r/TwoBestFriendsPlay • u/[deleted] • Oct 10 '19
Why it’s so difficult to recommend RPGs/JRPGs to people.
77
u/Valkenhyne [He/Him] Smaller than you'd hope Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 10 '19
Idk, on my first playthrough of a JRPG I'm usually getting pretty invested in the story and world, so I'm not bored at all.
On repeat playthroughs I can see this being a thing maybe, but even then. I've played through FF7 dozens of times and the midgar section is still great. I played through DQXI at launch and now I'm playing through it again on Switch, and the intro + lead up to getting a full party is still as enjoyable as it was the first time.
3
u/Feoral Oct 11 '19
I had the opposite reaction to FF XV. It was fun to begin amd was a chore to complete and see how rushed it got.
2
u/Valkenhyne [He/Him] Smaller than you'd hope Oct 11 '19
I liked XV but I'm well aware that I'm in the minority there :p I mean, it's flaws were glaring but I still enjoyed it.
2
u/Feoral Oct 11 '19
I don't regret getting it, but as someone who loves writing and telling stories, the flaws were glaring at me.
1
u/ahack13 Space Book Says This Bad. Oct 11 '19
I couldn't disagree more on Midgar. Trying to get through it has killed so many playthroughs of ff7 because of how boring I find that section of the game.
359
u/Dundore77 Oct 10 '19
I never understood this ive enjoyed plenty of rpgs and jrpgs from the start.
108
u/Hugokarenque Oct 10 '19
Never had this problem either. I guess we're weirdos.
80
u/JoshManVGH Oct 10 '19
I think people are comparing the start of some some games to the middle or end of some games, after mechanics have really opened up or the story has popped off. Those moments when then game gets MORE fun.
Upon looking back to the start of the game, they are using those pop off points as the baseline of fun, so it skews their own opinions.
But then again people claim that FINAL FANTASY XIII "gets fun" at Gran Pulse, some 30 hours into the game, while admitting that the first 30 hours are painful. So there may also be some of that Brand Loyalty Bias at play in these conversations.
51
u/AstralTeran Oct 10 '19
Ff13 has good systems, the issue is the god awful pacing and denying the use of those systems in full until said point of the game.
→ More replies (1)21
u/midnight_riddle Oct 10 '19
It also didn't help that for like 12 hours or so you had no control over who was in your party since the story split people up into pairs of 2.
→ More replies (14)4
Oct 10 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
6
Oct 10 '19
"Opens up" is being generous. It just more labyrinthine corridors rather than a straight hallway. And the only thing to do on the planet is engage more with the boring battles system.
I got to that part, was still not having fun, and had to drop the game. So bad it turned me off of playing 15 as well.
→ More replies (1)40
u/TheRenamon Digimon had some good episodes fuck you Oct 10 '19
there are a bunch where its frontloaded with story and tutorials. Like P5. how long from the start of the game is it until you actually get to play in a palace without a tutorial. 2-3 hours?
33
9
u/Mad_Piplup242 Oct 10 '19
Well I would imagine it's to show people that it's cool to take your time through a dungeon and should you find yourself in a situation where you simply can't go any further you can just leave and come back later
And from a story stand point the game literally builds up Kamoshida to be the biggest piece of shit in the known universe so that you want nothing more than to beat the shit out of him
40
u/Dundore77 Oct 10 '19
i was actually engaged in p5 from the start and just because it doesn't immediately start you into it it gives a good start with the casino scene and the story. Tutorials dont mean you can't have fun or be engaged from the start.
3
u/SidewaysInfinity Oct 10 '19
So you can only get engaged with something if you are actively controlling it?
38
u/iOnlySawTokyoDrift Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 10 '19
It's a game. Some people are okay with slow beginnings and long cutscenes, but I don't blame anyone who wants to actually be playing the exciting parts without waiting a few hours first. The market is absolutely filled with games that get into their core gameplay within minutes, if not seconds, after pressing "Start", so there isn't really a need for someone to have JRPG levels of patience to enjoy games in general.
→ More replies (1)9
u/JJJacobalt Brooke Hogan's Legs Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 10 '19
Yes, it’s a video game.
Mandatory tutorials where the game doesn’t let you do anything are awful. At least give the option to skip it.
7
u/Heyoceama Oct 10 '19
The best kinds of tutorials in my opinion are the one's in the Souls games. You're told the mechanics and then it's up to you to decide whether or not to use them before progressing. You can take basically as long as you want since there's no consequence or even really risk of death and do it in pretty much any order, while also gaining some practical combat experience the whole way that you're likely to put to use soon. And if you've already played the games and know everything or are one of those types who wants to learn everything on their own you can just hack your way through and get on to the game proper.
6
→ More replies (1)5
u/TheRenamon Digimon had some good episodes fuck you Oct 10 '19
I just want to be able to start playing a game when I start a game
8
u/0nvd0 Way to move those dick-based goalposts. Oct 10 '19
Same EXCEPT with smt, there just something about mainline smt that makes me put the game down.
15
u/Stigge Ah, my breadsticks! Oct 10 '19
SMT IV had a rough first 5 hours, but after that it became one of my favorite games ever.
11
48
u/mitch13815 Are you gonna be a fucking jiggysnipe too you fucking spag!? Oct 10 '19
I have tried many jrpgs, and fallen off pretty much all of them.
