r/btc • Bitcoin Enthusiast • Jun 22 '19

Chrome 'Has Become Surveillance Software. It's Time to Switch' -> Brave to support BCH!

https://www.slashdot.org/story/357332
331 Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

50

u/obesepercent Jun 22 '19

Why anyone would use a browser made by the biggest surveillance and tracking company in the world is beyond me

14

u/Dark_Shroud Jun 22 '19

It's not as bad as it used to be but there were a lot of vocal Google fanboys back in the day. Those were the assholes walking about with Google Glasses or acting like Chrome books were the best thing ever.

Hey lets get the parents/grand parents a chrome book so we don't have to worry about them using the computer anymore. Who cares that we're handing all their information over to Google and the five eyes on a silver platter.

10

u/docelder Jun 22 '19

Good to know somebody out here even knows what five eyes is.

Don't be evil was abandoned long ago. If it ever was a thing with them.

8

u/onlysupremebeing Jun 22 '19

Unfortunately they also run the biggest cell phone platform on the planet. Can't wait until a fully functional Ubuntu platform comes out for daily use.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19

[deleted]

0

u/rexduke Jun 23 '19

they aren't perfect, but they are a lot better

3

u/Big_Bubbler Jun 23 '19

How bad it is may not be as obvious as it used to be? I'd guess it is much worse now.

1

u/TheCruzKing Jun 23 '19

One reason now would be for stadia if it takes off... otherwise nothing else

0

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '19

[deleted]

12

u/brianddk Jun 22 '19

Isn't Opera owned by PRC?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '19

Could very well be. I suggested Palemoon and Waterfox but IT was like “ball’s already rolling on this, we’ll check alternatives in the future”.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19

[deleted]

2

u/brianddk Jun 23 '19

I hope your being ironic

9

u/BlackDeath3 Jun 22 '19

...anyone caught using any browser but Opera is terminated...

Jesus. Do you work at NORAD or something?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '19

No, QA contractor, tho, so NDAs are treated almost ridiculously. You also get fired if you leave project content on a checked out device, even though all employees sign the same NDA.

I’ve just accepted it at this point until I find something better.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '19

What's wrong with Firefox? It was created precisely for this.

4

u/phillipsjk Jun 23 '19

They disabled audio playback on Linux not running ESound and BSD by dropping OSS support.

16

u/vswr Jun 22 '19

What’s interesting is that apps are tracking us without our knowledge. I’ll use iOS as an example. They’ll look at WiFi networks and Bluetooth to try and determine your location since using those does not trigger a permission warning (this is fixed in iOS 13 as the app will now request permission).

So with chrome, even if you did not give it location permission, it can still guess your location.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '19

I know about this Google stuff for rather some time. Check for yourself. In case you are running Google Chrome on a mac -idk where it is located in Windows. Look in your ~/Library/Google/GoogleSoftwareUpdate/TicketStore folder. There're two 'Keystone'-files. Under water these are doing 'something' every ff-ing day. God knows what or why. Doesn't matter if you haven't used Chrome for months.

For business reasons I had to install it once for setting up a Selenium WebDriver framework. I am not a big fan of Google at all. "Don't be evil" my ass. When I found out about this keystone process I tried to stop it by deleting the Chrome app after the job was done. It wasn't that simple. Keystone activity kept showing up in the logs for a few days(it runs once a day). It took me some days to kill it.

Some of us may not know. Google doesn't need your Gmail-, YT-login or whatever to track you. They collected so many data about your past internet behaviour and your specific computer settings they identify you by your profile.

Anyone concerned about his privacy should use Brave, esp. now they integrate BCH. Or Vivaldi(incl. extensions: duckduck privacy essentials, privacy badger and ghostery). YT adds? I don't know what that is. Yeah, I take the "disable your addblocker" messages or banners on a lot of sites for granted. Click OK and go on without seeing adds. Sometimes a site refuses to work. Bad luck then. I have been told Opera(offers a very basic poor man's VPN) is in Chinese hands. Doesn't feel comfortable either.

