r/btc • • Apr 26 '19

With Bitcoin, for the first time in modern history, we have a way to opt out.

Post image
356 Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

20

u/knight222 Apr 26 '19

*With Bitcoin (BCH)

20

u/SwedishSalsa Apr 26 '19

Well of course. :) I believe economic freedom is the foundation of a prosperous, civilized society. Even if the "stream has been blocked" so to speak with the take over of BTC, the market always finds a way to route around attempts to control it. Money is information and information wants to be free. As it looks now, BCH is the best version of Bitcoin. Not only is it the best money the world has seen, it has the best community, the best momentum and the best developers. What a time to be alive and how lucky am I to be part of this movement.

6

u/horsebadlydrawn Apr 26 '19

What a time to be alive and how lucky am I to be part of this movement.

This. Antifragile.

2

u/RipsawBitcoin Apr 27 '19

I can post in this subreddit too!

-5

u/Trident1000 Apr 26 '19

Keep dreaming

14

u/FUBAR-BDHR Apr 26 '19

That's right. We still believe in the dream of bitcoin. BTC gave up. We will continue dreaming until it's reality.

-5

u/junglehypothesis Apr 27 '19

Actually, Bitmain is giving up on BCH by all accounts. Bitcoin is going from strength to strength, e.g. highest ever Bitcoin output count this week and eTrade about to launch BTC trading to their 5m customers.

-9

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Apr 26 '19

They’re not dreaming they’re lying.

5

u/knight222 Apr 27 '19

What lie?

-14

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Apr 27 '19

Stop telling new people BCH is the bitcoin they’ve been hearing about in the news. You’re lying to people to try to prop up your failing investment.

9

u/knight222 Apr 27 '19

I don't know what is the bitcoin told in the news but I know that BCH is the Bitcoin described in the whitepaper. Beside, I couldn't care less about "investments". I care about financial freedom for the world free of fractional reserve and central banks.

-3

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '19 edited Apr 27 '19

>I know that BCH is the Bitcoin described in the whitepaper

I'm sorry - I can't see it.

  • Regular protocol forks

  • Checkpoints 10 blocks behind the tip?

  • Block size restrictions?

  • Nodes ordering transactions?

  • Limits which cripple the utility of scripts?

The economics of bitcoin will fail with those limits in place. Dead man walking.

5

u/knight222 Apr 27 '19

I'm sorry - I can't see it.

Let me help you. Right here:

Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System

-2

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '19

I see you have clearly addressed my points. Excellent work.

4

u/knight222 Apr 27 '19

Well none of your points go against mine.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/jessquit Apr 27 '19

>I know that BCH is the Bitcoin described in the whitepaper

I'm sorry - I can't see it.

  • Regular protocol forks

"Any needed rules or incentives can be enforced with this consensus mechanism"

  • Checkpoints 10 blocks behind the tip?

Name one instance of a 10+ block automatic reorg that is desirable by anyone. Show me the use case, make your point how a 13 block reorg ensures the security of the system.

  • Block size restrictions?

Huh?

  • Nodes ordering transactions?

Huh?

  • Limits which cripple the utility of scripts?

Huh? It's "Peer-to-peer Electronic Cash" not some fancy global Turing machine.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '19

"Any needed rules or incentives can be enforced with this consensus mechanism"

This is not referring to changes in the protocol. It's referring to miner behaviour within the protocol.

Name one instance of a 10+ block automatic reorg that is desirable by anyone

If you prevent a 10 block reorg, then what you are doing is removing the incentives for miners to build a network that is high performance.

Bitcoin fundamentally works because miners should be afraid (and work to avoid) a reorg - because a reorg may endanger their profits.

It's a natural economic balance which requires no "central authority".

make your point how a 13 block reorg ensures the security of the system

Who is going to build a network which can handle large blocks? Miners. Why are they going to build the network? Because if they don't they will not win the block reward.

