r/2020PoliceBrutality • u/princesshabibi Community Ally • Jul 09 '20
News Update Breonna Taylor’s Family Claims She Was Alive After Shooting but Given No Aid
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/06/us/breonna-taylor-lawsuit-claims.amp.html38
Jul 09 '20
Should I be surprised?
74
u/princesshabibi Community Ally Jul 09 '20
No but it’s a reminder that she was murdered in her sleep by cops at the wrong house. The person the cops were looking for was already in jail.
-38
Jul 09 '20
That’s not the case according to what the police say. Obviously they could be lying, that wouldn’t surprise me in the slightest, but according to the latest info Taylor‘s house was the house they were trying to go to.
https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/07/us/breonna-taylor-lawsuit-gentrification/index.html
56
u/princesshabibi Community Ally Jul 09 '20
Well according to the police report her injuries were NONE but actually she got shot at with 22 rounds. 8 bullets hit her.
23
Jul 09 '20
Damn. It’s insane that these idiots think they can lie and nobody will notice
5
u/princesshabibi Community Ally Jul 10 '20
Now is not the time to blindly trust them and assume they are trustworthy. It’s time to defund and educate on human compassion and civil rights.
15
Jul 09 '20
Not really. As a society we haven't given them any reason to believe it wouldn't work like it has every other time over their entire careers.
5
1
u/Churosuwatadade Jul 10 '20
Well why do idiots like you still give them the benefit of the doubt every time?
3
Jul 10 '20
Who said I’m giving them the benefit of the doubt? I’m just saying what the official lawsuit and police affidavit said. There’s no argument they were in the wrong in killing her
1
u/Churosuwatadade Jul 10 '20
2
Jul 10 '20
You mean the comment when I said this is info according to the police and said they could be lying and I wouldn’t be surprised?
-2
8
u/MorddSith187 Jul 10 '20
From what I’ve read, they were at the house listed on the warrant. But the reason why it was listed was wrong. From what I remember, the warrant was issued because of suspicious mail but the post office concluded there was no suspicious mail yet police proceeded anyway. So technically they were at the correct address as listed on the warrant, but the reason the warrant was issued at all was incorrect. So they shouldn’t have been there at all.
9
u/GreatCornolio Jul 10 '20
This happened to my step uncle in police custody. Died in a cell receiving no medical attention for gunshot wounds.
1
u/princesshabibi Community Ally Jul 11 '20
I’m so sorry for your loss. 😢 I’m sick of them doing this. It’s so heartbreaking. The prison is filled with Covid 19. They dehumanize people so much in the prison system.
33
u/MrBigChest Jul 09 '20
I imagine the cops would have faced more punishment if she had survived.
69
u/princesshabibi Community Ally Jul 09 '20
The boyfriend survived and they took him to jail after seeing his girlfriend get murdered.
15
Jul 09 '20
Why do you think that? Do you understand how qualified immunity works and that it’s almost impossible to actually levy charges against cops?
6
Jul 10 '20 edited Feb 25 '24
vase dull point sip zephyr treatment weather swim chop plough
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
1.1k
u/Filomianor Jul 09 '20
Regardless of if she could've been saved, she was lying there, multiple shots, scared out of her mind and in what I can only imagine unthinkable pain for 6 whole minutes, and realising help was NOT on the way. 6 minutes may seem a short time, but I bet it felt like years to her.
592
u/joshuajackson9 Jul 09 '20
The last thing she knew was she was not worth the police officers time to help her.
745
Jul 09 '20
And the police are not worth our help. Defund those fuckers and never give them any respect. Fucking murderers.
50
u/Hatesredditmods Jul 09 '20
They aren't worth their own lives at this point imho. Unfortunately, we are better than them, and they will have their day in court unlike ms Taylor
8
u/TheHoofer Jul 10 '20
All the Constitution-thumping ALMers seem to have forgotten the 6th amendment
14
Jul 10 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
10
u/KissMyGoat Jul 10 '20
'No civil police force could hold out against an irate and resolute population. The trick is not to let them realize that.' - Terry Pratchett
2
u/TheCrazyComet Jul 10 '20
But, what if defunding the police reduces their quality even more? Why not tear the police force down and build from the ground up?
