r/hiphopheads • . • Jul 31 '19

Chance the Rapper - The Big Day ALBUM REVIEW

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjriHA-MLPg&feature=push-u-sub&attr_tag=m7rryxEOPA381T0E%3A6
14.6k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

8.1k

u/JohnWalI Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

0/10 holy shit the mad man actually did it. Chance now joins a very elite company of 0/10’s. Maybe he’ll bounce back with a 10/10 like Kid Cudi did ...

4.6k

u/CharlieTheViking Jul 31 '19

... on a 7 track album with Ye. Good Ass Job confirmed 10

1.1k

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

If we ever get it.

→ More replies (32)

249

u/Jayyburdd Jul 31 '19

Still waiting for Corey Feldman's 7-track.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

511

u/sewious Jul 31 '19

Honestly don't think Chance has the potential for a 10/10 from Fantano

537

u/CoolHandHazard . Jul 31 '19

Considering he gave Acid Rap a 6 I’d agree. But I will say I think that’s absurd, I’d rate it 8/9

→ More replies (55)
→ More replies (2)

95

u/The6ixBasedGod Jul 31 '19

Damnnn never thought I'd see the day when John Wall is commenting on a r/hiphopheads thread

35

u/H-TownDown Jul 31 '19

He’s gotta do something while his Achilles is still healing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (390)

3.8k

u/corruptbytes . Jul 31 '19

a speeding bullet to the fucking head.

Melon did not let up for a single moment, and honestly good, because this album just wasn’t fun or even made sense.

0/10

426

u/cubedG Jul 31 '19

I legit thought I had the album on shuffle at first with how over the place it was

→ More replies (4)

1.0k

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

Here's to hoping that he pulls a Cudi and Good Ass Job gets a 10/10 and all is right with the world.

1.4k

u/Afrolion69 Jul 31 '19

Lmao Kanye out here carrying all these children.

→ More replies (27)

93

u/Bauer22 Jul 31 '19

The mythical Childish Gambino album being his Kids See Ghost??

→ More replies (4)

185

u/CPU_Bot Jul 31 '19

Funny thing is Speeding Bullet got a 0.9472/10 not a 0 so technically this is worse than it .

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

359

u/ThePhillyGuy Jul 31 '19

Unfortunately, I 100% agree. I’ve been a stan for Chance since 10 Day. It’s crazy for me to think of all of the people over the years that I’ve introduced Chance to, and then to know that he put out a debut album so bad that I’ve only managed to listen halfway.

Side note—does anyone else automatically think of Womp Womp as soon as Chance enters on Hot Shower?

115

u/Prowler_in_the_Yard . Jul 31 '19

You saying "debut album" frustrates me because it reminds me Chance will probably be eligible for "best new artist" at the Grammys soon

105

u/Anderson_Paakin_Dick Jul 31 '19

He already won that. He used Coloring Book to campaign so mixtapes would be recognised, as far as I remember. It also won best rap album and he got best rap performance for No Problem.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/RastaSauce Jul 31 '19

Damn youre right, Hot Shower is just a bad version of Womp Womp, right down to the beat

→ More replies (6)

4.3k

u/PoliSWAG- . Jul 31 '19

'A 22 track long torture chamber'

Busted out laughing at this, the man aint wrong but still that's fukn brutal.

How long before Chance and his lawyers get this video taken down?

398

u/johnnguyening . Jul 31 '19

Even worse, Chance is gonna personally tell God not to let Fantano into heaven

56

u/MyUshanka Jul 31 '19

Fantano is a vegan he's not going anywhere but hell

674

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

They could take the video down because it features the album cover, similarQC (or whomever) did with Lil Baby and Gunna's project

2.1k

u/other_batman Jul 31 '19

Then Anthony can reupload the review with an actually good cover

→ More replies (40)
→ More replies (1)

843

u/Sircartier_24k Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

Chance is really heading down the same path as logic when you really think about it. After this album people are starting to look at chance like a joke

I remember in 2017 people like joe budden were saying chance was the future and had the potential to be in the same tier as drake etc... this album put that conversation in a coffin

640

u/fallgout Jul 31 '19

logic was a slow downfall tho, chance just fucking plummeted

→ More replies (60)

163

u/ooken Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

I don't think it majorly tarnishes the strength of Acid Rap and Coloring Book; it just shows that Chance is inconsistent, which will make some more hesitant to listen to his future music.

I'm wondering how he'll handle this newfound level of criticism. He certainly hasn't handled it very gracefully in the past, and he really hasn't faced many negative reviews since he got famous. A lot of the reviews so far have been more positive than I expected.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (16)

350

u/CremeDeLaCremeHomie Jul 31 '19

Can we just acknowledge Vic Mensa had a better debut album?

208

u/bbpsword Jul 31 '19

I can't believe that's reality we're facing, but OOOOOOOOOFFF

→ More replies (27)

1.0k

u/jeric13xd Jul 31 '19

Props to Fantano for pulling no punches

→ More replies (57)

117

u/other_batman Jul 31 '19

I think that's part of the reason why it's so brutal. He knows chance hates negative reviews and his strong reaction to this album is bound to garner views

16

u/ThaMac Jul 31 '19

This review was legitimately hilarious, this was some of Fantano's best comedy ever.

→ More replies (11)

1.8k

u/larchmontvandyke Jul 31 '19

It’s pretty clear Fantano’s biggest issue with this album is its lyrics, which is totally valid. The bars on this album are pure garbage. He could’ve pulled some from literally every song.

754

u/OldTrafford25 . Jul 31 '19

The hug and hug you line alone, even when taking into account the theme of the song, was unforgivably awful.

→ More replies (4)

627

u/idkwhattoputasmyname Jul 31 '19

I mean he's Chance "the rapper" this album has definitely put into question his rapping abilities.

