r/TwoBestFriendsPlay • • Nov 19 '19

Geoff Keighley Confirms Game Awards Just an Excuse to Hangout With Hideo Kojima

https://thehardtimes.net/harddrive/geoff-keighley-confirms-that-the-game-awards-just-an-excuse-to-hangout-with-hideo-kojima/
1.1k Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

289

u/King_Allant "You fool, don't you understand? No one wishes to go on." Nov 19 '19 edited Nov 19 '19

This article is from The Hard Times, but I honestly bet he'd be happy to admit it if you asked him.

129

u/Astradael Nov 19 '19

As bad as stuff like the mountain dew and doritos halo thing can be, Geoff himself seems like a genuinely nice person that everyone loves. I know, dating myself with these names, that Kevin Peirera and Adam Sessler on Kevin's podcast talked about how after Adam was fired from G4, that him and Geoff had lunch together and just shot the shit.

59

u/BlargleVVargle Combined Luppy and Luppy... Nov 19 '19

He and Phil Spencer are in the same boat, so far as I can tell, where a lot of people view them as "gamer bro that corporations roll out so we'll think they get us", but both seem genuinely invested in and passionate about the medium of games as an art form. Could I do without some of the advertisement tie-ins with The Game Awards? Sure, but I'm also realistic about what it takes to get the funding for these kinds of productions.

31

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '19

Geoff was clearly not happy during the halo thing anyway. At least we got Pope Doritus out of it.

60

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '19

I agree, Geoff is really passionate about the industry and about the people who make these games. He catches a lot of flak but I've read some Game Informer articles about him and he comes across as a very sincere dude

51

u/Astradael Nov 19 '19

He's passionate, he's made some mistakes, but I can't honestly think of any real recent issues that he's been involved in. Seems like he's learned from the missteps and is genuinely wanting to improve the industry and perceptions of games as a whole.

39

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '19

For sure, I would honestly take someone who is clearly passionate, but stumbles, over someone who approaches games with clinical precision but is super corporate about it.

9

u/SilverKry Nov 20 '19

Hes a good sport about the doritos and mountain dew thing and I respect that.

15

u/Trachyon Nov 20 '19

Correct me if I'm wrong, but at one point I think Geoff was speaking in an interview with someone at Fox News who was claiming negativity against the sex bit in Mass Effect

Geoff was extremely passionate and eloquent when it came to defending the point, and looked visibly displeased at how his points were being brushed off by a pair of complete idiots. He's a reasonable person who clearly loves the craft he presents, I think.

10

u/Otogi Nov 19 '19

It feels weird that he gets criticized for it but the Monster product placement gets bupkis.

12

u/Astradael Nov 19 '19 edited Nov 20 '19

The big different is that one is a product placement throughout the entire piece of media that is supposed to be a review (same product that was also linked to the game in question halo 3 I think) so it reads as being a paid for review. Monster in death stranding (that's the thing I'm assuming you're talking about if not please correct me) is just in the game and is likely just a sponsor to help fund the game, no review involved. That's the thing I would think at least.

tl;dr it's the context, Geoff incident is seen as review being paid for by products linked directly to the game in question, monster is just a sponsor so it doesn't affect that actual product/review outcome.

2

u/N0VAZER0 Nov 20 '19

whats this about mountain dew and Doritos halo?

4

u/Astradael Nov 20 '19

Geoff did a review of halo 3 or reach or something along those lines on an interview set with a poster in the background, and bags of Doritos and bottles of Mountain Dew on a table, cause the video was sponsored by hose products. Those products were also linked to rewards/competition/codes for the game in question. Like double online exp or whatever. Maybe prizes I don’t remember. Point is a product with a sponsorship deal on the game also did one with Geoff for a review.

Now the game was good, but it’s hard to take a review sponsored by a company sponsoring the game in question seriously,

136

u/JakeIsNotGross Nov 19 '19

Hey, now! That's not all it is.

He also gets to hang out with Reggie.

29

u/Theproton BUSTAH WOLF! Nov 19 '19

I mean he use to.

16

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

Now he has to summon Reggie the same way we all do, by going to our local Pizza Hut’s restroom and saying “my body is ready” three times into the mirror.

2

u/Hawkbone CoD Zombies Loremaster Nov 20 '19

Reggie is still attending this year, isn't he?

226

u/BobTheTraitor Tiny Spider Feet Nov 19 '19

I feel like anyone who spends more than 10 minutes around Kojima ends up going on some strange and convoluted journey. Good luck trying to order food with him around.

112

u/Metatermin8r Office of Halo Intelligence Nov 19 '19

Kojima is a drug trip you don't even need to take anything to go on.

65

u/BlargleVVargle Combined Luppy and Luppy... Nov 19 '19

It's his Quirk, or his Stand. He just projects an AoE of his essence.

37

u/Ar3YouTh3Gat3K33p3r Nov 19 '19

His stand was originally [Space Oddity], but was then changed to [Way to Fall]

8

u/Canubearit Nov 20 '19

Using DOOM's he's able to pull chaos into this world.