Xenoblade, Ni No Kuni 2, Dragon Quest, Tales of [something]eria.
For me it's just there are so little stakes, and nothing to drive you forward. You wake up very calmly (sometimes after a cutscene of a big battle) in a beautiful little village and are expected to go out and do menial tasks like deliver letters or kill slimes.
That's just not fun to me. I like to have a good hook to get me invested, and with how saturated the market is with other games I just don't have the time to spend getting invested with something that takes 10 hours to get interesting.
56
u/Dundore77 Oct 10 '19
Yes i wont lie there are also plenty of rpgs that do the lame boring "wake up one morning in your quiet nothing ever happens to village as you go about to do your morning chores...." route. But there are a good amount of ones that put you right into it or after short tutorial ff7,ff10, persona 5, dragon quest 3, for example are ones that i was engaged immediately.
22
Oct 10 '19
Well even that can be implemented well. Chrono trigger has one of my favorite opnkngs ever because it's quick and intrioduces a lot of mechanics that come into play later. It even has a practice fight that you can do in the beginning if you want.
48
u/Sleepy_Thing Oct 10 '19
FF7 literally starts with you going on your way to be a terrorist to take down most hardcore authoritarian government to have ever existed and will ever exist.
Persona 4 starts you off being a know-nothing highschool student with a murder happening vaguely nearby that nobody knows about.
Final Fantasy 15 starts with EVERYTHING YOU LOVE being murdered while you are roadtripping with your best buds on your way to your wedding.
Several Dragon Quests start you with the lowest stakes imaginable.
JRPGs get into some hyper hectic stuff by the end, but the ones I've played have no problem making you wait to get to that point.
EDIT: Removed P5 and replaced it with P4 since that one actually starts with like no stakes.
14
u/Felteair Contact Mike's #1 Fan Oct 10 '19
FF9 starts with attempting to Kidnap the princess of a kingdom
→ More replies (3)18
u/ExDSG Oct 10 '19
I mean you get thrown into prison and have to escape like what 2 hours into DQ 11?
→ More replies (3)10
8
u/Chumunga64 assassin's creed ratio'd Musk Oct 10 '19
what are you talking about for FFXV?
the boys, Ignis' food, Iris, and the car are all fine!
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)7
u/SirMeepo Oct 10 '19
FF15* : Starts with EVERYTHING YOU LOVE being killed OFFSCREEN. God I hated Vanilla day one FF15. People recommend replaying with the new added cutscenes added through out the story and the dlc. Recommend?
→ More replies (3)9
Oct 10 '19
Persona 5 does have the opening sequence to try getting you hooked, but right after that, it is a LOOONG time before you get to the meat of the game. And after every palace there is another LONG stretch of cutscenes before you get any real control again.
23
u/lpeccap Oct 10 '19
Huh that's interesting. I love the early stages of so many jrpgs. Just taking in the world, getting a picture of the character's life with little stakes is so enjoyable and relaxing before the conflict begins. I love it.
→ More replies (1)26
u/SidewaysInfinity Oct 10 '19
There's probably a lot of overlap between people who hate the lower stakes worldbuilding parts of RPGs and those who think any episode of an anime that isn't 80% or more intense action is "filler"
→ More replies (3)4
u/rooik Oct 10 '19
The tales of games don't really fall into that problem. Usually things ramp up story-wise pretty quickly.
4
u/dr_tomoe Oct 10 '19
I had the same issue with a lot of the Tales series, then I got to Tales of Berseria. That one had enough of a good hook to keep me into the story and push forward.
3
u/TTsuyuki Oct 10 '19
I don't know which Tales Of you meant, but i was the same as you until i played Tales of Berseria. This game gets interesting pretty quick and the progression feels just right.
→ More replies (3)4
u/midnight_riddle Oct 10 '19
Ni no Kuni 2 is an oddball in which the first hour or two is exciting with all the possibilities, then quickly drops off after the second or third town and becomes a boring snoozefest until the grand finale which is just a load of disappointing bullshit.
4
u/mitch13815 Are you gonna be a fucking jiggysnipe too you fucking spag!? Oct 10 '19
My issue with Ni No Kuni 2 is, I actually enjoyed the beginning quite a bit.
Thought it was the first jrpg I would get into, but once you get into the sewer section there was a large room with actually like 50 items and treasure chests littered on the ground. My ocd had a panic attack and I had to stop playing.
I can't stand games with overwhelming amounts of loot, especially when it's jrpg loot where 90% of it is garbage you'll never use.
→ More replies (3)2
u/snakebit1995 Did you Know Chrom once ate an Unpeeled Orange Oct 11 '19
I felt like this a lot in Xenoblade chronicles 2
Sometimes it felt more like I would play for 10 mins and then have to sit though basically 20 mins of cutscenes or talking. I specifically remember one part where you watch a nearly 10 min long cutscene, walk around the corner on the path with no enemies and then have to watch another 5 min long cutscene.
Like fuck off im sorry am I here to play the game or watch the abridged cut of your anime pitch that was turned Into a game?
2
u/Scudman_Alpha Oct 10 '19
Some hook you right at he start.
Others start off so slow that you have to fight sleep more than the initial enemies.
