r/2020PoliceBrutality • Community Ally • Jul 31 '20

News Report Army sergeant says he's the one who shot a protester to death in Austin

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/austin-protest-fatal-shooting-army-sergeant-says-he-did-it/
1.0k Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

29

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '20

I bet he's proud of it to.

5

u/DankNerd97 Community Ally Aug 01 '20

*too

404

u/jk_throway Jul 31 '20

The fact that this guy was photographed when he showed up at the vigil to harass people kind of destroys his "I'm devistated, it was self-defense" bullshit.

54

u/CharlesDickensABox Aug 01 '20

Not saying I don't believe you, but can you source that claim?

121

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

61

u/skytomorrownow Aug 01 '20

That's going to go over real well in his trial.

42

u/DankNerd97 Community Ally Aug 01 '20

He’s essentially invincible. They never get convicted.

23

u/Dungeon_Pastor Aug 01 '20

Nah, he's not a cop, just a psycho. He'll get his.

23

u/HashFap Aug 01 '20

George Zimmerman wasn't even fully white and he still got off.

27

u/LawBird33101 Aug 01 '20

Army guys get convicted for shit all the time, you're thinking of cops.

32

u/SpeakThunder Aug 01 '20

He's talking about right wing terrorists, not Army men

9

u/CantFixEverything Aug 01 '20

Not only can he get court martialed but he can be criminally and civilly held liable too.

15

u/CharlesDickensABox Aug 01 '20

I can't find a source for that claim in that article. They post a photo of a guy that looks similar (and could have been taken anywhere) and then source it to "Twitter" without a link to where they got it. Reverse searching the image leads to 4chan's /pol/ board, which I'm sure we all recognize as a wretched hive of scum and villainy. I don't know the ibtimes website or that reporter, and I can't seem to find where they got their info. Suffice it to say I remain skeptical. Until it's confirmed by a more reputable source I would be extremely careful repeating it.

5

u/DeadlyLemming Aug 01 '20

Here is an archive of his twitter: http://archive.vn/bDQTk#selection-309.2-309.26

-2

u/CharlesDickensABox Aug 01 '20

Specifically the claim I'm attempting to interrogate is whether the shooter showed up at the memorial the next day. I agree that his Twitter history is extremely troubling and indicates a violent disposition towards protestors. What I don't see is any evidence that he was present or attempted to antagonize people at Foster's memorial the day after the shooting.

-24

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

Google dot com

12

u/SeymourZ Aug 01 '20

Every time people get together to share opinions and information there’s always a twat like you.

-8

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/SeymourZ Aug 01 '20

They asked for a source and now it’s posted for all to see. They did nothing like what you’re saying, you just feel like an idiot for your comment and want to focus attention away from it.

-11

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/SeymourZ Aug 01 '20

Like I said already, the point of being here is for discussion, the sharing of information and ideas. Though, as you kindly proved, not everyone has something meaningful to contribute. Perhaps you can help the problem by staying on google and leaving the discussion here with the grownups.

-3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

God forbid someone already on the internet utilize it.

1

u/SeymourZ Aug 01 '20

You sure do get cranky when you’re downvoted.

→ More replies (0)

116

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '20

7

u/BestFriendWatermelon Aug 02 '20

“I have been dumped while I was in Afghanistan and my own parents made it pretty clear that when I better stay in the army,” Perry writes. “because when I get out that is it they are not going to help me out and I am going to be living in the streets like [those] vets you see begging for your change addicted to drugs because that is there only way put of the pain that they feel. All in all I am fucked.”

... and it's the left he's mad at. Unbelievable.

5

u/DOCisaPOG Aug 01 '20

And he was a furry? I always thought they were so much more chill than that.

1

u/LadyofDungeons Aug 08 '20

They usually are.

My boyfriend is one, and I’ve not really met any that violatile...weird sure, but not dangerous.

177

u/acavb Jul 31 '20

When I saw an account of this on national news, the police official (looked like a woman?) basically said he was defending himself. How she could have already come to that totally incorrect asumption??? But killing protectors is cool to cops i guess.

45

u/CharlesDickensABox Aug 01 '20

It's cool for them to murder protestors, anyone who doesn't toe the party line is fair game.

17

u/angrynobody Aug 01 '20

It's cool for them to murder... anyone is fair game.

There, I fixed that for you.