7

u/vswr Jun 22 '19

You're correct.

sudo launchctl list | grep oogle
-	0	com.google.keystone.daemon

Even though Chrome is not installed, the Google tracking software still exists in macOS and the library folder you mentioned has activity from earlier today.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '19

Thanks for your sharing your knowledge. Now I remember lauchctl ! To put it mildly: Searching out underwater related stuff isn't my specialty :)

-1

u/iamapapernapkinAMA Jun 22 '19

Not reading a terms of service doesn’t mean that it’s by default “without our knowledge”. That’s like saying “well I didn’t know I was supposed to charge my phone when the battery died because no one told me!”

13

u/vswr Jun 22 '19

Explicitly denying permission to obtain my location is a pretty clear message that I’m not willing to share it. Finding another way that doesn’t ask permission is sleazy, and telling me to read the ToS is even more silly. What 15 year old reads it? What 42 year old can comprehend that legalese?

I said no to location and the apps sneak behind my back and do it anyway.

I applaud Apple for shutting this bullshit down in iOS 13.

26

u/andromedavirus Jun 22 '19

If Brave adds BCH support I'll use it instead of firefox.

8

u/DubsNC Jun 22 '19

I like brave but it hasn’t become my primary browser yet. This may push me over. It’s great on the iPhone and W10, haven’t tried Mac yet. https://mobile.twitter.com/brendaneich/status/1142230515728056320

11

u/fapthepolice Jun 22 '19

It's been my go to on the mac for a while.

Ever since they fixed the UI from those awkward tabs that I would always accidentally drag for some reason, it's been the best browser to use.

P.S. But it doesn't block reddit ads and that's pissing me off.

7

u/addiscoin Jun 22 '19

But it doesn’t block reddit ads and that’s pissing me off

Brave doesn’t block first party ads for good reason: https://www.reddit.com/r/BATProject/comments/bz7hbf/comment/eqqm5d1

1

u/324JL Jun 23 '19

It’s great on the iPhone

There's a few things that are annoying, but it's my main browser on iPhone now.

I would like a "list view" of open tabs instead of "tiles" that seem to randomly change order.

Also, the "open in new tab" is annoying, because it opens in the background, then has a notification asking you if you want to switch to the tab. It should be two options, "open in new tab" or "open in new background tab."

Also, can't directly copy images, have to "open image in new tab", then switch to that tab, then can copy the image.

Other than that, it works great.

Also, if you're using iPhone you should at a minimum download the 1.1.1.1 app from cloudflare (simple/easy), or setup your own VPN that uses that DNS server (advanced/hard). Much faster than your carrier's DNS, that probably tracks you anyway.

6

u/brianddk Jun 22 '19 edited Jun 22 '19

If Brave adds BCH support

They already do. Content Creators earn tips from followers or visitors. Currently those tips are cleared through the Uphold exchange. Uphold will allow you to receive your revenue in BCH, USD, or most major currencies.

The in-browser wallet is Ethereum based. They are folding in MetaMask and will support all ERC20 tokens. Their native token (BAT) is ERC20.

Asking to scrap Ethereum support and move to integration of BCH as the native token is an exhaustive PR to make.

Your best bet would likely be Dissenter. They forked Brave, I believe, to add BCH support. I don't believe they have ever issued a PR based on their modifications upstream.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19

The in-browser wallet is Ethereum based.

Last I checked, there was no in-browser wallet in Brave in the sense that we understand. What it has is an account in a contract controlled by Uphold. But you can't call it a custodial wallet either because you do not have the authority to transact with the amount you deposit (or somehow receive).

I am telling this because if you send in all of your BAT thinking it is an Ethereum wallet (like I did), you will not be able to get it out. If this has changed, I'll be happy to be corrected.

They forked Brave, I believe, to add BCH support.

First time I've heard about Dissenter, thank you.

2

u/brianddk Jun 23 '19

I am telling this because if you send in all of your BAT thinking it is an Ethereum wallet (like I did), you will not be able to get it out. If this has changed, I'll be happy to be corrected.

