r/2020PoliceBrutality • Community Ally • Jul 26 '20

Video Federal judge warned DHS would lose immunity if targeting a journalist. They did last night.

https://twitter.com/andrewkimmel/status/1287319466120904704?s=21
725 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

121

u/AanthonyII Jul 26 '20

Why do they even have immunity to begin with?

92

u/Projectrage Community Ally Jul 26 '20

DHS shouldn’t have any immunity, but it’s a legal loophole.

65

u/RadioFreeAmerika Jul 26 '20

Police neither. They should be held accountable under the same laws as everyone else.

54

u/AanthonyII Jul 26 '20

buT hOw WiIl thE PoLiCe bE aBle tO dO tHerE joB iF thEy’Re tOo WorRiEd aBoUT gEtTinG in TroUbLe?

Easy, in there own words “just don’t break the law.”

12

u/RadioFreeAmerika Jul 26 '20 edited Jul 26 '20

They still would have their "thin-blue-line" "blue wall". As long as they keep covering for each other, it will be very difficult to convict them. At least that's how it works in a lot of countries where the police do not have qualified immunity.

10

u/AanthonyII Jul 26 '20

That's true, but getting rid of qualified immunity would at least be a start

6

u/UseDaSchwartz Jul 26 '20

The thin blue line is the police protecting the public from criminals or something like that. The blue wall of silence is officers covering each other.

5

u/RadioFreeAmerika Jul 26 '20

My bad, corrected.

3

u/goat-head-man Jul 26 '20

I thought that QI was made out of whole cloth by the judiciary and is a doctrine, not even law or approved by the people. It exists to not only protect the police but also the two other members of the triumvirate - prosecutors and judges, both of which have been sadly omitted in the discussion about police overreach.

3

u/U1tramadn3ss Jul 27 '20

I agree. Bad cops are the tip of the ice berg (if only a third) of the deep systemic injustices minorities face in the American Justice System.

Many judges are appointed by the president and approved by the legislative branch; Supreme Court picks are extremely influential, but there should be more focus on the circuit court judges who decide how someone spends the next decade(s) of their lives.

3

u/PunkyBrister Jul 26 '20

Their union

30

u/eightiesladies Jul 26 '20

Bunch of cowards.

26

u/desertfoxz Jul 26 '20

The supreme court with it's make up would throw out the federal judge decision. The supreme court currently favors police immunity.

4

u/Slow_Rogue Jul 26 '20

Sauce?

20

u/desertfoxz Jul 26 '20 edited Jul 26 '20

https://www.npr.org/2020/06/15/876853817/supreme-court-will-not-re-examine-doctrine-that-shields-police-in-misconduct-sui

From June 2020, they already refused the newest push. The most conservative judge Thomas actually supports getting rid of immunity for police so it isn't always liberal judges that can make such changes.

-2

u/AnthropocenicRoute Jul 27 '20

I fucken hate Judge Uncle Thomas with a special burning hatred reserved especially for him.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '20

That is why there is the End Qualified Immunity Act and the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act of 2020, both sitting in House right now. Neither would pass the republican controlled Senate though and definitely would be vetoed by Trump, so they would have to have a 2/3's majority I believe to avoid the veto. It would have to wait for Biden to be president, so next year. But if these things do pass, they would overwrite the Supreme Court I believe? Checks and Balances and whatnot. That's why we have three branches of gubment.

1

u/desertfoxz Jul 29 '20

Nope, the supreme court would still be deciding party. This is why Roosevelt tried to pack the court when in office.

https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/roosevelt-announces-court-packing-plan

17

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

Empty words from the judge. Trump hasn't been held accountable for anything he's done, don't think it's gonna magically start during an election that determines if he lives the rest of his life in prison vs staying the most powerful man in the "free" world.

4

u/yaosio Jul 27 '20

The judge then said, "2 and a half..."

The joke here being the parents saying if they count to 3 their child will be in trouble, but never reaching 3.

2

u/blurryfacedfugue Jul 27 '20

God damn that was hard to watch. I need to spread this subreddit. It'll make police's work more dangerous, but fuck. This needs to stop.

edit: uh wtf...the tweet just got deleted? It was up a second ago

edit2: it still works if I visit the link in my history. Weird...I wonder whats going on: https://twitter.com/andrewkimmel/status/1287319466120904704?s=21

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 26 '20

Welcome to /r/2020PoliceBrutality.

If you wish to contribute by anonymously sharing incidents that you've come across either in-person/IRL or in your feed, please fill out the following form: https://forms.gle/Npcykamuqz8UEcE58

As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion of police abuse of power.

While the content is by nature somewhat inflammatory and disturbing, calls for violence will not be tolerated as they violate site-wide rules and could result in this subreddit being quarantined or banned. The purpose of this subreddit is to raise awareness of the events discussed here, so any actions which threaten the ability of the subreddit to continue operating will not be tolerated and will result in an immediate permanent ban.

A note: we are downloading all videos to our local media and to our repository.

Relevant Links

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-5

u/spastic_narwhal Jul 26 '20

I'm not defending the police but I'm pretty sure journalist protections only apply if you're not actively participating in the protest

10

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

"protest" they will just call it a riot and problem solved.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Projectrage Community Ally Jul 26 '20

So it’s valid to just pepper spay an unarmed guy in the face??

3

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/DFrostedWangsAccount Jul 27 '20

Uh... if he writes an article for his blog later, does that make it journalism? I don't exactly understand the distinction here.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/DFrostedWangsAccount Jul 27 '20

Press aren't required to be impartial, and if they are then a lot of people are doing their jobs wrong.

What exactly is the qualification then that separates a protected "Press" member and not this man?

9

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/JustaBCer Jul 26 '20

Possible feelings of regret seems to be the worst consequences these guys are facing.

10

u/lejoo Jul 26 '20

The funny part is the cops are claiming PTSD when they are literally the ones attempting to traumatize civilian.

Only bullies play the victim when they get called out.