-5

u/HouseofMontague Aug 01 '20

The guy’s car was getting mobbed and someone came up to him with a rifle. Look I’m not saying this guy was a good guy but from outside looking in, I can see why he shot Garrett.

The driver also claims he was in the area due to dropping someone off from a ride share trip. If that turns out to be true, then it seems to me like it was more a matter of unfortunate circumstances then malice.

Him harassing people at the vigil though, that’s just straight heartless.

10

u/Aruvanta Aug 01 '20

The car wasn't being mobbed. The car advanced into a mob. I think there's a small difference between these two.

-4

u/HouseofMontague Aug 01 '20

People began hitting the car and they were angry. I’m not going to assume the reason for going into the crowd.

Personally, I do think it’s a matter of circumstance then placing blame on either side. I can understand how both sides reacted and I think it’s a tragedy Garrett was shot and killed.

42

u/UltraMegaMegaMan Aug 01 '20

This was a deliberate and premeditated murder. Daniel Perry had tweeted multiple times about how protestors should be killed. When Garret Foster was interviewed, Perry probably saw it and became enraged.

Perry just so happened to drive his car directly into a crowd that contained Foster, almost running over several people in the process. When people accosted Perry for almost running them over (including Foster), Perry shot Foster to death then drove away.

I am as confident as I can be that if Austin PD can be bothered to investigate Perry's internet activity and where he was that day, it will be clear that Perry drove around looking for Foster for the express purpose of creating a circumstance where he could shoot Foster and claim self-defense.

It was deliberate and contrived. Garrett Foster was standing his ground vs. a person who deliberately was driving his car into a crowd, and Perry murdered him for it.

10

u/Meme_Man_Sam Aug 01 '20

Yeah. Its Obvious. Theres even been videos of people saying that they will kill the protesters. Foster was a good guy. Scumbags just want to find a reason and excuse to kill someone and be "patriotic".

1

u/eloquent_petrichor Aug 01 '20

I wonder if there is a way to find out who the prosecutor will be and link them this reddit so they know what proof to search for

3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

So murder with malicious intent and a history of pretending about it.

3

u/failedaspotcheck Aug 01 '20

I'd also read that his army unit was giving him no end of shit for this. Thankfully it's not a common sentiment among the military. Hope he gets a conviction.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

Excessive force. Why didn't he just grip the person's throat with his manhands and peer into their soul, changing them forever?

22

u/SpicyWarlock69 Jul 31 '20

I feel like there is a lot of conflicting information. If this was in cold blood why would he immediately call the cops after he shot the protester? Did the protester actually point the ak-47 at the driver? Did the driver actually aggressively Rev his engine? I would really like to see some video evidence supporting either persons claim. Did this 8 year army vet serve over seas and having an Ak47 point at him possibly trigger flight or fight response? This is going to be a long trial unless some video/audio is shown.

77

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '20

I haven't heard any witness accounts (aside from the shooter) say that he was pointing the gun at the man.

The driver sped into the protest area, many witnesses heard the tires squealing and were surprised that nobody was hit. The man who was killed had been pushing his girlfriend's wheelchair up until this point. He approached the shooter's car, carrying his gun with the muzzle pointing at the ground. His only other option was to leave the AK-47 unattended.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '20

[deleted]

91

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '20

Witness accounts can be skewed, but I would trust multiple witnesses over one man who shot and killed someone. The fact that NO witnesses agree with the shooter's story is suspicious.

27

u/imagenius0 Jul 31 '20

Agreed. There's also video of the event (you don't see the actual shooting) where you can tell something caught the attention of every protestor in the intersection and a second or two later shots ring out.

9

u/clairebear_22k Aug 01 '20

Dont think it's jumping to conclusions when you have someone tweeting about how they want to kill protesters and then many witnesses say they violently drive into a protest and then they shoot a protestor. like what more do you want?

3

u/pugofthewildfrontier Aug 01 '20

They want the “evidence” that exonerates the murderer. THEN they have all the evidence. Until then we can’t jump to conclusions.

5

u/NorthernRedwood Aug 01 '20

what is 'actual evidence'

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20 edited Feb 25 '24

theory test boat cobweb narrow different quiet chubby forgetful north

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

-16

u/NorthernRedwood Aug 01 '20

i thought 'actual' evidence wouldn't be the 2nd easiest to fake by any 10th grade computer student.

