r/btc • u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator • May 23 '19
Last night's BCH & BTC meetups in Tokyo were both at the same restaurant (Two Dogs). We joined forces for this group photo!
12
u/sto7 May 23 '19 edited May 23 '19
I wish I'd known there was a Bitcoin Cash Meetup group. Now subscribed (Tokyo Bitcoin Cash Meetup)!
What Bitcoin group was the BTC one?
Update: found it, Tokyo Bictoin Hackers.
12
u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator May 23 '19
Are you in Tokyo? The meetup is every week on Wednesday, hope to see you there!
12
6
u/justinjustinian May 23 '19
This is beautiful! As a holder of both BCH and BTC with equal weight, I for once am very happy that people from both factions get along quite nicely :)
3
u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator May 23 '19
Yes, it was nice to see that for all the arguing online, we could still get together and have beers with one another. Saw some familiar faces there too!
17
u/reverseacid May 23 '19
This makes me weirdly happy. I feel like BTC and BCH can both succeed as they're meant for different people. BTC wants to be a global settlement layer and go the institutional route, good job. BCH wants to be cash for individuals to propel efficient remittance without using a centralised intermediary, good job. Probably will get downvoted to oblivion, but I genuinely think both networks will do well in what they're trying to advocate for.
18
u/moleccc May 23 '19
I feel like BTC and BCH can both succeed as they're meant for different people.
What can you find in BTC that you cannot also find in BCH, especially when hypothetically assuming BCH took the lead and had more hashrate / value?
BTC wants to be a global settlement layer and go the institutional route, good job.
that's not valuable in itself. Not good job.. it wont work and I guarantee it wont be used like this in any widespread manner.
1
u/dnick May 23 '19
The one thing neither of them can do is avoid centralization of the coding, so BTC will be stuck with BTC problems, and BCH will be stuck with BCH problems. Both of them diverge from the white paper, just for different reasons with different justifications. Basically it’s a type of centralization not addressed with the white paper, even though it addressed the 3 main limitations to cryptocurrency in general. I think BSV tries to do an endrun around the issue by not upgrading(?) but that’s not a solution either as there are definitely things that need to be addressed. They’ll still have the same issue of centralized development, just that if they don’t compete with software updates, it won’t be their team it centralizes around. Of course it doesn’t matter if no one cares about your fork.
This isn’t to say no one could compete with core or abc, it’s just that there isn’t a mechanism within Bitcoin to ensure that competition will be successful so it is a risk between a successful payoff or failure or a fork to go about making a competing client. Anyone could overtake either team in development, but if it isn’t even competition (both groups developing to the same goals) then at best you just get a different centralized team, not a balanced, competitive software system.
7
u/DaSpawn May 23 '19
BTC diverged from the white paper by declaring it is no longer cash and only to be used as a settlement layer for the LN, directly opposite the title of the design document and not even close to what it defines throughout
BCH is fulfilling the white paper that BTC used to follow, how do you believe BCH is diverging from the white paper?
your entire comment is a "there both broken just the same" and is the same garbage used in politics trying to say both parties are the same
0
u/dnick May 23 '19
Well I didn’t mean to say they’re both the same, just that they’re both broken in the same way...from a centralized development perspective.
BCH can be an absolutely ideal solution today, and an absolute shitshow tomorrow and it won’t depend on anything you say, it will depend solely on politics and fear and whatever the team ‘leader’ can convince enough people to suffer through to accomplish his purpose, same as BTC has/is suffering from. If you trust that leader not to do it, that’s fine, but recognize it as trust in the leadership, not as a trustless cash system the white paper describes. ‘Bitcoin’ as any particular invocation is trustless, but if you’re relying on one group to write the software and you’ll follow whatever thread they can convince 51% of miners to follow, then your following whatever politics they’re playing.
BCH, for example, implemented a protection against the attempted BSV takeover which conflicts with the white paper and prevents certain kinds of competition. You and the BCH team might consider it worthwhile, but that’s the problem with feature creep and whittling away at robustness...it can be justified from some angle and then it’s just there. Just a little bit harder for the next guy to compete with the centralized development team.
2
u/DaSpawn May 23 '19
what you consider feature creep is nothing of the sort, that is a network upgrade to the stability and security of the network. What part of that upgrade do you consider changes the functionality of the network itself if BSV (or any other attack vector) didn't exist?