→ More replies (14)

27

u/haaaannnn . Jul 31 '19

my biggest issue with it is he cancelled his headlining performance at Australia's largest festival last week so he could concentrate on the rollout of the absolute piece of trash. smh paid good money to see him

6

u/AllAboutTheAce . Jul 31 '19

“Now she giving me ultimatums, I told her I don’t like tomatoes”

→ More replies (8)

1.4k

u/mobinschild Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

Fantano made an official 0 trophy and gave it to Chance

Edit: first gold, I'd like to thank the kind stranger, melon, and chancelor bennett's wife

24

u/tooshortfk15tirelire Jul 31 '19

Cudi passed on the throne

18

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

The moment he released that album cover, I knew it was shit

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

00f

→ More replies (8)

1.6k

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

Wow.

I didn’t see a 0 coming, but I understand it. I don’t see myself coming back to this much if at all. I really enjoyed all three of his mixtapes, and for this to be this much of a mess, is such a let down. I guess I get the 0 because as a chance fan, the feeling is similar to a cudi fan after hearing SB2H.

471

u/raditt_ . Jul 31 '19

Yeah pretty much. There are definitely worse albums/projects than this but since it's Chance he expected something decent at the very very least lol

306

u/sewious Jul 31 '19

He gave Revival a better score than this, which is actually offensively bad at points IMO. Fantano was super disappointed in Chance here

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (8)

126

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

Chance has enough expectations to where an album like this deserves all the roasting it’s getting. Would never have believed in 2011 that this would be where Chance ended up

→ More replies (2)

12

u/atp2112 Jul 31 '19

I kept thinking "Wow, he hates this. This is maybe a 1 or 2. Let's see if he finds something redeeming." As it got further and angrier, it transitioned to "Is he really about to give Chance a 0?" This was just an impressive collapse.

→ More replies (8)

111

u/NCCubs1231 Jul 31 '19

Even after a few days I still cannot believe this album was actually released. Holy shit.

The worst part is I think Chance is too delusional to see any problems with it which is why I’m not expecting much out of his next one either.

23

u/ayon88 Jul 31 '19

Tiktok is his new fanbase. And cant wait to see him to perform in next fortnite world cup

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

718

u/Its_Your_Boi_MaxB . Jul 31 '19

FANTANO DOESN'T LOVE HIS WIFE CONFIRMED?

in all seriousness I totally agree. This was one of my most anticipated releases of the year and I stayed up till 4 am waiting for it to drop in a Discord with people from /r/chancetherapper. This might be the most let down I've ever been by an album, his early work is some of the first music I can remember actually being passionate about

99

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

Lol how was the reaction after everyone finished their first listen through?

140

u/Its_Your_Boi_MaxB . Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

I was so disheartened with the album I didnt check

I did see somebody say that it was the most experimental release of the year on /r/Chancetherapper

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/IIIIIIIIIIIIlllll Jul 31 '19

Yo I was in that sever too what was your name?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

980

u/medspace Jul 31 '19

Holy shit, at one point he yelled and that was the first time I truly felt his frustration and anger towards anything he has ever reviewed, wow...

→ More replies (13)

960

u/bbpsword Jul 31 '19

I just think that this album is a reflection of Chance's life. He's spending all day with his kids, it's a VeggieTales-ass album. Anything that could be of substance has been glossed over, and there's no real commentary on anything at any point in the album. His rhymes are wack, and he's clearly surrounded by a bunch of yes men with regards to the content.

It's dope to spend time with your kids and family, but I'll be damned if it doesn't sound like he's been driving kids to daycare listening to kids music albums and using that as inspiration. This shit is so corny.

380

u/blue-dream Jul 31 '19

Yo Freddie Gibbs just did a freestyle of the year with his child in his lap. Don't let kids be the excuse for Chance.

A good artist should always have the taste and vision to know what works and doesn't work with the sounds they create regardless of what was the inspiration to create them.

229

u/SuckingOffMyHomies Jul 31 '19

Freddie Gibbs even has a bar about potty training his daughter and then going back to cooking up drugs in his kitchen lmao

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

719

u/Zoombini22 Jul 31 '19

Don't don't drag Veggietales down by associating them with this shit

231

u/bbpsword Jul 31 '19

Lmfao true. VeggieTales is straight fuego

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

45

u/-RDX- Jul 31 '19

This albums sounds like someone who isn't really happy and is trying to convince themselves they made all of the right decisions

31

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

Mr. Peanutbutter ass album

17

u/Banezi Jul 31 '19

I don't think that's an excuse. Is his life really this perfect and lovely and boring that he couldn't write something more deeper and introspective? He couldn't do one tenth of what he did on Acid Rap despite being 5 years older and more mature? This is just uninspired drivel that rides on his positivity persona so I don't mind the overly harsh grade from Melon, maybe some criticism will make him put his soul more into the next one

→ More replies (10)

533

u/fuck_you_leddit Jul 31 '19

Hot Cal Hot Melon Hot Flannel

Red flannel 100% earned the pitchfork review was way too lenient and dependent on chance's career. Sheldon Pierce (did the Invasion of Privacy Review) never actually talks about the actual fucking album lmao

174

u/Dropdat87 Jul 31 '19

Chance and pitchfork collaborate and are both in Chicago. They can’t shit on it if they want him playing their festival or giving interviews etc. A 6.9 from them is like a 2

→ More replies (4)

89

u/Shaushage_Shandwich Jul 31 '19

never actually talks about the actual fucking album

Well it would be weird if Pitchfork drastically changed up their formula for this review

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

492

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

This album literally sounds like a birthday cake. Except its overly sweet and just leaves you brushing your tounge against your gums wondering why you ate those cavities.

