r/2020PoliceBrutality • • Jul 25 '20

Portland “police” caught shouting “LEAVE NO EVIDENCE BEHIND” as they pick ammunition rounds up from the ground. Earlier in the protests, police were seen picking up tear gas canisters to hide how much they have been gassing protestors.

9.6k Upvotes

203 comments sorted by

831

u/HeyCharrrrlie Jul 25 '20

This is a crime scene if there ever was one. This cannot continue. They must be stopped.

757

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20

It is literal treason in every sense of the word. Not an exaggeration. The 1st, 4th, 5th, and 10th constitutional amendments are being violated in Portland by Federal government. We cannot allow this to stand, because if this is normalized, it's a final death knell for democracy as we've known it. If we allow this to stand today, then it will be also used for elections and any form of attempting "freedom of speech and the right to assemble." It will be used in spite of the mandate forbidding "unlawful search and seizure," or "deprivation of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law."

404

u/zixd Jul 25 '20

18 U.S. Code § 2381.Treason

Whoever, owing allegiance to the United States, levies war against them or adheres to their enemies, giving them aid and comfort within the United States or elsewhere, is guilty of treason and shall suffer death, or shall be imprisoned not less than five years and fined under this title but not less than $10,000; and shall be incapable of holding any office under the United States.


That's the legal definition of treason in the US. I'm sure you could make a case for this and that, but keep in mind that that's what it means to commit treason here in the legal sense.

82

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20

Thanks for that, and I'm sure it could be argued if we establish how Russian influence is factoring into this. We ARE at war, the kind that does not require bullets to be fired. We are being targeted by ideological subversion (psychological warfare) and have been from at least the Cold War with the Soviet Union, and now present day Russia. That said, our founders purposefully narrowed the legal definition of treason to prevent abuse of it. But it can be EASILY argued that Trump is adhering to our enemies. It can EASILY be argued that Trump is waging war against U.S. citizens. Hell, Republicans are guilty of this with every "War on XYZ" slogan they've normalized over the past 50 years. You don't go to war against your own civilians. You especially do not violate multiple amendments to assert dominance over them. This is not what this nation is supposed to be. Also, if going by the more general definition treason, we are clearly seeing a betrayal or subversion of one's own nation from a position of power. It needs to stop..and stop today.

31

u/El_Rey_247 Jul 25 '20

To add on to the previous comment, we should all know that words on the Constitution are basically meaningless except for how the Supreme Court interprets them. Current supreme court interpretation of treason is that you must be levying war against America, or both adhering to an enemy and giving aid. The bar to prove adherence to an enemy is at least two firsthand witnesses who saw explicit allegiance, if not other hard evidence.

Trump sits in a space where allegiance is indeterminate. So far, we know he has acted against the interests of Americans, even in favor of opposition governments, but incompetence is not a crime. If he is doing it all for personal gain, and maybe even if he's being blackmailed, I don't think that reaches the legal bar for treason.

Various other crimes, sure, but impeachment is supposed to handle that. Frankly, a President can be impeached for any reason, crime or not, but those checks and balances have largely been broken, so it doesn't really matter whether Trump committed treason or not.

Hell, with federal actions in Portland, seemingly illegally occupying and enforcing law, there might actually be a better "levying war" argument, though like everything else, the question remains if it would actually be traced all the way back to Trump, or if someone else would take the fall.

However, as that first source says, the definition of "levying war" is also narrow and possibly outdated. Too bad the Supreme Court is so slow. Constitutional rights could be violated today, and you might not have that confirmed for years.

Trump will probably go down for tax fraud or one of the many state cases lined up against him long before ever being charged with treason.

(Disclaimer: I'm not a lawyer, nor am I anything close to a constitutional scholar. Just a random internet person who spends too much time reading about and watching legal shenanigans.)

-2

u/Jaxxsnero Jul 25 '20

The so-called federal agents have been identified as paid mercenaries from a private company that provides contract security. ZTI group. These are Eric Prince mercenaries.

They’re going to try to claim that they deputize an army that swore No oath of loyalty to the constitution.

They are private military group that is beating people in the streets. Sworn no oath to the constitution. they are as foreign of an army as anything we seen on American soil.

5

u/El_Rey_247 Jul 25 '20

I'm not seeing any credible sources reporting this, and at least this site has pretty high resolution images from other angles showing that the single photo that spread, showing "ZTi" is actually showing "ZT1".

Why "ZT1" and if there is any significance to that, I don't know, but I personally wouldn't feel comfortable throwing ZTI under the bus for this. Not without something more solid, at least.

2

u/HeyCharrrrlie Jul 26 '20

Perhaps this is where the missing coronavirus money went, to pay for the private army. I have no proof, it's just a hunch but it makes sense.

-7

u/SirDaddio Jul 25 '20

So like antifa?

-6

u/Jaxxsnero Jul 25 '20

We don’t have to establish a link to Russia these are not FEDs they are private military groups operated by Eric Prince, the ZTI group. They owe no allegiance and swore no oath of loyalty to the United States. they are a private militia.

They are traitors and this is treason

5

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20

I think the ZTI angle was debunked (or atleast the association from the markings on these federal militants, as you can see more examples where they seem to be individual markers).

The problem though, and you elude directly to this here, is that you cannot have opaqueness and anonymity here...as it leads to EXACTLY this type of confusion and opens the door for all kinds of abuse. For example, what is to stop local militias from stepping in and pretending to be federal troops? Nevermind that due process is not being observed in any of this as is.

