old! I don't know what I expected but it wasn't this. I'm so happy for them. Very well deserved for having such good songs and performances! I can't wait for their comeback!

21

u/Mercylic I am the ghost from OK!+ Oct 07 '21

Monster rookies indeed 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿

20

u/JonathanGaming37 Oct 07 '21

Huge congratulations to ENHYPEN. They really deserved it! Still addicted to Drunk Dazed and Fever.

19

u/fuckitjm Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

I am so happy to be able to see they grow. 910K pre orders in 20 days for a 10 months group THAT'S INSANE I'm so proud of my boys 💖 They will only get bigger and bigger. Hot icon and Monster Rookies!

38

u/pinkkpunk ♡ ♡ ♡ Oct 07 '21

Enhypen and Aespa are seriously taking 4th gen kpop to the ... next level

44

u/Bayjoon00 Oct 07 '21

will they be the fastest kpop group to be a million seller?

40

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

Yes, the title is currently held by Skz who did it in 3 years.

38

u/Bayjoon00 Oct 07 '21

wow enha set a crazy record, i’m still in shock by these numbers.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

Pretty sure EXO did it in like a year and 2 months

Edit : Thanks fellow redditors, EXO first million was in 2017 meaning 5 years post debut.

29

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

Nah, EXO didn’t sell 1m with a single album until the war (2017).

15

u/92sn Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

I remember that exo won mama aoty 2017 because they counted with repackage despite BTS actually has more album sales for love yourself her if we compare single album.

Edit: i checked again wikipedia, exo the war did sold more than 1mil. But like i said, ly her has higher album sales if we compare single album excluding repackage.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

I’m pretty sure we’re both right, Ly her sold more and lost it’s aoty from mama because of the repackage but I still think the war sold 1m (at least on gaon).

Luckily they changed the rules the year after regarding repackages.

2

u/92sn Oct 07 '21

Okay i checked again at wikipedia and exo the war did sold more than 1mil at gaon. But yeah ly her lose because they counted the war repackage.

Ohh do you mean mama no longer count repackage or what?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

Yeah in 2018 most award shows changed their rules regarding repacks (aside from GDA, idk if they still count repacks or not now though).

4

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

Ok, yeah I was including Growl. Then I guess ENHYPEN would be the quickest.

7

u/92sn Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

No. As far as i know, exo never get 1mil album sales for single album not including repackage previously until like last year or 2019 i think? Which mean their 7-8th year.

Edit: i was wrong. Exo the war 2017 the one reached 1mil. Mean when exo at 5th year.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

Yeah someone already said it, but I'll edit my comment

10

u/anime_gurl_666 Oct 07 '21

fastest million seller is actually h.o.t, their debut album sold 1.5 million

4

u/anime_gurl_666 Oct 07 '21

by debut i mean they debuted by releasing an album and it sold that many. thats the album that has candy and warriors descendant

1

u/woahnat Oct 07 '21

I'm pretty sure Wanna One sold 1mil with their debut album but correct me if I'm wrong

12

u/Camyhan Oct 07 '21

They sold 805,290 (debut - best selling album by them)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

[deleted]

5

u/anime_gurl_666 Oct 07 '21

it was h.o.t, they debuted with the album we hate all kinds of violence, which sold 1.5 million.

13

u/roszabiel Oct 07 '21

The growth Enhypen has is absolutely astounding!! I hope they continue to grow!

34

u/Bayjoon00 Oct 07 '21

IN ONLY 10 MONTHS??? IMAGINE IN A COUPLE YEARS!!!

10

u/Kpoopfan Oct 07 '21

Wow that’s impressive!!

10

u/biancaaa12 Oct 08 '21

I feel like a proud mother!!! Loved i-land since batch 1 trainees have been announced 😭

8

u/eeeetttt123 Oct 07 '21

does anyone have some stats for their albums? hanteo, gaon, first day, week 1 2 3 4, and monthly updates + how much they grow percent wise? that would be nice to see

8

u/Eastern_Wasabi_4573 Oct 08 '21

I'm still recovering from the last comeback! Luv Enhypen!

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 08 '21

Hello /u/Eastern_Wasabi_4573. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

14

u/tafattsbarn ♡ cloudy sky, clear air ♡ Oct 07 '21

This is incredible, just wow :0

-13

u/inbox789 Iridescent Turquoise Oct 07 '21

What's the reason for this sudden jump in the number and the high number of invested fans buying albums? Surely it's not only the music, they've released only 2 mini albums till now in less than a year. Are the members or their label good in making people invested and spending money on them? I don't hear much about the members either other than that one time their fans were alleging that one of the members was getting bullied. And which countries are these sales coming from?

27

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

Their core fanbase is from SEA countires and Japan. They recently had a hit song on tiktok called fever, which made them the fastest group to hit 4 million monthly listeners. They're one of the most known groups on tiktok.

-9

u/inbox789 Iridescent Turquoise Oct 07 '21

Even Weekly's After School went viral on tiktok, probably more than Fever but Weeekly's sales barely increased. I guess it could be because Weeekly is from PlayM Entertainment, which isn't a big label/company? Whereas Enhypen is from HYBE/Belift so they generally get more hype and and people being invested in them due to the label?

