r/btc • u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator • Apr 25 '19
WSJ: Bitfinex Used Tether Reserves to Mask Missing $850 Million, Probe Finds
https://www.wsj.com/articles/bitfinex-used-tether-reserves-to-mask-missing-850-million-probe-finds-11556227031?mod=rsswn33
u/GeorgAnarchist Apr 25 '19
Could be the biggest Crypto scam ever witnessed. Who gives 850 million USD to a shady panama company without any contract or whatsoever.
Things get interesting at around half of the document.
15
u/Cthulhooo Apr 25 '19
What are a the chances this money wasn't 100% clean?
16
2
Apr 26 '19
Remember when a bank in poland got raided that was deep in to the columbian drugs trade? Bitfinex was one of their customers. Rumours had it that Polish bitfinex users got questioned by the police
1
u/Cthulhooo Apr 26 '19
Yeah I remember. The most interesting thing is not what we know but what we don't.
1
u/barnz3000 Apr 26 '19
Who, but legitimate businessmen, would require "internet money" in $300M chunks?
9
46
u/AlpraCream Apr 25 '19 edited Apr 26 '19
It's about fucking time! Anyone that browses r/bitfinex could have seen something big coming from a mile away.
Few examples
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/as5yi2/waiting_2_months_for_a_serius_answer/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/b2h94l/bitfinex_huge_problem_big_money_loss/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/azv90z/my_account_with_money_has_been_frozen_for_6_month/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/ak1sem/i_demand_my_16k_back_from_bitfinex_follow_my/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/bayr0j/am_i_alone_in_having_delays_in_wire_withdrawals/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/bc08um/i_have_been_trying_to_withdraw_my_funds_for_2/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/ba5mnr/expedited_24_hr_withdrawl_has_not_happened_very/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/ajomdq/funds_have_not_been_recieved_for_over_3_months/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/b8lcxq/hey_bitfinex_i_asked_for_a_wire_to_withdraw_funds/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/aw91zw/my_bitfinex_withdraw_is_locked_they_ask_me_the/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/az3a4b/withdraw_stuck_on_processing/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/as7iug/btc_deposited_to_usdt_wallet_8_months_ago_jun/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/b83jrs/3_days_crypto_withdrawals_from_my_bifinexethfinex/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/b7gtn1/didnt_recieve_iqx_withdrawn/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/afxjv2/my_usd_withdraw_passed_15_months_cancelled_and/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/b5oidt/bitfinex_lost_my_150_zec8400_during_withdrawal/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/aj1xxm/withdrawal_no_credited_since_december_20th/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/ahed8t/bitfinex_please_tell_me_where_my_2_whidrawals_are/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/afpagw/withdrawals/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/af4c2p/usd_withdraw_canceled_by_adminsupport_team_not/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/abelfj/fiat_withdraw_canceled_by_admin/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/ab55tn/why_my_usd_withdrawal_been_canceled_by_admin/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/aa1th0/eur_withdrawal_117323/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/a7vf0t/bch_deposit_not_credited_since_a_month/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/a7a84a/4_weeks_with_no_response/
https://www.reddit.com/r/bitfinex/comments/a79olk/2_months_withdrawal_never_received_money_request/
15
u/5400123 Apr 25 '19
Yeah this is like a year in the making lol
14
Apr 25 '19
Where is bitfinex'ed, he's been calling them out from the start and lots of people were giving him crap for it
7
u/Churn Apr 26 '19
He probably died of old age two weeks ago, never knowing he was proven right.
6
u/ceejayoz Apr 26 '19
He's on Twitter enjoying the vindication. https://twitter.com/Bitfinexed/status/1121560004220399616
3
1
20
Apr 25 '19 edited Jun 16 '23
[deleted to prove Steve Huffman wrong] -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/
9
u/Abelgo Apr 25 '19
Best news of the day. I hope those fuckers burn and and the US gov goes full Julian Assange on them. Bitfinx crew should have done jail time years ago already. I never understood how they got away with it for so long and why people every used their IOU scam coin.
17
u/jimbonezz Apr 25 '19
anyone else find it coincidental finex stolen BTC was moved the same day this news came out?
