r/btc • u/JonyRotten • Jun 29 '19
Ross Ulbricht Letter Questions the Wisdom of Imprisoning Non-Violent Offenders
https://news.bitcoin.com/ross-ulbricht-letter-questions-the-wisdom-of-imprisoning-non-violent-offenders/11
u/jonald_fyookball Electron Cash Wallet Developer Jun 30 '19
where can we write to Ross?
10
u/_-________________-_ Jun 30 '19
Ross Ulbricht #18870-111 USP TUCSON P.O. Box 24550 Tucson, AZ 857343
18
u/nootropicat Jun 29 '19
Non-violent offenders are likely to be more docile.
Running a profitable forced labor enterprise would be much harder if most prisoners were impulsive thugs that don't react rationally to incentives.
3
2
u/FirebaseZ Jun 30 '19
This non-violent victim paid to have five people murdered. During his sentencing the judge said, "She addressed the murders, noting that, sure, no bodies had been found, but that in her mind that did not matter. “Did you commission a murder? Five? Yes,” she scolded. “Did you pay for it? Yes. Did you get photographs relating to what you thought was the result of that murder? Yes.” - American Kingpin
1
Jun 30 '19
I’m not condoning any crime , but I don’t get how some criminals think they are better than others , violent offenders are in the same boat as drug offenders and are facing tougher penalties because some politician promised to get tough on their crimes because it got them votes , It’s well established that prison does not rehabilitate and is a mostly an in humane environment . The worst part for any inmate to be treated any less than another because of the crime that was committed.
2
Jun 30 '19
A rapist absolutely deserves worse treatment than a pothead. You would actually argue against that?
1
Jun 30 '19
Your projecting you own bias. It’s prison , same treatment different amounts of time based on societies perception of a problem or what the legal system has set as a debt to society to be re payed . Your forcing an argument on the basis that you’ve been sold that one crime is better or worse than another , I am not condoning either crime or wishing to Be involved in inmate politics.
2
Jun 30 '19
Interesting way to avoid answering the question
1
Jun 30 '19
What do you want me to say ? That I think everyone is a criminal in a criminal social system that rewards and or persecutes people based on manipulation of popular opinion by other criminals?
2
Jul 19 '19
I was honestly just hoping you would answer the question
1
Jul 19 '19
It’s hard to answer your question , especially knowing that smoking pot is punishable by death in some countries , but that is probably alternative bias to your belief ,
-6
u/Hoolander Jun 29 '19 edited Jun 30 '19
Ross Ulbricht personally profited from the anonymous sale of cyanide. He deserved 5 years for that alone. I reckon a fair(ish) sentence would have been 10 years before out on parole.There were certain items that he allowed to be sold on his marketplace (and I am not talking about narcotics - that's a separate issue) that were so dangerous that he easily deserves ten years. Life sentence is outrageous though.
14
u/_-________________-_ Jun 30 '19 edited Jun 30 '19
anonymous sale of cyanide. He deserved 5 years for that alone.
eh, you may as well prosecute Home Depot for selling a hammer later used to kill someone.
A Toyota dealership for selling a car used to run someone down.
A gun dealer for a selling a weapon used in a future murder.
I mean, yes, the guy could have thought ahead to ban such items on the platform to assuage the rampant paranoia of law enforcement, much like some later DNMs did with fentanyl and whatnot...
All that being said, the life sentence was supposed to represent a strong deterrent to future people thinking of running a DNM. Big surprise -- it failed miserably.
0
u/FirebaseZ Jun 30 '19
If Home Depott or Toyota sold cyanide, do you think they should be prosecuted?
1
u/_-________________-_ Jun 30 '19
No... I have no doubt Home Depot probably does sell various rat poisons, weed killers, pesticides, etc. which could all be used for nefarious purposes.
Just because 'cyanide' has an infamous reputation doesn't mean it doesn't have any legitimate purpose.
0
u/FirebaseZ Jun 30 '19
What if Home Depot sold a nuclear weapon?
This is an interesting discussion, and we probably agree more than we disagree. The question is, where do you draw the line? When does it make sense for a third party (the government) to step in and say, “Ok, nope.” When Person 1 sells Person 2 a chicken? Alcohol? Moonshine? Marijuana? Psilocybin? Heroine? Cyanide? A dirty bomb...?
At some point, the individual rights of Person 1 to transact with Person 2 can harm Person 3-n and it makes sense for a third party to protect Person 3 and those around them. Person 2’s sovereign right to buy a nuclear bomb can infringe on Person 3’s sovereign right not to get atomized.
-8
u/b1daly Jun 30 '19
The non-violent claim rings hollow when he directly profits from the violent activities of others.
If Ross were willing to come clean and admit remorse about his massive violation of the law and norms of his society his plea for mercy would have a better chance.
