r/btc • Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com • Sep 20 '19

The new Bitcoin Cash wallet is so fast!!!!!

329 Upvotes

191 comments sorted by

21

u/Damascene_U Sep 20 '19

When we are going to have it too? it's v5.11-rc3 currently for me on Android

65

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Sep 20 '19

We are getting closer. I guarantee it will be less than 18 months!

18

u/chainxor Sep 20 '19

What new features besides that blistering speed will be in it? :-)

37

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Sep 20 '19

SLP Tokens and Privacy Mode!

3

u/mantiss87 Sep 20 '19

What kinda privacy?

11

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Sep 20 '19

Cash shuffle and coin fusion. Maybe we will even get TOR into the mix too.

3

u/saddit42 Sep 21 '19

If you're looking for a next project at some point..: Tor itself would totally benefit from BCH micro payments to incentivize tor nodes to provide bandwidth and make the network immune to spamming

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

Would it be the first mobile wallet with cashshuffle?

I've been trying different wallets, but I'd be sold on that.

21

u/Damascene_U Sep 20 '19

That would be awesome. I can't wait to see SLP tokens support on the merchant app to start making deals with some local restaurants and send on chain meals to my friends. Thank you roger.

13

u/knowbodynows Sep 20 '19

Sending a meal. Very cool.

14

u/Damascene_U Sep 20 '19

I meant I go to a restaurant and buy like 10 meals, I told them every one paying with this meal token you give them one.

10

u/knowbodynows Sep 20 '19

It's obvious to me that Groupon should be all over SLP. I asked my friends but can't find a contact there yet.

11

u/Damascene_U Sep 20 '19

I think we should wait for SLP support in merchant app first.

-1

u/barsoapguy Sep 20 '19

And you never will.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

If you see this and haven't heard of the idea yet, the Gov't should issue foodstamps as a SLP token. The increased statistics on how/when/where they are spent would be the selling point.

4

u/mantiss87 Sep 20 '19

Chill with that, how am i gonna buy foodstamps off the junkies then?

8

u/chainxor Sep 20 '19

Nice!

Privacy mode - is that CashShuffle? Or something else?

3

u/Ishan1121 Sep 20 '19

Woah awesome..will it only for transaction between Bitcoin.com wallets or transaction with other wallets as well?

6

u/lubokkanev Sep 20 '19

It's all on the BCH network.

9

u/eyeofpython Tobias Ruck - Be.cash Developer Sep 20 '19

I've seen it live by a Bitcoin.com dev during the last meetup in Tokyo and was very jealous!

5

u/Egon_1 Bitcoin Enthusiast Sep 20 '19

🌶

19

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Sep 20 '19

It's like NFC fast

Which begs the question: when is NFC support coming? Seems like the next logical step?

20

u/Peter__R Peter Rizun - Bitcoin Researcher & Editor of Ledger Journal Sep 20 '19

Wasn't there a wallet for SV that already had NFC?

I really like the idea of NFC bitcoin payments. If designed right, NFC could also help improve privacy for SPV wallets. With NFC, the sender's phone can deliver the bitcoins directly to the receiver's phone. There is no need to use the bitcoin network itself as a relay.

It is kind of weird when you think about it, but when phone A sends a payment to phone B using QR codes, the payment is effectively sent all across the world and then back to phone B. Phone B learns of the payment from the network, rather than directly from phone A.

The privacy problem relates to the mechanics of how phone A learns of the payment from the network. One method is just to listen to all of the transactions on the network, but that would be a lot of bandwidth at scale. What happens instead right now with a wallet like BRD is that it registers its new receiving address for the payment in the BIP37 bloom filter is has with nearby full nodes. These nodes pass all transactions they receive through the filter, and send the wallet all the transactions that match. But this leaks information about which addresses are of interest to the SPV wallet. Copay-style wallets are even worse in this regard. The Copay server knows pretty much everything about the wallet except its private keys.

This complexity goes away if phone A sends the payment to phone B directly.

11

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Sep 20 '19

I think you're referring to the Handcash wallet which had NFC. Afaik they never released the source code or a spec for it.

12

u/Peter__R Peter Rizun - Bitcoin Researcher & Editor of Ledger Journal Sep 20 '19

Yes, that was it, thanks. And yeah it was closed source, wasn't it.

We need an open source NFC feature where the transaction is passed locally rather than via the network!

