r/hiphopheads • u/drugzis . • Apr 15 '19
Dissect's Season 4 will be about Flower Boy
so hyped about this
196
u/JoeyGinaldi Apr 15 '19
I’m gonna listen, and I’m sure it will be a great season, but I was really hoping for something a little less recent. I understand he did the Lauryn Hill miniseason and the rest of his seasons are about contemporary albums. I’m just interested in him talking about something with a little bit more time behind it so it could possibly go more in depth about influence and the atmosphere surrounding the album when it came out vs. now and points like that. Hyped anyway, love his podcast and he does amazing work.
73
u/SeniorHankee Apr 15 '19
I'd love to hear some dissection on 2001,Illmatic, any ATCQ album and if we went recent The Book of Ryan would be a great one.
25
u/Cafuh . Apr 15 '19
Honestly I think you’re gonna need a whole other podcast to breakdown all of those. The guy from dissect made it pretty clear he’s gonna try to keep it modern for the main seasons, but he said he’d wanna do miniseries on some out there stuff even like classic music. Would be kinda cool to see that
6
0
Apr 15 '19
[deleted]
6
u/flexlikeherqueles Apr 15 '19
A season on OK Computer or Kid A would be an absolute treat, some of my fav albums of all time
31
u/sourcreamonionhummus Apr 15 '19
shoulda been die lit
15
u/ksgibtch Apr 16 '19
narrator's voice so today we're going to take a 30 minute analysis on why playboi carti wants to go fuck that bitch
16
130
Apr 15 '19
Ehhhhh, I'm kind of dissapointed by this because I feel like a) it's too new but most importantly b) it's completely self explanatory.
I love the album no doubt, but I don't feel like it was Tyler's best and even if it was I think there's more interesting stuff to cover.
45
u/zizzor23 Apr 15 '19
If anything, it’s probably going to look at what brought Tyler to this point kind of like how the Frank Ocean season also went into Channel Orange
8
u/BavidDeckham Apr 15 '19
I'm very excited for the Odd Future/Bastard/Goblin/Wolf episode. Through the wire and backpack rap kanye are my favourite dissect episodes so far
1
u/Beanbaker Apr 16 '19
First episode is on Spotify and does exactly that. Really in-depth and super interesting to get a perspective in early OF
21
u/Dragonpiece Apr 15 '19
From the interview, it sounds like he was more excited about talking about the production aspect than the lyrics specifically
72
u/ChipsAgainstDip Apr 15 '19
What is there to dissect? In this line tyler talks about driving. But in this next line, he name drops Leonardo DiCaprio - which suggests that he is possibly gay or just a really big fan of Leo.
-6
Apr 15 '19
This is my problem with the album, too. Good melodies, rhythms, and let’s not forget—cHoRdS!!1!
But the album just feels bland. I don’t know why everyone praises it for being creative and groundbreaking when it sounds like your basic Intro to Neo-Soul and Funk music album.
But that’s just my opinion.
19
u/AustinRiversDaGod Apr 15 '19
People praise it because of him coming out, and it's the least aggressive Tyler album by far, which means it has the most mainstream appeal.
Also, just personally, I think Tyler is much better at the smooth stuff. Like Bastard and all that were great ways to get people to pay attention to him, but songs like Lonely are a better lane for him. Also you see all the other Odd Future artists moving into a new direction sonically, and it was time for him to as well. It's funny: I loved Odd Future for being so over the top, but now they're all moving toward mainstream without cheapening their sound at all.
8
u/cjdennis29 Apr 15 '19
I'd argue Frank and Earl have gradually been moving further away from pop since their OF days.
3
u/AustinRiversDaGod Apr 15 '19
Yeah I worded that poorly. I meant to say their sound is becoming more mainstream without them embracing a more pop-y sound
8
u/real-prssvr Apr 15 '19
You might just not be looking at the whole picture.
For long-time Tyler fans invested in him as a person, it was a huge payoff to see his growth and maturation.