2

u/Jaxxsnero Jul 25 '20

Just saw the SRT identifier postings. You’re right. This is crazy. you can’t have anonymous camouflaged people running around and beating moms.

39

u/hottestyearsonrecord Jul 25 '20

The definition doesn't even matter or Trump would be in jail for aiding the Russians

29

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

Yes, the GOP senate has already allowed the treason. The entire GOP is an enemy of the USA, much like the confederacy was. They have actively defended the traitor president, they don't even give two shits about bounties placed by Russia on our soldiers heads. For that matter, many soldiers support a president and party that allowed bounties on their heads. We are at a very dangerous crossroads. What we do today has long term consequences for the USA. We have allowed our reputation to be permanently tarnished globally. We have shown weakness beyond reprieve by leaving trump in office. What we the people do to stop the tyranny at home will be very telling.

5

u/InquisitorZeroAlpha Jul 25 '20

Indeed, Trump siding with Russia as they attack our elections and offer bounties on our soldiers makes him a Constitutionally-qualified traitor that deserves execution.

2

u/Daaskison Jul 25 '20

Sedition might be more appropriate in this case

1

u/zixd Jul 26 '20

18 U.S. Code § 2384.Seditious conspiracy

If two or more persons in any State or Territory, or in any place subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, conspire to overthrow, put down, or to destroy by force the Government of the United States, or to levy war against them, or to oppose by force the authority thereof, or by force to prevent, hinder, or delay the execution of any law of the United States, or by force to seize, take, or possess any property of the United States contrary to the authority thereof, they shall each be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than twenty years, or both.


That seems about right to me.

2

u/titsahoy1 Jul 25 '20

I thought you guys had guns for this very reason?

2

u/zixd Jul 26 '20

That's the idea, yes. The thing is, most of us that have guns for the purpose of controlling a rogue government don't actually care about government overreach if it doesn't affect us specifically. We can keep migrants in concentration camps on the border and the gun crowd won't do a thing because they like it when bad things happen to people like that. That, or they just don't care.

It's an aesthetic in modern day America. It's like sneakers or sports teams.

2

u/titsahoy1 Aug 07 '20

Good luck out there. Stay safe.

1

u/HorridlyMorbid Jul 26 '20

Is it war against the US if you only want to go after congress?

1

u/zixd Jul 26 '20

In what way?

1

u/HorridlyMorbid Jul 26 '20

Well like you said it's treason to levy war against the US if you have allegiance to the US. I wonder if you only have a problem with congress but not the US as a whole if it's still treason.

50

u/SpooktorB Jul 25 '20

Dont forget 6th, the right to face your accuser. Arresting officers are considered accusers in the judicial system, so these snatch and grabs by the unmarked feds are direct violation of this as you cant identify who is illegally seizing you for reprocussions.

9

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20

Damn good observation. Thank you

23

u/SpooktorB Jul 25 '20

You can also throw in the 9th, as it states that citizens rights are not found only in the constitution, which allows for the Human right of innocent until proven guilty to be a protected right by the bill of rights.

15

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20

You're absolutely right about this. The 9th is one of our simultaneously most significant and yet most neglected. It's basically a way to say, "don't abuse this system of rights. Use common sense."

I'm also thinking the 8th is relevant here too, in particular "cruel and unusual punishments inflicted."

23

u/gorpie97 Jul 25 '20

Based on what the other guy said, it's not treason (legally), but it is violating the Constitution. And what's new about that (hello Patriot Act)?

10

u/Destrina Jul 25 '20

How is this not levying war against civilians in Portland?

1

u/gorpie97 Jul 26 '20

Whoever, owing allegiance to the United States, levies war against them

I would interpret this to mean that it's legally not treason. The troops aren't levying war with the US, but with US citizens.

That doesn't mean it's not wrong, and a violation of any oaths they took to protect and defend the Constitution, and are war crimes, and things like that.

-16

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (4)

10

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20 edited Jul 25 '20

I think we can argue it's the legal definition of treason fairly easily. It's right there in plain sight at least in how it satisfies one of Russia's goals for us...just getting that past a population that has blinders on and bananas in their ears is the challenge in a fascist America :/

Also, I'm happy declaring Trump as an enemy of the nation...so Russia need not apply to the definition.

(but yea, I was in my comment actually referring moreso to the general definition....the legal definition is purposefully restricted to prevent abuse of it)

3

u/Sczytzo Jul 25 '20

Perhaps insurrection would fit better?

2

u/gorpie97 Jul 26 '20

Insurrection might apply to the citizens, though I think they just wanted to engage in their first amendment rights (and instigate change)!

I don't see how that would apply to the soldiers. (I'm not going to call them cops.)

2

u/Sczytzo Jul 26 '20

To my mind, in a democracy the authority of the government derives from the will of the citizenry. As such I tend to view the citizens as the rulers of a democratic country. As for the cops, they are also meant to serve the will of the public as expressed through the government we elect. As such, if the cops, who are in the end citizens, are acting in opposition to the will of the rulers of the country(the people) that sounds like an insurrection to me.

2

u/gorpie97 Jul 26 '20

Looked at your way, it is treason or insurrection (too tired to look up the difference now!).

The citizens are supposed to be the rulers. And it's neither just nor right that the oligarchs have used fraudulent means to subvert our elected representatives.

I'm not sure that cops are supposed to be there to protect and serve us, though - that may be a fiction that we're told so that we don't complain about paying their salaries. I think the ones who agree with you/us end up leaving after a few years because of the corruption.

