r/btc • • Sep 13 '19

So you want small blocks with high fees to validate your own on chain transactions that happen OFF CHAIN?

Post image
213 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

31

u/jonald_fyookball Electron Cash Wallet Developer Sep 13 '19

-30

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Sep 13 '19

Nobody cares. BCH is collapsing in value relative to BTC and nobody is actually using BCH for transactions. The moonboys won.

11

u/knowbodynows Sep 13 '19

Thank you for speaking for everyone. What's everyone's favorite soup? Which ice cream flavor does nobody like? How can I too become accredited to speak on behalf of everyone? Is there a fee? A training course? If you're ever wrong do you lose your license?

I use BCH for all my air and ride hailing travel, most of my apparel and shoes, all my coffee, a giant chunk of my dining, most of my groceries. I'm a little frustrated that I can't buy gasoline or the car I want... yet.

-3

u/Bag_Holding_Infidel Sep 14 '19

Thank you for speaking for everyone.

Wasn't that what OP did?

-2

u/akuukka Sep 14 '19

... while losing shit tons of money

-7

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Sep 13 '19

Was basing on data. Big empty blocks.

https://fork.lol/tx/txs

7

u/knowbodynows Sep 14 '19

Big empty blocks.

There is no such thing as big empty blocks. Learn about Bitcoin.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '19

[deleted]

1

u/hifrom_laura Sep 14 '19

10 @spicetokens

test

-3

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Sep 14 '19

https://fork.lol/tx/txs

I’m sure some people spend dogecoin, too. The BCH fork is dying.

17

u/WippleDippleDoo Sep 13 '19

classic

8

u/Zyoman Sep 13 '19

Still true

-8

u/herzmeister Sep 14 '19

this is one of the most stupidest (also quite old) bcash/bsv "memes" i dont even

we don't do "don't trust, verify", because we have a fetish.

if payments that we're not interested in can be grouped because they won't be able to be double-spent against us or violate consensus rules, that's very fine, but for a long time that was a difficult problem to solve, and that's the whole idea of a second layer.

but what am i debating with btards...

5

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

I usually downvote anti-BTC posts, but this was good, I had never quite thought of it in this way. Thanks!

3

u/bitcoiner_since_2013 Sep 13 '19

Also, lets compare the block size to downloading a webpage, because this is our level of understanding of Bitcoin.

4

u/aashay2035 Sep 14 '19

The average website is 2mb. So like everytime you load up some content rich website (YouTube) you kinda already consumed all the data a 1mb block size will do all day.

6

u/bitmeister Sep 13 '19

A web page? How about one image on the page.

2

u/curyous Sep 13 '19

This is gold.

-6

u/FieserKiller Sep 13 '19

I don't need to validate my own transactions. I want to validate all other transactions which touch the chain because I don't trust but verify. that includes all payment channel openings and closings, I do not care what they do in between.

11

u/SILENTSAM69 Sep 13 '19

Nothing stops you from running a full node. The resource requirements to run a full node are not significant. Even with 32MB blocks it takes a regular PC. At the highest end it might require a gaming PC.

If those who want to run a full node can not invest as much as a gamer can then obviously they do not care that much about verification.

To make it so cheap that it can be done on a cheap Raspberry Pi makes no sense. It makes a network the poor can afford to verify, but not afford to use.

High fees create the worst kind of centralization. It centralises who can actually use the network.

7

u/James-Russels Sep 13 '19

It makes a network the poor can afford to verify, but not afford to use.

This is a great way to think about it, thanks.

2

u/wtfrelaly Redditor for less than 30 days Sep 13 '19

0% of bitcoin is secured by non-mining nodes. Even if you detect something you can't do anything about it.
Private/public key handles 99% of things, and the rest is handled by game theory(which you need specialized mining hardware to join).

1

u/FieserKiller Sep 13 '19

My node won't accept this block so in my reality this attack never happened and node will waiting for the chain to be extended. This next block may or may not come. If it never arrives my blockchain ended at this point.

1

u/wtfrelaly Redditor for less than 30 days Sep 14 '19

No. Longest chain wins, which is a why it works at all. Your node literally does nothing.

3

u/FieserKiller Sep 14 '19

Longest chain of valid blocks wins

2

u/wtfrelaly Redditor for less than 30 days Sep 14 '19

Yes, validity is determined by who's mining on them. Not who's sitting passively watching. A passive node is like a fan in a stadium.