9
3
3
0
u/MaximumInflation Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 25 '19
What would be the link/motivation between these two events?
6
8
u/CityBusDriverBitcoin Apr 25 '19
$1 u/tippr
6
u/tippr Apr 25 '19
u/BeijingBitcoins, you've received
0.00372505 BCH ($1 USD)!^^How to use | ^^What is Bitcoin Cash? | ^^Who accepts it? | r/tippr
Bitcoin Cash is what Bitcoin should be. Ask about it on r/btc
15
u/GeorgAnarchist Apr 25 '19
So its clear that Tether is unbacked but instead of Tether crashing Coins are crashing, Crypto Economy is a real miracle...
6
u/mogray5 Apr 26 '19
Tether's "reserves" are probably actually in BTC and they're selling it for USD to dole out to people rushing for the exits.
2
7
17
u/0023N02 Apr 25 '19
and there goes bitcoin... what about the people holding the tethers? You'd think there'd be an initial rush out of tethers into BTC, as they can't exactly cash it out. Thoughts on how this affects the markets?
22
u/MobTwo Apr 25 '19
Tether is as good as worthless if it cannot be changed back into money. And with what seems to be going on, there is a chance of exchanges delisting Tether altogether. Anyone holding on to tether will be like holding on to Bitconnect tokens.
If I were holding Tether, I would definitely quickly change all these into cryptos. But no matter what, someone will be left holding the bag, since every seller has a buyer.
-1
u/jpdoctor Apr 26 '19
But no matter what, someone will be left holding the bag,
Not really the same as bitconnect: If it drops below the insolvency percentage, then tether/bitfinex will buy the coins, "redeem" them, which will solve their insolvency.
4
u/MobTwo Apr 26 '19
This is assuming exchanges still list tethers after this fraud incident. If they delist tethers, then whoever hold tethers will be left holding the bag since you can't change for crypto anymore.
2
u/freedombit Apr 26 '19
Two things:
Won't Tether themselves redeem?
There was really only one big user - Bitfinex.
So I can't imagine many people getting stuck "holding the bag."
I really don't have a fight in this game, so don't care either way, but while there seems to be strong evidence of fraud, one must remember that there is a lot of USD expatriated that cannot be returned to the US. I have to believe that Tether would be very attractive to those USD holders. If the truth is actually freed, we are about to find out either way.
1
u/MobTwo Apr 26 '19
Only Bitfinex would know the answer to your first question. If the Bitfinex guys got apprehended, would they still be able to do anything? The US government is powerful and I am not sure even Bitfinex can get away with it.
2
15
u/Nunoyabiznes Apr 25 '19
Maybe it was happening and that was the bump in bitcoin over the last 2 months...thereâs always people who are in the know before the big reveal.
7
u/5400123 Apr 25 '19
Impending liquidity crash
12
u/cryptos4pz Apr 25 '19
Good point. Yep.
According to the article Tether made up ~80% of BTC trading, but right now Tether is the hot potato no-one wants. So the market panics, but this time... they won't sell out to Tether; they want dollars. There are not enough dollars. So the Ask just drops lower and lower. Looks like it means the overall price of cryptos, which generally follow BTC, can dip in an exaggerated fashion on this episode.
5
u/5400123 Apr 25 '19
As far as a detailed âa-b-câ cause and effect breakdown of what will happen, Iâm not a maverick trader who understands the fine print of financial instruments and how they orbit.
But from my laymenâs understanding: it would seem 80% of their volume was being done with funny money.
In my mind, if Tether is a bubble and is really worth .50c - to make simple, then 80% of Btc volume in Tether, and that was overvalued by 50% - or in other words BTC was 40% overvalued.
If Tether drops to zero, damn, the market is going to basically fail. Thatâs not even like a stock market crash. Thatâs like waking up and the USD/EUR market on forex, all the sudden EUR is worth 0
5
u/cryptos4pz Apr 26 '19 edited Apr 26 '19
if Tether is a bubble and is really worth .50c - to make simple, then 80% of Btc volume in Tether, and that was overvalued by 50% - or in other words BTC was 40% overvalued
Nah, your extrapolation isn't correct. The price value of something does not equal its volume. As you correctly point out, as far as the market is concerned the problem is just one of liquidity. Cryptocurrency thankfully sits on a complete free market, which is as precise as one can get. There really are X number of people out there who think 1 BTC has a value ~$5K. Whether or not they can convert that into or out of some other currency as quickly as they'd like is another story.
