r/2020PoliceBrutality • u/Hyasfuq Community Ally • Oct 20 '20
News Update The Breonna Taylor juror's statement is very damning: Roberto Aram Ferdman on Twitter
https://twitter.com/robferdman/status/1318606578938007556?s=20295
u/Schmancy_fants Oct 20 '20
The anonymous juror's attorney just sent out a press release with a statement by the juror. It confirms what many have suspected:
"The grand jury was not presented any charges other than the three Wanton Endangerment charges against Detective Hankison."
"The grand jury didn’t agree certain actions were justified, nor did it decide the indictment should be the only charges in the Breonna Taylor case. The grand jury was not given the opportunity to deliberate on those charges"
114
u/rogthnor Oct 20 '20
Does the Grand Jury normally get to deliberate on charges?
275
u/i0datamonster Oct 20 '20
Yes, and it's completely insane that the police & courts did the very thing all these protests were fighting against.
Looking at everything our government is doing right now it's like it wants to be overthrown.
77
u/Mad_Aeric Oct 20 '20
Both insane, and completely expected. Which describes a lot of what's been happening lately.
15
-105
u/TheConboy22 Oct 20 '20
Reformed. You couldn't overthrow the government no matter how much you might want to and talk of such is just ignorance.
85
u/portenth Oct 20 '20
I would encourage you to look at history, mostly the all of it part thx
People will use the system until it does nothing for them, and then they pretty much always end up scrapping it and starting over, or having a neighbor do it for them.
-59
u/TheConboy22 Oct 20 '20
Lets look at history. Since the invention of automatic firearms. How many superpowers have fallen due to armed revolution? I'm not saying we don't reform the government, but the thought that you could "overthrow" the US government is a complete joke. The only way it would happen would be with the US Military backing it and then what. Military dictatorship?
39
u/BisonBait Oct 20 '20
America has a record of firsts.
We had plenty of automatic weapons, napalm, and chemical agents in Vietnam, look how well that went.
I doubt a military of volunteers would be super motivated to mow down a population that includes their friends and family in defense of a government that continually screws them.
Military coup is certainly not out of the picture, but i highly doubt the rest of the world would let it continue any further than that.
20
u/portenth Oct 20 '20
How many of those armed revolutions weren't proxy wars for the benefit of the military industrial complex and imperialist soft power? I'd argue very few.
The early US was a military led overthrow of their government. They (mostly the people who owned the land and the guns) elected most of the senior military leadership (wealthy land owners with guns) over the following decades to government - how is that not a military dictatorship?
The point is, at a certain point the mechanisms of the government could cease to benefit the overwhelming majority. Some would argue they have. When the harm surpasses the benefit, how long do people have to wait before their constitutionally protected human rights and freedoms finally become more important than the system? I would argue that given the clauses in our founding documents encouraging later generations to tear it all down if it ceases to serve them, then politicians in charge should tread lightly on their assaults on our rights.
-24
u/TheConboy22 Oct 20 '20
What stops a hostile power from influencing any group through intelligently directed media influencing that over throwing the government is more important than the prosperity of the people within their country?
14
Oct 20 '20
How much prosperity is there in the US right now? Honestly. Wait until the covid bans on evictions goes away in a few months.
Then you'll really see the prosperity of the US.
10
u/portenth Oct 21 '20
Considering that wages against inflation are down since the 70's, millenials economic ownership is down to 3% compared to 18% for the same time for boomers, cost of living has nearly quadrupled in some indexes, and the top .01% have seen massive income growth while everyone else in the country has seen nothing
I'd argue the system you're defending doesn't really support anyone anymore, besides the extremely wealthy, the politically connected, and corporations.
What stops people from being influenced by a foreign power like you describe is their living conditions not being so shitty that foreign powers have influence.
Right now things are so bad in America that the party that pushed for education cuts for decades has been infiltrated by dangerous foreign interests and their most ardent supporters are also all of the people who (due to said education cuts) are too stupid to realize that they're being spoonfed foreign lies to the point of self delusion. That same parties last 4 presidents combine for 2 impeachments, average double digits criminal indictments, and have run the economy into the ground through corrupt interests like clockwork.
