r/kpopthoughts • • Oct 04 '21

Boy Groups Thoughts on Yeonjun featuring on Enhypens song?

As a multistan I was really happy to hear the news but the chaos that ensued afterwards... now not so much honestly.

I've been reading what people were saying on twitter and while moas are happy, engenes are not and you can guess that this sparked a fanwar. Idk i feel like it would have been better if bighit released more playground type content so both fandoms get accustomed with both groups interacting before having a feature because if the announcement created this much drama and hate towards yeonjun I don't even want to think about will happen when the song gets released.

The best example I have is how moas tore up modsun for featuring in 0x1 lovesong remix and that was truly horrendous and I'm so scared of that happening to yeonjun.

There is also the fact that whether he sings or raps engenes will not be happy because line distribution is huge point of contention within the fandom, i can't imagine what will happen if yj has more lines than one of the enhypen members. And I understand engenes for feeling this way. And I also understand moas wanting to hype yj. And as a multistan this is my worst nightmare.

Idk after taking some time to think about it, this collab sadly might bring more harm than good and yj will sadly be caught in the crossfire.

I would love to know what you're thoughts are and if I'm just on the negative side of stan twitter and you guys have seen more positivity.

37 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 04 '21

Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read.

Oh, and you can fill out our Feedback Form while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

45

u/Radiant-Pineapple-81 Iridescent Turquoise Oct 04 '21

everyone were excited within the first hour and it went bad real quick. like damn, we cant all have nice things?

tbh, moas and engenes really dont have that good of a peer-fandom relationship because there are moas who straight up anti en- and vice versa. so you will see the toxicity from both sides. that cant be helped unfortunately.

as a moa, im super excited!'i wasnt expecting a feature, maybe some writing credits but a whole feature? yeonjun is so cool. im looking forward to the song! hopefully the song is such a banger that we will be free from all complaints 🙏🏼

57

u/NavyBlue_525 Oct 04 '21

"moas are happy, engenes are not" believe it or not most of my engene mutuals were extremely excited and still is. Don't let those immature idiots from both fandom ruin your excitement. Yes I saw many negative tweets but it all started from something else not just because of Yeonjun is featuring in one of the songs. All those stupid tweets about charts and sales and privileges etc etc. Yeonjun+ TXT and Enhypen all were getting unnecessary hate from what I saw.

3

u/ConsiderationLoud348 Oct 05 '21

Exactly there's a lot of hating going on between any 2 grpups you name on twitter. The loud toxic minority has the potential to make any 2 groups with even the best chemistry look like they are at war!

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 05 '21

Hello /u/ConsiderationLoud348. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

26

u/longtime_lurker004 Oct 04 '21

I think the important thing to remember about twitter fan wars/fights is that at least 90% of them are started by people in both fandoms. Indeed, the start of a fan war can usually be attributed to either fandom depending on where you draw the starting point.

But for twitter fan wars, if you are in one fandom, you will likely see tweets that make it seem like the other fandom started a fight and your fandom is just defending your favs, but that is also true of the other fandom. So, if you are a MOA, I can totally see how in you would come across tweets that make it seem like MOAs were just chilling and then Engenes started complaining about YJ's feature. If you are an Engene, you probably saw tweets that make it seem like Egenes were excited until MOAs ruined the fun and started criticizing/dismissing Enhypen.

The reality is probably that both are true. For the most part, MOAs were excited about YJ's feature and Engenes were excited about the collaboration. However, toxic fans on both sides turned the situation sour pretty quick. Toxic MOAs started invaliding En's success saying that the album will only be successful because YJ is featuring on it. And toxic Engenes started complaining about YJ and Enhypen's line distribution.

Both arguments are silly. First, people don't buy albums just because their fav is featured on one song. If they did, then Armys would have all bought Freeze because RM helped write Love Song. Sure, maybe some MOAs were on the fence about buying the Enhypen album and the feature is pushing them to do it, but the fact is: it is Enhypen album with YJ featuring on one song. He won't be in any of the photo books or other contents, so it would be silly for someone to buy an album of a group they don't like just because of one song. Also, Enhypen had 600,000 stock preorders after the first couple of days and was sold out at Universal Music in Japan before this feature was announced, so I don't actually think anyone believes this album would have been a "flop" without YJ. I am a bit disappointed in the toxic MOAs because they didn't like when Armys did this to them with Love Song, but now they are turning around and doing the same thing to En.

