r/btc • • May 30 '19

Nobody uses Bitcoin Cash

https://imgur.com/UAZT1Mi
179 Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

106

u/[deleted] May 30 '19 edited May 30 '19

While I'm not agreeing with the premise "nobody uses Bitcoin Cash" it's unfair to compare a UTXO model blockchain with a state model blockchain. In a UTXO model, like BTC/BCH, you (typically) spend an entire input. That means if I have an input of $1000 but am only spending $10, my transacted amount is still $1000 since I have to send $990 back to myself in an output. In a state model like Ethereum, I can simply sent $10 directly. This would result in a state model blockchain having a significantly less transacted amount via this analysis.

19

u/gingeropolous May 30 '19

Yeah, or monero, where u can't see the amount

28

u/hoomiin4 Redditor for less than 60 days May 30 '19

Great point! Never considered how much UTXO systems exaggerate volume/activity before.

-9

u/Oinfkan May 30 '19

Does nobody else see the Russian bots pumping Ethereum in this sub? It's pathetic

7

u/GuessWhat_InTheButt May 30 '19

This metric can also be gamed really easily on a low-fee network like Bitcoin Cash. I'm not saying it is, but it's certainly not suitable to extract the last truth out of it.

5

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto May 30 '19

Yup. You can pass $10,000 to yourself back and forth easily and make it looks like there is a lot of dollar activity, for cheap. You can’t game this in the same way if transactions are expensive.

4

u/Gregonomics May 30 '19

You missed the sarcasm. Chart shows that Bitcoin Cash is used quite a lot in comparison to its current valuation.

16

u/goldMy May 30 '19

The chart does not show how much anything is used more or less. Look at active Adresses if you want to get an image of how much a chain is used.

ETH > 500,000wallets used per day

BCH > 40,000wallets used per day

5

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

Again, this is not a good metric, especially with the rise in popularity of things such as Cash Shuffle. How do you define a "wallet" is it an address? Is it a group of tainted addresses? etc...

7

u/jessquit May 30 '19

in what way is cash shuffle not a valid use of the blockchain

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

It’s like driving around your block for 8 hours and ending up at your house.

5

u/jessquit May 30 '19

Right, I see why you'd say that. But hear me out:

If I used the chain to do an decentralized atomic-swap with you from BCH to ETH wouldn't you say that's a legitimate value-exchange onchain transaction?

Now explain how a shuffle is different.

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

Honestly, I really don’t have a strong opinion on it, but if swapping coins with you is the ultimate goal than that’s a valid transaction. But if the ultimate goal is to make it appear that the bandwidth is higher, or to just “launder money” with thousands of transactions, than the end goal is what defines legitimacy not the method.

I can go in a bank and sign a withdraw slip and get money from the clerk. I can also go in a bank and write “give me all your money” on a withdraw slip and get money from the clerk. Pretty much the exact same transaction, but it’s the intent that makes it legitimate not the method,

0

u/BOMinvest Redditor for less than 90 days May 30 '19

I mean, its not the exact same transaction. One type will put you in jail.

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

Your right, it’s not exactly the same, I was having trouble coming up with a good metaphor.

But you get the idea, its not the actual process you use, it’s the reason your doing it that should determine if it counts as transaction volume.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/mcmuncaster May 30 '19

only way to measure it is active addresses that I'm aware of.

1

u/joeknowswhoiam May 30 '19

How isn't that also easily gameable?

1

u/mcmuncaster May 30 '19

yup totally gameable - but really it's all we got

4

u/324JL May 30 '19

ETH > 500,000wallets used per day

This includes the thousands of tokens on ETH.

How many addresses on ETH are active per day based on just ETH usage?

1

u/Free__Will May 30 '19

why does that matter?

1

u/324JL May 30 '19

Because you can't make a direct comparison between ETH and any crypto, because the vast majority of ETH transactions are token transactions, and not ETH transactions. A number of tokens running on Ethereum probably have more transactions per day than people actually transacting in Ethereum. But they all get added to the ETH "wallets used per day" number.

3

u/Free__Will May 30 '19

but if they are built on Ethereum, and pay gas to use the network, then they are transaction on the Ethereum network... why would you discount these?

1

u/324JL May 30 '19

Because they are not "Ethereum" transactions. They're *tokenXYZ* transactions.

1

u/Free__Will May 31 '19

If they are paying gas on the Ethereum network, then they are by definition Ethereum transactions.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Free__Will May 31 '19

well, lots of people do take that approach... that's kind of the point of BCH - that on chain transaction aren't spam - they are people using the network!