2

u/FieserKiller Sep 14 '19

Exactly. No one cares if one or the other fan is upset and switches teams. But if the team behaves so badly that it upsets all its fans, they leave and don't come back, stadium is empty, no one buys tickets and merch anymore and team goes bankrupt a few seasons later.

1

u/wtfrelaly Redditor for less than 30 days Sep 16 '19

No that metaphor doesn't work to that extent. Passive nodes add 0 value to the network and don't matter at all.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '19

I don't need to validate my own transactions. I want to validate all other transactions which touch the chain because I don't trust but verify. that includes all payment channel openings and closings, I do not care what they do in between.

If you want to fully validate the chain, good for you.

But I disagree full system auditing should be cheap at the expense of usability.

-7

u/Contrarian__ Sep 13 '19

I don't see how this makes sense. Presumably if you're using some kind of layer 2, you're still validating your transactions on that layer as well. If the argument is, "but you're not validating everyone else's transactions", that's not really particularly important, since they can't modify the base currency. It's not like it affects Bitcoin the currency if an exchange gets hacked.

7

u/Adrian-X Sep 13 '19

Have you read the bitcoin white paper? you just made an argument for SPV, the original scaling plan described in the white paper.

0

u/Contrarian__ Sep 13 '19

Here's the key distinction:

since they can't modify the base currency

If every user ran an SPV node, miners can do whatever they want without even being detected. Fraud proofs are not yet widely available, and may never be for every type of fraud.

5

u/lubokkanev Sep 13 '19

If you only use LN why would you run a node?

1

u/throwawayo12345 Sep 13 '19

You still need to run a node to make sure that your counterparty doesn't fuck you by doublespending through publishing an old channel state.

1

u/Adrian-X Sep 14 '19

Ask the any person in the street if they will run a bitcoin node, then ask why.

In fact the answer is the same for 99% of people who have bitcoin.

1

u/throwawayo12345 Sep 14 '19

99% of people who own BTC don't spend it, let alone hold their own keys.

I am simply explaining the theoretical need to run a node should one desire to use the lightning network.

1

u/lubokkanev Sep 15 '19

Once everyone is using BTC about no one will be doing on-chain transactions. The most you'll need is opening a single channel.

-9

u/Contrarian__ Sep 13 '19

I'm not an expert with lightning, but since it uses the blockchain to open and close channels, you'd need a node if you wanted to fully validate it. It may even be a requirement at this point.

Lightning transactions are just regular Bitcoin transactions anyway, AFAIK.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

[deleted]

0

u/Contrarian__ Sep 13 '19

What do you think lightning users exchange back and forth with each other?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

[deleted]

1

u/Contrarian__ Sep 13 '19

Try publishing a tab to the blockchain.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Adrian-X Sep 14 '19

Miners have an incentive, to be honest, that how we predict it's more cost-effective to cooperate that deceive.

Miners collude to change the protocol all the time and running a side can't stop them, e.g. Segwit.

1

u/Adrian-X Sep 14 '19

can't modify the base currency

not sure where this bravado comes from, it's the investors in the currency that keep eh miners committed to the 21M not the nodes.

5

u/phillipsjk Sep 13 '19

If you are validating both layers anyway, why not just keep the transactions in one convenient place?

It is not like moving to a second layer saves any processing time or storage.

8

u/Contrarian__ Sep 13 '19

If you are validating both layers anyway, why not just keep the transactions in one convenient place?

What if you don't care about 99% of transactions that won't have any direct effect on the currency itself, but still want to trustlessly validate all the rules that you care about, to the best of your ability?

Note, I'm not convinced Lightning is a great solution. I just think this is a poor argument.

3

u/phillipsjk Sep 13 '19

SPV is explicitly mentioned in the whitepaper.

That was the whole point of using a merkle tree.

2

u/Contrarian__ Sep 13 '19

SPV will let you verify that your transaction is in a block. It will not let you verify that the miners took the correct reward, for instance.

2

u/phillipsjk Sep 13 '19 edited Sep 13 '19

SPV wallets will detect chain-forks through the POW in the block-headers.

I was able to get my BSV tokens for sale by using an SPV wallet.

