r/btc • • May 04 '19

Craig Wright Ordered to Produce a List of Early Bitcoin Addresses in Kleiman Lawsuit

https://news.bitcoin.com/craig-wright-ordered-to-produce-a-list-of-early-bitcoin-addresses-in-kleiman-lawsuit/
189 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

35

u/KosinusBCH May 04 '19

Personally, I'm excited to add another document to https://github.com/kosinusbch/cult-of-craig

0

u/TwatoshiSuckafucko May 05 '19

Something something unhatched chickens.

48

u/earthmoonsun May 04 '19

Looks like the fraud will be busy to forge some documents these days. Can't wait to see how he gets caught gain. Lol.

25

u/goldMy May 04 '19

He is probably prepared for that ?

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5124203.0

4

u/TheLepos May 04 '19

It's the verified to be faketoshi? Or are we speculating here?

14

u/goldMy May 04 '19

Of course its speculation, we do not know whos behind the several buy requests that started to appear early this year.

But if CSW provides prove to the court, this things can and need to be double-checked.

7

u/TheLepos May 04 '19

Makes sense, wasn't sure if he's outed himself using that account or not. It seems unlikely for someone to make that kind of request with those exact clauses for any other reason other than, "I can show I have a wallet from these dates", as having a wallet that old doesn't provide any extra utility, obviously.

13

u/palacechalice May 04 '19

There's an argument to be made that anybody interested in laundering money might have made that post, but the "2008 - 2010 inclusive" stipulation really puts Craig at the top of the list of candidates.

There's just so few reasons I can imagine to have that stipulation beyond trying to impersonate Satoshi. As a whole, it seems like a very peculiarly crafted set of requirements that mesh very well with Craig's desperate needs versus the needs of another trickster. In most contexts, I could imagine it being counterproductive for a launderer since they would open themselves up to more trouble by not paying taxes for the BTC they claim they had. Also, I found it interesting that the user gets extremely defensive when people start accusing him of being Craig.

IMO, I think Craig or somebody playing coy games trying to embarrass Craig (as if he doesn't do a good job of doing that by himself) are at least as likely as any other explanation.

4

u/TheLepos May 04 '19

That certainly seems to be a legitimate observation, I'm thinking the same here...

4

u/meetinnovatorsadrian May 05 '19

Hopefully some people sold him some wallets and will demonstrate it to the public when the time is right.

4

u/kilrcola May 05 '19

Good way to set up a trap.

3

u/kilrcola May 05 '19

Simple psychology tells me if that people thought it was Craig and wasn't Craig, it would be whoever's account's best interest to let people think it is ACTUALLY Craig...

By going and posting.. Not CSW, that sets off warning signals that it actually is.

If the person that posted it simply doesn't care that people think its Craig they would be like, yeah I don't care if you think I am.

4

u/Zectro May 04 '19

It's speculation.

-5

u/Vernon51 Redditor for less than 60 days May 04 '19

It's 99% verified

6

u/Contrarian__ May 04 '19

I enjoy your novelty account.

4

u/jbrev01 May 04 '19

It could be CSW and co. attempting to impersonate, but in all likelihood that's a successful drug dealer looking to launder his illegal proceeds as an early adopter. Or anyone else with illegal money who bought BTC and wants to launder it and appear like an early adopter. Considering he's only looking for up to ~$2 million I'd say it's a darknet drug dealer.

2

u/goldMy May 04 '19 edited May 04 '19

Considering he’s only looking for up to ~$2 million I’d say it’s a darknet drug dealer.

Well, thats a valid point, because he wrote:

5) Buying up to 3 wallets that meet the criteria above.

But in fact we do not know the real quantity, this line could have just been added that he can use exactly this statement to remove the focus.

  • “If a drug-dealer want to launder money this way, he actually risks to get caught if the financial regulator requests a prove of mining, what requires hardware and increased electricity bills during that time. There is also the possibility of a down-tracking to the current coins he hold. Such things can happen. “

This would be just a low level argument against a defence statement that its just a drug-dealer.

3

u/jbrev01 May 04 '19

Yeah that's true, but I don't think most people would be able to provide an electric bill from 2010. Plus you have to remember Bitcoin was worthless back then, weren't many people paying out of pocket for huge electricity costs, most people mining were doing it casually and just a fun computer hobby. Not until 2012/2013 when people started getting serious because they could sell BTC to cover electricity costs. Mining 150 BTC in 2010 would barely make a dent in your bill.