0

u/Spartan3123 May 30 '19

Yes if anything you should take the smallest output

-6

u/[deleted] May 30 '19 edited May 30 '19

It is quite easy to distinguish between the transacted amount and the return address because people dont define amount sent precise to 0.00000001 BTC. Hence the return address always has a higher precision. You point is stale.

The chart is misleading as bch has a median tx value of < 1cent on empty blocks. Meanwhile btc blocks are full of high fee tx, median tx is 400usd. Meaning the value for volume transacted on btc is all payed for with many high value, high tx fee tx. While on bch Ver is moving his own coins back and forth with himself at 0 cost.

7

u/iCrushDreams May 30 '19

Maybe you don’t, but many wallets will let you type in an amount in fiat currency and convert that to its equivalency in crypto to a very precise extent. Lots of people also just use converters to see the fiat value equivalent and copy/paste that amount.

-7

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

The fuck you on about? Instead of debating me with stupid shit you could just take a look at the blockchain. But I guess confronting reality just is out of the question.

4

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

It is quite easy to distinguish between the transacted amount and the return address because people dont define amount sent precise to 0.00000001 BTC. Hence the return address always has a higher precision. You point is stale.

If you send a Dollar amount the amount send is precise to 0.00000001

-2

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

I send bitcoin. Looking at the blockchain so does everyone else.

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

If BCH is used for purchase your trick doesn’t work

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

I guess we'll never find out. When it comes to brick and mortar "not being used" is what I would say about BTC. The statement "BCH is being used" is so farcical that it's not even false.

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

Brick and mortar payment doesn't show your pattern, that all I was saying.

5

u/svener May 30 '19

https://i.imgur.com/UAZT1Mi.png

Please link directly to the image and not the the imgur album page, esp. when there's only one image in the album!

4

u/jessquit May 30 '19

I used the RIF app on my phone to create this, sorry

3

u/Juankestein May 30 '19

there's a tick when you post to prevent this, on RiF

4

u/jessquit May 30 '19

I suck

1

u/xenyz May 30 '19

Reddit is Fun is fun, but Boost for Reddit is worth a look!

24

u/where-is-satoshi May 30 '19

What I am seeing on the ground in North Queensland would be a chart with just a BCH line. No one in NQ even accepts other crypto-currencies as their volume is too low for merchants to consider.

5

u/goldMy May 30 '19 edited May 30 '19

How is it possible that the median transaction value is below $0.01 then.

With 60k transaction per day that would be a „sent in USD“ of just 600USD.

We know how a median value is calculated so we know that the majority of transactions are below the value of 0.01USD and the overall „Sent in USD“ is propped up by a view 1000transactions sending a shitload of money circulating through some wallets.

Edit: The median tx value on

BTC >100$

LTC >100$

DASH >30$

14

u/jessquit May 30 '19

How is it possible that the median transaction value is below $0.01 then.

The data includes stress tests and also BCH is used by services like memo.cash

you appear to be making the assumption that the data are not valid because they don't match some assumptions you hold

suppose that exchanges have begun using BCH for settlement. that would produce exactly the sort of data we're seeing and would be a perfectly valid use of the token

13

u/ShadowOfHarbringer May 30 '19

How is it possible that the median transaction value is below $0.01 then.

Because a chinese startup called "B1ITZ" or something is pushing massive amounts of price ticker data to the BCH blockchain because it's the only blockchain usable and cheap enough.

It was talked here a lot, it is not some kind of secret or anything.

0

u/Zarathustra_V May 30 '19

So the majority of those few daily txs are below $0.01

8

u/coin-master May 30 '19

Because "median" is not equal to "average"

-9

u/Trident1000 May 30 '19

Because large bch holders are systematically moving 43% of the supply per day in large value transactions to try and drive the mean value up. Other chains are around 5%, its a huge outlier and clear manipulation.

9

u/jessquit May 30 '19

Because large bch holders are systematically moving 43% of the supply per day in large value transactions to try and drive the mean value up.

That's your assumption.

Why? this seems like a terrible idea, you could lose a shit ton of money if your bot fails.

If you want to drive the mean value up using a bot, you'd send many medium sized transactions. this would risk far less money and also produce much more convincing data.

There's no real reason to fake data in the way we're observing: it's so cheap to send BCH transactions that there's no real savings involved in making fewer transactions.

1

u/ShadowOfHarbringer May 30 '19

Because large bch holders

Because you are a [Core Shill] who cannot be trusted and is trying to destroy this community.

0

u/Trident1000 May 30 '19

I'm stating fact here for debate. You don't need to personally attack me.

Actually at 35% today, slightly better than 43% yesterday. Still off the charts. BSV is doing the same tactic.

https://bitinfocharts.com/

3

u/mjh808 May 30 '19

Compare https://openmarketcap.com/ with coinmarketcap and you will see much less fake volume on BCH, that's what traders pay attention to.