In fact, education standards are so low that we have registered voters in hotly contested swing states considering third party candidates and calling themselves informed. So I guess fix education and income inequality and you don't have to worry about your country collapsing as much
2
u/rad0910725 Oct 21 '20
The biggest problem is that this has been the Republican plan all along. They need those poorly educated to vote against their own interests and they found a way to do that by bringing religion into politics. Oncethe Republicans became the party that the Moral Majority endorsed by using the issue of abortion (Republicans were originally the pro choice party) they were able to finally get people to allow the government to screw us over financially by saying we'd be blessed for saving the unborn. These people have been conned and they can't see it. They will continue to vote against their interests, to hate " baby killing" democrats and independents to the point that they will be poorer than they should be because they refuse see what's really happening to them. It's going to take those people being on the brink of losing everything before they see the forest and not just the trees. Their churches and televangelists keep preaching the prosperity gospel and the evils of the democrats along with turning this country into a Christian theocracy and they eat this up. They want these things because they've been told it's moral and that they'll prosper if these things come to pass. They're so denuded that they refuse to see that we're not prospering because of Republican political ideals. They think it's because abortion is legal and gays can get married. Until this demographic comes to terms with reality not much will change. They'll just keep driving America down in an effort to follow what they believe is right, to follow what their pastor and congregation say they should follow otherwise they'll go to hell and be ostracized whileon earth. It's really sickening to see the brainwashing that has happened via the religious right since Roe v Wade. Until those people see it too then we're probably fucked.
10
u/CptHammer_ Oct 20 '20
Why is automatic firearms a qualifier when you have another qualifier "superpower" which only includes 5 countries over a 122 year span?
By the way, the answer is 2. Germany and France were both overthrown in your short time frame. That seems to be a 66% success rate for overthrowing superpowers. Only one other was attempted, Russia, which as we know failed.
8
u/killabru Oct 21 '20
And the Soviet Union over threw itself lol.
3
u/CptHammer_ Oct 21 '20 edited Oct 21 '20
That seems to be considered a collapse. I'm not sure what the distinction means in this context.
Edit: It seems the distinction is a lack of change of government for Russia. The Union was simply disband by decree because they were tired of fighting about it.
26
u/i0datamonster Oct 20 '20
Tell that to the 176 countries who have had their government overthrown over the last century.
1
-8
u/TheConboy22 Oct 20 '20
Reread my comment and tell me which of those 176 countries was a super power.
12
u/i0datamonster Oct 20 '20
Well none of them were and I get your point but BLM protests is just one of many problems boiling over right now. Whatever comes out of this will still be called the United States of America, but we're going to see very turbulent transitions. It won't be a peaceful reform.
3
2
u/TheConboy22 Oct 20 '20
I don’t see that at all. Police stop killing citizens and this shit stops. They need to be held responsible for it. If people eat and aren’t fearing for their lives than the turmoil is gone.
18
u/i0datamonster Oct 20 '20
The commercial real estate market is about to collapse. A significant amount of the economy is financed by these mortgage backed securities. We still have a pandemic. We're already seeing indicators that the covid-19 economic recovery will be a K-recovery (rich get richer). Our political system is closer to civil war than ever. US foreign relations are strained more than ever. US trade with China is becoming less stable as China is running it's belt and road initiative and did you notice all the border conflicts China has right now.
We're closer to collapse than we've ever been.
A million paper cuts...thucydides trap.
We all need to chill the fuck out.
10
Oct 20 '20
The real estate market is about to collapse as is. Once the covid holds are over we're going to see mass evictions and foreclosures as people can't pay their bills.
→ More replies (0)11
u/ganja_and_code Oct 20 '20
While I agree that reform is better than revolution...that begs the question: How do you force reform upon a government which does not abide by the law?
-2
u/TheConboy22 Oct 21 '20
In our current system you vote. You try to cross borders between people with differing thoughts than you. Do what’s within your power to lessen the divides that are destroying us as a people. Enough people are against something and it changes.
10
u/ganja_and_code Oct 21 '20
That's how it works in theory, sure, but not in practice. When the choices are between two different flavors of inept radicals, for whom can one vote to remedy the problem?
2
u/TheConboy22 Oct 21 '20
I'm confused as to how Biden is a radical. Regardless of that statement. The way we get rid of two party voting is to eliminate FPTP voting system and install some sort of system where if the top candidate doesn't get 50% of the vote than you have a run off between the top 2. In our current system. Any vote for a third party is a vote wasted. This stops them from ever being able to gain traction and keeps us in this ridiculous system of direct down the line division. Any issues we face you have people who just create two sides without any nuance.
7
u/ganja_and_code Oct 21 '20
I don't think he's very radical, but I know he's inept.