For most exchanges looking to validate the source of Bitcoin, I doubt they would ask for detailed history like electric bills. But there would definitely be an issue not being able to link your current wallet to the original mining wallet -- 150 BTC today with no provable link to the mining wallets. I'm sure that would be a red flag for an exchange like Coinbase or Gemini. BUT, you could claim you had been trading and moving into altcoins that entire time to cover up the fact there's no link to the mining wallets. I'm sure they would ask for altcoin exchange statements.

Or you could sell OTC. And if government asked for proof of funds, the old mining wallets would probably be good enough. IRS wouldn't care especially if you claimed a zero dollar cost basis. Showing a mining wallet from 2010 would be enough for them to cancel out laundering.

1

u/zlozer May 05 '19

How would empty wallets help that?

6

u/homopit May 04 '19

Craig Wright Ordered to Produce

lol That's not a problem for him. He is know for his 'products'. Stolen, plagiarized, falsified... How the court likes them?

3

u/cameltoe66 May 05 '19

Wasn’t someone “cough cough faketoshi” caught trying to buy some early wallets recently?

1

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

Yes, the same way that over in that animal farm known as /r/bitcoin/ anything mysterious that happened was immediately ascribed to Roger Ver, that attempt, or pretend attempt, to buy an early wallet was ascribed to CSW.

5

u/cryptocached May 05 '19

Good point, we shouldn't jump to conclusions about that event. Besides, it would be quite out of character for Wright to be so proactive in establishing a somewhat, even if barely, plausible evidentiary basis for his fraudulent claims. He is remarkably sloppy in his forgery and completely inarticulate when presenting narrative.

1

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

Your first sentence made sense. Not sure about the rest.

3

u/cryptocached May 05 '19

Sound it out and don't be afraid to look up any big words. I believe in you, you can do it!

1

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

Hubris is a powerful drug.

4

u/cryptocached May 05 '19

I prefer to snort it off the asses of angels. We get so high and close to the sun so as to ensure the eventual comedown is a horrific spectacle.

4

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

Hey, not judging. What you do with your personal time is your own business. :)

2

u/Vernon51 Redditor for less than 60 days May 04 '19

I don't care if he has 1m early mined bitcoin and he bought the bitcoin.org domain in 2008, and he can sign the early addresses and move coins, I will never believe he is Satoshi

10

u/James-Russels May 05 '19

I saw a statement from Vitalik a while back to the effect of "If I found out Craig Wright was Satoshi, it'd change my opinion of Satoshi more than it'd change my opinion of Craig Wright.". That's how I look at it.

2

u/Phucknhell May 05 '19

Haha yes couldn't be more true..... Vitalik has a way with words for sure. It would be a sad day for crypto if Suetoshi was satoshi

-1

u/TwatoshiSuckafucko May 05 '19

Aka backpedaling. Vitalik didn't really think it through. If he's Satoshi then every "fraud" he supposedly committed needs to be reexamined.

5

u/deltanine99 May 05 '19

Good for you. That would be a fairly idiotic position to take if he did provide the evidence you cite. But people are entitled to believe whatever nonsense they choose.

5

u/jessquit May 05 '19

If I had the Satoshi keys would that make me Satoshi?

You wouldn't believe it for a moment. You'd ask, "where'd you get the keys?"

I'll add that, compared to CSW, my writing capability is much closer to that of the white paper's author and my online persona is much closer to Satoshi's online persona. Neither Craig nor I is a skilled C++ dev but I'm 100% positive my dev skills would produce a vastly superior Hello World program. Maybe I created the pseudocode for Bitcoin and paid someone to code it up.

Possession of keys proves nothing about identity. Satoshi's work products and online persona are more indicative of identity than keys. And in this regard I'm more likely to be Satoshi than CSW based on CSWs writing, coding, and online persona.

2

u/deltanine99 May 05 '19

This is true. The keys alone are not sufficient. So why is everyone so butthurt that csw refuses to sign publicly?

-3

u/Vernon51 Redditor for less than 60 days May 05 '19

We already know he is a fraud, so whatever he produces is therefore fraudulent. Once he produces the fraudulent stuff we will then have the evidence he is a fraud. It all fit's together perfectly.

2

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

Good to see that he brainwashing has been successful with this subject. wrings hands

2

u/tophernator May 05 '19

I don't care if he has 1m early mined bitcoin

He doesn’t. He just claims he does but can’t offer any proof.

and he bought the bitcoin.org domain in 2008,

He didn’t. He just claims he did, and posted an easily forgeable screen shot as evidence.

and he can sign the early addresses and move coins

He can’t, and has tried to pass off fake signatures multiple times.

