r/btc • • May 30 '19

PSA: BTC not working so great? Bitcoin upgraded in 2017. The upgraded Bitcoin is called BCH. There's still time to upgrade!

In summer 2017 Bitcoin performed a hard fork upgrade to bigger blocks and a soft fork upgrade to Segwit.

Suffice to say we can see how that's all turning out.

BCH works like Bitcoin always worked and was upgraded like we were promised it would be from the beginning.

187 Upvotes

190 comments sorted by

14

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer May 31 '19

Scammer

40

u/jessquit May 31 '19

In October 2010 Satoshi proposed a hard fork block size upgrade. This proposed upgrade was a fundamental factor in many people's decision to invest, myself included.

BCH implemented this upgrade.

-7

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer May 31 '19

Liar

8

u/jessquit May 31 '19

Liar

That word comes too oft from your lips, Grima Wormtongue.

In October 2010 Satoshi proposed a hard fork block size upgrade.

This proposed upgrade was a fundamental factor in many people's decision to invest, myself included.

BCH implemented this upgrade. BTC chose not to.

Now shut your mouth with those fighting words. the only liar and scammer here is you, Luke.

-6

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer May 31 '19

no u

Satoshi said how it can be done. Right after he said not to do it. That's not a proposal.

7

u/jessquit May 31 '19

he said for others not to do it on their own. he said he would do it. can't you read?

When we're near the cutoff block number, I can put an alert to old versions to make sure they know they have to upgrade.

2

u/wisequote May 31 '19

Of course he can read, he just doesn’t dare understand.

His salary depends on not understanding.

15

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

24

u/jessquit May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

He would 100% agree today that blockweight can only be adjusted in combination with some incentive for more user run Active Nodes, otherwise he would know that it is at risk of centralization which breaks the entire point of the project.

Actually if you read the white paper, section 5, you'll learn that, according to Satoshi you are not even running an "active node" as you call it.

Satoshi believed the network would scale up into data centers and thought it wouldn't be a big deal if blocks were 1GB. He also addresses centralization in the white paper and argued that even if one entity has 51%+ hashpower that doesn't automatically break the network, so I don't think he'd agree with you that centralization breaks the entire point of the project. The incentives work.

Sorry man. The facts are not with you. I think you need to study the actual paper, and what Satoshi actually said, instead of what you think should be there.

8

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited Jun 01 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

20

u/jessquit May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

Wow those are very big letters.

You may think that 80GB/mo is a lot of data. Satoshi however argued that 100GB/day wasn't unreasonable.

And you missed the point that Satoshi would not have agreed that your non mining hobby node was at all critical to the network. Because it really isn't. Read section 5.

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

18

u/jessquit May 31 '19

You are all lost.

It's okay if you don't agree that Bitcoin can work as designed.

Don't invest. Or, mine an altcoin.

But BCH is the Bitcoin I invested in. You can shout all you like, but I fundamentally disagree with all of your rhetoric. No, 100GB/mo isn't a lot of data. Do you work in professional capacity in infotech? These are the sizes of mail files, not the world's most important financial data.

It costs literally a few dollars to store 100GB. My home internet can download 100GB in a matter of seconds. And the world's future financial system can't be dependent on hobbyists.

The number of business that can afford to run nodes at scale number in the low millions. The number of individuals that can afford to run nodes at scale also numbers in the low millions. The issue isn't that there won't be anyone who can afford to do this. The issue is that we haven't onboarded them.

6

u/LegalComment May 31 '19

100gb per month is definitely a lot in the country im currently in. Internet is metered and you pay per GB. 5gb per month currently runs me $20. Is self sovereignty only for those more privileged?

13

u/jessquit May 31 '19

Self sovereignty does not derive from having a copy of the ledger. If that were true we'd have no need for miners.

Self sovereignty requires that you control your keys, can transact on demand, and can validate transactions for yourself. You do not need a copy of the ledger to validate your own transactions. You cannot transact on demand on a congested chain.

→ More replies (0)

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

100gb per month is definitely a lot in the country im currently in. Internet is metered and you pay per GB. 5gb per month currently runs me $20. Is self sovereignty only for those more privileged?