To get all your BAT out:

  1. Create a youtube or twitter channel.

  2. KYC through uphold as a "Creator"

  3. Tie your youtube or twitter to your "Creator" account.

  4. Browse to your twitter account and tip your entire balance to yourself.

  5. Withdrawal all your balance from Uphold.

Twitter requires the Dev browser BTW.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19

Nice breakdown, thanks. Obviously I won't go through with that, but at least helps to demonstrate that it is not actually an in-browser wallet. :-)

1

u/brianddk Jun 23 '19

not actually an in-browser wallet

I still suspect it is in-browser. If it ever became known that they where holding custodial funds US regulators would shut them down within the week.

Easier just to put a global BIP39 passphrase on all the wallets. Customers get a seed that magically works to restore their wallet and Brave Inc can swear before the BitLicense cops that they have no idea what the private keys to the funds are. Actually no one has the keys. Only the seed + the hardcoded secret passphrase can unlock the funds.

You may be right, it might be custodial after all, but they are going to loose their ass if FinCERN ever finds out.

Just for grins someone should war-dial some obvious passphrases and a brave wallet to see if they ever hit a key. For all we know the passphrases may be "ChromeSux"

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19

Good points, though I remain skeptical about the potentiality of unobstructed access. I guess I'd better investigate how they structured the scheme before speculating more.

2

u/brianddk Jun 24 '19

Last I checked, there was no in-browser wallet in Brave

Leaked developer build of in-browser wallet

1

u/324JL Jun 23 '19

Asking to scrap Ethereum support and move to integration of BCH as the native token is an exhaustive PR to make.

Or they could put a BAT token on BCH, maybe take half the ERC20 BAT off the market, and make a site where you can trade them 1 to 1.

Wouldn't be too difficult, for the amount of extra flexibility.

3

u/zimmah Jun 23 '19

It seems BCH is making a really strong push and may even have a chance to beat Bitcoin if it keeps up like this, especially with Brave backing it.

I think the exchange bullex.eu favors BCH too. Which is also good for Bitcoin (the real Bitcoin).

22

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '19

Been using Brave for over a year and it's the best switch I have ever made :)

6

u/500239 Jun 22 '19

no ill will, but I find that Chrome/UBlock origin or Firefox/Ublock origin work much better than brave. ON mainstream sites and less mainstream ones.

for example try to play any tv show from this site using the Brave browser: goojara.ch

10

u/shitpersonality Jun 22 '19

Brave is great on iOS.

I prefer Firefox/uBlock Origin on PCs.

-7

u/500239 Jun 22 '19

that doesnt respond to my comment at all, such a non answer.

7

u/shitpersonality Jun 22 '19

no ill will, but I find that Chrome/UBlock origin or Firefox/Ublock origin work much better than brave.

Brave is great on iOS.

I prefer Firefox/uBlock Origin on PCs.

that doesnt respond to my comment at all, such a non answer.

??????

-2

u/500239 Jun 22 '19

no ill will, but I find that Chrome/UBlock origin or Firefox/Ublock origin work much better than brave. ON mainstream sites and less mainstream ones.

4

u/shitpersonality Jun 22 '19

You're not making any sense?

-3

u/500239 Jun 22 '19

for example try to play any tv show from this site using the Brave browser: goojara.ch

5

u/shitpersonality Jun 22 '19

How are you installing uBlock Origin in iOS?

4

u/Epick_362 Jun 22 '19

goojara.ch

Brave now uses Chromium at its core which means it behaves almost identically to Chrome except for the Brave Shield which is what is causing that site to not work. I have Brave+uBlock (you can install Chrome extensions to Brave now) and when I turn off Brave Shield on that site, the player starts to work.

1

u/500239 Jun 22 '19

Brave now uses Chromium at its core which means it behaves almost identically to Chrome except for the Brave Shield which is what is causing that site to not work.

The site works, it just doesnt block any popups or ads. While uBlock origin gets everything.

5

u/Epick_362 Jun 22 '19

No it does block popups and ads because you only turn off Brave Shield but keep uBlock Origin enabled. This only happens on some sites so its not too annoying.

2

u/isisishtar Jun 22 '19

It's true. I'm using Brave on iOS and enjoying how it can cheerfully steamroll most ads and popups (not all, though! Some can still play fully.)