2

u/Sczytzo Jul 26 '20

I'm not an expert in legal terminology, but my impression would be that for the leaders making the decisions it would be treason. For the officers on the front, using violence to suppress the people who are supposed to be in charge, it would(I think) be better described as an insurrection.

As for the Oligarchs, I wouldn't say they have used fraudulent means to subvert our government. What we have now is just the result of under-regulated capitalism. In capitalism, money is power. If the acquisition of power(Money) is not controlled to at least some extent by the people, eventually some groups will come to hold enough to start exercising control over other forms of power(government/social/media). It's just a natural outcome of the system.

No matter how they have existed historically, or how they are used now, police take an oath to uphold the law. If the people are in control and decide what the law will be, then any officer honestly carrying out their duty will be acting on behalf of the people. Unfortunately the police force that we have now grows from a long tradition of not being employed on behalf of the people, and they are corrupt from root to leaf. To me, it is clear that the entire institution must be torn down and remade if we wish to have a police force that serves the people of our nation. Under such fundamentally corrupt conditions, it is not surprising that the individuals who seek to serve the populace don't last long. They are out there however, though no longer working as police, and they might be the best shot we have at building a reformed police force.

2

u/gorpie97 Jul 26 '20

I like what you said!

By "fraudulent means", I meant them buying donating large sums to our political representatives and gaining access and influencing things behind the scenes. At least that's how it started however many decades ago.

1

u/Sczytzo Jul 27 '20

Thank you, I spend a lot of time thinking about this stuff and try to come up with ways to clearly communicate my thoughts. It's always nice to get some feedback, and hearing that I'm managing to get my point across is always gratifying.

I understand what you are expressing when you say fraudulent means. I just don't see it as something that can be separated from the overall system, so I don't think of it as fraudulent, just the logical conclusion of the system in place. Even if you don't allow direct donations and fix that part of influencing campaigns, large sums of capital are going to be able to exert power in the political arena. The fact that so many of the voters in a politician's district depend on a particular company for employment is going to exert a pressure to avoid hurting them. On a larger scale than that is the recent trend of "too big to fail" regarding recent financial collapses. If a company cannot fail without jeopardizing the economy of the entire nation, then that company has power over the livelihood of the people and therefore the politicians who represent those people. Because of things like that I tend to see the current situation with the oligarchs as an entirely natural outcome of the system in place. I'm not going to argue that complete conversion to socialism is the only solution, just that the people, through their elected officials, need to have greater control over how much capital can be amassed and how it can be used.

9

u/EnemiesAllAround Jul 25 '20

Except nothing's gunna happen as usual. People will huff and puff and swear this time they won't give up and will keep fighting.

Time will pass, tempers will cool, politicians will change.

Nothing will change.

2

u/Fidodo Jul 26 '20

It's fascism. We've been talking about how this administration was doing fascist like thing, now it's undeniably full blown fascism. (although I personally would argue that we already crossed that a while ago)

2

u/skeen9 Jul 26 '20

It's sedition against Democratic traditions of governance. But not treason

1

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 26 '20

I agree with you on our legal definition at least. There is a significant chance Trump has been colluding with Putin, and if that connection is ever established then the legal definition of treason kicks in.

But when I wrote that, I was moreso using the dictionary definition of treason. Sedition also works. Betrayal, subterfuge, flagitious malfeasance, etc etc

1

u/altgoobyFAK Jul 26 '20

You're right, and it's also in our rights to forcefully overthrow unconstitutional acts by government agents as stated in the constitution. Why are people still peacefully protesting? It's our right to shoot back at this point. This country was founded on stopping government bullshit.

1

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 26 '20

We are no where near that sort of escalation. And to be honest, you are echoing Russian propaganda. You're free to advocate whatever you want of course, but calling for violence, destruction of property, etc just plays into the hands of those who control the executive branch right now. They will use those actions as justifications to go full on Reichstag fire. If you're trying to be more helpful than harmful we all need to be aware of this danger. We need to be waving our American flags when we are being attacked/teargassed. Because we ARE patriotic and we DO love our country and want to see it succeed. But was also want to be INCLUSIVE, not EXCLUSIVE...no matter how hard a narrow minded fascist faction tries to make us play their game.

Ultimately we are losing a war of attrition in the courts, and need to focus on that the moment we regain control in the Senate. And push our representatives to laser focus their attention on preventing this kind of subterfuge in the future...because what we are witnessing today from the GOP is outright flagitious.

-7

u/someduder2112 Jul 25 '20

because if this is normalized, it's a final death knell for democracy as we've known it.

You mean democracy as liberals know it

This shit aint new and your grand modernist ideals arent going to help you

3

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20

This shit aint new and your grand modernist ideals arent going to help you

Hey you're either advocating for it, or for the alternative we're "enjoying" presently.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[deleted]

1

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20 edited Jul 25 '20

Point me to an interpretation of it that aligns with yours. The 10th has been used expressly throughout history to limit the power of congress from imposing on state rights. However you may already know that the word "expressly" is how this was challenged as well.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[deleted]

1

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20

Where is that from? Here? https://www.britannica.com/topic/Tenth-Amendment

The rest of that statement follows as:

; though there had been an attempt to do so, Congress defeated a motion to modify the word delegated with expressly in the amendment. It thus does not grant states additional powers, nor does it alter the relationship that exists between the federal government and the states. It merely indicates that the states may establish and maintain their own laws and policies so long as they do not conflict with the authority of the federal government.

...

