r/btc • • Jun 27 '19

Which one is false advertising and misleading people?! Bitcoin.com or Bitcoin.org

Post image
235 Upvotes

82 comments sorted by

24

u/500239 Jun 27 '19

where's /u/djpeen to explain away the false advertising on Bitcoin.org?

-18

u/djpeen Jun 27 '19

fast and low are relative terms so I guess it depends on what you are comparing it with

I agree low fees are a relic of the past (https://medium.com/@rusty_lightning/the-three-economic-eras-of-bitcoin-d43bf0cf058a), its not realistic to expect a decentralized highly redundant ledger to be cheaper then a centralized one, i would remove that point and instead focus on bitcoins censorship resistance

17

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Jun 27 '19

its not realistic to expect a decentralized highly redundant ledger to be cheaper then a centralized one,

Ah, yes, Ethereum, Monero, LTC, BCH, and NANO would like to point out that you are 100% full of shit.

43

u/DylanKid Jun 27 '19

Your mental gymnastics genuinely impress me

-8

u/djpeen Jun 27 '19

in which way am I inconsistent?

21

u/KillerHurdz Project Lead - Coin Dance Jun 27 '19

in which way am I inconsistent?

In exactly the same way that Bitcoin Core fees are inconsistent.

I agree low fees are a relic of the past

It's going to be bitter sweet watching the BTC project be superseded by the rest of the crypto economy but perhaps we could start advocating for even smaller blocks on BTC in order to speed up the process.

8

u/TNSepta Jun 27 '19

start advocating for even smaller blocks on BTC

You don't even need to do that, the BTC Core devs (most notably Luke dashjr) are already doing that.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

Bitter sweet indeed. It was my first love, but I found love again.

-13

u/djpeen Jun 27 '19

In exactly the same way that Bitcoin Core fees are inconsistent.

that is supply and demand, not mental gymnastics

15

u/KillerHurdz Project Lead - Coin Dance Jun 27 '19

that is supply and demand, not mental gymnastics

We don't seem to be talking about the same thing here but you might find reading this paper helpful to explain why the "supply" in "supply and demand" refers to market supply, not forced supply.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3fpuld/a_transaction_fee_market_exists_without_a_block/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zwQHovqJGDs

-9

u/FargoBTC Jun 27 '19

How’s your investment doing bud? Does it hurt?

4

u/DylanKid Jun 27 '19

oh my feelings, they hurt so bad.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

Its not realistic to expect a decentralized highly redundant ledger to be cheaper...

What you pay for on visa is not the real cost. It's much higher.

Even if your claim was true, Bitcoin might both have a higher cost to transact than Visa, and still be pennies.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

its not realistic to expect a decentralized highly redundant ledger to be cheaper then a centralized one,

Not true.

3

u/djpeen Jun 27 '19

well it seems obvious the the decentralized highly redundant ledger will need more computing resources

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

well it seems obvious the the decentralized highly redundant ledger will need more computing resources

Two factors lead to people running a node.

Incentives and cost.

Large block increase cost of running a node but also increase incentives too.

Large block crypto allow for more use case that requires nodes (token/Dapp/...)

That’s why ETH has nearly as much full nodes than BTC despite being massively more ressources incentives.

What are the incentives to run a nodes for Hodl? Set set up a paper wallet and you are good.

8

u/namborghini69 Jun 27 '19

So then the premises of Bitcoin does not scale. The base layer does not scale. Cool.

-5

u/djpeen Jun 27 '19

no, my premise is that bitcoin has tradeoffs: 1) increased decentralization and 2) less scalability

a decentralized network is not as scalable as a centralized one

it takes more resources to process a transaction redundantly multiple times as opposed to only once

6

u/SILENTSAM69 Jun 27 '19

There are a few types of important decentralisation though. I would agree that increasing scaling requires increasing the base required resources. That is one type of decentralisation though, and we can not maximize that at the cost of others forms of decentralisation.

Another important factor is not centralising the ability to use Bitcoin to only the few who can afford to use it. It is no use having the resources to run a node cheap enough for people who can not afford the fees to use the system. That would be a network run by the poor for the benefit and use of the rich. It wouldn't work.

Another important decentralisation is governance. Blockstream is the BTC governance, and they have an agenda to move traffic off to proprietary products instead of on chain. BCH at least has different competing dev teams.

1

u/djpeen Jun 27 '19

Another important factor is not centralising the ability to use Bitcoin to only the few who can afford to use it

I wouldnt really call this a form a decentralization, however I do agree that if decentralized processing of the ledger has too high a cost then it is a problem. Unfortunately we dont have a good model for the externalized costs of processing and storing transaction data.. on a blockchain where fees are very low these costs are going be externalized by validating nodes dealing with a heavy to process blockchain or by inflation, either that or the blockchain processing will become centralized

Another important decentralisation is governance. Blockstream is the BTC governance, and they have an agenda to move traffic off to proprietary products instead of on chain. BCH at least has different competing dev teams.

