r/btc • u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com • Sep 29 '19
Just another day at the Bitcoin Cash accepting super market in Slovenia.
16
u/swdee Sep 29 '19
Roger, you forgot the Fruits and Vegetables!
12
u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Sep 29 '19
That guy is a jujitsu black belt too!
8
2
u/Malouw Sep 29 '19
Is Bitcoin Cash payments with Bitpay faster than Bitcoin payments with Bitpay?
1
1
Sep 30 '19
BCH payments are reliable. BTC are generally reliable, but not always. When they are reliable, they are both fast. If not then you're kinda fucked.
Bitpay uses BIP70 to streamline the payment, which streamlined the payment. If I remember correctly, Bitpay decides the transaction fee for you, to prevent unreliable payments, which is good.
Recently the Bitcoin Core Wallet, the reference implementation for BTC, has disabled BIP70 support tho. Other wallets still support it.
1
1
u/MrHat7 Sep 30 '19
Wait... You got your black belt? If so then congratulations! That's actually big.
-1
-11
5
u/brunommpreto Sep 29 '19
Which part of Slovenia, I'm in Ljubljana never saw that
11
u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Sep 30 '19
I’m in Ljubliana too. Download the Marco Coino app to see all the BCH accepting locations.
5
1
u/mjau-mjau Sep 29 '19
It looks like the one in BTC but I'm not too sure
1
u/brunommpreto Sep 30 '19
Its probably in BTC center.
10
u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Sep 30 '19
Yes, but they may be changing their name to BCH City. (No joke)
2
u/Febos Sep 30 '19
Blagovno Trgovinski Center cant be short named BCH. Unless they change their name after 70 years of existence. Running such company is not like in crypto where you re brand yourself every 2 years.
1
u/kopachke Sep 30 '19
I believe this is Tus supermarket in BTC. You pay with BCH and get Eligma crypto tokens which serve as reward points. Eligma is actually the one that has a working product and is accepted in hundreds of stores around Slovenia and Croatia.
1
u/varota1985 Sep 30 '19
What is the name of those stores?
1
u/kopachke Sep 30 '19
They are all different stores and shops with different owners. Just search for Elipay locations.
-1
u/varota1985 Sep 30 '19
Yes but your statement that there are hundreds of them around croatia and slovenia is a lie.. Stores in croatia does not accept euros yet and you are spreading the fud that they are ready for crypto... lol
1
u/kopachke Sep 30 '19
I don’t get it, why is it a lie? That’s a bit dramatic. https://gocrypto.com/en/locations
1
u/varota1985 Sep 30 '19
Those locations use 3rd party payment services, you can’t pay directly from your wallet
2
u/kopachke Sep 30 '19
Yes, true, Roger Ver in this video also used this app. Here is the video https://youtu.be/oQv-012VE_M
Nonetheless, it is still a working product and a brave leap forward where retailers actually accept crypto as a payment and even give back rewards in crypto tokens back. I don’t know about you but i find that amazing.
1
u/homopit Sep 30 '19
Yes, they are using a payment processor, but you can use your BCH wallet to pay at Elipay locations, by scanning that QR code. It's a standard BCH payment request.
So far, I used bitcoin.com wallet, Badger wallet, Electron Cash Android wallet, Crescent Cash wallet.
My experience - https://old.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/c9ei8p/paid_with_electron_cash_android_wallet_at_elipay/
And another one - https://old.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/c9ei8p/paid_with_electron_cash_android_wallet_at_elipay/etl8xr5/
1
2
Sep 30 '19
So what, from the customers perspective they are paying with a BCH app on their phone which is all that matters. Now if they have a job that pays in BCH or any income from BCH they can direcly by food with it without the hassle got get fiat for it.
That's called customer comfort.
1
u/homopit Sep 30 '19
you can’t pay directly from your wallet
Yes, you can. At Elipay equipped stores you can use a regular BCH wallet to pay.
So far, I used bitcoin.com wallet, Badger wallet, Electron Cash Android wallet, Crescent Cash wallet.
