r/btc • u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator • Jun 16 '19
I'd post this to /r/Bitcoin but they would just remove it right away (also I'm banned)
2
u/Aequitaaa Jun 17 '19
At least give credit to u/srgrafo ...
2
u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Jun 17 '19
His watermark is in the comic and other people have tagged him in this post. Not trying to steal his thunder.
4
u/Kashpantz Jun 17 '19
Why is this still a conversation? Can't we talk about other things apart from sledging other Blockchains?
1
u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Jun 17 '19
It's a joke, lighten up bro
1
u/Kashpantz Jun 17 '19
It's a joke, that's great then put it in the meme sub, we don't need these shit posts in this sub.
10
u/Anen-o-me Jun 16 '19
Something something security, bro.
Also gold something. Lightning something. Something, something.
25
u/fiah84 Jun 16 '19
if the original author were here, he'd post an edit with "JUST USE LITECOIN OK"
9
u/fiah84 Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
and after that he'd probably add a panel with trolls desperately spamming this comment section. I don't know how'd he do that but I bet he'd nail it, dude is pretty talented
edit: he'd even manage to make fun of how the trolls make every other sentence bold in feverish desperation to sound more important
5
-19
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
if the original author were here, he'd post an edit with "JUST USE LITECOIN OK"
Indeed, use Litecoin if you're a noob trying to use Bitcoin-Cash. Is that clear enough? Litecoin is a lot... more secure then Bitcoin-Cash is... that is a fact. BCH/Bitcoin-Cash is so insecure it's just going to entirely fail.
Nothing is more secure then Bitcoin ...
Instead proclaiming its not possible to use Bitcoin, then trying to use something called "Bitcoin-Cash" realize you should just use Litecoin since it's the original big block fork of Bitcoin. Blocksize*4, which means it has four times the block space of Bitcoin. There's no reason for Bitcoin-Cash. Litecoin has been the alternative since 2011. Litecoin does not have 51% attack and reorg risks like Bitcoin-Cash has.
BCH/Bitcoin-Cash adds unnecessary confusion though branding and when Bitcoin-Cash fails (and it will fail) it's going to make Bitcoin look bad to people that were confused about the differences between the two. There are massive security differences.
10
u/Cmoz Jun 16 '19
Litecoin is more secure than Bitcoin Cash, huh? Tell me...how much hashpower do you think it would take to successfully attack Bitcoin Cash?
10
-12
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
Bitcoin Cash has to compete with Bitcoin's miners. 2 percent of Bitcoin's miners can halt the Bitcoin Cash chain. Bitcoin Cash has a constant struggle to survive under threat of 51% attacks in the future and it will only get worse until it fails.
Apparently, just "randomly" on may 19th BTC.top had 54 percent of BCH's hash rate before receding when everyone made a big deal about it..the so called balanced ratio of miners on BCH has to be artificially maintained since any one of those pools could easily have over 50 percent if they wanted..., BCH's relative hash rate is so small that 2 percent of Bitcoin is over 51% of BCH. This is what makes attacking BCH easy. Today.... right now... Many different people can easily have majority on BCH if they wanted to attack it. Basically any small miner on bitcoin could do it.
Can 2 percent of Bitcoin's miners halt the Litecoin chain?.. no, no other chain poses a existential risk to Litecoin since they use their own miners and they're essentially all of the scrypt hash rate.
12
u/Cmoz Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
2 percent of Bitcoin's miners can halt the Bitcoin Cash chain....Basically any small miner on bitcoin could do it.
If thats the case, I wonder why no one's done it yet ;)? The reality is that your figures are leaving out a key mitigating detail: We've seen that many miners mining bitcoin, actually support bitcoin cash. For example, when Craig tried to gain majority hash, miners switched from BTC to BCH to defend it. Despite having over 2% of BTC's hash thanks to Calvin and NChain, which led him to believe he could 51% BCH to get his way....he failed.
