r/btc • • Sep 25 '19

A single person controls nearly half of all the Lightning Network’s capacity

https://www.theblockcrypto.com/daily/41069/we-interviewed-the-person-that-controls-40-of-lightning-networks-capacity-heres-what-they-had-to-say
139 Upvotes

102 comments sorted by

29

u/jjduhamer Sep 25 '19

Can someone copy-paste it? It's subscribe-walled...

30

u/Neutral_User_Name Sep 25 '19 edited Sep 25 '19

Person behind 40% of LN’s capacity: ‘I have no doubt in Bitcoin and the Lightning Network’ by The Block
SEPTEMBER 25, 2019, 3:22PM EDT · 5 MIN READ

QUICK TAKE

  • Since its launch, the Lightning Network grew to nearly 10,000 public nodes with over 36,000 active channels with a total capacity of almost $7 million

  • One of the largest contributors to this growth is LNBIG, an entity which makes up 40% of the network’s capacity

  • The Block has reached out the anonymous individual behind LNBIG to answer some questions

Since launching on the Bitcoin mainnet in early 2018, the Lightning Network has experienced significant adoption and growth. The first Lightning Network implementation developed by Lightning Labs was launched in beta in March 2018. The other two popular implementations were developed by ACINQ and Blockstream which were launched in late March and late June, respectively.

Since its launch, the Lightning Network has actively been stress-tested in the public. In less than two years, the layer-two scaling solution for Bitcoin has grown to nearly 10,000 public nodes with over 36,000 active channels with a total capacity of almost $7 million at the time of this writing.

Behind the Lightning Network’s growth is LNBIG, a mysterious entity which, at times, made up over 40% of the Lightning Network’s capacity. Recently, The Block reached out to the anonymous individual behind the project to see if they would answer some burning questions our team and members of the community have.

Our conversation covered a wide range of topics, from the person’s background, their reason for launching so many Lightning nodes, their vision for the future of Bitcoin and the Lightning Network, and how they feel about the growth of Ethereum and DeFi.

Below is an excerpt from our conversation. Our interview has been edited for clarity. The full interview is available for Daily and Genesis subscribers here.

The Block: Do you want to share something about yourself?

I have been familiar with bitcoin since the beginning of 2014. I am a programmer, and I was initially skeptical about this system. When I first read the Bitcoin whitepaper, I understood the point. Then I tried the “Bitcoin Core” (“Bitcoin Qt” at the time) node, and I waited a long time for it to sync, which did not impress me. Only after I tried Andreas Schildbach’s Bitcoin Wallet and made several payments between it and Bitcoin Core and the bitcoin transactions go through immediately — only then was I really impressed by this technology.

The Block: How much of LN’s capacity do LNBIG’s nodes currently control?

The sum of all local balances in channels in LNBIG network is 331.5 BTC. The total LN capacity is 832.2 BTC. But, I have 1,800 channels between my nodes and each channel with a capacity of 0.16. So LNBIG’s capacity is about 40% of the total capacity.

The Block: What was the reason that you launched so many LN nodes? You said that you don’t run the nodes for financial reasons but rather as a way to support the network. Is that still the case?

At first, I had no idea I would be running so many nodes. I experimented in March-April 2018 with the testnet. I also wanted to understand the technical side. At first, I tried c-lightning, but I had problems compiling it. Then Eclair fell away because not all OS’s have the correct version of Java, and installing it from the source is a painful process. Then I tried LND and, surprisingly, it turned out to be easy to compile and run.

The Block: Based on the growth of LN so far, are you bullish on its success? Is it too early to judge LN’s success?

This is not the first time I had to wait for the success of a technology. Before my eyes, bitcoin has grown from $230 to $20,000. I have no doubt in Bitcoin and the Lightning Network. In any case, the Lightning Network is the same breakthrough in itself as Bitcoin. Micropayments are the future. Especially without waiting a long time. Over the year, I saw how many merchants on the Lightning Network appeared. I see no reason for this to slow down. It may take another year for LN to get the properties users need. The infrastructure for payments will be formed. But the basic infrastructure is already there, and it’s becoming significant. I am now so used to paying with LN that I use on-chain transactions only if the merchant does not accept LN or if it’s a payment above the current LN’s limits.

The Block: You said that you earn “5,000–10,000 sats per day” or “$20 a month maximum” from routing fees, and that you spent more than $1,000 on opening and closing the channels. Is that still the case?

Recently, I have reduced commissions to virtually zero. Earning $20 a month or zero is not a big difference. Having lowered the commission, I wanted to see how many payments go through my nodes per day in order to indirectly understand the number of payments in the Lightning Network. But having reduced and observed, I did not see a big correlation with the commissions. The number of payments was still 300–400 per day. Maybe a maximum of 600.