At core, he still seems to believe the law shouldn’t apply to himself.
Running a large drug distribution network is a crime of choice, not a crime of conscience.
11
Jun 30 '19
The Federal Reserve Note is 100% responsible for providing incentives to criminals to commit crimes...better ban that fiat note now!
-3
u/b1daly Jun 30 '19
Well, your logic would be sound if people were arguing that the existence of bitcoin caused Ulbricht to commit his crimes.
6
Jun 30 '19
The sentence is not proportionate. Bush,Cheney,Wolfowitz, Rumsfeld, walk free among us. They are responsible for more death and destruction on this planet then 20 Ross Ulbrichts. Let him go. He has served enough time and bring Edward Snowden home for that matter
1
u/b1daly Jul 01 '19
There’s no doubt the sentence is disproportionate. I’m just saying pleas for justice or mercy in a case like this would be easier to support if he was willing to own up to his own crimes, instead of doubling down on quasi-libertarian tropes.
1
-1
u/jbrev01 Jun 30 '19
That's exactly what I see - he won't come clean about his misdeeds and show remorse. He continues to push an obviously false story about being framed even though he was caught red handed and literally all evidence points contrary to his lie. If he were to come clean and repent his despicable choices, I would give him so much more support. The fact he won't come clean is just disgusting. Regardless, life without parole is insane no matter how you look at it all.
0
Jun 30 '19
[deleted]
-3
u/jbrev01 Jun 30 '19
But then he said he sold Silk Road until a month before the arrest. Despite the fact that Silk Road logs and messages match up and correspond directly with his personal activities found in his gmail account, facebook, travel itinerary, etc. during the time he says he didn't own the site. Blatant lies, which might possibly hold up if he wasn't caught with his laptop open and unencrypted, with a personal daily diary containing information on everything he's ever done in silk road and his personal life. Yet he still holds onto this bullshit story about how hackers planted everything on him... including 130,000 bitcoin that just happened to be in his personal wallet. Which he claimed were earned from legitimate bitcoin trading, until the prosecution brought in blockchain experts who pointed out that every bitcoin on his laptop came directly from silk road wallets... oops. He recanted on that argument real quick.
-7
u/greeneyedguru Jun 29 '19
I think Ross should get a new trial including the murder for hire charges. If he's found not guilty of those I'd be ok with a reduced sentence.
2
-46
u/z3rAHvzMxZ54fZmJmxaI Jun 29 '19
He deserves to rot in prison for what he did and he should be grateful that he didn't get the death penalty
28
u/Zyoman Jun 29 '19
What he did exactly that offend you soo much? building a website for free trade?
0
Jun 29 '19
[deleted]
16
u/sip404 Jun 29 '19
There were no hitmen on SR. You are retarded.
0
Jun 29 '19
[deleted]
4
u/claireapple Jun 30 '19
All drugs should be completely legal anyways so it's just arbitrary.
How is allowing someone else to use a drug in anyway violent?
4
u/sip404 Jun 30 '19
If I remember correctly there were no firearms either. So it was a market place for drugs which is a victim less crime, heaven forbid someone wanted to get high and not go to the ghetto to meet some asshole with a fucking gun.
-5
u/btceacc Jun 30 '19 edited Jun 30 '19
.. Or some psychotic who is given access to dose of ice and commits a violent crime...Or a person who dies of an overdose. Victimless, really.
3
1
2
u/Zyoman Jun 30 '19
Hitmen? give me a break, that was proven to a setup by the FBI guy and they were the one stealing money... Not sure who is the criminal here.
3
1
u/phro Jun 30 '19
If you don't like what he did why are you for crypto? There will be a lot more like him if we replace state control of money and commerce. He was definitely a net positive. None of the more heinous accusations were even charged let alone proven true in a court of law.
0
Jun 29 '19
[deleted]
25
7
u/crypt0crook Jun 29 '19
Why does the transaction id from the wired transcripts not exist on the blockchain? Interesting.
14
u/timepad Jun 29 '19 edited Jun 29 '19
There's just no space between the address and the txid in the transcript. The txid referenced is indeed on the blockchain.
But of course, this doesn't prove Ulbricht did anything. It's a fact that multiple people had access to the DPR account (likely including multiple corrupt state agents).
Ulbricht claims that although he started SR, he was no longer active as the maintainer of the site. He only came back to help because he was specifically asked to by the current maintainer. Shortly after being pulled back in, he was arrested.
Ulbricht was the fall guy.
4
0
Jun 29 '19
[deleted]
9
u/RockyMtnSprings Jun 29 '19
What? And lose all that propaganda credit? They would rather release the 9/11 reports about melting steel.
42
u/Mr-Zwets Jun 29 '19
FreeRoss