From the death of Marshall until the 1930s and particularly since the mid-1980s, however, the Supreme Court has often used the Tenth Amendment to limit the authority of the federal government, particularly with regard to regulating commerce and with regard to taxation, but has generally stood firm on the supremacy of the national government and the U.S. Constitution. In contemporary political debate, conservatives often point to the Tenth Amendment as a means of arguing in favour of restrictions on federal authority.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[deleted]

2

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20

I assume you're trying to be helpful, although in a bit of a dismissive way. But to err on a positive side I will assume you are trying to be helpful. So the Supremacy Clause:

https://law.justia.com/constitution/us/article-6/06-supremacy-clause-versus-tenth-amendment.html

Clause 2. This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby; any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.

...

Interpretations have changed, and more recently:

Until recently, it appeared that in fact and in theory the Court had repudiated this doctrine,34 but, in National League of Cities v. Usery,35 it revived part of this state police power limitation upon the exercise of delegated federal power. However, the decision was by a closely divided Court and subsequent interpretations closely cabined the development and then overruled the case.

...

https://constitutioncenter.org/interactive-constitution/interpretation/article-vi/clauses/31

Under the Supremacy Clause, the “supreme Law of the Land” also includes federal statutes enacted by Congress. Within the limits of the powers that Congress gets from other parts of the Constitution, Congress can establish rules of decision that American courts are bound to apply, even if state law purports to supply contrary rules. Congress also has at least some authority to put certain topics wholly off limits to state law, or otherwise to restrict what state law can validly say about those topics. As long as the directives that Congress enacts are indeed authorized by the Constitution, they take priority over both the ordinary laws and the constitution of each individual state.

So based off what I'm seeing, there have been more recent changes to the interpretation of the clause (as well as the 10th amendment itself). This does not invalidate what you are saying, just noting that interpretation is an important piece of how laws are retained or even modified if needed.

But...let's go back what what I'm referring to in my OP, the power of "Federal police"

https://law.justia.com/constitution/us/amendment-10/03-federal-police-power.html

In 1995, reversing this trend, the Court in United States v. Lopez43 struck down a statute prohibiting possession of a gun at or near a school, rejecting an argument that possession of firearms in school zones can be punished under the Commerce Clause because it impairs the functioning of the national economy. Acceptance of this rationale, the Court said, would eliminate “a[ny] distinction between what is truly national and what is truly local,” would convert Congress’s commerce power into “a general police power of the sort retained by the States,” and would undermine the “first principle” that the Federal Government is one of enumerated and limited powers.44 Application of the same principle led five years later to the Court’s decision in United States v. Morrison45 invalidating a provision of the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) that created a federal cause of action for victims of gender-motivated violence. Congress may not regulate “non-economic, violent criminal conduct based solely on that conduct’s aggregate effect on interstate commerce,” the Court concluded. “[W]e can think of no better example of the police power, which the Founders denied the National Government and reposed in the States, than the suppression of violent crime and vindication of its victims.”46

Notwithstanding these federal inroads into powers otherwise reserved to the states, the Court has held that Congress could not itself undertake to punish a violation of state law; in United States v. Constantine,47 a grossly disproportionate excise tax imposed on retail liquor dealers carrying on business in violation of local law was held unconstitutional. However, Congress does not contravene reserved state police powers when it levies an occupation tax on all persons engaged in the business of accepting wagers regardless of whether those persons are violating state law, and imposes severe penalties for failure to register and pay the tax.48

So what this really comes down to. Are these "federal officers" responding to a localized issue, or national issue? And if it is a national issue or crime, what is it? What laws specifically are being followed? The Supremacy Clause still has the limitation of only allowing what is Constitutional, correct? Are we on the same page there at least? So if you have actions that are violating at least four amendments, any one of those violations makes the action unlawful, even unconstitutional. It therefore invalidates the Supremacy Clause (in my view here) as it exceeds the powers granted by the constitution, and furthermore if this is being done under a federal law of any kind, yet done in a way that violates the constitution, then it also violates the 10th Amendment, which has been interpreted (above) that local law enforcement activities, are among those specifically reserved to the states or the people.

17

u/Sam-Culper Jul 25 '20

It's both a crime scene and a misleading title as far as I can tell. That's not the voice of someone wearing a gasmask which all of the police/mercs are wearing.

18

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

You are correct. That is the voice of a protester very near the camera, not one of the guys picking shit up. The title of the article is a lie. Things are plenty bad without resorting to this.

2

u/endubs Jul 25 '20

Seriously, and it looks like the guy was just looking for something, not trying to "clean up evidence". This is what happens when information becomes condensed and manufactured.

8

u/mr_robbotic Jul 25 '20

Yeah, that’s a good point. When I listened to it again, it’s definitely not by someone who is wearing a mask. Your voice is incredibly muffled if you have a proper seal. Even if you yell, it still doesn’t carry very much. For this, it’s unclear who yelled it, but I’d also be curious if he isn’t doing exactly that.

4

u/Sam-Culper Jul 25 '20

I agree It does look like he's picking up expended munitions

2

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy."

284

u/DJEB Jul 25 '20

At least there is employment out there for people who are too stupid to know that cameras exist.

143

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

The cameras don’t matter.

16

u/DankNerd97 Community Ally Jul 25 '20

They don’t care. They know they’re being filmed, and they know they’re essentially immune from consequence.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[deleted]

45

u/DJEB Jul 25 '20

That’s not entirely true. They often get paid vacation ti... er, I mean administrative leave.

6

u/AceValentine Jul 25 '20

Follow police home. They know where you live, it's only fair to know where they live. Don't advocate violence just free information.