5

u/Egon_1 Bitcoin Enthusiast Sep 20 '19

Android allows NFC access to my knowledge.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

[deleted]

7

u/Peter__R Peter Rizun - Bitcoin Researcher & Editor of Ledger Journal Sep 20 '19

One or both of the wallets still need to broadcast it.

If you're thinking this leaks privacy, you're right. But I would argue less so and in an easier way to improve than registering one's addresses in a bloom filter (especially the way the bloom filters currently work).

The other potential privacy leak is when you fetch the Merkle branch proof to check that the payment was confirmed in a block.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Sep 21 '19

email me! [email protected]

Thanks!

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

when is NFC support coming?

The NFC fad has been "coming" for 2 decades now...

The market penetration (hardware wise) is going to get less from now on, not more.

9

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Sep 20 '19

Instant payments via smartwatches and credit cards, where you just blip it against a machine, means cryptos need something similar.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

Instant payments [ ] cryptos need something similar.

Are you seriously talking about needing more speed on a post that shows a practically instant payment?

We already have a faster-than-banks payment here...

6

u/craptocoin Sep 20 '19

When I buy my coffee I just tap with my debit card. It is a lot slower than this, but way more convenient.

6

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Sep 20 '19

No, I'm talking about convenience...

I was referring to how convenient other alternatives are. You just blip your watch or your credit card and you're done. This is what we need for cryptos as well.

3

u/skatistic Sep 20 '19

Wasn't this faster? I keep the NFC off most of the time so turning it on and high fiving phones seems like it'd take longer than scanning a QR code like this.

Is it more of a security concern?

12

u/caveden Sep 20 '19

I believe NFC can wake up the app, so you don't need to unlock and launch the app, click scan etc. It can be faster if that's true.

Plus NFC allows for the sender to be offline, delivering the tx directly to the receiver. This can be very helpful when connectivity is bad. After the BCH City conference we went further north for a Meet-up and in the way stopped at this small coastal town where some businesses accepted BCH. But mobile connectivity was so bad that at least one person couldn't make the payment.

4

u/skatistic Sep 20 '19

Ah I see, the working offline bit would be very helpful.

Thanks!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

[deleted]

1

u/caveden Sep 20 '19

Honestly I'm not sure. But it'd be great if I could just get the phone from my pocket, approach it to the sensor and done. Just like NFC CCs.

1

u/TiagoTiagoT Sep 20 '19

Not all phones got NFC; maybe something using ultrasound might work? What's the bandwidth available in the frequencies above the human hearing range that most phone speakers can emit and their mics pick up reliably a few CM apart?

1

u/500239 Sep 20 '19

NFC is too fragmented and makes no sense. Camera + QR code will work better in the majority of situations.

The reason you're bringing up NFC is most likely because you're using google/apple/samsung pay with your phone at classic PoS registers and expecting it.

56

u/Alexpander Sep 20 '19

Lightning fast.

14

u/PreviousClothing Sep 20 '19

lol 18 months

-18

u/mathaiser Sep 20 '19

Yawn. When I see this I know it’s zero conf and can’t be trusted for more than just a coffee.

Maybe more... “but I could buy $xxxx

Fine. So be it. At some level, with risk assessments and everything, it fails.

10 min per block. Many conf required for security no matter what. That is the speed I personally accept and only accept.

12

u/bUbUsHeD Sep 20 '19

you are delusional

-1

u/nyanloutre Sep 20 '19

Go to the infirmary

1

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19

10 min per block. Many conf required for security no matter what. That is the speed I personally accept and only accept.

What is your business that you accept only confirmed BTC transactions and no cash or credit or debit cards?

Because I don't think your business actually exists. I think you're just making this up.

0

u/mathaiser Sep 21 '19

Car sales

1

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19

oh, so it's not even relevant to the discussion. this discussion is about point of sale applications. nobody buys cars "at the register." but we can agree: car sales are not applicable for zero conf transactions, or Lightning transactions, or credit card or PayPal transactions either.

but see, I'm quite sure you're lying, because if you were really in car sales, you'd know this already, and you probably wouldn't be arguing you can double spend by spending at different coffee shops using copies of the same wallet

2

u/mathaiser Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19

You freaking asked me what my business was and I told you truthfully. I didn’t bring it up or say that was what we were talking about either. Despite my business which I told you, and I don’t know why you even asked me? I’m not saying that has anything to do here. I’m talking about point of sale and still think confirmations are needed no matter what. That’s what I said above and that’s what I’m representing here.