When you take away the threat of less profit ... you take away their inventive to build the network. A highly connected network improves the security of bitcoin (see: small-world network model)

Block size restrictions? Huh?

BCH has a restricted block size.

Nodes ordering transactions? Huh?

BCH nodes are implementing a scaling solution which requires nodes to specific order transactions. This is fundamentally flawed.

not some fancy global Turing machine

Well, actually it IS a fancy global turing machine.

Bitcoin developers imposed limits on parameters which they did not understand.

-1

u/jessquit Apr 28 '19

"Any needed rules or incentives can be enforced with this consensus mechanism"

This is not referring to changes in the protocol. It's referring to miner behaviour within the protocol.

No fuckwit.

I'm not going to waste any more time on you because you're either an idiot or yet another troll.

Changing the incentives or the consensus rules is a direct change to the protocol.

The rest of your comment is complete idiocy like the rest of the BSV idiocy. No Bitcoin isn't intended to be a Turing computer or a file storage system. It's peer to peer cash for causal payments between two willing parties. Read the mother fucking paper.

Now go away and build your Not-Bitcoin and please for the love of Satoshi go cause numerous and repeated 13 block reorgs to prove to us all how much better it makes your token than ours. Stop talking about it and go do what you say. Reorg the fuck out of your chain until it's just the best chain ever.

Now go.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/mjh808 Apr 27 '19

You're lying, nobody does that.

1

u/jessquit Apr 27 '19

Stop telling new people BCH is the bitcoin they’ve been hearing about in the news.

Except it is. BCH works the same way Bitcoin did from 2009-2017: with always low onchain fees to support the concept of "Peer-to-peer Electronic Cash." It's BTC who is changing the way Bitcoin works from "Peer-to-peer Electronic Cash" into a settlement token for the failed Lightning Network concept. In 2015 we were going to "bank the unbanked" now the folks in charge of BTC say Bitcoin isn't for the poor. Who really changed what?

How many people who buy BTC because they heard about it in the news have any idea that they're buying a speculation on "Lightning Network" not Bitcoin like it existed in the silk road days where everyone could make an onchain transaction in the next block for under a penny and when everyone understood the block size limit was just an anti-DOS mechanism that would get raised long before we got to 1MB?

JFC SMH I was using "the Bitcoin that they heard about on the news" back when the news was still being made. BCH is Bitcoin. Deal with it.

0

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Apr 27 '19

By your argument, those who say BSV is bitcoin or bitcoin gold is bitcoin are just as valid. The reality is the market decides what bitcoin is. The market (both by market cap and number of transactions) is choosing BTC.

Stop telling new people BCH is bitcoin. This meme is increasingly pathetic, and obviously disingenuous. You don’t actually believe this.

For example, if you saw a “bitcoin accepted here” sticker on the front door of a business, would you send BCH to the address during payment? Because you’d lose your fucking money if you did.

1

u/jessquit Apr 27 '19

By your argument, those who say BSV is bitcoin or bitcoin gold is bitcoin are just as valid.

No, merely making the claim isn't sufficient. But yes, any Bitcoin variant has a claim on Bitcoin genetics. Bitcoin isn't a brand name. It's up to investors to do their own research.

  • which Bitcoin is the one that works like Bitcoin did from 2009-2017

  • which Bitcoin has bet the farm on an experimental technology called Lightning Network which is years behind schedule, may never work, and is definitely not what you've heard about in the news.

the market

Loved pets.com

0

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Apr 27 '19 edited Apr 27 '19

BCH users claiming the market doesn't matter reminds me of economists comparing bitcoin to tulips.

I'm curious how long you will hold out saying the market doesn't matter. It's been almost 2 years now that the market hasn't matter to you guys (from BCH trading at 1/4 BTC, to now trading at 1/16th BTC).

But you ignored my point of BCH having fewer transactions than BTC. Interesting. Shouldn't you instead be comparing the poor fundamentals of BCH to pets.com?