There is multiple distributions/various dev teams and multiple miners all competing on the BCH network just like they used to in Bitcoin, that is not centralization, that is proper distributed competition/working properly. BTC has a single distro/dev team that ousted the original devs and took over the distro calling all the shots now
one is certainly nothing like the other, one is broken, one is working as it worked before the BTC distro got taken over and has continued progressing/upgrading just like Bitcoin always did (before the takover of course that halted any progress on Bitcoin itself and made themselves no longer Bitcoin by forcing that significant stagnating change the network)
0
u/dnick May 23 '19
‘Working just as it worked before the BTC distress got taken over’...and what is in place to prevent exactly the same thing. I’m not saying BCH is broken in the same subjective way as BTC, I’m saying it objectively has nothing inherent in the protocol to prevent the exact same thing happening.
And the ‘feature’ I’m referring to was a flag or config put in place to make it harder for BSV to operate or compete on the same chain. Basically, by being willing to do that to ‘protect’ the chain, they’ve made it that much harder for others to compete. Just because they are working with multiple DEV teams now doesn’t mean they have to and the fact that Ver and company were willing to divert funds from BTC to defend BCH was a perfect example of how the guy with the most toys wins...it was practically a matter of pride and bragging that ‘my side has more hash than yours so it’s going to win’ even when immediate financial motives (which are supposed to be the main protective mechanism of bitcoin in general) would have dictated mining BTC. It was more than obvious that neither side was achieving their hash rates based on merit, but simply a measure of how much money they could bring to bear.
Does that sound like something the whitepaper envisioned as a viable mechanism for an open source blockchain? Do you think people would have looked twice at bitcoin to begin with if the protocol and clients had been tweaked back in the early days if hash wars and little config traps were how it was developed?
2
u/DaSpawn May 23 '19
this has nothing to do with pride and bragging, BTC was compromised and BCH kept Bitcoin going as it always was working/upgrading. Upgrades to the network are to be expected if it is able to upgrade and adapt to network attacks
Bitcoin BTC has failed to upgrade the network to prevent the easiest most detrimental attack possible at this moment, a significant loss of hash power for any reason will grind the network to a halt, BCH does not suffer that fatal flaw which opened the door for the attack possibilities the upgrade solved but you think it is "preventing competition" even though it is doing nothing of the sort, it is only preventing attacks and all honest miners are on equal footing with the mining competition as Bitcoin was always designed
There is nothing variable about Bitcoin Cash, what are you on about? The network creates blocks to ensure blocks are created on average every 10 minutes as Bitcoin was always designed (and even BTC has variances of an hour very often). Bitcoin was "tweaked" many times before the dev team was compromised.
Bitcoin Cash is the continuation/upgrade of Bitcoin that always existed and expected from the beginning and all the social engineering in the world can not stop an idea whose time has come
1
u/dnick May 23 '19
Bitcoin was built on the (brilliant) concept that the inherent rewards built into the system could ensure a trustless system acting with its own self interest could maintain itself. It’s not profitable to sabotage the system because it’s more costly to overtake the system than its worth in profits. For example a 51% attack isn’t worth the cost because it’s expensive to get half of the hash power only to benefit from one or several double-spends/rollbacks, which would result in loss of trust, loss of value of the coin, and collapse of the blockchain (or some version of that). What the BCH/BSV showdown showed (and the BTC/BCH to a lesser degree) was that you can have people working against their own interests within the blockchain not for immediate incentives within the chain, but simply for control of the chain. It’s no longer a self correcting system, it obviously relies on people willing to lose money to maintain or obtain control. No ‘miner’ can do that, only huge consortiums or groups of miners can hope to sustain loss of profits in order to achieve that. Once consensus is based on groups large enough (centralized enough) to manage this, it’s basically outside anything the whitepaper was meant to address.
Think of it this way, what if Roger and Co. and CW had been on opposite sides and the massive hash power had been dumped into BSV? Would that have made that chain the right one? Technically, of course it would, but if you say ‘well,we’re just lucky that the hash was on the BCH side’, or that the BSV chain would have been fine as long as it was our side controlling it instead of CW, then you’ve basically demonstrated how centralized the control is. Of course there can be multiple DEV teams, as long as they’re not doing anything outside of what a dozen people at the top want them to do, or at least only stray so far, it’s in their interest to spread out the work. But come up with something they don’t like and it’s rally the troop and, if necessary, the money and we’ll see who wins.
