r/TwoBestFriendsPlay • • Jun 04 '19

every single discussion of crazy talk

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

182

u/SteakEater137 Jun 04 '19

Hmm that guy is right though. Lying is based on what you know or believe, not being "right".

Ie If Pinocchio was a true flat earth believer and said the earth was flat without his nose growing, it wouldn't be proof.

93

u/temperamentalfish Jun 04 '19

That's what always bothered me about the whole "my nose will grow now" "paradox". Prior to saying it, Pinnochio has no way of knowing the future, so he also has no way of lying about it. When he says "my nose will grow now", his nose inevitably doesn't grow, because he didn't lie, he was just wrong.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

So lying works just like killing intent is this correct

28

u/SteakEater137 Jun 04 '19 edited Jun 04 '19

Even if he doesn't know the future it could be/not be a lie. If he said "my nose won't grow" while truly believing deep down it would, it'd be a lie and would grow.

Consequently, Pinnochio saying that his nose will grow is not a lie, because it is what he honestly believes at the moment. Thus it doesn't grow.

Even if Pino accidently told someone a fact, if he thought he was being deceitful at the time, it'd still grow. It's his personal dishonesty that is being tested against, from a moral standpoint.

17

u/PescadoDeFuego How many mouths can you fuck in the frozen time? Jun 04 '19

I think we're ascribing a lot to Pinocchio's stand that we can't say for sure. Using the wealth of evidence in the historical biography "Shrek", we can see that Pinocchio's nose grows when he says something he knows for a fact to be not true. "I'm wearing women's underwear" and the like. I contest that it's not important how much he BELIEVES that he's wearing underwear for the nose to grow, it's that he's willfully contradicting something he knows to be factually correct. The limits on his power might be his own understanding. If he said "the world is flat/round" it might not grow because he couldn't 100% prove either side himself.

But now i think it gets philosophical about "what is a fact". So we'll leave that shit right there.

2

u/temperamentalfish Jun 04 '19

I disagree. Not knowing the future precludes whatever he says from being a lie. He can be right or wrong, but he can't lie because the statement itself has no truth value before the event of his nose growing or not happens.

7

u/SteakEater137 Jun 04 '19

But that's not what a lie is. A lie is being willingly deceitful.

It's like if you said to someone "if you fall from terminal velocity, you'll live". There is a very very very slim chance a person can survive that fall, but this statement is still a very blatant lie since you know and believe that falls at that height are overwhelmingly fatal. Just because you can't predict the future, aka if that person would survive the fall or not, does not stop it from being a lie.

The whole Pinocchio thing is based on morality more than being right or wrong factually. When he says things he deems to be personally untrue is when his nose grows.

3

u/temperamentalfish Jun 04 '19

But that's not what a lie is. A lie is being willingly deceitful

Exactly. He can't be willingly deceitful about something he has no way of knowing whether it's true. He would have to know the future to actually lie about that.

8

u/SteakEater137 Jun 04 '19

You can be willingly deceitful about something you believe to be true/untrue though.

Ie if you lied and said you're going to be a billionaire tomorrow to impress someone. You may not know the future for a certainty, but you have no actual reason to believe you're just going to stumble across a billion dollars, and you're deceiving someone if you say otherwise.

2

u/tradam Ok, but what are you gonna do in the game? Jun 04 '19

But you know that flat earthers would use it as proof

85

u/WretchedMog It's Fiiiiiiiine. Jun 04 '19

This is only tangentially related, but this SMBC is my favorite interpretation of Pinocchio.

58

u/metaphizzle Now I'm revitalized… surging with power! Jun 04 '19

27

u/DavidsonJenkins Jun 04 '19

That went from 0 to SCP real quick.

4

u/FelixFestus Jun 05 '19

That's just that one scene from Shrek the Third but even more drawn out.