Second, line distribution arguments are silly when we haven't even heard the album. Who knows if YJ is rapping. Who knows if any other members are. We don't know if YJ is singing a harmony. We honestly have no idea. The fact is that on each Enhypen song, someone will get the least amount of lines. That is inevitable. If it is the same person for all six songs (excluding the intro/interlude), then that is a bit messed up. But, we don't know if that's the case yet. I'm disappointed with toxic Engenes/solo stans who immediately assumed YJ would steal all the lines when they haven't even heard what kind of song it will be, let alone the full song itself.

TLDR: Fan wars are usually both fandoms toxic fans' fault and who started it depends on where you the draw the line. In reality, with this situation, most MOAs and Engenes seem excited about this.

Edit: Spelling.

7

u/Sunwhoo Ni-Ki's lost wig Oct 05 '21

if you are in one fandom, you will likely see tweets that make it seem like the other fandom started a fight and your fandom is just defending your favs, but that is also true of the other fandom. So, if you are a MOA, I can totally see how in you would come across tweets that make it seem like MOAs were just chilling and then Engenes started complaining about YJ's feature. If you are an Engene, you probably saw tweets that make it seem like Egenes were excited until MOAs ruined the fun and started criticizing/dismissing Enhypen.

I SUUUPER agree with this. This is what I'm always trying to say on twitter too but people just can't help but find someone to blame in anything cause thats just the only way they can feel good about it. They wont listen to you. Either you'll get ignored or get cancelled for not defending your faves. 😔

21

u/Affectionate_Dirt_65 Oct 04 '21

Excited and curious 😳😳

20

u/Eterynix Iridescent Turquoise Oct 04 '21

I am beyond excited you have no idea. Recent Kpop fan, am an Engene and have been dabbing my fingers into TXT because I watched the mtvfreshout performance of Magic and the live ad libs blew my mind.

What I have to say is:

If Yeonjun and Heeseung harmonize, the world might implode.

🌎💣

36

u/cea_bow Oct 04 '21

I generally can see where you’re coming from but just want to say that the modsun thing is different. There wasn’t an original enhypen-only version of the song YJ will feature in, so there’s nothing really to compare it to. A lot of MOAs liked Lovesong a lot and just genuinely thought Modsun’s voice and verses on the track were too grating. But all the hate he got subsequently was stupid. I do think that YJ will get a lot of negativity from this from other fandoms, but I am still curious as to what role he will play in the song even though a lot can be assumed that it’s a rapping role.

44

u/fuckitjm Oct 04 '21

Sorry but engenes overall ARE happy with the featuring, I've seen some moas dragging enha because "wow they had to call someone else outside the group because their favs can't rap" "yeonjun carried the album" "the only good song in the album because of yeonjun" and so on but it's not everyone too. I've seen more slander towards enhypen members than to yeonjun himself already. Yes some engenes are hesitant because of the hate or line distribution but it's not an overall thought in the fandom. Its the second time we are walking in shells with moas in a short spam of time, first with the replacement of mubank mcs, and now with the featuring.

25

u/Sunwhoo Ni-Ki's lost wig Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21

Engenes are extremely happy about this though? I saw some toxic Moas that kept dragging Enha because of the featuring too and Engenes obviously wont be happy about that. Just don't let immatured minority of both fandoms affect your excitement about a positive news.

On the other hand, YJ FEATURING IN AN ENHA SONG IS GREAT. I thought he's just going to help in the song writing. The thing I'm wondering about is how would they distribute the lines lmao.

12

u/sunsungseung Oct 04 '21

moas are happy, engenes are not

engenes are definitely happy about the collab and are pretty excited too but all things went bad real quick when antis/solos from both fandoms started making sht

but yeah let's just enjoy the collab and ignore the bitter ones. at the end of the day, enhypen and txt are good friends and are looking forward to work together.