2
u/DaSpawn May 23 '19
It’s not profitable to sabotage the system because it’s more costly to overtake the system than its worth in profits
your assuming people would only attack the system for profit, and honestly the attack that should be worried about (and is probably already happening) is the persons willing to piss away money to destroy Bitcoin
your other arguments all fall apart if you fail to take this into account
The chain that is "right" is the chain that works as the whitepaper calls for, a peer to peer cash, and if it is not used as cash it is not Bitcoin, plain and simple.
This also has nothing to do with the claim over a name, it has to do with the reality that a network that is not used is essentially useless and nothing but a ponzi scheme as it relies solely on the investment of others to bring gains and "maintain value"
The only Bitcoin that will survive is the network used for original purposes, as cash, all by itself. fiat "pegs" and vacations are absolutely meaningless in the long run and nothing but old school holding onto what they only know/understand. Bitcoin was born due to the certain nature of fiat failing as it always had throughout history
Bitcoin does not need fiat in any way, and if it has no use without fiat it is even more useless as cash and even more useless as a "store of value"
Your right Bitcoin is a brilliant idea, and it takes a lot of understanding to realize how it will fail/survive
→ More replies (0)2
May 24 '19
Dev team can be kicked out,
BCH dev team take the most risk by HF every 6 months, it is trivial to use a SF to kick them out.
In my mind that make the BCH dev team the most legitimate because it explicitly ask miner support every six months.
Edit: IMO the most dangerous thing is media centralisation...unavoidably leading to censorship and manipulation.
1
u/dnick May 24 '19
Well, 'asking for miner support' is working fine when all the miners are in agreement, but I'd hardly say it's trivial to kick them out based on the recent BSV attempt. Something that works when everyone agrees, but invokes the wrath of god and makes people willing to pull hash power from a more profitable chain just to keep control is hardly a trivial threat.
Granted the hash power was considered self defense against a similar threat, but how can you say you trust in the 'miners' when the first time someone brings on a large group of miners to vote, your response is to bring in even more miners to overrule their vote? Honestly, the fact that both groups were willing to mine at a loss to attempt control over the clients is the achilles heel of bitcoin in general.
1
May 25 '19
Well, ‘asking for miner support’ is working fine when all the miners are in agreement, but I’d hardly say it’s trivial to kick them out based on the recent BSV attempt.
Because CSW is an idiot, he went for a conflicting HF.
It was know from day that the chain chain will split apart.
If he released a conflicting SF, then it would have been a very different story.
He could have kick out the ABC team with no risk of split.
Something that works when everyone agrees, but invokes the wrath of god and makes people willing to pull hash power from a more profitable chain just to keep control is hardly a trivial threat.
That’s why I have so much respect for the ABC they are the only one to put their position at risk every six months for the good of BCH.
1
May 23 '19
The one thing neither of them can do is avoid centralization of the coding
Well actually, anyone can do soft forks if they want without splitting the network - at least if they have concensus among miners. You don't have to talk and agree with several teams to do some change, unlike with hard forks, where you have to get, not just the other team, but the whole community to run your code.
1
u/dnick May 23 '19
True, it can and has, especially in the early days, but human nature isn’t to take the logic cooperative route, especially when large rewards are available for going different routes and bitcoin, while brilliant in figuring out how to mitigate technical threats, isn’t any better than anything else at mitigating human nature. We’ll get multiple currencies and just like the internet, whoever happens to get the larger user base will determine what ‘kind’ of coin(s) we get, and the larger user base will be based on politics and money and fear as much as technical expertise.
1
May 23 '19
Glad theres someone here who shares this sentiment. You said that Satoshi didn't address this kind of dev centralization in the whitepaper - he probably didn't directly or on purpose, but he did at least write that "any new rules and incentives can be enforced by this concensus mechanism". Depending on how you interpret this, it could mean he's referring to soft forks when talking about new rules.
0
May 23 '19
[deleted]
3
u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator May 23 '19
How many altcoins have anywhere close to the same level of merchant acceptance, developer activity, and grassroots community that BCH has?
0
May 23 '19
[deleted]
1
u/BiggieBallsHodler May 23 '19
So first it was thousands. Now it's several. But you still won't name them.
2
u/JustSomeBadAdvice May 23 '19
BTC's network security comes exclusively from the price.