Of course, I can be very mistaken, but I think that a maximum of 1,000–1,500 payments go to the network per day. The exact number is not known if users prefer to pay merchants through a direct channel. When I wrote that I spent a thousand dollars on channels, that amount was calculated very roughly. I took the approximate number of open channels and multiplied the channel opening transaction by the average network commission. The reality is a bit more complicated. The biggest losses start when the channel closes. If you can choose a small commission for the Bitcoin network to open a channel, then closing the channel, especially if it is force closing, the commission there is determined by contractual relations at the protocol level. In addition, closure can give rise to a long chain of transactions, the commission of which is paid by the initiator of the opening of the channel.

The Block: What do you think is the biggest weakness of LN?

The weakness is that few users are familiar with it. Take Bitcoin network users; every day about 300,000–350,000 transactions are made on the blockchain, and in the Lightning Network, about 1,000. If at least a small percentage of people who use bitcoin would transfer their transactions to the Lightning Network, they would instantly make my project profitable, for example.

24

u/Neutral_User_Name Sep 25 '19

My favourite quote:

The biggest losses start when the channel closes. If you can choose a small commission for the Bitcoin network to open a channel, then closing the channel, especially if it is force closing, the commission there is determined by contractual relations at the protocol level. In addition, closure can give rise to a long chain of transactions, the commission of which is paid by the initiator of the opening of the channel.

HA-ha-ha-ha-ha.

3

u/likebike2 Sep 26 '19

Can you please explain why you think this is funny? I don't know enough about Lightning to understand what you mean.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

Say your node opens a channel to my node, at a time of low fees.

Say I force close the channel at a time of my choosing. What the quote says is that it is you, the one that opened the channel, that will pay the fees for me force closing it.

Disclaimer: I cannot verify nor falsify this claim.

14

u/MoonNoon Sep 26 '19

Thank you for sharing the article. So this guy is just running a charity hoping that LN takes off.

5

u/unitedstatian Sep 26 '19

So the LN is far worse in hub centralization than predicted?

4

u/Fly115 Sep 25 '19 edited Sep 25 '19

Edit: Removed copy/paste as someone else beat me to it

7

u/bgrnbrg Sep 26 '19

Many decentralized.

Such hodl.

Wow.

19

u/opus_1 Sep 25 '19

This is not the first time I had to wait for the success of a technology. Before my eyes, bitcoin has grown from $230 to $20,000.

Does this fool not understand that BTC being Tether pumped to 20K was not a “success” of the tech. The tech literally fucking broke and was unusable. Even P & D admit LN can't work with full blocks.

9

u/meta96 Sep 25 '19

haha, lightning is a cryptho joke

3

u/brandguerrero Sep 26 '19

Nothing surprising in this situation.

2

u/Egon_1 Bitcoin Enthusiast Sep 26 '19

That's good for BCH!

0

u/Fly115 Sep 25 '19

Controls

This is a bit misleading. Having high capacity on LN does not buy you any power over the network (unlike a POW/POS network). Each node runs their own rules which have no influence over other nodes. If they jack up their fees or do something else dodgy people can easily choose to route around them.

If someone wants to lock up a heap of money on LN they can do as they like. They wont get much profit from it

12

u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Sep 26 '19

This is actually a bit misleading. Borrowing from another comment of mine:

It’s important to keep in mind that the Lightning Network is not a piece of software. It’s a network of nodes and channel connections that grows and changes as people open channels, route payments through those channels (thereby changing their liquidity states), and close channels. There is of course a cost to opening a channel. This cost includes the cost of the requisite on-chain transaction as well as an opportunity cost, e.g., funds committed to one channel can’t simultaneously be used to fund another channel with someone else. There is also a cost associated with the risk that a particular channel will not prove useful, leading to its closure in the future and the re-dedication of those funds to some other channel, thereby necessitating additional on-chain fees. On the other hand, the primary benefit of opening a channel, at least as far as end users are concerned, is the possible future payments it will allow you to send and receive. The greatest benefit in these terms is provided by a well-funded (on both sides) channel connection to a channel partner who has a huge number of other well-funded channel connections, i.e., a “hub." That's the kind of channel that enables you to send and receive the most payments and do so with the shortest (and thus, likely the cheapest, easiest-to-find, and least-likely-to-fail) routes. Of course, becoming such a “hub” will require massive capitalization to fund all of these channels. There’s also a positive feedback loop / network effect aspect to hub formation. As an emerging hub grows more connected, it becomes an even more desirable channel partner, encouraging even more connections, making it an even more desirable channel partner, etc., etc. A constrained base blockchain amplifies this naturally-centralizing dynamic by greatly increasing the cost of opening and closing channels. If, for example, it costs $50 every time someone goes to open (or close) a channel, individuals will have a strong incentive to be very reluctant to open channels with any nodes other than those who can provide the most benefit (i.e., massively-capitalized, massively-connected hubs). And of course, the real minimum number of LN channels for a user is not one -- it's zero. High on-chain fees will price some users out of using the LN entirely. They'll opt for cheaper (and infinitely easier to use) fully-custodial solutions.