→ More replies (1)1
20
Oct 10 '19
I think it comes down how much patience does the player have when engaging with. I'm going to assume most fans of JRPGs have a certain amount of expectation that the game will have a somewhat slow start in order to properly establish the mechanics and lore of the world. Someone new to the genre might not have these expectations and simply fall off of a game because "nothing happens".
It's a little hyperbolic to say that JRPGs take 10 hours to get good, but they on average do take their time at the start of game to properly set stuff up, and not everyone will have the patience for that.
Trails in the Sky (and the rest of the games in the series) might be one of the most laid back and slow ass games I've played but man do I love that series.
→ More replies (3)
85
u/DamiWolves Oct 10 '19
I half resent this sentiment. I mean feels very true especially for turn based JRPGs, but I feel like there are well designed ones that make good use of the early game like Super Mario RPG. I just don't want to resign myself to "That's just how the genre is".
39
u/Diem-Robo I'm aging rapidly Oct 10 '19
The successors to SMRPG, Paper Mario and Mario & Luigi, are also fun from the get-go.
So it's not just how the genre is, it's just bad game design.
12
u/the_most_crigg Oct 10 '19
To be fair though, the first bit of the original Paper Mario is a little tedious on replay because it takes so long to get the Lucky Star, but thankfully TTYD follows in SMRPG's footsteps by letting you just go "nah, I know how this works" and skip the tutorial.
god i wish you could skip the tutorials in the m&l games
4
Oct 10 '19
Yea this feels like saying "being a fan of FPS games means your only gonna have fun for 5-8 hours before its over". That's a sentiment that only applies to the bad ones. Dragon Quest XI, Final Fantasy 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10 are if anything at their best in the first 10 hours. Those are clearly the most well paced and finely tuned hours of the game imo. After that they slow down quite a bit for the second act land dont reach those heights again until the mid game weird bosses or the post game where things are the most opened up and you can really stretch your legs with the optional content. Chrono Trigger doesnt have this issue. Shin Megami Tensei Nocturne and 4 get you in right away to the good stuff. This sentiment may only apply to Persona and Atlier games and other mid tier anime RPGs games that nobody except [REDACTED] plays.
4
u/ExDSG Oct 11 '19
FF8 starts a bit boring with the Ifrit quest, but it's an hour at most then it gets super hype with Dollet, meeting Rinoa, and then going to Timber, but yeah 10+ hours in you are doing stupid stuff with NORG.
→ More replies (1)
67
u/Lieutenant-America Scholar of the First Spindash Oct 10 '19
I still can't believe I managed to get my friend into Persona 5 after we wrapped on Automata.
I wasn't even expecting him to accept the initial offer since I was upfront about its length, and after that I expected him to lose interest once we wrapped our first session.
3 Persona games and 300 hours later...
54
u/halsgoldenring I Promise Nothing And Deliver Less Oct 10 '19
But Persona 5 also doesn't feel like it takes 10 hours for the game to start.
31
u/KF-Sigurd It takes courage to be a coward Oct 10 '19
Persona 5 might actually have a longer intro than 4 (if you consider the point where you finally have the freedom to spend your days as you choose the end of the intro). You got the casino prologue, the interrogation, the intro to Tokyo and Shujin, the initial dive into the metaverse and Kamoshida's castle, the investigation of Kamoshida, the long buildup of Kamoshida's crimes, then another initial dive into the palace, then Ann's awakening, then finally does the game take off the leash.
It's intersparsed with more (heavily restricted) gameplay parts than P4 so I didn't notice it on the first time through but boy, when watching someone else's LP of it did I feel the boredom at how long it takes for the game to get set up.
39
u/AurochDragon Oct 10 '19
Persona 4 on the otherhand...
10
Oct 10 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
8
u/megavoir Oct 10 '19
i remember on my second playthrough of p4g, skipping all the cutscenes i could, i was amazed at how long it took to play the actual game
12
Oct 10 '19
Playing it now and it kinda does tho lol. Doesn’t feel like it lets the leash off until after the first dungeon and yeah that can totally take 10 hours.
13
u/Theproton BUSTAH WOLF! Oct 10 '19
Man I love P5. Its IMO the best RPG of all time.
But its like 4 hours until you actually do stuff. And then like 5 hours until the game takes off all the training wheels.
Like dont get me wrong I love those first 10 hours but 5 hours in I realized "holy shit I still dont have a full party".
→ More replies (1)2
u/WeilageM SHOOT THE VAGINAL SACK i guess... Oct 10 '19
Maybe I’m in the minority but for me the first 15-20 hours felt like a drag, and it didn’t pick up much from there. I ended up stopping around the 35 hour mark at inklings palace. Needed to grind in mementos to to get through the palace and I just couldn’t be bothered at that point. It’s a good game but the constant text based story and totally binary combat got old for me eventually.
→ More replies (1)
22
u/Frederick_Peters Zipp-Lineman Oct 10 '19
But Dragon Quest 7 only has a boring first hour before you even fight, and the original PS1 version was even longer. Plus DQ8 gets started right away.
16
u/Captain_Carl The Dragon Quest guy Oct 10 '19
"unpopular opinion" I guess but I like the beginning. The goal of it is to create a mystery for the island and how it isn't just a simple place with you gradually finding out the truth. Dragon Quest isn't all about fighting stuff, there's more to it than just that.