7

u/iCrytek Jul 25 '20

Time to kill them too

148

u/bjorn1978_2 Jul 25 '20

Protesters should start collecting these. The police obviously have an interrest in these... and that alone is enough reason for protesters to collect them. Post pictures of stamped data from them on instagram or somewhere. If something is found that turns out to be of media interrest, it can be left for the media at an agreed location.

Do you think they are collecting these out of the goodnes in their hart, or because they are trying to cover up something??

107

u/BipolarSyndicalist Jul 25 '20

People have been arrested for picking them up lmao

46

u/Carvinrawks Jul 25 '20

Wait, can I get in trouble for theft if I steal their bullets with my ripped and torn flesh?

44

u/Thnewkid Jul 25 '20

You joke, but I heard an anecdote out of some authoritarian African country about a man being shot in a protest and the police arresting him from the hospital (or at home waiting to go back to the hospital) while he was waiting for a surgery to remove the bullet. They tried to get him to sign some papers and undergo surgery with their doctor so that they could get the bullet back so he wouldn’t have it as evidence of being shot by government agents.

11

u/Konukaame Jul 25 '20

There's also that story out of a some other country where a man was charged for bleeding on officers' uniforms after they beat him.

8

u/A70m5k Jul 26 '20

The NYPD recently arrested a homeless man for assaulting their fist with his face.

https://champ.gothamist.com/champ/gothamist/news/cops-punch-homeless-man-subway-then-charge-him-assault

1

u/Carvinrawks Jul 26 '20

Looks like that got dismissed, thankfully.

Disgusting.

41

u/gorpie97 Jul 25 '20

On what grounds??? If the cops don't want them picked up, then perhaps they shouldn't litter in the first place.

75

u/BipolarSyndicalist Jul 25 '20

On what grounds? Whatever they choose to make up lol. Legal acountability is long gone.

1

u/gorpie97 Jul 25 '20

The troops don't mean we aren't (supposed to be) a nation of laws. Habeas corpus still applies, so there needs to be grounds for arrest, even if it's a new, made up thing.

18

u/DankNerd97 Community Ally Jul 25 '20

Because the cops just want a reason to assert dominance.

1

u/gorpie97 Jul 25 '20

Yes, that's why. But that doesn't explain how they try to explain it.

13

u/Oldkingcole225 Jul 25 '20

Lol dude are you seriously still pretending we live in a country where cops need to follow any kind of law? These guys are breaking laws every 10 seconds. Trump doesn’t care.

1

u/gorpie97 Jul 26 '20

In my area of the country they do. I'd assume they still need a justification in PDX as well - even if it's a brand new thing and mostly made up.

EDIT: I live in the rural part of a rural state now, but miss Portland! But am glad I wouldn't be living downtown at the moment!

27

u/paralleliverse Jul 25 '20

So I remember an army guy telling me he had to do this and he'd get in a shit load of trouble if he lost one. I don't remember why. I think it either has something to do with keeping track of your ammo count or maybe it was a money thing, like they got some money from the supplier for trading in the shells.

27

u/gorpie97 Jul 25 '20

If the guy who said "Leave no evidence behind" was one of them, then using the term "evidence" disputes this idea. But it's not obvious who said it.

11

u/paralleliverse Jul 25 '20

I can't play with sound right now, but other commenters seem to think it's the cameraman saying it.

8

u/gorpie97 Jul 25 '20

Yes, because the gas masks would muffle sound too much. But they also say it's not good enough quality to be sure. (So I'm going with "not the soldiers" at the moment. Just pointing out the words.)

17

u/KacerRex Jul 25 '20

Brass can be reloaded, so you collect it up to re-use it. Other than that, it's accountability, you can't have ammo floating around, that's dangerous for obvious reasons. We would actually get in a fair bit of trouble if we still had rounds after turn in.

7

u/RagingBillionbear Jul 25 '20

or because they are trying to cover up something??

I bet it's because it's got made somewhere in America on it.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

Now there's an idea

5

u/fancydecanter Jul 25 '20

They try. The shells are very hot for awhile, and if an area has been gassed it’s because the cops are trying to clear it so it’s often necessary to move away before they’ve cooled enough to bag. There seems to be an increasing effort to pick off and arrest people that hang back to pick up the spent munitions.

3

u/cnelsonsic Jul 25 '20

Protestors have been gathering spent casings when they can.

3

u/elcapitan520 Jul 25 '20

This is all being done

4

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

Because they are not just firing tear gas balls out of the splat ball guns?

The lead filled rubber wrapped bullets from their "less lethal" ammo would fit in one.

-7

u/APwinger Jul 25 '20

I have heard (unsourced) that there have been expired canisters and that they apparently can turn into cyanide gas when expired.

5

u/LostGundyr Jul 25 '20

“But experts said the levels of cyanide found in tear gas are unlikely to cause any immediate harm.”

You’re fine.

3

u/elcapitan520 Jul 25 '20

A local reporter, one that was arrested for recognizing a PPB officer and calling him by name, has an unspent can of CS gas shot by the feds. Expiration is 5 years. The manufacture date is 2007. You can take down your unconfirmed tag. Twitter: @ therealcoryelia

5

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

Can we not spread complete bullshit please?

There’s enough of it floating around, we don’t need to add more.

3

u/mullett Jul 25 '20

The expired tear gas is real. Portland police were using until the feds stepped in with a bountiful fresh supply.

1

u/bjorn1978_2 Jul 25 '20

And that needs to be documented!

39

u/anickel120 Jul 25 '20

The person shouting "Leave no evidence behind" is a protestor standing behind the camera man. But yea this is still sketch. I read that this could also be them trying not to leave live rounds on the ground. Or unexploded tear gas/smoke bombs, but regardless fuck the feds

4

u/CeleryStickBeating Jul 25 '20

Or fingerprints.