Then don’t run a node.

You have still full access to bitcoin and your coin with an SPV wallet.

→ More replies (0)

8

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

16

u/jessquit May 31 '19

Every business in the world is owned by 4 organisations.

Oh dear. Maybe you are better off in BTC after all.

→ More replies (0)

6

u/jessquit May 31 '19

Non mining nodes are not peers! Read section 5. You've been bamboozled.

→ More replies (0)

9

u/JonathanSilverblood Jonathan#100, Jack of all Trades May 31 '19

Find a way to make users want to run more nodes even if the resources needed double. (2MB Blockweight+segwit).

This is a simple task. If you had raised the blocksize instead of letting it be capped, adoption wouldn't have been halted. For every N users, someone will run a node.

For every Y blocksize increase someone will stop running a node.

According to current technological trends, if you double the blocksize, you will more than double the number of people that are capable and willing to run nodes, but you will not remove more nodes due to the increase.

The cost of bandwidth, storage and processing power has gone down alot since the 1mb limit was enforced.

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/jessquit May 31 '19

And yet user active node participation has remained stagnant.

real world BTC adoption has been down since the block size limit was hit

3

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/jessquit May 31 '19

the only thing that's gone up on BTC is the backlog and the Tether-pumped price.

BTC dominance over altcoins is down from 90+% to ~50% in the period during which the blocks got full.

almost every business that used to accept BTC dropped it when blocks got full. Microsoft? dropped. Steam? dropped. Dell? dropped.

great strategy. much adoption.

→ More replies (0)

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

How so? Explain how if you make it even harder to run nodes than now, more people will want to run them. Please, because even with prices of data \ quota decreasing the number of nodes remain pretty much the same.

More growth, lead to more peoples willing/needing to run nodes.

1

u/JonathanSilverblood Jonathan#100, Jack of all Trades Jun 02 '19

Explain how if you make it even harder to run nodes than now, more people will want to run them.

To explain this, you first need to understand that the correlation between a desire to run a node, and the difficulty to set on up, is only weakly connected.

Instead, the desire to run a node is correlated strongly with the number of people involved and using the system. Most of those capable of running nodes today, would also be capable of running nodes with higher requirements. The assumption that they are not is akin to saying that most nodes are perfectly balanced on the edge of their capacity, which should logically mean that as adoption happens they'd drop off anyway.

We've had lots of growth over the year, and this has not happened - instead the node count have consistently grown with adoption.

Get more people invested into a future where nodes matter, and more people will invest their time and effort into getting nodes.

8

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Find a way to make users want to run more nodes even if the resources needed double. (2MB Blockweight+segwit).

I disagree with your premise, even Satoshi said it was a not a good way to scale.

Why every single user need to full audit the chain to it?

11

u/JonathanSilverblood Jonathan#100, Jack of all Trades May 31 '19

risk of centralization which breaks the entire point of the project.

Quantify decentralization first. Set target goals. Measure current state. Calculate impact of raising blocksize. Evaluate value gained vs risk taken. Commit to action. Confirm if your model adheres to reality. Repeat.

The growth rate of technology outpaces your current growthrate of adoption.

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/jessquit May 31 '19

Otherwise you are selling out to anyone with enough money to "be the peers"

sad trombone

peers are the miners

Read section 5

Now read section 4 to learn why.

requiring money to be a peer is an integral part of the design.

your problem is that you don't understand the design, and think your sybil node is a peer.

it is not. I assure you that block producers are not peering to you.

8

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

All this is none form day one.

And Satoshi replied that bitcoin never hit a scaling limit.

Gmax replied that Bitcoin can only be a notary service for second layer.

-1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Also satoshi did not realize the size bitcoin would grow to before it could take the world banking system.

He did.

He was questioned about scaling and never left any doubt, he was an extrem large blocker.

8

u/LovelyDay May 31 '19

Scammer

Great way to signal from the outset that you have brought no real arguments

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Scammer

Why your fork be more legitimate than BTC?

Care to explain?