11
u/2_lazy Jul 10 '20
Ideally it would mean they wouldn’t be able to afford military grade weaponry anymore and the money could go to programs that actually help their communities. Unfortunately bureaucracy makes the tear everything down and rebuild method essentially impossible. I think it’s going to be a long, slow process and the police unions will be fighting every step of the way.
3
u/TheCrazyComet Jul 10 '20
True. That’s the saddest part. More meaningless casualties and death because of them having too much power.
1
u/Shadeleovich Jul 10 '20
But most of the police military shit comes from the military, it’s outdated equipment that the military sells to PDs for really low pricing. The corrupt police chiefs, if defunded, wont reduce military equipment, but will just reduce training costs. Imo the police force of the US needs a complete restructuring. And it should work like here in Europe where police goes to a sort of college for several years and get mental and reactionary testing every couple of months to evaluate if they’re still fit to serve
0
Jul 10 '20
[deleted]
1
u/TheCrazyComet Jul 11 '20
I think that would depend on how much money is going to the police and where it’s going. We don’t know how much money they have yet.
0
0
Jul 09 '20
[deleted]
19
u/austinwer Jul 09 '20
Lmao he literally said defund he didn’t even say abolish chill
0
Jul 09 '20
[deleted]
15
u/RockStarState Jul 09 '20
Defunding police and putting that money towards better communities and creating opportunities for the people who would become part of for profit prisons is the goal.
Police are a band-aid for misguided funding. They are still needed, they just don't usually look like the monstrosity that Americas police force has become.
2
u/2_lazy Jul 10 '20
Profitable prisons was literally the south’s response to the end of slavery. They still needed free farm laborers so they arrested just about any black person they could on often false or petty charges, hiked up the sentences, and payed them pennies on the hour for hard labor on plantations as part of the prison work. This is still how many prisons do it today. Except now in addition to plantations some prisoners also work in what amounts to manufacturing sweat shops for multi billion dollar corporations. They could afford to pay the prisoners more than a few cents per hour, they just don’t want to.
0
Jul 09 '20
[deleted]
15
u/RockStarState Jul 09 '20
.....the fact that you got "minorities" from "communities" and "those who would end up in for profit prisons" does miles more to show your racism and classism than I ever could.
Bravo. Also, racists are inherently stupid in my book so I'm sticking to the defunding plan.
0
18
Jul 09 '20
Always find it funny when people think "defund the police" means just take the money away. You put that money towards other social services where the workers aren't sociopaths with a license to kill. Police forces are riddled with white supremacists too. Do we just retrain them to not be racist? No, we need other people going on wellness checks, not members of the KKK. You are dumb as fuck if you think retraining is the answer. Lol "different approach to citizens", I'm sure racist cops will change in a heartbeat when told they are in the wrong. Fucking idiot.
10
u/LazerHawkStu Jul 09 '20
Exactly. America spends $100 billion a year on police and another $80 billion a year incarcerating people. The police have about $8 billion worth of military grade equipment. Our taxes also go towards paying around $300 million per year for Police misconduct lawsuits...then some of our major cities dish out $500-$800ish million per year to settle some of those lawsuits. I'm pretty sure we can move some money around.
0
Jul 09 '20
[deleted]
7
u/betaleg Jul 09 '20
That’s the police brutality version of “I’m can’t possibly be racist, I have a black friend.”
0
Jul 09 '20
[deleted]
4
u/betaleg Jul 09 '20
Yes, it really is. Like super ultra very much. Are there statistics that indicate white people are killed at a disproportionately higher rate than black people? Those would be interesting to see. What’s petulant is pretending that since white people also get killed by the police, it’s a tacit indicator that there isn’t a problem with racism in policing. It’s lazy, and indicative of a lack of respect for the intelligence of whomever you’re trying to sell it to. The FBI was voicing concerns over this very issue as early 2006, as reported in this article from 2016.