For Tyler fans invested in him as an artist, it was a huge pay off to see his music so refined, dynamic, and intelligible.
As an album itself, yes all those elements may be typical in isolation, but they're all strangely mixed together in a fashion very specific to him while still tying into the over all narrative.
For example, Glitter has some unusually aggressive rhythms and drum sounds for a love song - a quality shared with IFHY and See You Again. But it's also a creative choice that ties into the albums narrative: Glitter symbolizes the burst of joy and happiness Tyler feels as he leaves a voicemail describing his love to his crush. There's this slow build in the intro with swirling pads/guitars that guide Tyler's vocals into the main instrumental (his feelings slowly bubbling up before gushing out.) I could go on, but I'm sure Cole will provide a much better analysis, lol.
It's just a very thoughtful album with an impressive level of sophistication considering who made it. (Cherry Bomb might still be his best album though)
3
u/oldcarfreddy . Apr 15 '19
As someone who's kind of neutral on the album, I DO think he did a good job of incorporating that piano-driven 70s-inspired indie rock sound into a rap album, which is basically catnip for young people into more forward-thinking music these days. Like, to me is sounds like a perfect fusion (and better version) of all the alternative-R&B and indie spotify playlists I hear (Are & Be, Pollen, All the Feels) with Tyler's usual OF sound. Like, if you've ever tuned into this youtube channel but you also like rap, you'll basically love Flower Boy.
Like you said, I do think that sounds like it incorporates some pretty basic neo-soul / piano rock / bedroom pop or r&b. But that IS the wave right now. Basically distilling influences like Mac de Marco, Rex Orange County, The Internet, Tame Impala, etc. into a Tyler rap album. Personally I don't find that end result all that compelling. Mostly because I've never loved Tyler's shtick and I'm not into that current wave of minor-key bedroom pop. But I do think Tyler was very successful at it so he has one of the best examples right now of a rap album with that sound.
0
108
Apr 15 '19
What a disappointing pick. Flower Boy doesn't seem nearly as consequential of a record as TPaB, MBDTF, or Blonde.
31
u/Cafuh . Apr 15 '19
Yeah kinda weird seeing Flower Boy listen in that great of a list. Not sure which contemporary albums that have come out in the past couple years I’d want to see be dissected tho. Flower Boy is a great album just don’t know how flowerboy can have the same amount of content as blonde did for this podcast.
32
u/hugh__honey Apr 15 '19
Yeah I was hoping for Lemonade or A Seat At The Table if he kept with R&B/hip hop
Or Radiohead/Bon Iver/Sufjan
17
Apr 15 '19
Radiohead would be dope
12
u/oldcarfreddy . Apr 15 '19
That would but I think Radiohead has been dissected to death by rock journalists already for the most part. There are literally books on radiohead. I think the point of this series is to dissect more recent albums that maybe haven't been broken down like that.
8
4
u/Cafuh . Apr 15 '19
Honestly he may just be trying to grow his fan base as best as he can. Flowerboy might get more streams then Blondes season did, but if he did radiohead it would most likely have a lot less viewers.
2
u/caramelgod Apr 16 '19
Lemonade or A Seat At The Table
flower boy is better and more substantive than both those
prob shouldve been like the blueprint or perhaps something older even for rap.
but otherwise definitely should have been kid a
1
u/PrintShinji Apr 16 '19
I don't think The Blueprint (or anything related to Jay-Z) is going to happen as long as Spotify is sponsering the show.
0
Apr 15 '19
[deleted]
3
u/hugh__honey Apr 15 '19
Agree to disagree, but I think both of those are better options and more worthy than Flower Boy
And realistically, he'll probably do a few episodes on Tyler's past work in the beginning of the season like he has in past seasons
1
u/AustinRiversDaGod Apr 15 '19
Lemonade would have been fine, but I think this podcast works with albums that have a lot more material to explore. I've been dying to see more actual musical analysis of hip-hop. Any Roots album would have been better
3
u/Bitmazta Apr 15 '19
Cole really likes to go into the personal lives of the artist and what caused them to turn their music to this direction, so in that sense I can see much more content for Flower Boy considering the different stages in Tyler's career and what lead him to do a 180 with Flower Boy.