31

u/pinkkreddit Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21

As someone who's not in any of the two fandoms (tho for context I'm army), here are my initial thoughts:

  • Good for him.

  • Bighit, I see what you're doing.

  • Oh wait is he actually featuring as a singer/rapper and not just a writer? I wonder how that's going to sound like - tho I think I have an idea.

  • Looking forward to it.

I think that's about it. Line distribution is always a point of contention for fandoms of groups which only worsens when there's an artist featuring. BTS' best featured songs are typically paid dust (very unfortunate given how hard they work for it) because stans feel shafted for one reason or other. Tbh there's no way to avoid it. So I'd say, sit back, expect the pettiness (from both sides) and enjoy the ride.

Edit: nawt someone downvoting this immediately lmao

2

u/rushedcanvas tubatu Oct 05 '21 edited Oct 05 '21

Just curious (don't mean for this to sound sarcastic so sorry if it does) - what do you think BigHit/HYBE is trying to do this with this feature?

When the TXT members mentioned one of them would participate in the ENHYPEN album I thought it'd just be writing credits or something (which would make sense in the grand narrative of TXT getting more involved with their music in the last few months), but a feature is bigger than that. Nonetheless, I don't think like it makes sense for HYBE/BigHit to push Yeonjun as a solo artist right now, so what can it be?

Maybe there's no specific reason but I like to speculate. I do think it's curious how it's the second song with a feature by a HYBE artist in recent times, I felt like they were pretty uncommon in general (besides the BTS x Western collabs and some gems like GOT7 x Hyolyn's One and Only You, etc).

2

u/pinkkreddit Oct 05 '21

You didn't come off sarcastic at all! From what I can see it looks to me like Bighit is simply aiming to reap the benefits of a feature (i.e. greater exposure for both parties) while encouraging and establishing friendliness/familiarity between the two groups (fans old or new become less resistant to checking either groups out). At the same time they get to increase their artists' credentials.

This next point is more speculative but it also doesn't seem impossible to me that, considering they're all from the same label, the song could've originally come with Yeonjun's rap/whichever parts that the producer felt would be beneficial to retain especially given the advantages I mentioned above. Of course this is all just my pov but it's what came to mind when I heard the news!

2

u/rushedcanvas tubatu Oct 07 '21

That makes a lot of sense! I totally agree with the credentials thing - now that you've said it, this feature kind of reminds me of what SM does when they put a trainee/recently-debuted artist of them to feature in another artists' song (i.e, Taeyong in Be Natural, Karina as a dancer with a unique part in Taemin's WANT) - except of course Yeonjun is a veteran to Enhypen.

I did think Bighit/HYBE might be trying to make the ENHYPEN/TXT fanbases closer but I wondered if they really cared that much about it. Maybe they're trying to avoid a intra-company BG fandom rivalry as seems to be common in the industry? It's impossible to avoid it I'd say but at least deter it somehow.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '21

Line distribution is always a point of contention

For ENHYPEN though I feel their current line distribution already throws out the members with slightly deeper voices like Jay and Ni-ki so if YJ was to feature it would mean that Jay and Ni-ki lines are gonna be less than they normally are (also with Jay and Ni-ki they got a total of like 10 seconds out of 2:50 in their Japanese debut when they are the only members fluent in Japanese) , so I think their solo stans have the right to criticise the song writers/feature if a feature is getting more lines than 2 of the members.

8

u/sarangdungi Oct 04 '21

so I think their solo stans have the right to criticise the song writers/feature if a feature is getting more lines than 2 of the members.

Do they really though? I think it's unfair to criticise someone new for the issue if the problem already exists from before. Since enhypen has 7 members, it's inevitable that there will be a lack of satisfaction from the solo stans but that doesn't mean you can hate or drag the feature or contributor. Idk just my thoughts~

4

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '21

I'm not saying it's completely okay to drag a feature. It's just that these solo stans have been asking that maybe their 2 faves can get a few more lines and generally speaking they rarely get full verses just parts of the chorus and if a feature were to pick up a few lines, it'll be taken from these guys and their solo stans can get upset and criticise because their faves aren't getting lines and they have the right to scrutinise without consequence.