15

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

Whereas Enhypen is from HYBE/Belift so they generally get more hype and and people being invested in them due to the label?

it just so happens that a lot of people love their music they decided to buy their albums. magic.

-7

u/inbox789 Iridescent Turquoise Oct 07 '21

it just so happens that a lot of people love their music they decided to buy their albums

That's obviously not the only reason, because if that was the only thing that mattered even Red Velvet would be selling a million albums.

17

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

bro BGs in general have more dedicated fanbases than GGs. that's why their album sales are higher. for enhypen's case, their spotify listeners have drastically increased since BD:C came out. their monthly listeners hit a new peak with 4.7 million last month. Fever is the most listened to 4th gen track with anti-romantic behind it. being under Hybe and having a survival show was one thing, but there weren't many Engenes before the BD:C comeback. They are very popular in Japan which is known to have a big music market second to America.

Enhypen's music and fans hyping up about the comeback did all the talking so casual listeners ended up buying their music. Fever blew up with celebrities in SEA countries on Tiktok dancing to it and Enhypen's fan base there is extremely dedicated and is still growing.

29

u/Jaydani7 Oct 07 '21

To add to the previous comment, you asked what their label do to make fans invested in them, here's my answer.

Aside from their music and the boys charming personalities, I think what played a big role in creating this very dedicated fanbase is the connection that the boys were able to extend to their fans. Belift did a great job with that. The boys are all very active in Social Media especially twitter, weverse and tiktok. Fanservice, call it whatever you want, they're really good with that.

We also get a variety of content. Not just any random content but contents that show the members personalities and interests. We don't get just random contents, most contents we get, the boys are involved. (E.g. They released individual vlogs wherein the members not only did the things they wanted to do on their free time but also, they themselves input the captions they wanted in their vlogs.) Recently, their Charybdis individual concept photos for Dimension:Dilemma also showcases the members different interests.

There's so much more reasons why fans get so invested in them. It's just unfortunate you've heard the issues that were made by antis instead of the good things they've actually done and achieved.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

[deleted]

26

u/jansan_0209 Oct 07 '21

Enhypen only need a gp friendly songs then boom they will be unstoppable. I really wish they will have a good digitals this comeback. 🙏

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

[deleted]

15

u/Remarkable-Category4 Oct 07 '21

i rmb reading abt how txt was the only 4th gen bg to chart in melon 24h chart which is the chart that shows what the general public listens to- its rlly hard for bg's to chart there in general, even top 3rd gen bg's struggle to chart there too, gg's do much better since their songs r much more gp friendly

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 10 '21

Hello /u/Abitcommentfromme. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

[deleted]

21

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

If DD sells at the same rate, in 6 months time it should reach 1.5 million sales.

18

u/RealGreenTrainee Oct 07 '21

This is not exactly how sales work, they are not that stable 😂

40k+ this month was their 3rd biggest month for Carnival and I assume stores ordered bigger amount due to new album release to have it in stock for people who will buy older albums along with D:D

Previous two months were also big with 28k each month so there's definitely 📈, my bet is by the end of this year they'll definitely reach 750k and get 3xplatinum. If they keep monthly sales around 25k on average even 800k is possible but you can never predict next months stock.

Depending on their future growth I think it's very possible for them to reach 1M with Carnival too but I don't think it will happen in 2022, more like in mid to late 2023. That is if nothing unusual happens and sales follow the same pattern as Day One after Carnival was released.

Either way, they seem to have good longevity looking at their previous albums so I'm positive they'll keep selling well.

17

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

I didn't say they were explicitly stable, however the fact that they do have a stable fanbase alongside a company willing to invest and progress their careers, one could use previous market sales and trends to form a relative prediction on the basis of consistency. Most prediction/business estimates work on the factor of ensured consistency. An example would be socialblade estimates. Therefore, DD could reach 1.5 million in a month or 2 months, but it could also take a year.

What we can safely say, although the market has potential for inconsistencies, we as a predictor can be confident enough to pit the milestone of 1.5 million sales to within 6 months. This is only due to the current amassed preorders of 910k and previous album sales and their amassed preorders; subconsequently, a rapid increase in preorders over the next 4 to 5 days could see a rise to 950k preorders, in conjunction with this estimate it would allow us to find a more accurate iteration for the 1.5 million mark which could mean 5 months and 2 weeks.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

[deleted]

18

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

It's crazy when considering BC as well. 63% growth on top of the pre orders is crazy. They are averaging nearly 60k sales a month

17

u/Legitimate-Taro-398 bangtan always and forever. Oct 07 '21

Their growth has been insaaaaneeee. Touch wood.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

[deleted]

30

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

As a fan of both groups, maybe you'd like to take a look at this.

I personally don't like comparisons like these due to the fact that they usually are the reason for fanwars and both groups are doing great. TXT just got named the best selling 4th gen act of 2021 and Freeze is still the best selling and longest charting korean album in the United States of 2021.

So, yeah, let's leave it at both groups are doing great, this isn't the Wild West, both are doing well on their own.