20
u/SidewaysInfinity Oct 10 '19
Dragon Quest isn't all about fighting stuff, there's more to it than just that.
That seems to be the disconnect in this whole thread. I love the slow, story-heavy parts of games
4
u/RocketbeltTardigrade "What's that emotion? Tired scream. Yawning." Oct 10 '19
I like the hermit, at least.
5
u/AurochDragon Oct 10 '19
Dragon Quest 7 is boring until Alltrades Abby, 20 hours into the game.
22
u/Captain_Carl The Dragon Quest guy Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 10 '19
That's completely false. The stories that you encounter are fun and engaging. The beginning is divisive but to say that its boring up till Dharma temple is doing it a disservice.
You can't possibly tell me that the second place with the rain that turns you to stone is boring. That place is great. Or the MechWarrior one, that one is fantastic.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (7)9
u/Frederick_Peters Zipp-Lineman Oct 10 '19
While Alltrades Abby is probably one of my favorite parts of the game, I disagree with everything else before being boring. You can't possibly tell me that Regenstein, Faraday, and the place with the roamers was boring.
4
u/Captain_Carl The Dragon Quest guy Oct 10 '19
Special mention for regenstain and greenthumb gardens developing as the overall story goes on and you visiting it several times. I love that place. What a depressing area.
1
u/Heyoceama Oct 10 '19
Plus DQ8 gets started right away.
Ehhhhhh. As a big fan of this game I'm going to have to disagree. It takes a bit before you're let free to roam around the starting area, and even then grinding is pretty much mandatory before going into the first dungeon, so you've got spend a bit before you can start making any story progress and during that time you likely don't have much in the way of abilities if any. It's definitely not the worst offender when it comes to making a player wait a long time to play the game and it smooths out right after, but it's still there.
95
u/Psykoknight65 Oct 10 '19
I mean DQ 11 and P5 were fun like 1 hour in but ok
57
u/Frederick_Peters Zipp-Lineman Oct 10 '19
I mean, I played and enjoyed Persona 5, but I was still pretty railroaded until like midway through the first palace which wasn't until a few hours in.
35
u/chorus42 Oct 10 '19
A game with that many systems has to teach the player how to use them one by one. Because player freedom is wrapped up in a calendar-day system, they have to railroad you or else they'd have to frontload that system instead of systems that are more fun and rhythmically appropriate at that moment, like combat.
Also railroaded =/= not having fun? You get into the palace delving pretty quick, like in the first or second hour. For a game juggling narrative, life sim, and combat, I'd say that's impressive.
18
u/ShadSilvs2000 ZERO TWO IS A SHIT WAIFU Oct 10 '19
And then there are those parts where you're locked into the plot and can't do anything else for the rest of the day.
30
u/Panory #The13000FE Oct 10 '19
Rest of the day? Try rest of the week.
8
u/ShadSilvs2000 ZERO TWO IS A SHIT WAIFU Oct 10 '19
Beating Okumura's Palace was especially bad with this.
9
u/radixius Oct 10 '19
The game just kind of falls apart around Okumura's palace, I think.
→ More replies (5)7
Oct 10 '19
Well my problem with P5 was that it starts off strong with the flash forward and then we get a tutorial for hours, so of which was unnecessary. The one that always gets me is the stealth mechanic because you have to do it in the flash forward but after that you have to wait for the game to teach you. I agree that it was fun regardless but it did annoy me and kinda put me off multiple playthroughs.
12
u/chorus42 Oct 10 '19
Yeah, but you can screw up the stealth mechanic in the flash forward and still get through it.
I'm guessing you were pretty familiar with how previous Persona games work, if not how most JRPGs or games in general work. If you knew how much some players who don't have that same familiar need those tutorials, you wouldn't be so quick to dismiss them. The game has a lot of systems to learn.
→ More replies (5)
19
u/SwineFlow Kinect Hates Black People Oct 10 '19
SMT Nocturne goes from 0 to 100 in half an hour. Then it goes beyond that.
9
u/KLReviews Oct 10 '19
It's something I liked about restarting Tales of Xillia. It takes 5 minutes before the plot gets moving and the action starts. Compared to Trails of Cold Steel where it's taken 15 hours for a noble to do something bad.
→ More replies (3)
25
u/Tuschi Tofu on the streets! Oct 10 '19
I generally like Alpharad but sometimes I feel like he has no clue what he's on about.
19
u/frostedWarlock Pat harvested my oats. Oct 10 '19
A lot of Friends Without Benefits are like that. Ended up getting into a small fight on their Patreon discord when Dillon kept insisting that Ethan can die an hour into Heavy Rain despite all of the evidence to the contrary and that he had only played it once like eight years ago.
24
u/ExDSG Oct 10 '19
RPGs, especially JRPGs have this really weird phenomenon where people judge the genre by using talking points from like 20 years ago or talking points from Newgrounds parodies or webcomics (because they don't seem to engage with the genre), it's like when a family member treats you like they did when you were a kid. Do people still make jokes about status effects attacks not working?
Still pretty much all RPGs have a plot hook at most 2 hours in, like who killed the reporter in Persona 4, why did the king throw you to jail in DQ 11, what's with the curse in DQ8, you know the train sequence in FF7.