18

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20

"Land of the brave, home of the free"

20

u/Beard3dtaco Jul 25 '20

At what point does a rational human began to realize "are we the baddies?"

10

u/DankNerd97 Community Ally Jul 25 '20

“No...it’s everyone else that’s the problem!”

24

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

Look I'm all for exposing atrocities and fighting back against them, but this doesn't seem like an officer yelling that...

The two are standing next to each other and have no need to yell, and the "leave no evidence behind" was much clearer than it could likely be from an officer in a facemask...

12

u/LaserGuidedPolarBear Jul 25 '20

I dont really think the words are what is important here. I've been attacked by police enough to know that picking up spent ammunition and casings is not normal. Hell in June someone in my city picked up several.garbage bags worth and dropped it off at the police precinct with a passive aggressive note.

The fact that they are picking up after themselves and possibly arresting people for picking them up (not sure if that is confirmed)....that shows nefarious intent all by itself.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

TRUMP’S AMERICA

5

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

Just want to clarify that I don't in any way support federal operations happening in Portland, Chicago, and the like. I do, however, think that it's possible this video is being misconstrued. They're probably taking the rounds specifically so that they CAN be accounted for.

Everyone knows what happened there, and there are multiple videos of the line they formed to push protesters away from the courthouse. Why would they be trying to downplay the use of gas if it's all caught on video?

4

u/Kflynn1337 Jul 25 '20

If you're concealing evidence, then it's usually a sign you're doing something you shouldn't.

9

u/fancydecanter Jul 25 '20

If you watch, they’re only picking up certain ones.. They pick up, inspect, and either drop it back on the ground or keep it depending what it is.

It’s not just about volume... They’re using munitions they’re not supposed to use.

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 25 '20

Welcome to /r/2020PoliceBrutality.

If you wish to contribute by anonymously sharing incidents that you've come across either in-person/IRL or in your feed, please fill out the following form: https://forms.gle/Npcykamuqz8UEcE58

As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion of police abuse of power.

While the content is by nature somewhat inflammatory and disturbing, calls for violence will not be tolerated as they violate site-wide rules and could result in this subreddit being quarantined or banned. The purpose of this subreddit is to raise awareness of the events discussed here, so any actions which threaten the ability of the subreddit to continue operating will not be tolerated and will result in an immediate permanent ban.

A note: we are downloading all videos to our local media and to our repository.

Relevant Links

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/MiketheImpuner Jul 25 '20

I can’t tell if it is a cop of protestor saying it.

3

u/trash-juice Jul 25 '20

Criminals leave ‘evidence’ in the commission of crimes, they’re a gang

3

u/bush_killed_epstein Jul 25 '20

After seeing this, I had a crazy idea. What if someone put together an app that allows people to log projectiles (tear gas, rubber bullets, etc) by taking a picture? It would take time and location into account to prevent redundancies. If enough people used it, you could create charts of how many projectiles were used against people every day/week/month. It seems like there is no comprehensive database of just how many of these things are being used

6

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

That’s the cutest lil baby agent I’ve ever seen. I wanna put em in mah pockettttt

2

u/Yukisuna Jul 25 '20

Are they TRYING to sound as evil as possible? At this point there’s no way they haven’t realized that they’re acting like cliché movie bad guys.

2

u/dedicated2fitness Jul 25 '20

man this larping is out of control

2

u/ReyTheRed Jul 25 '20

If you care about the safety of cops, hold them accountable now, because if they keep pushing their luck, the uniform alone will be considered enough of a threat to require defense with lethal force.

2

u/SayLem37 Jul 25 '20

Why are all of the clips from Portland only 30 seconds long? Surely there are more extensive clips available to see, but i can't seem to find any. Just little snippets.

3

u/piptimbers Jul 25 '20

Devil's advocate and all but isn't it standard practice to pick up spent cannisters? I've been fortunate in that I've never personally experienced tear gas, but when the RCMP raided a drug lab in my girlfriend's apartment block they sent somebody to recover spent flashbangs. I can understand the "no evidence" narrative but in my experience its been happening for years.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

American police don’t really do courtesy

4

u/piptimbers Jul 25 '20

I don't think it's a courtesy thing, I think it's legitimately a function of how the police operate, for better or worse.

1

u/dedicated2fitness Jul 25 '20

yeah the cannisters are expensive

2

u/cantbreathe444 Jul 25 '20

this is so scary

-3

u/Milk_My_Dingus Jul 25 '20

That’s what they (they media) want you to feel. This is so obviously a false narrative as it is clear as day that some protestor yelled that from behind the camera somewhere. You wouldn’t be able to hear them that clearly from behind the masks and it sounds as if that was an accusatory statement not someone giving an order. But for people who want to be scared, they will hear whatever fits the narrative. Come on man you are better than being fed an obvious lie.

2

u/StitOrange Jul 25 '20

mans been watching too much fox i’m dead

-1

u/Milk_My_Dingus Jul 25 '20

I don’t watch a second of fox but it’s obvious this was not the police. Sounds like a 20 year old yelling it because he thinks that’s what they are doing. kEeP wATcHinG CnN

1

u/aequitas3 Jul 26 '20

You're parroting talking points from the literal biggest cable news outlet and literal biggest Facebook news outlet, though. Fox and the Daily Wire. At least you're not doing that while railing against the MSM lol

1

u/Milk_My_Dingus Jul 26 '20

What talking points? You can tell this dude yelling this sounds like he’s 20 and not wearing a respirator and it comes from off camera not in front of it. Y’all act like view points you don’t like are not valid simply because you don’t like them and they sound like something apparently you watched on msm.