BTC is a hugely modified chain, not even trying to be a currency anymore, how come it be bitcoin?

12

u/pyalot May 31 '19

Flatcoiner

4

u/LovelyDay May 31 '19

1000 bits u/tippr

3

u/tippr May 31 '19

u/pyalot, you've received 0.001 BCH ($0.432034532764 USD)!


^^How to use | ^^What is Bitcoin Cash? | ^^Who accepts it? | r/tippr
Bitcoin Cash is what Bitcoin should be. Ask about it on r/btc

17

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

You and others changed BTC into something else that isn't what the plan was and isn't what people had bought, and capitalised on the popularity BTC had gained (as a medium of exchange). Back in 2013 nobody would have mined/bought BTC if they were told that the transaction fees were expected to rise to 50$ to incentivise miners to secure the network.

At the very least you should recognise that BCH is a legit contender for the bitcoin name.

Edit: comparison of what people had bought vs what it has become

Edit2: just to be clear, the left slide describes what BTC was and what BCH is, and what BTC is not. Fight me.

-5

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer May 31 '19

Those are lies.

12

u/IWriteCrypto May 31 '19

Can you explain which of the statements is a lie, and why? There are a lot of people on this sub because they're curious about BCH vs BTC (as opposed to having a strong opinion) and it'd be nice to see someone actually engage in conversation instead of the same old name calling and arguments from both sides.

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

I hope can take the time to do so. I don't find his answer satisfactory (I'll let it slip that he called me a liar).

-5

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer May 31 '19

Early on, no-fees was used as an incentive for adoption (by some people), but was always understood (by people involved) to be a temporary thing.

The Bitcoin developers from those days are still working on Bitcoin today too.

In 2017, a bunch of newbies (most with no background in Bitcoin development) didn't like Bitcoin's most recent upgrade, launched a new altcoin and called it "Bitcoin Cash". It is not in any sense a "legit contender" for the name, and even has wildly different goals from Bitcoin. The real Bitcoin continues on.

Bitcoin is a decentralised system, offering censorship-resistant, irreversible payments, similar in some ways to gold and cash.

BCH is a centralised payment system, offering low fees, much like VISA.

11

u/jessquit May 31 '19

Early on, no-fees was used as an incentive for adoption (by some people), but was always understood (by people involved) to be a temporary thing.

That is false.

Satoshi: I don't think the threshold should ever be 0. We should always allow at least some free transactions.

The Bitcoin developers from those days are still working on Bitcoin today too.

No, this is false.

Gavin and Mike, who led the project after Satoshi, and many others left.

In 2017, a bunch of newbies (most with no background in Bitcoin development) didn't like Bitcoin's most recent upgrade

This is false. I was involved in Bitcoin before you, Adam, or Greg. you are the newbie Luke. I was a developer before you were born, Luke.

-6

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer May 31 '19

Liar

8

u/jessquit May 31 '19

you wouldn't say that to my face, Wormtongue

8

u/fiah84 May 31 '19

I don't think the threshold should ever be 0. We should always allow at least some free transactions.

this is a direct quote from satoshi: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=994.msg12168#msg12168

10

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Hey, thanks for an actual response.

I'll bite, for the benefit of u/IWriteCrypto and all the other people out there.

no-fees [...] was always understood [...] to be a temporary thing

Yes. Non sequitur, tho.

Having no fees is one thing, having low fees is another, having high fees is another. I think we can agree that when block rewards diminish, the security of the network will need to be payed for by fees. Lets say, for the benefit of simplicity, that we have a target of 10 bitcoin per block of fees.

There are many different ways to have a 10 bitcoin fee reward in a block: one single transaction paying 10 bitcoin, one thousand transactions paying 0.01 fee, or ten million 100-satoshi-fee transactions.

BTC has gone the "low amount of high fee transactions" route, by limiting the blocksize. High fees is the intended state of the system, so far that Gergory Maxwell, (ex)collegue of Luke-jr, has famously popped chaimpaign over 50$ fees in Dec'17.