Nontheless this album makes me want to get a wife just to cheat on her

281

u/capitalistsanta Jul 31 '19

You can hear his wife breathing down his neck as he rapped some of those verses

96

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

now we just need logic to borrow his wife and take an ancestory test

→ More replies (8)

15

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

It's a birthday cake but the kind you grab from Food Lion after work

→ More replies (1)

767

u/Jpr1ce17 Jul 31 '19

I almost feel bad for Chance. He was so happy on this record, you could tell he was really in love and wanted to share it with the world. He had such good intentions and positivity and his message was really really good, but it was just so badly executed. I wish i could say i enjoyed the album for his sake, but i just didn’t. Too repetitive, too corny, too many lackluster bars.

442

u/hamgangster Jul 31 '19

It’s one thing to say “I’m happy, I feel wholesome, life is great” but it’s another thing to say only that and not really elaborate or go deeper with it. I agree the execution is bad. For example, he loves his wife, but why does he love his wife? What does she do, what activities do they do together, what hardships have they overcome together, what makes their love strong. There’s a lot he could have said that he just alluded to

111

u/m0_m0ney Jul 31 '19

If he had one song about how happy and in love he was it would have been not 22. It’s just shallow when you get down to the bottom of it and I agree the only thing he actually says about his wife is she’s pretty and and she wouldn’t let him fuck at one point.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

12

u/Insane_Wanderer Jul 31 '19

He had such good intentions and positivity and his message was really really good, but it was just so badly executed

Perfect way to explain how I feel about it. An artist can have the greatest intentions and the most beautiful message to share but unfortunately the end product is only as good as its execution, which this project falls short on

7

u/HyphySymphony Jul 31 '19

I don’t know. Fantano speaks about how Chance’s lyrics about being in love and how a side chick/guy isn’t as great as what you have at home feel like they’re coming from a place of insecurity. I think he may be right. It feels like Chance is overcompensating and trying to tell himself that this is what happiness should be.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

People saying they feel bad for Chance are nuts. He made and shipped a piece of garbage to his loyal fans. Save your sympathy and your "I wish... for his sake" for people who actually need it. What happened here is a millionaire celebrity put out a trash album because he didn't care enough to make it good.

6

u/chewie_were_home Jul 31 '19

It's weird living in a world with old town road at #1 which as is or even more corny as fuck as this album. There...somehow....is still some hunger behind old town road and this album is completely void of any hunger or passion. I can't explain it but somehow it's just there and somehow all people recognize it.

11

u/Hip_Hop_Orangutan Jul 31 '19

the ones who need to shout "I AM IN LOVE AND HAPPY!" the loudest on social media are usually the ones who are not that happy or in love...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

68

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

fuuuuck.

I can't even argue. Chance the fuckin Rapper put out a 22 song album and there isn't a single track I've been interested in going back and listening to. This sucks.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

I keep going back to Hot Shower just for a laugh. Fuck me what is that song

→ More replies (1)

187

u/FuckEthan Jul 31 '19

I remember when Chance was supposed to be performing in Dublin. I told myself that he cancelled to work on the album. CLEARY FUCKING NOT. THE FUCK CHANCE.

64

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

While I definitely disagree with Fantano on a lot of his reviews (Swimming is the biggest offender) he couldn’t have been more spot-on with this.

Chance has completely lost it. He has fallen off, and this isn’t a case of somebody simply not being able to top their mixtapes. This album is objectively TERRIBLE, and things that mildly annoyed me about Chance before are the forefront of this album, which means they’re impossible to ignore.

Awful lyrics, in fact I wanted to teabag a bear trap after the “booyah” line. His voice is no longer cute, or funny, or charming - it’s fucking infuriating. I listened to this ONCE and removed it from my library entirely - I will never listen to this steaming pile of shit again.

-1/10

→ More replies (2)

60

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

I've never thought the tUnE-yArDs would be name-dropped to trash a rap song in 2019 but I guess we're at the point where something is so exquisitely bad that you need to get that specific

Water Fountain bangs harder than anything Chance has ever made though

edit: As in the comparison is unexpected, not that they're bad. The Tune Yards are dope lol I adored the Sorry to Bother You score

7

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

wait what when was tune-yards namedropped

i like tune-yards :(

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

1.7k

u/CoolHandHazard . Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

He seriously hit him with a 0 lmao that’s crazy. I’ve only listened to like 2 tracks and I did not enjoy it at all so I’m probably never gonna actually listen to this album tbh. No need to waste 77 minutes of my life.

Crazy how far Chance has come man

Edit: fell is probably a better term lol

1.8k

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

How far he's fallen you mean. At one point he was like, a single hit away from being on that J Cole, Drake, Kendrick level of fame and respect. He had everything ready to go to be a big star. Now he's making music for people who vote at the grammys.

1.1k

u/other_batman Jul 31 '19

People who vote at the Grammys is my new favourite insult

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (62)

331

u/xvalicx Jul 31 '19

Even as someone who loves Coloring Book, I couldn't stomach more than a couple tracks before I shut it off. Went back to Cordae and had a lovely time.

→ More replies (9)

29

u/LosToast . Jul 31 '19

I haven't listened to it either but i think now that ive seen this rating i actually need to see what the talk is all about lol

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (36)

54

u/Scorch8482 Jul 31 '19

Its weird, because I didnt like Coloring Book for how cheesy and over the top happy it was. It felt unrealistic and all these songs about blessings and miracles and shit was just annoying to hear, listening as a person who was deppressed at the time.

Then eventually it clicked and his over-the-too warmth felt like a blanket when I needed it.

But this, this is just annoying. Like cool, you got a wife and shit and your life is a dream. I cant relate, so what am I supposed to do with this? At least with coloring book it felt more hopeful and more like “good days are coming for you too, boy.” This was just a happy life flex on all his fans. What are kids in Chicago supposed to do with these songs? He coulda dropped an album with 1-3 songs about how great his life is and moved on. Instead he made it his debut and slapped 22 fucking songs on it for now reason.