1

u/aequitas3 Jul 26 '20

Lol there it is. Guy using MSM talking points from the literal 2 biggest outlets and then unironically complaining about the MSM, even after I praised you for not being contradictory by doing that lmao

1

u/Milk_My_Dingus Jul 26 '20

Where did I say anything about me watching or complaining about msm? I don’t have a clue what you are saying. I criticized what you said and apparently that’s a msm view point now. Convenient you can change the subject and attack me for something I have no clue what you are talking about

1

u/knoam Jul 25 '20

According to the original narrative, the guy is shouting to his guys, so of course you'd be able to hear him. So either you or the original narrative is spreading disinformation, so I have to agree that the whole situation is scary.

2

u/Redd_Monkey Jul 25 '20

Is it me or they forgot that everyone now has a camera on them at all time and they are constantly filmed... Its like : nobody will know we used force if we hide the evidence.

-What about the cameras?

-The what now?

2

u/Needleroozer Jul 25 '20

You keep misspelling "terrorists."

2

u/Decenrad Jul 25 '20

That “leave no evidence behind” was to clear to come from a someone wearing a gas mask. It’s the person recording or someone around them who said that. Common sense here kids

2

u/log609 Jul 25 '20

Isn’t there a law about tampering with evidence?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

At... Least they aren't littering..? Fuck. Idk. I'm trying to find a bright side but the reality is the whole concept of "police" at this point should be disassembled and power washed.

1

u/JerkyWaffle Jul 25 '20

These are really crappy people. =(

1

u/jackandjill22 Jul 25 '20

1

u/VredditDownloader Approved Bot Jul 25 '20

beep. boop. 🤖 I'm a bot that helps downloading videos

Download via reddit.tube

If I don't reply to a comment, send me the link per PM.

Download more videos from 2020PoliceBrutality


Info | Contact Dev

1

u/rustandbones Jul 25 '20

I dont think the cops said "make sure to get all the evidence" as it looks as if all the cops have gas masks on.. they're still absolutely wrong

1

u/mixingu Jul 25 '20

These aren't the police

1

u/boopbopnotarobot Jul 25 '20

Do they really think they got their brutality hidden so well that we don't already know they're brutalizing people? Whats the point of even trying hide this; it's hardly a secret?

1

u/lockitup-stage5cling Jul 25 '20

Got gassed downtown last night in front of the courthouse, not fun stuff. Tons of people

1

u/JRPaperstax Jul 26 '20

Insane how many “conservatives” are cheering this on. If you support this, you can no longer call yourself a conservative. Being conservative would imply that you adhere to a set of principles, things like small government and states rights. As soon as you support federal officers attacking and detaining people because of their political opinions, you aren’t conservative, you’re just a pathetic, spineless Trump groupie.

1

u/sasha_baron_of_rohan Jul 26 '20

Y'all reaching pretty hard on this one.

1

u/Driver8666-2 Jul 26 '20

Most dangerous weapon in the world at work, a camera.

1

u/mediadivides4profit Jul 28 '20

You got it wrong. Protestors are picking up shell casings from shootings between protestors.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

You're telling me there are police manipulating data to suit their narrative. Never!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

Wait is this live ammunition?

2

u/DankNerd97 Community Ally Jul 25 '20

If it were, we would have heard about it. I’d be flabbergasted if not a single major news source reported that otherwise.

1

u/Jedi_Bacon Jul 25 '20

I was wondering that. They were firing at the rioters and no one showed that part?

1

u/IdiotsAreStupid Jul 25 '20

It was probably shouted from the person filming. Sounded far too clear given the apparatus the guys are wearing on their faces.

1

u/Web_peasant36421 Jul 25 '20

Don’t think that was the police who said that big fella.

0

u/jbrux86 Jul 26 '20

Most people are peaceful protesters, but enough are also asshats making it harder on the good protesters.

Fight your government by replacing your representatives.

If you don’t like your government get off your ass and BE A CITIZEN. Take part in local government. Go to city council meetings. Make your voice heard through conversation and discussion.

I would ignore a 2 year old screaming at me or a 30 year old screaming at me too. Sadly law enforcement is not as nice as I am. They don’t ignore it, they try to stop it.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20 edited Jul 26 '20

I’m sure this won’t be a popular comment but I think this is somewhat of a stretch. Ironically, this is is what is known as a police call. It usually entails a large portion of the lower enlisted or all uniforms, to go and retrieve any expended shell casing from the environment.

All the gas canisters that were launched were more than likely documented on camera anyhow. I hate these fascist fucks too but we shouldn’t just pull claims out of our ass as it just ends up discrediting our movement in the long run.

-14

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

Can someone explain to me why Portland protests are so off the rails? Is this just a case of people without any work? Portland is wayyyyyy liberal and progressive. They seem to be the last city which needs social protests like this.

19

u/Rayvok Jul 25 '20

Things were petering out until the abduction and unmarked vehicles went viral. Until then DHS were staying mostly next to their own buildings.

The police beutality in response to their union building being a subject of protest also reignited protests in late June which included egregious assaults on journalists. This kept things ripe for the battle of July 4th which featured a firework bombardment on the federal courthouse and an increase in federal presence.

Those are some of the key highlights as to how, it kept being such a big thing for so long.

2

u/cuspacecowboy86 Jul 25 '20

Well said!

Also "police beutality" made me chuckle, thanks!