1
u/homopit Sep 30 '19
There are more than 400 of them in Slovenia, and about 20 in Croatia so far. https://elly.com/en/locations
1
u/homopit Sep 30 '19
TUŠ supermarket, that's equipped with a self-serving terminal. https://elly.com/en/locations
1
u/Febos Sep 30 '19
It is in all big TUŠ stores. And is like this for more then half year. Accepting few coins. Lets hope for the best it will be used and will not take off.
15
u/Dugg Sep 29 '19
Looks pretty slow
31
u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Sep 29 '19
It was unusually slow this time for some reason. I’ll go back again tomorrow and buy some more.
11
1
u/nicethingslover Sep 30 '19
It may seem less flashy but for me this is good. Knowing what a sub-optimal experience is like is very valuable. And I must say, if this is bad then I definitely still would love to be able to use it where I live.
-16
u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Sep 29 '19
Yea, that seemed really slow. Also, as bitcoin cash becomes less popular as a store of value, do you recommend purchasing it using a debit card immediately before, then spending it at the grocery check out?
12
12
u/sandakersmann Sep 29 '19
More usage leads to more value stored. I even hold some fiat and the only reason I do that is because it can easily be spent.
-8
u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Sep 29 '19
More usage leads to more value stored.
Then why is BCH collapsing in value relative to BTC? The narratives here have some holes.
8
u/ErdoganTalk Sep 29 '19
Assuming you are serious: You need to think my friend. The BTC does not have transactional capacity to onboard new users...unless some others leave. Due to heavy disinformation pressure, the market can not see that - not yet.
10
u/MoonNoon Sep 29 '19
lol I’m not worried. I got into bitcoin because of the fundamentals. Nothing has changed in that regard.
0
4
u/wickedplayer494 Sep 29 '19
But quicker than holding up one of those for 10 minutes or more, to be fair.
-2
u/Dugg Sep 29 '19
Well as a payment tool your rival is Visa and Cash. In both instances would have completed before the Bitcoin.com app.
6
u/wickedplayer494 Sep 29 '19
Visa (and its rivals of MasterCard and American Express) can still be bottlenecked by slow internet connectivity, particularly in America where many payment terminals are still backed by dial-up.
Physical cash is definitely pretty hard to compete against, though speed-wise there's always the risk you run into a cashier of low skill, or maybe they run out of a certain bill or coin and need to retrieve/crack open a roll of some. And automated bill acceptors take a moment to do their thing, usually 1 bill at a time in most cases.
1
u/tl121 Sep 30 '19
Speed depends on who is timing. There is the customer's time and the clerk's time. The clerk's time is born by the employer. In the case of cash, the employer has additional time required to count the cash and to verify that the clerk isn't skimming.
0
u/Dugg Sep 29 '19
particularly in America
There is your problem, Europe is 10 years ahead with this kind of stuff. Not surprising a European grocery store is running this experiment not a US one.
Visa Contactless will go through faster than it takes to grab your bags off the bagging area.
there's always the risk you run into a cashier of low skill
I don't see a cashier in this video? Are they inside the machine?
insert your money and seconds later your change comes out.
If you actually watch Rogers video you will see it takes 40 seconds from pressing pay, to the payment completing.
10
u/tralxz Sep 29 '19
Beautiful to see this. BCH ftw
3
Sep 30 '19
Yeah this is a super cool video. Man I wish I could convince the local superstore here to go with elipay. That would be so awesome.
8
5
4
4
2
u/worthlessTbill Sep 30 '19
Still feels a lot like standing behind that person that takes 15 minutes to write a check.
At some point maybe the transaction side will get there.
1
u/cryptos4pz Sep 30 '19
Still feels a lot like standing behind that person that takes 15 minutes to write a check.
There were several things that could have been faster which added together were slow.
First, there is no reason Roger should have had to touch the screen twice before scanning the QR code. At any point when he was done scanning there should have been a small QR code, maybe in a corner, where he could have scanned and got the total, ready for payment. Second, Roger had to get his phone ready to pay; in the future there might be a "grocery shortcut" icon which opens the correct wallet and awaits the QR code, 1-click. For small amounts, once it scans the payment is sent. Last, on the EliPay terminal side, they just need to get that consistently faster, which can happen with time. Altogether, paying via BCH can be faster than any existing payment method, including fumbling with cash and coins.