3

u/sarangdungi Oct 04 '21

Ahh I understand your point. I just feel like since they're coming back with a full-length album, the focus shouldn't be on the line distribution of one-song since there will be more songs this time so there'll be a higher chance of their faves getting more lines and parts in the album as a whole. Obviously since we don't know what Yeonjun is going to do in the song since he can sing or rap, I think that'll be a factor in deciding how many lines he has in this one song so to me it feels a bit extreme to dislike a feature because of line distribution reasons.

2

u/ConsiderationLoud348 Oct 05 '21

I agree with your opinion. It's gonna be a full album so line distribution should not be an issue

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 05 '21

Hello /u/ConsiderationLoud348. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

30

u/bbearxxx Oct 04 '21

There are a lot of engenes that are mature and welcome Yeonjuns contribution to the album. Even when the news were revealed generally everyone was positive. There will be akgaes for sure and people who try to create negativity to create fan wars however people should not care about them. There are already people from both sides that fight with each other regardless of yeonjun contributing. We didn't even hear the song. Also it seems like enhypen members are very happy about yeonjun featuring. All of them said how much they love him. People should not forget this.

21

u/ellz7 Oct 04 '21

I personally am SO HAPPY about this collab!! Yeonjun is so incredibly talented and he genuinely likes ENHYPEN, and has been so kind to them - they have great chemistry as well! I think their voices will be great together! I am also DREAMING of a Ni-Ki + Yeonjun dance collab , on whatever platform possible, I don’t even care - Twitter, tiktok, Youtube, just give us something, PLEASE! Both have expressed interest to dance together so if that happens I literally won’t shut up!!

And regarding the drama - Frankly I am not sure what you have seen on your tl, but the initial reaction was 99.99% positive on ENGENE Twitter. The 0.01% that reacted negatively were scared that MOAs will drag ENHYPEN , and that’s exactly what happened. ENHYPEN and Blockbuster (the name of the YeonJun feature) trended on Melon, with Blockbuster trending higher, and the comments that started pouring from some toxic fans were “Yeonjun is the Star of #that album”, “and the credit goes to.. Yeonjun”, “hybe getting Yeonjun to do something for that rookie group so they get some relevance” etc etc - the comments like that were actually endless! Engenes are a young fandom and are fed up with ENHYPEN being dragged so they started dragging back. I’m on both MOA and ENGENE Twitter and was checking all fanbases. This was started by MOAS and then it became a mess.

I am also seeing some unpleasant reactions from engenes being “THATS WHY WE DIDNT WANT THIS”, “I knew this would happen” - which really sucks cause I hope ENHYPEN or Yeonjun never see these types of comments. It’s heartbreaking that fans would feel that way, but also that they think they have a say in what their artist does. They are not barbies and I hope they continue doing what they do! And I hope fans would wisen up on both ends!

27

u/niclaswwe Multistan for better health Oct 04 '21

I don't understand why people would be upset?

If anything this shows the issues of solo stans.

26

u/Margaux_H Oct 04 '21

Didn't think it was a thing to get upset about. Im just happy Yeonjun is featuring in another artist's/group's song. 🤷

5

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '21

Ikr? Kpop stans are silly tbh, how they manage to find a problem with anything it's beyond me...

8

u/Margaux_H Oct 04 '21

And how conveniently they forget that both groups adore each other to smithereens. Some people just want to watch the world burn and all that.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '21

Exactly! People like to forget that TXT and ENHYPEN are literally in love with each other like wth y’all just want to fight because y’all don’t have friends and that is not the boys fault

9

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21

They’ll get over it, because I doubt this will be the last the two groups will interact. Fan wars are so stupid especially when these two groups are basically in the same building daily.