BCH isn't bitcoin. If a store has one of those "Bitcoin Accepted Here" signs, you can't send them BCH. You will burn your coins.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '19

[deleted]

-16

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Apr 27 '19

The entire world is a conspiracy except for BCH.

6

u/Redcrux Apr 27 '19 edited May 11 '26

This comment formerly contained words. Those words were removed in bulk with Redact because I value my privacy more than my karma points.

bow oatmeal chop coordinated dinner groovy spectacular cats teeny literate

-6

u/CraigRite Apr 27 '19

"Look, I'm sorry Roger that Satoshi put in a 1 megabyte block limit. At the time Satoshi put in a one megabyte block limit he kind of assumed that it would be simple to just make it bigger in the future. The reality of the situation was that when the Bitcoin Core Developers did their research and they initially thought about going to a bigger block, they realized that there is no way that was going to happen: You can't force people to update their node and they knew that the community was going to split. So they they made the safe, they made the smart decision, not to even try and what they had to do was find a better way to scale"

4

u/sq66 Apr 27 '19

...and the split happened anyway.

1

u/bitmeister Apr 27 '19

the Bitcoin Core Developers did their research

No they didn't. They merely did some back-of-the-napkin math, declared there was a problem, and that THEY reserved the right to solve this critical issue in order to remain in control of Bitcoin. To cement their control, they declared the 1MB limit to be permanent.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/vdistracted Apr 26 '19

Can someone explain to me the biggest issue with our current banking system?

5

u/SwedishSalsa Apr 27 '19

The video posted by u/mjh808 explains it pretty well.

I'd recommend you to read Economics in One Lesson by Henry Hazlitt: https://mises.org/library/economics-one-lesson , it will fundamentally change your understanding of economics and politics. Or any book on Austrian economics for that matter.

7

u/mjh808 Apr 27 '19

4

u/SwedishSalsa Apr 27 '19

Great video, I'm gonna share this with some people today. And to address the people calling "nazi", as Steven Forbes points out here: https://youtu.be/iFDe5kUUyT0?t=1680 yes, this system of theft creates "social distrust". It's no wonder the 1900-hundreds were so violent, part of it is certainly the corrupt monetary system in which governments and the banking cartel can actually profit from waging war.

19

u/obesepercent Apr 26 '19

The supply of money is controlled by a private organization which can "print" money at will. There's more issues, but that's the most significant one. After they ended the gold peg sometime 50 something years ago the inflation began to skyrocket

6

u/UpDown Apr 27 '19

It’s literally tether. They are identical. And look how tether seems to hold its stability despite its flaws. Hmm what’s up with that

5

u/saddit42 Apr 27 '19

With tether people at least expect that it is backed by something.. the dollar is even more of a scam than tether.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '19

They are the same exact scam. Tether just re-created the Federal Reserve on top of Bitcoin and a bunch of scam ass exchanges supported it.

1

u/saddit42 Apr 27 '19

At least they didn't scam the whole society into thinking that they can get away with it forever

30

u/szechuan_anon Apr 26 '19

It's amazing that people are not aware of the criminality of our banking system/monetary policy. It slaps you in the face every day. #vivalaresistance

5

u/526rocks Apr 27 '19

Can I get an example of this?

15

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '19

If you have $100 in your account and a $1000 deposit and $200 withdrawal pending, it's not uncommon for them to withdraw the $200, charge you an overdraft fee, then deposit the $1000.

7

u/ChillPill247365 Apr 27 '19

This is very true. Many charges and credits are processed oddly. Each bank has their own policies. I've bought a bottle of coke and a pack of gum that cost me an additional $135 because of the order of processing. It takes a legal degree to understand the fine print and it's designed to make the bank money off of financially insecure people.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '19

[deleted]

11

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '19

No my example is simply one example of the criminality of our banking system as requested.