Hell, I could have a garage sale how about. I won’t let my shitty lawn mower go without conf. Sorry. Maybe I’m a weirdo but it’s me and this is the obstacle you need to overcome if you’re trying to convince me to accept it.

“You are your own bank”. Well, if that’s the case, I’m locked up more than Fort Knox and y’all can buzz off if you don’t like it.

I’ll keep using my credit card for quick in and out because of the guarantee and charge back ability and customer service. It’s not worth it to me otherwise even though I’m a stout believer in crypto.

1

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19

car sales are not "point of sale" which you would know if you'd ever bought one.

you think "all sales should be settled" then you go and talk about credit cards which literally take weeks /months to settle.

then you go on about how easy it is to double spend by using copies of a wallet. hahaha. fucking moron

you don't know the first thing about any of this. admit it.

1

u/mathaiser Sep 21 '19

I don’t know anything yep! No one cares and no one uses it. You’re really inspiring.

1

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19

go double spend a coffee or stfu

1

u/mathaiser Sep 21 '19

I’m not interested in that because I’m not a dick. But I don’t like using a product that is open to scammers and bad actors like that either. I know I personally can’t, but I also can’t hack someone’s devices to steal either. I’m specifically not able to do that, but others are and I don’t like to participate in that space.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19

where do you use credit cards? at what store?

I'm shocked! shocked! that such a store would accept an unsettled transaction. surely you educate the stores management on the danger of credit card fraud and explain how they need to wait 90 days for the payment to settle before giving the customer their merchandise.

1

u/mathaiser Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19

Customer service department? Investigations? Chargebacks? Regulations protecting both consumer and store? A general ability to hold people and businesses responsible and a framework to keep everyone in line? Credit cards have all of that. Crypto is FINAL.

Sure, credit cards are unsettled, but it’s not “all or nothing” either. A quality that I support in crypto is that it can’t be reversed, or charged back. The person you sent it to could have an anonymous wallet and once something is sent, it can never be undone, you’ll never find them again and theres no way for any government agency to protect you. That is why I don’t trust this shit. That’s why I wait for confirmations and for everything else, there’s MasterCard.

Personal preference. But at the same time, maybe I’m speaking from a point of view that others hold as wel and even IF it’s wrong, then at minimum that is a barrier to adoption that procrypto people need to realize is a reality. People. Don’t. Trust. It.

I DO trust it, but only when used with confirmation. Is that so hard to understand? Why is that something that you ostracize me about. You are so cavalier about throwing your money around... worry some,...especially when “you are your own bank.”

→ More replies (0)

1

u/foreigncircle Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 21 '19

Car sales takes several hours anyway. Hell I spent half the day there when I was making a cash purchase with no financing

1

u/laustcozz Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 22 '19

Zero Conf is exactly as secure as a personal check. As long as both parties treat it as such there is no problem. Fine for coffee. Fine for groceries if I know you or have your ID. Not fine to drive a car off a car lot.

Even something like a vending machine, if you put a 5 second double spend watch before vending the item, your profits from failed double spends should exceed your losses from successful ones.

1

u/foreigncircle Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 21 '19

So you wait 3 months before accepting a credit card transaction?

1

u/ComeToVoat4 Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 22 '19

When I see this I know it’s zero conf and can’t be trusted for more than just a coffee.

That's the point.....

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

[deleted]

-7

u/mathaiser Sep 21 '19

OkAy, you send bitcoin with zero conf to the Starbucks, then you use your other wallet with the same seed that has no recollection of the transaction and spend at another place and another. Once you paid 3 times at different places, two will be left unhappy when the actual block is mined. I’m not talking actual double spend, im talking tricking the wallet and no one knows any better until confirmations start showing up or don’t.

12

u/bUbUsHeD Sep 21 '19

you have no idea how Bitcoin cash works but keep on your retarded shitposting

it would be nice if you trolls got at least some basic concepts right, this way you are just embarrassing your employers

6

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19

this will never, ever work. you haven't the first clue what you're talking about.

and yet, behold your troll gold.

here's a hint: that second place you tried to spend at? it already sees your first txn. SMFH. but yeah you're a fucking genius telling us what's what, aren't you. delete your account.

7

u/JonathanSilverblood Jonathan#100, Jack of all Trades Sep 21 '19

Most wallets would see the unconfirmed transaction and not spend it again. You'd have to be at three different places at the same time for that to actually make sense.

