r/btc • u/SwedishSalsa • Jul 14 '19
Satoshi reply to Mike Hearn, April 2009. Everybody, especially newcomers and r-bitcoin-readers should take a step back and read this.
From: Satoshi Nakamoto [email protected] Date: Sun, Apr 12, 2009 at 10:44 PM To: Mike Hearn [email protected]
Hi Mike,
I’m glad to answer any questions you have. If I get time, I ought to write a FAQ to supplement the paper.
There is only one global chain.
The existing Visa credit card network processes about 15 million Internet purchases per day worldwide. Bitcoin can already scale much larger than that with existing hardware for a fraction of the cost. It never really hits a scale ceiling. If you’re interested, I can go over the ways it would cope with extreme size.
By Moore’s Law, we can expect hardware speed to be 10 times faster in 5 years and 100 times faster in 10. Even if Bitcoin grows at crazy adoption rates, I think computer speeds will stay ahead of the number of transactions.
I don’t anticipate that fees will be needed anytime soon, but if it becomes too burdensome to run a node, it is possible to run a node that only processes transactions that include a transaction fee. The owner of the node would decide the minimum fee they’ll accept. Right now, such a node would get nothing, because nobody includes a fee, but if enough nodes did that, then users would get faster acceptance if they include a fee, or slower if they don’t. The fee the market would settle on should be minimal. If a node requires a higher fee, that node would be passing up all transactions with lower fees. It could do more volume and probably make more money by processing as many paying transactions as it can. The transition is not controlled by some human in charge of the system though, just individuals reacting on their own to market forces.
Eventually, most nodes may be run by specialists with multiple GPU cards. For now, it’s nice that anyone with a PC can play without worrying about what video card they have, and hopefully it’ll stay that way for a while. More computers are shipping with fairly decent GPUs these days, so maybe later we’ll transition to that.
A key aspect of Bitcoin is that the security of the network grows as the size of the network and the amount of value that needs to be protected grows. The down side is that it’s vulnerable at the beginning when it’s small, although the value that could be stolen should always be smaller than the amount of effort required to steal it. If someone has other motives to prove a point, they’ll just be proving a point I already concede.
My choice for the number of coins and distribution schedule was an educated guess. It was a difficult choice, because once the network is going it’s locked in and we’re stuck with it. I wanted to pick something that would make prices similar to existing currencies, but without knowing the future, that’s very hard. I ended up picking something in the middle. If Bitcoin remains a small niche, it’ll be worth less per unit than existing currencies. If you imagine it being used for some fraction of world commerce, then there’s only going to be 21 million coins for the whole world, so it would be worth much more per unit. Values are 64-bit integers with 8 decimal places, so 1 coin is represented internally as 100000000. There’s plenty of granularity if typical prices become small. For example, if 0.001 is worth 1 Euro, then it might be easier to change where the decimal point is displayed, so if you had 1 Bitcoin it’s now displayed as 1000, and 0.001 is displayed as 1.
Ripple is interesting in that it’s the only other system that does something with trust besides concentrate it into a central server.
Satoshi
Source: https://nakamotostudies.org/emails/satoshi-reply-to-mike-hearn/
76
u/masterD3v Jul 14 '19 edited Jul 14 '19
The fee the market would settle on should be minimal.
To bring this full-circle, BTC's peak average transaction fee of $54.901 on December 21st, 2017 was not minimal. Core wants $100-500 transaction fees. They should be removed from the Bitcoin project due to Blockstream's conflicts of interest.
It could do more volume and probably make more money by processing as many paying transactions as it can.
In summary, the plan was for to miners make money with low fees on many transactions, not high fees on only a few transactions. Further, this fee market isn't actually needed for decades, because our hardware can handle 32Mb and has outpaced usage, just as Satoshi theorized.
57
u/JerryGallow Jul 14 '19
They were removed through the creation of Bitcoin Cash.
14
-2
u/sebrings2k Jul 15 '19
The only thing bcash removed was decentralization. I read Satoshi and look at Bitcoin and for me it's working perfectly. I'm not worried about transactions.
5
u/JerryGallow Jul 15 '19 edited Jul 15 '19
I'm not worried about transactions.
Bitcoin is literally a system to facilitate a series of transactions.
1
u/phro Jul 20 '19
2MB to 32MB blocks are far less centralizing than pricing out 3/4ths of the world's population. The fees even preclude small miners from taking daily pool payouts. There is 0 evidence that modest block size increase would have caused centralization. In fact Bitcoin's rise from 0 to 1MB completely contradicts the narrative that raw block size and centralization are inversely related.
1
u/sebrings2k Jul 21 '19
I would agree with, there is zero need to increase block size at this time. I'm not going to say Bitcoin is perfect. But for now it is, I want a privacy fix I before I want transactions fix. Maybe other people's encentive's are different. I experienced mining like most of us and I don't currently think it's centralized.
-9
27
u/500239 Jul 14 '19
And then you have users like /u/gizram84 who have shifted Bitcoin's purpose so much they're telling it's not for retail payments and the high fees are a good thing. Idiots.
Retail isn't important. Currency is needed for more important things than retail. - /u/gizram84
.
What does any of this nonsense have to do with what we're talking about? Just for one minute try to wrap your head around the fact that mundane petty retail txs are not important. Just try. - /u/gizram84
My how the goalposts keep shifting. Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, not for retail use.
-32
u/gizram84 Jul 14 '19
And then you have users like /u/gizram84 who have shifted Bitcoin's purpose so much they're telling it's not for retail payments and the high fees are a good thing. Idiots.
First of all, why do you mention my username every day? You have a very odd obsession with me. It's weirding me out.
Second of all, like usual, you completely misrepresent my argument. I have simply said that petty retail isn't important, not that you can't use Bitcoin for retail. I just think unimportant things could be done on second layers.
But why should I expect something more than outright lying by scammy BCH fanboys? Pretty par for this sub.
19
u/500239 Jul 14 '19
Did I misquote you or are those your quotes? Do you believe retail for Bitcoin is not important?