6
u/ebplinth Jul 09 '20
Yeah police kill white people too much too, that's just more of a reason to defund them, there are better ways to deal with societies problems than with a gun. I dont think youre interested in that though, more interested in using whatever excuses you can to persecute people you don't like
4
u/itsgroovintime Jul 09 '20
No. Police are a tool of the justice system. As long as the government and the corporations that control it have an interest in controlling the populace, through exessive arrest and brutality, there will be arrests and brutality. The police are the problem. We have reformed and changed and shifted to the times. It obviously has not worked. Defunding does not mean abolishing. Police in America are beefed up to the point of small grade military. 'Defunding' is a pretty tame solution to such an awful and chronic problem. Policing would still suck, but with less power.
65
Jul 09 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
0
Jul 09 '20
[deleted]
45
u/Deipnosophist Jul 09 '20
If I were in his position I would wish I was dead. I can't imagine the pain and torment he must be enduring right now.
67
u/hormondoc Jul 09 '20
Brett Hankinson and his buddies planned to rape Ms. Taylor. They expected her to be alone. It’s the only way the events make any sense.
103
u/crypticedge Jul 09 '20
There was a different theory I read earlier this week, in that the police were actually weaponized by a land developer against her and her ex, who used her as an example to try to force her ex to sell his property 10 miles away, because he was the only hold out on a plan to tear down and build a new high priced development.
This gains a degree of validity due to them showing up there looking for the ex, for no good reason, with a dubious no knock warrant.
48
u/SmileLikeAphexTwin Jul 09 '20
I'd be interested in reading further on this because that's an even darker reason for this tragedy. Not incompetent government forces but what is essentially government backed extortion. Source?
58
u/crypticedge Jul 09 '20
The city bought it for $1 to make that developer happy a few days ago.
15
u/keetykeety Jul 10 '20
Can someone explain how the city was able to buy the house and at such a low price.
32
u/crypticedge Jul 10 '20
The theory is this (note! this is not proven, this is purely the line of thinking)
The city used the police to put pressure on both Breonna's ex and his landlord by executing a no knock raid against Breonna's home "looking" for Breonna's ex who was "wanted" on a dubious drug related investigation. This no knock raid deliberately resulted in her death (property value loss, future rental potential loss)
The result of this was then used to pressure the ex to move or face the same fate (breaking the lease, at financial expense to himself) and the threat of the same happening to future renters to the same property if it's not sold. Landlord sees property value already basically in the toilet, arranges an under the table agreement to go along with it, so long as the city officially reports it as $1, so he/she can avoid the taxes on the sale. Landlord gets more than a buck, but it comes out of some other source or benefit.
Soon, the city will either start a plaza project for gentrification or the entire collection of homes picked up in off the books operations either through threats or actual murder will be sold to a developer who will knock the homes down, build 600k+ condos and the wheels of capitalism will be properly greased with the blood of innocents once again.
28
u/LiquidMotion Jul 09 '20
That is way more common than you'd think. Corporations use cops to shake people down all the time.
14
u/ccbeastman Jul 10 '20
in fact, public police forces were established more or less for that exact purpose. Pinkertons in the north and slave-patrols in the south. in the case of the Pinkertons, the capitalist class sought a way to offload the expense of their private security onto the public, so they found a way to institutionalize their strike-busters (the Pinkertons) into a codified gang of public police.
16
3
u/FracturedEel Jul 09 '20
Darker than rape?
8
2
u/Mike_Kermin Jul 09 '20
That's almost certainly not what he meant. He's saying that he considers it concerning if a violent crime is committed to control people for profit.
So, on top of all the normal concerns with violent crime, not instead of it.
6
1
u/INeverAskedF0rThis Jul 12 '20
Isn't that the plot of LA Noire? I wouldn't doubt it. If I recall correctly, Michael Brown's death turned out years later to have been weaponized by the convenience store clerk who ripped Brown off in a marijuana deal.