1.4k

u/TheInfinityGauntlet Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

The Big Fat Fucking Zero

I can't believe Chance earnestly put this out, he must have an incredible camp of yes men around him, a talent taught to him by his lord Yeezus Christ

I don't think I'd give it a zero just because some of the beats are sometimes interesting and there's a Meg feature but outside of that yeah

Woof

HE'S MAD AS FUCK ABOUT A FUCKING DONKEY KONG REFERENCE THIS IS INCREDIBLE

I need The Infinity Flannel

324

u/pk4171 Jul 31 '19

"More like the big mess" is too accurate

223

u/TheInfinityGauntlet Jul 31 '19

The part about some songs starting good and having potential before Chance comes in and just does something to ruin the track is so 100% on point

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

300

u/Iamallamala Jul 31 '19

He met Kanye West, he's never going to fail.

363

u/TheInfinityGauntlet Jul 31 '19

That verse was so good man I was really ready for Coloring Book to be incredible

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (2)

218

u/neverparley Jul 31 '19

There’s a reason Kanye’s name is seen nowhere on this garbage

183

u/BoobyLover69420 Jul 31 '19

when first seeing the track listing: "wtf ye, why you have to do this to us?"

after hearing the album: "ok ye you was right again"

seriously though, no Ye or Bino feature should have been the first big hint that the whole thing was garbage.

→ More replies (2)

213

u/Sentibite Jul 31 '19

I mean at least Kanye drops consistently good to amazing music.

→ More replies (24)

36

u/NSGWP_Mods Jul 31 '19

Kanye hasn't put out an album anywhere near as bad as this

8

u/LynchMaleIdeal . Jul 31 '19

he must have an incredible camp of yes men around him, a talent taught to him by his lord Yeezus Christ

yeah but Kanye never put out a trash LP like this, he ignored most of his yes men and did what he wanted lol

→ More replies (28)

160

u/WD23 Jul 31 '19

I don’t think I’ve ever viscerally cringed harder than the first time I listened to Hot Shower. A 0/10 is harsh but, considering the fact that there really is no track worth going back to at all, I can see why he had to do it to em.

→ More replies (4)

189

u/zeytah Jul 31 '19

Shout out to Chance for repping the top agricultural export of his home state of Illinois by making this album corny as fuck

seriously though it’s almost insulting how god awful the lyrics are on this thing. maybe not a 0/10 but pretty damn close to it

37

u/CaptainOvbious . Jul 31 '19

Shout out to Chance for repping the top agricultural export of his home state of Illinois by making this album corny as fuck

congrats on having one of the only funny comments where someone calls something corny.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

361

u/blackiechan99 . Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

"... then we have the track 'Hot Shower'. more like Hot Garbage"

I can't say it any better, this shit was an abomination and I could barely get past the first half. I've never really liked Chance, but Jesus H were his mixtapes so much better than this. this is almost 'are you sure you wanna put this out' type bad*

*on second thought, it's absolutely this bad

7

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

I listened to it once in disbelief, and then once for fun. It's so awful it's hilarious. "TRYNA CATCH SOME SLEEP!". What the fuckkkk

19

u/ACanadianPenguin Jul 31 '19

I'm appalled that it is the most popular song on the album (at least on Spotify)

It is truly the definition of sonic torture

His flow is laughably bad and the writing/bars are toxic waste

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (13)

89

u/TheyCallMeYDG Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

the “barbecue” line in Hot Shower had me crying laughing

and not in the good way either. I was crying laughing at Chance’s lyrics and that half-assed rip-off of Valee.

I’m so pissed off. I though Acid Rap and Coloring Book were perfect tapes. But this? THIS? Hot garbage.

WWE Analogy: Chance’s first three tapes: WWE ‘98, ‘99, ‘00. The Big Day is the WCW Invasion Angle of 2001.

Like the Invasion Angle, this album is sloppy. Incoherent. No flow or clear message. Just doing it because he’s at the height of his popularity and has to put something out.

8

u/Untitledprject Jul 31 '19

The Invasion angle at least had some highs like the ECW Originals turning on WWF. Or Austin joining the Alliance.

This is more WCW >will Goldberg follow the script????

→ More replies (2)

108

u/MasterTeacher123 Dinner with Jay-Z Jul 31 '19

The bars on this record are YouTube comment section level bad and I’m glad he pointed that out throughout the review. It was embarrassingly lazy

28

u/livindedannydevtio Jul 31 '19

I think it was todd in the shadows who said they were worried that chance peaked on his Grammy night. I said he was being ridiculous but now i say he was right.

10

u/enxj Jul 31 '19

i thought he only followed billboard pop

who am i kidding thats what chance is lmao

→ More replies (3)

102

u/OldTrafford25 . Jul 31 '19

I feel bad for Chance because it’s never fun to have people shit on your art. I hope he’s happy, because this is going to be hard for him.

This was Chance’s African Child in Get Him the The Greek terms.

The album is indeed a true 0 for me. Long album, not one song that I even thought was decent. It sounded so bad to me that I felt emotionally sad at times while listening to it. I’ve listened four times all the way through, and I actually like it significantly less each time, which I’m not sure has ever happened to me.

It’s such a letdown to me after those singles last year. I think Wala Cam, My Own Thing, 65th, and particularly Work Out are all incredible songs.

This might genuinely be the worst album I have listened to by an artist I generally enjoy.

59

u/SilkyGazelleWatkins Jul 31 '19

It sounded so bad to me that I felt emotionally sad at times while listening to it.

I know this wasn't supposed to be funny or anything but I find this hillarious

→ More replies (1)

12

u/GoodOutlook Jul 31 '19

LOL fucking african child

10

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

you feel less bad when you realize he's making millions off of low effort trash art

→ More replies (3)

53

u/PinkertonRams . Jul 31 '19

It’s easily Chance’s weakest album, but a gdamn 0? Damn that’s brutal.