Yes this is important. I would argue that BTC governance is the most robust out of all the cryptocurrencies.. it is the only crypto network where the developers are unable to unilaterally change the consensus rules.

In all the other cryptos I have worked with the developers have free reign to change the consensus rules

4

u/SILENTSAM69 Jun 27 '19

Isn't there already a horrible imbalance in the BTC cost to run a node vs cost to use the network? It seems the resources required to run a BTC node is far less than the resources to watch Netflix. It is this balance that I feel the BCH devs have a far better handle on. Running a BCH node is relatively cheap, and would remain cheap even if it was heavily used.

BCH has no centralisation pressure due to resource requirements. The idea that there is any centralisation of this form with BCH seems to be a myth.

BTC governance seems to come from a central authority. You may call it robust. I call it quite centralised.

How is it that you feel that BTC prevents consensus rule changes better than other blockchains? Miners still have to decide if they will use any new code. Any change would only happen if the miners updated to any new consensus rules. Also, if an update was created for BTC that the miners liked, they could decide to use it, couldn't they?

2

u/phro Jun 28 '19

It is completely reasonable. 4MB raw size would have completely alleviated a fee market. Instead we have 4MB weight with segwit and barely any increased throughput.

1

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Jun 28 '19

Instead we have 4MB weight with segwit and barely any increased throughput.

And a ton of added complexity.

3

u/SILENTSAM69 Jun 27 '19

Why do low fees have to be a thing of the past? Many low fees can easily provide more reward to a miner than fewer high fees.

If you are okay with removing benefits to concentrate on a shrinking list of benefits then there is a problem.

1

u/Ascendzor Jun 27 '19

This is an excellent answer. Their stake/bias in bch is why you taking on flak.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

[deleted]

-2

u/djpeen Jun 27 '19

of course it feels slimy to you.. you live in the land of nano ("Instant transactions, Zero fees, Infinitely scalable")

you probably dont want to come back to reality where there are trade offs

9

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

you probably dont want to come back to reality where there are trade offs

BTC have chosen another set of trade off.

It may or may not maximize decentralization and censorship resistance (rather ironic that it need censorship to promote the idea)

Time will tell, it might very well be counter productive.

Just like it is nearly impossible to be a small miner on BTC without collecting unspendable outputs. Giving competitive advantage to larger miner.

4

u/djpeen Jun 27 '19

exactly BTC has one set of trade-offs, BCH another

6

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Jun 27 '19 edited Jun 27 '19

BTC traded for nothing real.

A full node can be run for $3.50 per month. A single average transaction today is going to cost more than that.

No one runs full nodes for something they can't afford to use. Smaller blocks protect against absolutely nothing. You have destroyed the greatest invention of our lives for nothing more than a paranoid delusion that you can't even articulate.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

exactly BTC has one set of trade-offs, BCH another

The consequence of BTC tradeoff killed it off as a currency.

1

u/throwawayLouisa Jun 27 '19

What trade offs do you think Nano makes?

1

u/djpeen Jun 27 '19

I think they trade their buzzwords ("Instant transactions, Zero fees, Infinitely scalable") for lack of security and eventual centralization (if the currency lasts long enough to have high usage)

1

u/throwawayLouisa Jun 27 '19 edited Jun 27 '19

Ok.

If I might reposte:

for lack of security

I agree It's not bombproof right now. Because if any attacker ever had the unlikely success of gaining 51% voting control, they could vote in favour of a double spend, reversing previous spends.

But coming in the Nano roadmap is Dual Phase confirmation:

  • An initial voting round to gain consensus

  • A second permanent imprimatur.

This will make Nano transaction's immutable.
(More so even than Bitcoin's after six confirmations.)

eventual centralization

Oops. That's actually where Nano has a massive secret advantage over all over designs.
Everyone focuses on its "feeless" feature as if that's great for the end-user. It is - but that's not the most wonderful thing about fearlessness. No no no.

The real benefit is that no one gets paid.

That means no one is incentivised to collect more votes than the minimum required to get rebroadcasted - 0.1%.
In fact anyone actively soliciting for more than 0.1% is viewed with suspicion.

So Nano will not suffer "eventual centralization" - it will actually become increasingly decentralized.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

Known tactic of bad actors: accuse your enemy of what yourself are doing

5

u/CastrosBallsack Jun 28 '19

"Fast" and "Low" are relative. Bitcoin.com is misleading to crypto noobs because it's a Bitcoin Cash propaganda site.

BTW, I 100% agree that Bitcoin is slow and expensive to transfer compared to lots of other cryptos. I just don't think purposefully misinforming crypto noobs is ethical.

2

u/Phucknhell Jun 29 '19

I thank the lord baby jeebus every day that Bitcoin.com isn't owned by any on the Core camp

3

u/Izzyhudson43 Jun 27 '19

Bitcoin.org

3

u/BOMinvest Redditor for less than 90 days Jun 27 '19

Both are false advertising...why do we need to choose?