23
u/Boulderdorf Oct 10 '19
people judge the genre by using talking points from like 20 years ago
Honestly, as a mecha fan, that's just niche genres in general. Often people just experience like 1 game from the genre and assume it's representative of all of them or it's the best that's out there.
7
u/ExDSG Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 10 '19
I'd go so far as to say half the time they don't even experience it due to how shallow and wrong the talking points are. Pretty clear with mecha and dating sims (mostly because you know, these games don't come out from Japan).
Also are RPGs a niche Genre? Pokemon, FF and KH are pretty big IPs outside Japan.
9
u/Boulderdorf Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 10 '19
I think you wind up with 2 kinds: The people who just make premature judgements without playing any entry ("JRPGs are like 50 hours of cutscenes with 30 hours of grinding") and the people who experience an entry that made it big overseas and really enjoy it, but just tout it as a masterpiece pioneer of the medium and refuse to check out anything else in the genre (like how older mecha fans get annoyed at TTGL or Eva fans, or the new P5 tweet making its way around).
I'd say JRPGs as a whole are a bit niche from a Western perspective. There's a few that have made it big like FF and the Pokemans, but stuff like Tales, Atelier, etc still remains niche over here. Kinda like how Gundam is gigantic in Japan but only has a decent size audience here, and if you ask a random anime fan here what a Getter Robo is, you'll probably just get blank stares.
→ More replies (2)
14
u/SpookyNishiki Oct 10 '19
I don't know about you, OP but personally, I'd recommend jrpgs to someone who I know is already playing them. If you're still having trouble getting people into those games then consider the idea that you might have shit taste.
7
u/javierich0 Oct 10 '19
Persona series always starts strong, P3 had me the second they summoned Thanatos.
6
u/Velvet_Daze Oct 10 '19
The same can can be said for every Ubisoft sandbox game with their 3 hour tutorials.
11
11
19
u/AurochDragon Oct 10 '19
Xenoblade 2 wants to know your location
17
u/iOnlySawTokyoDrift Oct 10 '19
Man, I loved Xenoblade 2, but when I was well into the second continent and the "Chain Attack" (a mechanic I already knew from Xenoblade 1) suddenly got introduced out of nowhere, I just kinda laughed at realizing how long this game had been tutorial-izing its players. Even effing Pokemon doesn't take 15-20 hours to teach you a mechanic from the first game.
10
u/powerprotoman Lord of Fortuna #13000FE Oct 10 '19
lets be real xenoblade 2 sold way more than one(which will be changing as of definitive edition)
but regardless when torna the golden country shows a tutorial message during the final boss its the hypest shit
5
u/CHaoTiCTeX Oct 10 '19
To be fair, I don't think for a combat system with as many elements as xbc2 has, you don't assume they carry over knowledge from the first game. I, for instance didn't play the first game (waiting on the definitive edition now), so I had no clue. However, in my ng+ playthrough, after experiencing it again, they could have compressed it some, maybe in the end of chapter 2 would have been a good spot for chain attacks.
Once that combat system gets rolling though, I love it.
→ More replies (2)2
Oct 10 '19
The craziest part is that you can use it in the tutorial, sure, but at your current character level you aren't even able to take advantage of the elemental orbs yet. So it was like "hey, did you like that? Well you can do it on your own in another 50 levels."
3
1
u/zephyy Griffith Did Nothing Wrong Oct 10 '19
I'll be honest, I got this and I got to the first city (the one after you land in the forest) and I have like no interest in picking it up. Does it get better? Specifically the combat, because the combat is boring as shit.
→ More replies (2)
10
u/ForwardDiscussion PUNISHED ZAIBATSU: A fandom denied their best friends Oct 10 '19
Nah, it's just different kinds of fun. First 10 hours is establishing characters/setting. Rewatch BFP Persona 4 - that's what it's like. Making fun of over the top or cliche characters, giving a respectful nod to things you think could blossom into something good.
The gameplay usually isn't outrageously fun until you get a cool build going.
5
u/KinoKage JEEZE, JOEL Oct 10 '19
Nier/ Drakengard, Final Fantasys 1-10, & ... Like a crap ton of other games would like to have a word with you.
5
u/kaisean YOU DIDN'T WIN. Oct 10 '19
Didn't feel this way about P5, Nier, etc., but I did feel this way about Fallout 4. That opening sequence is not as compelling as it's supposed to be.
5
9
u/Bl00dY_ReApeR Oct 10 '19
I think the problem is that if it takes you that long to enjoy it, you might not really like JRPGs. Some might have a slow start until 2 hours in where something big finally happens but most are still entertaining, giving you time to meet some characters or learn the basic mechanics of the game.
9
u/DylanTheVillian1 Desperately Wants Kamiya's Royal Release Oct 10 '19
I think he just needs to play better JRPGs.
4
u/Panory #The13000FE Oct 10 '19
Narrative is always hit or miss, but good ones grip you early on just fine. What he’s almost universally right about is gameplay. Early on in JRPGs you don’t have a ton of options, even in good ones. Meaningful decisions beyond “should I heal now?” pretty much don’t exist.
4
u/Boulderdorf Oct 10 '19
I can understand the sentiment. JRPGs are usually long as hell, so they spend a decent amount of time on exposition, and some people just want to jump into the gameplay. Early tutorial battles usually just consist of "Spam Attack Button." Probably applies more for people who haven't really experienced the genre. They're not all like that of course, but something like Persona which railroads you for several hours might make you go "Man, I'm just watching an anime/reading a VN."