The reality is that it would take at least 14 Eh/s to outhash BCH's supporting miners, which is about 10x what you'd think it would be if you were only looking at current BCH hash rate. For this reason, a literal billionaire tried to attack BCH and failed.
needing over 14 EH/s with SHA256 miners to attack BCH would be much more expensive than needing enough scrypt hash to attack LTC.
-11
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
Craig Wright actually had more then 51% for a while, he just didn't do anything with it because he's an idiot... Craig could have halted the chain but he didn't for some reason.
You should be thanking Craig for either showing grace or being an idiot.
The reality is that BCH is hoping that Bitmain or Jihan Wu will always be there to mine it at a loss. That's not nakamoto consensus at work, that's called "Proof Jihan Wu/ Bitmain is my daddy" That kind of protection will not last, it's not sustainable.
https://www.coinchoose.com/news/bitmain-wants-out-of-its-1m-bch/ Bitmain may not be doing well these days: https://twitter.com/btcking555/status/1123873599037767680 Whatcha gonna do for protection without Bitmain...?
10
u/Cmoz Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
Craig Wright actually had more then 51% for a while, he just didn't do anything with it because he's an idiot... Craig could have halted the chain but he didn't for some reason.
No, you're missing the point. He thought he had 51%...but bitcoin.com, btc.top, antpool, etc simply switched more miners over to BCH to counteract him. In reality it became clear he never had 51%, because the functional hashrate of BCH security includes those mining on BTC who are willing to switch over to defend it.
additional edit:
The reality is that BCH is hoping that Bitmain or Jihan Wu will always be there to mine it at a loss. That's not nakamoto consensus at work, that's called "Proof Jihan Wu/ Bitmain is my daddy" That kind of protection will not last, it's not sustainable.
It is actually nakamoto consensus at work, because as long as BTC is crippled, BCH provides their miners with additional value by providing a SHA256 chain that actually functions well as currency, and clearly has market value. It would be against the miner's rational self interest to attack a coin which provides additional value for their miners to harness.
1
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19
No, you're missing the point. He thought he had 51%
Wrong. He clearly had greater then 51% for long enough to orphan everyone else blocks but he didn't.... He built on top of blocks other miners gave him.
He actually had ample opportunity to orphan everyone's blocks. He just didn't do it for some reason.
7
u/Cmoz Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
He built on top of blocks other miners gave him.
Because he realized that miners were actively switching from BTC to BCH chain as he ramped up, which means his blocks would have quickly been orphaned if he tried to start his own chain. Craig didnt have 14 eh/s, yet the people supporting BCH did.
Theres also a possibility that he started to mine a secret chain, but that chain quickly fell behind and was never broadcast, since BTC miners switched over to BCH and supported the main chain. His attack failed because, like you, he didnt realize that BTC miners would switch to defend BCH ;).
2
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
He's an idiot.... I think he was trying to reorg the chain (mine a secret chain) instead of orphaning blocks, which would have worked instantly for him, but it would have also completely destroyed BCH, sending the BCH price to 0. Maybe he didn't want to do that? because he thought he would lead BCH from that point on?
If he just immediately started orphaning everyone else's blocks as soon has he had 51%, that would have been guaranteed to work if total destruction of BCH was an intent.
→ More replies (0)2
u/zimmah Jun 17 '19
You can't even really attack a blockchain by having >51% as the chain can in fact be rolled back if the rest of the nodes just decide to ignore the attacker.
In other words just fork the attacker.
4
u/zimmah Jun 17 '19
It's the Bitcoin core supporters that are confused about which Bitcoin is the real Bitcoin. The real Bitcoin is a peer to peer digital currency.