Retail isn't important. Currency is needed for more important things than retail. - /u/gizram84
Your words not mine. Please expand on your vision of Bitcoin.
-19
u/gizram84 Jul 14 '19
Yes, that's what I said. Retail isn't important. I never said it can't be done. As I've said from the beginning. Petty, unimportant use cases can always be done on some layer two solution.
15
u/500239 Jul 14 '19
That's all I needed to hear thanks. Retail is second to a store of value on Bitcoin: Peer-to-peer Electronic Cash.
-10
u/gizram84 Jul 14 '19
Yes. I prioritize the important use cases. Storing your earned wealth in a decentralized, inflation proof asset that can't be seized or garnished. Escaping keynesian monetary policy is revolutionary. Buying coffee at Starbucks is mundane and unimportant.
So Bitcoin can prioritize the store of value use case, and BCH can prioritize buying socks at Walmart. We'll see which coin the market values more.
6
u/snugghash Jul 15 '19
Your vision for bitcoin would make it basically yet another belief-based cult token, like all the other currencies (even gold, pre-electronics use case). It makes the case for maximalism and the banning of bitcoin by all countries (because then it's competing with belief in their country's token), effectively killing it because nothing that's not dark web can be represented in BTC.
Market value is meaningless without usecase. USD for example only has value because it's being used, and that's in SPITE of inflation. The belief in it is stronger than inflation can dilute. If BTC appears as competition; it becomes an investment vehicle with 10% yoy returns and low economic transaction fees, thus leading to it being considered a foreign currency and banned.
2
u/gizram84 Jul 15 '19
Your vision for bitcoin would make it basically yet another belief-based cult token, like all the other currencies (even gold, pre-electronics use case).
That is a completely inaccurate, and it doesn't represent what I believe. This is just a nonsensical rant.
Market value is meaningless without usecase.
Agreed. But that use case has to be meaningful. Buying socks at Walmart is a stupid use case that has little market value. No one has a problem paying for mundane consumer goods. It's not important, and no one is going to switch to cryptocurrencies for this use.
Escaping global keynesian monetary policy is revolutionary. That is an important use case. Being able to save and transact in an inflation proof store of value will help billions of the most oppressed people on earth.
So you can prioritize BCH for buying socks, and I'll prioritize BTC for protecting against inflation, central banks, and statism, and we'll see which use case the free market values more.
2
u/snugghash Jul 20 '19
Escaping global keynesian monetary policy is revolutionary. That is an important use case. Being able to save and transact in an inflation proof store of value will help billions of the most oppressed people on earth.
And what specific evidence would convince you otherwise on this? If there's nothing, it's by definition a religion...
Regardless, I see the value and want what you described to happen. But I think higher transaction costs than now (both in raw financial cost and the offset from the economic my-currency-is-no-longer-subject-to-monetary-policy cost) will prevent any further adoption at all.
→ More replies (0)5
u/jessquit Jul 15 '19
if I store my wealth in a coin that doesn't allow me to freely exchange it at will because it has a built in transaction flow restrictor then my sovereignty over my store of value is reduced commensurate with the friction incurred in using my money as I see fit to pay whomever I want when I want
if I have to lock my funds in a channel with a counterparty to enable me to use my funds as I see fit, then my sovereignty over those funds is also reduced commensurate with my counterparties ability to block transactions or delay my ability to recover funds (typically 7-10 days)
a network which is uncongested and therefore allows me to move my funds to whom I choose, when I choose, with essentially no fiction offers me greater sovereignty over my funds than one which is congested and may cause me to incur delays or significant fees in order to access what should me mine to control if I want to consider myself sovereign.
1
u/gizram84 Jul 15 '19
a coin that doesn't allow me to freely exchange it at will
This doesn't describe bitcoin.
I have to lock my funds in a channel with a counterparty to enable me to use my funds as I see fit
You don't have to do this. Lightning is optional.
a network which is uncongested
I think you meant "unused".
Your whole rant is basically just "I won't use Bitcoin because too many people use it. I just want a dead blockchain because low fees are more important than security".
This is why BCH is worthless, and dropping. No one wants a dead, unused, toy blockchain with no security. If you don't understand that, you're going to end up broke.
But like I've said to you before, I bet you're still actually holding bitcoin, because the loudest critics always seem to quietly know deep down that BCH is going to be a failure. That's the difference. I know BCH is a failure, so I dumped it to aquire more BTC. But you'll never sell your BTC, because deep down you know it's revolutionary.
2
u/jessquit Jul 15 '19 edited Jul 15 '19
you can say BCH has no security but it securely moves over a billion dollars a day which is more than any other token except BTC and BCH has not been successfully attacked once since its inception so I'm starting to wonder if you know what you're talking about
→ More replies (0)3
u/pecuniology Jul 15 '19
You position is that Bitcoin users should restrict the assets that they can exchange Bitcoin for to national fiat currencies through the banking system, rather than directly for goods and services.
0
u/gizram84 Jul 15 '19
That's not accurate at all. That's not my position. You're just lying.
1
u/pecuniology Jul 15 '19
Whoa there, tiger. No need for drama and outrage. It was a simple observation.
If Bitcoin is not to be used to buy socks at Wal-Mart, then what specifically is it be used to buy?
→ More replies (0)1
u/phro Jul 20 '19
Commerce is price discovery. Value is what someone will give you in exchange. BTC is solely for large sum speculation or niche premium use cases that can tolerate undefined confirmation times.
→ More replies (0)1
u/phro Jul 20 '19
Or they will go to substitute coins and if that coin happens to use SHA256 it will erode BTC's one remaining selling point of hash monopoly. The aggregate of all use cases priced out of BTC will almost certainly exceed a smaller niche of premium use cases.
1
u/gizram84 Jul 20 '19
Or they will go to substitute coins
I doubt it. You BCH zealots have been saying that for years, and BCH has only lost value compared to bitcoin. The split is now about 97/3. When will you admit defeat?
and if that coin happens to use SHA256 it will erode BTC's one remaining selling point of hash monopoly
Retail isn't the source of "hash monopoly". Price is. Miners follow the value. They will mine whichever coin is most profitable. Not whichever coin is being used to buy coffee.