If they jack up their fees or do something else dodgy people can easily choose to route around them.

Unfortunately, that's not likely to be the case, especially when the base blockchain is highly constrained. If your channel partner jacks up their fees or does something else dodgy, you can try to route around them by closing the channel (unilaterally if your now-dodgy partner refuses to cooperate) and moving those funds to a new channel with a hopefully less dodgy partner, but the transaction fees required to take that action could make it potentially quite expensive. And the real difficulty may simply be finding another channel partner who is as well-connected and capitalized as the one you're leaving. In short, the problem is that LN hubs naturally develop a strong network effect and will thus tend to become entrenched and costly to route around. It's sort of like saying that governments can't misbehave when it comes to management of their currencies. "If they do, users will just migrate to superior forms of money like crypto that can't be arbitrarily inflated." Well, yeah, maybe. Eventually (we hope). But it's still a difficult and costly migration because of the power of network effects.

1

u/Fly115 Sep 26 '19

Of course 'hubs' will appear. The only danger would be if there were no options but to use a malicious hub (i.e no other well funded nodes). There are already hundreds of nodes with greater than 1BTC and well funded channels (0.16777215 BTC is the current default limit). And there is no reason why the number of routing options wouldnt increase over time. Even if you assume every LN user is dumb and can't make good decisions on which node to connect with, its trivial for wallet software to simply find nodes that agree on x,y,z rules and have good fees.

With splicing you will be able to open multiple channels (or top up an existing channel) all in one multi-output transaction. This adds very little cost to the tx and provides incentive for people to have multiple channels.

Your argument of 'it will cost to much to open channels' is entirely dependent on how the fee market develops.
- On-chain capacity increases as more txs are moved off-chain. I've done 50+ LN payments with one channel, which has clearly reduced onchain load. This keeps onchain txs cheaper.
- There are now Fiat to LN onramps meaning you can refund channels without additional on-chain txs. 'Wallet of satoshi' has also done this for a while now. Or you can splice in new BTC to an existing channel.
-On chain is just inherently expensive (imagine asking 10k+ computers to keep a record of your coffee purchase for ever and ever). Blocksize increase is always an option down the road.

Opportunity cost is a stupid argument considering almost everyone has their BTC sitting in a wallet doing nothing anyway.

Your last point again assumes people would only have one channel connected to a 'bad' hub. The worst they can do is jack up the fees because changing the rules would close the channel and/or incur a penalty on them. Why jack up the fees in a competitive market? The route will be decided in the back-end of a good wallet. People will use the good wallet because it works the best.

Why fight so hard against having another payments option? LN is quite similar to just putting bitcoin on a stick and trading the stick around different merchants. -except you can do it in a way that guarantees no previous owner of the stick can take your money, and in a way that lets you trade online.

10

u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 26 '19

Of course 'hubs' will appear.

Absolutely. The LN's naturally emergent topology is centralized, and the pressures towards centralization become progressively stronger the more the base blockchain it's operating on top of is constrained.

The only danger would be if there were no options but to use a malicious hub (i.e no other well funded nodes).

Well, no I don't think that's the only danger. And the usefulness of a hub isn't just determined by how well funded it is. It's also based on its connectivity. Coins in the LN have position-dependent value. Coins positioned closer to the center of economic activity are more useful (and thus more valuable) than coins positioned on the network's periphery. High on-chain fees increase this discrepancy in value (and thus undermine fungibility) by increasing the costs of converting poorly-positioned coins into well-positioned coins.

And there is no reason why the number of routing options wouldnt increase over time.

But there absolutely IS reason to expect the number of routing options to decrease over time. The LN's fundamental liquidity issue stems from the fact that a LN channel is like beads on a string. The beads can't leave the string (without additional on-chain transactions). There are liquidity issues even in the pathological and 100%-centralized case of a single mega-hub that everyone else connects to. But that's the case that minimizes the network's liquidity problems (although it requires an insane amount of capital on the part of the mega-hub) because it minimizes the number of (inherently-flow-limiting) strings. The more decentralized you imagine the LN's network topology being, the worse the liquidity problem becomes.

With splicing you will be able to open multiple channels (or top up an existing channel) all in one multi-output transaction. This adds very little cost to the tx and provides incentive for people to have multiple channels.

No, that only partially reduces the disincentive for people to have multiple channels. The more channels you have, the more value you need to set aside to allow for those channels' future closure.

Your argument of 'it will cost to much to open channels' is entirely dependent on how the fee market develops. On-chain capacity increases as more txs are moved off-chain. I've done 50+ LN payments with one channel, which has clearly reduced onchain load. This keeps onchain txs cheaper.