7
7
u/obesepercent Jun 16 '19
I had 3/4 top level comment authors tagged as "troll" before I came here. Looks like the comic hit just the right spot
2
u/fiah84 Jun 16 '19
They're so very triggered. So sad that they waste their lives away spamming this subreddit
2
2
u/hoomiin4 Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 17 '19
Nobody 'likes' paying high fees, but they're willing to for transactions that need such a high level of security. (Not every transaction needs to be recorded on an immutable ledger, and most consumers dont care about paying 1-2% more for items with card payments)
If BCH was just as secure as BTC, AND had lower fees, then you'd have a point.
BCH could definitely be as secure as BTC with a high volume of low fee tx, but that day hasn't come yet.
1
u/cryptohost Jun 17 '19
Once every 24 hours, transactions with 1 sat/byte get confirmed. How is 1 sat/byte a high fee?
1
-13
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
After the next halving bitcoin fees will account for at least 15 percent(based on the fees right now, can go up a lot) of the block reward(mining rewards). BCH's fees will still account for basically 0 percent of it's block reward(%0.08) even after the BCH halving. Assuming the current fee for the last 30 days, in 5 years the bitcoin fees will account for at least 30 percent of the block reward.. BCH, still %0. (Who cares right! fees bad!)
If Bitcoin's fee is around ~3 dollars, in 5 years, the bitcoin tx fees will account for more then 50 percent of the block reward(mining profits) with current variables. Which means you will have an increasing disparity between BCH - bitcoin hash rate which leads BCH failing at nakamoto consensus. If BCH is 0.5% percent of the bitcoin hash rate, Roger Ver blinking will create a gust of wind powerful enough to push BCH into it's grave. What changes BCH's relative hash rate is not BCH's own price, it's Bitcoin's variables that change BCH's hash rate. Making BCH easy to 51 percent attack.
Are you so convinced by Roger Ver's "intelligence"?? that you refuse to believe what I'm telling you is true even if you can easily verify what I'm saying.
What you have here is dumb people following an even dumber person. The only thing you can do in this situation is to stop mindlessly following along and try to understand why I'm telling you BCH will fail.
20
u/lubokkanev Jun 16 '19
You're missing a critical point. BCH can have much more transactions than BTC.
-13
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
You're missing a critical point: BCH doesn't have any transactions.(doesn't have any fee revenue) You going to convince everyone to use "cash shuffle" to pay for transactions they don't need to do at all, thats why every other post on r/btc is begging people to cash shuffle.
p.s. good post https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/bzvpr3/300_days_to_increase_transaction_demand_by_100x/
18
u/DylanKid Jun 16 '19
BCH doesn't have any transactions.
This makes you look stupid
-11
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19
Tell me what percentage of BCH's block reward is from fees?
I'm waiting...
9
u/funkalistic Jun 16 '19
In theory though, lets say bch achived mass adoption, if bch have, lets say 100mb blocks, that'd be 3k/block in fee reward with 1 cent fees (if the block is at the max capacity) 1gb blocks that equals 30k dollars per block in fees with 1 cent fee on each transactions.. In the case you have 3mil transactions that is.. am I wrong here? If our goal is to have many users, bigger blocks would solve the reward problem..
-5
u/_false_positive Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19
And If you don't achieve mass adoption in time?
6
3
u/lubokkanev Jun 17 '19
BCH doesn't have any transactions
That's absurd. BCH has more transactions than any other crypto, except BTC and ETH. BCH has more volume than any other crypto, except BTC. BCH has the number of transactions that BTC had, only ~2 years ago. And you call that "no transactions"? That's delusional.
doesn't have any fee revenue
Again, same as BTC 2 years ago. Anyway, we have 110 years before the block reward fades, no need to rush. If you are worried about the halvening - BTC high fees wouldn't make up for it either. Either the price will rise a lot, or the security will go down a bit.
You going to convince everyone to use "cash shuffle" to pay for transactions they don't need to do at all
That's not something anyone has any interest of doing.
thats why every other post on r/btc is begging people to cash shuffle.
Nah, that's to help increase our privacy.
p.s. good post
Troll post. The same applies for BTC.