77

u/lightsofdusk Jun 04 '19

Kingdom Hearts implies that this would actually work. At some point he gets hurt and says "Jiminy, I'm not gonna make it" and his nose grows and he says "oh, I guess I'm fine then"

96

u/Panory #The13000FE Jun 04 '19

Alternatively, Pinocchio was being a drama queen and pretending to be grievously injured, only to awkwardly walk it back when his nose ratted him out.

56

u/BlumenkranzSCT Wooliestorm Guy Jun 04 '19

Which would be totally in-character for him to do.

17

u/Nivrap She/Her Jun 04 '19

Yeah that sounds about right.

44

u/Spirit_Theory YOU DIDN'T WIN. Jun 04 '19

An unknowingly omniscient Pinocchio is a strong writing prompt.

6

u/therealchadius Jun 04 '19

Post that to /r/WritingPrompts immediately

38

u/A_Feathered_Raptor Woolie in the Atomic Purple House Jun 04 '19

Could make for some dramatic tension. Like Pinocchio's with his girl and he isn't sure where things are going but likes her well enough. And he says that he loves her, hoping and praying that he's not lying... then his nose grows.

12

u/Krogs322 Jun 04 '19

Is this a case of him honestly not believing that he loves her, or thinking that he loves her but unaware that the emotion he's feeling isn't "love" in the way he finds meaningful? Because his power isn't based off of objective fact - it's based off of willful deception. It's an old-ass story that's supposed to teach a lesson about not lying, and you can still lie by saying "the earth is round" if you honestly believe that the earth is flat.

7

u/A_Feathered_Raptor Woolie in the Atomic Purple House Jun 04 '19

Well according to Woolie, Pinocchio's brain would just measure the chemicals and move based on that.

18

u/Krogs322 Jun 04 '19

Well Woolie says a lot of things. He says he can read, an he says he doesn't steal pies.

4

u/ctc5059 Jun 04 '19

Would a magically animated puppet have a chemical based brain to cause that reaction?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '19

[deleted]

1

u/ctc5059 Jun 05 '19

Wood is, but is his brain in the wood or is his brain the blue fairy's magic? I think we need to perform exploratory surgery.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

I'm thinking it's the kind of situation where you say that you love someone but it's more propelled by the desire to just be experience love or not be alone than any actual attraction to the other person. Less "I love this girl she's so great!" and more "Well, if I'm going to be with someone it might as well be her."

There are plenty of people who seem to always be with somebody because they're afraid of being alone.

24

u/Austin_N Jun 04 '19

Has there ever been a supernatural thing that caused characters to speak the actual truth and not just what they believe to be the truth?

36

u/A_Common_Hero Adult cat girls shed ~ six cats worth of hair. I did the math. Jun 04 '19

In Umineko supernatural characters can speak using the Red Truth (literally coloring their text red), which is one hundred percent absolutely true. At one point this power is lent to a mortal character, Battler, in order to prove to him that no, really, the person he thought was his mother is actually not, and a different character is. He tries to speak a lie that he believes is true, in the Red Truth, that the character he believes is his mother really is his mother. He literally ends up choking on his words because they aren't true.

But in case you want to argue that this is a case of a character believing something deep down and not wanting to admit it to themselves, the Red Truth holds the power to reveal the truth to such an extent that it can even theoretically unmake itself through the power of paradox. Magic (like the Red Truth) in this series is... weird and hard to comprehend, but it seemingly boils down to the idea that there are magical beings that exist outside our normal reality, Witches, who can claim responsibility for mysterious events in our own world in order to "become real" in our reality. Magic only exists in the gap between what we know is true and what we can't explain. But if a character ever speaks in the Red Truth that magic isn't real, this would seemingly close all avenues for magic to enter the real world because, since its true that magic isn't real, we now have solid evidence in all instances that magic can't claim responsibility for anything that happens in the real world ever, for any reason. Thus magic ceases to exist altogether, even (it is implied) in the "outside world" they normally seem to exist inside of. Characters threaten to do this multiple times, and specifically word all dealing which involve the Red Truth to include a clause to the effect of, "No I will never, ever say magic isn't real in the Red Truth," for this reason.

Or something. Umineko is weird.