The aggregate of all use cases priced out of BTC will almost certainly exceed a smaller niche of premium use cases.
Again, retail isn't an important use case. People aren't buying cryptocurrency because they want another payment option at the register. The reason they're buying is for a store of value.
Even if BCH overtakes Bitcoin as a retail payment option (it won't), it still won't be worth anything, because people will continue to use their credit cards 99% of the time.
The only worthy use case is escaping the power of central banks and inflation. That is what makes bitcoin valuable and important. That is why people value bitcoin, and why BCH is worthless in comparison.
10
-7
u/BOMinvest Redditor for less than 90 days Jul 14 '19
500239 does like to cause trouble. He seems to enjoy picking fights with those that have dissenting opinions and grind them down with strawmen and red herrings.
-11
u/Storm5had0w Jul 14 '19
lol does that guy really mention you every day? You have your very own Reddit stalker X_X
1
u/gizram84 Jul 14 '19
2
u/emobe_ Jul 15 '19
well all they've done is point out what you said and you've agreed that's what was said so rip exposed
1
u/gizram84 Jul 15 '19
You wouldn't find it weird if you woke up every morning to someone calling out your reddit username in threads you weren't even participating in?
1
u/emobe_ Jul 15 '19
Of course, however you're not some random person, you don't "never participate". It's a subreddit as a whole.
0
Jul 14 '19
[deleted]
6
Jul 14 '19
Paid shills organized themselves into trade unions and demanded free reddit gold per 10 posts.
10
Jul 14 '19
To reiterate: BTC bets on high fees, because with limited transactions per block, it won't be able to pay the miners for securing the chain, long-term.
Sometimes-low-fees on BTC will be extinct.
-5
u/antikama Jul 14 '19
Core wants $100-500 transaction fees.
Source?
20
u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Jul 14 '19
0
u/MDDx0z Redditor for less than 30 days Jul 14 '19
He literally says lower fees would be really good. How does he “want” $100-500 fees?
1
u/phro Jul 20 '19 edited Jul 20 '19
https://twitter.com/adam3us/status/872422714237177856
Further down the thread he says segwit will get those fees down. He's either malicious or he was flat out wrong.
https://twitter.com/adam3us/status/872690738752086016
Also, just FYI almost every one of us banned from /r/bitcoin predicted that segwit would not deliver any meaningful increase in capacity. They are not building to reduce fees. They deliberately created the fee market. They're also economically illiterate about how equilibrium is restored and they clearly didn't predict that people would seek substitutes.
-8
u/antikama Jul 14 '19
Doesnt say $500 though. Its just one persons opinion. Master03V made it seem like everyone on bitcoin wants that
7
u/mojo_jojo_mark Jul 14 '19
Still says $100 though. Usually, if he is saying it, minions are saying it too.
Imagine buying into that store of value coin when it hit 14k last week, then seeing your stored value drop to 10k today....then decide to remove it to be hit with a fee...awesome.
-20
u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Jul 14 '19
That’s great, all of these are such great points. You should fork off and see if the market follows you. 🙂
14
u/MarchewkaCzerwona Jul 14 '19
That’s great, all of these are such great points. You should fork off and see if the market follows you. 🙂
Thing is, market will jump on any scam that promises pump and profit.
Market is not good indicator is coin working or valuable to deliver bitcoin idea goal. Market chase profit probability and is very unstable in doing so.
-15
u/MikeLittorice Jul 14 '19
Looking at the current state of Bitcoin Cash: apparently not every scam.
13
5
4
0
Jul 15 '19
[deleted]
1
u/LovelyDay Jul 15 '19
Hello newly bought, wiped aged shill account
0
Jul 15 '19
[deleted]
3
u/LovelyDay Jul 15 '19
Every shill wants to resell their account to another shilling outfit once its burned.
It is however a violation of Reddit's User Agreement
-15
u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Jul 14 '19
Market is not good indicator is coin working or valuable to deliver bitcoin idea goal.
This is the biggest lie being peddle on this sub lately. You’d have to believe this to still be involved with a failing coin. But holy shit, you guys love the white paper, but fail to understand the markets and game theory that underpin bitcoin’s success.
7
u/MarchewkaCzerwona Jul 14 '19 edited Jul 14 '19
Is it really a lie?
Does it mean you would be able to accept centralised Orwellian coin only because market says so?
Do I fail to understand market and "game theory"? Perhaps.
What I see though for couple of years now, is cupidity and total lack of understanding of what bitcoin was supposed to deliver.
That's why noobs keep showing price as measurement of success, which is not.
Edit : correcting autocorrect
1
u/zeptochain Jul 14 '19
Self-gilding isn't really valid dude.
-2
u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Jul 15 '19
The banks give me the money, I actually prefer BCH they just pay me to be here.
12
u/wisequote Jul 14 '19
Unban everyone who would share exactly those points from rBitcoin, and watch the market follow.
Go ahead and share those great points yourself, you’ll be banned in no time.
You kidnapped a momentum you dimwit, don’t quote your hostile takeover and censorship and the resulting market ignorance as a success metric, because that just makes you a filthier being than you already are.
Blockstream cockroach.
-10
u/shazvaz Jul 14 '19
Eventually the mining community will collectively come to our senses and choose to run an upgraded client on the main chain. It's a group consensus that needs to be achieved, but once it is there is nothing Blockstream or Core can do to stop it.
9
u/etherael Jul 14 '19
You might want to research the way the exchanges actually decide what btc is before you say that. I won't ruin the surprise for you but let's just say you're in for one.
-4
u/shazvaz Jul 14 '19
I couldn't care less what any particular exchange uses as a ticker. At the moment Bitcoin is given the BTC ticker on most exchanges but that isn't what makes it Bitcoin. What makes it Bitcoin is majority hashpower and longest valid chain. Exchanges and tickers will follow.
8
u/etherael Jul 14 '19
Exchanges and tickers will follow.
You're in for a rude surprise. Look up the exchange announcements from major exchanges around the time of the s2x split.