3

u/GovmentTookMaBaby Aug 01 '20

Yea because anyone can do a legitimate deep fake that fools forensic investigators?!? Just because you’re easily fooled doesn’t mean everyone else is.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20 edited Feb 25 '24

squash boat slap reach wasteful domineering bored squealing carpenter afterthought

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

-11

u/NorthernRedwood Aug 01 '20

yes, what Im saying is "there is no such thing as actual evidence"

1

u/A_Bored_Canadian Aug 01 '20

Well then I dunno what to tell you

50

u/broswithabat Jul 31 '20

If this was in cold blood why would he immediately call the cops after he shot the protester?

(Not to ignore everything else you said, because there is a lot of info we don't have yet. But to just focus on this point)

A lot of people out there feel like they can turn gunslinger as long as they technically follow the rules. Usually its people saying stupid shit like "if hes on your property you can shoot him" or "if you shoot a burglar make sure he dies before he gets out into your yard" depending on the local laws for when you are technically able to shoot another person.

Lots of these people come off as secretly just itching for someone to give them the reason. But also they in their own minds are following the rules so its ok. Those people will think they are totally in the right and call the cops.

Not saying this is what happened here. More info will be needed. But it is a reason someone would do that.

-4

u/Sluggish0351 Jul 31 '20

Speculation of what was going through a person's head doesn't do much other than muddy the waters when trying to gather facts on an incident.

Additionally, the term, "in cold blood", really gets tossed around and missused a lot. Killing in cold blood is sociopathic level stuff. Having cold blood is to feel no emotion. if he wanted to kill a protester because he dissagreed with them, that isn't cold blood, that is premeditated and aggravated. If he was feeling threatened by a person brandishing a weapon at them, that is also not in cold blood. Walking by a stranger in the middle of the night and shooting them in the back of the head for kicks, that is cold blooded.

22

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '20

Someone posted an article showing that Daniel perry had previously threatened violence against protesters. If he expressed interest in shooting protesters, went out drove his car through a crowd of protesters, then shot a protesters id say in cold blood.

I've driven during plenty of protests, strikes, parades, sports celebrations and never had to come close to running anyone over, I dont really buy any of the excuses I keep seeing that people are mistakenly driving into crowds or people that just doesn't happen its road rage or a planned assault.

3

u/MiguelMenendez Aug 02 '20

It’s really interesting that people don’t seem to “accidentally” drive into crowds after a baseball or football game, or Independence Day fireworks with any sort of frequency. It seems to happen quite a bit during liberal-supported marches.

14

u/broswithabat Jul 31 '20 edited Jul 31 '20

Speculation of what was going through a person's head doesn't do much other than muddy the waters when trying to gather facts on an incident.

Which is why I started my comment with a clarification that there is a lot of info we don't have so I wasn't doing that. Just answering that one question about why someone would call the cops after doing something like this even if they were hypothetically in the wrong.

Edit: actually I even started AND ended my original comment with clarification of that exact point. I couldn't have done much more to say I ain't trying to speculate about this incident.

Additionally, the term, "in cold blood", really gets tossed around and missused a lot. Killing in cold blood is sociopathic level stuff. Having cold blood is to feel no emotion. if he wanted to kill a protester because he dissagreed with them, that isn't cold blood, that is premeditated and aggravated. If he was feeling threatened by a person brandishing a weapon at them, that is also not in cold blood. Walking by a stranger in the middle of the night and shooting them in the back of the head for kicks, that is cold blooded.

Yea that is all a good point, this wouldn't have technically been cold blood and there are a lot of better terms for it depending on what the facts turn out to be.

-11

u/Sluggish0351 Jul 31 '20

Yeah, but saying something along the Ines of, "not to speculate, but (enter speculation here)" doesn't seem like a comment to have in a serious conversation to begin with. I'm not trying to attack you personally, I've done this myself, but understanding that speaking this way is in no way helpful just makes for cheap talk. If speculation isn't good then don't do it.

10

u/broswithabat Jul 31 '20

Speculation about what was going through this person's head(which is what you brought up and we both agree is not good) is different from a conversation about why someone who has done something bad would call the cops.

The first one would be unhelpful and unfounded, the second is a perfectly legitimate conversation to have about a related topic that had come up, while we wait for info about the main topic. Which again I pointed out I wasn't talking about.

Since we agree we have nothing yet on this incident I was making a separate point about one thing that had come up in the conversation. If it wasn't clear with my two qualifiers in the first comment it should be by now.

