r/btc • • Oct 04 '19

200,000 People Have Signed Ross Ulbricht's Clemency Petition

https://news.bitcoin.com/200000-people-have-signed-ross-ulbrichts-clemency-petition/
236 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

42

u/x62617 Oct 04 '19

" Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted. "

8

u/SwedishSalsa Oct 05 '19

As a foreigner, let me say: what happened to this young man is un-American. What a disgrace.

31

u/MarcusDGray Redditor for less than 60 days Oct 04 '19

This man does not deserve to be in prison...

10

u/fribitz Oct 04 '19

I can see lessening his sentence to something more appropriate but didn't he run an illegal site that trafficked illegal drugs etc?

5

u/kush_lungs Oct 04 '19

The guy ran a site that facilitated many criminal acts. He's not an idiot, he must have known he was at risk of a huge sentence. Weather or not you agree with the law, it is the law and if you break, assist or conspire to break the law then you're running the risk of jail.

4

u/fribitz Oct 05 '19

Yes.. I agree. I feel bad but it's hard to feel that bad for someone when they do something that stupid.

4

u/bearjewpacabra Oct 05 '19

People waged war in north america against an army much, much larger than their own... and won. They are labeled 'founders', not criminals.

4

u/antonivs Oct 05 '19

Congratulations, that's the most ridiculous false equivalence I've seen for some time.

0

u/fribitz Oct 05 '19

Fascinating

1

u/moleccc Oct 06 '19

If noone tries anything "stupid", nothing "great" will ever be done.

You know how stupid it was once perceived to try and build a computer for personal use? The IBM at the time said there was demand for maybe 8 computers worldwide, so it'd be "stupid" to build something like a PC.

Oh, and if that doesn't derail the conversation enough, how "stupid" do you think it was to try to kill Hitler?

1

u/WikiTextBot Oct 06 '19

20 July plot

On 20 July 1944, Claus von Stauffenberg and other conspirators attempted to assassinate Adolf Hitler, Führer of Nazi Germany, inside his Wolf's Lair field headquarters near Rastenburg, East Prussia. The name Operation Valkyrie—originally referring to part of the conspiracy—has become associated with the entire event.

The apparent aim of the assassination attempt was to wrest political control of Germany and its armed forces from the Nazi Party (including the SS) and to make peace with the Western Allies as soon as possible. The details of the conspirators' peace initiatives remain unknown, but they would have included unrealistic demands for the confirmation of Germany's extensive annexations of European territory.The plot was the culmination of efforts by several groups in the German resistance to overthrow the Nazi German government.


[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28

1

u/fribitz Oct 06 '19

Not all "stupid" is created equal. The risk vs reward calculation is indispensable. In this case the risk clearly outweighed the reward by an inordinate amount in my opinion. You should never risk your personal freedom for money OR for your political beliefs (if that's why you believe he actually did it, I don't, I think he did it for the money). In the case of Hitler the world had everything to gain from defeating Hitler and would have lost its freedom had they not confronted him. So there's that...

2

u/Odbdb Oct 05 '19

He ran a website. People trafficked many illegal things in it. Two separate things in my opinion.

From what I remember he was caught soliciting a hit man on his own website. While he was being federally investigated. Not smart.

However, I faintly recall the investigation into his dealings were far from moral much less legal. I believe there were also several federal agents that were convicted of crimes involving theft of assets linked to Ross (several hundred thousand BTC). That obviously changes the conditions of his case.

2

u/fribitz Oct 05 '19

Yeah two different things for sure but I try to put myself in someone else's shoes (try at least) and I just can't see myself ever taking the risk he took. What did he think was going to happen? I believe it's wrong to lock someone up if there is a good chance that they are capable of changing their ways, regardless of what they did. Forgiveness is important. They clearly wanted to make an example out of him though.

4

u/Forlarren Oct 05 '19 edited Oct 05 '19

From what I remember he was caught soliciting a hit man on his own website.

