r/TwoBestFriendsPlay • • May 13 '19

George R. R. Martin taking notes while looking at the final episodes of Game of Thrones.

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

444

u/Tython199 May 13 '19

I really hope that it’s true the other books are done already and he’s just using the show as a real time method to see audience reaction before he does rewrites. It would simultaneously be one of the biggest asshole and hilariously awesome moves in history.

189

u/Sean-Benn_Must-die infected with COCKBIG-19 May 13 '19

Could the madman have done it? Use the biggest show as a marketing strat to sell his books?

287

u/Heraclitus94 PM ME NUDES OF YOUR WAIFU May 13 '19

GAME OF THRONES WAS JUST AN ANIME TO SELL THE MANGAS THE WHOLE TIME!

117

u/ShadSilvs2000 ZERO TWO IS A SHIT WAIFU May 13 '19

Anime-exclusive arcs never turn out well

52

u/SuperUnhappyman Read DMC5: Visions of V May 13 '19

tell that to the g-8 arc in one piece

5

u/Overcharger Lighthearted Post Apocalypse May 14 '19

So good Oda made it canon!

1

u/SuperUnhappyman Read DMC5: Visions of V May 14 '19

he did?

1

u/Overcharger Lighthearted Post Apocalypse May 14 '19

The manga has a bunch of references to Vice Admiral Jonathan. His subordinates even show up at the Marineford war.

31

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

While less an "arc" than literally an entire story, the 2003 Fullmetal Alchemist is a spectacular example of how to use the framework of a preexisting manga to tell a completely different story.

15

u/pareidolist May 14 '19

2003 FMA had some great parts to it, but it definitely didn't turn out well. The main antagonist turned out to be a centuries-old war criminal in a teenager's body obsessed with marrying the protagonist. The finale was derailed by sending the characters to WWI London.

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '19

Hard disagree there, chief. I think the last quarter of the 2003 anime is its strongest part, the ending included.

Aside from the fact you didn't really explain the "why" of how anything you just described is indicative of the show "not turning out well", your assessment of the main villain is completely incorrect. Dante was totally down to bone Ed, but that was more of a side-gig to fuck with Hohenheim. He primary objective was to simply prolong her own life virtually indefinitely.

Lastly, you say that the show was "derailed" with the other side of the gate leading to earth, but I don't see how. It was heavily foreshadowed and built up as early as the halfway point in the series, so it absolutely doesn't just come up out of nowhere to steal the ending away.

Honestly people don't give FMA 2003 enough credit. It's like people watch it, barely paying attention, then get to the end of episode 51 and go "IT WASN'T THE MANGA AND THE ENDING IZ DUM." and call it a day. There's so much to dig into regarding the story and the themes and it's incredibly frustrating that it's as overlooked as it is. But I guess people would rather watch the anime that ends with Ed punching the evil badguy in the face and getting a deus ex machina reward.

12

u/Stranghill May 14 '19

I didn't know anything about the Manga or brotherhood when I watched the 2003 anime.

That ending was flip flopping ridiculous. It was a punchline. It's like hoping Kratos got sent to modern day. That show unraveled as it went on, Manga notwithstanding. Brotherhood ending isn't perfect either, but it's consistent with the rest of the show.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '19

If you could give some examples or explain why then I might agree with you. But just saying "it's ridiculous" doesn't help at all.

I guarantee whatever issues you have are based entirely in your own personal distaste for the ideas in the anime rather than how they were done.

3

u/Brahmus168 May 14 '19

I’m with you man. I just finished rewatching the 2003 version and aside from the pacing being ratcheted up a bit towards the end it was great.

172

u/alexandrecau That's Bricks! May 13 '19

and even more important, it means the book are finished

56

u/Dundore77 May 13 '19

Hes not doing rewrites. D&D rewrote his stuff. They all but said this during those interviews. Even basing off before they ran out of published source material the show was going a different direction.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

[deleted]

36

u/ImnotfamousAMA FFT Shill May 13 '19

My number one thing would be switching the Cersei/Night King order stuff. Having it all sorted in the first major battle really makes them seem like a minor threat rather than the world ending shit they really are

39

u/SirRosstopher The Ghost of Saint Laurent May 13 '19

The Night King is a show invention, probably using some of Eurons hype shit from the book such as the horn that can control a dragon, and Valyrian Steel armour which could tank dragonfire.