2
2
2
2
u/SpeakSlowly4Me Sep 30 '19
Grocery store is still running the risk of that block not getting confirmed, correct?
Genuinely curious if someone can explain this from more technical perspective. What if Roger decides he wants to buy some clothes, can he rush there, and pay for a higher priority?
3
u/Tiblanc- Sep 30 '19
No need to rush to buy clothes. Simply pay yourself.
What is the risk of a chargeback from a credit card purchase? If I lost my credit card, anyone could use it for payments under $100 until I disabled it, yet merchants don't hold me captive for days until cash settles months later.
User experience is worth more to commerces than bullet proof security. The vast majority of people will not risk fraud charges and this allows 0-conf to work on legacy and crypto payments. The use cases where you need confirmations don't need instant delivery of services.
1
u/SpeakSlowly4Me Sep 30 '19
You are correct, however once a credit/debit card is ran, there is no way of returning the funds until the item posts and there is a dispute filed; or if the merchant fails to send through their batch of transaction. If you swipe a card for a $1 transaction, have it go through, and then call your bank to close it, the transaction will still pend and post unless the merchant does not send that batch through.
I’m coming from the point of merchants. A clothing store was a bad example. Let’s say, with this same system, we are in a gas station. We perform an equivalent $10 transaction.
We know with a credit/debit card once that transaction is ran, the transaction cannot be stopped so the transaction is, and always will be legitimate.
If a block is not confirmed, that is going to lose user’s (particular merchants) trust in the long run. Someone could make this equivalent $10 transaction through BCH, run across the street to the other gas station, and make this same transaction and pay for a higher priority. Make sense?
I’m still curious for an answer though.
4
u/Tiblanc- Sep 30 '19
You can do a chargeback by calling your credit card company weeks later. You'll get your money back and someone will eat the loss, either the merchant or credit card company.
A double spend attack is similar to a chargeback because you sign another transaction with the same UTXO. The merchant will have an unspendable UTXO because its parent won't be in a block.
The merchant can take this to court by linking 2 known transactions signed from the same output. Publishing a double spend would be like counterfeiting money on top of commiting a fraud. It won't be long before clever thieves try this and get busted, like drug dealers of early 2010s with BTC.
From the point of view of a merchant, this is more secure because double spend attacks have to occur within seconds. You can keep video footage as proof or alert authorities immediately. A credit card chargeback can occur weeks after the event and you lose all hope of catching the thief.
1
u/cryptos4pz Sep 30 '19
You'll get your money back and someone will eat the loss, either the merchant or credit card company.
The merchant (meaning customer ultimately) eats the loss either way. If the card company eats the loss they just raise their already high processor fees. All fees eventually get passed to the customer in the form of higher prices or degraded quality/service.
For the customer and merchant to have the best experience possible, there should be as little friction & middlemen/fees between their transaction as possible.
1
u/Tiblanc- Sep 30 '19
Right, so if in both cases the merchant takes the loss, then accepting 0-conf is the same than accepting credit card payments. As a benefit, they get their money instantly and don't need to pay 3% to the credit card company.
If a merchant wants 0 risk for all transactions, they'll have to go through a trusted entity that will guarantee payments. That entity will charge a fee based on double spend risk and profit. This would be good for businesses with low transaction volume. For a supermarket, they have enough volume that variance has little impact and would not benefit from hedging the risk.
1
u/cryptos4pz Sep 30 '19
I agree with everything except for this:
"If a merchant wants 0 risk for all transactions, they'll have to go through a trusted entity that will guarantee payments."
I think it's impossible for any merchant to have 0 risk. For example, there is risk of theft (eg some items not being scanned etc). Even with a cash transaction there is risk the paper is counterfeit. So there is always risk just to be in business. The goal is simply to reduce risk so small that it's easy to still profit. I think that's what Bitcoin Cash enables, either by accept payments directly or using an efficient pay processor. :)
2
u/tisallfair Sep 30 '19
It's exceedingly difficult to double spend on the BCH network without raising some red flags. Since valid transactions are almost always processed in the next block, a payment processor can easily scan the mempool for other transactions from or to the same wallet and choose to calculate the current balance in the time order the transactions were generated. Thus, for low to medium value transactions, a merchant can be reasonably confident they won't be screwed.