Nope, never even charged with it.

That was the propaganda. Not only that but his investigators were themselves committing much much much worse crimes during the investigation, and that wasn't allowed into evidence.

The whole thing was a kangaroo court.

The government also accused Ulbricht of paying for the murders of at least five people, but there is no evidence that the murders were actually carried out, and the accusations never became formal charges against Ulbricht.[46][47]

And:

In late March 2015, a criminal complaint issued by the United States District Court for the Northern District of California led to the arrest of two former federal agents who had worked undercover in the Baltimore Silk Road investigation of Ulbricht, former Drug Enforcement Administration agent Carl Mark Force IV and Secret Service agent Shaun Bridges.[49][50] The agents are alleged to have kept funds that Ulbricht transferred to them in exchange for purported information about the investigation.[49][51] The agents were charged with wire fraud and money laundering.[52] In late November 2016, Ulbricht's lawyers brought forward a case on a third DEA agent, who they claim was leaking information about the investigation and tampered with evidence to omit chat logs showing conversations with him.[53]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silk_Road_(marketplace)

1

u/moleccc Oct 06 '19

From what I remember

This is the problem: some baseless accusations are sprinkled in with real, more tangible, provable charges and what people "remember" "as fact" somehow are those baseless accusations. The human mind is such a fuckup. If it was software, I'd call it "buggy as hell" or even "faulty by design".

7

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/aphisosys Oct 05 '19

he never sold anything.

4

u/streetsmart26 Redditor for less than 60 days Oct 05 '19

I believe reading that he sold drugs himself as well

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

[deleted]

1

u/aphisosys Oct 05 '19

To my knowledge he never sold anything on there. Pretty sure he bought stuff though. I could be wrong idk. Been a long time since I dug into the whole deal.

But regardless, even if he did sell something on there he was never tried or convicted on it so it's irrelevant in the discussion at the end of the day.

5

u/gulfbitcoin Oct 04 '19

As long as first we let out all of the minorities who similarly had victimless crimes who were convicted before Ross.

5

u/bearjewpacabra Oct 05 '19

The government does not recognize your self ownership. You are a slave, property of said government. One of their primary objectives is to prevent you shifting your mind away from the production and consumption of goods and services.

2

u/fribitz Oct 04 '19

Last time I checked, victimless crimes are crimes...

9

u/tbjfi Oct 04 '19

Why is it a crime if there is no victim?

2

u/Tergi Oct 04 '19

Who's the victom of speeding? It's still a crime.

9

u/tbjfi Oct 05 '19

The argument goes that speeding shouldn't be a crime, either. But "driving dangerously" is a crime because in order to be danger you have to be endangering a person or a person's property.

1

u/fribitz Oct 05 '19

I guess you'll have to ask a legislator that question.

-3

u/Bahnhofklatscher1962 Redditor for less than 60 days Oct 04 '19

It's that so people can assert dominance over others based mostly on differing political views

1

u/bearjewpacabra Oct 05 '19

Like selling loose cigs. Eric Garner totally deserved what he got by your reasoning. In fact, if you do not have people willing to murder people to enforce any law, the law is worthless.

3

u/fribitz Oct 05 '19

I have to disagree strongly with your hyperbolic depiction of the law and misrepresentation of what I said. It also does no good to use borderline cases to exemplify the general state of things. If you know you are breaking the law you should stop. If you know you're being arrested, you should stop. Two different situations, same best practice.

6

u/bearjewpacabra Oct 05 '19

If you know you are breaking the law you should stop. If you know you're being arrested, you should stop. Two different situations, same best practice.

These people were breaking the law and about to be arrested. Should they have stopped?

Fuck your mental cage.

2

u/fribitz Oct 05 '19

Sorry I'm not a political activist. Sorry you feel the need to curse at me as well.

6

u/bearjewpacabra Oct 05 '19

Sorry I'm not a political activist.