GRRM has said that he hates when villains are evil for the sake of evil, the Walkers in the books have their own language and culture.

The Long Night in the books is gonna be at least two books, rather than a few episodes, judging from the titles The Winds of Winter and A Dream of Spring.

Cercei probably isn't even on the throne at this point anyways, in the books she's just a drunk that thinks shes smarter than she is.

Honestly, even if the story is 90% the same in the books it will feel better because the detail will be there to give the plot points the time they need.

17

u/valdrinemini Disappointed May 13 '19

the Cersei/Night King order stuff.

I thought for sure after season 6 ended, that 7 was going to focus on cersi while 8 would have tied up the WW/AOTD plotline. At least that's what they should have done.

12

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

You see, DB and DW subverted your expectations, genius

16

u/GyroGOGOZeppeli hopes the Tomba series comes back May 13 '19

Honestly, the last line Euron has in the show would feel more earned and satisfying if he actually had a character arc or motivation rather than just being Fratboy Bam Margera.

17

u/TrumpKingsly May 13 '19

That would be awesome, but I seriously doubt he plans on finishing the books. Isn't he on record telling someone that, if they want to know how it ends, they should watch the TV show?

He seems like a guy who's made his money and wants to be done.

And that will be sad, if true. It's groan-inducing when TV and movies rip their ideas from literature. It's actually upsetting when TV and movies kill literature in progress. Because literature only needs one writer, it's the only form of entertainment that represents pure, unique perspectives on life. Movies, TV shows, games, are all Frankensteins-by-committee. Novels are singular visions.

40

u/Tython199 May 13 '19

That particular comment I believe was made during one of the many interviews where he was pissed about fans rushing him so I took it more as “if they want to know how it ends so bad, watch the show since it’ll end first” instead of him saying he wouldn’t finish it. That said, I also wouldn’t be shocked if he didn’t finish them purely out of spite now.

11

u/TheRainTransmorphed May 13 '19

I know what you mean, but books have editors and in some cases they make lots of changes. Sometimes good, other times bad and pretty similar to studio interference. Specially with big names it's not as simple as the author writes what s/he wants and it's published as it is.

-7

u/TrumpKingsly May 13 '19 edited May 14 '19

I'll take the perspective of author + editor over the perspectives of writers + actors + director + film crew + casting + producers any day :)

We're talking two people (one of whom thinks they're in marketing) and the risk of the author's time vs hundreds of people and the risk of hundreds of millions of dollars.

EDIT: Why is this comment making people unhappy? Film fans don't think films are made by committee? Editors who think editors really are marketers? People who hate emojis?

5

u/polo5004 Ah, a fellow poet of shitposts. Let us trade verse. May 14 '19

Implying less people = good

2

u/TrumpKingsly May 14 '19

When it comes to expressing a unique perspective, I'm asserting it. Not implying it. When anything is designed by a large group of people, it ends up reflecting what they all have in common. The more people, the more commonalities have to be expressed.

The perspective that shines through at the end will reflect what those many people have in common, not the unique perspective of an individual. And in my experience, individual perspectives are more often surprising and enlightening than group perspectives are. You lose a lot of detail in what the group have in common with one another. Weird ideas come from individuals, on the other hand.

1

u/polo5004 Ah, a fellow poet of shitposts. Let us trade verse. May 14 '19

That's your totally subjective and personal opinion. Mediocre normie garbage made by execs actually sucks just as much as some weirdo hamfisting his shitty viewpoints and expecting to be lauded for it.

4

u/SidewaysInfinity May 14 '19

So everything sucks? Wow you're so mature and smart!