Well, sure, artificially high on-chain fees discourage use of the blockchain and encourage use of off-chain alternatives. And high fees can also lead to demand destruction such that demand for on-chain transactions remains lower even after fees come down. But that's absolute poison for something like money whose value proposition is based almost entirely on the network effect. Also don't forget about the problem of securing the blockchain as the block subsidy diminishes and eventually disappears entirely. We've already established that the LN doesn't work with high on-chain fees. But Bitcoin proper (with a tiny, artificially-constrained capacity) doesn't work with low on-chain fees. In order to have "a lot" of security in the future, miners will need to collect "a lot" in transaction fees. Theoretically, that could be achieved in one of two ways: a huge number of individually-quite-cheap transactions (the original Satoshi plan) OR a relatively small number of individually-very-expensive transactions (the Core redesign). What absolutely can't work is a tiny number of individually-cheap on-chain transactions (with a much, much greater number of transactions being handled by the LN).

On chain is just inherently expensive (imagine asking 10k+ computers to keep a record of your coffee purchase for ever and ever).

Sorry, but no, on-chain transactions are absolutely NOT "inherently expensive" (or at least not in the sense that counts). Borrowing from another comment of mine:

Some quick googling just informed me that the average cost of hard drive storage is around 3 cents per gigabyte (or at least that's what it supposedly was in July 2017). Even if a particular blockchain allowed me to make really cheap transactions, I'm probably not going to be able to make 1-GB worth for 3 cents (or at least not in any reasonable time frame). If I assume 300-kb transactions and that each transaction only costs 1/10th of a penny, that's still over three bucks to make 1-GB worth. So yeah, compared to other databases, blockchains are "inherently expensive." But so what? Blockchains aren’t first and foremost generic databases. They are first and foremost monetary ledgers. And they’d better not prove to be “inherently expensive" for that function if we want them to successfully compete with other forms of money! (After all, the entire purpose of money is to reduce transactional friction.) Bitcoin's inventor certainly didn't think that blockchains are "inherently expensive" as payment networks. Read the first paragraph of the Introduction of the Satoshi whitepaper, e.g., "The cost of mediation increases transaction costs, limiting the minimum practical transaction size and cutting off the possibility for small casual transactions..." That's how Satoshi described one of the primary problems with conventional forms of digital money that he sought to address with his invention. Or how about these Satoshi quotes: "Bitcoin is practical for smaller transactions than are practical with existing payment methods. Small enough to include what you might call the top of the micropayment range. But it doesn't claim to be practical for arbitrarily small micropayments." And then later in that thread: "While I don't think Bitcoin is practical for smaller micropayments right now, it will eventually be as storage and bandwidth costs continue to fall." Link.

Blocksize increase is always an option down the road.

Well, it's not "always" an option. But sure, BTC probably still has some time to unfuck its protocol. The danger is that "Bitcoin delayed" sufficiently will eventually prove to be "Bitcoin denied." Setting the adoption of Bitcoin back enough might render it weak enough to kill. Bitcoin's front-loaded issuance schedule was designed to give Bitcoin a non-trivial (but certainly finite) period of time to grow its network effect / transaction volume to the point that network security can be adequately funded primarily (and eventually entirely) by transaction fees as the block subsidy diminishes.

Your last point again assumes people would only have one channel connected to a 'bad' hub

No, it doesn't assume that. Many people, especially those with less money, might have zero channels if the on-chain fee environment is bad enough. But even if you have your funds spread across multiple channels, that only partially mitigates the problem. "Great, only some of my money is tied up in poorly-positioned, value-destroying channels (or essentially equivalent, with a now-malicious partner) that make it difficult or impossible to spend how I want."

The worst they can do is jack up the fees because changing the rules would close the channel and/or incur a penalty on them. Why jack up the fees in a competitive market?

Because it won't be "competitive." You're ignoring the overwhelming significance of network effects here, and the way that these would enable a handful of hugely-capitalized, mega-hubs to entrench themselves at the network's center. Your question is sort of like someone asking: "why would central banks ever debase their currency via arbitrary money printing in a competitive market for money?"

Why fight so hard against having another payments option?

Huh? I want people to have more options. As I've said before many times, there will always be a natural balance between money proper (in Bitcoin's case, on-chain transactions) and various money substitutes (whether those are traditional, fully-custodial banking networks or a semi-custodial banking system like Lightning). The problem with an arbitrary and increasingly-inadequate limit on the capacity of the former is that it distorts this balance and limits options by forcing users off the blockchain proper and onto inherently less secure and more centralized substitutes.

LN is quite similar to just putting bitcoin on a stick and trading the stick around different merchants. -except you can do it in a way that guarantees no previous owner of the stick can take your money, and in a way that lets you trade online.