3
0
19
Apr 15 '19
where is the MADVILLIANY
17
u/waviestflow . Apr 15 '19
It tends to be albums with a narrative story arc or something where there was a lot of interesting content surrounding the album's release. I'm a huge DOOM fan as you can see by the flair but he's never really been a great storyteller beyond the comic book persona.
32
u/ox_ Apr 15 '19
The narrative is that the villain smokes a shitload of weed.
5
u/waviestflow . Apr 15 '19
Man with DOOMs narratives I'm thinking it's more than weed
4
Apr 15 '19
I'm an interview Madlib talked bout how him and DOOM would drop shrooms while working on Madvillany. Some quality inspiration for that album
2
26
u/schmatty23 . Apr 15 '19
Little disappointed tbh. Flower boy is a great album but it feels a little out of place next to TPAB, MBDTF, and Channel Orange/Blonde.
14
10
u/ssinha023 Apr 15 '19
I want this podcast to get so much bigger, partly because it's amazing and I want everyone to experience it, but also because I just really love the host, Cole. He puts so much care and effort into these episodes, you just don't find material like this everyday.
5
u/JGad14 Apr 15 '19
I want this podcast to grow. I believe that this album won't help it grow. I know multiple Dissect listeners who loved TPAB and MBDTF, but are now uninterested because of these last albums. I think he should go back to bigger name artists like Jay-Z and some more of the OGs to get his following bigger
3
u/BavidDeckham Apr 16 '19
He should be challenging his listeners to listen to something new instead of pandering to what they want
9
u/DoctorArK Apr 15 '19
There's definitely enough layers within the lyrics to do a great analysis. Excited to hear more about Garden Shed and how it thematically ties with the album's concept of "blooming" and growth artistically and perhaps sexually.
7
Apr 15 '19
People keep saying this album isn’t complex enough. I disagree. It’s not as esoteric as, say, MBDTF, but it has a lot to analyze. Fantastic symbols and motifs throughout.
4
Apr 15 '19
Meh. Not the biggest fan of Tyler, but I love the podcast. I also wasn’t as big on Frank Ocean like a lot of people. But his analysis made me love and appreciate his music way more.
65
u/Bob_The_Mexican Apr 15 '19
I heard about this show and got really excited about it until I actually heard it. I appreciate how much effort he puts it but it seems like he overanalyzes it so much that it's not even worth listening to. And this is coming from someone is who a mega fan of most of the artists the podcast has covered.
110
Apr 15 '19
I'd disagree. He plays the interviews audio directly and reads from any credible sources when they're available. When he's speculating, he makes sure to say that it's his personal speculation, but between all the seasons (especially MBDTF and Blonde/Channel), it seems like he does out of his way to avoid speculation unless it's a widely accepted theory.
11
Apr 15 '19
Agreed that he's pretty self-aware about his analysis in general. I love the content of the podcast. I just wish that his voice wasn't so monotone...
17
u/SheenEstevezzz Tell em play Metro Boomin at my Funeral Apr 15 '19
He's pretty open about reaching when he does reach
4
u/ssor21 Apr 15 '19
I like the podcast but in the first season, he's analyzing the skit on GKMC where Kendrick's friends are passing him the bottle (pass dot the bottle) and he mishears the line and overanalyzes it as "doctor bottle" being a metaphor for a healing bottle of alcohol or something lmao.
I had to stop listening for a bit after hearing that. Couldn't take it seriously.
5
u/oisin1001 Apr 15 '19
Same, I thought I'd love it, but it just didn't appeal to me when I sat back and listened.
4
u/jjool Apr 15 '19
Yeahh as much as I wanted to like it I agree with you. I only listened to the GKMC analysis but I thought that he overanalyzed a lot of it and came out with the wrong conclusions some of the time too.