Anyway I’m looking forward to it! 😌

38

u/Jaydani7 Oct 04 '21

I get where you're coming from and understand that, that's your experience as a Moa. I would like to share mine as an Engene.

First off, I curate my twitter following really well and always try to stay on the positive side of twitter. I only follow big and unproblematic Enhypen fan accounts so I almost never see any fanwars on my timeline.

Last night though and today was a different case. When the featuring was announced, YJ's name trended higher than Enha. After that, there were a lot of Moa's saying things like how relevant YJ is and how irrelevant Enha is since we can't even trend higher than him. Things like the album is only going to sell well because of YJ. This is what triggered Engenes last night. Engenes got defensive and started a whole ass dragging fanwar.

Even the most unproblematic and one of the biggest Enha fan account countered one of the post. My timeline was a mess and I'm honestly not liking it.

Now, I'm not here to defend Engenes nor to drag Moas, I'm sure the dragging goes both ways. I'm just merely amused at the reason of the fanwar. The stones thrown at us were the very same stones that were thrown at them before, if you get what I mean.

As of now, I have a mixed feeling about it. Both groups are doing amazing at what they do so I'm trying to stay positive and hope that fanwars would stop at one point before the comeback date.

1

u/PeekingFromMyWindow Oct 10 '21

As a moa there at that time I got a lot of engene tweets saying how mad they are that YJ trended higher and that Moas should support the tt and trend it higher instead. I saw a lot of the responses you were mentioning after that. It was quite a letdown for me because everyone was so excited and talking about making a playlist for it. Then it became this big mess. Sigh.

15

u/Goodandhorrid Oct 04 '21

I'm Moa and a casual listener of Enhypen and I'm really excited! I was excited for Enhypen's comeback anyway so this was just a pleasant bonus. I've been desperate for a Niki/Yeonjun dance Collab since playground so this is just one step closer to my ultimate goal! Hahaha.

Don't let Twitter get you down. Just because the negative people are loud doesn't mean they're the majority. And Yeonjun is sensitive but he's also strong and he loves Enhypen-- all of TXT does. If we all support each other and don't give power to the haters I think this is going to be a really cool bonus to a really cool comeback.

20

u/Responsible-Cookie76 Oct 04 '21

Most engenes are really happy and excited tbh, the ones I’ve seen that are mad are annoyed about comments belittling the fact that it is enhypens song and album.

While the majority are excited I’m honestly still really worried about release day, the petty comments and fan wars from both side really need to stop. We are lucky as it is getting a collab.

7

u/prathi20 Oct 04 '21

As an engene since iland and a moa since chaos chapter, this is like a dream come true for me. But honestly with the way moa and engene's relationship have been strained, I expected a lil amount of hate from the toxic ones in both the fandom. So stopped going to my engene acc just to stay away from negativity and I can assure you I'm as excited as ever.

If you dont see those comments, it wouldn't influence you so I suggest you to stay away from social media especially Twitter or curate your timeline.

13

u/rjcooper14 Oct 04 '21

I don't find value in considering what toxic fans (of whichever artist) could possibly be dramatic about. If I were a Hybe manager, I can certainly see how this is beneficial for either of my artists. How others react, more so if they react in an immature manner, is the least of my concerns. My main concern would be to ensure that Yeonjun and Enhyphen benefit from the experience of collaboration.

Also, maybe the fans should wait first to listen to the song?? I'm just a casual listener of TXT and Enhyphen but I am looking forward to this.

You should probably curate your timeline, haha! :)

14

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '21

My advice is, if you want to enjoy anything, don't go on twitter, or any social media lol reddit also ruins stuff.

Personally, I'm super happy and excited :3 I even made a post about it in case u wanna check it out and be happy with us.

1

u/ConsiderationLoud348 Oct 05 '21

The best comment 👌

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 05 '21

Hello /u/ConsiderationLoud348. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/4thinking Oct 04 '21

As a MOA and non-engene, I am very excited for this collaboration! If and when I see people making a fuss about it, I simply block and move on. I will not let anyone's twisted perception and/or petty reasons influence negatively my own anticipation, experience and excitement. It's such a great opportunity for both artists! And I believe they truly enjoyed it and so will we 🤗

5

u/aSulTae Oct 04 '21

I’m an ENGENE and big casual fan of TXT, so I’m super excited! I do share similar concerns for Line distribution though, especially if Yeonjun gets more than some of the members who tend to get least more often. I’m not looking forward to that.