Also it's important to understand that a higher number of pre-orders doesn't immediately mean x groups sells more than y.

As someone who stans both:

TXT is king in South Korea, no other 4th gen boygroup comes close, Enhypen dominates Japan and SEA countries like no one else and surprisingly TXT's United States fanbase seems to be growing because they are the owners of many 4th gen records there (I say surprisingly because as a MOA I thought other 4th gen groups were bigger than TXT in USA).

19

u/Remarkable-Category4 Oct 07 '21

yep and the one winning here is hybe lmao- they truly know how to do boy groups- having two monster rookie boy grps under their belt (though ig txt arent rlly rookies anymore)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

i think that TXT's SEA fan base is actually a decent size but lesser than Enhypen's. idk about other SEA countres, but there are lots of MOAs in the Philippines(they might be the loudest) and Indonesia.

30

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

bigger fandom in South Korea / Japan,

Definitely agree with South Korea but disagree with Japan. TXT last Japanese Comeback in January sold like 100k copies whereas both ENHYPEN korean albums sold 100k+ in Japan. Also the end of the Border Trilogy, Hakanai, sold 350k+ exclusively for Japan and made them the fastest foreign artist to pick up a Japan only platinum.

For reference:

  • Foreign Album sold also in Japan: Platinum = 200k

  • Album (by any artist) only sold in Japan : Platinum = 350k

42

u/Jaydani7 Oct 07 '21

I don't exactly know the demographics for txt since I don't follow them. But in Enha's case, they're big BIG in Japan and SEA countries. They're also rising in popularity in Europe and US.

Japanese engenes are doing great in promoting and supporting Enhypen there. Dimension:Dilemma has been sold out twice in Universal Music Japan. It's also best sellers in other Japanese stores that counts for Billboard and Oricon. I dare say, J-engenes are the backbone of our fandom.

In SEA countries, Enha made it big because of TikTok. Fever getting viral definitely made a big role in that. And even though SEA is not considered as one of the biggest music market, sales of merch and albums are still high in these countries since a lot of people from these countries are invested and really show support in K-pop in general. Enhypen being the most hyped up group in TikTok helped a lot in making these non-fans and fans of other groups pay attention to them.

In Europe, with B:C, Enha was able to chart in a couple of local charts in some countries such Belgium, Hungary, Poland, Germany and Switzerland. Their fanbase in Europe may not be as big as other groups but Fever definitely added a good amount of people in the fandom

In the US, they charted on BB. They probably have a bigger following the US than in Europe but I could be wrong. I don't really know much about their demographics in the US aside from the charts they charted in BB.

24

u/Bayjoon00 Oct 07 '21

txt isn’t more popular in japan. enhypen has a huge fanbase over there. have you seen their numbers?

28

u/monogguk Oct 07 '21

Enhypen have more stable fandom in SEA countries. That's based on what I see. I rarely see anyone really listening to TXT here, but FEVER causes Enhypen to blow up in SEA countries.

-13

u/robertmaria654 Oct 07 '21

It has to do with competition. If x1 didn’t disband txt might have sell 1m by now. Because moa don’t have much competition we were not going too high with the numbers , now that we see the competition we are going higher . For example I only buy one album per comeback but now I will be buying all version of the album lol .

22

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

If X1 was still there almost all 4th gen group wouldn't have been as big as they are now. They sold 600k for their debut. It would've been like how wannaone's debut stagnanted a lot of groups' growth.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

[deleted]

24

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

No lol TXT are still the best selling 4th gen act of 2021… Why do y'all have to make everything weird.

12

u/Margaux_H Oct 07 '21

Is it me, or is TXT somehow the standard for some 4th gen stans by which they measure their faves' (or token faves') success? I've seen a few users on this sub and kthoughts this past week bring up TXT like, 'oh, my faves are going to surpass TXT sales'. That's great for your faves, but I find it funny how TXT needs to be mentioned as well. Ponderous, man. Really ponderous.

18

u/pink_mango21 Oct 07 '21

txt are not nugus what? 😂 out of all the 4th gen boy groups rn they’ve consistently charged on melon, line music and billboard global 200.

9

u/Margaux_H Oct 07 '21

Please explain this TXT 'nugu' thing because last I heard, their album FREEZE (+ the repackaged/deluxe) is currently the sixth bestselling album released in the US this year, and it's the longest charting 2021 Kpop album on Billboard so far.

16

u/robertmaria654 Oct 07 '21

Not really lol. They will sell more next comeback , as time goes competition grow bigger , txt is the first 4th gen group to sell 700k album .the will definitely sell 1m next comeback

-4

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

txt is the first 4th gen group to sell 700k album

Technically speaking yes, but if we include album release date then ENHYPEN B:C is at 736k and is older than TCC Freeze.

7

u/robertmaria654 Oct 07 '21 edited Oct 07 '21

Yeah if you say , tdc freeze is currently at 800k+ now( don’t have time to check the chart now) , they had a repackaged a month after that which is currently at 600k+ so 🙄. If other sell the same latter doesn’t change the fact that you are still the first lol .

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 07 '21

Hello /u/mmjiiye. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.