Gotta hand it to Melon, he was articulate and well thought out as usual. Still seems too harsh to me

14

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

My thinking is, if there is not a single redeeming quality about the album does it really deserve anything more than a 0 even if it sounds 'harsh'? Like with most bad albums, you can point to a section or a beat that was ok, or a single cool bar, or an idea that would have been cool if the execution was better. This had none of that. Really a 22 track torture chamber.

143

u/pussyonapedestal Jul 31 '19

Jesus christ i didn't think the dude would really go through with it. A well deserved score given how talented Chance is and how he could've created a very good solo album but absolutely blew his chance heh

→ More replies (2)

343

u/ThatParanoidPenguin Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

I don’t think I can say I agree with how low this score is (album is definitely very bloated but I did enjoy a fair amount of tracks, and I don’t think this is anywhere as bad as SB2H or fucking Dead Petz for that matter) but my god did he tear this apart and that’s always really enjoyable.

This thread is gonna be hilarious and Fantano really is at his best shitting on an album or heaping it with praise.

I can’t believe he actually did it, Chance getting a lower score than Logic, Miley Cyrus, AND NAV. Truly a remarkable achievement.

133

u/atp2112 Jul 31 '19

I think for him, scores are based in part on artist expectations/intentions and how well they meet them, as well as his enjoyment of a project. So a 2 for Eminem =/= a 2 for X, for example, since both projects came with different artistic intentions, as well as different expectations surrounding the musician. That said, a 0 for this album still surprised me.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/esclasico Jul 31 '19

I'd rather listen to NAV than this shit. Tap, Habits and Baguettes in the Face are all bangers better than anything on this project.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/DeadmanIQ445 Jul 31 '19

Actually, no. He said that Supermarket is worse then SP2H, since it is not even trying to do something( on a Livestream, I believe). And Big day is strong 0 to a light 1, thus it is higher then SB2H. So it's a fight between Corey (since he said that album is worst in the decade in the review) and Logic for the worst album in his opinion.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

20

u/beemurz Jul 31 '19

Now that we have Chance’s Revival, I can’t wait for his Kamikaze. “Divorced my wife fuck that bitch, all these fake fans can eat fat dicks. AAAHHCK!”

→ More replies (6)

17

u/falconpunch9898 . Jul 31 '19

So I havent heard Chance's shit before and decided to give this album a shot. Heard Acid Rap was a banger, though, so I came in here with higher expectations.

Lo and behold, this album is hot fucking ass. Makes me not want to listen to whatever else he dropped. 100% agree with Melon

→ More replies (1)

43

u/tomseymour12 Jul 31 '19

A chance fan told me I was listening to the album wrong when I told him I thought it wasn’t great. He said I couldn’t label tracks as bad because it’s all part of one big narrative. He’s holding onto dear life trying to defend the album that he knows deep down is trash

32

u/ChrisTweten Jul 31 '19

Reminds me of J. Cole fans acting like his music is too deep for people that just don't like it

→ More replies (1)

15

u/JGar453 . Jul 31 '19

I didn't think it was 0 bad but this album was fucking awful. Definitely worse than Revival, probably worse than Speeding Bullet imo. I don't consider any 0s but all garbage. Also seems the entire music industry was paid off on this one, melon is the only negative reviewer. Chance is lethargic on this album, and he didn't need 22 tracks to talk about his marriage. He's also come off as an asshole as of late

14

u/CamusGrapes . Jul 31 '19

i’d give it like a 3 but i get his points. the only thing that got me through the album wasn’t chance but a couple beats and features. i enjoyed lil durk and dababy’s verses and the ben gibbard feature but chance at best was passable at any given point of it imo. to be fair i’ve never been a big chance fan but this really was a chore to get through.

12

u/hopeless_dick_dancer Jul 31 '19

A little off topic, but does this mean he's not going to review Maxo's album? Was looking forward to hearing his thoughts about it but it's been a bit since it came out

18

u/Ralamadul . Jul 31 '19

He reviewed the Benny the Butcher EP approximately 1 month after release, so it's definitely not impossible.

7

u/Horizon96 Jul 31 '19

It's in his latest YUNO, he basically just said he thinks there's some good songs on the album but overall it's average.

→ More replies (3)

293

u/pm_me_your_last_pics . Jul 31 '19

Hopefully this wakes him the fuck up. 0/10 is deserved. If you think this album is good you are delusional, seriously. I fucking love Chance but this is straight trash. Like what the fuck has gone on with him in the past 2 years. Say what you want about Coloring Book but shit give me that 10 times out of 10. "22 track torture chamber" describes it perfectly. Don't get me started on Hot Shower. Only good tracks were Roo (mostly because I've been wanting a new song with his brother), Do You Remember, 5 Year Plan, and Sun Come Down. Everything else is hot trash. Oh did I mention Hot Shower was horrible? The fact that it is getting praise by some people is fucking beyond me.

390

u/PARPS Jul 31 '19

Hot Shower is like when a group of high school kids make a lowest-effort-possible extra credit video for their chem class where they rap about covalent bonds.

65

u/JealousBishop Jul 31 '19

Lmaooooo. I'd want to see the extent of the overlap between the school rap and Chance fan circles

59

u/luvdadrafts . Jul 31 '19

And DaBaby is the guy that low key takes this shit seriously and does his best to salvage it to no avail

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

36

u/kimboslice11 . Jul 31 '19

Crazy part to me is that I loved his singles he dropped just last year.

Put those in the album and instant improvement.

Instead we got such a weak album it’s gross.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/j-benz . Jul 31 '19

Did he say Meg The Stallion was on Hot Shower?