3

u/polo5004 Ah, a fellow poet of shitposts. Let us trade verse. May 14 '19

It's more like "there's no real one-size-fits-all solution for storytelling" but on hindsight I worded it wrong.

0

u/bizarre-strange-odd May 14 '19

Are you denying that mediocre normie garbage sucks?

5

u/SignalWeakening Scholar of the First 900 ° May 13 '19

As long as its better than the show I dont care

2

u/hyperfell May 13 '19

Wasn’t that how was full metal alchemist was done?

2

u/SidewaysInfinity May 14 '19

No, the anime just outpaced the manga

1

u/N0VAZER0 May 14 '19

don't worry, they're not

1

u/Skellingto May 14 '19

A smart man would take the bad reaction to the show as an opportunity to rewrite the book to be more satisfying to the audience.

A true man would take it as a challenge to make the book much, much worse.

80

u/SailorSenshiDarkSun r/TwoBestFriendsPlay your second best source for most things May 13 '19

Last I checked about GRRM, he seems to have a track record of endings that don't land, or were at least unsatisfying in his previous works.

Hope that's changed, it would suck to disappoint the fans a second time

30

u/NewWillinium Local CRPG Freak-Beast He/Him May 13 '19

. . . Looking back at Tuf Voyaging you do have a bit of a point there regarding his endings.

11

u/torke191 NO GODS OR KINGS, ONLY SSAPO May 13 '19

What kind of ending was it?

27

u/RunningScotsman Umbrella turned my niece into an anime princess May 13 '19

One where the protagonist genophages a planet with a super-powerful bio-warfare ship and a woman decides that therefore he must be God.

If memory serves.

3

u/Sean-Benn_Must-die infected with COCKBIG-19 May 14 '19

Pat and paige? I guess he would have to genophage a toilet tho

142

u/lassengan May 13 '19

We only need to george RR martin to finish the manga so we can get game of thrones brotherhood

87

u/Th3SmartAlec I guess I'm a F/SN shill now May 13 '19

game of thrones brotherhood

Holy shit could you imagine if that was the long con?

35

u/MutatedMutton '0' days without dick jokes and staying there May 13 '19

"whats that? Didn't like the last season? Well, better keep that HBO subscription!"

4

u/Bman8444 Drop Your Shield May 14 '19

I would pay...

30

u/AHyperParko Flawless Style Beast May 13 '19

Honestly, I could totally see an animated adaptation of the books like a decade from now doing really well. Especially if they were more faithful to the books and actually had all of them to adapt.

26

u/derolme May 13 '19

All of the books

In a decade

Pick one :(

1

u/choptup Quadrilogy's not a word! May 14 '19

If they're gonna do it animated, they HAVE to do it in the style of the Japanese book covers.

9

u/SailorSenshiDarkSun r/TwoBestFriendsPlay your second best source for most things May 14 '19

Game of Thrones Brotherhood animated by studio Bones.

Now with characters accurate to their book ages

4

u/infamousoni MAMORU May 14 '19

GoT: Shippuden

Gotta get your GRRM-flavored Boruto’s in there!

1

u/kel811 May 15 '19

Or End of Game of Thrones

1

u/lassengan May 15 '19

Game of thrones 3.0+1.0 you cannot drag(on)

42

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Nah he's gonna pull a Super Kami Guru from DBZA and be like "Sure would be a dick move if I died right now.....Ugh my heart."

1

u/pockpicketG May 14 '19

Naaiiillll!

84

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

No. Don't do this.

21

u/Th3SmartAlec I guess I'm a F/SN shill now May 13 '19

What's the context of the picture (I mean in terms of DBZ)?

12

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Cell saga I think?

9

u/Th3SmartAlec I guess I'm a F/SN shill now May 13 '19

No, I mean is it just supposed to be Vegeta looking smug? I get the GOT debacle going on but I'm looking for how the picture connects.

40

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Yes. Hes going into the hyperbolic time chamber to get stronger. He has this shit eating grin cuz he thinks he'll be able to beat kakarot.