I almost did once though. By using a multisig wallet (1-of-n) and being unaware of situation, both me and my girlfriend was shopping at roughly the same time. The unconfirmed was catched and handled properly in that case, but there could be an edge case for this particular setup, where if 2 or more make a payment within 1~2 seconds of eachother, then it might actually "fool" someone.

Of course, the proper solution to this is for the merchants PoS to be aware of this and do risk management, when a new TX comes in they can just keep a lookout for a second or two and have a strong alert if someothing goes wrong

Also, you're totally right that for high value purchases, the proper wait time is hashrate * blockcount on a sliding scale, not just "is included in a block".

1

u/ModafOnly Sep 22 '19

Interesting case. Didn't know you could double spend and not being aware of it Even with "preconsensus" enabled (avalanche, Delta blocks or whatever) you'll look like a thieve that tries to double spend. This never ever happens with a credit card (or with LN assuming it works one day)

Makes me wonder how we can patch this issue .. any idea ? I can imagine with a system like eth it's ok if you double spend 10$ if your account has 100$ on it (10$ will just disappeared from your wallet multiple time) but with a UXTO model ..

1

u/JonathanSilverblood Jonathan#100, Jack of all Trades Sep 22 '19

Well, with double-spend proofs and/or avalanche it actually sorts itself out very quickly, and you'd just have to pay again.

The key is detection, and either your wallets detect it in time and don't do a double-spend, or the PoS terminal would detect it after, but within a second or so and make a visiable and audible notification. Then the personel can just say that something went wrong with the payment, and the wallet should have already picked up the competeing transaction allowing you to try again.

1

u/ModafOnly Sep 22 '19

Yeah ok why not

1

u/foreigncircle Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 21 '19

You need to be online to send a transaction, so the wallet will know about the other transaction

The problem isn't tricking the wallet as that is trivial, I mean you could write your own.

The problem is the second merchant sees the first transaction as it was publically broadcasted and refuses service

1

u/mathaiser Sep 21 '19

So, you have three wallets with the same seed sending the same transaction at the same time from three different places and you get free stuff.

1

u/foreigncircle Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19

You are describing the easy part. Sending multiple transactions is really trivial, and no one is saying that you can't send doublespends. Like I said before, you can always make a wallet that allows doublespends which removes the need for this trickery

The difficult part is sending multiple transactions in a way where the merchant only sees the transaction going to them, and where the transaction they don't see gets confirmed.

Talking about why that's difficult gets really technical, but boils down to the fact that miners tend to mine the transaction they see first, which means if the merchant saw her transaction first, then most of the miners likely did as well

Remember we don't need fort Knox for point of sale. CC have a high fraud rate. We simply need a lower fraud rate then credit cards. Doublespends sometimes will work, but their effectiveness can be greatly reduced with good practices

At one point I was I routinely paying 5 digit cash payments with zero conf. There are ways to make it very safe while only making the person wait 1 minute or less

2

u/bextman Redditor for less than 2 weeks Sep 20 '19

Where can I download it?

5

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Sep 20 '19

In the Apple and google app stores. The current version will be updated to this one soon.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

How can it be so fast? I have seen apps do much simpler things in much longer duration, due to network latency.

-1

u/jeffzebub Sep 20 '19

It's probably just settled off the blockchain, like they had a Lightning Network channel open.

3

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19

nope, this is just zero conf the way bitcoin used to work until around 2016 - - the way it was always supposed to work before it got corrupted. read the satoshi snack machine thread.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=423.msg3819#msg3819

being able to accept "good enough" unconfirmed transactions was always part of the design. but it requires predictable next block inclusion, which BTC no longer supports (by design), but which BCH very much supports (per original vision of the software).

1

u/DavidScubadiver Sep 20 '19

That looks as fast as nano. Nice work! Does it require any kind of special setup?

2

u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Sep 21 '19

Nothing special.

7

u/LeoBeltran Sep 20 '19

I like it, but the optimization is only at the wallet level. Transactions still need to be included in a block, which takes longer.

In any case, that’s a pretty good application, although it would be great to have it as libre software without any proprietary components or Google’s spyware.

2

u/papacryptobear Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 20 '19

well.. thats impressive!

3

u/the_evil_priest Sep 20 '19

is this supposed to be impressive?