3

u/Guardiansaiyan You only live TWICE Nov 20 '19

So its healthy, got it!

7

u/MegalomanicMegalodon Basking Shark Apologist Nov 20 '19

Like a Yakuza substory character lmao

60

u/Parzival1331 Nov 19 '19

Sooooo... Is Death Stranding going to be Game of the year, isn't it?

42

u/KLReviews Nov 19 '19

It's one of the nominees for game of the year at Keighley's show. Can't help that might be a conflict of interest on some level (friend of the director, hosted trailers for it, person running the show is in the game) but that won't stop them.

78

u/ginger_gaming Nov 19 '19

Keighley doesn't vote on the outcome, its a panel of independent industry judges including Jeff Gerstman, Jason Schrierer, I believe Austin Walker last year, and several others.

55

u/KLReviews Nov 19 '19

That's good to hear. Though I imagine Geoff Keighley giving an award to game featuring Geoff Keighley made by Geoff Keighley's friend is a situation they might want to avoid

14

u/lpeccap Nov 20 '19

Or just like...let it win goty if thats what the panel decides?

7

u/KLReviews Nov 20 '19 edited Nov 20 '19

Do that but don't have Keighley handle that part of the show. If it deserves to win then it shouldn't have the achievement marked by accidentally giving the impression this is a guy giving his arty friend a pat on the back. Even though I doubt that would have any impact on the judges.

5

u/mitch13815 Are you gonna be a fucking jiggysnipe too you fucking spag!? Nov 20 '19

I was about to say the same. Geoff is simply the host. He has no more power over the vote than an e-sports commentator.

I mean, I guess he could lie on stage, but that would get him fired, sued, and probably ruin his career and life.

13

u/SirPTF24 The Pat Foundation Nov 19 '19

The more pressing matter is that Famitsu gave it a Perfect 40... even though someone from Famitsu (I think the Editor-In-Chief) is in it

6

u/KLReviews Nov 20 '19

That's a real problem. That is normally the type of thing that would stops you from covering the game.

12

u/SirPTF24 The Pat Foundation Nov 20 '19

The guy (Famitsu's former editor-in-chief, but current head of their Publisher) straight up has a line of dialogue thats like "yknow, Sam, you're a cool guy, maybe one day, you'll end up in the porter Hall of Fame", which is also the name of Famitsu's Perfect 40 rated games

https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2019-11-11-death-strandings-famitsu-cameos-spark-questions-in-japan

2

u/SirPTF24 The Pat Foundation Nov 20 '19

I'm hard pressed to give them a tough time, though

Everyone would be screaming at them if it was the current Editor-In-Chief and if, yknow, Death Stranding sucked, but it is absolutely a 10/10 so eeeeeeehhhh

8

u/KLReviews Nov 20 '19

The fact he's the former editor in chief makes it better (still odd if he's involved in the publishing side but less of an issue). It is an odd situation to be in, especially with a game that is either a perfect masterpiece or deeply flawed depending on who is talking.

-1

u/KrustyKrabOfficial BIG CURSE Nov 20 '19

I'll never be able to take game awards seriously. Movie awards are bad enough.

5

u/dj_ian Zubaz Nov 20 '19

I loved DS, i definitely think it deserves the nomination, but Control and Outer Worlds were both great releases in their own right, especially Control which i'm seeing a lot of nintendo fans shitting on right now as the one that "took" Fire Emblem's spot. I think those three especially have the best chance of winning, but I doubt DS takes it.

0

u/DarthButtz Ginger Seeking Butt Chomps Nov 20 '19

Considering he's good enough friends with Kojima that he's IN the game, what do you think?

-10

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '19

not biased btw

21

u/King_Of_Regret Nov 19 '19

Considering gerstman is on the panel, i doubt itll make it. Plus like, while its my favorite game in a good long while, its not a wide reaching game of the year style game. Which is ok. Game of the year is lowest common denominator games, widest possible appeal.

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '19

Lowest common denominator? Sounds vaguely insulting. Also Witcher 3 and God of War won GOTY in the past and those games do not have the widest possible appeal

16

u/King_Of_Regret Nov 19 '19

I didnt mean it as a value judgement.

Witcher 3 and god of war absolutely were the biggest, widest appealing games for those years. The sales numbers were nuts. Theres certain types of game (multiplayer focused shooters for instance) that will never/very rarely get game of the year no matter the wide appeal. So as far as big budget single player games? Yeah witcher 3 and god of war were easily the winners there.

-6

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '19 edited Nov 19 '19

I would argue the games that have the largest reaching appeal ARE multiplayer focused shooters, of which Overwatch won GOTY the year it came out. A single player focused, slower-paced action game and a 100+ hour RPG aren't the same broad appeal as a GTA or Call of Duty

Edit: also, I double checked, God of War won over Red Dead Redemption 2, and Witcher 3 won over stuff like Fallout 4. RDR2 and Fallout were absolutely aimed at a broader audience. If GOTY was just about mass appeal, Nintendo would take the gold home every single time

The creator of GoW stated he was worried about whether it would be a hit or not, Witcher 3 was a risk. They weren't aimed at a broad audience, they found that audience because they were (shockingly) great games, your stance is kind of contradictory, imo.