Don't take this the wrong way, because I say it with love. But that might be the worst analogy I've ever seen. :P

2

u/ssvb1 Sep 26 '19

Theoretically, that could be achieved in one of two ways: a huge number of individually-quite-cheap transactions (the original Satoshi plan) OR a relatively small number of individually-very-expensive transactions (the Core redesign). What absolutely can't work is a tiny number of individually-cheap on-chain transactions (with a much, much greater number of transactions being handled by the LN).

If you check the LN whitepaper, then you can see that it estimates that the whole world adoption would need ~130MB blocks and each user would be doing roughly 3 on-chain transactions per year (to manage their LN channels). According to fork.lol stats, right now BTC blocks have ~1MB average size and are providing total ~$107K rewards per block for miners. And ~$2K gets contributed by transaction fees from ~2K transactions per block. With ~130MB blocks, each block is going to provide ~$260K from transaction fees alone if transaction fees remain at ~$1 per transaction level. This is more than the current block reward and should keep the network secure.

Have you tried to estimate the size of BCH blocks, which would be necessary for the whole world adoption?

3

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 26 '19

Have you tried to estimate the size of BCH blocks, which would be necessary for the whole world adoption?

We could have VISA level throughput onchain in about 30 years, without significantly increased node cost, simply by taking advantage of current growth rate of bandwidth and storage capacity.

The bigger issue is that we shouldnt be stunting onchain capacity and causing high fees during bitcoin's consumer growth stage, when eventually technological increases will make the blockchain bloat of 8mb blocks completely irrelevant.

1

u/WippleDippleDoo Sep 26 '19

actually, LN was designed in a hub and spoke model from day 0.

5

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 26 '19

Why fight so hard against having another payments option?

You guys miss the point every time. The point isnt to prevent 2nd layers from developing. The point is to not cripple the primary layer when 2nd layers clearly arent ready for effective consumer use. We told you morons this years ago, at which time many of the economically illiterate core devs claimed that fees would never exceed $1 usd. Fast forward a bit and we've had fee crisis events with up to $50 fees that occur at the worst possible time for consumer adoption.

its 2019 and you're still talking about theoretical proposals to prevent LN from being so godawful to use.

1

u/Fly115 Sep 26 '19

Then why is this sub filled with LN attacks? let it go. if it works it works. You have your big blocks now so carry on making BCH better. I wont stop you.

The BTC community/devs havn't done anything to cripple btc scaling. In fact they have stuck with the same basic protocol that satoshi had which included a 1mb block limit. What you are actually asking for is for a change to the consensus rules. which is fine, if you have consensus. The entire community literally voted on this at the time of the fork, and the market overwhelmingly supported not changing the blocksize right now. So don't be so sour just because you were in the minority group that didn't get your own way.

This is my point of view. This biggest risk to bitcoin failing its security. never compromise on security to get cheaper payments or any other tradeof. For this thing to survive as a world currency it needs to be robust enough to handle a world war. That means you cannot push nodes to a handful of centralized server farms. Node sync times and bandwidth costs already exclude a huge portion of people in the world.If you can create sound - unconfiscatable money then you have a chance at creating a payments currency - it doesn't work the other way around (paper money would have never worked if it wasn't originally backed by gold).

Don't be so bleak and impatient. There are alot of very smart people working on lots of different angles. The more work that happens the better. This tribalism doesn't help anyone.

6

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

What you are actually asking for is for a change to the consensus rules. which is fine, if you have consensus. The entire community literally voted on this at the time of the fork, and the market overwhelmingly supported not changing the blocksize right now.

Miners literally voted to increase the blocksize. And then a massive censorship campaign was waged and deception was carried out to prevent it from happening. Are you new here or something?

-1

u/Fly115 Sep 26 '19

Of course miners want big blocks. That doesn't mean it's the best decision long term. The only thing that keeps the miners in check is the market.

Can you seriously blame a 80+% defeat on censorship of reddit/Bitcoin forum. The Bitcoin world is much bigger than those small english forums. Maybe instead of these wild conspiracies you could just admit that not everyone came to the same conclusion you did.

6

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

Can you seriously blame a 80+% defeat on censorship of reddit/Bitcoin forum.

Like I said are you new here? Seriously, were you not around when the censorship took place?

The Bitcoin world is much bigger than those small english forums.

Those "small english forums" represented the vast majority of online discussion in the bitcoin world at that time, and represented the nexus of the bitcoin ecosystem. Bitcoin was literally developed on those english forums.

3

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

Of course miners want big blocks. That doesn't mean it's the best decision long term.

Also, why do you think miners want big blocks if not for long term interests of bitcoin?

1

u/Etovia Sep 26 '19

Also, why do you think miners want big blocks if not for long term interests of bitcoin?

they think they will earn more from many small fees, and that it is not possible to earn on lesser amount of higher fees.

4

u/dicentrax Sep 26 '19

Of course miners want big blocks. That doesn't mean it's the best decision long term.