BCH has gone the "high amount of low fee transactions" route, by lifting the blocksize limit. This is arguably what Satoshi had intended to do when it was required, as the limit was temporary while the network was small and the price low.

In 2017 [...]

It was clear that the original plan, and the original offering of Bitcoin (fast low-fee transactions) would not be possible on BTC anymore. That's why the split happened.

Bitcoin is a decentralised system, offering censorship-resistant, irreversible payments, similar in some ways to gold and cash.

BCH is a centralised payment system, offering low fees, much like VISA.

Opinion.

-1

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Core Developer May 31 '19

BTC has gone the "low amount of high fee transactions" route, by limiting the blocksize.

This is false. Lightning expands the number of transactions by magnitudes without increasing the block size. In the long run, Bitcoin fees will likely be cheaper than BCH fees. Even today, the only reason BCH [non-zero] fees might be lower, is because Bitcoin is worth more than BCH - you can send a minimum-fee (1 sat/byte) Bitcoin transaction and it will still confirm.

BCH has gone the "high amount of low fee transactions" route, by lifting the blocksize limit. This is arguably what Satoshi had intended to do when it was required, as the limit was temporary while the network was small and the price low.

You're ignoring all the real harm that even 1 MB blocks proved to cause. Lifting the block size limit to the extreme BCH has, is suicide for a decentralised network. Even the increases in block size Bitcoin has done may be fatal.

It was clear that the original plan, and the original offering of Bitcoin (fast low-fee transactions) would not be possible on BTC anymore.

That's nonsense.

6

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Lightning expands the number of transactions by magnitudes without increasing the block size.

Lightning is cool technology. I don't like it being pushed as THE scaling solution, tho. Expecially since it has been promised for the longest time, but is still not ready. Also it doesn't work as good as described if the onchain fees are high.

Even today, the only reason BCH [non-zero] fees might be lower, is because Bitcoin is worth more than BCH

Even if/when BCH price increases, the fees are expected to remain low (that's why the blocksize limit was increased), and BCH to work for payments.

Even today [...] you can send a minimum-fee (1 sat/byte) Bitcoin transaction and it will still confirm.

It probably will eventually. How long will it take - nobody knows.

It might also be the case that a 1sat/B transaction won't confirm. It did happen Dec'17 that people's transactions went stale for weeks in miners' mempools, and were eventually dropped.

In the long run, Bitcoin fees will likely be cheaper than BCH fees. Even today, the only reason BCH [non-zero] fees might be lower, is because Bitcoin is worth more than BCH - you can send a minimum-fee (1 sat/byte) Bitcoin transaction and it will still confirm.

How will the BTC network pay the miners for securing the network when there are only few low-fee transactions? If there are only few transactions, fees need to be high to pay the miners to secure it. I see no way around it, please explain if I'm wrong.

You're ignoring all the real harm that even 1 MB blocks proved to cause.

I understand your argument that the majority (ideally 75%+) of network participants should run a validating node, as stated in the recent u/mccormick555 interview. I disagree with the premises, tho. It takes just one single miner, no matter how small, to alert of an attempt to hijack the network. Add to it that in a healthy ecosystem there will always be businesses, exchanges, universities, and yes hobbyists that will run validating nodes, this is a non-issue.

Also, with optimized software even current RPi hobbyist validating nodes could handle a capacity increase, just run it in pruning mode (you'll still have the full UTXO).

9

u/LovelyDay May 31 '19

"Bitcoin Cash" [...]. is not in any sense a "legit contender" for the name, and even has wildly different goals from Bitcoin. The real Bitcoin continues on.

Who's the liar around here?

Bitcoin Cash literally exists to fulfil the definition of "Bitcoin: a peer-to-peer electronic cash system" which BTC has abandoned.

https://bitcoin.com/bitcoin.pdf

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/LovelyDay May 31 '19

Literally the identical paper, but from a different website.

https://blockchair.com/bitcoin/whitepaper

You know what "decentralization" means?

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Ah yes, the ever famous peer to peer electronic store of value. "It has value because it has value!" Is the pitch ;)

10

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Sellout

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Thanks, but I can determine what is a scam all by myself, I don’t need you to tell me. Nice of you to drop by though, nice to see your fear laid out for all to see 😊.