0
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
That's absurd. BCH has more transactions than any other crypto, except BTC and ETH.
If the transactions are free I can just send money to myself all day, shuffle all day, can't I?
But what I mean is BCH has no fee revenue.
BCH has the number of transactions that BTC had, only ~2 years ago. And you call that "no transactions"? That's delusional.
It is none if you're existence is entirely based on being relative to bitcoin. If you're trying to borrow security from Bitcoin but not willing to pay for it. The topic is the matter of BCH security which entirely hinges on it's ability to borrow it from Bitcoin.
Litecoin security is a different story because it doesn't try to share the same miners.
Anyway, we have 110 years before the block reward fades
Do you understand the block rewards don't just exist then not exist 110 years later?
Troll post. The same applies for BTC.
Looks like you have a hard time understanding that BCH's security is borrowed. As each block halving passes, fees account for a greater percentage of the block reward. Which means BCH borrows less and less security from bitcoin, because it has no fee revenue. The relative hash ratio has to fall irrespective of the BCH/Bitcoin price ratio.
2
u/lubokkanev Jun 17 '19
If the transactions are free I can just send money to myself all day, shuffle all day, can't I?
Transaction fees are low for all other coins, except BTC and ETH. Yet BCH is at the top.
The topic is the matter of BCH security which entirely hinges on it's ability to borrow it from Bitcoin.
Litecoin security is a different story because it doesn't try to share the same miners.
Those are kinda correct. But again, you are missing a critical point. BTC miners prefer BCH. They mine BTC for profit. They'd defend BCH more than BTC, if that's what's needed. It was evident on the BSV hash attack too.
Do you understand the block rewards don't just exist then not exist 110 years later?
Yup, totally. It halves every ~4 years, the same as BTC. The question is, which is easier - for users to pay twice higher fees, or for users (transactions) to get twice as many and pay low fees.
As each block halving passes, fees account for a greater percentage of the block reward. Which means BCH borrows less and less security from bitcoin, because it has no fee revenue. The relative hash ratio has to fall irrespective of the BCH/Bitcoin price ratio.
This is true. But our fees are going up too, the transaction number doubled the last few months. It's not black and white. BTC fees make some percent of the rewards, bigger than the BCH percent. Our percent grows though, so every halving is not a complete net-negative for the BTC/BCH ratio. Will the sum of the BTC fees also keep rising, or will people stop using it?
3
1
u/Anen-o-me Jun 16 '19
We don't need fees to replace the block reward for another 110 years.
Use can grow by then to levels that will sustain miners on fees alone.
Your position is literally stupid.
-3
-8
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19
You could just use Litecoin if you really need lower fees, (2 cents) /lower security.. At the same time Litecoin does have much higher security then BCH/Bitcoin-Cash and does not have the risk of reorgs and 51% attacks.
No need to be a nuisance to bitcoin and the whole ecosystem through branding confusion.
19
u/SoulMechanic Jun 16 '19
*Promotes litecoin on a Bitcoin sub.
*Claims other coin is more secure through the magic of lip service.
*Calls a minority attack a 51% attack
*Claims we're there ones doing brand confusion.
-You forgot to call it Bcash!! 5/10
-6
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
*Claims other coin is more secure through the magic of lip service.
Litecoin is a lot more secure then bitcoin-cash based on math and something called facts.
You are not aware of the fundamental problems with BCH? Are you willing to learn?
I will break that down for you further if you want me to. If you genuinely want help, I will genuinely help you.
10
u/SoulMechanic Jun 16 '19
I've been using Bitcoin since when it was worth $100. But I long ago sold my Bitcoin and switched mainly to Bitcoin cash. I'm well aware of the challenges BCH and all other cryptos face.
Are you aware of the fundamental problems of Litecoin and Bitcoin? Are you willing to learn?
I'll break it down for you further if you want me to. If you genuinely want help, I will help you.