Im sure Enhypen and Yeonjun are all very excited about the collab, so I’m just gonna do my best to ignore any negativity, and just just enjoy.

31

u/ddan_sch hulaulaulaulahoooop Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21

to me - an outsider who likes both of the group’s music but doesn’t keep up with the fandoms - it looks like moas are still insecure from the “bts gave txt their success” accusations and are now enjoying having some sort of power/seniority over a younger group

29

u/JaySeulChimJun Oct 04 '21

This is what I thought too. Especially what happened with TXT’s recent title track being written by a BTS member. They’re doing what the senior fandom did to them to a younger group.

20

u/ellz7 Oct 04 '21

That honestly sounds pretty accurate. It seems to me like they have been feeling threatened too, by ENHYPEN’s presence, as their sales and streams are coming quite close to TXT’s. I think it came as a shock to some people, how well they’ve been doing, and how fast they rose.

I personally think the groups are so different anyway, why create such rabid sense of competition?? It’s a whole different vibe, sound and even marketing, not to mention TXT are literally thriving, they’re doing so so well, like, why care so much about how another group is doing??

4

u/ddan_sch hulaulaulaulahoooop Oct 04 '21

oh i actually thought that the groups were pretty similar but it’s probably because i don’t follow them closely

5

u/92sn Oct 04 '21

I think, if i just listen to their music, i can see the similarity. I honestly feel they have similar music,similar vocal tone(except yeonjun) n easily can change music with each other. But if we check out their universes, its definitely feel different.

8

u/ddan_sch hulaulaulaulahoooop Oct 04 '21

that makes sense!

either way, they’re all talented boys, they really don’t deserve hate from any fandom

11

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21

I and other Engenes are mostly fine about the collab, set aside from a few trolls. However I personally wish this collab didn’t happen because it’s led to Moas being nasty towards Enha, which was bound to happen given the relationship between our 2 fandoms being pretty bad all things considered.

8

u/sarangdungi Oct 04 '21

i feel like all the hate is so unnecessary especially since the featuring means more exposure to both groups. yeonjun featuring means that their comeback will be anticipated by moas as well. it's just more publicity and a chance for an increase in fans. what's the problem in this? enhypen's music gets more exposure and yeonjun also gets to showcase his skills. i just think it's a win-win situation. i know engenes will be mad if yeonjun gets more lines or something but that happens anyways inside the fandom because there are 7 members and some members get more lines anyways. i just hope both fandoms can unite and support their groups and each other if they want.

10

u/karinaluvbot Oct 04 '21

everything was fine, everyone was happy until a "moa" ( who i think is a troll) said something bad about enhypen. also engene are fed up with multis bringing another idol/group in whenever enhypen has something new so that might add up.

10

u/Key-Needleworker-452 Oct 04 '21

I beg you to check this tweet's quotes to see a new side of this story lmao

I've seen engenes happy or indifferent to the Yeounjun feature that immediately after seeing the "thank you yeonjun" tweets they changed their tune to defend their faves... as well as you might have seen those happy moas tweets, so really, it's a matter of perspective lol 🤷🏽‍♀️

I am a txt casual listener so I'm looking forward to this song, and there are many like me within the enha fandom, so don't overthink it and just enjoy it when it comes out 😉

4

u/Sunwhoo Ni-Ki's lost wig Oct 05 '21

I beg you to check this tweet's quotes to see a new side of this story lmao

I shouldnt have looked 🙈

9

u/92sn Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21

As non fan but as army, i feel weird with hybe decision. And as enhypen even coming from survival program, i already expect that fans n solo stans would not like the line distribution. Honestly, i dont understand what HYBE want to achieve from this feature. But like others said here, seem like txt fans gonna like it more as its show txt seniority n presence plus they dont need to feel threaten this time. Anyway, looking forward to it. I think line distribution fanwars always bound to happen but this time its gonna get even more messy.

