r/btc • Moderator • Apr 22 '19

The guy who won this week's MillionaireMakers drawing has received ~$55 in BCH and ~$30 in BTC. It will cost him less than $0.01 to move the BCH, but $6.16 (20%) in fees to move the BTC.

Post: https://np.reddit.com/r/millionairemakers/comments/bg1c7o/its_an_easter_miracle/

I arrived at this figure by looking at the number of inputs in his BTC address (13 at the time of this post), and using the current recommended fee for next-block confirmation on BTC, which is 58 satoshis per byte according to https://bitcoinfees.info/

This is also ignoring the fees that were required to send him the BTC in the first place. I see several transactions that had to pay $0.50 or more in fees just to send the guy $1. Those people are effectively only giving the guy $0.50 instead of the dollar they think they are sending, because he now has to pay the fee to move it himself.

This is why BCH still works as p2p ecash and BTC doesn't.

161 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

30

u/loomenaughty Apr 23 '19

How many people didn’t add a dollar to the BTC pot because of high fees?

8

u/Zyoman Apr 23 '19

make sense

5

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

How many people didn’t add a dollar to the BTC pot because of high fees?

Also how much is lost on fee among the people that donated?

Let’s say 10 peoples donate to reach $30...

With $1 fees that mean that mean $41 has been spend to unable that donation...

(10x $1 to millionmaker and them $1 to send the donation to the winner)

36% loss... wtf

So much inefficiency..

Edit: (To some degree it apply to miner too, they pay two time the fees.. first when they collect the payout from the pool and then when spend it.. I doubt there is many small miner left on BTC..)

Edit2: same calculation with BCH would have only led to total cost of ~$30.2\30.4 about ~1% loss.

5

u/Ithinkstrangely Apr 23 '19

These are the same minds that would prefer internal combustion vs electric powered by solar.

Yay status quo.

They don't understand, thus they don't know.

2

u/BifocalComb Apr 23 '19

What a terrible analogy. Intermittency is obviously a huge problem for solar. In fact it makes much more sense the other way around. Btc is supposed to be fancy and futuristic, but doesn't do a whole lot and is very expensive, whereas BCH is cheap, reliable and accessible.

1

u/Ithinkstrangely Apr 23 '19 edited Apr 24 '19

Google the phrase: lithium ion battery investments, Tesla Powerwall and Powerpacks. Energy storage investments make sense. Energy can now be stored efficiently...

And, it's not a terrible analogy. It's the terrible truth.

The Bitcoin protocol was specificly designed to scale on chain as a base layer to the point where we use our excess world energy to secure the financial system.

Fossil fuels are here for us to reach escape velocity. There is no existing technology to use electrical power to get off of Mother Earth.

This is fairly obviosus. Learn to extrapolate.

0

u/BifocalComb Apr 23 '19

Oh it can be? Strange that it isn't. It's almost like fossil fuels actually ARE cheaper and just because research is being conducted into other sources of energy they're not as cost effective.

0

u/Ithinkstrangely Apr 24 '19

Fossil fuels are currently cheap but still expensive.

1

u/BifocalComb Apr 24 '19

Expensive compared to...

1

u/Ithinkstrangely Apr 24 '19

Coal and gasoline. They no longer make economic sense.

Next is natural gas and nuclear.

Renewable >>>> Non-renewable

6

u/MiserableElection Apr 22 '19

Why can't he pay 0.0000001 satoshi per byte to move the BTC? this 58 sats/byte is for urgent transactions.

6

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Apr 22 '19

A transaction paying such a low fee would never confirm.

24

u/MiserableElection Apr 23 '19 edited Apr 23 '19

Then what about the 26201 transactions that were confirmed today with a fee between 0.000001 - 0.000003 1-3 sat per byte??

Edited for clarity

6

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Apr 23 '19

I thought you were talking about fractional satoshis. So you're talking about 10 to 30 sats/byte? Still quite expensive.

23

u/MiserableElection Apr 23 '19 edited Apr 23 '19

I'm talking about 1-3 sats per byte. There were over 26,000 transactions that were confirmed for 1-3 sats in the last 24 hours.

4

u/CollinEnstad Apr 23 '19

Hmmm... yes... let's do this over the last 365 days and see what % of the days this would work in.

0

u/MiserableElection Apr 23 '19

Well probably most of the last 365 days as the mempool has been empty during the bear market.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

[deleted]

-5

u/SatoshisVisionTM Apr 23 '19

It's not supposed to be like this.

According to what oracle, you?