But it doesn't work well with streaming sites, like tv and movies. Have to go back to Chrome or Safari for that.

6

u/MassSnapz Jun 22 '19

I just switch like 4 days ago and it was pretty smooth. Havnt run into any issues so far. Now I just need an alternative to every other Google service.

1

u/sneakysneakygirl New Redditor Jun 22 '19

1

u/MassSnapz Jun 23 '19

Haha thank you. Of course that's a site lol

4

u/Dunedune Jun 22 '19

Or, you know, just use Chromium, without the ads bullshit

3

u/Dark_Shroud Jun 22 '19

You can turn that off in Brave.

You can also use Vivaldi instead.

3

u/taipalag Jun 22 '19

If you care about website publishers earning a decent revenue for their efforts, use Firefox and don't block ads.

Brave is stealing web site publisher's revenue by blocking web sites' ads and insert themselves as a middleman.

I know this isn't a popular opinion here but if all users started to blocks ads, a lot of websites would close shop.

You'd have a lot less websites you could surf for free.

(I'm a website publisher).

1

u/ishimoto1939 Jun 23 '19 edited Jun 23 '19

Better yet use Adnauseam with Firefox (banned on Chrome): clicks on all ads without loading them to obfuscate Google's personalized data analytics.

2

u/taipalag Jun 23 '19

You realize that by doing this you could get the website publisher get banned and demonetized from the ad network because of fraudulent clicks.

Don't do this on small publisher's websites, please. Until you have built and tried to establish a website in the search engines, you have no idea on how difficult and how much work it is.

The problem with privacy doesn't come from small publishers but from the big tech companies such as Google, Facebook, etc.

0

u/ishimoto1939 Jun 23 '19

Realize that obfuscation works by large scale implemention where you can't pin point the perpetrator. Think cash shuffle. Read how Adnauseam works to get a better idea. PS: I am a webmaster.

1

u/taipalag Jun 23 '19

I can see how it protects you as a website visitor but if too much visitors visit your site with that extension installed, I can see your website being banned for unnatural traffic with a high number of fraudulent clicks.

Thank god my website is not in the tech niche :-)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19

[deleted]

3

u/taipalag Jun 23 '19

See what I wrote in previous comment.

Brave is stealing web site publisher's revenue by blocking web sites' ads and insert themselves as a middleman.

I'm a Mediavine publisher, a network of about 4000 high-quality blogs and websites. My site was manually vetted by advertisers and so I get access to exclusive advertisement campaigns.

My RPM (revenue per mille) is 5-10x higher than what I could earn with Adsense.

Do you really think that Brave can match that, where they effectively block ads that are specifically tailored to my site, with his generic ads that most likely will have a way lower earning rate than Adsense, because the pool of advertisers is much smaller than on Adsense?

What Bredan Eich is doing is highly unethical towards content creators. He's stealing their revenue, sorry.

If he cared about content creators, he would simply have implemented the tipping functionality/crypto wallet in his browser without blocking ads.

Furthermore, he would have allowed the cryptos in Brave's crypto wallet to freely flow in and out of the wallet and transactions to occur on chain. Currently, all BAT transactions occur in a centralized database run by Brave/BAT, because the network capacity of Ethereum is too small to support BAT with onchain transactions. Furthermore, to cash out BAT as a publisher, you need to do KYC/AML via Uphold.

It is a mystery for me why people in this sub support a browser with so many red flags as Brave/Bat.

Finally, the BAT ERC token doesn't bring anything new to the table from a functionality POV, except to fund Brendan/Brave, as the tipping functionality would have worked with any of the major cryptocurrencies.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '19

[deleted]

1

u/taipalag Jun 24 '19

The problem isn’t the small publisher, it’s the big tech companies.

If you don’t like the ads on a website, don’t use that website, otherwise you are a hypocrite.

2

u/itshappening99 Jun 22 '19

There's no mention of BCH or Bitcoin in this article.

1

u/Mooks79 Jun 22 '19

Yeah. And you can really see them screwing their own token like that.