Full nodes fail to detect soft forks or hard forks. Well, if you pay attention to the logs, you may notice a spike in incompatible nodes.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

Its a meme and therefore hyperbolic. On LN is your transaction even recognizable on the Bitcoin blockchain or is it lumped into a single big transaction (justification for small blocks)? If its not then why would you need to run a full node? It seems like in an effort to make nodes easy to run they have created a reason to not run a node at all - working against itself on the small block argument. You could say thats win win if you ignore the users that wanted larger blocks for on chain scaling and direct BTC transactions.

2

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer Sep 14 '19

Yes it does... You only validate YOUR OWN L2 transactions, not everyone's.

3

u/phillipsjk Sep 14 '19

At the risk of repeating myself, SPV exists.

-2

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer Sep 14 '19

Except it doesn't.

3

u/phillipsjk Sep 14 '19

Theoretical description:

Page 5, Section 8 :Simplified Payment Verification

Implementation:

bread

Example user complaint about slowness, compared to more centralized implementations:

Noob question: Why does Breadwallet have to "sync" while Mycelium does not?

-1

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer Sep 14 '19

Theoretical description:

Page 5, Section 8 :Simplified Payment Verification

This has never been implemented, and in fact has been found impossible to implement.

2

u/phillipsjk Sep 15 '19

Are you disqualifying BRD wallet because it actually fetches the transaction?

I backed up my claim (that SPV is a thing). I am curious why you think BRD wallet does not qualify.

Edit: if you claim if does not detect hard-forks, I will point out it supports both BCH and BTC.

0

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer Sep 15 '19

It doesn't detect miners violating the rules (alerts from network nodes, using white paper terms)

2

u/phillipsjk Sep 15 '19

It doesn't have to do so directly.

Miners violating the rules will likely cause a chain-split. SPV wallets can detect chain-splits by examining the block headers.

2

u/mossmoon Sep 15 '19

SPV wallets can detect chain-splits by examining the block headers.

Once again /u/luke-jr's fantasy world comes face to face with reality and he runs away like the lying coward he is.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '19

The person who wrote this meme and most commenters here are either ignorant or manipulative.

You run your own Bitcoin node to validate the transactions yourself including the management of your LN channels! You also run an LN node, and thus you can validate both your transactions on-chain and on the second layer. This is how you achieve both sovereignty and scale.

-15

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

try again. this time with some effort to understand.

4

u/_imba__ Sep 13 '19

Well posting here means you're not scared of being downvoted, so if you disagree and understand things well enough to say why it would be cool if you could elaborate.

It might be beter to criticise the article in the top comment than the meme as it comes down to the same thing but better argued. I read as much on lighting and its workings as I can and I don't hold bch, but I do think btc should not have gone the super small block + future-lighting route. I'm pretty sure there are many like me on this subreddit.

-7

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

so if you disagree and understand things well enough to say why it would be cool if you could elaborate

Im not gonna waste my time unless someone show at least some effort to present this in a manner that represents the contrary viewpoint. the posters here have no intention of trying to understand. im pretty sure this exact meme has been posted before and shot down in flames... vut here we are again

hint: try to figure out why its important to be able to validate the blockchain.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

You have already spent a significant amount of time posting here. Could have had a good start explaining it already.

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

contrarian and two others already explained. no need for me to do that also.

i was hoping someone would actually try to challenge themselves to a pretty good exercise: understanding other peoples arguments instead of setting up strawman arguments line the OP

3

u/_imba__ Sep 13 '19

I guess properly reading my entire message was too much effort too. Anway, my bad for engaging and trying to understand, enjoy the rest of the trolling.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

i see you were not up for the challenge.

-5

u/boobalicous Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 13 '19

That's not how it works here.

5

u/tr14l Sep 13 '19

Yeah, we understand. We're just not idiots.

-3

u/boobalicous Redditor for less than 60 days Sep 13 '19

The market says otherwise.

4

u/tr14l Sep 13 '19

Markets also fully collapse themselves on a regular basis. Markets are full of idiots that have no idea what they're doing

And idiots are the types of people that think markets indicate anything other than hype

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '19

Yes. And it is completely secure, and accurate.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '19

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '19

BCH is like internet cash. You can earn it hold and spend it like just like cash.

Why would anyone want cash that has equal value around the world?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '19

Why would anyone want cash that has equal value around the world?

Is it not desirable feature?

Do you never travel?