-3
u/shazvaz Jul 14 '19
Why would I care what they do? I can confirm for myself which chain is Bitcoin, I don't need some central authority to tell me. You've clearly missed the point of Bitcoin in the first place, maybe you'd be better suited to USD where the government can keep you safe and tell you which currency to use.
8
u/etherael Jul 14 '19
You don't seem to realise the Nash equilibrium of a pack of clueless herd cultist followers buying a ticker symbol they don't understand which is by extension allocated by the fiat issuance of a software package from a group of six people, given the fact that miners must pay for ops costs in fiat currencies the vast majority of the time, and the exchanges control the bulk of transfer between fiat and cryptocurrency.
Just keep reading the above until you figure it out I guess.
-1
u/shazvaz Jul 14 '19
Or it's just that I don't care. You're way too hung up on what other people are doing, no wonder 'thought leaders' are so big around here, a lot of you can't think for yourselves.
8
u/etherael Jul 14 '19
Whether you care or not doesn't matter. According to your own policy you're going to be permanently on the chain that has rules defined by the current core council, period. I'm tired of explaining shit to you and remembering how fucking stupid you are so I'm going to leave it there. You have fun.
1
u/shazvaz Jul 14 '19
I'm going to be permanently on the chain which achieves majority hashrate and accumulated proof of work, regardless of which client it is running, and regardless of which ticker any exchange happens to use to list it.
14
u/BitcoinIsTehFuture Moderator Jul 14 '19
Ripple is interesting in that it’s the only other system that does something with trust besides concentrate it into a central server.
Ripple existed back then? I thought it came out later.
7
u/ErdoganTalk Jul 14 '19
Yes it was before bitcoin, but it doesn't use proof of work as described in satoshis invention, so I don't regard it as a proper cryptocoin
9
-29
u/poopiemess Jul 14 '19
Different things, XRP is a scam like BCH. They stole the name.
19
u/Ithinkstrangely Jul 14 '19 edited Jul 14 '19
BCH preserves Bitcoin's original protocol; BCH is true to the intention of Bitcoin and follows Satoshi's roadmap. BCH will and CAN be used as money after a worldwide economic collapse.
You're either are a corporate schill or you're oblivious that BTC was hijacked by corporations. Or, you're a non-libertarian thinker who embraces corporate control and theft.
Bitcoin is not a for profit play for an elite group controlling it's development.
It's an instrument for transfering wealth and exposing the corruption of governments and elites. And, other criminals.
It's a redundancy for when economic systems collapse. It's a fallback. A plan B. Which is looking like it's going to be needed. Good job Satoshi!
Enjoy your electronic "fool's gold"! (BTC. RIP that chain.)
edit: l2lawofacceleratingreturns
14
u/AlastarYaboy Jul 14 '19
You read the email and still think bch is a scam? Are you functionally retarded?
Oh wait. You didn't bother to read the post at all. Just here to push a narrative.
-7
u/poopiemess Jul 14 '19
I've read the emai, I read it when Mike published it.
10
u/mojo_jojo_mark Jul 14 '19
You clearly didn't, otherwise you would admit BTC has been crippled and the project rescued by BCH.
1
u/poopiemess Jul 15 '19
It did turn out great for Bitcoin, when the BCH crowd left.
The markets jumped happily.
2
0
Jul 14 '19
[deleted]
1
u/harbinger-alpha Jul 14 '19
Wait...what? Ripple existed before BTC? And Satoshi commented on it favorably? This actually makes me want to pick up a few more.
6
4
1
u/TTEEVV Jul 20 '19
Classic Ripplepay is probably intended to be an accounting system for local currencies or LETS. It's not decentralized and there's no finality of settlement (it's a credit network…), but it seems to be the model for the oft-overlooked IOU component of the XRP and XLM ledgers, so those ledgers are perhaps a merger of Ryan Fugger's classic ripplepay with Jed McCaleb's Bitcoin without mining concept.
1
u/WikiTextBot Jul 20 '19
Local exchange trading system
A local exchange trading system (also local employment and trading system or local energy transfer system; abbreviated LETS) is a locally initiated, democratically organised, not-for-profit community enterprise that provides a community information service and records transactions of members exchanging goods and services by using locally created currency. LETS allow people to negotiate the value of their own hours or services, and to keep wealth in the locality where it is created.Similar trading systems around the world are also known as Community Exchange Systems, Mutual Credit trading systems, Clearing Circles, Trade Exchanges or Time Banks. These all use 'metric currencies' – currencies that measure, as opposed to the fiat currencies used in conventional value exchange. These are all a type of alternative or complementary currency.In the 21st century, the internet-based networks haves been used to link individual LETS systems, into national or global networks.
[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28
11
u/awless Jul 14 '19
Doesnt sound like SN thought much work would be needed to scale the project.
11
u/moleccc Jul 14 '19
no, he thought there would be enough incentive to put in the work and make it possible. I think that's correct.
7
Jul 14 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
9
u/TiagoTiagoT Jul 14 '19
He underestimated the power of misinformation.
3
u/moleccc Jul 15 '19
It's not over yet, so too early to call. However currently it looks like the type of adversarial attacks being committed are hard for Bitcoin to defend against. The enemy is smart, motivated and resourceful.
1
u/bitmeister Jul 15 '19
Clearly he wasn't a control freak and didn't fear participation from big scale networks ("big iron"). He expected it. Although I feel he was somewhat naive to expect hardware to pick up the slack and Moore's law to carry growth. Still it's a far cry from the current BTC artificial 1MB on-chain limit or the 4:1 SW trx fee subsidy (or call it a 75% on-chain fee penalty, etc).
10
u/SatoshMe Jul 15 '19
Imagine satoshi in 2009, when people ask him what can i do with this new revolutionary digital currency called bitcoin...and he says "nothing. Its useless. You just tell everyone its a store of value and hold it so when other sheep like u buy in, you sell for more cash."
6
12
u/supremeMilo Jul 14 '19
By node here he means mining node correct?