1

u/Dark_Shroud Jun 22 '19

While I agree that they're screwing over their own token they really haven't built the support out enough for it. They just recently added feature like being able to tip users on some social media.

Gab forked brave and is adding normal BitCoin support. I would guess that's why Brave is supporting several cryptos besides standard BitCoin (BTC).

1

u/Mooks79 Jun 22 '19

I think there’s confusion here as to exactly what BCH support they’re offering compared to BAT.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '19

This site is great for learning about privacy-centered software: http://privacytools.io/

1

u/remotelyfun Jun 22 '19

BitTube has a new browser as well with Airtime built in. BitTubeapp.com

1

u/DennisNr47 Jun 23 '19

Mozilla is also ok!!

1

u/265 Jun 23 '19

Firefox is the best choice for privacy. I am not sure if brave 100% open-source. Even if it is, chromium isn't configurable as firefox. I don't understand why they didn't build upon firefox.

1

u/7623945223Aa Redditor for less than 30 days Jun 23 '19

Power move art of war

1

u/sqrt7744 Jun 23 '19

Is there an easy way to move my saved passwords from Chrome to Brave? That's the biggest obstacle to switching IMO.

1

u/amorcloteas Jun 23 '19

Don't forget to also switch search engine. I started using duckduckgo instead of google

1

u/Vainhafen Jun 23 '19

I’m a web developer and switched to Brave 2 months ago. The workflow is exactly the same since it’s built on the same chromium core but the whole experience is just better overall!

  • Better UX

  • Alot faster

  • built in tracking- and adblock

  • BAT rewards to support creators or yourself with donations

I recommend everyone who sees this to make the switch!

Never going back :)

1

u/TwistedTarzan Jun 22 '19

Brave is super cool

1

u/GeriGeriGeri Jun 22 '19
  1. first, i suggest you use linux. windows (/android) will send every password, bookmark, and keypress to microsoft (/google). forgot using windows ever again.

  2. second, use chromium. ensure it does not syncs your history/cookies/browser data - ensure you never log into gmail (only from private mode). chromium is the free source code of chrome, without most of the google specfic stuff.

  3. Install domain blocker extension, basically block every domain on every site if you dont know what they are. there are some websites with literally 100's of tracking services.

  4. use truecrypt https://truecrypt.ch to encrypt your data. use a password you never used elsewhere, at least 20 character long. create an encrypted partition, and copy all of your files to there. yes, your coins too. use --datadir=whatever where it is necessary. if somebody asks what your truecrypt password is, the proper answer is: WHAT IS A TRUHKRIPTH SIR?

2

u/jbrev01 Jun 23 '19

What linux distro do you use / recommend?

2

u/GeriGeriGeri Jun 23 '19

I recommend Debian Linux. As windowing system, i recommend LXDE. That offers you a scalable product that can be run from a pentium1 to a 128 core xeon server without any problems. Yes, it will be ugly, but fast, realible, stable... and even the torrent client will not show you horse porn ads unlike the windows versions.

I dont recommend other linux distributions, as they are usually just specialized versions of debian, wiith own (buggy) scripts and complex eyecandy.

Download debian 64 bit net install package https://www.debian.org/CD/netinst/ create a 16-32 gb partition for the OS itself (and 256 or 512 mbyte for the efi if you use it in that mode). install the most important software with the apt-get command, for example: apt-get install codeblocks

Please note that linux is not complitely secure either, for example it will create a thumbnail for every picture you view in the ~/.thumbnails directory, which you maybe want to delete once in every day.

-1

u/11lookas87 Jun 22 '19

No thanks Orbot working much beter than chrome = no privacy !!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '19

[deleted]

1

u/sanchaz Co-founder - Cryptartica.com Jun 23 '19

the article mentions chrome. not chromium. aka not the same bs.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19

[deleted]

2

u/sanchaz Co-founder - Cryptartica.com Jun 23 '19

other way around.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19

Which browser do you use?

3

u/ishimoto1939 Jun 23 '19

It's worrying how much you need to scroll down for this comment. With the latest FOMO, due diligence is going down the drain again. Sad.