The main problem will just be one of panic sellers and weak hands unsure what to do. Those are the ones that will drive the dollar price lower until it finds a bottom.
EDIT: in terms of the Tether being worth say .50c that missing money comes from Tether holders if they're not able to convert them to anything.
2
2
u/MaximumInflation Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 25 '19
oh, r/buttcoin will have hit the mother lode of comedy gold veins if that's the case.
6
2
12
u/Hoolander Apr 26 '19
Astonishing that this news isn't even on the front page of .r/bitcoin . Censorship on an unimaginable level.
28
u/MobTwo Apr 25 '19
For what it's worth, this news is actually bullish for Bitcoin Cash over the mid and long term. Based on data, it seems the price of BTC is maintained through tethers so if you take that away, BTC's price will take a hit.
Bitcoin Cash may also take a hit in the short term but given how hostile Bitfinex (the tethers founders) are against Bitcoin Cash, I would be glad they are gone. They got the karma they deserves, one by one, they fall. Sweet sweet justice.
12
Apr 25 '19
BTCâs price is maintained through tethers but all other cryptos pretty much follow BTC in one way or another.
17
u/MobTwo Apr 25 '19
That is up to exchanges to add more pairings and not be such dependent on BTC.
7
u/MaximumInflation Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 25 '19
Doesn't help the current situation though.
9
u/MobTwo Apr 25 '19
Look on the bright side. If tether is around longer and continues to grow bigger, the impact would have been even worse.
3
Apr 26 '19
I agree that we will not have a decoupling before Tether dies. But I also think that BCH is only valued at about 100 USD right now. If we hit 1/1 in price with BTC but that price is 100 USD. Would that be good or bad for us?
2
u/MobTwo Apr 26 '19
Good or bad... If it has to be done, it needs to be done, just like surgery to remove a tumor.
11
u/futureshockdotapp Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 25 '19
How is tether still above 0?
1
u/Bag_Holding_Infidel Apr 25 '19
Because they have at least $1.5bn USD in reserve.
8
4
1
u/fap_nap_fap Apr 26 '19
so in the SHORT (couple weeks) term, would it be a terrible idea to sell my crypto with the goal of buying back in at a lower price so that I have more crypto?
1
3
7
u/CaptainWeee Apr 25 '19 edited Apr 26 '19
Anybody who didnât see the writing on the wall with Bitfinex or actually thought Tether was a legit thing is an idiot. Most if not all of these âStable-coinsâ are frauds. Anybody who sold today based off the dump from Bitfinex deserves the gift of having to buy higher. Tether should have been delisted from all exchanges a long time ago. Also Bitfinex is trash. Just wanted to say that.
2
u/Kryai Apr 26 '19
Bitfinex and Tether may be insolvent. Bitfinex and Tether and owned and operated by the same people. They are separate entities, but they share significant common personnel.
Today the Assistant NYAG filed a motion to try and prevent Bitfinex from taking part in any transaction between it and Tether. Here's the raw document: https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/fbem/DocumentDisplayServlet?documentId=vIexA1b0spKOnK_PLUS_ZUGTJ3A==&system=prod
Reporting on the above filing is available from the WSJ: https://www.wsj.com/articles/bitfinex-used-tether-reserves-to-mask-missing-850-million-probe-finds-11556227031?mod=rsswn
What is going on? The filing lays out that Bitfinex has lost access to $850 million dollars of corporate and depositor money to a company called Crypto Capital. Bitfinex believes that those funds may have been stolen and that Crypto Capital has been engaged in defrauding Bitfinex. Bitfinex - in order to pay out withdrawals has been running out of cash. Bitfinex has engaged in multiple transactions with Tether of questionable nature. It has obtained lines of credit and fiat currency (ostensibly to pay out fiat withdrawals - this is speculation but a logical conclusion based on the filing and its context) It also appears to have sold equity in itself to Tether for access to Tether's reserves. There is still a lot of missing information, but it seems clear that Bitfinex has lost $850 million dollars in some fashion and attempted to fulfill customer withdrawal requests from funds from Tether reserves.