4
u/JameTrain Oct 10 '19
I mean, maybe in general? Idk? But for Xenoblade 1 you were IN THERE in the first 4 hours.
Fuckin' Metal Face swooping down. Robots eating people. Your gf getting fucking FLAYED. Shulk saying, "I'LL KILL YOOOOOU!", but with like REALLY good voice acting, setting off to the cave with the big evil spiders. Then Gaur Plain.
Yeah no the first 10 hours of Xenoblade 1 were radical.
15
u/Flare3500 THE 2B SHIT DISAPPEARED , IDK WHY...#BOWSETTE Oct 10 '19
I don't know what JRPGs this guy plays but the first hours are usually really good even the old ones like FF6 starts with you being chased down and a castle submerging in sand , P3 starts with Yukari doing an homage to Kurt Cobain and modern ones like Code Vein starts with big giant anime titties
→ More replies (1)
7
u/Sekshual Oct 10 '19
I always found it was the idea that you won't really know if the game is good until about the length of another game has already passed. Huge timesink for a potentially okay game.
4
u/Boulderdorf Oct 10 '19
Kinda like how I feel about some long shows. Some of my friends were super into Gintama, and they were pushing me to watch it, going "oh yeah the first ~30 episodes are kinda bad but once you get past that, it gets really good!" Like man, I have to get through a whole show's worth of bad episodes to see whether I like it or not, I don't have the time for that.
11
u/icyneesan My Legs are OK Oct 10 '19
Final Fantasy 4, 6, 7, 9, 10, and 15, Tyranny, Pillars of Eternity, Divinity Original Sin 1 and 2, and Fallout New Vegas would all like to know your location and tell you how theyre good rpgs with decent hooks that can catch you immediately if you give them a chance.
24
u/mitch13815 Are you gonna be a fucking jiggysnipe too you fucking spag!? Oct 10 '19
Tyranny, PoE, D:OS 1/2, and Fallout NV are VERY much not jrpgs.
11
Oct 10 '19
The original post says "RPGs/JRPGs".
EDIT: Well, OP's title does, balls half-exposed.
4
u/mitch13815 Are you gonna be a fucking jiggysnipe too you fucking spag!? Oct 10 '19
Ah shit you're right, I didn't even notice OP's title.
We can share one ball each for exposure.
2
4
u/the_most_crigg Oct 10 '19
There's also FF5, the game that introduces you to the Job system about 30 minutes in and gives you free reign over 9 jobs (10 if you include freelancer) before the end of the second hour, and a lot of those jobs are the stupidly useful and fun magic classes.
3
Oct 10 '19
I mean I agree a bit, though I think 10 hours is a bit too much, for newer jrpgs anyway. But then again, I aint coming to these for gameplay so the opening of character introductions and world building as the plot starts to hatch keeps me going along
3
3
5
5
u/Captain_Carl The Dragon Quest guy Oct 10 '19
What a load of nonsense. There's countless JRPGs that hit the ground running and even the ones that don't do that don't take "10 hours to be fun."
1
4
u/Guigcosta CUSTOM FLAIR Oct 10 '19
Well, the best parts of the best RPGs really are hours into the game, but if its common to you to not have fun for hours i really think you are not much of a fan to begin with
2
u/Huaun There's no way a woman can be that hot, she's gotta be a man! Oct 10 '19
You underestimate my weeb passion.
2
u/StarSkullyman Hex Girls Are Too Strong For Waifu Wars! Oct 10 '19
I say this is more of an issue on repeated playthroughs.
2
u/FruitierGnome Oct 10 '19
I mean that depends. Sometimes the intro sucks but some are really fun. I can imagine on 3rd playthroughs the tutorial being tedious.
2
u/umbypokochan Oct 10 '19
I'm weird because my favorite part of any RPG/JRPG is the beginning. I hate when they end. Sometimes I won't beat them just so I can start over and feel like I still have something to accomplish. I just love the feeling of starting a journey.
2
u/Kino_Afi Oct 10 '19
Started playing dq9 again recently and that was lovely from the start
Also playing through Radiant Dawn, even the first mission was butt clenching.
2
u/BreathingHydra It's Fiiiiiiiine. Oct 10 '19
Western RPGs usually don't have this problem, with the exception of stuff like the beginning of fallout 2.
2
u/morpheusforty suffer not the ayy to lmao Oct 10 '19
Sorry all I read was "I've only ever played Persona 5 and I have a short attention span."
2
u/shit_tier Oct 10 '19
Is what people who tend to not actually play JRPGs or don't play many tend to think. Alongside the silly "I don't have time to get into an 100 hour long game! I'm already working another job!" And then they'll play 10 20 hour long games back to back.
5
u/TechnicalDrift I Promise Nothing And Deliver Less Oct 10 '19
I like western rpgs but JRPGs are usually a miss. I can't quite pin down why, maybe it's the convoluted writing or the way dialogue is handled. Maybe it's the monotonous gameplay loop or the overly-designed stat systems. Final Fantasy games come to mind. On the flip side, I recently started playing MHW, and I'm loving it.
I'm not trying to bash JRPGs, I just wish I could enjoy more of them.