11

u/Austin_N Jun 04 '19

Ah, neat.

A logical limitation of devices or objects that compel the truth is that the person they're used on may say something that isn't true, but that they think is true. I was just curious if there was ever a story with something like that that had no margin of error.

7

u/RocketbeltTardigrade "What's that emotion? Tired scream. Yawning." Jun 04 '19

I can barely think of Umineko as something about characters and events, because so much of it is about the actual text of the script of Umineko. Story just wants to tell you something about storytelling.

15

u/BlumenkranzSCT Wooliestorm Guy Jun 04 '19

The classic comedy Liar Liar, of course.

"THIS PEN IS RRRRRRRRRRROYAL BLUE!"

13

u/choptup Quadrilogy's not a word! Jun 04 '19

A bit past the halfway point of season 1 of Code Geass, Suzaku is compelled by Lelouch's Geass to "live". This means he is incapable of doing any course of action or inaction that would cause him to die, and it's something exploited near the end of the series to let him miraculously figure out how to defuse a fantasy supernuke he has no knowledge of.

4

u/Aeoneth Just play Freedom Fighters damnit! Jun 04 '19

Okay that's pretty good. A curse that slowly gets twisted into a superpower like that is an awesome writing prompt.

13

u/VeiledWaifu It's Fiiiiiiiine. Jun 04 '19

Stille remember in Kingdom Hearts when Pinocchio either fucking lied he wasn't gonna make it or he didn't know

11

u/TrumpKingsly Jun 04 '19

strikeyouout is doing the lord's work. Pinnochio's nose doesn't grow when he says false things. It grows when he lies.

showerthoughtsofficial should spend some more time in the shower ruminating on the difference.

1

u/Heyoceama Jun 04 '19

Does it grow for only lies or for any kind of deceit such as half truths? For example, say you're asked if you did your homework and you say yes despite having only dome some of the assignments. What you have stated is factually correct, you have done homework, but it is misleading as the intent behind the question is whether or not you've done all of it.

1

u/TrumpKingsly Jun 04 '19

I think in that case Pinocchio is gaming the system, so it's his wiener that does the growing.

4

u/Atlasbot17 THE BABY Jun 04 '19

Well in kingdom hearts he tells jiminie that hes "not going to make it" then his nose grows but he didn't seem to know if he would make it out or not

2

u/Krogs322 Jun 04 '19

Yeah, but then that would mean he was willfully deceiving the cricket. It's not objective fact, it's willfully lying something - his nose would not grow unless he was trying to deceive someone.

4

u/PlagueOfGripes The Real Plague Jun 04 '19

That old "would his nose grow if he said it would" line of thought always annoyed me for this reason. He isn't an absolute vessel of knowledge. He's just a dumb fucking kid that lies.

7

u/Krogs322 Jun 04 '19

GET READY FOR 100 COMMENTS TO EXPLODE AS WE ALL ARGUE THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN OBJECTIVE FACTS AND WILLFUL DECEPTION

5

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

*Pinocchio walks up to you*

Pinocchio: "U mom gay"

*Pinocchio's nose doesn't grow*

2

u/JMRboosties do combo Jun 04 '19

i dont know what i like more about this, the idea of an omniscient nose which is essentially a god of time and space and responds to the words of the mortal being its attached to, or that everyone on that thread spelled his name differently

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

Gotta get the lore straight for the new sequel, Pinocchio: King Of Puppets.

2

u/Diablosword Jun 04 '19

yo what if pinocchio said "my nose will grow" tho

4

u/Boron_the_Moron I've chosen my hill, and by God, I'm going to die on it. Jun 04 '19

His head explodes, as punishment for his hubris.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '19

to be fair that is a vague line, if he said "right now" in that sentence then yeah there would be a problem. not specifying when makes it a truth since he will most likely lie in the future.

1

u/CelioHogane The Baz Everywhere System developer. Jun 05 '19

Does that mean Pinnochio can lie if he doesn't know he is lying?