5

u/DyKarN Sep 20 '19

Can someone explain how it can be so fast when the average block is solved after 10 min?

27

u/ErdoganTalk Sep 20 '19

It shows unconfirmed transactions, which are safe under some conditions, and you can also spend the received coin immediately (the second transactions confirmed simultaneusly with the first, which is quicker than waiting for 1 conf, then waiting for the new transaction to be confirmed in the second block)

3

u/pistolpeteyoutube Sep 20 '19

So it's unconfirmed, why use BCH when NANO confirms transaction in less than a second?

Not trolling, i wish for an honest answer.

21

u/Greamee Sep 20 '19

Every design choice has its trade-offs.

Nano uses a fundamentally different consensus protocol compared to Bitcoin.

Just because a Bitcoin transaction is unconfirmed, that doesn't definitively mean it's less secure than a confirmed transaction on another chain.

9

u/ErdoganTalk Sep 20 '19

NANO

Change to POW then we can talk

0

u/pistolpeteyoutube Sep 20 '19

They just did, check out their sub reddit

16

u/bortkasta Sep 20 '19

That's if you're only reading the titles of Reddit posts.

A very small PoW has always been used per transaction for Nano for spam protection.

For consensus, PoW has never been used, there's ORV (Open Representative Voting), a variant of DPoS.

The only thing changing here is the algo used for that existing anti-spam PoW.

4

u/dontlikecomputers Sep 20 '19

This is as good as it gets for Bitcoin, it is safe enough for small value transfers. I prefer Nano myself but this is great too, and there are more places that accept bch than nano.

2

u/95trz New Redditor Sep 21 '19

Nano's protocol is fundamentally flawed. If it ever scales, many of the nodes will go offline due to overwhelming network requirements. Literally every transaction creates a metric shit ton of broadcasts. You broadcast to send, you broadcast to receive, you broadcast to vote and all votes are broadcasted and rebroadcasted. It's almost like a 5 year old designed the protocol. It's the worst out there. Don't believe the hype. I can't imagine making a worse implementation for scaling. I have yet to be able to sync a wallet from scratch and truth is no more exchanges are even considering them because you pretty much have to have geographically separate verifcation nodes just to hope you can correctly verify your transaction went through and then, if they wanted to, they could go back and revote again to rollback transactions. They are never truly settled.

Think what you like but I STRONGLY recommend against Nano.

2

u/RockmSockmjesus Sep 21 '19

What you're saying is bandwidth is the bottleneck of the system. That's fine in reality because bandwidth is the easiest to scale. Also with things like vote stapling and dual-phase voting, the bandwidth requirements will lessen.

Also, what wallet did you try to "sync from scratch"?

You also don't have to geographically separate nodes, nor can a node vote to rollback transactions.

Also welcome to Reddit!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19

[deleted]

2

u/RockmSockmjesus Sep 21 '19

Since v19, once a transaction is confirmed it cannot be rolled back. Perhaps you are going off of old information?

1

u/dontlikecomputers Sep 22 '19

He is using old information, nodes could in theory revote on one block although it never happened. Block cementing is a recent addition.

1

u/DyKarN Sep 20 '19

Thanks. What prevents double spending? I read about scammers using double spend to withdraw from a BTC ATM for free.

15

u/abcbtc Sep 20 '19

The BTC ATM was incorrectly set up to allow a feature called RBF (replace by fee) which is in effect a double-spend mechanism allowing you to replace your previous transaction with another higher-fee transaction. This was introduced in to Bitcoin Core client to help mitigate stuck transactions due to the blocks being full and other fees rising above your transaction's fee.

BCH on the other hand does have RBF functionality but it is disabled by default. This means the sender has to manually set their transaction to allow RBF.

In the case of the ATM, the owners had configured it to allow RBF transactions, somebody figured this out and used it to withdraw money then replace (aka double-spend) their BTC transaction to a different address before it was confirmed to the ATM.

Practically, RBF being on by default means 1 of 2 things: Either 1) users need to be tech-savvy enough to disable RBF before sending their BTC to the ATM. Or 2) users need to wait for 1 confirmation before they can withdraw their cash from the ATM.

0-conf (as the name implies, unconfirmed transactions) are generally safe as there is an opportunity cost to double spend a transaction, so long as this cost is higher than the value of said transaction, it is economically ineffective (costs more than it's worth) to double spend below this value.