3

u/Alexpander May 31 '19

Back to your shitcoin vegeta sub you scammer.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Hijacker.

Liar.

Technophobe.

Bankster.

In 20-30 years you get to look back on your failures and tell your kids/grandkids you were a whore for the banks and kept millions/billions that much longer in poverty so the existing banking system could squeeze out just a little more momentum.

At least we have the courage to build the world we want to live in you talentless hack.

3

u/ChaosElephant May 31 '19

4

u/tippr May 31 '19

u/WeaponizedMath, you've received 0.003554 BCH ($1.5 USD)!


^^How to use | ^^What is Bitcoin Cash? | ^^Who accepts it? | r/tippr
Bitcoin Cash is what Bitcoin should be. Ask about it on r/btc

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Did you brush your teeth this morning? They won't be growing back, mate.

4

u/addiscoin May 31 '19

Given the comments I've observed in this thread, it looks like /u/luke-jr has bought another sock puppet account, /u/SupremeChancellor, and is spewing nonsense in r/btc for some days now. Vote manipulation for little Luke's accounts is evident here. /u/luke-jr you are full blown turd.

-1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/addiscoin May 31 '19

Both your accounts are getting vote manipulated in this thread. Coincidence?

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/addiscoin May 31 '19

Is it a problem that there is a competing opinion

Yes, this is false.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/jessquit May 31 '19

and yet here you are having conversations while downvoted so someone must be seeing it....

3

u/addiscoin May 31 '19

Vote manipulation is not welcome. You are simply trying to make it look like there are competing opinions in this thread. I have no problem with other's opinions express free here. I have a problem with your shady tactics, Luke.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Lol, you can just smell the fear from the propagandists puppet masters in this thread.

4

u/jessquit May 31 '19

I know right? vote bots and guildmasters in full force.

3

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

I love it! Means we are absolutely on the right track!

Have a great weekend /u/jessquit!

7

u/fiah84 May 31 '19

if you guys want to see vote manipulation at work, look no further than the comment by luke-jr

12

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Would you rather it was... Censored?

To be honest calling BCH scammer when the project run as bitcoin was intended while BTC has fees permanently above $1 is wierd.

I would deserve upvotes if he care to explain and prove that BCH is a scam..

Besides that it is just name calling and deserves downvote.

8

u/fiah84 May 31 '19

so his comment is shown unlike any of those below.

bullshit. Anyone with a browser can see that those comments ARE MORE VISIBLE than the other comments for people who aren't logged in, in fact they cannot be hidden. If those comments are not visible to you then that's because of your settings. This has been the case on /r/btc for a long time now

here's how it looks like: https://gfycat.com/perfectboldgraysquirrel

10

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/fiah84 May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

Believe whatever you like sir.

and you just stop addressing the point whenever you get called out on your bullshit with a video

Would you rather your safe space where your circlejerk is downvoting anything not with the party line?

you already have yours, so why are you here? Don't you have something productive to do in your life?

edit: also go ahead and edit your own post 9 minutes after I already replied to it. Good job, really helps with the discussion, especially when you don't even tell us what you edited. A+

4

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/fiah84 May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

edit:

I edited it, because if that was your first argument then others will have the same.

So I just wanted to clear it up before I get downvoted into oblivion down here.

See, I like to have my opinions heard. I know I know, sounds crazy.

so you're just going to fuck up this whole discussion again by editing your posts more? way to go

original post here:


This is what the majority sees.

you assume that the majority of people reading reddit are logged in, which is not typically true for other websites. Do you know if that's the case for reddit?

also I guess the 4 upvotes your comment got in a few minutes are completely organic, right? at least try and make it look like a brigade and also downvote my posts instead of just upvoting your own

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/fiah84 May 31 '19

You made an argument, I made a counter argument after you accused me of not being able to back up my claims which was a reasonable counter argument.

You disagree, fine.

no, I called you out on your bullshit, then you were unable to substantiate your claim but you haven't rescinded it

I have no knowledge, or power over anything that is happening with the votes on my posts.