3

u/Rayvok Jul 25 '20

Lol, my thumbs are a bit clumsy on the mobile keyboard so I often have to go back and fix stuff. I probably shouldn't worry about that type of typo this far down.

5

u/pandaeatbambo0 Jul 25 '20

IMO, Portland has white people who are progressive enough to actually protest for the length that they have. I honestly, can't think of another major city protesting for this length of time.

-7

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

I feel like these protests would be more impactful in like LA. Being in already super progressive Portland just seems like preaching g to the choir. It’s like holding a Bernie Sanders ca Paige rally in Vermont. Just seems kind of like wasted energy

IMO Portland is more about people bored with life looking for excitement and purpose, with nothing else to do.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20 edited Jul 25 '20

Portland’s PD is notoriously cozy with fascist movements, in spite of the city’s “progressive” image. That’s why Portland is ripe for anti-police demonstrations, it’s a hotbed for police abuse, and has a department that actively collaborated with far right agitators, many of whom come from outside the city.

https://www.wweek.com/news/courts/2019/02/14/texts-between-portland-police-and-patriot-prayer-ringleader-joey-gibson-show-warm-exchange/

https://theintercept.com/2019/08/16/portland-far-right-rally/

https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.huffpost.com/us/entry/us_5bc5e853e4b0d38b5871be1b/amp

-2

u/Justinian_Kaes Jul 25 '20

So now not wanting to litter is a crime?

Man, these cops can't catch a break!

-5

u/oppe1 Jul 25 '20

They are literally cleaning the streets up lol

0

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[deleted]

78

u/FarHarbard Jul 25 '20

Yeah, that was an awfully clear shout to be coming from within a respirator.

12

u/Un1337ninj4 Jul 25 '20

What, are they're not wearing respirators?

12

u/FarHarbard Jul 25 '20

The cops are, not the protesters.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[deleted]

8

u/FarHarbard Jul 25 '20

Clearly the protester recording wasn't, his voice is way too clear.

1

u/endubs Jul 25 '20

No they don't, most wear masks but not respirators.

1

u/mapdumbo Jul 26 '20

Many protesters now wear respirators and full face gas masks

2

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

What? It's absolutely coming from somewhere other than behind the camera. It'd be much louder, not muffled and wouldn't sound far away.

21

u/RLRR_LRLL_ Jul 25 '20

I honestly can't tell who said it. This video isn't good enough evidence that they said this for me to acknowledge. I mean ACAB still, but I'll need better evidence to accept that they are doing this in an official capacity.

13

u/parliamentofcats Jul 25 '20

I don't know. I think it still could've been one of the officers.

That said, it's definitely not clear enough to attribute to anyone. Claiming the cop said it is misleading and pushes a narrative that we really don't need false/unclear evidence to push.

10

u/TeamRedundancyTeam Jul 25 '20

Come on guys. I like this sub but no one should have fallen for this lie for a second. Everyone should have questioned this and saw through it and reported it. It's very clearly not the police yelling this, why would they even yell this in the first place. Mods need to do their job and get rid of outright lying titles.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20 edited Jul 25 '20

This sub keeps getting hijacked by morons

3

u/Milk_My_Dingus Jul 25 '20

There are a lot of people who will knowingly lie and see it as justified because they think the cause is more important than being truthful. It’s sad

2

u/The_Bravinator Jul 25 '20

It really would make very little sense for then to be audibly yelling about hiding the evidence.

1

u/MarcGregSputnik Jul 25 '20

Disappointed in this sub that I had to scroll so far to find any scrutiny.

Not sure it was the person recording, sounded too muffled. But perhaps they were sensible and were wearing a mask.

But it is not immediately apparent that it was a police-person shouting it.

1

u/knoam Jul 25 '20

Then what was he picking up? It's not just what was said. It matches the behavior I saw him doing.

2

u/jarsnazzy Jul 26 '20

Of course he is still doing something sketchy, which is why the person yelled "leave no evidence", but it wasnt the police shouting it, as OP claims

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

It's hard to tell and since the story in the title is not fully believable it's safe to assume they are not picking up canisters for the purpose of hiding how many they've fired.

-12

u/scubasme Jul 25 '20

Sensationalism at its finest.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[deleted]

13

u/NeverLookBothWays Jul 25 '20

Yea really hurts the mission here too using misleading/incorrect headlines. I mean, without the shouting part, this is exactly what these militant forces are doing, they're covering up their tracks. If we were just looking at that, it is damning enough...but now it is muddied by a false narrative added to it.

To me, the falsehood here is easily filtered out and I see this for what it is. But not everyone is able to filter out noise and retain the key issues. They instead throw the whole thing out (baby with the bathwater). This is one of our biggest challenges too, as it's a type of strawman reasoning that is pushing the outcomes of elections, and is the type of strawman reasoning that is enabling this form of fascism. Be vigilant, objective, and rooted in reality folks. It's a long and painful fight ahead.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

They have identification sometimes and when they do it isn't enough to identify the person. It's plausible deniability for them.

"One of the officers hit me and ruptured my eye!"
"Oh yeah, which one?"
Done.

1

u/masuabie Jul 26 '20

Ask any of them for a name or badge number.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/masuabie Jul 26 '20

But that’s not what you said.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/masuabie Jul 26 '20

Ha. All Halloween stores sell those exact "identification."

5

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/knoam Jul 25 '20

Even easier than making a fake badge is making up a fake name and badge number.

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/DenverNick Jul 25 '20

Police impersonators are not rare at all. Google it and there are recent stories about it all over the country.