18
u/PMX-TheO Oct 10 '19
On the flip side I have nothing against wrpgs but those are oddly my same gripes with them and then some. Differents strokes I guess?
11
u/lpeccap Oct 10 '19
Same, to me they all feel too identical. The music is always similar, they all use the same setting. That whole european medieval castles and wood shacks gets so tiring after a while. I love how imaginative and colorful jrpgs are.
→ More replies (1)8
7
u/Valkenhyne [He/Him] Smaller than you'd hope Oct 10 '19
MHW is arguably pretty different to the kind of games that the original tweet is referring to. That's more of an action-RPG. I guess it's open to interpretation but I get the feeling that tweet was referring to turn-based or slower paced RPGs like Divinity Original Sin and the FFs - games in which it can take awhile for you to get a full party and have a lot of tools at your disposal.
→ More replies (1)11
Oct 10 '19
For me, it's the lack of customization. D&D is the primary inspiration of most Western RPGs, so you play your character the way you want. The opposite is true in most JRPGs, where you play a Japanese game dev's character the way they want.
That, and the way they haphazardly throw steampunk and robots in everything, internal consistency of the worldbuilding be damned.
9
3
2
u/billyalt I Promise Nothing And Deliver Less Oct 10 '19
Honestly this resonates so strongly with Mass Effect 1 it's bumming me out.
2
u/NatCritFail Oct 10 '19
Mass Effect wasn't that long was it? I thought it was pretty average when it came to length wise and you knew at the beginning if you liked the gameplay or not.
2
u/billyalt I Promise Nothing And Deliver Less Oct 10 '19
Not at all, it is a complete dredge at the beginning. It gets way more enjoyable as you progress. It takes way too long to leave the citadel.
2
u/NewAccountOldUser678 Oct 10 '19
I can understand this sentiment. For Persona 3, 4, and 5, it takes at least several hours to reach the proper gameplay, unless you skip cutscenes and dialogue.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/BrockenSpecter Worst Timeline Oct 10 '19
Looking at you Xenoblade Chronicles X
→ More replies (1)6
Oct 10 '19
50
Hours
to get the mech
→ More replies (2)3
u/Darlos9D #1 Xenogears shill Oct 10 '19
That honest to god kept me from playing it. I'd kill for a Xeno game that actually revolved around piloting robots good and proper like Xenogears and even Xenosaga did.
Though really it'd feel kinda empty without a fucking whackadoodle pseudo-philosophical Evangelion ripoff plot too. I miss that shit.
1
Oct 10 '19
I wouldn't put it precisely that way... the start of an RPG is fun with an asterix. It's not typically the gameplay that's fun, until a good amount of time in, JRPGs are almost all braindead to play (either trivially easy, hard but tell you what to do, or appears hard but it trivialized by grinding). But, for the good ones, there's excitement at the prospect of what is to come, either story wise (thinking about the places in this world you're going to visit) or gameplay wise (thinking about the gameplay systems becoming full realized). That excitement at the possibilities for the future is your "fun", and it can be retroactively lost if the game never realizes these possibilities.
So I'd put it more as "Being a JRPG fan means not really knowing whether a game is fun until 10 hours in".
1
u/UrsusDerpus Eternal Sleeping Dogs Shill Oct 10 '19
The first 4 hours are for story dumping and world building so you don't have to ask too many questions when they finally let you loose upon the world. But even so, it's only bad if the game as a whole is bad.
In Yakuza games, sometimes the beginning is a drag, but it isn't not enjoyable. It's just more fun to kick random thug ass and go golfing.
I think it's just that usually those are the tutorial hours since some J/RPGs can be pretty dense, so you don't get all your toys until the game teaches you how to use them all.
1
1
u/MasterChris725 Oct 10 '19
It’s hard for me to recommend personally cause a few jrpgs i’ve played, the combat was never at all engaging for me.
1
1
u/Ultimaniacx4 Oct 10 '19
Fun is different to different people. I enjoy taking in the setting of a new world.
1
u/dblackdrake Oct 10 '19
More like never for me, which is sad.
Turn based rpg's have just lost all appeal; unless they have a gambit system.
It's fun while you learn the system and figure out the optimal strategy, but after that it's just repeating the same action in a menu until you win.
It's about as exciting as adding info to an excel sheet.
1
Oct 10 '19
Persona 5 managed to fix this issue, which was a BIG problem the previous Persona games had.
3
u/AgentTexes Advent Apologist Oct 10 '19
Not really. The first 10 hours are being yelled at by a cat to go to bed.
→ More replies (4)2
u/CreepingDeath0 Oct 10 '19
Huh, I thought Persona 5 was one of the worst recent offenders for this.
1
1
u/Introspectre12 Think about it. Oct 10 '19
I have the reverse problem where all the JRPGs I play feel like they drag the end of the game out as long as possible.
1
u/DrewbieWanKenobie JEEZE, JOEL Oct 10 '19
I mean, liking jrpgs is all about liking characters, dialogue and story. If you're in it for the super fun gameplay, well, honestly not many jrpgs are going to fit that. I mean plenty will be fine and you might even go so far as to say enjoyable but it's not ever going to rival like, as metal gear revengeance in gameplay.