So I still feel like its a matter of you not only misunderstanding my point but also ignoring the qualifiers I specifically put in my original comment to avoid people like you misunderstanding my point and thinking I am doing the exact thing you now are think I am doing. Idk what else to tell you. The first and last sentence of my comment were for people like you and you just blew right by em.

2

u/friendlymonitors Aug 01 '20

Speculation of what was going through a person's head doesn't do much

It establishes motive. Motive is a key factor in determining the level of culpability for a murderer. Motive is the difference between first degree murder and manslaughter.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

Simple: You call because you want to look like a good upstanding citizen that killed someone in self defense and hopefully avoid trial altogether or get to trial and not be convicted of anything.

5

u/rddman Aug 01 '20 edited Aug 02 '20

If this was in cold blood why would he immediately call the cops after he shot the protester?

To create the impression that he acted in good faith (self defense).

-1

u/Rainbike80 Aug 01 '20

Almost all engagements are at 400+ yards in Afghanistan and Iraq....plus by the looks of the photo he was in calvary so IF he saw the enemy it was from a seat in a vehicle or turret.

The Kurds don't have a PTSD problem....most candy asses claim it for money. Not because a few rounds going over their head actually left an impact. Door kickers are rare and have a very limited shelf life. Doubtful he was ever one of them.

3

u/BestFriendWatermelon Aug 02 '20

Almost all engagements are at 400+ yards in Afghanistan and Iraq....plus by the looks of the photo he was in calvary so IF he saw the enemy it was from a seat in a vehicle or turret.

There's a growing body of evidence that "combat fatigue" is caused by damage to the brain caused by IEDs or other explosive impacts to the brain, rather than being psychological as had always been assumed.

That said, you're being somewhat naive if you can't imagine traumatic stress from being an unwelcome presence in a country where everyone wants to kill you, even at extreme range. You do not need to see or be in close proximity to a persistent threat to be traumatised by it. Any long term stress can cause psychological damage; our minds are not designed to exist in a permanent state of 'fight or flight'.

The Kurds don't have a PTSD problem

The scope of the problem of PTSD on veterans around the world is vast. Veterans have markedly higher suicide rates, homelessness rates, alcoholism rates, etc than the general population in every military conflict. This includes the Kurds. What there is, however, is tremendous social stigma among Kurdish fighters about seeking psychological treatment.

....most candy asses claim it for money.

PTSD/combat fatigue is well documented and well understood, perhaps moreso than almost any other condition on Earth, thanks to the enormous resources militaries around the world have put into studying it. It is not in the military's interest to play up the damage done to people in their care when sending them out to fight, and for a long long time they denied it like tobacco companies denied a link to cancer.

Not because a few rounds going over their head actually left an impact. Door kickers are rare and have a very limited shelf life. Doubtful he was ever one of them.

Stop minimising the damage the wealthy and powerful elites do to the poor when they send them to fight in their wars for control of resources.

1

u/CMDRDregg Aug 01 '20

I would never call for violence but this guy.....

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 31 '20

Welcome to /r/2020PoliceBrutality.

If you wish to contribute by anonymously sharing incidents that you've come across either in-person/IRL or in your feed, please fill out the following form: https://forms.gle/Npcykamuqz8UEcE58

As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion of police abuse of power.

While the content is by nature somewhat inflammatory and disturbing, calls for violence will not be tolerated as they violate site-wide rules and could result in this subreddit being quarantined or banned. The purpose of this subreddit is to raise awareness of the events discussed here, so any actions which threaten the ability of the subreddit to continue operating will not be tolerated and will result in an immediate permanent ban.

A note: we are downloading all videos to our local media and to our repository.

Relevant Links

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-5

u/52089319_71814951420 Aug 01 '20

All the questions and considerations that people have pointed out in this thread ... they went out the door when Garret pointed his gun at the guy. That is also one of the only parts of this fiasco that is clearly caught on camera.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

Really? Link it.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '20

[deleted]

22

u/gdsmithtx Aug 01 '20

No, the article does not say that at all. It says that the police made that statement. That account is disputed by eyewitnesses.

-6

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

-5

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

So? That doesn't change anything. He was doing what everyone does: hustles to tell their version first hoping they can beat everyone else to the punch, hoping that sways it in their favor.

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[deleted]

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[deleted]

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (0)