Then who the fuck makes the decisions in this network, if it's not the main mining and economic nodes with actual skin in the game? A cabal of self anointed core devs perhaps?

2

u/dicentrax Sep 26 '19

The entire community literally voted on this at the time of the fork, and the market overwhelmingly supported not changing the blocksize right now. So don't be so sour just because you were in the minority group that didn't get your own way.

It was basically a 50/50 split, Bitcoin unilimited and Segwit2x gained a lot of traction in the community. Many miners and important economic nodes supported a blocksize increase.

There was never an objective discussion, only FUD and troll campaigns by certain high profile bitcoin core devs and massive censorship on the main forums (that's why /r/btc was created)

0

u/Fly115 Sep 26 '19

The least biased indicator is the free market. Even before the fork BCH futures were at 0.2BTC and market value has only been lower since. Now its less than 0.03BTC.

1

u/dicentrax Sep 26 '19

BS because a minority fork always has more inherent risk, therefore lower value. BCH is basically a hedge against BTC failing to scale.

Now imagine if BTC had 8MB blocks, it would have low fees, high security. Transactions would be allowed to grow organically for a few more years. More than enough time to work out robust 2nd layer scaling.

Ask yourself the question why BTC still has the goddamn tiny 1MB blocks ffs

1

u/Fly115 Sep 26 '19

minority fork.

Exactly. Minority. Thanks for proving my point.

It takes 3+weeks to sync a node right now. Bandwidth costs exclude many people already. Ask how long it would take if the blockchain was 8times bigger? Who would wait 24weeks? Or is that just for the handful of servers?

4

u/dicentrax Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 26 '19

Thanks for proving my point.

You don't prove a point.

A big part of the BTC community supported bigger blocks. They do not automatically have to support the pre segwit BCH minority fork.

Who would wait 24weeks?

The People who want to run a full node

The same people that want to fund 40% of the lightning network.

The same people that will need to sync in 30 years from now, and have to wait god knows how long despite the 1MB blocks.

And this inconvenience for a handful of people is the only fucking reason you don't want more transactions on chain? goddamn....

EDIT: and to your other argument. You worry about Bandwidth excluding some people to run full nodes, but your are totally fine for them to pay $10 per on-chain transaction?

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

Then why is this sub filled with LN attacks? let it go. if it works it works.

Because you morons said it was the solution to all our problems and it would be ready ages ago. We told you it wouldnt be, and guess what, we were right. And bitcoin continues to lose marketshare to alternatives because of it.

2

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

never compromise on security

uh oh, better decrease the blocksize to 300kb or less then.

0

u/Fly115 Sep 26 '19

Don't make changes unless majority agree. thats what makes bitcoin resilient to attacks. Majority will not agree to a blocksize decrease btw.

6

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

Don't make changes unless majority agree. thats what makes bitcoin resilient to attacks.

The majority did agree. Go look at threads before the censorship campaign. Look at miner signaling. Look at bitcoin businesses. There was a massive disinformation campaign to distort the will of the community.

2

u/nolo_me Sep 26 '19

Bitcoin was already successfully attacked. Devs with integrity were driven out and nodes running XT were DDoSed off the network.

0

u/concerned_mouse Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 26 '19

Of course it's misleading. LNbig has no control over the network whatsoever. Users are free to connect to any node they please and wallets either have or can implement routing fee limits.

3

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

Users are free to connect to any node they please

its not free because you have to pay to open a channel

-1

u/concerned_mouse Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 26 '19

Freedom of choice idiot, not the transaction fee.

4

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

If the fees are too high, lots of people don't have a choice. Money constrains people's freedom, idiot.

-1

u/concerned_mouse Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 26 '19

Entirely different issue. There are so little issues with the LN that you have to invent them in your mind. Even if fees are high, people are still free to choose which node they want to connect to should they decide to pay the on chain free and open a channel. It's really very simple to understand.

4

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 26 '19

Its entirely the same issue. I'm not concerned with your theoretical freedom of choice, I'm concerned with the practical reality and the economic incentives that determine real world human activity.

In the real world its not very interesting to say that consumers have the choice to live environmentally friendly if they just pay the higher prices. In the real world you need to make the desired outcome the economically incentivized one, or else you need the government to dictate it.

0

u/concerned_mouse Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 26 '19

It's an entirely different issue and off topic regarding the content of the parent comment to which we are replying and also the post topic.

I'm concerned with the practical reality and the economic incentives that determine real world aggregate human activity.

This has nothing to do with a single entity "controlling nearly half of the LN", which it doesn't, obviously.. You're basically arguing with yourself.

3

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

The topic is literally about economic incentives encouraging centralization in LN. That people theoretically have the freedom to route around that centralization isnt significant, because the alternative routing has costs which prevents it from being useful for most people. Those costs are entirely relevant, despite you not wanting to acknowledge them.

as was said earlier:

"If they jack up their fees or do something else dodgy people can easily choose to route around them."