17
7
2
u/ShadowOrson Jul 14 '19
Yes. There are, of course, easily thought of reasons why this is the case. Though, there are idiots and disingenuous individuals that try to, and unfortunately succeed at times, in confusing other individuals, of lesser intelligence, that Satoshi meant otherwise.
17
Jul 14 '19 edited Jul 14 '19
Has anyone ever compared all the writings of satoshi to Hal Finney? Hal Finney is the computer scientist that received the first Bitcoin. Some say he is the real satoshi. He passed aug 28th, 2014. (From Lou Gehrig's disease) He's my leading canidate for being the real satoshi.
Edit: Answered my own question: https://towardsdatascience.com/stylometric-analysis-satoshi-nakamoto-294926cdf995
7
u/harbinger-alpha Jul 14 '19
I feel bad that Hal didn't get to see the gains (price and awareness) that has transpired. If not Satoshi he was there helping at the beginning. And here I am.trying to flip shitcoins for.aome small gainz. Puts things in perspective.
11
u/itshappening99 Jul 14 '19
He lived in the same city as a guy named Satoshi Nakamoto. The odds that that is a coincidence are very low. I don't know if Finney was THE Satoshi but there's a good chance that if it was multiple people, he was one of them.
5
Jul 14 '19
The study I posted above in my edit states something about Satoshi communicating with Hal over email. And because of this, Hal shouldn't be considered the Only Satoshi. (But he could still be one of many if it was a group effort.)
6
u/itshappening99 Jul 14 '19
Yeah it does seem strange that he would go to the lengths of writing a bunch of emails to himself back and forth. On the other hand, if Finney wasn't Satoshi, the only explanation for the name choice (other than an incredible coincidence) is that someone deliberately picked that name to make it look like it was Finney. Ether way there was some elaborate misdirection going on.
5
u/TiagoTiagoT Jul 14 '19
Isn't talking to yourself while presenting it as a dialog between two people, actually a teaching technique that was already being used back in the ancient Greece times?
2
u/jessquit Jul 15 '19
Yeah it does seem strange that he would go to the lengths of writing a bunch of emails to himself back and forth.
not really, if you're trying to ensure plausible deniability
0
u/pokemin49 Jul 14 '19
If you mean strange as in it makes it extremely unlikely that Hal is Satoshi, than yes, it is strange.
0
u/jessquit Jul 15 '19
because of this, Hal shouldn't be considered the Only Satoshi
Why? Hal couldn't have had a Satoshi email account?
Whoever created the Satoshi identity obviously went to great lengths to obscure his identity. Why not create strong plausible deniability by having fake conversations with yourself?
by the way I don't think Hal is Satoshi. They had disagreements, and I think Occam's Razor suggests that the most likely explanation for their disagreements is because they were two different people with very different opinions about many things.
2
u/jessquit Jul 15 '19
the more interesting question is: if Hal was Satoshi, then what when Hal disagreed with Satoshi, which was his real opinion?
3
u/pokemin49 Jul 14 '19
Lol. Yeah what are the chances of someone living in the same city as a Japanese person with a very common name?
4
u/itshappening99 Jul 15 '19
That isn't a very common name, and they lived a few blocks from each other.
1
1
1
u/FreeMyMen Jul 14 '19
So why can't the guy with the actual name who lived in the same city be found?
1
u/Churn Jul 15 '19
He has. That’s the guy whose face we see used to represent satoshi all the time.
1
u/FreeMyMen Jul 15 '19
Oh wow. Is he gone?
1
u/Churn Jul 15 '19
Nah, he just doesn’t have anything to do with bitcoin.
1
u/FreeMyMen Jul 17 '19
Did you read my theory? 😶 I really like your username, so simple yet so many interpretations. Also interesting that you got that word, no one else had taken it.
1
1
u/FreeMyMen Jul 15 '19 edited Jul 15 '19
The creators named him the owner because they admired him as he was a mentor to one of the group who didn't have a good home life growing up and Mr. Nakamoto acted as a father figure when things were bad at home, even mentoring him by showing him computers and some engineering, he promised to never tell who his friend was that helped make it so he just acts like he has no idea what it even is like this.
1
u/iguanarchist Jul 14 '19
A lot of people have speculated that, and most of those have dismissed it.
-3
u/pokemin49 Jul 14 '19
No. We know Satoshi is Japanese because he said so, and he wasn't a liar. Hal isn't Japanese. The end. Is this stuff really that hard?
11
7
u/Richy_T Jul 14 '19
Those who want to be able to keep running Bitcoin on a Raspberry Pi should know that Raspberry Pis were launched in February 2012 while Bitcoin's genesis block was mined January 2009.
6
2
u/Votefractal Redditor for less than 30 days Jul 15 '19
By Moore’s Law, we can expect hardware speed to be 10 times faster in 5 years and 100 times faster in 10
So here we are 10 years later, consumer laptop I have changed from old 2 core to less old 2 core with 8 GB ram instead 2 afair and bigger disk and moved to ssd.
My desktop PC changes from 2009 some athlon 2 core to 8core with 16 GB ram.
So it did not grew x100 in 10 years, Satoshi was simply not correct.
It did not grew x10 even.
Not even to mention goal of switching to open hardware instead the gov backdoors filled Intel's and amds , open risk, which tend to be far slower.
The progress will happen o e day maybe in 10 yes but from now, when we are there and initial full verification of blockchain takes less than few hours then in Bitcoin we will probably increase once more blocksize to use this method of scaling to expedite onboarding.
4
u/tikitembo7 Jul 14 '19
Important information in this mail.
Satoshi is an European guy (from an European state). No one else on earth will calculate the value of a bitcoin in Euro if not based in Europe!!!
6
u/antonivs Jul 14 '19 edited Jul 14 '19
That's an easy deliberate misdirection, though. If he wanted to remain anonymous, it would make sense to throw some misdirection like that into his writing. Much easier than consistently maintaining a different writing style.
5
Jul 14 '19
Yup. This, deliberate double spaces after sentences, Japanese pseudonym, posting mostly when Americans aren't sleeping.
TBH the real answer could be in his initial code, since it for some reason contained things related to gambling.