4
72
59
u/unbelizeable1 Jul 09 '20
6 minutes may seem a short time
Put down your phone and just sit still for 6 minutes doing nothing. That feels like a long time and I'm in no sense of danger or anything. I can only imagine how it'd feel for someone going through what she did.
19
u/Filomianor Jul 09 '20
Pure terror and fear
12
u/Mike_Kermin Jul 09 '20
It would be torture, all you would want is safety and help and comfort and you'd get nothing. Just agonizing pain and fear.
It's unconscionable that someone go through this.
23
u/simjanes2k Jul 09 '20
6 minutes may seem a short time, but I bet it felt like years to her.
It was literally the rest of her life.
11
6
u/Adium Jul 09 '20
To add to that, even if the coroner is correct, no one on the scene in the moment knew she couldn't be saved. But I'd bet they knew if they did nothing, she would die.
5
u/draykow Jul 10 '20
I can confirm that time is different when you think you're gonna die. I got thrown off a motorcycle on the freeway and slid several dozen feet, and while I wasn't moving for more than three or four seconds, it felt like over a minute.
4
u/throwaway1239448 Jul 09 '20
What an awful scenario for that family and community to have to imagine
1
157
u/outline_link_bot Approved Bot Jul 09 '20
Breonna Taylor’s Family Claims She Was Alive After Shooting but Given No Aid
Decluttered version of this New York Times's article archived on July 06, 2020 can be viewed on https://outline.com/HFWWXh
13
6
81
u/shotputlover Jul 09 '20
I am sick and tired of police being inhuman robots that don’t give a fuck about the people that they are supposed to protect.
15
15
10
Jul 10 '20
That’s how the mafia operates, no witnesses
2
u/Isair81 Jul 10 '20
Dead people tell no tales after all. I’m sure they would have much preffered they’d killed everyone in the house, that way only their side of the story would be heard.
4
u/MorddSith187 Jul 10 '20
“The lawsuit also names an LMPD squad called Place Based Investigations as being part of the plans for the developments. They’re the same team noted on the warrants served on Taylor’s boyfriend.”
I’m having a hard time figuring out what this means. Is PBI an offshoot of the LMPD that can be rented out? And it was rented out to the development group ?
2
u/INeverAskedF0rThis Jul 12 '20
This is surprisingly common with police shootings. Just the other day, I watched video of police killing a black college student. Of course, everyone in the comments was calling it justified, but nobody acknowledged how the police just stood around for agonizing minutes shouting nonsense commands at the kid instead of helping him as he lay bleeding to death and begging for his life.
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 09 '20
Welcome to /r/2020PoliceBrutality.
If you wish to contribute by anonymously sharing incidents that you've come across either in-person/IRL or in your feed, please fill out the following form: https://forms.gle/Npcykamuqz8UEcE58
As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion of police abuse of power.
While the content is by nature somewhat inflammatory and disturbing, calls for violence will not be tolerated as they violate site-wide rules and could result in this subreddit being quarantined or banned. The purpose of this subreddit is to raise awareness of the events discussed here, so any actions which threaten the ability of the subreddit to continue operating will not be tolerated and will result in an immediate permanent ban.
A note: we are downloading all videos to our local media and to our repository.
Relevant Links
Github Repository: https://github.com/2020PB/police-brutality/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md#How-to-Contribute-1
Twitter: https://twitter.com/r2020PB
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/antagonizedgoat Jul 10 '20
No wonder aliens dont make contact with us. Look at how brutal we are. We are little more than evolved primates and we will all die on this planet.
0
Jul 10 '20
[deleted]
3
u/DangerousLoner Jul 10 '20
Calling 911 for medical attention will call the cops too. I’d rather call my Dad (Ex-Navy Corpman) or a neighbor Dr. than 911 if I was shot. Cops will just come kill you if they arrive before Firefighters or an Ambulance.
351
u/wageslavend Jul 09 '20
As a first responder, failure to render aid is a crime. Aren't the cops medically trained enough to be considered first responders?
I mean I get that the supreme Court said that there's no duty to protect but there is a duty to render aid if you are so trained, afaik.