r/btc • u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom • Jun 01 '19
Erik Voorhees on Twitter: “I wonder if you realize that if Bitcoin didn’t work well as a payment system in the early days it likely would not have taken off. Many (most?) people found the concept of instant borderless payments captivating and inspiring. “Just hold this stuff” not sufficient.”
https://twitter.com/erikvoorhees/status/113443860848238592176
u/pyalot Jun 01 '19
Money that's not meant to be used is a patently ridiculous idea.
50
u/hawks5999 Jun 01 '19
This technology is going to truly revolutionize the world as we know it.... so long as no one ever uses it.
31
u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Jun 01 '19
HODL’ing is using it!!1 /s
19
2
-30
u/Hernzzzz Jun 01 '19
So you hold no BCH? I don't either.
8
Jun 01 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
-11
u/Hernzzzz Jun 01 '19
True, but clearly more people spend and hold BTC than BCH.
7
1
u/andromedavirus Jun 02 '19
You clearly equivocate "people" with "corporations" and "governments".
BTC is manipulated into the #1 spot because a non-captured cryptocurrency being in the #1 spot is unacceptable to your corporate paymasters.
12
u/HenryCashlitt Jun 01 '19
Money that's not meant to be used is a patently ridiculous idea.
The great thing about Bitcoin Cash (BCH) is that it's easy to use with cheap and reliable transactions, but it's also inflation-proof so it can be a store of value in the long term.
Bitcoin Cash can do it all.
4
3
1
u/Holacrat Redditor for less than 60 days Jun 01 '19
Patents are illegitimate
2
u/pyalot Jun 03 '19
Patently derives from the word patent. Patent the word predates "patent rights" by thousands of years and is used to describe something open, obvious and explicit, derived from the latin "patens" (lying open). Its use pertaining to legal rights was introduced by the "letter patent" that predates the "patent right" by several hundred years. Its modern use in the patent rights legal system is a parallel development to its continued use in language not partaining to the patent rights legal system.
This kind of phenomenon occurs fairly frequently for words that are "borrowed" in a specialized context to describe a specific thing, but mean something else in common use. For example the word "Class" is contextual and can mean among other things:
A group of pupils in school "The class of 1978"
Something of impeccable taste "That's class"
A category of things "The class of problems described by fluid dynamics..."
A programming language construct "class Foobar {}"
A good grasp of the contextual meaning of a word is mastery of a language.
1
u/Eirenarch Jun 01 '19
I don't see anything ridiculous in the idea. The idea might be proven wrong but it is not ridiculous. It seems like gold has become one such form of money. That might be wrong judgement but it is not ridiculous to suggest it.
5
u/meta96 Jun 01 '19
But the idea was allways: Sure, it works for payments, but the intention was always to be Gold 2.0. This is just bllsht, the maximalist are now on the reverse history trip ... and the old man keiser is part of this brainwash train ...
2
u/Eirenarch Jun 02 '19
Oh I agree with you completely. However the claim that it can't be store of value unless it is mass used for payments bears the burden of proof.
1
u/pyalot Jun 03 '19
Gold became what it is based on its intrinsic properties and the fact that it was used as money for thousands of years. It is true that it has lost its money property in modern times, but if it hadn't been money in the first place, it would've never become what it is today.
The important thing to realize is that gold can become money again at any time. It being relegated to something not quite money is only an external circumstance, not something that's inherently wrong with gold. Bitcoin (BTC) being crippled can never become money in the first place, neither now nor in the future. I do hope you see the difference.
1
u/Eirenarch Jun 03 '19
Well, in theory they can increase the blocksize
1
u/pyalot Jun 03 '19
Bitcoin has increased the blocksize, it's called BCH. The same thing would happen if anybody attempts to increase BTCs blocksize again, it'd just be another fork.
The problems of increasing the blocksize as a BTC majority fork are too numerous to overcome, and many of those in "charge" rightfully suspect that doing it would be an admission of guilt, defeat and having been wrong, and that it would relegate BTC to a has-been even faster than it's being relegated already by having no feasible use (for instance most miners would simply leave).
1
u/Eirenarch Jun 03 '19
If the one who increases the blocksize is in a position to keep the brand (like control official repository of the Bitcoin Core client and get support from the exchanges) it would be more successful "fork" than BCH. Of course it would be admission of guilt but who knows maybe different people will be in charge in a couple of years.
1
u/pyalot Jun 03 '19
You fundamentally don't understand. Increasing BTCs blocksize is simply impossible. There's nobody rational left there to do it. And even if there would be some who would want to do it, they're a super-minority, and all you'd end up with is another fork (likely at least 3, including the loonie 300kb blocksize fork).
And even in the extremely unlikely event that somehow big blockers (of which there aren't any left interested in BTC) would gain a super-majority, it'd be such an utter admission of failure that nobody would trust BSCore ever again, and it most likely would be the even faster downfall than it already is.
There's simply no scenario which is even remotely feasible or successful for BTC to raise the blocksize. It all ends up the same way it's already ending up, with BTC relegated to irrelevance.
Believing otherwise is simply foolish. The blocksize debate has resolved and BTC has decided to never increase it, despite numerous well run efforts to break the stalemate, and even a user, miner and business super-majority failed to do it, several times. All you're asking is a repeat performance, and nobody wants that. Anybody rational will simply use BCH.
73
u/Joloffe Jun 01 '19
As a relative old-timer the comments under that tweet are truly cringworthy. Pretty amazing that btc utility has dropped over the last 7 years in spite of the incredible progress we have seen in every other aspect of global internet services.
You have to give it to /u/nullc and the Blockstream clique - capturing the codebase and neutering any meaningful scaling has been a highly successful strategy.