"Unfortunately, that's not likely to be the case, especially when the base blockchain is highly constrained. If your channel partner jacks up their fees or does something else dodgy, you can try to route around them by closing the channel (unilaterally if your now-dodgy partner refuses to cooperate) and moving those funds to a new channel with a hopefully less dodgy partner, but the transaction fees required to take that action could make it potentially quite expensive. And the real difficulty may simply be finding another channel partner who is as well-connected and capitalized as the one you're leaving. In short, the problem is that LN hubs naturally develop a strong network effect and will thus tend to become entrenched and costly to route around. It's sort of like saying that governments can't misbehave when it comes to management of their currencies. "If they do, users will just migrate to superior forms of money like crypto that can't be arbitrarily inflated." Well, yeah, maybe. Eventually (we hope). But it's still a difficult and costly migration because of the power of network effects."

0

u/concerned_mouse Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 26 '19

You're entirely off topic unless you go through some serious mental gymnastics, as you've clearly displayed.

That people theoretically have the freedom to route around that centralization isnt significant

It isn't theoretical, they can do that.

because the alternative routing has costs which prevents it from being useful for most people. Those costs are entirely relevant, despite you not wanting to acknowledge them.

I'll just leave this here.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/nolo_me Sep 26 '19

There are so little issues with the LN that you have to invent them in your mind.

Preserving this for posterity.

0

u/concerned_mouse Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 26 '19

Please do.

2

u/nolo_me Sep 26 '19

It's funny because Lightning is a Rube Goldberg nightmare of issues that were never present in the base layer. Everything from routing to centralization to having to preemptively lock your coins into channels to worrying about channel state. Lightning isn't a scaling solution, it's an act of sabotage.

0

u/concerned_mouse Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 26 '19

It's funny because Lightning is a Rube Goldberg nightmare of issues that were never present in the base layer.

What nightmares? Have you ever used it? Run a node? You've been told its a nightmare.. it isn't. It also provides desirable functionality that isn't present in the base layer.

Everything from routing

Occurs automatically.

to centralization

It isn't centralized.

having to preemptively lock your coins into channels

Isn't an issue. Bitcoin are technically locked into the UTXO in which they reside, hence you require the private key to spend them.

worrying about channel state.

I run a node. I don't worry about that. Everything occurs automatically as far as channel states go except for rebalancing which is done via simple python script, static backups and watchtowers already exist.

Lightning isn't a scaling solution,

Sure it is.

it's an act of sabotage.

No it isn't. You're not forced to use it, it allows for free, instant and private transactions and the software and wallets are provided for free.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

[deleted]

2

u/Fly115 Sep 26 '19

wallets pick the best route in the backend.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

[deleted]

1

u/Fly115 Sep 26 '19

"too many choices for mom and pops"

"don't make decisions for me i want to choose"

comical.

you do realize every time you do a BTC/BCH transaction your wallet is making hundreds of choices for you in the background?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

[deleted]

2

u/Fly115 Sep 26 '19

I actually referenced both BTC and BCH. Thats not shifting the goal posts its just pointing out an inconsistency in your argument. if you are unwilling to trust LN software to find the cheapest LN route then you shouldn't be trusting your other wallets hold your keys and to sign and propagate your transactions to the rest of the network, at the right fee.

1

u/amtodd Sep 25 '19

Is it Brekken again?

1

u/Evanbrowncrypto Sep 26 '19

Lightning Network does show a lot of potential. In fact it has recently tied up with Canada's Crypto Exchange platform too.

Read: https://www.fintechcryptonews.com/canadian-bitcoin-company-joins-2-mins-btc-transactions-inter-exchange-network/

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

A single person controls all of Bitcoin Cash's code and nobody dares challenge him.

Amaury Sechet

A single person also controls the vast majority of all Bitcoin Cash related media, and backs Amaury Sechet

Roger Ver.

Whatever these two individuals say, goes. Name me the last time they both wanted something on BCH and didn't get it.

5

u/Egon_1 Bitcoin Enthusiast Sep 26 '19

So my comment from yesterday about tagging you as Core minion was correct :)

I strongly recommend to use RES, makes your life deception free

https://redditenhancementsuite.com/

3

u/WippleDippleDoo Sep 26 '19

I control a bitcoincash node, so this is clearly false.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

You don't affect anything.

Try to push a change in the code through.

2

u/ShadowOrson Sep 26 '19

Is it your intention to acquire as many down votes as you can, now that you've "found friends" in BSV?

Just because you say a thing does not make it true. Just because you make your print larger does not make it true, and honestly it makes deranged.

1

u/Phucknhell Sep 26 '19

Caps lock is cruise control for cool?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

I'm just trying to make a point. And that's not caps lock, I used the "#", "##", and "###" symbol at the start of a line to create headers.