3

u/TiagoTiagoT Sep 20 '19

BCH on the other hand does have RBF functionality but it is disabled by default.

It's not disabled, it's not even present in the first place.

0

u/abcbtc Sep 20 '19

I was under the impression BIP 125 opt-in RBF is still available in BCH?

1

u/TiagoTiagoT Sep 20 '19

Hm, that's not what I remember. How would I go about verifying that?

1

u/dontlikecomputers Sep 21 '19

It's always at the discretion of the winning miner.

3

u/ErdoganTalk Sep 20 '19

0-conf (as the name implies, unconfirmed transactions) are generally safe

But probably not for pure money/money transactions as an ATM, any amount.

3

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Sep 20 '19

xmr.to, a service for converting XMR to BTC accepts Monero 0-conf up to around $1000. If they can do it, so could a BCH ATM.

9

u/Greamee Sep 20 '19

Miners typically prevent an obvious double spend.

If you're accepting a payment like this IRL, a person doesn't simply run away within 5 seconds. If 2 competing TXs are broadcast more than 5 seconds apart, miners can easily tell which came first.

The question is: will miners always be honest about this? My answer would be: yes, assuming there isn't a huge fee on the double spending TX.

That's why unconfirmed transactions will work fine for low amounts. And even for larger amounts (will a miner take a $50 bribe and permanently degrade peoples' trust in the network?) depending on the recipient's risk apetite.

For ATMs, accepting unconfirmed transactions might be too risky for high value payments. That said, I think the last time an ATM got defrauded, it was because of RBF (replace-by-fee). If the operator disables RBF, it becomes much harder to double spend.

RBF doesn't exist on BCH, only on BTC.

6

u/ErdoganTalk Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19

No RBF, plenty capacity, the current flat fee structure, the first seen first included miner principle. But beware if you receive thousands from an unknown party, wait for some confirmations.

4

u/sneaky-rabbit Sep 20 '19

0 confirmations tho

3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

What did you just prove with that video? That the new app can pop a green check sign in zero time? Who the fuck cares how fast the app works, the issue here is the blockchain settlement. Is this how you envision future of digital cash?

8

u/curryandrice Sep 20 '19

If none of us here can reverse a block from settling then zero conf is as nearly secure as block settlement. BCH zero conf works under reasonable expectations of security.

How secure do you need your < $1800 tx to be? The block reward is ~$3600 currently so you need someone bribing miners with alot more and it also incurs miner reputation damage even if they do accept and that would devalue their asic value return.

Your concerns are completely unwarranted in the context of this dynamic.

6

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Sep 20 '19

Actually credit card transactions don't settle for many weeks. Blockchain settlement is a bit of a smokescreen really as long as 0-conf is reasonably secure.

4

u/DavidScubadiver Sep 20 '19

Hmm. When you do an instant transaction with nano it is settled instantly. It isn’t the same with BCH?

1

u/Flaynas Sep 20 '19

No it's pretty much just the wallet that shows a transaction has been initiated.

2

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19

...and has almost no practical chance of reversal...

0

u/curryandrice Sep 21 '19

My suggestion is that we should address security concerns with attack vector costs to rate security of one chain vs another.

BCH zero conf settlement: ~5 second Cost to attack: ~$3600 + miner bribe (% of asic network+reputation value) Effect: Users in 1 block can be doublespent

BTC Settlement: ~10 minutes, Cost to attack: RBF doublespend = highest tx fee in block Effect: 1 user accepting doublespent

Nano Settlement: ~5 second Cost to attack: DoS spam (+50tx/s) (10 GPU cost ~$8000)$80,000 + electric Effect: Denial of Service for whole network for duration of gpu's being run

2

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19

Who the fuck cares how fast the app works, the issue here is the blockchain settlement.

the txn settles in about ten minutes, which is months faster than the credit card txns that the economy largely runs on

Is this how you envision future of digital cash?

well yeah. it's literally the sort of vision satoshi laid out in his snack machine example.

2

u/BitcoinIsTehFuture Moderator Sep 20 '19

This type of video should posted daily or weekly. This will be Bitcoin Cash's greatest advertising. This is Bitcoin Cash's best attribute from a consumer point of view.

-6

u/drrgrr123 Sep 20 '19

Unconfirmed transactions? This is a gimmick.

7

u/BitcoinIsTehFuture Moderator Sep 20 '19

0 conf transactions work with high reliability on BCH. So it's no gimmick. Very useful for low value transactions.