We should abandon the entire monetary system because it is a fiat system and there is a 100% failure rate for fiat currencies throughout ALL human history.

3

u/sq66 Apr 27 '19

..and for the misplaced power of central banking.

3

u/jessquit Apr 27 '19

What is needed is an electronic payment system based on cryptographic proof instead of trust, allowing any two willing parties to transact directly with each other without the need for a trusted third party.

2

u/bitmeister Apr 27 '19

Parent post asked for an example, not the ultimate cause for abandonment you appear to be looking for.

3

u/ThisdigitalERA Apr 27 '19

If the bank delays two days on “posting” your payment but has received the funds, they have that money to accrue interest and “hodl” in different markets. Yeah it might be only two hundred bucks but those couple hundred bucks multiplied by a couple hundred people every couple days that starts to add up.

Take the company Uber for example.

They collect money every day from riders and then pay the driver at the end of the week. Well, you might get paid on a Sunday on the books but your payment from them doesn’t come through until Tuesday. Uber was making money on your money.

Now your bank holds the payment for a minimum of 24-48 hours before posting to your account and starting to accrue you interest, meanwhile they are using your money to make them money by the hundreds of accounts that they have processing payments just like yours on a day to day basis. Crooks Edit was “ hodl” parenthesis.

2

u/EnayVovin Apr 27 '19

The absence of personal responsibility for the books for those running a bank when their paycheck depends on how much risk they can load (and preferably hide and preferably set to explode decades after) unto such books, coupled with the power of issuing debt that gets used as legal tender that can be generated even without having any funds first, coupled with the monopoly, i.e. the freedom from competition that is not sanctioned from within the industry, and the state protecting such special state-given rights with guns, is what is criminal. It leads to insane societal Ponzies, huge mal-investment of people's efforts chasing Ponzies, followed by huge busts. It also leads to huge profits from the fraud.

The bailouts that follow the busts, the tax that the inflation of prices is, (caused primarily by inflation of the quantity of debt, velocity of debt and a few other factors), the central banks, the public insurance of bank liabilities (in some countries including derivatives), alone make it a huge criminal system but these things are secondary to the first paragraph. The inflation makes the hole digging easier, the Ponzi chasing stronger, and gives the general public a sense of having a shot at a piece of the cake.

2

u/szechuan_anon Apr 28 '19

Monetary policy/fractional reserve banking at its finest. My degree is in econ, with a emphasis on monetary policy. Most of my college career (besides partying) was muttering "are you fucking kidding me" when learning about how this system works, and how people sheepishly accept it. The simplest example is paying ATM fees in general. It absolutely insane. Money is created out of thin air "creative accounting" it's absolutely criminal. If you or I did it we would be imprisoned. SMFH. It's a sad state of affairs

5

u/lokojones Apr 27 '19

Once people realize the power in own monetary system which no one can control, no one can take it from you we will become humans 3.0

Hodling until the last bank collapse.

3

u/abekekz Apr 27 '19

That would be nasty. Trigger for the biggest bull run. Small bull runs already were in Turkey, Iran during local crisis.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '19

I'm one of the who don't understand. Can anyone enlighten me for this subject?

5

u/saddit42 Apr 27 '19

watch this talk about voice and exit: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cOubCHLXT6A. Crypto currencies give us the ability to peacefully exit the financial system (in which money can be created at will which equals stealing from everyone)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '19

Knowing Ford, “banking and monetary system” was most likely a dog whistle for Jews

-7

u/Thewalrusking2 Apr 26 '19

Yeah we should stop quoting this nazi sympathizer.

1

u/horsebadlydrawn Apr 26 '19

/THREAD

Godwin's Law confirmed after only 2 posts!