2
u/nolo_me Jul 15 '19
Double spacing isn't a geographic habit, but it suggests he learned to type on a typewriter.
2
u/sebrings2k Jul 15 '19
Typing class was my favorite class in high school. I always double space. I need to buy a typewriter.
2
u/NilacTheGrim Jul 15 '19
I double-space because that's what they taught us in school to do in typing class (yes, we had typing classes in elementary school -- NYC public ed!).
I still find it super hard to kick the double-space after periods habit.
3
u/TiagoTiagoT Jul 14 '19
Didn't the quote in the Genesis block come from an British newspaper/magazine?
2
u/jeffroddit Jul 14 '19
Euros also extend around the planet to the overseas countries and territories, right? Why not Bermuda? The Caymans? Could explain the Euro, and Brittish press connections. Or how about New Caledonia, it's a bit closer to Japan... Heck, I bet he's from Pitcairn Island!
2
u/cryptostory Jul 14 '19
I had the same thought. Even if he was say an American travelling or living in Europe at the time, he would likely still reference his home currency the $ in such a discussion, which also happened to be the main global currency.
1
u/NilacTheGrim Jul 15 '19
I'm an American living in Europe. I could easier switch between EUR and USD when discussing prices. It depends on who I'm talking to. I'm not 100% convinced by that argument .. and Satoshi had incentives to say EUR even if he was American (misdirection)...
2
1
5
Jul 14 '19 edited Jul 14 '19
The existing Visa credit card network processes about 15 million Internet purchases per day worldwide. Bitcoin can already scale much larger than that with existing hardware for a fraction of the cost. It never really hits a scale ceiling. If you're interested, I can go over the ways it would cope with extreme size. By Moore's Law, we can expect hardware speed to be 10 times faster in 5 years and 100 times faster in 10. Even if Bitcoin grows at crazy adoption rates, I think computer speeds will stay ahead of the number of transactions.
Assumption #1 from 2009 : By Moore's Law, we can expect hardware speed to be 10 times faster in 5 years and 100 times faster in 10.
If this assumption is on track, then, by now, hardware speed should be 100 times faster than in 2019. Is Satoshi correct on this one?
I don't anticipate that fees will be needed anytime soon, but if it becomes too burdensome to run a node, it is possible to run a node that only processes transactions that include a transaction fee. The owner of the node would decide the minimum fee they'll accept. Right now, such a node would get nothing, because nobody includes a fee, but if enough nodes did that, then users would get faster acceptance if they include a fee, or slower if they don't. The fee the market would settle on should be minimal. If a node requires a higher fee, that node would be passing up all transactions with lower fees. It could do more volume and probably make more money by processing as many paying transactions as it can. The transition is not controlled by some human in charge of the system though, just individuals reacting on their own to market forces
Assumption #2 from 2009: 1 MINER = 1 NODE (all miners run full nodes and all full nodes are mining)
Is Satoshi correct on this one?
Eventually, most nodes may be run by specialists with multiple GPU cards. For now, it's nice that anyone with a PC can play without worrying about what video card they have, and hopefully it'll stay that way for a while. More computers are shipping with fairly decent GPUs these days, so maybe later we'll transition to that.
Assumption #3 from 2009: Best mining technology will be GPU's.Is Satoshi correct on this one?
If all 3 assumptions made in 2009 by Satoshi are correct, then Bitcoin may scale like VISA. Otherwise, Satoshi is wrong and it may not scale the way it was originally intended to.
Let's elaborate on the scenarios:
#1 correct, #2 correct, #3 correct: Bitcoin scales like VISA, yay!!
#1 correct, #2 correct, #3 incorrect: Bitcoin scales like VISA, but only miners with ASIC's have nodes => few nodes = centralization = bad
#1 correct, #2 incorrect, #3 correct: Bitcoin scales like VISA, but nodes are run only by volunteers, miners don't exactly need them => few nodes = centralization = bad
#1 correct, #2 incorrect, #3 incorrect: Bitcoin scales like VISA, but a few mining pools and ASIC farms remain, nodes are ran mainly by volunteers => few nodes = centralization = bad
#1 incorrect, #2 correct, #3 correct: The miners with the fastest CPU's and bandwith get an increasing advantage as Bitcoin scales, eventually few nodes = centralization = bad
#1 incorrect, #2 correct, #3 incorrect: The miners with the best ASIC's and bandwith get an increasing advantage as Bitcoin scales, eventually few nodes = centralization = bad
#1 incorrect, #2 incorrect, #3 correct: As Bitcoin scales, nodes ran by volunteers disappear, only a few nodes ran by some of the miners remain = centralization = bad
#1 incorrect, #2 incorrect, #3 incorrect: As Bitcoin scales, nodes ran by volunteers disappear, only a few nodes ran by some big ASIC farms or mining pools remain = centralization = bad
So, if Satoshi is wrong on one of the 3 assumptions, then we have to trade "scaling" with "centralization". VISA is already scaled and centralized. So, if we scale Bitcoin like this when in fact all these assumptions are incorrect, then Bitcoin will become an inefficient competitor to VISA and centralized which is what BCH is planning on doing.
7
u/homopit Jul 14 '19
Even if Bitcoin grows at crazy adoption rates, I think computer speeds will stay ahead of the number of transactions.
Correct.
Your other points you put forward are pure BS.
2
u/ATHSE Jul 14 '19
All markets tend towards monopoly, it's their nature, and unlike the corporate world, there are no anti-trust crypto-mining commissions breaking them up in the future.
Large dominant pools are inevitable, the only thing that can suppress their dominance of BTC is other profitable coins to mine with the same hardware, using their self-interest to encourage diversifying. Still no guarantee though...
2
u/ErdoganTalk Jul 15 '19
Not true. A monopoly or cartel can reduce output, but then entuse cheaters inside the cartel or raise profits for outsiders. Real monopolies can only exist if they are supported by the coercion of the state.
1
u/ATHSE Jul 15 '19
Do you not understand that plutarchy and oligarchy are not supported by the coercion of the state, and instead exist as a rival to the state?