What does this mean?

2

u/fribitz Oct 05 '19

It means I don't invest significant amounts of my time and energy into changing government policy.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/moleccc Oct 06 '19

Yes, he sold stuff to people who wanted to buy

Did he, though? My impression was he was running the marketplace, but not offering anything himself.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

[deleted]

1

u/vocatus Oct 05 '19 edited Oct 05 '19

He got enough life sentences they dropped the charge because they didn't anything more to put him away. But it was part of the original charges brought against him.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

[deleted]

1

u/moleccc Oct 06 '19

Not getting charged means they couldn't get enough evidence to prove it.

yeah, or it was too likely the fact that it was all a setup would come to light.

what's really sad is that this allegation just keeps sticking in peoples heads while it should be simply "off the table". Yet people constantly use it in arguments.

1

u/vocatus Oct 07 '19

It all boils down to how much is required to get x sentencing. If you can get consecutive life sentences with xyz evidence there's no point in dealing with burden of proof on extra data.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

[deleted]

1

u/vocatus Oct 07 '19

I think two things are true:

  1. Ross Ulbricht isn't some innocent guy. He went down the rabbit hole that many, many people have before him when getting into criminal enterprises. The best intentions etc

  2. FBI/gov etc were sketchy in the case and how they approached it and definitely not on the up and up in some ways.

Both can be true at the same time, but all the drones on Reddit act like it has to be one or the other. They are wrong, it is not mutually exclusive. And I agree with you WRT the business...I support free enterprise, and while not a drug user myself I don't have any problem with consenting adults doing what they want with their bodies.

1

u/donteatyourvegs Oct 04 '19

well if drugs were legal he would have made 0 money. only reason he made money is cause he took the risk to do something illegal.

1

u/moleccc Oct 06 '19

well if drugs were legal he would have made 0 money.

there's your solution. Legalize drugs and those crimes go away (hell, the government could even make a bunch of money on taxes). Look to Portugal, it works and since they legalized their drug-related problems have lessened considerably.

18

u/Mr-Zwets Oct 04 '19

FreeRoss

6

u/shadowofashadow Oct 04 '19

Has a petition like this ever worked? This is why I never sign stuff like this or change.org. I've never seen anything happen other than ignoring it

3

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '19

Professor Trump may be persuaded to grant him clemency

4

u/Tonto115 Oct 04 '19

Maybe cause u never sign it.

1

u/shadowofashadow Oct 05 '19

That's a tautology. I will start signing them if someone can show me they work. There are plenty that have millions of signatures.

4

u/butcherofballyhoo Oct 04 '19

Ross is a legend. He gave btc a use case. He deserves our help

1

u/gulfbitcoin Oct 04 '19

"help"

1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

Even if he is never freed we can still find ways to help his time in prison.

2

u/skrillabobcat Oct 04 '19

I sure as hell signed it!

1

u/Ploshad Oct 05 '19

Ross is one of my heroes and inspired me to quit my job and start my own business. I hope he gets his freedom.

2

u/nycguychelsea Oct 05 '19

I wish you success in your business -- unless that business is running a criminal enterprise.

1

u/Ploshad Oct 05 '19

It’s nothing illegal, haha. I could have been clearer — I was inspired by the way he formed an idea that fit his worldview, then taught himself to code to build it, and then created a place for customers and likeminded people to congregate.

0

u/wmurray003 Oct 05 '19

Lol, it's funny how you guys come rallying to get this guy out of prison after he ran an online black market website that facilitated thousands of transactions and he possibly attempted to solicit a hit man for hire to kill a potential threat to his organization. etc, yet there are thousands of minorities in jail for minor drug related crimes yet you say nothing.

What's different this time?

-7

u/jusbusiness Oct 04 '19

Can someone please explain why everyone seems to think his crimes were victimless? He tried to hire a hitman on multiple occasions to take people out for him.