-3
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19
I've been using Bitcoin since when it was worth $100. But I long ago sold my Bitcoin and switched mainly to Bitcoin cash. I'm well aware of the challenges BCH and all other cryptos face. Are you aware of the fundamental problems of Litecoin and Bitcoin? Are you willing to learn? I'll break it down for you further if you want me to. If you genuinely want help, I will help you.
Judging your response, which is similar to say a child with a temper tantrum, I would say you are not genuinely interested in learning.
Did you try to read the link that I gave you?
11
u/libertarian0x0 Jun 16 '19
You assume that the hashpower is static. Big miners are willing to point their hashpower to the BCH chain in case of attack, as happened last time.
Performing a 51% attack on BCH is not that easy. Checkpoints make them even more difficult.
7
u/SoulMechanic Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
What tantrum? You misjudge, I was being genuine.
Would you still like to learn why Litecoin and Bitcoin are not without serious issues?
1
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 16 '19
Did you read the link that I gave you? If you tell me you read the link I gave you, I will read something you give me, yes.
The subject is why BCH has low security relative to Bitcoin. If you have relevant information then just share it with not just me, but everyone reading.
8
u/SoulMechanic Jun 16 '19
No I've not read it, I'd much rather have a real conversation.
Last I checked the top two BCH pools do have over 50% of a BCH mining but so do the top 3 of BTC, anyone can verify this in their own research, so not really a high mark for either coin. This isn't a really good argument to use BTC over BCH.
The hope is as with any coin as the network grows it finds a more diversified distribution.
But "growing network" that is a serious issue Bitcoin and Litecoin is facing as the mempool is limited to only 1mb and the talk of any talk of that limit/bottleneck was summarily banned from discussion on rbitcoin or any sub or forum controlled by Theymos. This is something BCH does not suffer from.
As such BCH can handle exponentially more tps than both BTC and LTC combined and why BCH is much cheaper to use per transaction.
-22
u/kerato Jun 16 '19
The problem: Bitcoin brakes 9k again, while bch chain is empty
The solution: owner of rbtc and paid employees of bitcoin,con pretending to be mods, bitching about r/bitcoin
Enjoy your 51%
15
u/wisequote Jun 16 '19
You’re riding the momentum you kidnapped you little shill, Blockstream could have never dreamed to get such utility on Bitcoin if since day 1 they announced third-party managed LN and Liquid.
The only reason you’re able to reference this metric is because you STOLE an open-source project, rather than build one.
You’re betting on market ignorance, we’re betting on Bitcoin.
See you down the line you little shill.
-5
u/fnchain Jun 17 '19
TIL by not breaking consensus with hardfork code == 'stealing' a project.
3
u/SoulMechanic Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
When Bitcoin was reaching the 1mb limit it had nearly 90% if all the crypto market, what's it at now?
The special pleading that has to be made to defend the 1mb limit is glaringly obvious to anyone that understands market dynamics and what core gave up that day.
Then I watched as it stopped being accepted by Microsoft and Steam and many other merchants because of fees and wait times. And took what, over a year to again be accepted by Microsoft? Once the mempool came back down. And why did the mempool come down? Because many of us had enough and moved onto other coins.
Now Bitcoin has to compete with far more coins as a result and rides the momentum of being first mover but no longer the best mover. All it has now is price hype.
I never cared for price hype, it's dumb and short sighted. I want a currency that's safer than cash, and more secure than a bank, cheaper to use than bitcoin and I've got one.
Trolling here is a waste of your time.
-2
u/fnchain Jun 17 '19
Going shopping with on-chain transactions that will be stored in the blockchain for eternity is dumb. Microsoft and Steam stopped accepting it because NO ONE went shopping. Only a few short sighted bcash/dogecoin kids were spending, because they can't possibly understand how valuable Bitcoin is. Shopping is a novelty. Want to know what spreads awareness more than anything? Price bubbles!! Don't end up like the pizza guy!!