15

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Hyperchronic lion tamer

11

u/SignalWeakening Scholar of the First 900 ° May 13 '19

Hydrochloric ladder climber

8

u/[deleted] May 14 '19

Hypersulfic Child Kramer

7

u/Th3SmartAlec I guess I'm a F/SN shill now May 13 '19

Ah got it, thanks.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

You're welcome :)

5

u/Blackraptor00 May 13 '19

But it didn't even matter tho.

9

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

All he did was throw one ki blast at Cell.

3

u/DylanTheVillian1 Desperately Wants Kamiya's Royal Release May 14 '19

It did until Vegeta thought he had bigger dick energy than he actually had and Trunks thought he had any amount of big dick energy.

45

u/xx-shalo-xx They took my wife in the divorce May 13 '19

The guy said he doesn't watch the show anymore, he knows! Get that money.

32

u/Metalwater8 Ginger Seeking Butt Chomps May 13 '19

I can respect that level of hustle tho

18

u/ragmondead May 13 '19

I actually think it makes sense to not release his book as the show is still releasing and have two separate on going canons.

35

u/GoneRampant1 WOKE UP TO JUSTICE... and insatiable bug fetishes May 13 '19

Actually, I know a few people on /r/Fantasy were talking about this and a lot of bookstore owners are pissed that Martin never released a book while GoT was running. Compared to Harry Potter where they could have midnight openings and push tons of copies out thanks to the hype factor of the movies, they were never really able to do that for ASOIAF.

4

u/SirRosstopher The Ghost of Saint Laurent May 13 '19

It wouldn't surprise me if that was part of his HBO contract.

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Just do the opposite of all this

6

u/SabotTheCat May 14 '19

With all the talk about "GoT has gone to shit," there's been a thread on twitter that has been making its rounds that I feel explains a lot if true.

tldr; GRRM starts his writing with characters and builds most of the world/plot around "how would these characters respond to x situation" and building from there. This builds well fleshed out characters, but often leaves the larger plot meandering. D&D, especially after going past the book contents, have been primarily focused on trying to build towards a conclusive ending that ties up as many loose ends as possible. This results in what is essentially whiplash whereby characters who previously were off doing their own self-motivated stories in the world have to be redirected towards events that will bring about the end/closure. This often employs plot contrivances that, in most other stories, would probably be overlooked, but here instead are laid bare in stark contrast to the previous, more organic precedent.

6

u/Northensnow May 14 '19

I said it before (to other people) and I'll say it again. You have no idea what you're talking about.

If there's one thing this TV show proved once and for all is that "what" happens doesn't matter as much as "how" and "why" it happens. The books understand this, the TV show doesn't. You can boil everything down to bare plot points and say that the show is "exactly like the books", but the truth of the matter is that the books provide a context and have consequences that the show doesn't. You can take the basic events of the show and make them work, except for a few that are so completely absurd and unfitting that only the biggest of hacks would consider implementing them.

What you're saying is like suggesting that Miura is probably taking notes about the artstyle of the godawful CGI movies to avoid pitfalls he already soars miles above.

10

u/choptup Quadrilogy's not a word! May 13 '19

Had this theory going for years.

5

u/A_Feathered_Raptor Woolie in the Atomic Purple House May 13 '19

Props to Grum for the most elaborate and expensive book promotion ever

4

u/red_tuna Master of Salt and Iron May 13 '19

Mondo cool

3

u/Blackraptor00 May 13 '19

This is a terrible metaphor. Vegeta letting Semi-Perfect Cell absorb 18 is like GRRM letting the show finish on their terms.

Then he's going to job and JK Rowling and her kid need to swoop in and actually finish the fight.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '19

Leaked scene from the next Game of Thrones episode.

Okay not really but it'll probably basically be that.

2

u/attikol Poor Biscuit Hammer Anime/Play Library of Ruina May 14 '19

I love how dumb that picture is

7

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Title2ImageBot May 13 '19

Image with added title


Summon me with /u/title2imagebot or by PMing me a post with "parse" as the subject. | ^About | ^feedback | ^source | Fork of TitleToImageBot