I am usually downvoted.

so you agree that the voting behavior in this topic is atypical

1

u/CraigRite May 30 '19

Difficulty adjustment every block and a rolling checkpoint, just like we were promised!

My point being, things change.

-13

u/iupqmv May 30 '19

Not really an upgrade if you get 5% from hashrate and price, rather very loud forkcoin minority, I'll give you that.

Let's play along:

In November 2018 Bitcoin Cash performed a hard fork upgrade to bigger blocks from 32 to 128.

Suffice to say we can see how that's all turning out.

BSV works like Bitcoin always worked and was upgraded like we were promised it would be from the beginning.

16

u/jessquit May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

Not really an upgrade if you get 5% from hashrate and price

A lot of people were coerced and/or disinfomed about the upgrade. People were told that 8MB blocks would break the network; they were told Segwit would be a 2MB block size increase, they were told Lightning Network would be able to "encompass the global financial transaction volume in all electronic payment systems today, without a single custodial third party holding funds or requiring participants to have anything more than a computer using a broadband connection."

Etc.

Suffice to say a minority chose the upgrade at the time. And we see how that's turning out. BTC is, predictably, congested. Because it turns out congestion is the new strategy.

But there's still time to upgrade if you decide maybe congestion isn't a great strategy after all.

9

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

BSV was completely unnecessary drama perpetuated by a technically incompetent buffoon and charlatan. Sad.

-14

u/MrRGnome May 31 '19

You are one of the most dishonest people on this sub. "upgraded"? Come on.

15

u/jessquit May 31 '19

In October 2010 Satoshi proposed a hard fork block size upgrade. This proposed upgrade was a fundamental factor in many people's decision to invest, myself included.

BCH implemented this upgrade.

-8

u/the_defiant May 31 '19

It’s irrelevant what Satoshi wanted in 2010 in 2019. Satoshi kicked off this project but he himself would admit he has no more authority than anyone else who is actively involved in the development. Satoshi is not a god who needs to be praised as the ultimate source of truth. Stop using him for your propaganda.

7

u/jessquit May 31 '19

It’s irrelevant what Satoshi wanted in 2010 in 2019.

It is not.

It demonstrates that BCH is following the original Bitcoin plan and BTC reflects the changed strategy

This is relevant because BCH's strategy, that is, Bitcoins strategy, is solid. BTC's strategy is clearly not working out.

8

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

"Dishonest"? Come on.

12

u/World_Money May 31 '19

Every piece of software you use is upgraded regularly.

Bitcoin Cash is faster, cheaper, and has more features than Bitcoin BTC. BCH is most certainly an upgrade.

6

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

It's there same thing that the honey badger has always done. It doesn't care that blockstream forked themselves off the network or that they spent so much money to steal the brand.

We just keep on going. Like always

-4

u/0xHUEHUE May 31 '19

there was no blockstream fork afaik

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

It was the most insidious fork. A soft fork where they shoe horned segwit into anyone can spend txs

4

u/IWriteCrypto May 31 '19

Why is it not an upgrade? Genuinely asking. Is it because there are fewer BCH nodes, making it more centralized? Or what? The fees are a lot lower, and would be even if BCH volume was as high as that of BTC. That's clearly a good thing. So why do people believe that it's not an improvement?

A BTC dev chimed in above but all he said was "scammer", "liar", etc - no actual explanation as to what the problem is with BCH.

1

u/MrRGnome May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

BCH has lower fees and larger blockspace. The blockchain is an append only data structure with every participant of the protocol having to perpetually verify that structure. That's the whole point of bitcoin - you don't trust you verify. You can only do this by running a node. You can only participate in the protocol by running a node. Nodes have a substantial security role as well and having a diverse population of them shepherds upgrades and keeps miners honest. The larger that data structure, the larger the blocks, the more difficult to scale and run a node. Less nodes is bad. BCH has been losing nodes - down over 30% in just the last several months.