0
Oct 06 '19
[deleted]
1
u/tisallfair Oct 06 '19
A 0 sat fee would immediately be flagged by a payment processor as suspicious. I imagine a brick and mortar store would opt to inform the client why a wait is necessary and an honest client would pony up the fraction of a cent next time to avoid this issue.
1
u/homopit Sep 30 '19
Grocery store
No, not the store. They are using a payment processor, Elipay, that takes all the risk. The store gets € in their bank account.
1
1
1
u/livmarsh1992- Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 30 '19
Brilliant I wish they will bring in more places to pay via Bitcoin.
1
1
u/omegaalphaomega Sep 30 '19
simply amazing.
1
u/omegaalphaomega Sep 30 '19
to imagine that one day I might be able to live a peaceful life in a city without a bank account
1
u/pearjinman Redditor for less than 2 weeks Sep 30 '19
This is so cool, this makes me believe that bitcoin will finally get the appaluse it deserves! What are your thoughts on bitcoin? Here is what CoinJanitor thinks...
https://www.coinjanitor.io/news/why-does-coinjanitor-believe-in-bitcoin/
1
u/AnoniMiner Sep 30 '19
Disclaimer: Eligma has a strategic cooperation with Bitcoin.com. None of the information in this article is intended as investment advice, as an offer or solicitation of an offer to buy or sell, or as a recommendation, endorsement, or sponsorship of any products, services, or companies. Neither Bitcoin.com nor the author is responsible, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on any content, goods or services mentioned in this article. This editorial is for informational purposes only.
1
u/zeptochain Sep 30 '19
Awesome!
If I could do that everywhere I go to buy stuff, I'd have one less thing to take with me EVERY time I leave the house (my physical wallet of cash and cards).
Bring it on.
1
u/worthlessTbill Oct 01 '19
Not saying it won’t. Just still has a very long way to go. Not to mention the lack of acceptance globally for everyday goods.
Devils advocate.
1
1
1
u/galan77 Redditor for less than 6 months Oct 02 '19
There are literally thousands of cryptos that are accepted at some store.
If this is something special for bch, then it’s a bit weak
1
1
u/Wiebel- Redditor for less than 60 days Oct 04 '19
Wow so cool!
1
u/radicalwhale Oct 04 '19
50 @spicetokens
1
u/SpiceTokens Redditor for less than 60 days Oct 04 '19
Hi! I have transferred your tip of 50.0 🌶 SPICE 🌶 to Wiebel-
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
u/mrladdie Sep 30 '19
So it didn't require any confirmations? Sounds like a bad plan on the stores part
2
u/Plasmatica Sep 30 '19
I don't know what terms BitPay sets for merchants, but I'd assume BitPay takes on the risk of double spends.
0
0
0
-34
u/imyewya028 Sep 29 '19
Buying trash with B trash....
9
-1
u/dadachusa Sep 30 '19
Hopefully there is also a men's clothing store somewhere in there...
Now do a BTC payment with the same tx fee, a couple of cents. We know you still hold plenty...
-2
-8
u/srdulam Sep 30 '19
Just a stunt; Who wants to use volatile asset as cash; it will fade same with BTC or BTC Cash or any other volatile asset; People will hold it but not spend it;
What we all need is BTC / BTC Cash kinda asset which is stable or say "Decentralized stable coin" to use as money for purchase.
3
0
Sep 29 '19
[deleted]
17
u/BouncingDeadCats Sep 29 '19
Bullshit
I’m not a fan of bitcoin in general (mostly hold ETH and XTZ) but I’m impressed by the constant push for BCH adoption and payment integration.
I wish BCH success. If you succeed, the rest of us succeed.
6
u/BsvAlertBot Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 29 '19
u/ScotchHorse666's history shows a questionable level of activity in BSV-related subreddits:
BCH % BSV % Comments 80.0% 20.0% Karma 25.0% 75.0% This bot tracks and alerts on users that frequent BCH related subreddits yet show a high level of BSV activity over 90 days/1000 posts. This data is purely informational intended only to raise reader awareness. It is recommended to investigate and verify this user's post history. Feedback
52
u/greencycles Sep 29 '19
No fees other than the one cent tx fee?