Price comes from adoption. (And hype feedback loops).
Adoption is leaving BTC for coins that work. Price will follow; Security will follow.
1
u/moleccc May 24 '19
What can you find in BCH that's not in thousands of other altcoins?
It's what I bought in 2011.
1
u/Tiblanc- May 23 '19
High value transactions require high PoW to secure which is equal to block reward. This is directly tied to transaction volume and coin value. If you split value between 2 coins, that affects block reward and lower PoW, which makes neither chain usable for high value transactions.
There's higher benefits in using a single chain since high value transactions attract a whole ecosystem of low value transactions that end up increasing coin demand and it creates a positive feedback loop.
-10
u/HoldBag May 23 '19
I'll never use BCH simply because it tries to confuse people into thinking it is BTC, and has even hijacked "BTC" as their subreddit.
I agree BTC is shooting itself in the foot and is no longer the future. It will have to be something else. Maybe BCH, but I hope not. If it had been named anything else I would have gladly come along.
Downvote and/delete all you like. It won't change it. Everything good about BCH is wasted by being in the service of what amounts to a shady bait and switch attempt.
27
u/onchainscaling May 23 '19 edited May 23 '19
Maybe if you understand that those that forked off to form BCH were part of BTC and simply want what was always the plan you would look at Bitcoin Cash more openly. When the 1MB limit was put in it was clearly stated that it was a temporary spam measure. Nothing more and nothing less. It was brought in as a soft fork knowing that taking it out would be a hard fork. A small group of people in the community proceeded to oppose doing such a hard fork because a) it could cause a split and users would not understand so it could cause loss of confidence and price loss which could kill bitcoin (yes this was the main argument at the time) and b) it was not needed because the limit was not reached. Unfortunately Satoshi who at the time was still in control, left before lifting the temporary limit.
Then as argument b) started to become invalid it was replaced by c) bigger blocks could cause miner centralisation - less security -failure of bitcoin d) doing a small increase would not solve c) long term and create expectations of blocksize increases and e) a number of other fear mongering arguments that opposed ever hard forking that were invented as goal posts were moved.
As the currency grew lots of new people came in who were unaware of the initial goals and roadmap (lift the limit and allow the system to grow) and they were unaware that BTC had in its early days hard forked. The “no fork” movement grew, lead by the “1MB for ever” devs who had climbed up to positions of power and influence.
Those that knew LN would prove a disaster, knew how fees would spiral out of control and saw how some were lying to users to push through their plans (no-forkers said at the time to not worry as fees would stay under 20 cents as LN would take over trafic as it would be ready for use in a few months -summer 2016), were at some point left with two options, leave the project they had helped make a success or split the project in two branches allowing each group to pursue its goals. Some left and some chose the second option.
As those that branched off in Bitcoin Cash intended to pursue the initial goals as laid out in the whitepaper and discussed in the early years and a substantial group had even been part of those discussions it is entirely fair that they did not give up on the name of the project and some of its branding characteristics. Why on earth would they. That brand as many call it was built by them also. Why would one side of the divorce be required to walk away without anything. The beauty of Bitcoin the concept as laid out in the whitepaper, is that it CAN fork. That way it will always be able to continue. Even if a group of developers take it down a path that leads to it being deformed into something it was set out to oppose. Bitcoin Cash chose another path. An alternative reality. The “what if we had decided to turn right at that crossroad”.
Calling Bitcoin Cash a scam was the BTC side of thing trying to keep it all as they feared Bitcoin Cash would long term convince users and take them away. If you believe you have a better product you should not fear competition. The scam accusations and negative campaigns against Bitcoin Cash should give you a clue. They do not want you to have choice. They fear when you look at Bitcoin Cash without prejudice you will see what it is and realize it has a better chance of succeeding reaching the original goals of peer to peer digital cash for the ENTIRE global population. My position is that you should be free to chose the roadmap you think has most potential. In fact, those that did not want to chose did not have to. They had coins on both chains. Two versions of the future being tested. Time and the market will decide and over time lies will be uncovered as truth always finds it way out from under those that try to keep it hidden.
Edit: as for the sub: this is where those that wanted Bitcoin to go this direction found each other as voices opposing keeping the limit were all banned from the Bitcoin subreddit. This became our place. The split came later. We did not claim the ticker for the coin but there is no reason we would move out of this property even though it carries the ticker of the other branche as name . No reason at all.