1
u/ErdoganTalk Jul 15 '19
No, don't agree. In the market, monopolies seldom appear, and they are always bombarded from the contenders, and they can only continue to exist if they are better at doing what they do.
This is relevant for bitcoin mining btw, it is a competitive market
0
Jul 14 '19
[deleted]
2
u/ATHSE Jul 14 '19
Actually they do, and that did too, what you're seeing in financial diversity is precisely what I described about mining multiple coins, they invented new financial instruments to create more markets to play with, allowing more players to specialize.
0
2
u/Halperwire Jul 15 '19
Well said. I would also like to add by asking a question. How do you get around free or almost free transactions being spammed on the network killing up even the biggest blocks? I think this was one of cores major points. If you don't have a fee market it won't work essentially. The block chain becomes less efficient overall, too centralized, or you create a fee market...
2
u/SatoshisVisionTM Jul 15 '19
This is a good point. Note that new, innovative ways of transacting might increase the volume of transactions by several orders of magnitude. Microtransactions and pay-per-use might start to make sense if 'block space is free' and could drive as a centralizing force in the ability to run a full node. This would then make the network useless.
1
u/GameofCHAT Jul 14 '19
A key aspect of Bitcoin is that the security of the network grows as the size of the network and the amount of value that needs to be protected grows.
1
u/TheSwoogs Redditor for less than 2 weeks Jul 14 '19
Satoshi had a vision, and again, greed has been our worst enemy.
1
u/EsquireRichmond Redditor for less than 60 days Jul 15 '19
Just a question, what happens when the I.R.S wants their cut?
1
u/haktirfaktir Jul 15 '19
What's that about ripple? They weren't around back then we're they?
2
u/snugghash Jul 15 '19
Ripple org was different, XRP is a later and different thing that satoshi is not referring to
1
Jul 15 '19
Bitcoin has come so far from this that almost none of it rings true anymore. I don't think Satoshi anticipated the level of resistance to ANY change that we're now witnessing with bitcoin. Subsequently, bitcoin can't handle even nearly that volume of traffic, fees rule the network, and everyone has been priced out of mining. GPU mining is a distant memory.
If Satoshi hadn't disappeared, maybe we'd have the kind of authoritative steering to greatness. Instead we've got countless shitcoins that have forked off and an impersonator trying to turn bitcoin into a mess.
1
1
1
1
u/legallydaria Jul 20 '19
KNL tokenization platform is the digitization of grain assets, real estate, and property. The top - priority task is the solution of one of the most severe market issues, which is the access of producers to financing, which will allow to modernize industry, implement innovations and keep crop yields safe.
1
u/asdvxgxasjab Redditor for less than 30 days Jul 14 '19
I think the issue is disagreement over what it means to be "decentralized." Does it mean it should only cost $100 to run a node? $500? $5000? At what resource expenditure is "decentralization" materially impacted? I'm not sure there is a good answer to that, at least none that I've heard are particularly compelling. It seems as though Satoshi's goal was just that it be "decentralized enough" such that a small handful of entities didn't control it. Others seem to view that as insufficient. I guess I somewhat align with Satoshi's view but I can understand and appreciate the counter-arguments to an extent.
2
u/Tiblanc- Jul 14 '19
He speaks of mining nodes. Back then every node was mining without a pool. It's only with the advent of pools and asics that non-mining nodes became a thing, but they are nearly worthless for the network so it's pure selflessness to run one.
-1
u/asdvxgxasjab Redditor for less than 30 days Jul 15 '19
They're worthless for the network but they're the only way to truly trustlessly work with bitcoin. If you're not using a full node that you manage you're trusting someone else's node. It's a level of trust most people are fine with though.
4
u/Tiblanc- Jul 15 '19
It's the same level of trust. If your non-mining node detects a bad chain state, what is it going to do? Stop propagating the new blocks? Then what? You'll be cut off from the network if a majority of miners forked off without you. Who are you going to trust from now on?
Truth is you have as much voting power than someone who doesn't run a full node. You'll have to bend over to miners' will or be kicked out of the network.
0
u/SatoshisVisionTM Jul 15 '19
It's the same level of trust. If your non-mining node detects a bad chain state, what is it going to do? Stop propagating the new blocks?
My full node doesn't propagate blocks that fail its consensus rules every day. It doesn't propagate those blocks, as it doesn't propagate invalid transactions. Since mostly everyone else is also doing this, the bitcoin network remains valid.
If I must trust another node, I must trust them to follow consensus rules. If they don't, they can lie to me about my balance, about my transactions, and about transactions in the rest of the world.
You'll be cut off from the network if a majority of miners forked off without you. Who are you going to trust from now on?
The minority of miners that is still following the consensus rules my full node also accepts. Let's rewind the clock to 2017. SegWit is still getting blocked by BitMain. A full node implementation goes online that will activate SegWit after the last activation window has passed, regardless of miner signalling. That implementation gets downloaded by an increasing amount of economic users. This poses a problem for the miners that want to block SegWit; if they don't, they will be mining a chain only they are using. If the supermajority of economic activity gradually moves to the SegWit-activated chain (which at that time was certainly not unthinkable) then they will be mining a dead chain. They losses would be catastrophic.
We all know what happened. BitMain is financially in bad weather, has a massively illiquid stack of BCH lying around that nobody wants to buy, and has suffered major reputational damage.
Truth is you have as much voting power than someone who doesn't run a full node. You'll have to bend over to miners' will or be kicked out of the network.
UASF proves that this is incorrect. An economic majority of non-mining full nodes have the power to deny changes to the network that miners propose.
1
u/Tiblanc- Jul 15 '19
Your full node succeeds in preventing a propagation attack if every other full node also prevents it. If malicious miners with more than 50% hashrate can find a way to propagate blocks with each other, they overtake the network regardless of the number of honest full nodes. If they both know each other, they'll do a direct connection and bypass all the securing full nodes.
About trusting other nodes for your balance and transactions, it's the same principle. You only need to find 1 mining node that won't blacklist you to successfully use the network. You would need 51% of hashrate that blocks your transactions for you to get kicked out of the network. The same principle apply if you have a full non-mining node. You gain nothing by owning a full node here.