→ More replies (1)

60

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

I really am the only dude on this website that loved this album, aren't I lmfao

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (35)

11

u/interwebbed Jul 31 '19

I really wanted to like this album, I did, but really no tracks really stand out so I don't find myself coming back to it. It sucks, I really wanted to put this one on repeat but it's just not doing it for me. Some track are okay but it doesn't hold enough. He should've stuck to a shorter tracklist and just destroy those. For a debut album, 20 something tracks is a big stretch. Hard to keep your audience interested

52

u/the_labracadabrador . Jul 31 '19

I agree with mostly all of what Fantano says but with that score: damn... you don’t need to crucify the guy.

Keep in mind how this albums faults are ones that push Anthony’s buttons like nothing else. This is coming from the guy who gave Swimming a 3, it’s no surprise he felt so strongly about a lackluster album of this nature.

26

u/luvdadrafts . Jul 31 '19

He gave Swimming a 3? Jesus

→ More replies (2)

23

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

Swimming didn't deserve that :\

10

u/virtualespionage Jul 31 '19

Chance in my opinion is very egotistical and through this album you can really see it. That “I ain’t single no more” on repeat off the track “found a good one” was cringe worthy. I feel he tried to addressed the people whom he knew were going to hate in the first track: “you can’t please everybody.” Which is true, especially in music, you can’t please everybody. I feel like he will run to that line and feel that is it’s defense.

But honest to his Christ and savior God, who did this album actually please...? -5/10 and that is coming from one of Chance’s biggest supporters and fan. I bumped Acid Rap non stop and still do to this day. I even found and defended the beauty found in “surf.” This album however is just pop, synth electronic garbage.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/Pig_Benis69 Jul 31 '19

Acid rap changed the way I viewed modern hip hop.

Coloring book brought a tear to my eye.

The big day gave me gas.

I can't believe the artist I used to scour the internet for his music and live performances dropped this travesty.

9

u/BigGucciThanos Jul 31 '19

“I LOVE MY WIFFFEEEEEEE “

lol album is a mess, and where’s all the fire instagram snippets he was posting. It’s ashame that if groceries or the all that song was on this project it be the best songs on here lol

Boy chance is changing and I can’t be mad at that. But I damn sure don’t have to listen to it. Hot shower the only that that got added to my playlist and even that song is too long and madeInToko should have been cut.

25

u/Jwad35 Jul 31 '19

This is the most iconic, hilarious, sad, memorable review I think he will ever do (maybe even more than MBDTF). He gave it a 0. Holy shit. This is hilarious

38

u/mayodefender Jul 31 '19

Hell yes Fandango

The worst part about this record is the sheer mediocrity. It’s one thing to make a bad record, but this record peaks at points that are so banal and forgettable that it’s almost worse than being bad. At least terrible records are going to be remembered for something...

→ More replies (2)

326

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

God damn, I am so excited that Fantano went and did it to Chance. This album was hot fucking garbage (or should I say, shower)? I can't believe people really enjoy it. It is so trash, and deserves this negative criticism. Chance really, REALLY dropped the ball.

Now, I already didn't like Chance's music (at all), even Coloring Book, but this album really made it so I'm never going to really give him another chance (ha ha). Shit, I'll even give Logic another chance whenever he drops another album, and he hasn't put out really anything good since TITS. 0/10 for me as well.

22

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

That logic comparison is brutal lmao point well made

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (136)

8

u/orangehatkid . Jul 31 '19

After having listened to Fantano's review and reading a few others, I finally understand why this album gets as much hate as it does (although I think 0 is even a little egregious, but that's why these are opinion pieces, we are going to disagree). I listened to this album while I was preoccupied doing something else, and because of how inoffensive this album sounds when you aren't really "listening" it is really easy to think that this album is better than it is.

Having gone back and listened to some of my favorite tracks from the album again, I can see what Fantano is getting at, especially in regards to lyricism. These are far and away the cheesiest lines Chance has put on a project, and they are consistent through out, not just one-offs for comedic relief. It's as if this whole album tries to be comedic relief, and I think that's where the problem ultimately lies.

7

u/LegitPandaMang Jul 31 '19

that was brutal. i'm glad to hear someone felt similarly about chance's bars. they were just SO on the nose. i was really doubting my opinion because of how chance has been lyrically in the past.

7

u/jakeringo Jul 31 '19

I'm bummed out by how bad this album is. But I'm also super happy that TIERRA WHACK exists and honestly is putting out some of the most exciting music in the game right now. I only mention Tierra because I think her music fills any hole that Chance might leave. Tierra out here fillin' holes

6

u/DeepFreezeDisease Jul 31 '19

I mostly agree but Fantano fucks up when he says he wants to take out Megan The Stallion's bar in Hot Shower (she doesn't rap in that song?) and also the basketball reference to the Professor is completely missed

6

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

My gripe with this album is just how unremarkable it is. With each mixtape Chance dropped, there's just something about those works that made each individual project special and unique.

10 Day was a 'fuck the establishment, we still thriving' kind of vibe, with a sort or triumphant and powerful theme of still finding life even more enjoyable after fucking up pretty badly (he got suspended for 10 days due to smoking weed on campus)

Acid Rap is a bit of a no-brainer. The bars, the production, the delivery, everything felt like a massive drug trip that goes just right. From the intro to the outro, everything truly felt on point and rather mesmerising. It was rap's equivalent to Tame Impala's Currents long before such an album even existed lmao. One of the best mixtapes of all time, period.

Colouring Book had kind of the opposite effect to 10 Day, with Chance finding happiness in his successes such as staying independent, making music for everyone for free, getting off the drugs etc. and expressing this happiness in an actual fun and sensational way, all the way from the Kanye feature to the gospel that runs throughout the project. It is literally The Big Day, but much MUCH better with an actual structure and cohesive message to spread to its listeners - be happy by changing your life for the better.