Low fees mean miners aren't paid as much, means there is less incentive to secure BCH. It would take hundreds of times the volume of Bitcoin and hundreds of times the blocksize to match the fees miners on bitcoin get to secure the network. Literally ~175 MB blocks. Today 2.5% of the available hashpower could attack BCH at will. It was just 51% attacked and some miners were robbed. BCH is simply not secure.

That's not an upgrade. It may seem like a better user experience because of fees and the incorrect perception you don't need to run a node, but those are gains of centralization.

The influential handful of people who control BCH bought every relevant bitcoin social media account and domain they could get their hands on, claim BCH is bitcoin and continue a multi year PR crusade to confuse new users that BCH is bitcoin. Or that it is an upgrade. They bought the btc subreddit, the Bitcoin twitter account, and the Bitcoin domain name just to name a select few.

Maybe you can see why many people view BCH as a scam, its proponents as liars. They only exist at all for merit of confusing new uses who are interested in Bitcoin and fall into their propaganda trap. Some of us find that offensive, to be taking advantage of the ignorant, and come here to speak facts in the face of lies.

4

u/Alexpander May 31 '19

Youre not going to elaborate? Come on.

-16

u/nesta420 May 31 '19

This is just sad.

6

u/Alexpander May 31 '19

No Gold for this troll??

9

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Yeah, the blockstream brigading is getting desperate

-17

u/LegalComment May 31 '19

This is not a good look for you guys.

7

u/SwedishSalsa May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

Lol, we don't care. Go away pathetic troll. BCH is the real Bitcoin.

-1

u/LegalComment May 31 '19

Upvoted! Thanks for the laugh.

4

u/Alexpander May 31 '19

If you prefer a jammed, high fee vegeta shitcoin I know just the right sub for you.

10

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

A blockchain that actually works quickly and cheaply isn't a good look?

-4

u/LegalComment May 31 '19

The method of promotion isn't.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

The method of promotion isn’t.

BCH= bitcoin as intended BTC= notary service for second layer

What wrong with BCH promotions method?

1

u/LegalComment May 31 '19

I don't see any other project constantly attempting to compare itself with another. Except maybe xrp trolls for a while last year. Seems desperate. Attempting to pass as bitcoin is straight up bsv's agenda.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '19

I don’t see any other project constantly attempting to compare itself with another. Except maybe xrp trolls for a while last year. Seems desperate. Attempting to pass as bitcoin is straight up bsv’s agenda.

It is the result of the project capture.

Imagine a business get involved in BTC to change it, start to promote a soft fork that only allow empty block.

They take over forums so that it is not allow to talk about digital gold or ecash, Bitcoin chain is now a pure hash number generator. All other talk is deleted.

If the soft fork succeeds what are the alternatives left to the Bitcoin core crowd?

The empty block chain keep the ticker and the name because it was a soft fork.

Bitcoin core will have no choice but to split.

Would you think the chain continuing with empty blocks is the original Bitcoin?

-13

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

It was upgraded again with BSV.

10

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

More like an asshole stole a life raft and sank it during his tantrum about the life raft not calling him Captain.

4

u/ChaosElephant May 31 '19

3

u/tippr May 31 '19

u/WeaponizedMath, you've received 0.00118466 BCH ($0.5 USD)!


^^How to use | ^^What is Bitcoin Cash? | ^^Who accepts it? | r/tippr
Bitcoin Cash is what Bitcoin should be. Ask about it on r/btc

-22

u/CraigRite May 30 '19

Difficulty adjustment every block and a rolling checkpoint, just like we were promised!

My point being, things change.

25

u/[deleted] May 30 '19 edited May 30 '19

Yeah, bitcoin was working too well as a currency so blockstream changed the meta, turned Bitcoin Core into a shadow of its former glory and strung the ignorant along for the ride.

Bitcoin Cash is Bitcoin as it was meant to be. Instant transactions for less than a penny.

But cheap fast transactions aren't the only reason to support the real bitcoin, we're actually making improvements to the protocol in regards to privacy and scaling, just to name a few.

Yes, things change. Some things die. Core died as a currency once fees rose above a nickle imo. All it is now is a cumbersome exchange token. It's only relevancy is its price.