2

u/polyclef Apr 23 '19

Mainly because bitcoin is worth over $5k, vs less than 1/10th of that like BCH.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

[deleted]

1

u/polyclef Apr 29 '19

Of course. But the OP was complaining about the cost in fiat too. Demand will increase price. That is basic.

Lightning, despite its current growing pains, allows for far more transactions overall than a bitcoin that only scales on chain. Even BCH developers admit that there is a cap to what is doable on chain. That is why they didn’t follow BSV’s choice to increase block size further.

The dispute comes down to whether to abandon the original bitcoin chain, BCH chose to, BTC didn’t. That is what a hard fork does.

6

u/jungans Apr 23 '19

Do you realize your advice cannot be good for much longer or the whole network security is at risk? BTC depends on fees for it's security. Blocks need to be full of txs paying a significant % of the block reward or there won't be enough incentive for miners to secure the network.

0

u/MiserableElection Apr 23 '19

And has any other bitcoin fork resolve that yet? we got like 50 years to worry about it.

It's like reminding everyone the sun's going to run out one day.

4

u/jungans Apr 23 '19

But that is exactly what core did. Worry RIGHT NOW about a situation 140 years from now. Bitcoin cash on the other hand follows Satoshi's design in which fees can be super low forever as long as enough people use it.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

During the previous bull market, my BTC transaction with a fee of 1.22 sats/byte once took several months to confirm.

https://www.blockchain.com/btc/tx/f831d0ba5034910e0e1beec5cd57ff090fb65d2bf9677d80430d985004d144ed

When people start actually using BTC, it becomes unusable. I can't imagine how absolutely fucking retarded one needs to be to support BTC at this point.

-2

u/MiserableElection Apr 23 '19 edited Apr 23 '19

If you look at the mempool from sep to dec there were plenty of periods when it was cleared out. Your claim that it took "several months" requires some more details. If a transaction goes unconfirmed for too long, it will eventually disappear.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

Are you blind?

0

u/MiserableElection Apr 23 '19

Yes but why then did a transaction get confirmed in minutes with someone paying 2.9 sats instead of taking months.

https://www.blockchain.com/btc/tx/bef5c643d5de9c05d52aa37f6f4930073820e35550b50b54cdfedd980c43b789

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

Because congestion clears out when usage drops.

0

u/MiserableElection Apr 23 '19

So let's go back a few blocks when it presumably was "full" and your transaction couldn't possibly get in....

https://www.blockchain.com/btc/tx/c2856dd385f87f50c5a0fa4ea12d8f072c9612c0cbac22068355858f2919eefb

Here A fee of 1.139 that waited 11 minutes was included.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

Let's go back to the time when blocks were continually full for months and the resulting accumulated congestion meant that transactions with fees that low had no chance of being confirmed.

https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#0,all

0

u/MiserableElection Apr 23 '19

But they did get confirmed otherwise the mempool wouldn't drop...

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

Yeah, several months later. Are you saying this is acceptable?

→ More replies (0)

3

u/AlessandroHH Apr 22 '19

6.16 Dollars Fees to send 20$ ? Are you sure you know about you are speaking ?

18

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Apr 22 '19

It will cost him $6.16 in fees, or 20% of the total, to move the $30 he has received thus far.

The more inputs a transaction has, the more money in fees you will have to pay. A tx containing 13 inputs, as his does, should be around 1968 bytes. Multiply that by 58 sats/byte and you get .00114144 BTC in fees, or $6.16

6

u/_false_positive Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 23 '19

Why not pay 2 sats per byte?

12

u/World_Money Apr 23 '19

2 sats per byte does not guarantee getting your transaction into the next few blocks which means high wait times. Additionally, if transactions fluctuate upward the mempool will grow larger and delay his transaction further.

If you believe that Bitcoin is a store of value then this is operating exactly as designed. If you believe Bitcoin is supposed to be the world's best money AND a store of value, then the wait times are unacceptable.

4

u/CatatonicMan Apr 23 '19

Or 1. Only reason to pay more is if you're in a hurry for some reason.

9

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Apr 23 '19

It would be better if all transactions would pay the same fee and confirm in the next block. That's how it used to work on BTC, and how it still works on BCH.

-6

u/CatatonicMan Apr 23 '19

Better for the users, certainly. Not necessarily better for the long term health of the network.

5

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Apr 23 '19

What is good for the users is good for the long term health of the network. The network needs users.

3

u/CatatonicMan Apr 23 '19

Might as well make all transactions free, then. That's even better for the users, right? Therefore it's even better for the network! Genius!