Now what does The Big Day have? All of the tracks sound different, I cannot think of a single good line from the fucking album that stayed with me (except 'every song could be the outro' I thought that was nice) and there was no long-lasting, empowering effect similar to Chance's other projects. This felt more like a tape of demos that bare no resemblance to his previous mixtapes and each of their main themes - when trying to describe how this album made me as a listener feel, all I could come up with is 'OOH I LOVE MY WIFEEEEE' and 'Be happy otherwise I will fucking kill you'.

To summarise, this project could be seen as Chance's version of 'Folding Clothes' by J Cole, except having it stretched out to over an hour of Chance jerking himself off for being married via his wedding ring alone. Even that isn't a fair comparison, as The Big Day lacks any of the charm, instrumentation and vocals that made the 4YEO song listenable.

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 31 '19

REMINDER: Review thread guidelines:

  • Parent comments in review threads must be over 140 characters.

  • Comments that solely name the score or describe the clothing the reviewer is wearing are not allowed

  • Meta comments solely about how the subreddit will react to the review are also not allowed.

  • Comments that only compare the review to other scores by the publication or by other publications are not allowed.

  • If this is a Fantano review, visit r/fantanoforever for all low-effort comments

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/5ive22 Jul 31 '19

I completely agree. Production on this album was not even close to the standard he set in Coloring Book. The only good feature is Gucci on Big Fish but Kanye would have had a better feature. The album is way too “poppy” and the lyrics are disappointing to say the least.

But on a positive note I feel that YBN Cordae put out an album that rivals coloring book, and you can tell that he has had a lot of inspiration from Chance. I would definitely give The Lost Boy a listen if you haven’t already!

→ More replies (2)

5

u/senoniuqhcaz Jul 31 '19

Melon really was simultaneously offended, confused, and disorientated while reading those lyrics out loud. Almost as if he was trying to convince himself that Chance has to be trolling only to realize that it was in fact a very serious effort.

5

u/2trill702 Aug 01 '19

I remember I got downvoted in this sub for saying it was gonna be hot garbage and man truth be told I wish it wasn’t but this album one of the most boring and uncreative things ever

9

u/shoxballin11 Jul 31 '19

Him reading the lyrics out to the opener really highlight how BAD these references are. Yes, he’s spitting fast and the scheme is good - but wtf is he talking about?

11

u/Boh-dar Jul 31 '19

I honestly had no idea Coloring Book won three freaking Grammy's. That was a good year for hip hop and it won over The Life Of Pablo, Run The Jewels 3, Schoolboy Q, Untitled Unmastered, Danny Brown, and A Tribe Called Quest?

I know I know, Grammy's are trash. But damn....is there even a single person who has listened to coloring book since 2017?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

There is something so satisfying about hearing Fantano explain exactly how you feel about an album but just a lot more eloquently than you can put it lmfao. This album was downright offensive to music

4

u/broby52 Jul 31 '19

I mean its fun and games to shit on but god damn Chances trend downwards is just sad. I am rooting for a comeback but I am sincerely not holding my breath nor will I anticipate any future quality releases.

4

u/KGeedora Jul 31 '19

Never been the biggest fan of Fantano but this is all correct. I gave this thing a 1 (honestly without trying to be hyperbolic). I hope this stuff gets back to Chance purely to make him hungry to change up big time for his next project

4

u/SilverSurfer1738 Jul 31 '19

definitely not good. The song I like the most is 'Do you remember', mostly because of Ben Gibbard during the chorus. For me to enjoy the song, I have to ignore Chance's lyrics and just kinda wait until the chorus comes back.

51

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

A 0/10? I understand completely hating this tape but that implies it’s at the quality of Speedin’ Bullet 2 Heaven which was just borderline unlistenable and gave a “Kid Cudi is losing his mind” feeling.

20

u/MuricanTragedy5 Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

It’s more that Chance has shown he has such amazing talent in the past, not mention all the money, time and clout he’s had coming into this, and then he puts out this hot pile of dog shit. It’s a pretty fair score with that in mind

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Shademan_DS Jul 31 '19

I mean that's how I felt listening to this album too

43

u/succx . Jul 31 '19

SB2H had at least 5 good tracks though

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

68

u/v0rdul Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

A 0? That’s a little extreme. The album is not inaudible. Maybe he didn’t like that it was so long and he had to sit through the whole thing? Guess I don’t blame him lol

Chance should’ve put out a 7 track album lol

182

u/TheInfinityGauntlet Jul 31 '19

You could pick any 7 tracks off this project, it wouldn't crack above a 4 and the score would only increase (in comparison to this) due to being more respectful of the listeners time

→ More replies (9)

6

u/Zoombini22 Jul 31 '19

Fantano definitely lowers the score when you go 0/22 tracks instead of 0/10 tracks. It's more painful to sit through the longer it is

→ More replies (6)

7

u/LynchMaleIdeal . Jul 31 '19

Is nobody gonna mention Cal’s appearance? That was fucking hilarious. Everything he said about the album is true though and the outpour of comments here that agree with that sentiment goes to show. I wonder if Chance will now dub this as a mixtape (despite what it’s title refers to) due to it flopping or he’ll just jack the media and remove all negative opinions again.

This whole album rubs me the wrong way; weak production, shit lyricism and obnoxious amount of tracks. And what the fuck is that artwork supposed to mean? It literally looks like an image you’d get on the packaging of a blank CD set.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/charlesokstate Jul 31 '19

Years ago I’d think you were crazy If you told me Tyler the creator was a better more impactful artist than chance but he is miles and miles ahead.

17

u/Stevepwm Jul 31 '19

This is even worse than speeding bullet to heaven. Anthony gave kid cudi just a 0 while he gave a chance a strong 0 which to my knowledge is the worst possible rating you can get.