0

u/ShadowOfHarbringer May 30 '19

You don't need to personally attack me.

Your mere presence in this sub is an attack on P2P Cash.

13

u/skuma_stronk May 30 '19

I mainly use BCH on my Bitpay cards to avoid the BTC fees which are usually 10$+

3

u/xenyz May 30 '19 edited May 30 '19

That bitpay screenshot from the AT&T post is the best advertisement for Bitcoin Cash I've ever seen

26

u/500239 May 30 '19

BCH has more transactions than LTC and Doge... waaaattt

/u/hernzzzz get on this and cherrypick a 4 hour chart to spin this thread around. We know you can do it.

13

u/fiah84 May 30 '19 edited May 30 '19

if we could only harness the energy from BTC trolls spinning arguments, we could solve the world energy crisis!

edit: or power infinite BCH miners. How's that for security!

10

u/500239 May 30 '19

Why wait, lets start now.

/u/hernzzzz Is buying coffee with Bitcoin an attack on Bitcoin, or have the fee's taken care of that problematic scenario?

9

u/bearjewpacabra May 30 '19

Denying reality is the worlds largest religion.

1

u/nomadismydj May 30 '19

is one address still responsible for ~50% of all transactions ?

11

u/jessquit May 30 '19

that application is/was creating many near-zero value txns so it wouldn't contribute to this chart. that's the point of measuring in usd equivalent transferred

3

u/Anen-o-me May 30 '19

So much for that theory.

5

u/UltraRik May 30 '19

Damn, then how did I pay for my beer yesterday?

2

u/sfultong May 30 '19

I'm just waiting for the number of OpenBazaar listings for bch to eclipse the number of btc listings.

2

u/doker0 May 30 '19

Why is bch more popular then eth? I feel eth is superior to bch

2

u/zeptochain May 31 '19

AT&T think I did. Good enough for me.

-3

u/Trident1000 May 30 '19

Fact. Half the BCH supply (about 43% as of recent) is moved each day by whales to drive the average value up even though the median is under a penny. Its a huge outlier. Most chains are around 5% of total supply moved per day.

10

u/ShadowOfHarbringer May 30 '19

is moved each day by whales to drive the average value up even though the median is under a penny

Hello, Shill.

The median is under a penny because an asian company called "B1ITZ" is using BCH blockchain to store massive amounts of price ticker data.

Why are they doing it? Because Bitcoin Cash Blockchain is the only Blockchain that is cheap and usable enough. And the BCH community is not going to call legitimate, fee-paying transactions "spam" like BTC or LTC communities.

-1

u/[deleted] May 30 '19 edited May 30 '19

Half the tx are near 0USD the other half of those 10kb blocks must be the residents of NQ buying coffee beans while measuring the amount by number of containerships. LOL

5

u/ShadowOfHarbringer May 30 '19

the restdents of NQ buying coffee beans while measuring the amount by number of containerships. LOL

Well at least they don't have to order an oil tanker to bring them coffee.

/s

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

Titles that bash BCH might be a good idea so that the the core minions will upvote without understanding the content as you would expect from them.

-5

u/fuck_you_dylan May 30 '19

Bitcoin cash will never be the real Btc

13

u/jessquit May 30 '19

I hope not, BTC is the ticker of the settlement version of Bitcoin

0

u/pietro_pete May 30 '19

Is that good it bad?

1

u/cryptoplane May 30 '19

it bad that is good me think

-2

u/[deleted] May 30 '19 edited May 31 '19

How come XRP wasn't compared?

Edit: Why would a few sensitive souls downvotes this comment, not for saying anything controversial or making a statement, but for merely asking a question?

Of the first 8 coins on the list, 7 are displayed and XRP was left out. I was just curious.

5

u/jessquit May 30 '19

doesn't show up on the chart when I include it

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

It's being used by companies. OP probably doesn't want word getting around that xrp has the most transactions.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

XRP is being used and has transactions, but I don't think it has the most.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

Non Google Amp link 1: here


I am a bot. Please send me a message if I am acting up. Click here to read more about why this bot exists.

-2

u/HyperTanquility May 30 '19

There is only one Bitcoin, it's worth 8k$ and the internet chose it as its currency.

-5

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

Now show the graph where it shows the different users using it over time and not just total usage stats.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

[deleted]

7

u/jessquit May 30 '19

If you show this not in USD but in transactions per day, the picture might look different.

We would need to exclude transaction processing tokens like ETH that churn a gazillion txns with no financial relevance

measuring in usd is a useful metric because it implies the transactions have financial weight