2

u/WikiTextBot Apr 26 '19

Godwin's law

Godwin's law (or Godwin's rule of Hitler analogies) is an Internet adage asserting that "As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1"; that is, if an online discussion (regardless of topic or scope) goes on long enough, sooner or later someone will compare someone or something to Adolf Hitler or his deeds, the point at which effectively the discussion or thread often ends. Promulgated by the American attorney and author Mike Godwin in 1990, Godwin's law originally referred specifically to Usenet newsgroup discussions. It is now applied to any threaded online discussion, such as Internet forums, chat rooms, and comment threads, as well as to speeches, articles, and other rhetoric where reductio ad Hitlerum occurs.

Godwin has stated that he introduced Godwin's law in 1990 as an experiment in memetics.In 2012, "Godwin's law" became an entry in the third edition of the Oxford English Dictionary.


[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28

2

u/Thewalrusking2 Apr 27 '19

Godwin's law only applies If the subject does not have actual ties to nazis. Ford was an unabashed supporter of the third reich and at one point was a financial supporter of the nazi party .

2

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '19

If you're discussing a direct nazi supporter, then it's only fair.

You can't be against r/bitcoin censorship and have bazi supporters quotes both at the same time.

2

u/Thewalrusking2 Apr 27 '19

I mean to be fair you can do that but it's terrible optics for the community.

1

u/spectreoutreach May 14 '19

Especially those who have no access to traditional banking and no experience in getting a hold of their own finances. Bitcoin may give the impression that you can get rich using it quickly but ultimately, that is not the point of this cryptocurrency. The main point is to provide a global currency that gives everyone the chance to have access to a global financial system that can help them.

1

u/mondayblues18 May 15 '19

How does this help the unbanked ?

1

u/spectreoutreach May 15 '19

Well , there’s used gift cards lying around and you needed money, you can join a trading platform and trade those gift cards for some bitcoins. Then, you can trade those bitcoins for cash by setting cash as payment. You can also sell those bitcoins and set money transfer as a mode of payment since you don’t have a bank account where they can send the money directly.

For example , Bitcoin Casino like Vegascasino.io which offer gamers like me online gaming experience that is second to none. With easy to use registration process and & it prepared a convenient mobile version for those who love playing slots on mobile devices like me .

It offers more than 200+ games like Bitcoin slots like both low and high limit slots, progressive jackpots slots, and old-school style 3 reel slots. I do like vast selection of Roulette, Blackjack and other table games will have a considerable number of titles to choose from because I stand better chance in winning a lot of btc. Texas Hold’em , Satoshi Baccarat, VIP American Roulette 7 etc are some of favorite games.

Information pertaining to games by clicking the information – or ‘I’ button – located in the bottom right-hand corner of any game . The dealers are really friendly which provide fun atmosphere . Withdrawal & deposit is really fast & simple plus it offers news players up to 1 BTC instantly on their first deposit. Overall , a solid and ambitious platform for Bitcoin players like me because Bitcoin is perfect for sending remittances. Think of it as a form of money that you can instantly send without fees to any part of the world.

1

u/ptisn1 Apr 27 '19

J.O.O.'s

0

u/liquidocean Apr 27 '19

this is a misquote

0

u/Johnbosko Apr 27 '19

BTC the best"

-4

u/stos313 Apr 27 '19

Um, probably don’t want to post a quote about banks from America’s favorite Nazi. While you may agree with his sentiment I can assure you, you probably don’t agree with the motivation behind those sentiments.

Unless you are just a REALLY big asshole (which, at times I get uncomfortable becoming aware of the conspicuous intersection between anti semites and crypto holders).

3

u/SwedishSalsa Apr 27 '19

I don't know much about him being a Nazi. At the time, most people in my own country were more or less nazis by "current year" standards. It doesn't invalidate Fords genius in manufacturing or his insights into the financial system.

3

u/MentalRental Apr 27 '19

3

u/SwedishSalsa Apr 27 '19

Interesting read, thank you. A corrupt financial system has and will create social tensions, that's why we need sound money more than ever. In contrast with Ford, we should focus on criticizing the system, not religions.