15

u/Mr-Zwets Oct 04 '19

this is a myth

8

u/Bahnhofklatscher1962 Redditor for less than 60 days Oct 04 '19

The hitman charges were never tried before court. He was convicted of running the site

-3

u/jusbusiness Oct 04 '19

Correct, I am not saying he did it. But people act like the SR road network was all he illegally carried out. People talk about him like he was some choirboy who tucked in his shirt and just set up some huge illegal network of free trade. Look into the original charges, yes they were later dropped by a judge because they already knew he was going to be locked up for 2 lifetimes which ended up coming to fruition.

" FBI investigators said that on or about March 29, 2013, Ulbricht contacted a Silk Road seller “Redandwhite” to see about hiring him to to take out another Silk Road user — someone going by the nickname “FriendlyChemist” — who was threatening to release the identities of thousands of users of the site. "

10

u/gulfbitcoin Oct 04 '19

Then convict them of those crimes and punish accordingly. His sentencing is way out of line. I personally don't think he's innocent, I just don't think he's life-sentence-guilty. 10-20 years (comparable to what many street dealers get) would be appropriate.

-9

u/zcube97 Oct 04 '19

Finally something good to come out of this BCH shill sub.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '19

[deleted]

1

u/moleccc Oct 06 '19

Dude actively tried to get people murdered.

No court ever decided on that. He wasn't charged with that. AAAAND: it was probably a setup. They played him.

-2

u/SpiritofJames Oct 04 '19

Lies.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '19

[deleted]

8

u/hungliketictacs Oct 04 '19

I'd recommend hearing how the case went and the murder for hire lies from Ross' mom Lynn. IIRC this murder for hire claim wasn't brought up nor was he charged for it in court. It's a baseless claim and that FBI agent masquerading as a hitman laundered bitcoin and is now in prison.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '19

[deleted]

5

u/hungliketictacs Oct 04 '19 edited Oct 04 '19

You are right, I shouldn't have said baseless though it's important to note multiple people had access to the DPR handle when that chat happened. Nonetheless I got to hear Lynn speak about this case and it's convinced me that this case was bunk from the get go. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NxLrA1RYEds

2

u/nycguychelsea Oct 05 '19

Ross wrote entries in the journal that he kept on his laptop where he mentions having people he thought were liabilities killed. And he actually paid for those hits in bitcoin. It turns out he was being scammed and there were no actual murders. The targets and the hitmen were the same guy who was just looking to steal from the Silk Road. But that is immaterial -- he still ordered and paid for people to be killed and he believed they were actually killed.

I suppose if you really want to stretch credulity, you can believe that after the laptop was seized, some rogue agents planted and/or modified the journal just to frame him with the murder for hire chrages that ultimately were never proseecutied. And those rogue agents would have to be different from the the criminals investigating the case in Baltimore, as those guys were not involved in the arrest or seizure of the laptop.

I prefer to live in reality and recognize that Ross was not as nice a guy as many people think he is. Does he deserve to die in federal prison for this? I don't think so. I agree the sentence is outrageous, but Ross Ulbricht is no hero in my eyes.

1

u/hungliketictacs Oct 05 '19

Ross wrote entries in the journal that he kept on his laptop where he mentions having people he thought were liabilities killed.

Source?

2

u/nycguychelsea Oct 05 '19

Unfortunately, I cannot find a free source. But Wired did a story about the journal and other information found on the laptop. The story doesn't mention the hits, but it links to a Scribd pdf transcript of the journal.

Scribd is a pay service, however, so you will have to open at least a tiral account in order to read it on their website: https://www.scribd.com/doc/253551316/Ulbricht-Log#fullscreen&from_embed

As I mentioned, the Wired story links that pdf at the bottom and you can view it on the Wired page, but it's a pain in the ass to read it that way. Still, it's an option if you don't want to deal with Scribd. Here is the Wired story: https://www.wired.com/2015/01/heres-secret-silk-road-journal-laptop-ross-ulbricht/

For reference, the relevant entries start at 3/29/2013. Also, look at 4/6/2013.