12

u/SnowWhitae resident Taehyungist Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21

I like txt and their friendship with enha is adorable, plus Yeonjun is massively talented, but this collab is a no for me. There's a reason why idols don't feature in other idols albums and this is it. The fanwar already existed and moas drag enhypen all the time passing on to them the privileged tag they endured for their rookie years. They constantly belittle enhypen and now hybe gave them ammunition. Yeonjun's song will obviously receive a lot of attention and moas will have a field day using it to mock enhypen as they already began to do. It's gonna bring drama that a special moment like Enhypen's first full album simply didn't need

6

u/serd_nas Poppin' Star enthusiast 🌟 Oct 04 '21

Honestly, I was expecting TXT's participation to be in writing/composing some song and ft. Yeonjun was very unexpected, however, I really liked the idea. I'm curious what kind of song it will be and how the combination of their voices will sound like.

Maybe Hybe did this to create a sort of "family" feeling among their groups? I don't know, but it looks a bit forced. For people like me who just enjoy the music it's not a big deal, but on Twitter it was all out war, I hope only good things come out of this.

16

u/JaySeulChimJun Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21

Not happy with it honestly. Engenes like me have seen so many shits from Moas side when the news was released too. Telling us ENHYPEN is riding his popularity when we don’t even want a collab because we expected that comment. Lets just hope all of this will be worth it when the song comes out.

5

u/prodsolar Oct 04 '21

as person who likes all of hybe's "original" groups im excited but i think hybe is playing a dangerous game being so obsessed with tying their groups careers with e/o so much

2

u/cee_uu Oct 06 '21

Wait what do you mean moas are happy and engenes are not? Engenes literally happy because they collaborate with other artist not untill some moas discreeting enha, saying " and the credits goes to yj" "thanks txt" " it will be probably flop if there's no yj" and saying shits enha, some moas feeling superior. They literally shading enha. They literally started it.

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 06 '21

Hello /u/cee_uu. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/PeekingFromMyWindow Oct 10 '21

On my tl everyone was excited until Yeonjun started trending on Melon higher than Enha, and the name of their title track. Now as a Moa who casually listens to Enha, I wasn't that surprised. Txt trends at the drop of a hat on Melon. These were the first set of mad tweets from Engenes that came on my tl. Then Moas got mad cause we know this to be a regular occurrence so why are they mad about it. This is where things devolved because what is usual for us is not usual for Engenes. It literally happened just hours later when Tae recommended a song and his name as well as the song was trending top 2. Of course Moas felt justified, but that just escalated the matter even more. Now I'm avoiding twitter because one fandom is playing victim right now and it's making the other fandom act out of pocket. I just want the song to come out so I can add it to some of my playlists and give my boy YJ some streams cause this is ridiculous.

1

u/shslcloud Oct 05 '21

both parties are getting benefits. enhypen's gonna get more recognition and yeonjun's getting bag (lmao). i've seen valid concerns from both side, like engenes worrying about enhypen being discredited and worrying about line distribution, but also especially k-moas' concern. txt has had so many activities with enhypen (i-land, playground, radio, now featuring). now we know ifans are mostly flexible and open towards other groups that are not their ults, but kfans are more "focused". some kmoas feel like they're being "used" by hybe. they still remember how txt went to i-land, making moas tune into the show and yet giving txt zero screentime. txt also got so much flack and got called riding off of bts' fame despite not even having much interaction so i think moas became really sensitive. i just hope hybe will play their cards smarter and i hope engenes won't worry bc at the end of the day everyone will be jamming to the song.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/shslcloud Oct 05 '21

i'm talking about recognition in korea. i know they're already popular and succesful.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 04 '21

Hello /u/Iam_Blackberry_. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts, or because your account is less than 7 days old. This is to prevent spam and to keep this subreddit safe. Please send us a mod mail with a link to the submission if you have any further questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.