26
u/Cryosanth May 18 '19
In 1995 Robert Metcalfe, the inventor of the internet predicted that the internet couldn't scale and would collapse by 1996. Sometimes even brilliant people can be spectacularly wrong.
7
u/roybadami May 18 '19 edited May 18 '19
Robert Metcalfe is the inventor of ethernet; not sure I'd say he was the inventor of the Internet.
The growth of the backbone routing tables in the late 90's was a big problem, and yes, we came close to the limits (mainly RAM) of the hardware that was widely deployed. But this was averted by a combination of changes to the way address space was managed and, of course, improvements in hardware - and the growing populatity of the Internet, which made it commercially viable to deploy new hardware.
EDIT: I've no idea though whether Robert Metcalf declared that the end of the Internet was nigh, but he may well have done. Such concerns were frequently raised in that era (and indeed, had no action been taken, the predictions would probably have come to pass).
1
u/Cryosanth May 19 '19
Sorry, yes should've said Ethernet, not Internet, was quoting from an article I'd found, but obviously there is no single inventor of the internet.
16
May 18 '19
Exactly, every new tech future potential is completly unpredictable, restricting it because "it can't scale" is ridiculous..
In what world we would be living if aviation would have been restricted in its first decades? same for internet?
-14
u/lkasjhdk May 18 '19
The internet was restricted for decades and still is. I don't recall getting 200 phone lines installed to my house in the early 90s to get 200x58k bandwidth and I'm in the same position today.
Bitcoin is a POW driven, decentralized consensus network on top of a gossip protocol. There are real world engineering limitations and trade-offs involved and no amount of illiterate hand waving will make those go away.
12
May 18 '19
The internet was restricted for decades and still is. I don’t recall getting 200 phone lines installed to my house in the early 90s to get 200x58k bandwidth and I’m in the same position today.
Limited by tech, not by an arbitrary low limit.
Bitcoin is a POW driven, decentralized consensus network on top of a gossip protocol. There are real world engineering limitations and trade-offs involved and no amount of illiterate hand waving will make those go away.
I agree.
I also agree that the PoW technical limitations are above 1MB and can be improved by increment in the future..
Like internet did in the past.
(Also second layer have limitations too, somehow that it seems to never quite enter the debate)
1
3
May 18 '19
Joe Rogan had a t1 connection in the 90's so he could play quake without lag. Not the best analogy
-2
u/lkasjhdk May 18 '19
I guess Joe Rogan could have run a one man "decentralized" Bitcoin network then too!
1
8
3
13
u/kristoffernolgren May 18 '19
It's kind of funny. I'm not saying it's wrong, it' actually a pretty good way to scale fast, but this picture represents a hardware approach. Just throw more iron at the problem. Kind of what bch does.
7
u/junseth May 18 '19 edited May 18 '19
Correct. The humor of this picture is that it is an image of something that doesn't scale. This is what a world with electricity using DC would look like. Edison was pushing this approach. Tesla pushed for AC. It scaled nicely. Bitcoin is the ac of blockchains. It scales by pushing most of the congestion problem into a second layer. Sort of like AC pushes the wire congestion into sub stations. Additionally, AC pushes the wire congestion problem into the home where much of the AC power is converted to DC (ever wonder why your computer has that giant box between it and the plug?). Bitcoin cash looks like the picture above. It's infrastructure doesn't scale. The network itself takes on the burden of bigger blocks. The humor to me is in the fact that people here are too stupid to see the irony in explaining their position with memes that negate their position.
3
u/robbak May 19 '19
By the way, these are telephone cables, not power cables.
-core's solution to this is legislating that there cannot be more than 10,000 telephones, and refusing to adjust that number. If more people need to communciate, then the persons who have phones can take messages for all the other.
-cash's option is to let it grow as it needs to, while seeking out ways to make it work at greater scale. All options for making it grow are on the table. Including taking notes for people that don't have phones.
3
u/junseth May 19 '19
Core is simply 1 implementation. What you refer to as "core" is actually just general consensus. You guys enacted an act that was outside of the status quo. You forked off. Core did nothing to stop you. Neither did the rest of Bitcoin.
Cash's option is unneccessary considering that the chain is largely disused. On average, Bitcoin's blocks are 30x larger than your blocks. So sure, you have made way for the chain to grow as large as it wants. But it seems that no one is using it.
1
May 19 '19
Exactly.. Both are different implementations of Bitcoin. I wish there wasn't all of this infighting.
2
u/spukkin May 19 '19
bch devs are actually upgrading the software to make better use of existing hardware, so you're actually totally wrong.
2
u/SpiritofJames May 18 '19
"More iron" where there is a dearth of it, not a surplus like this image. Stop being disingenuous. After all, it's BTC who wants every person to use their Raspberry Pis to run full nodes. If anything, their harebrained schemes resemble this far more than BCH.
1
u/IWasABitcoinNoobToo May 18 '19
But this image doesn't have a surplus of lines. That's how many lines that were actually needed at the time.
1
u/SpiritofJames May 18 '19
It's a surplus for this pole and this area.