4

u/King_Of_Regret Nov 19 '19

Which is why i pointed out that multiplayer focused shooters dont really count in goty award show discussions, despite their broad appeal. Overwatch was a farce.

Rdr2 absolutely was not a broad appeal game. Its a slow, plodding, oftentimes boring period piece, vs an actiony god romp with massive meme potential.

Witcher vs fallout 4 is a similar thing. Fallout is a decently hardcore rpg (not so much for 4, but the public sentiment is still there), and witcher is a simple gameplay, engaging narrative with enough action to keep your interest.

Intent doesn't matter, its the end product. And the end products were absolutely more wide appeal in witcher and GoW's case.

And before bias becomes an argument, I actually dislike all 4 games being discussed.

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '19

Fallout 4 sold 12 million copies in its opening 24 hours, it outsold Black Ops 3 in the same timeframes. You cannot realistically tell me that RDR2 wasn't going to sell because of the name of the game and the Rockstar logo alone, and they knew it. Also Fallout 4 isn't hardcore but that's a whole other argument.

RDR2, similarly, has sold double what God of War has sold. So if it's solely about popularity/sales/appeal, the numbers tell a different story. I mean, CD Projekt still isn't as big as EA or Ubisoft or Activision, so how would they have the same appeal as a long-standing franchise? Because they were objectively/subjectively better.

3

u/King_Of_Regret Nov 19 '19

Im starting to think you arent reading what I type. I specifically said fallout 4 wasnt hardcore. And sales isnt anything at all close to what i mean. Its "gamer" sentiment purely. There are a lot of extremely well selling games that are looked down upon and poorly selling games that everyone can agree are amazing.

-3

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '19 edited Nov 19 '19

And I'm starting to think you're moving goalposts. Widest appeal is pretty easy to understand, "gamer sentiment" is a murky, meaningless qualification. Unless you mean how it was received which... no shit? The game received well by most people... wins?

You start off saying that GOTY has only gone to widest appeal, lowest common denominator games. Wide appeal and lowest common denominator generally mean, most popular/best selling. There are at least two games that were less popular that the panel voted to win, and also performed well in public voting.

Then you say "well really widest appeal games would be shooters and those rarely win," so we're already sliding backwards. Also, you say you don't mean widest reaching = sales figures. But you pointed out that God of War and Witcher 3 sales figures were nuts. Before I corrected you about their competition selling better So, which is it then?

→ More replies (0)

15

u/Introspectre12 Think about it. Nov 19 '19

I wish he gave you the Ludens mask Die-Hardman wears like how you can get the otter hood from Conan.

11

u/baasnote Proud 13000FE Nov 19 '19

Didn't he actually say this tho?

24

u/Ringo_Roadagain7 Nov 19 '19

Who wouldn't do this?

2

u/DanteFTW Nov 19 '19

speaking of Geoff, there was a song written about him, https://youtu.be/5mrm9fQLNO0

2

u/N0VAZER0 Nov 20 '19

you cannot fucking tell me that this isn't a real story

2

u/Elias_Voorhees Resting Blackface Nov 20 '19

Let's not forget that time when he openly called out Konami we being the utter asshats that they are by banning Kojima to attend the Awards to receive a reward for a game HE made.

-5

u/jaygee101 Next time, I wont miss. Nov 19 '19

Is anyone a little irked that there’s an obvious bias for DS through Keighley?

I’m not saying DS doesn’t deserve it’s nomination and likely 5 or 6 awards it will win, for the most part it absolutely merits them, but it’s really obvious how unfair the advantage is in its favour when the creator of the awards is not only friends with the creator but in the game. Is that crazy to say or no?

24

u/lpeccap Nov 20 '19

Keighly. Doesnt. Vote.

17

u/AtomicVGZ Nov 20 '19

Nor is he part of the nomination process.

0

u/blazecc I Promise Nothing And Deliver Less Nov 21 '19

He owns the show and the voting is closed. It doesn't matter what the process is if he doesn't want to follow it.

-8

u/Rhotuz Nov 20 '19

Three Houses and DMCV got robbed. I'm just saying. DS will win GOTY because Geoff is Friends with Kojima. A riot will ensue. People die. Geoff apologizes, changes it to Sekiro. Everyone's happy

3

u/DrFoxWolf Succumb to the fantasy Nov 20 '19

Keighly doesn’t pick the winner. He created the show and hosts it but he doesn’t even nominate the games, let alone vote on them. On the judges panel are both Jeff Gerstman and Jason Schrierer, among others, who are some of the most trusted names in games media.

0

u/blazecc I Promise Nothing And Deliver Less Nov 21 '19

He owns the show and the voting is closed. It doesn't matter what the process is if he doesn't want to follow it.

-46

u/Jiko27 GHOST BABEL WHEN Nov 19 '19

For someone who calls himself a Games Journalist, Geoff must mistakenly think that "professional distance" means holding his nose directly against their pubis.

Sasuga, Dorito Pope.