It doesn't work reliably on BTC which is why this type of video isn't realistic on BTC.

-6

u/drrgrr123 Sep 20 '19

BTC has it's own thing in the works. I would love to support BCH but Roger Ver makes it hard.

4

u/BitcoinIsTehFuture Moderator Sep 20 '19

LN has been “in the works” for 4 years. And there’s no evidence that it will ever solve many problems it has such as making it fully decentralized, or opening/closing channels with full blocks.

I don’t see what’s not to like about Roger (except for FUD spread in intent to discredit him). He’s done nothing but help the bitcoin space for the past eight years or so. But even if you don’t like him, it really has nothing to do with the technology of Bitcoin Cash itself.

-9

u/drrgrr123 Sep 20 '19

Bitcoin.com. Trying to sell BCH as BTC is shady AF.

On another note the whole mess with using r/BTC as a BCH sub, calling BCH just "Bitcoin" and all other silly stuff going on here makes it impossible to take this project seriously. Look how nicely the LTC and BTC communities treats each other (mostly). That could have been the same with BCH and BTC.

8

u/BitcoinIsTehFuture Moderator Sep 20 '19

Learn some history of how the sub got it's name. It was due users to being censored and kicked out of the main bitcoin community. You're bringing up old and tired points that have been defeated in debate many times.

1

u/bextman Redditor for less than 2 weeks Sep 20 '19

So many of them in google playstore. Who do I know the real bch wallet?

1

u/fribitz Sep 20 '19

Incredible. Can't wait for it to drop!

1

u/Ahrlien Sep 20 '19

Like superquick.

1

u/sambarboza Sep 20 '19

Is it a p2p spv wallet or will connect to certain nodes via http?

1

u/LibX4life Sep 20 '19

Genuinely loving the speed on this. Raising the bar in crypto mandates performance upgrades network-wide, everything must meet this or better now or we're going backwards. Open source FTW.

1

u/JonathanSilverblood Jonathan#100, Jack of all Trades Sep 21 '19

Now that the QR code camera focus is the slowest part, it makes me glad to know you're also working on NFC support. <3

1

u/hari_99 Redditor for less than 30 days Sep 21 '19

😍😍🚀🚀🚀🚀

1

u/zhell_ Sep 21 '19

My last article explains why this kind of onboarding does not work anymore and what should be our new strategy.

https://www.yours.org/content/what-is-the-best-way-to-introduce-bitcoin-to-new-people---new-strategy-791cff73c5b2

1

u/Blixx87 Sep 26 '19

Might as well use PayPal or Venmo before you use unconfirmed transactions

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

What is that app?

3

u/libertarian0x0 Sep 20 '19

3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

Found it last night shortly after posting this. Thank you.

0

u/FlipDetector Sep 20 '19

It looks like it is sending money from a user account to another user account (client1 -> server -> client2). Ohh wait... BCH exactly does that except server = public ledger = all clients, no middleman. This technology is awesome and when 5G arrives this will possibly have no (humanly visible) latency! What do I mean by that? Just tap a button on a new phone's screen and see how quickly it reacts.

4

u/CatatonicAdenosine Sep 20 '19

I believe that this is actually going wallet A —> bitcoin.com backend —> wallet B, which is why it is so fast. Bitcoin.com's node then broadcasts the transaction to the rest of the network where it will be mined into a block.

6

u/ErdoganTalk Sep 20 '19

It is wallet to wallet (phone to phone), but servers help with supplying timely information

3

u/dontlikecomputers Sep 20 '19

They probably share the same mempool, this transaction may only exist on this one mempool.

0

u/staviac Sep 20 '19

0-conf .. same could work on BTC

2

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19

nope. zero conf requires predictable next block inclusion. BTC has an "always full blocks/fee pressure" strategy that is the opposite of "predictable next block inclusion."

2

u/Lucas_Meyer Sep 21 '19

With RBF? Nope.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19

[deleted]

2

u/jessquit Sep 21 '19

nope. zero conf requires predictable next block inclusion. BTC has an "always full blocks/fee pressure" strategy that is the opposite of "predictable next block inclusion."

-7

u/shanytc Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19

Lol so fast ... with 0 confirms it’s just sending packets over tcp/ip. No miner confirms it.. sadly ;(

7

u/ErdoganTalk Sep 20 '19

It is an SPV wallet, phone verifies, with its own servers for timely information. See also my comments above

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

Then it’s misleading. This is a tricky scenario to fool people on board.