1
u/IWasABitcoinNoobToo May 21 '19
So you're saying that the town, or telephone company, whoever paid for all of those lines, deliberately spent more money than they needed to?
1
u/SpiritofJames May 21 '19
No I'm saying that this is far from optimal load for a single pole.
1
u/IWasABitcoinNoobToo May 21 '19
Why, though? What's the incentive? Each of those lines is an expense. A surplus of lines means a surplus of expenses. What's the incentive for the phone company to spend the time and money to install unnecessary lines?
2
u/mantiss87 May 18 '19
Hate to be the lineman working on that grid.
4
u/MrTreborn May 18 '19
Looks pretty well mate, I saw server rooms where all cables were tangled.
-1
u/mantiss87 May 18 '19
Thats different those low voltage wires cant kill you. How do you work on the top lines without a bucket truck in those days, shut the whole city down?
3
5
u/lkasjhdk May 18 '19
Perfect illustration of BCH's scaling plans.
8
0
May 18 '19
Self gilded trolling is perfect illustration of how retarded your average buttcoiner is
-1
u/lkasjhdk May 18 '19
I use Bitcoin. You are the buttcoiner.
-1
May 18 '19
lol use it to what, hold? Eat shit troll
-2
u/lkasjhdk May 18 '19
So butt hurt. But I get it. I'd be butt hurt too if I bought into Ver's cringetastic bimbo, lambo and flippening propaganda in 2017.
5
u/spukkin May 19 '19
a lot of people here supported BCH before Ver did, but go ahead and roll thru your prepared talking points in lieu of an actual argument.
1
May 18 '19
Yeah I am so butthurt that I no longer associate with a shitcoin that gets slow and expensive when anyone bothers to move their BTC, who has fucktard cheerleaders like yourself for a "community".
Seems you're the butthurt one to come here and spread your bullshit daily. Sell your BCH at the bottom or are you just a sad wanker?
-6
2
May 18 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
May 20 '19
Thanks dad
1
May 21 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
May 21 '19
Im sorry you seem to think I asked you for your self-righteous bullshit opinion, I didn't, so fuck off
0
May 21 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
May 21 '19
Im not working for anyone trolling, I just don't like being told what to do by self-righteous SJWs like you. The banks don't give a fuck about your "be nice to everyone" campaign, get real
0
2
u/FUBAR-BDHR May 18 '19
Can't believe no one has said this yet but the pic looks like a visualization of LN. Centralized pole and all those wires.
1
u/djpeen May 18 '19
Is that a telephone or electricity network?
I mean they both scale by using centralised hubs no?
0
May 18 '19
[deleted]
1
u/Mr_Again May 18 '19
Telegraph
0
May 19 '19
[deleted]
1
u/Mr_Again May 19 '19
There are no residential buildings in this picture, it looks like main street. This is Pratt, Kansas, it's at the bottom of this article. https://io9.gizmodo.com/photos-from-the-days-when-thousands-of-cables-crowded-t-1629961917. Telegraph poles were common then, they moved underground or were phased out with radio.
0
1
1
u/Mr_Again May 18 '19
Those are telegraph cables. They were replaced by radio. It's bitcoin supposed to be telegraph in this analogy?
1
1
1
1
1
u/subinkp Redditor for less than 30 days Jun 08 '19
In 2021 blockchain technique will reach everyone.Opennity have good future in this technology.https://www.opennity.com/en
1
u/youcallthatabigblock Redditor for less than 60 days May 19 '19
The Lightning network is actually the new technology and r/btc says it can't possibly scale
2
-1
u/Vincents_keyboard May 18 '19
Speaking of new technology.
The first Berlin BSV hackathon is underway -->
0
12
May 18 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
14
u/5400123 May 18 '19
I worked in telecommunications for awhile. The most amazing thing is that all this “high tech” stuff when it comes down to the raw physical components are just copper wires with pin connectors, to state it very simply. Always blew my mind to be installing some high band antenna/dish and looking at the raw parts, you’d think you were just banging rocks together or doing plumbing or something. Mathematics/the unseen forces of nature are truly astounding.
Like a sub station ... just a bunch of coils and wires, but the functions they are performing on the electricity takes a masters degree to really understand.
6
May 18 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/mayoayox May 18 '19
Pardon my ignorance, but in contrast to analog, what makes digital tech more than just "copper wires"?
3
6
May 18 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/horsebadlydrawn May 18 '19
Digital is less accurate than analog, but also contains less noise. Strange paradox
3
u/roybadami May 18 '19
Digital is more accurate but potentially, given the right assumptions, less precise.
3
u/horsebadlydrawn May 19 '19
Digital always approximates a curve to an arbitrary degree (interpolation)
Analog mimcs the curve with greater accuracy because it's round
1
u/mayoayox May 27 '19
This bothers me the most with FM stereos. I can deal with digital volume but I need an analog tuner to tune into just the right frequency
68
u/masterD3v May 18 '19
You mean to say that global networks and hardware can actually handle more than one FLOPPY DISK every 10 minutes?
Blasphemy. You’re auto-banned from r/bitcoin!