Better rename this sub to /r/nanocurrency post haste.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

The optimal fees will be determined by the market, not economically illiterate central planner assholes at Blockstream and their sheep followers.

0

u/CatatonicMan Apr 23 '19

Contrary to what your tinfoil hat tells you, Blockstream doesn't actually determine what the Bitcoin fees are.

→ More replies (0)

9

u/HVDynamo Apr 23 '19

If it's better for the users, then how is it bad for the network?

-1

u/CatatonicMan Apr 23 '19

Because the miners don't work for free. The block reward isn't going to be around forever.

-1

u/KayRice Apr 23 '19

Not taking a side in this "debate" but it's worth mentioning some other cryptocurrencies have "tail emission" concepts where the subsidy decreases, but never actually goes to zero.

1

u/CatatonicMan Apr 23 '19

True, but Bitcoin isn't one of them. Changing one of the fundamentals (the 21 million coin limit) isn't likely to gain support.

→ More replies (0)

6

u/anthonyoffire Apr 23 '19

There will be no long term health of the network if it fails to acquire users.

5

u/vswr Apr 23 '19

And $1 of that is mine. Now with CashShuffle!

21

u/Hold-and-hope Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 23 '19

Hardly “MillionaireMakers”. . .

8

u/vswr Apr 23 '19

Maybe someday.... but the novelty and concept are neat.

7

u/pigeon_shit Apr 22 '19

What quasi-lottery are you running?

1

u/KayRice Apr 23 '19

It's the new High Yield Investment Program (HYIP) from Pirate40 (Trendon Shavers) now in Reddit form.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

[deleted]

2

u/KayRice Apr 23 '19

Thank you. It's been so fucking long I forgot about the @ part. (Also fun fact the "40" in his name refers to the hexadecimal 0x40 being the ASCII code for "@")

12

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

$6 on $30 is fucking brutal..

0

u/SatoshisVisionTM Apr 23 '19

It is also bullshit, because why on earth would he use a next-block confirmation fee? He could easily wait a couple of hours for his transaction to go through.

This also highlights how much of a clickbait post this is, since it states that it will cost him $6 to move his btc, which is simply false. He can set a 1 sat/byte fee and submit his tx. If a miner mines it, he will have moved it.

This sub needs to stop pricing fees in dollars, and start pricing fees in satoshis per byte. Anything else is simply deliberate obfuscation of the truth.

10

u/CollinEnstad Apr 23 '19

This sub needs to stop pricing fees in dollars

Anything else is simply deliberate obfuscation of the truth.

Lol wot

-5

u/SatoshisVisionTM Apr 23 '19

Pricing in dollars skews the comparison, since BTC is worth almost 20x more than BCH. Even if you used 1 sat/byte on both chains, it would still appear as if BTC is much more expensive.

4

u/Rolling_Civ Apr 23 '19

Pricing in dollars skews the comparison, since BTC is worth almost 20x more than BCH. Even if you used 1 sat/byte on both chains, it would still appear as if BTC is much more expensive.

This is correct, but the general point the OP is making is stil valid. 20*(current BCH transaction fee for such a transaction) is still a fraction of what the BTC fee would be. BCH transactions would remain at 1sat/byte to get into the next block even when handling 8x the transactions per second BTC is right now.

6

u/MrAmos123 Apr 23 '19

If I buy $100 worth of BTC now and move it to an offline wallet, I'll pay $6 to do that. Netting me $94 worth by the time I actually have it in storage.

How does that seem remotely acceptable to you? It doesn't matter what you're comparing it against, it's still the value of $6 worth to handle that transaction, that's obscene.

I don't trade in BTC or BCH, but if I was to, I'd use BCH simply because the transaction fees are lower. Why would I trade in BTC, it makes no sense for me to do so. Especially do pay for mundane stuff like coffee, etc... $3 worth of coffee, plus $6 to make that transaction, seems fair, right?

-1

u/SatoshisVisionTM Apr 23 '19

The amount to move and the fee you pay are (mostly) unrelated. What matters is the size of the transaction. As such, a fee market will always price out smaller transactions, since you pay relatively much in fees compared to the value you are moving. If you set a normal fee (not next-block, but lower), you would not be paying $6, but less, and in the future, when fees rise further, those fees go into securing the network.

I would prefer using a network with higher fees if that meant my network is secure. Claim all you want, but BCH is at risk of a 51% attack.