Regardless, you say the solution is to get rid of a 2 party system. Who's going to get rid of that system? Obviously not either of the 2 parties who currently hold power under that system...so who?
You see the problem here, right? The people need more choices so they have more power to change the system, but they won't get more choices until the system changes, which won't happen until there are alternative candidates, which there won't be until the system changes...
2
u/TheConboy22 Oct 21 '20
This type of defeatist mentality will only further the issue. You realize that right? The people do have the power to force change. They need to have a focus on what needs to be changed. A big issue is a lack of community leadership which is just a continuation on a lack of community due to so much division.
→ More replies (0)45
u/DeadSheepLane Oct 20 '20
The charges considered are presented to the grand jury by the prosecutor. In this case, the prosecutor is literally Mitch McConnell’s man.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Cameron_(American_politician)
4
12
144
u/talaxia Oct 20 '20
I'm so tired of being told Breonna was a drug dealer who deserved to die because she was shot in the hall, not her bed
58
u/BS0404 Oct 21 '20 edited Oct 21 '20
A lot of people don't seem to realize that even IF she was a drug dealer she shouldn't have been killed. They automatically think any criminal charge is the same as a death sentence and if they happen to be innocent but are killed during the arrest it's their fault for being in the way or something something... Some people are gross.
(Edit, some grammar errors)
28
u/Neato Oct 21 '20
The only reason police should ever use deadly force is to stop someone using deadly force. So unless Breonna had a gun and was killing an innocent (police invading on a no-knock are not innocent) there should have been no weapons. But police use deadly force any time they can get away with the defense of 'I was in fear for my life' which is pretty much 100% of the time because they are massive cowards.
4
u/TreAwayDeuce Oct 21 '20
The only reason police should ever use deadly force is to stop someone using deadly force.
I don't even think that is acceptable. There have been countless times that "evidence" of something has been planted so that the police can later be justified. Police have overstepped their bounds, IMO, so any and all reasons for them to do anything need to be rethought. Their place in society needs to be rethought. How we control crime needs to REALLY be rethought because it isn't working now and arguably never really has.
9
u/Dercken Oct 21 '20
Exactly! I really wish ending the war on drugs was part of the police reform conversation. People getting thier houses raided or sentenced to years in prison for possession of drugs is insane. Also does anyone really believe throwing an addict in jail and labelling them as a felon makes them turn thier life around? The war on drugs is just another way to oppress poor people.
-1
u/lejoo Oct 21 '20
sentenced to years in prison for possession of drugs is insane.
TBH the war on drugs was cracked introduced to black and poor communities, when people realized how shitty it was they started lighting up plants and big pharma got bag and paid off police to go after that instead.
War on drugs now means war on plants
4
u/Kowzorz Oct 21 '20
The war on drugs has pretty much always been racially motivated. We still observe this in modern arrest statistics, but it was introduced and bolstered all throughout American history as racist measures.
44
u/doooompatrol Oct 20 '20
Are we still pretending to be shocked?
20
u/maddiethehippie Oct 21 '20
We try to be, yes. Because when we stop even trying then we have accepted the shitstorm that is this place.
9
u/shelltower Oct 21 '20
Don't let the 'smaller' details escape your memory either. That area has been primed for gentrification... and the city buying the house Taylor was murdered in helps paint that picture a little clearer.
$1.
10
u/skytomorrownow Oct 20 '20
Would a Biden-selected Attorney General have grounds to take over, or try the case at the federal level?
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 20 '20
Welcome to /r/2020PoliceBrutality.
If you wish to contribute by anonymously sharing incidents that you've come across either in-person/IRL or in your feed, please fill out the following form: https://forms.gle/Npcykamuqz8UEcE58
As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion of police abuse of power.
While the content is by nature somewhat inflammatory and disturbing, calls for violence will not be tolerated as they violate site-wide rules and could result in this subreddit being quarantined or banned. The purpose of this subreddit is to raise awareness of the events discussed here, so any actions which threaten the ability of the subreddit to continue operating will not be tolerated and will result in an immediate permanent ban.
A note: we are downloading all videos to our local media and to our repository.
Relevant Links
Github Repository: https://github.com/2020PB/police-brutality/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md#How-to-Contribute-1
Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/2020PoliceBrutality/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/r2020PB
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/r2020policebrutality
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/r2020PoliceBrutality/
Website: https://2020pb.com/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copwatch
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.