2

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

Meh even if he is satoshi bcasher will deny him for muh avalanche lol

-5

u/CityBusDriverBitcoin May 04 '19

Not sure if you guys ready for reality yet ??

0

u/[deleted] May 05 '19

[deleted]

0

u/CityBusDriverBitcoin May 05 '19

I love your username

2

u/agree-with-you Redditor for less than 60 days May 05 '19

I love you both

-1

u/StrongLLC May 05 '19

I sympathize with anyone who spends more than 1 minute typing anything about this fraud

0

u/MarlonBanjoe May 05 '19

Account 1: 123fakestreet...

0

u/[deleted] May 04 '19

[deleted]

14

u/cryptocached May 04 '19

While I don't disagree with this article's conclusion that the 1.1M BTC claimed to be held in trust for Wight are a figment of his fraud, I do believe Kleiman has a valid claim regardless. Obviously he is not entitled to imaginary property, but that is not all which is at stake in this case.

Kleiman's claim is based on Wright fraudulently asserting control of assets including intellectual property rights belonging to Dave Kleiman's company, W&K Info Defense. There is no question that Wright took control of these assets, he did so through consent decrees obtained in the NSW Supreme Court. There is a question if he was authorized to do so. There is also the question of what those assets were and their value. At the time, Wright told the Court that the value was approximately $54M. He also used that valuation when attempting to claim R&D incentives from the ATO.

If Wright wrongly acquired assets from W&K, Kleiman is justified in seeking restitution. Even if the assets were worthless, Wright's fraudulent actions in obtaining those consent decrees, attempting to claim R&D incentives, and stringing Kleiman along in the process has caused real harm to the Plaintiff. While Kleiman may not be entitled to $11B of bitcoin or $54M of IP that Dave never owned, he has still been defrauded by Wright, has had to invest time and resources into investigating the matter, and has had to deal with the public scrutiny associated with the case.

Since Wright has stuck with the story instead of admitting his fraud, it is reasonable for the case to be presented on that basis. The argument that Wright did not have the authority to assert control over W&K assets, real or imagined, is strong enough to pursue in the unlikely event that there is any truth to the matter. If Wright decides to come clean, Kleiman will have demonstrated the fraud and be entitled to compensation on that front.

Wright has dug himself into a deep hole and keeps digging. His best bet to save face is to reach a settlement. There is an alternative, however. Wright could fail to give a defense and take a default or trial judgement against him, even for $11B. If, as I suspect, the assets he owns are limited, there will be little hope for Kleiman to collect. Wright can then play this off as a masterstroke of his genius - "Satoshi" gets to keep his bitcoin because the government can't seize it.

5

u/palacechalice May 04 '19

Isn't the theft of W&K's assets almost the same situation though? I'm largely assuming W&K's assets were worthless seeing as how Dave Kleiman shut it down not too long after he created it, so even if Craig claimed they were worth $54 million, it seems odd to me if the court would award Ira Kleiman very much much on that theft.

Put it this way, if I steal a fake Picasso from you, sell it on to somebody else for $54 million who believed it was real, and you sue me (with it coming out in court that it was fake), what is the court likely to award to you?

7

u/cryptocached May 04 '19

I think you are correct that they are unlikely to award $54M if there were no valuable assets. That doesn't preclude them from awarding substantial punitive damages, both for the hardship caused to Kleiman by Wright's actions as well as wasting the Courts resources by maintaining the fraud.

I wonder, however, if in the event that Wright does not have any assets, there is a legal recourse for the Plaintiff to go after those financing his fraudulent behavior. Ayre has repeatedly proclaimed Wright to be "the real" Satoshi Nakamoto and has financed nChain. There may be an argument that he is party to the continued fraud.

1

u/Vernon51 Redditor for less than 60 days May 04 '19

Ayre has repeatedly proclaimed Wright to be "the real"

But isn't Kleimans estate saying CSW is Satoshi?

9

u/cryptocached May 04 '19

Not exactly. They're saying Wright has lead the Plaintiff to believe that is so. If it is, he has stolen valuable assets from the Kleiman estate. If it is not, he has been engaged in fraud.

What they have not said, but I suggest, is that if he is engaged in fraud, they may be able to extend that claim to include Ayre as his financier.

0

u/Vernon51 Redditor for less than 60 days May 04 '19

But didn't Ira say that Dave told him he was working on bitcoin with a "wealthy foreign gentleman", and haven't they indicated they believe that to be Craig Wright?