7

u/ConalR Apr 23 '19

Ah brilliant! So when he goes to buy a coffee with that BTC all he has to do is pitch a lightning TM tent outside the shop and wait a few days for his 1 sat/byte fee payment to confirm, this IS the future of money. Those bcash fools got nothing on this

0

u/SatoshisVisionTM Apr 23 '19

He's currently got his digital gold spread out over multiple wallets. Since it costs effort to use a single wallet, it would be smarter for him to move all that digital gold into a single wallet when he doesn't need it directly, so he can use it from that single wallet when he does.

Since everyone on the planet needs to keep tabs on where everyone's digital gold is (UTXO pool), it is a wise decision to move all funds into a single UTXO, so everyone doing the verification can still have the UTXO in main memory.

6

u/BTC_StKN Apr 23 '19

Grandma should know better dammit!

3

u/pigeon_shit Apr 22 '19

I gave $5 USD worth of that BTC. Mainly bc I’m an asshole. But I still gave.

3

u/polyclef Apr 23 '19

Or he could wait a block or two and save himself the fee

14

u/KayRice Apr 23 '19

Fees only go down in BTC when less people use it. That's like telling someone who wants to buy and sell stocks to stop when trading volume is up, it's antithetical to the idea of trading and markets.

5

u/infinite_iteration Apr 23 '19

One only has to look at the last bull run to see the proof of that.

1

u/polyclef Apr 29 '19

Nope, that isn’t true. Fees go down when people increase the efficiency of their transactions. Otherwise we would still be at the fee levels of late 2017.

Fees go up and down over the course of any day. Much like traffic on the roads. If you have to drive during rush hour, then you deal with a longer commute. If you have a less urgent errand, you often wait until the roads clear a little bit.

Batching and segwit are like busses and subways. There is room for far more transactions on the network, but a lot of people are insisting on driving alone in their hummers.

1

u/KayRice Apr 29 '19

Fees go down when people increase the efficiency of their transactions.

Which has a finite limit to it. Individual transaction sizes can only be optimized so much, at which point the blocks are as full as they can be.

Fees go up and down over the course of any day. Much like traffic on the roads.

That fluctuation is based on less/more people using the blockchain at different times of day and the clearing of the mempool backlog.

Here is a graph of the transaction volume of Bitcoin https://i.imgur.com/EFrq7Mi.png

Batching and segwit are like busses and subways.

Sure, but with only a single lane road there is only so much optimization that can occur regardless of how large of a cart you use. As it stands legacy Bitcoin essentially has endless gridlock traffic. As more people go to use the roads they become even slower until people stop using the roads all together and start using alternative transportation.

2

u/sergbotz Apr 23 '19

This is bullshit, you can set a lower fee and wait a little longer. Waiting on 30 bucks is acceptable. Stop talking crap.

1

u/Artology Apr 23 '19

Stop using the term millionaire, it doesn’t work, nobody on Reddit has been made a millionaire apart from the shareholders

0

u/Spacesider Apr 23 '19

By this logic why not use another crypto that has even lower fees.

Nano has none.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

That is not true. You can pay low fee and wait few blocks

0

u/Ellielovee Apr 23 '19

LOL nobody put fees that high.. stupid pathetic people still trying to prove something against BTC.

BCH AND BTC are BOTH great.

Stop trying to make people believe that BCH is better than anything else.

-2

u/LuLu_Ma Apr 23 '19

so you think the BTC miners cooperated with core developers scam his money $6.16?

5

u/KayRice Apr 23 '19

No, the core developers ensure that block size is artificially constrained so they can attempt to justify LN and side chains. Miners just go along with it because higher fees seem enticing, despite the fact that almost all of their revenue still comes from block subsidy and not fees.

-1

u/LuLu_Ma Apr 23 '19

large block implies lower fees..., could BSV be better than BCH in this way?

what are the problems with lightning network and side chains? centralization? i thought everyone can participate in lightning network.

2

u/KayRice Apr 23 '19

large block implies lower fees..., could BSV be better than BCH in this way?

Why do you think BSV would be better to use?

what are the problems with lightning network and side chains? centralization? i thought everyone can participate in lightning network.

Have you seen any of the research from Peter Rizun?

-1

u/LuLu_Ma Apr 23 '19

" large block implies lower fees..., could BSV be better than BCH in this way? "

by experiment, buy 100 USD worth BTC/BSV/BCH and test the transaction fees.

" i thought everyone can participate in lightning network. "

untested. perhaps i'm wrong. i would like to try it anyway.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

[deleted]

6

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

Coretards don't even know how much BTC you're moving is irrelevant to the fee. Try multiple outputs, as in this case.