USAF didn't change anything. Miners want one thing and it's money. Whoever buys their coins for the most money will be their customer. People buy the coin that suits their view. In the case of USAF, there was 3 group of users. Those for SegWit, those against and those who didn't care. Since social media attacks succeeded in keeping the BTC brand, those who didn't care got bundled with those who were for it. If SegWit forked instead, those who didn't care would still be on BTC, but it would be with BCH's protocol. Turns out there's a high number of users who didn't care so they still buy the brand instead of the protocol.
1
u/SatoshisVisionTM Jul 16 '19
Your full node succeeds in preventing a propagation attack if every other full node also prevents it.
Technically, this is incorrect, since a single node propagating invalid transactions won't successfully attack. You'd need a very significant amount of nodes to achieve this, and you'd need to convince a majority of miners to accept the invalid transaction, or it won't be mined on top of.
If malicious miners with more than 50% hashrate can find a way to propagate blocks with each other, they overtake the network regardless of the number of honest full nodes.
Correct. And the rest of the network will reject their fork which doesn't follow consensus rules. This is bitcoin as designed, and still doesn't show a successful attack vector. It only shows how a majority of miners can decide to fork off.
You only need to find 1 mining node that won't blacklist you to successfully use the network.
That miner would also have to include your transaction in a block and actually find that block.
You would need 51% of hashrate that blocks your transactions for you to get kicked out of the network.
If 51% of the miners gang up and decide to censor blocks containing a transaction spending a specific UTXO address (like EOS does), then any attempt by the remaining 49% of the miners mining on top of such a block would eventually get reorged out. This is correct, and clearly stated in the whitepaper. I never claimed otherwise. I'm talking about blocks being invalid, not about blocks being censored.
USAF didn't change anything. [...] If SegWit forked instead, those who didn't care would still be on BTC, but it would be with BCH's protocol.
First off, the United States Air Force has nothing to do with this. ;)
Secondly, and more importantly: Bitcoin did fork for SegWit, as a softfork. Just like it did in 2010 with the institution of the 1Mb block size limit to prevent poison block attacks by Satoshi. Just like BIP65, which added an OP_CODE. All of these changes were made in the same way. SegWit is no different, yet you act like some hijinks were use to force through SegWit.
BCH forked off because it changed consensus rules (and was unwilling to change consensus rules as proposed by SegWit) without the economic majority backing it. Companies, users, whales and exchanges all thought that the change was not in the best interest of the network. That is why it isn't Bitcoin. It has nothing to do with the amount of people that were uncaring of the changes of SegWit.
1
u/Tiblanc- Jul 16 '19
That's all perfectly fine. My point is that it all boils down to miners. Your node has no impact in any of these attack vectors since the success is entirely dependent on having 51% hashrate.
1
u/SatoshisVisionTM Jul 16 '19
And again; a 51% attack is perfectly described and I have not mentioned those attacks. It is an unhealthy state of the network and there is little anyone can do against this on their own. Reducing the number of full nodes won't affect this either. Allowing people to run a full node and knowing that it is in everyone's best interest to adhere to the consensus rules makes perfect sense and allows for further prevention of attacks.
Also; even if there is a 51% mining cartel that is censoring some part (however small) of the network, that still allows you to write a client implementation that proposes to softfork away from that cartel. If so, and you gain enough of a following, you can fork away from the cartel of miners. If you get enough economic users to go along with you, there's always going to be miners willing and able to mine your chain.
1
u/Tiblanc- Jul 16 '19
Alright, but that doesn't explain which attacks running a full non-mining node prevents. All I'm reading is giving the impression there's a collective agreement on a ruleset, but it's easily bypassed. If no attack is prevented, then there's no security gained from running a full non-mining node and it shouldn't be a factor when defining the protocol.
→ More replies (0)-1
u/asdvxgxasjab Redditor for less than 30 days Jul 15 '19
Someone else's node can lie to your wallet about its balance and withhold or show it transactions that don't actually exist in the chain.
1
u/Greamee Jul 15 '19
You should read section 8 of the whitepaper.
It explains how light wallets (aka SPV) can receive a specific cryptographic proof that prevents exactly what you're saying.
1
u/asdvxgxasjab Redditor for less than 30 days Jul 15 '19
Merkle proofs don't prove your balance.
1
u/Greamee Jul 19 '19
They do prove your minimal balance.
1
u/asdvxgxasjab Redditor for less than 30 days Jul 19 '19
They prove a given transaction exists in a chain. If you aren't shown a transaction then you don't know to perform the proof nor how it affects your balance. Again, I'm personally of the opinion this detail doesn't matter much in practice. Most people don't use SPV wallets. They trust their wallet provider. They can also cross-check using other websites. I wrote my own decentralized ledger and instead of a Merkle tree use a simple hash list. Most people are really never going to care about SPV proofs. The last decade has shown that.
1
1
u/GreyJediGuy Jul 15 '19
Linguistics appear similar to Elon, to me.
I'm probably wrong. Just saying, the technical explanation, details, and no BS, yet humble and politeness (when trying to be).
I've seen several interviews of Elon speaking like this. And, he doesn't need the coins.
And, he knows Code.
And, he probably was under some sort of NDA/ not compete after PayPal sale that prevented him from doing this work. But it's Elon, and he'll do whatever he wants.
But, I'm probably wrong
0
u/0xHUEHUE Jul 14 '19
How do we know that this email is genuine? Do we have to trust Mike? Because I don't find him very trustworthy, so it'd be cool if there was a way to verify authenticity.
-1
u/BitAlt Jul 15 '19
There is only one global chain.
Got it. Thanks for clearing that up.
The fee the market
I thought there wasn't meant to be a fee market according to dogma here.
-13
-1
u/Bitsurfer777 Redditor for less than 60 days Jul 15 '19
This has been CSWs consistent message since 2014.
0
53
u/lettucebee Jul 14 '19
The foresight displayed by satoshi here is impressive, and he seems so humble.