Tether has recently updated its terms:
âEvery tether is always 100% backed by our reserves, which include traditional currency and cash equivalents and, from time to time, may include other assets and receivables from loans made by Tether to third parties, which may include affiliated entities.âThat other affiliated entity is Bitfinex. Tether now no longer holds all currency reserves - it now has extended a line of credit to Bitfinex - to the tune of $700 million, and may also hold shares in Bitfinex.
If Bitfinex has lost $850 million, then the equity that Tether holds in Bitfinex may be encumbered or worthless. If Bitfinex has taken out loans or drawn on its line of credit, those funds may never be returned. There is now clear evidence that tether is at serious risk of of not being backed at a 1:1 ratio.
What does this mean for you? Tether now is EXTREMELY risky to hold. There is clear evidence that Bitfinex has taken money from Tether, and its ability to repay it is in serious doubt. If Bitfinex truly has lost $850 million dollars, it may be insolvent. If Tether no longer has all the money backing it - because it owns Bitfinex assets, which are of questionable value, it's value will plummet, and all assets denominated in tether will appreciate.
There are lessons from Mt. Gox here. Mt. Gox did not just happen in one day. It played out over multiple months, the entire time with assurances that things are fine. Things were not fine - at all. The filing released today is damning. It is linked above, read it for yourself. The evidence presented in there is clear that something is terribly wrong at Bitfinex. It is not a certainty that Bitfinex is insolvent - but the filing lays out items that are terrifying to anyone holding significant financial assets related to Bitfinex and Tether entities.
Plain and simple: Depositors, and users of Tether are at serious risk of taking losses. Exchanges are the largest holders of Tethers, and when/if it becomes clear that tethers are no longer worth 1:1 they will be forced to freeze all tether assets until the situation can be straightened out. This process will potentially take years, into a decade or more. Mt. Gox funds are still not distributed to this day, over 5 years ago. The sheer complexity of a Bitfinex/Tether insolvency will play out over multiple jurisdictions and will take an eternity to sort out.
Again, read the primary documents filed by the AAGNY and decide for yourself if it is likely that Tether and Bitfinex are completely safe. Thousands of us lost our funds in Mt. Gox - and we've paid dearly. There are serious concerns if you are a Bitfinex customer, or if you hold USDT Tether on other exchanges.
Bitfinex has posted a response to the above: https://www.bitfinex.com/posts/356
2
u/Spartan3123 Apr 26 '19
Finally this is the only thing stopping the next bull market. Let's hope they get bulldozed quickly
2
u/Zape99 Apr 26 '19
What an absurd?!
Who will believe the woman which has stolen $750M of public funds and now wants to blame the leading crypto platform
At first her words have no proves at all
and as Bitfinex says "these Crypto Capital amounts are not lost but have been, in fact, seized and safeguarded" so there are needs to make panic!
3
u/mossmoon Apr 26 '19
It's going to be a lot more than $850 million after the BTC "hodl tulips" fraud plays out. If Bitfinex wasn't part of the club Tether would've been taken out three years ago.
3
Apr 26 '19
I said this probably about 9 months to a year ago. A Tether crash will lead to increases in crypto prices. As people flee Tether, demand for crypto will go up, not only in terms of Tether, but in real dollars as well.
2
1
1
1
1
1
-2
-5
u/bitmeister Apr 25 '19
So then Bitfinex-Tether got caught doing exactly what the Fed Res does. I don't see the problem here.
-7
u/outofsync42 Apr 26 '19
This is one of those strange times where something that wasn't worth anything (USDT) is used to buy BCH so the value of BCH is suspect because it pumped up due to people buying it with USDT. But if your not sure what the price of BCH is now and want to sell to hedge risk, the only thing to cash out to reliably was USDT (it had the volume). So what do you do? My guess is people are gonna sell some BCH to hedge risk for other for stable coins . But when people suddenly want to get out of their USDT positions i think you're going to see a rally in Crypto as they trade USDT for anything else. You will probably even see people sell BCH for USDT in the short run.