1
u/wariosthegreat Apr 15 '19
I listened to the pyramids episode and I think he reached a different conclusion that’s a bit surface level
-4
u/mrpopenfresh Apr 15 '19
Sounds like an overanalyzing music nerd podcast for overanalyzing music nerd podcasts.
26
Apr 15 '19
Is this album worth the effort? I personally didnt find it amazing.
26
u/LighterThanWHITE Apr 15 '19
I think it depends on if you find tyler’s style / production / music appealing to you. Or if you thought tyler’s older album was better. For Me personally I loved his production on flower boy at his peak so I would love to hear more in depth to his inspiration or decisions when making the album. But ye different strokes for different folks.
8
u/cannibalholocaust- . Apr 15 '19
Its really good, but not nearly as great as some people make it out to be.
3
Apr 15 '19
I love the album but yeah the lyrics don't require that much analysis for but I could see someone dissecting the production choices
0
3
u/Cskryps22 Apr 15 '19
it’s probably my favorite album of all time, but i can acknowledge that there’s a lot more to it production-wise rather than lyrically (not to say that the lyrics aren’t good, but it isn’t blonde). i just happen to love tyler’s production style, imo nobody has really been able to replicate it for me.
5
u/ox_ Apr 15 '19
I really love it. Probably my favourite hip hop album of the last 5 years. Really original.
3
u/vvomann Apr 16 '19
Agree. One of my favorites. The feeling it gives you throughout is nostalgic and beautiful
1
u/PrintShinji Apr 16 '19
Personally yes, but I also got the bee tattood on my leg so biases.
I'm mostly interested what he can dissect more than whats already available.
-1
Apr 15 '19
I would say its my personal favorite album of all time but I wouldn’t put it on the top hip hop albums of all time.
I can get why people wouldn’t like it as much as i did.
It’s definitely worth another listen though. The musicality, production, and content matter are all super unique for a hip hop album.
I would recommend Aint got time or who dat boy for bangers, See you again or Boredom for more smooth tracks, and 911 or glitter for more poppy songs
3
u/BubbaUnkle Apr 15 '19
See You Again is wayyyy more poppy than 911, its like the nee yonkers
1
Apr 15 '19
No way lol. 911 definitely more poppy. The Mr Lonely part is more rap but the song is definitely more pop than see you again
14
u/viln Apr 15 '19
What a waste. Respect for Tyler for what he did independently and what he did for LGBT (after bashing them for his whole career prior), but this is not a worthy of an entire season of dissect.
The previously featured albums had so much more going for them musically and thematically.
3
u/zizzor23 Apr 15 '19
Will this be the season he finds an elusive quintuple entendre?
The show is interesting, but dear god is the host the most unenthusiastic motherfucker to ever exist.
3
7
2
u/Coolmansam123 Apr 15 '19
Can't believe I haven't heard of this podcast before! One listen to the first episode and I'm already completely hooked on it
2
u/chopkin92 Apr 15 '19
It's honestly incredible the time and effort that goes into each episode, I wish I'd found it later so there was more content to binge ☹️
2
u/pharlap1 . Apr 15 '19
Can't wait. This album was probably the album that made me fall in love with music.
2
4
u/its_a_bhoy Apr 15 '19
i think the tyler fans especially can say theres shit all to dissect here. comparing frank's style to tyler's, frank specialises in complex metaphors and heavy symbolism which is perfect for dissect. but with tyler he's so upfront theres really no hiding behind anything sophisicated enough to warrant an entire season of deep diving into his lyrical content. i mean shit even wolf or any of his first 3 albums would've been a better choice because at least it incorporates the old storyline which i'm sure people who only know tyler at face-value might find interesting. this is a strange choice for sure
8
u/Dragonpiece Apr 15 '19
From the interview, it sounds like the Cole is more excited to dissect Tyler’s production/sample side than the lyrics specifically
0
u/its_a_bhoy Apr 16 '19
this makes sense, i've seen tyler like some of his tweets about his admiration for his chord selection. i just assumed after listening to the series on channel orange that it would be primarily focused on lyricism
3
3
u/Hollywood_WBS . Apr 15 '19
ah yes.. the most overrated album of the decade. skipping this season i guess.