1

u/moleccc Oct 06 '19

But that is immaterial

honest question: If I try to order a murder on someone (and think I succeeded), yet nothing really happens... is that still punishable? Where's the harm? I mean I can see how I tried to do harm, but I failed to do so in actuality. Are we being punished for our intentions now? Where does this end? You thought about not paying your taxes the other day? Well, tough luck: you're now a tax offender.

1

u/nycguychelsea Oct 06 '19

Well, it's not cut and dry. If someone really annoyed you and you thought -- I want to kill that person -- and you even shouted at that person, "I'm going to kill you!" -- and that's where it ends, then that probably isn't a crime (I'm hedging a little because I'm not a lawyer). You're allowed to think bad things, and even to say bad things. But in the same example, if you are pointing a gun at someone while you shout -- "I'm going to kill you!" -- then the threat is much more credible, and the person you're pointing the gun at is going to feel like his life is in danger.

I know that's not the same example, but it's a similar principle. If Ross had merely written in his journal -- "I'm being blackmailed and I don't know what to do. Maybe I will have to eliminate this person." Then that's just Ross thinking. It's just talk, and there is no actual threat or danger to anyone. But once he starts taking actual concrete steps to eliminate the blackmailer -- once he starts actually talking to people he thinks are hitmen, and orders the hit, and (this is the important part) pays for the hit -- now it's not just talk anymore. Those aren't thoughts. They're actions, and actions are definitely punishable.

Why are attempts that fail still crimes? Because you don't get a pass for being incompetent or just plain unlucky. If I shoot a gun at you and the bullet misses, should I not be punished? I mean, no harm no foul, right? Society can't just let people shoot at others randomly until someone actually gets hurt and only then do something about it. So, if you try to kill someone and fail, then society has to address that or you might try again and succeed.

But even considering all of that, Ross wasn't convicted of those acts. You and I and other reasonable people who look at the facts can say to ourselves that Ross isn't as nice a guy as some people think he is, and that he probably tried to get people killed -- the same way many reasonable people look at OJ Simpson and believe that he killed his ex-wife -- but that doesn't make Ross guilty of murder-for-hire any more than OJ is guilty of murder. They're not guilty of those crimes. But "not guilty" does not equal "innocent," and reasonable people can still draw conclusions based on the facts available to them.

-------

TL;DR: Thoughts aren't punishable, but actions are.

2

u/Forlarren Oct 05 '19

just saying it was initially part of it.

According to a thief and corrupt FBI agent who's a known liar and never vetted in court.

0

u/vocatus Oct 05 '19

Don't take my word for it, do your own research.

5

u/SpiritofJames Oct 04 '19

The evidence from the FBI is tainted.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '19

[deleted]

4

u/SpiritofJames Oct 04 '19

They had access to all of his accounts and the investigators were prosecuted.... They planted evidence.

1

u/vocatus Oct 05 '19

Sure, that's one theory.

0

u/jeeperbleeper Oct 05 '19

Do you have any evidence they planted evidence?

4

u/SpiritofJames Oct 05 '19

They had the means, the motive, and the opportunity. That's all I need to suspect the Feds of trying to enforce their bullshit as hard as possible.

1

u/jeeperbleeper Oct 05 '19

So no evidence though? Does Ross himself claim that another party wrote the chat messages requesting the murder?

2

u/brobits Oct 05 '19

Carl Mark Force IV was actually arrested and I believe is currently in prison for corruption, related to this case

1

u/vocatus Oct 05 '19

Yeah, reading about his involvement was pretty crazy. They could make a great movie out of the whole story.

1

u/Forlarren Oct 05 '19

Yet that arrest wasn't allowed to influence Ross's case.

Fucking kangaroo courts.