8
u/BitcoinCashKing May 23 '19
I am always amazed to find such lengthy and elegant responses so deep in a downvoted thread. Great work.
4
4
u/jonald_fyookball Electron Cash Wallet Developer May 23 '19
I'll never use BCH simply because it tries to confuse people into thinking it is BTC
BCH is a decentralized protocol. It doesn't "try to confuse" anyone. You can argue that individual people are trying to confuse other people. But even that is a wild claim. BCH is BCH. BTC is BTC.
0
May 23 '19
When I knew nothing about bitcoin and went to Bitcoin.com figuring to possibly buy some... I was confused as fuck. “Says I can buy bitcoin (bch) but why is the price so low?” Then further down the line, “what’s bitcoin cash it can’t be the same thing... I thought litecoin was the fast alternative,” It’s not at all a wild claim to say that some people were/are confused. Not by a long shot. I like the idea of bch and I support it for various reasons, but I’m not sure I’m the norm. I feel like a lot of people in my shoes might have just been irritated and either moved on from crypto entirely or just found an exchange to buy some btc.
3
u/BiggieBallsHodler May 23 '19
Sounds like you don't understand Bitcoin. BCH is Bitcoin.
0
May 23 '19
Yeah. Seems like you don’t understand human psychology. People often don’t like being misled.
0
u/HoldBag May 24 '19
You know exactly what I mean. And you know that you're posting this in /r/btc, which is the BCH subreddit.
1
u/jonald_fyookball Electron Cash Wallet Developer May 24 '19
I know what you mean, but its mostly nonsense. Every idiot that goes to CMC knows that there's 2 different coins, BTC and BCH... i mean come on. If that's your best argument against BCH, ..shrug
-2
u/chazley May 23 '19
I wish that was the sentiment of this subreddit, instead it's mostly just hating on Bitcoin in favor of trying (unsuccessfully based on Bitcoin/BCH exchange rate 85% price drop since January 2018's ATH) to advocate for BCH.
Bitcoin and BCH both have their niche they can be successful in. Stop worrying about Bitcoin.
When Bitcoin does well historically, smaller altcoins typically see their price raise even further percentage-wise than Bitcoin, including BCH.
9
4
1
3
3
3
u/enobyte May 23 '19
The man in the bottom right corner with the dark red shirt on is exactly what I imagine Satoshi Nakamoto looks like.
2
2
2
2
3
2
u/ilovebkk May 23 '19
What’s up with the right eye on the guy in the red shirt? Zoom in. I’m confused
2
1
u/lucchase May 24 '19
BTC group would have been talking about the weather... I.e. The lack of Lightning 👅
0
u/Alexpander May 23 '19
Were btc paying with credit cards? They were probably talking about how they hodled through the bearmarket.
0
-10
u/xGsGt May 23 '19
So basically you just upload a post of two group of crypto enthusiasts just to talk bad about the btc guys to get some brownie points with this sub reddit? Lol this is next level low
0
u/HoldBag May 24 '19
Yup. Compete lack of honesty and absence of self awareness that can only be deliberate. You're in /r/btc and you really can't figure out my point? Really? You can't even admit even to yourself why you are in /btc right now and not /bch?
That's the slimy, fishy behavior that makes the project a nonstarter. And no amount of down votes will change it. The whole group of BCH mooners chases away legitimate support with that scummy rigamarole. If you honestly can't see it then please understand that everyone else can.
-2
0
0
May 23 '19
[deleted]
23
u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator May 23 '19 edited May 23 '19
Half of the people in this photo are Japanese
edit: he deleted his post but he said it wasn't in Japan because he didn't see any Japanese people in the photo
11
May 23 '19
He's right to be embarassed. It took all of 5 seconds to find the venues website - https://www.twodogs-tokyo.com/
2
u/ericisshort May 23 '19
It is a larger percentage of white people than I expected from a meetup in Japan, so maybe it was just poorly worded hyperbole.
3
May 23 '19
Its someone going from the 1st to the 2nd stage of grief :)
People trying hard to find reasons for why other people are wrong, just so they can avoid facing the possibility that they themselves are mistaken.
159
u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator May 23 '19
At the end of the night, the restaurant staff told me that not a single person from the BTC meetup paid with cryptocurrency, only cash and card sales were made. Nearly all of the sales from the BCH meetup downstairs were made in BCH.