7
Jun 01 '19
https://twitter.com/maxkeiser/status/1134450469756121090
This reply and the comments on it is some top tier cringe material.
4
-36
u/CraigRite Jun 01 '19
Bitcoin continues to produce new blocks every 10 minutes, and remains the most censorship resistant money in the world.
Scaling isn’t neutered; many are working on scaling via layer 2 and side chains.
If you don’t believe that layer 2 is meaningful, luckily Bitcoin is open source, and BCH + BSV appear to have motivated people supporting them.
18
17
u/shadowofashadow Jun 01 '19
The whole purpose behind the second layer is nonsense though. There is no reason not to be scaling on chain.
13
6
3
u/phro Jun 01 '19
Layer 2 in lieu of even 2MB block size is sabotage. There is no other way to disguise it.
41
u/jessquit Jun 01 '19
what's the difference between hodling and stepping up to the roulette wheel and putting it all on black
the answer is, for most people, nothing
IMO most people "buying Bitcoins" now, at the current wave of adoption, leave them on exchange. IMO most people buying Bitcoin don't understand even at a high level how it works. IMO most people buying Bitcoin don't even understand the value proposition past "it has a track record of major gains."
Since the coins aren't being bought to serve a purpose, aren't being bought on some technological or philosophical basis, never leave the exchange, and might as well not even exist, it's just spinning the roulette wheel. no commerce is served, the market is not taking in new information, no value is being added. nothings happening but a straight gamble, buy now, sell later for more fiat.
That's hodling. That's storing value.
11
u/fiah84 Jun 01 '19
Even the people who are more knowledgeable have to make the choice: Do I keep my BTC on an exchange or do I take possession of my BTC and risk having to pay huge fees when I want to sell it? Many will go the easy route even when they're aware of the risks
17
u/shadowofashadow Jun 01 '19
People forget the dark net markets were a huge source of adoption of crypto.
11
u/moleccc Jun 01 '19
and satoshidice, which he invented, was responsible for 30% of btc tx once and was shat on by some now-core boys for being spamming the chain (most vocally by luke-jr)
15
u/hawks5999 Jun 01 '19
So he’s saying it operated as a medium of exchange BEFORE being a store of value????
B-b-b-but that’s impossibru!!!
/s
4
u/unitedstatian Jun 01 '19
That's exactly what I posted here a few weeks ago. The only thing which gave Bitcoin value was that it solved a real world problem, it wasn't hoarded because it had any inherent value.
4
u/Haatschii Jun 01 '19
Blows my mind that this guy literally uses the silk road as an argument for Bitcoin being a store of value and not a medium of exchange.
10
u/Cryptoinvestor5062 Jun 01 '19
100% agree, Bitcoin was never ment to be stored for value. It was ment to be used by everyone, regardless of nationality or your current FIAT situation. RIP the dream. Blockstream and core has destroyed the good in bitcoin. All I see now is a useless code of gold that people hope other people will buy to hold it so the price increases. But if there is no real value or usage of it, people wont buy it. And that seems to be the way bitcoin is going today. Pretty sad when you think about the amazing technology and idea that bitcoin is.
1
Jun 01 '19
I'm curious why bitcoin was created in the first place in your opinion? Here is what I think: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/btvni2/why_bitcoin_was_created/
5
u/Hoolander Jun 01 '19
Anonymous unstoppable worldwide payments was LITERALLY THE THING that astonished me about bitcoin. There wasn't a single thing mentioned about holding them back then.
4
2
1
1
u/Crixus5927 Jun 01 '19
Im curious what would happen if core decided to increase its block size. This is the one thing I hate about decentralisation. Reaching a consensus can be a bitch! Thus the inevitable never ending forks.
3
u/Lucas_Meyer Jun 01 '19
If they increase the block size, the main hurdle for BTC's growth is gone and the price will go up. That would make everyone happy except Blockstream.
0
u/Mattecles Jun 01 '19
I 100% agree that Bitcoin (Cash) should put it's focus on being adapted as an electronic currency with low fees, however with bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash (and allot of other crypto's) being deflationary currency, i can imagine it's a hindrance for ALLOT of people to actually be motivated to use it as much as possible. Considering the fact that there will only be 21 million coins mined it's obvious the price WILL rise sky high by the time it comes to the flippening, in this case the flippening with government backed currency like the Dollar and Euro. The average Joe is just to lazzy to top up their wallet everytime just to buy things online or groceries in the supermarket if it's just as easy to pay with Dollars. The reason Bitcoin was used to pay on Silk Road is becouse people didn't want to be tracked or found.
I see this as the biggest hurdle for Bitcoin Cash and why allot of Core supporters just don't care (anymore) about being able to spend their Bitcoins, they just see it as an investment, hoping the next person will pay more for their Bitcoin than they did. I think there will have to be some world changing politcal events before the average Joe's are REALLY incentivised to use crypto's on a daily basis.
Showerthoughts
-7
0
Jun 01 '19
[deleted]
2
u/ErdoganTalk Jun 01 '19
No, the capacity is really unlimited, but even if you think that it stalls at 32MB, many million more people can take part.
0
Jun 01 '19
[deleted]
1
u/myoptician Jun 02 '19
Whats captivating about bitcoin is decentralization, no need for third party and resilient network.
That's an unpopular opinion, but I think it is rather accurate. Many people fail to think adversarial: how easy a centralized crypto currency could be shut down once it becomes too much of a nuisance for central banks. Imagine US requiring bitcoin-dot-com to include only fully KYC/AMLed coins into their blocks: don't you see this as a threat?
25
u/curyous Jun 01 '19
Why does he still support Bitcoin BTC?