-17

u/Etovia Sep 25 '19

And yet no one is really affected.

My transactions in LN zip at 0.0001$ and often less - far cheaper then expensive-for-microtransactions altcoin BCH.

Now that is a great actual decentralization one person can control 80% of LN and nothing much, still I can open channels to healthy part of network (in the main guy would start being uncooperative).

Free market. Pure decentralization.

80% and no problem in LN - yet in onchain mining, if someone would grab 80% of hashpower it would be a very serious concern.


Please watch how my informative, correct and valid post is being downvoted by angry people who backed the wrong horse when choosing their favorite coin.

18

u/BCHIsMyBitcoin Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 25 '19

Not interested in your rube goldburg machine. BCH on-chain zero conf works just fine and dead simple to use.

4

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

Pure decentralization.

lol I dont think you know what decentraliztion means.

"US banking system is decentralized because I can just use another bank if mine starts acting up, or even start my own!" /s

0

u/Etovia Sep 26 '19

"US banking system is decentralized because I can just use another bank if mine starts acting up, or even start my own!" /s

Yeah it would be - IF you could trivially start own bank, with investing like 1,000$ instead 1,000,000$ (for some very cheap credit union maybe, far more for a serious bank).

You can in Lightning Network on Bitcoin.

3

u/Fly115 Sep 25 '19

80%

It's actually 40%. Not sure why this 80% statistic has been floating around.

2

u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 26 '19

And yet no one is really affected.

Well, no, I would think not. After all, the LN is still a tiny experimental toy network being played with by a few thousand sticker-buying geek enthusiasts. It's not handling any meaningful level of commerce. The fundamental problem with the LN is that it's a necessarily-imperfect substitute for the actual Bitcoin network and that it has a natural tendency towards overwhelming centralization. And, even worse, that it becomes a progressively more imperfect substitute--and the incentives towards massive centralization become progressively stronger--as on-chain fees rise. The idea that the LN represents any kind of meaningful "scaling solution" for Bitcoin is a complete farce. Expanded thoughts here.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19

Got any other flavors of snakeoil to sell?

-13

u/BeardedCake Sep 25 '19

A single person controls most of BCH hash rate and y'all don't complain.

5

u/TechCynical Sep 26 '19

A single person controls most of BTC hash rate and y'all don't complain.

-2

u/BeardedCake Sep 26 '19

Some do, HOWEVER its much much worse on BCH thats why the hash rate has not increased even with the more efficient miners coming out.

5

u/andromedavirus Sep 26 '19

It's the same mining algo and groups with the capability to mine both, dumbass. All BTC miners are BCH miners. If someone attacks BCH, they switch over hash rate. Go read up on what happened with the BSV attack, you dimwit.

-1

u/BeardedCake Sep 26 '19

Go read up on what happened with the BSV attack, you dimwit.

Well it turns out you can't read, how many BTC miners switched to "save" BCH or was it one entity which controls majority of harshrate that switched over to protect their own balance sheet? We both know the answer to that. Fact of the matter is that there are plenty of miners which mine BTC, but would never switch to BCH just because they don't believe in viability of shitcoins. You will claim that if it was more profitable to mine BCH everyone would switch. Guess what, it WAS more profitable to mine BCH plenty of times and BCH/BTC hashrate ratio never changed much.

1

u/Cmoz Sep 26 '19

Fact of the matter is that there are plenty of miners which mine BTC, but would never switch to BCH just because they don't believe in viability of shitcoins.

Its not plenty for you to attack BCH. over 50% of BTC miners are bitcoin cash friendly. Thats all we need.

3

u/BiggieBallsHodler Sep 25 '19

Even if that was true, that wouldn't give him the powers that controlling most of LN does. Please learn how Bitcoin works instead of making misinformed comments.

0

u/BeardedCake Sep 26 '19

the powers that controlling most of LN does

Controlling the entire chain does not give u more control a node on LN? now that's a funny statement. Please learn how LN works.

5

u/ErdoganTalk Sep 26 '19

Controlling the entire chain does not give u more control

Learn the market, it is simple

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '19

[deleted]

7

u/mojo_jojo_mark Sep 25 '19

$18 a month.........

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '19

[deleted]

6

u/Egon_1 Bitcoin Enthusiast Sep 25 '19

6

u/cryptochecker Sep 25 '19

Of u/lalolandavive's last 151 posts (31 submissions + 120 comments), I found 6 in cryptocurrency-related subreddits. This user is most active in these subreddits:

SubredditNo. of postsTotal karmaAverageSentiment
r/IWantToLearn231.5Neutral
r/Bitcoin351.7Neutral
r/btc1-2-2.0Neutral

See here for more detailed results, including less active cryptocurrency subreddits.


Bleep, bloop, I'm a bot trying to help inform cryptocurrency discussion on Reddit. | ^Usage | ^FAQs | ^Feedback | ^Tips