If you don't like jrpg style stories/characters/dialogue just don't even try
1
u/CelioHogane The Baz Everywhere System developer. Oct 10 '19
What? the 10 first hours of an JRPG are normally super fun, i loved the first hours of Grandia because i spent them on one of my favorite places ever, a very alive port city.
1
u/Mutant-Overlord I've promised nothing but will deliver Yes! Oct 10 '19
Jokes on you , I do have fun for first 10 hours of JRPGs.
1
u/Sassy_Sarranid Oct 10 '19
Only the first 10 hours? *Laughs in Megaman Battle Network*
Seriously though, those games don't really start until you get to the 40 hour mark. They're great, but woof is that a brutal replay.
1
u/Prince_Ire 19th Century Refugee Oct 10 '19
This is why I can't bring myself to replay Kotor 2. Sure, I think its vastly overrated and not as good as Kotor 1, but I still liked it well enough. But Peragus is simply too much of a hurdle for me to try another playthrough.
1
u/jenkind1 THE ORIGAMI KILLER Oct 10 '19
I don't like extended character creation stuff. Like in Fallout 3, you have to play through multiple story scenes before getting to pick your stats.
2
u/NatCritFail Oct 10 '19
The worst offender is Skyrim because you can't redo your character's race/appearance without going through the same intro. It's not as big a deal but in Oblivion/Fallout 3/New Vegas you had the option to change anything before continuing which made for an excellent save spot for new games.
1
u/BigBossGZV Pat's wrong, all's right with the world Oct 10 '19
A lot of people are taking this silly little hyperbole too literally. And even with that in mind, stuff usually doesn't start really popping off or emotionally getting you until a couple hours in
1
Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 10 '19
Hard disagree.
The opening to FF7 is one of the best video game openings of any genre.
Star Ocean 2 opens up with interdimensional travel, lasers, and a man with dragons fused to his shoulders.
Parasite Eve opens with a hot cop lady in a dress shooting melting cronenberg monsters while everyone around her bursts into flames.
Stop playing anything and everything with anime eyes and be more selective.
1
Oct 10 '19
That’s my problem: I’ve been so selective about playing the obvious good ones I now have no idea what JRPG to try, and the potential time investment for no payoff keeps me from even trying a game.
1
u/Brock_Lobster4445 Oct 10 '19
I would argue most rpgs slow down in the middle
1
u/SamuraiDDD Swat Kats Booty! Oct 10 '19
Bravely Default got this HARD with this
2
u/Panory #The13000FE Oct 11 '19
Bravely Default didn't slow down in the middle. It straight up stopped moving for a while. Then snapped back to a hundred and ten for the finale.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/ProfDet529 Investigator of Incidents Mundane, Arcane, and Divine Oct 10 '19
Give them Parasite Eve: that one is ZIPPY for a Square RPG.
Though, if they're shy about gore...
1
1
u/Krogs322 Oct 10 '19
I actually enjoy early game in most FFs. Like, FF9 early game is what I enjoy the most, and I'm not even mad if I get bored half way through the game because it means I get to play the beginning again.
1
u/James-Avatar Mega Lopunny Oct 10 '19
The openings can be one of the better parts, it’s the middles that tend to get stagnant.
1
u/Nebbymod YOU SAID HE WAS SLOW Oct 10 '19
This take is really fucking weird because some of the best games in the genre (The Persona series, the good FF games, and Chrono Trigger) all have a fantastic hook and usually get started maybe an hour or two in. Shit, Persona 3 took like...30 minutes to get the ball rolling tops.
1
u/LunarGolbez Oct 10 '19
It's funny because the fondest memories I have for JRPGs in general is usually the first act of every game. For FF7 after Midgar the story loses the energy it had with all the encounters prior. For FF8, After the Dollet mission, I begin to gradually lose motivation since I am coming off of the high from that mission. In FF10, the Spira becomes less interesting the minute I get to the Mi'ihen Highroad EVERYTIME I play it because it feels like at that point the mysticism of being a new world falls off.
I have actually gotten overwhelmed by content near the end of most JRPG games that I don't finish them. I think the only one I 100% was FF8.
1
1
u/employee2136487 The real black spider-man Oct 10 '19
This was true in 2010, things are better now. Three houses was fun within the first 30 minutes, but I will admit that P5 was tres ridicule.
1
Oct 10 '19
Alpharad with the good takes. I enjoy the first section, but theyre not the part where im really having fun. Or the part Ill remember
1
1
1
1
u/clickypen_champion I Promise Nothing And Deliver Less Oct 11 '19
You all know those comment is meant for the "Tales of" games.
1
1
u/lolhaxman Plz ignore the "man" in my username, I'm a non-binary shitlord Oct 11 '19
A lot of the less story focused ones just drop you right into the sick combat though
1
1
1
u/Runetang42 Oct 10 '19
To me the problem with JRPGs for me is that I don't like games that are a lot of menus. Every FF game I've played to me feels less like a game and more like micromanaging menus in menus. I thought it was the turn based combat, but I'm fine with games like Fire Emblem and Bannersaga. It's probably also why I don't like most mmo's
306
u/FoxInABeret He/Him Oct 10 '19
I really don't think this is true. The good JRPGs I've played generally don't have this problem. Some that are pretty good might drag a little at the beginning, but not nearly that long. The only JRPGs that really do this are, I think, frequently regarded as bad.