What happens if then he knows? Does it retroactivelly elongate?

What constitutes as a feeling? If he firmly believes in something that is wrong, do the nose grows?

Is it a mental state? Can you trick the nose grow like you can trick lie detection machines?

426

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

89

u/Talisign Powerbomb Individual Baby Pieces Jun 04 '19

Why must you always add Scooby Doo into your Jojo fanfics?

59

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

Shaggy is a Dragonball Z Character dropped into jojo's bizarre adventure

-Pat on Hunter X Hunter

42

u/BenicioDelPollo Jun 04 '19

I think I just had a stroke

113

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

46

u/zHellas TAG YOUR FUCKIN' SPOILERS HOLY SHIT Jun 04 '19

AND IT'S FUCKIN' SICK

36

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

"Scooby Jojo webcomic"

WHAT

62

u/Valentinius_Anodyne #13000FE Jun 04 '19

Scoob and Shag, it's super rad

4

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

That was a trip...

37

u/Barely_Competent_GM I Promise Nothing And Deliver Less Jun 04 '19

Scoob and Shag. Give it a read, you're not prepared

14

u/G0LD_LEADER Flippant, yet desirable Jun 04 '19

Well, I didn't believe you.

But I should have.

4

u/dfighter3 Cthulu with robo-tentacles Jun 04 '19

Only 76 pages so far, but so damn good.

9

u/plinky4 Jun 04 '19

cut to a shot of mista dead, since he has to die in every fight

oh and he also shot himself with his own stand again

7

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

Oh my God they killed mista!

You Bastards!

215

u/Nivrap She/Her Jun 04 '19

What would Pinnochio's Ballyhoo be called? [FALSE ADVERTISING]?

32

u/amusement-park The Lost Planet 2 Guy Jun 04 '19

[SWEET LITTLE LIES]

2

u/rooik Jun 04 '19

Perfection

1

u/ImAWhaleBiologist Fury-fapping is image training for fuck-fighting Jun 05 '19

Already owned by Todd Howard.

6

u/King_Of_Regret Jun 04 '19

Pretty little liars

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

[deleted]

55

u/Natertot98 ART INTIMIDATES LIFE Jun 04 '19

Technically Scooby doo too

11

u/robertman21 Jun 04 '19

how what

26

u/Natertot98 ART INTIMIDATES LIFE Jun 04 '19

Bohemian rhapsody causes literally every fictional character to come to life and last time I checked Scooby doo counts as one

1

u/VERSION444 Jun 05 '19

That was a entertaining fight we even saw Spider-Man's hand and if I recal Kenshiro fought Roah and killed alot of people in Japan .

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19

[deleted]

28

u/ibbolia [Any/All] This is my Bankai: Unironic Cringeposting Jun 04 '19

Ballyhoo are named after film and tv concepts.

41

u/PersonMcHuman ^Too unrealistic for fantasy settings Jun 04 '19

I remember something like that happening in Future Diary, a guy pretending he’d failed just to mess up the predictions of the people who could see the future (their view of it being limited, so they couldn’t see anything and everything) and whoop all their asses.

19

u/BlumenkranzSCT Wooliestorm Guy Jun 04 '19

That's just Scoob and Shag

14

u/N0VAZER0 Jun 04 '19

I too read Scoob and Shag

5

u/ItsSansom Flying through big nighttime Jun 04 '19

Pinnochidio

2

u/revlid Jun 05 '19

Pinnochio's Ballyhoo works like Ichimaru Gin's zanpakutou. He can extend and retract his razor-sharp, unbreakable nose at incredible speeds by telling lies and truths, but each lie and truth has a cooldown, and the more "dangerous" the lie or truth, the faster and further it extends or retracts. Risking his life by giving the opponent vital information that could kill him allows his nose to break the sound barrier out to a huge range, while a more mundane lie is closer to a sword thrust.

1

u/LeChuckWantsMoreSlaw Jun 05 '19

Pinnochio's punch rush is him lying and telling the truth at such a speed that his nose just brutalizes people.