24

u/Its_Your_Boi_MaxB . Jul 31 '19

strong 0 is better than 0

it would go light 0 > 0 > strong 0 > light 1 > 1 > strong 1

→ More replies (5)

9

u/P1SSY3LL0W Jul 31 '19

Kind of crazy that he gave this album a 0 but it still might not be #1 on his worst albums of the year list, he did say supermarket was worse than sb2h after all.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

I'm thinking this one will take the cake. He did say 1 or 2 good things about Supermarket, but couldn't pull it out here.

9

u/bootysensei Jul 31 '19

0?! Holy shit somebody in the release thread called this Chance's "Speeding Bullet 2 Heaven", but I thought he was over-exaggerating..

Everybody find that prophet!!

15

u/Its_Your_Boi_MaxB . Jul 31 '19

I also saw somebody claim Fantano would surprise people and give this an 8

Let's also find that clown

6

u/majormind329 Jul 31 '19

This album really shows that Chance really flanderized himself in every sense of the concept, but honestly I don't think he'll change from making this kind of saccharine gospel pop rap because (just like Kanye) he won't accept any criticism. Genuinely believe other reviewers went easy on him partly because of the positive persona he's cultivated and partly because of his evangelism, the latter of which no US publication will touch with a 10 foot pole.

3

u/AchillesShort Jul 31 '19

0/10 is harsh but Chance has so much hype and expectations around him that he really should have put out something with substance. Everything on this album just feels so lazily put together. Here's hoping he takes the criticism and comes out with something better in the future.

3

u/xeno-dwarf Jul 31 '19

Everybody that is saying this is not a 0/10 but a 2/3 out of ten is missing the point.

Overall a great review and fair play to fantano for not holding anything back. Sucks that this pile of trash will still go number one, probably pulling the wool over chance’s eyes.

3

u/Easycumup Jul 31 '19

Also, I can’t fathom why in the world the reception on Twitter seems to mostly be positive when I search about the album. Or, the “Owbum”

“Ow”! My ears! “Bum” ass boring bitch. Indeed !

Lol, I’ll see my self out now

→ More replies (1)

3

u/iWORKBRiEFLY Jul 31 '19

I seriously, like him, did not like any track at all. I usually like at least a couple tracks on every album i listen to except genres I don't like (like death metal). This is bad, he needs to recall this album.

3

u/landofthebeez Aug 01 '19

I wasn't a big fan of Coloring Book so when i was listening to Big Day I just thought it was another miss for me from Chance. But damn.

I've been meaning to go back, give it another chance, and finish listening to it but there was nothing there for me the first time up.

3

u/usernamessuxx Aug 20 '19

I don’t always agree with Fantano but when he’s right he’s god damn right. The max I would give that album is 1/10 cause I liked some of the features but never more than half a song, especially if it was just Chance.

7

u/Fadedfaith451 Jul 31 '19

Do you guys think the Album would have been better if it had a major label behind it? I feel like chance is trying to be too independent to the point where he's in a space where he gets no feedback or input. I can't see any label or team messing up like this

→ More replies (5)

102

u/ItsMDG Jul 31 '19 edited Jul 31 '19

It's about time everyone finally sees through the Chance hype. The only time he ever resembled something good was when he dropped acid rap and everybody tried weed for their first time freshman year of high school and wanted to be edgy. Then everyone rode his dick even more all because he said "This is my part nobody else speak" on ultra light beam. Everything he has done has been sub par.

114

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

You're not wrong but Acid Rap was genuinely great. Flows, beats, personality, substance, album structure, etc. He went downhill fast.

30

u/Khal-Stevo Jul 31 '19

Lost me at the ultra light beam shade, that verse is an absolute banger

→ More replies (1)

83

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

this is super harsh. the album sucked, but you don’t have to go far back to hear some great stuff from Chance. The man who has everything was so promising

38

u/magkruppe . Jul 31 '19

I mean thats just plain wrong... people loved 10 Day and coloring book. And people still do, they're not gonna start disliking Chance's old stuff

22

u/KawhiDollaSign Jul 31 '19

If you think that’s all Acid Rap is, you’re delusional. Chain Smoker, Acid Rain, and Cocoa Butter Kisses are perfect songs. The Big Day sucked, but to think he’s always been this bad is absurd.

11

u/broncosfighton Jul 31 '19

The hype was deserved after Acid Rap and the features he was putting down for a couple of years lol this album doesn't just re-write history

→ More replies (1)

9

u/shagreezz3 Jul 31 '19

Im ready for the downvotes but here it goes, tbh Chance did have alot of hype around him after dropping 10 day and acid rap, however, I was about 23 years old when that came out and to this day both of those tapes are dope, you seem to be discrediting them when you say “everybody tried weed and wanted to be edgy” which seems to say you dont think those are any good?

You made a valid point about the hype but honestly you sound like one of those people who see ppl dickride a artist and at that point you dont care about the music or quality, you now dislike that guy because you feel he has undeserved hype, coming off as someone who just dislikes chance period because of his fan base

72

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

Acid Rap is one of my favorite albums ever. And it was unique. I'll forever check out his new work. I don't have to like it. But you seem mad about it

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '19

Huge disagree I can still go back to everything else he's made and I still like it. I don't worship him like some people did and I never have, but I still love all three of his mixtapes. Just because this album sucks doesn't change that.

→ More replies (16)

5

u/kloocoo Jul 31 '19

Some of the songs would have been great without chance’s wack ass rhymes that try too hard or don’t try at all

“Roo” for example has great ass music production in the back but chance tries too hard to be unique that it ruined the song

→ More replies (1)

8

u/shadynasty_etl Jul 31 '19

Damn man. I don’t see a single post in here about the album being good. I actually really liked it. I definitely like acid rap and coloring book better but damn, 0-10?? He’s happy and real as fuck on this album and that’s what music is about. Not comparing it to his old shit. Not comparing him to other people. Not listening to some dude who reviews it on YouTube. Yea everyone has their own opinion but I’m surprised that almost NO ONE in this thread likes it.

→ More replies (6)