-3

u/shanytc Sep 20 '19

💆🏻‍♂️

-2

u/jdchappie Sep 20 '19

It needs to be fast, a few more seconds and the bitcoin transaction it’s worth double or half lol

-2

u/Trosso Sep 20 '19

What do you use it for when it’s not accepted anywhere

2

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Sep 20 '19

Just some things I've bought using BCH:

  1. Computers

  2. Phones

  3. Books

  4. Food

  5. Drinks

  6. Headphones

  7. Lego

2

u/Trosso Sep 21 '19

That’s pretty cool! Especially the Lego part hahaha

1

u/jeffzebub Sep 20 '19

Paying back friends.

1

u/Trosso Sep 21 '19

People who use bitcoin cash have friends?

0

u/_cryptodon_ Sep 20 '19

Making videos for Reddit points

-1

u/loneystoney44 Sep 20 '19

😂👍🏻🤡

-3

u/anselal Sep 20 '19

This does not belong in this subreddit

0

u/the_remeddy Sep 20 '19

Still denominated in dollars...

-4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19

https://doublespend.cash/

Zero confirmation transactions are not safe they can easily be double spent. All you have to do is rebroadcast a raw transaction with the new address and a higher transaction fee. Every single purchase you will make will pretty much be free ripping off the seller. No RBF needed.

5

u/matein30 Sep 20 '19

Did you even look at what you shared. I went as far as i could go and only seen one successful double spend on which the original had lower than 1 sat per byte.

1

u/_false_positive Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 21 '19

I went as far as i could go and only seen one successful double spend

There's more than one page.

Try download Download data dump of all double spends

and search over those files for "winner": "second"

There are almost 3000 successful double spends

1

u/forkstir Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 21 '19

Is it miners choice to select transaction based on its fee rather than the "first seen rule" ?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19

If you can create 2 transactions with the same unconfirmed funds but 1 tansaction has a greater mining fee than the other, that one will receive priority over the other. The transaction with the lower fee with get rejected.

Best way to be successful at this is if you can make the fee for the original transaction less than 1 satoshi per byte. 2nd transaction has to be over 1 satoshi per byte. Obviously anyone who downloads a wallet from android or iphone marketplace won't be able to do this. You need to get all the raw inputs and do it manually.

https://medium.com/coinmonks/how-to-create-a-raw-bitcoin-transaction-step-by-step-239b888e87f2

1

u/forkstir Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 21 '19

So the first seen rule isn't enforced

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

[deleted]

13

u/ErdoganTalk Sep 20 '19

on any other cryptocurrency

Faster than BTC relative to the level of finality of payment, see my answer above

12

u/Peter__R Peter Rizun - Bitcoin Researcher & Editor of Ledger Journal Sep 20 '19

Actually no. The BU nodes act as a fast relay network for transactions on the BCH network. Core added a bunch of delays in their transaction relay code paths which BU removed. Transactions propagate much slower across the BTC network and this was by the purposeful design of the Core developers. They thought the loss of speed was worth the benefit (which is that it makes the network harder to map by an observer watching the flow of transactions).

1

u/bortkasta Sep 20 '19

Actually there is one out there where it's as fast as this or faster but also fully confirmed and immutable.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/ErdoganTalk Sep 20 '19

AFAIK all BTC SPV wallets also shows unconfirmed transactions, and can send the received coin on before it is confirmed (maybe a configuration setting or a warning screen). But Bitcoin.com wallet has worked hard to speed up the servers. It is a dual coin wallet, you can check the speed of BTC yourself. It should be possible to do the same for the BTC backend.

7

u/Greamee Sep 20 '19

There's no reason BTC couldn't be similarly fast.

But BTC's low blocksize limit makes unconfirmed transactions less reliable. Also, there seems to be little to no commitment to improving unconfirmed transactions in the BTC (developer) community.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Sep 20 '19

RBF makes it unreliable yes.

But full blocks can also make them unreliable if you're unlucky to get stuck in the backlog. Which can randomly happen even if you pay enough, but transactions after yours decide to pay even more, pricing you out.

1

u/Greamee Sep 20 '19

That's a little less direct I feel.

RBF is optional. But it's cumbersome to reject payments. Also, it sends the wrong signal. It's basically admitting defeat.