1

u/MentalRental Apr 27 '19

we should focus on criticizing the system, not religions.

I agree but there's really no actual valid criticism in the quote. A good criticism would be pointing out an actual flaw and offering an alternative.

This is a quote with no context. We have no idea what Ford is referring to. We have no idea if he knows what he's talking about. The year of the quote is stated as 1922. This is nine years after the Federal Reserve Act was passed but, at that time, the US was still on the Gold Standard. Money wasn't fully fiat. So what was he saying? Perhaps he was, instead, talking about the Bank Panic of 1907 which is what induced the creation of the Federal Reserve?

It sounds like I'm grasping at straws until you consider that Woodrow Wilson was the President that established the Federal Reserve (in 1913) and he and Henry Ford were close friends. So close, in fact, that Wilson convinced Ford to switch political parties and run for Senate in 1918.

So there's a good chance this quote may not mean what you think it means. He may have been advocating for a totally fiat-based currency which would have allowed a country to "control" its own finances instead of letting it risk being bankrupt and then at the entire behest of bankers. Remember, in 1907, if JP Morgan hadnt stepped in to stop the crisis, the whole nation may have gone bankrupt. That's enormous power at the hands of banks. Setting up an independent entity comprised of big, competing banks, yet controlled by a government appointed board was supposed to deal with this problem.

2

u/stos313 Apr 27 '19

Here is a poem an in house Ford magazine under Henry titled “Führer”

“Even when we cannot understand you, We will go with you. One day we may comprehend, How you can see our future. Hearts like bronze shields, We have placed around you, And it seems to us, that only You can reveal God’s world to us.”
(Source: https://www.thenation.com/article/ford-and-fuhrer/)

Here is Henry Ford getting the highest award the Nazis could give to a civilian, the grand cross of the German eagle or something:

https://antizionistleague.files.wordpress.com/2013/07/henry-ford-receives-grand-cross.jpg

Henry Ford was the only American mentioned in Mein Kampf:

http://www.redpillsentinel.com/home/henry-ford-is-the-only-american-mentioned-in-mein-kampfhitler-regarded-ford-as-his-inspiration

I fact apparently there is a “Ford Translation?” (I honestly don’t know what that’s about, and holy fuck the reviews are just and endless list of shitbags)

https://www.amazon.com/Mein-Kampf-Translation-Adolf-Hitler-ebook/dp/B004LDLI0S

Henry Ford even published an anti-Semitic newspaper called “The Dearborn Independent” which released its a bunch of its articles in a volume called “The International Jew”

https://daily.jstor.org/henry-fords-anti-semitism/

Henry Ford really, REALLY hated Jews and real REALLY loved Nazis.

-3

u/PeerToPeerCash Apr 27 '19

Looks like r/btc is a problematic pseudo neo-nazi dogwhistle subreddit full of basement dwelling crypto incels upvoting famous anti-semite quotes and downvoting any legit criticism.

Yikes.

6

u/SwedishSalsa Apr 27 '19 edited Apr 28 '19

Not true. For example, you will find a lot of Austrian Economists here, most of which the most prominent were jews, like Mises and Rothbard. It's very unfortunate that a corrupt monetary system fosters hate and distrust between different groups, and that's why we don't want to create another corrupt system like what is happening to BTC.

1

u/PeerToPeerCash Apr 28 '19

I was being facetious, u/stos313 comment was so full of normie redditspeak rhetoric that i had to give it a try myself

that said this sub is still pure cancer

-3

u/stos313 Apr 27 '19

Oh that doesn’t surprise me one bit. While the relationship between antisemites and crypto is pretty strong, I feel like that intersection is stronger with BCH.

I’m not saying BCH is “anti-Semitic,” just number 1 with anti-semites.

Lol- looks like I have been put in “time out” for pointing out the Nazi sentiment of this post and have to wait like 10 minutes to post.

Well done mods, well done!

<slow clap>