5

u/cryptocached May 04 '19

The complaint reads:

On Thanksgiving Day 2009, Dave told Ira he was creating “digital money” with a wealthy foreign man, i.e., Craig.

This is one of the factual allegations which form the basis of the Plaintiff's complaint. That is an allegation of fact, not an undisputed fact. The Plaintiff brings his complaint to the Court requesting that they assess the allegations and require the Defendent to engage in discovery. Standard procedure at this point is for the Court to accept the Plaintiff's allegations in the most positive light.

The Defendant, Wright, has had an opportunity to dispute the factual allegations with evidence or legal argument. He also has the opportunity to make arguments regarding the Court's jurisdiction to hear the case. Wright has done both of these and thus far the Court has concluded that the Plaintiff's complaint merits discovery and that it is the proper venue for a trial.

Wright has disputed some of the factual allegations, but not all. He disputes the nature of his relationship, personal and in business, with Kleiman and the ownership or control of some assets. Importantly he has not, as far as I know, disputed any of the allegations that he was involved in the creation of Bitcoin, that he mined large quantities of bitcoin, or that he is entitled to a vast fortune of bitcoin held in trust. If they are false, failing to dispute these allegations and, as Wright has done, acting to encourage the Court to belief that they are true is fraud.

While it is ultimately the Plaintiff's responsibility to prove his allegations, the Court has ordered the parties to engage in mutual discovery. They are required make available evidence in their possession to the other party. The Plaintiff has the right to amend his complaint and factual allegations based on evidence uncovered during this process. Likewise, the Defendant may amend his arguments and evidence based on what is produced during discovery and amendments made by the Plaintiff.

7

u/nullc May 04 '19

The court only cares about making a determination over facts which are in dispute.

If you and I both claim that the painting is worth $54m then for the purpose of a lawsuit between us over its theft that matter is settled. The court will spend its time on matters where the parties do not agree. The whole process of the court depends on the existence of a dispute: it's isn't a magical truth oracle but depends on opposing sides vigorously arguing their own cases.

Wright could bring a rapid end to this litigation by admitting that he was defrauding everyone all along, but presumably this would just expose him to even worse criminal and/or civil charges. At least in this case he should be able to settle his way out of it, if he hasn't bamboozled the plaintiffs too hard.

0

u/Vernon51 Redditor for less than 60 days May 04 '19

admitting that he was defrauding everyone all along

What was the fraud?

4

u/noone111111 May 05 '19

Well, for one he is suing people for claiming he is a fraud, so that would make all his libel and defamation suits fraudulent since he's admitting to being a fraud.

1

u/Vernon51 Redditor for less than 60 days May 05 '19

That makes sense

4

u/cryptocached May 05 '19

What was the fraud?

That depends on the truth of the matter, which is what discovery is meant to help identify.

Based on Wright's statements, public and allegedly in private, as well his documented actions, the Plaintiff has taken the approach of focusing on Wright's successful acquisition of consent decrees assigning him rights to the intellectual property of W&K. If Wright did not have the authority to act as he did he would have committed fraud in doing so.

If by evidence or Wright's admission it is shown he has been misrepresenting his participation in the creation of Bitcoin, having mined a large sum of bitcoin, or entitlement to a vast fortune of bitcoin held in trust, other statements and actions may qualify as fraud. It's hard to say what those are unless and until that evidence or admission are produced. It appears likely that his actions within the context of this case and his statements to the Court would qualify as one example of fraud in that event.

0

u/Vernon51 Redditor for less than 60 days May 05 '19

If Wright did not have the authority to act as he did he would have committed fraud in doing so.

But wasn't Craig Wright a fraud long before this came to light? There must be something before this

3

u/cryptocached May 05 '19

Well sure, there is a trail of evidence for fraudulent behavior stretching back a long time. None of that is particularly relevant to this case as far as I know.

0

u/Vernon51 Redditor for less than 60 days May 05 '19 edited May 05 '19

While I don't disagree with this article's conclusion that the 1.1M BTC claimed to be held in trust for Wight are a figment of his fraud,

Exhibit 15 is a fake document.

2

u/cryptocached May 05 '19 edited May 05 '19

Exhibit 4 15 of which filing?

The evidence submitted thus far need only be sufficient to support the Plaintiff's claims and justify discovery. It is possible that evidence submitted with the complaint are never presented in trial.

The Defendant has the right, and has been granted ample opportunity, to dispute the merits of the Plaintiff's complaint, including the evidence presented to support it. The Court has heard from both sides and ruled that the Plaintiff's complaint warrants discovery.