The cruelest irony now is the fact that for so long early adopters spent much of their energy convincing people that bitcoin wasn't a ponzi or a pyramid scheme, but a real currency you could use to be your own bank. Today with fees as high as $50 for some transactions, and at least $1 for most others, Core is simply another scam run by the very bankers bitcoin was meant to supplant.

Bitcoin Cash is Bitcoin. You can't kill the honey badger of money. The idea is too good to let die.

-10

u/CraigRite May 31 '19

That company has so much rent space in peoples’ heads it’s scary. Bitcoin is open source, with many implementations each with many developers. Calling followers of the most secure chain ignorant is extreme hubris.

Bitcoin Cash is a good project, but the majority of miners want real Bitcoin. Hash rate doesn’t lie, Reddit comments do.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

The blockstream implementation, by definition, is not as secure as the Bitcoin blockchain.

Blockstream is not implementing the bitcoin protocol. They stopped Bitcoin development in favor of their technologies.

That's the exact opposite of security.

1

u/CraigRite May 31 '19

wat

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

Blockstream froze their protocol development years ago. Their Bitcoin has not advanced from where it was since that time. Just throwing hash at a blockchain does not mean it is inherently more secure.

If you want to upgrade your protocol Bitcoin implementation you have to hard fork. In order to freeze development Blockstream had to enforce the narrative that hard forks are bad and no further development has happened on the Blockstream repository of the Bitcoin protocol since then.

The only changes they have made are to shoe-horn their required interfaces for the technologies they have patented to steer users onto their platforms and capture those users.

That's it. That's not more secure.

If you want to use Bitcoin you have to use Bitcoin Cash. The protocol development is not happening anywhere else.

The miners mine where they can profit. The only advantage Blockstream has is that they stole the brand. Their technology is a shit show failure in every capacity -- but for the banks that means 'working as intended'

1

u/CraigRite May 31 '19

I appreciate you expanding your thoughts, but I’m still confused. Are you talking about the Bitcoin Core implementation? It is absolutely not frozen in development. BIP 174, 156, 144, 116, 199 are all being reviewed and looking to go live. Blockstream is not the only company working on Bitcoin!

I forgot to mention Schnorr signatures. Good on BCH for seeing the value, and of course a centralized project can hard fork changes into a project more quickly than a decentralized one.

The irony of Schnorr signatures (developed by a Blockstream employee) being hard forked into BCH is not lost on me.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

The irony of developers bankrolled by banks to subvert the protocol is not lost on me.

-8

u/Adrian-X May 31 '19

What you may be saying is bitcoin is not just code but a network of users.

As open source code, I think the version of bitcoin that has the best ability to scale is called Bitcoin SV.

The more interesting fact is the network of users have systematically sold their bitcoin because they believe they know which bitcoin is the one that will accommodate the most users.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Bitcoin is not a democracy. It is not the users

1

u/Adrian-X May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19

Bitcoin is nothing but a network of users who share a believe. I never suggested it was a democracy.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

It's not belief. It's a protocol. It's written down and described clearly.

It is not the users.

It's an instruction manual for permissionless cash.

It is not the users.

1

u/Adrian-X Jun 01 '19

You can copy the code that describes the protocol indefinably, it's is not valuable.

Where does the vale come from?

One explanation is from the users who believe using the same ledger and writing to it using the same protocol is valuable?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '19

The value comes from the protocol.

The token is important because for the first time in history we're able to monetize a protocol.

The market exists for the implementations to compete.

-5

u/CraigRite May 31 '19

I am absolutely saying Bitcoin is both code AND what network users decide to use.

SV can definitely scale, on-chain. Putting Youtube on the base layer to be recorded for all time? Interesting but dumb (in my opinion).

Your last point I don’t understand I’m sorry.

-13

u/greasydoorknob May 31 '19

Where's my sidechains already!

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

[deleted]

2

u/jessquit May 31 '19

I upgraded my Bitcoin client with a hard fork in 2017.

It's not my fault you got bamboozled and stayed on the non upgraded version.