4

u/Soluchain Jun 27 '19

And BCH isn't these either when theres instant and feeless solutions. BCH is shooting itself in the foot by thinking it's better because it beats bitcoin with these facts

11

u/mallocdotc Jun 27 '19

It says "low" processing fees, not "no" processing fees. The claim isn't "lowest fees and fastest confirmed transactions."

Bitcoin Cash is indeed the things that Bitcoin used to be.

1

u/Soluchain Jun 28 '19

My point is that BCH community keeps going on about being better with regards to these traits. Yes it is, but it's not the best. So when you finally beat bitcoin and you're holding the torch victorious then other coins are simply going to turn around and say hang on, if that's whats taken you to the top, then we're actually better so why not make us the best? BCH should be focussing much more on its other good qualities rather than this daily regurgitation of fees and speed

3

u/WippleDippleDoo Jun 27 '19

Fuck the #CultOfCore

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

Bitcoin.org is a scam site. Bait and switch scamming. Really they should be responsible for the money they're causing people to lose.

2

u/fipoch Jun 27 '19

At least it doesn’t need to claim to be the real Bitcoin

10

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

It does. That's literally the only thing that keeps it afloat.

2

u/DeBeuker_ Jun 27 '19

I thought I was the only one thinking this in this sub

0

u/stos313 Jun 27 '19 edited Jun 27 '19

Bitcoin.com

edit: thank you for the gold kind stranger!

2

u/nolo_me Jun 28 '19

We know you gilded yourself like every other fucking troll.

0

u/stos313 Jun 28 '19

Yes! Of course! That must be it! Because your movement and cause is so universally loved that no one would EVER agree with me. You found me out. Brilliant deduction.

1

u/Phucknhell Jun 29 '19

Hey, at least you're honest about it. thankyou

1

u/ekcdd Jun 28 '19

Still faster and cheaper than transferring fiat around especially in large amounts.

1

u/vrddka Jun 28 '19

hmmm, you're right shady AF.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19 edited Jul 01 '20

everything on this site is getting deleted and censored lol

1

u/oh_the_C_is_silent Jun 28 '19

This BCASH vs Bitcoin thing is fuckin old ladies and gents. I think you’re yelling at a wall.

Different functions for each. You won’t ever be recognized as superior because nobody sees these two as the same... because they’re not.

You keep bringing up why BCASH is better than bitcoin instead of just listing the cool things BCASH is doing in the world.

It’s like you can’t enjoy the fruits of your labor unless you get to keep measuring your dick to your neighbors.

It’s quite exhausting and unbecoming.

1

u/ekcdd Jun 28 '19

I'm surprised that this hasn't been downvoted for calling bitcoin cash bcash.

0

u/oh_the_C_is_silent Jun 28 '19

Word.

“That’s not my name.”

“Uh huh.”

“Nuh UH!”

“BCASH”

“MOOOOOOOOM!”

1

u/pgrujoski Jun 27 '19

let me guess, the second one is false

1

u/zcube97 Jun 27 '19

Shillers day in, day out.

-3

u/Liiivet Jun 27 '19

Lefties always project.

1

u/phillipsjk Jun 28 '19

It is not a right vs left thing.

1

u/Liiivet Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 28 '19

I'm right, they left (and tried to take everybody with them) to LEGAL NAME/PAPER FICTION.

It is actually left vs right (brainsides) completely ignoring the pineal gland in charge of both.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

[deleted]

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

Sinister.

-3

u/VanquishAudio Jun 27 '19

Great point! Both

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

These guys HATE CRYPTO!

➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖

Centralised Media:

https://i.redd.ct/5n2epuyz6yc01.png

https://youtu.be/ZggCipbiHwE

➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖

Coordinated Cryptocurrency "FUD narrative"

https://imgur.com/a/LbxeCGS

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

[deleted]

11

u/NeVroe Jun 27 '19

I remember that, didn't know that they changed back to what they know to be incorrect.

11

u/otherwisemilk Jun 27 '19

They've reached the bottom of the barrel and started calling it a "store of value" now. What's next, "Free space heater for miners"?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (0)

2

u/JcsPocket Jun 27 '19

I love u boo

  • ur btc homie

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

These guys HATE CRYPTO!

➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖

Centralised Media:

https://i.redd.ct/5n2epuyz6yc01.png

https://youtu.be/ZggCipbiHwE

➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖

Coordinated Cryptocurrency "FUD narrative"

https://imgur.com/a/LbxeCGS

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

[deleted]

2

u/andromedavirus Jun 28 '19

misbehaving bot

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

[deleted]

6

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Jun 28 '19

The .com is owned by Roger Ver, aka /u/MemoryDealers.

The .org is owned by Theymos and Cobra, two anonymous guys who also censor and control /r/Bitcoin, the bitcoin.it wiki, and bitcointalk.org.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

[deleted]

1

u/phillipsjk Jun 28 '19

You either have an inconsistent persona, or are genuinely confused.

Read the stickied FAQ if you have not yet.

-7

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Hoolander Jun 27 '19

Looks like some inbreds have gotten lost from The_donald.