. I never cared for price hype, it's dumb and short sighted. I want a currency that's safer than cash, and more secure than a bank, cheaper to use than bitcoin and I've got one.
Sure, you want to time travel 20 years into the future after all the hard work and price discovery has already occurred, that's fine, we'll get there eventually. Just understand that it's still very early, and we have years of asset class flippenings to occur before Bitcoin turns into a currency. Trying to use Bitcoin today as a currency and then complaining about it sucking, because no one accepts it is freaking hilarious. Stop being impatient, Store of Value is 100x from here, currency will be another 2-5x from there.
4
u/SoulMechanic Jun 17 '19
There's the Bcash name, that's how we know we're dealing with someone of high caliber discussion.
-2
u/fnchain Jun 17 '19
Fine, dismiss the reality of the industry because someone mentions bcash. Thats on you.
3
u/SoulMechanic Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
I just visualize a full grown man resorting to 4th grade level name calling and I just can't take you seriously.
I'd like to imagine you must realize how absolutely foolish that makes you look but I guess you don't or your wouldn't do it.
Hey Todd, want a bud?
Eww gross buttwiper sucks, I only drink Coors!!
Hey, it's cheap, taste fine to me and it gets the job done Todd.
It's like that, but only worse because we're not in college anymore and we're talking about something a bit more serious than beer, but I get why you do it. You do it for the psychology peer pressure effect. Only again I'm not in college and I don't really fall for silly peer pressure, I'm a sucker for well reasoned mature debate.
And that's the reality that goes completely over your head.
1
u/fnchain Jun 17 '19
I have a hostile tone in this sub, because no matter how many good arguments I make ,I get buried, by a bunch of idiots who think all this decentralized infrastructure is here to make a better PayPal.
Majority of people in this sub don't understand this technology. If you're here for cheap payments and helping Africa, you don't get it. Not yet anyway. We have to topple huge asset classes first and disrupt the very nature of finance. Money/Currency is the last step along a very long road.
The biggest issue is that many big blockers are willing to SELL OUT decentralization in the name of buying coffee. The project would end up just like Facebook coin, running in data centers and controlled by the people in the cloud. Roger had said he's ok with that outcome.
The sacrifices that are made with 1MB blocks, high fees, and always striving to be backward compatible, builds a solid foundation that ENSURE Bitcoin will be around for a very very long time. Enough time that we may actually WIN! Not second place, not runner up, not nice try, not a failed project on the way to some other totalitarian currency like Zuckbucks, but a REAL decentralized hard money for the world, outside of any state control and is impossible to change.
And then we build all the layer 2 systems we can imagine, ALL on top of a perfectly finite money supply.
3
u/SoulMechanic Jun 17 '19
You don't have a hostile tone, you have a childish one and it does you zero favors. You might as well argue with rock if you think belittling people is a good strategy ever.
The truth is some coins will be good at some things and other coins will be good at other things, there's nothing wrong with that. In fact you should be happy BCH is around, if you put you childish emotions aside you'd see that.
I don't spend my time trolling rbitcoin, I just unsubbed once the propaganda bans started and it became an echo chamber.
This sub is what you get when you don't ban people, we want a currency, not moon lambos get rich schemes. If you don't agree with or think it's foolish, there's the door, quit wasting yours and our time-->
→ More replies (0)8
u/SILENTSAM69 Jun 16 '19
You mean the 51% where miners colluded to defend against an attacker? Yes I enjoyed that.
0
Jun 16 '19
[deleted]
6
u/Anen-o-me Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
You want salt, wait until investors begin to realize how BTC has hoodwinked them and the trickle out of BTC that's already happening turns into a flood.
Because utility is king.
0
4
u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Jun 17 '19
I got a $10 tip with /u/srgrafo's name on it if he shows up in this thread to post one of his famous edits.