0
Apr 25 '19
[deleted]
13
u/324JL Apr 25 '19
Tethers should sell for a discount to represent this risk, which is apparently ... real.
Looks like the risk is $0.016 (1.6 cents) on the dollar now. What a joke, should be 10% or more.
3
u/barnz3000 Apr 26 '19
Wouldn't that be huge for Tether themselves? Can't they buy back their own coins? THEY have the ability to burn them and claim to their USD (just no-one else has the right to redeem).
So if they sell for a discount. They can happily buy them up. Which is potentially alot of price support.
It seems they're missing 30% of their funds. 850million of 2.8B (which is quite a lot IMO)
1
u/nonestdicula Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 28 '19
Not when they donât really have any money to buy them back with:
0
Apr 26 '19
[deleted]
5
u/shadowofashadow Apr 26 '19
Efficient, mature markets are almost always right. Crypto is neither efficient nor mature.
1
2
u/324JL Apr 26 '19
Where can I short USD-T? This could take years to play out, not enough return in that case, unless using leverage.
8
u/KohTaeNai Apr 26 '19
To short something, there has to be someone going long on the other end. And since USDT should never be worth more than 1USD, only a total idiot would go long on it.
3
u/phillipsjk Apr 26 '19
Kraken lets you short it.
The main risk has been that you pay interest on your loan while waiting for Tether to finally collapse. After interest and exchange fees, I have not been able to make much on shorting Tether.
There other week I also accidentally bought Tether instead of closing my short position (by not enabling leverage). Sold when the price rose enough to cover the trading fee.
2
u/tl121 Apr 26 '19
Sure, the market is always right, except when it is wrong, e.g. the NYSE on October 23, 1929, just before the crash. There were those who realized that the market was wrong, such as my grandfather who liquidated his investments in August, 1929.
0
Apr 26 '19
[deleted]
0
Apr 26 '19
[deleted]
2
u/tl121 Apr 26 '19
Some here are trying to develop a new financial system for all. We already have enough money for our own needs.
1
u/rnbrady Apr 26 '19
Wouldn't they still be redeeming USDT for USD at 1:1 so the peg will hold initially? The first 70% of USDT to be redeemed will get 100c on the dollar, the last 30% will get whatever proportion of the loan is repaid by Bitfinex.
0
Apr 26 '19
[deleted]
6
u/jessquit Apr 26 '19
Tethers have to be redeemable to someone. That someone is going to be pretty upset to learn that they're short a few hundred million bucks.
5
Apr 26 '19
Tethers have to be redeemable to someone.
Why? They explicitly aren't money or debt and Tether has no legal obligation to satisfy any redemption.
5
u/TypoNinja Apr 26 '19
Then why the USD reserves at all?
6
u/shadowofashadow Apr 26 '19
So they can publically declare they are backed without it being some sort of fraud?
2
2
u/unitedstatian Apr 26 '19
That someone is going to be pretty upset to learn that they're short a few hundred million bucks.
Unless that someone gets a paycheck from the government.
2
0
Apr 25 '19
[deleted]
0
Apr 25 '19
[deleted]
-6
u/dontlikecomputers Apr 25 '19
they took out a loan to cover the gap, if it's good enough for a bank...
0
Apr 25 '19
[deleted]
18
Apr 25 '19
That sub is just another group-think maxi den shithole just like /bitcoin
5
u/TheTruthHasNoBias Apr 26 '19
Once in a while there's a gem of decent insight, but overall its only really good for measuring the sentiment of the idiots.
4
1
u/fap_nap_fap Apr 26 '19
Yes, I remember reading those comments the day before this news came to light and thinking, "how can they be so blind when there is so much evidence that Tether is shady?"
0
69
u/coworkerhitandrun Apr 25 '19 edited Apr 25 '19
$850mm missing out of a $2.9 Billion dollar market cap does not look good. They've 'lost' roughly ~30% of their market cap.
Still seems to be trading around a dollar though.
I'm honestly surprised it took this long.