4
u/Micah_04 Apr 15 '19
FUCK YEAH! I love dissect and flower boy! I was contemplating they would do this, but I was thinking they would do saturation 1,2, or 3
2
2
2
u/*polhold04045 Apr 15 '19
Honestly there's not enough to really warrant a full season for flower boy.
Ideally he would do madvilliany or maybe a HOV album.
2
u/Chlorophyllmatic . Apr 15 '19
I think Flower Boy lacks both the gravity and the depth of the last three records they’ve analyzed. Not really feelin this one.
1
u/djmk671 Apr 15 '19 edited Apr 15 '19
I think it’s going to be interesting, he’s probably going to go into Tyler’s relationship with OF and his early style of music... as someone who has fucking LOVED Tyler since Bastard I’m hype.
EDIT: I’m thinking a theme in this season is going to be Tyler’s love for riding bikes, sorta like how in the Frank Ocean season he talked about cars throughout.
1
Apr 15 '19
As a huge frank ocean fan I tried listening to the dissect on him but I just couldn’t enjoy it. There was some interesting points but I feel music shouldn’t be over analyzed to the degree it is in dissect (ironic based on the name). I respect the work and research but I find it can take the enjoyment out of music listening to that.
1
1
u/WhyNotBatman Apr 15 '19
I could have guessed by the Pothole clue but all the other clues seemed somewhat random.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Dragonpiece Apr 15 '19
I've listened to Flower Boy literally every day, at least one song, so this excites me a lot. Have watched numerous reviews, reactions,etc so I am so excited to check out this podcast. I loved their TPAB dissection, and I am curious to see how the podcast tackles this album.
1
1
1
Apr 16 '19
Thanks a lot for posting this, never heard of the show but I just listened to the first episode of season 1 and I got to say I'm impressed. I love all the albums he has done so far so I'm super excited to listen to all of these.
1
1
1
1
u/iamnicholas Apr 15 '19
I didn’t see the tweet, but I saw the cover art update and was like HOLY SHIT YES
1
0
-2
0
-3
u/Moron_on_Oxy- Apr 15 '19
If you don’t feel like it belongs I encourage you to sit with it again. I’ve never seen an album be so cohesive in sound, aesthetic, and content. The production is amazing and I imagine what they will be focusing on.
Here’s an hour long interview with Tyler about the album, I’m sure will be a frequent point of reference. Must watch if you love the album
-2
0
Apr 15 '19
[deleted]
131
u/PlayboiCartisAdLibs Apr 15 '19
I agree, I was kinda hoping for something like Doom or Hov or something. The Score or Miseducation of Lauryn Hill would be dope too
174
36
u/ChaosRevealed . Apr 15 '19
4:44 would've been an insane album to do narrative wise, if he were looking for a recent album to do
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)16
→ More replies (2)27
u/radubs Apr 15 '19
have you listened to dissect before? cause if so, you know that the interview is nowhere near in depth as this show is finna get. shit he'll probably use the shit out of it.
0
Apr 15 '19
[deleted]
24
u/basa_maaw Apr 15 '19
Definitely recency bias was the cause.
27
u/oldcarfreddy . Apr 15 '19
Also Radiohead's worthy of in-depth analysis, but it's been done before in everything from books to tons of rehashed online articles, reviews and rankings.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)54
u/hugh__honey Apr 15 '19
Yeah I like Tyler but this feels like an enormous step down
Kanye, Kendrick, Frank, and Lauryn are four of the very best artists alive, and those respective albums are generation-defining.
Tyler is like... cool. His album is great. But it's not one that scholars and analysts are gonna discuss in years the way they will (and already do) with those others.
I wish he kept to analyzing these highly significant, gamechanging ones. Like Lemonade or A Seat at the Table. Or something by Radiohead, Sufjan, or Bon Iver.
I feel like all the Frank enthusiasts who tuned in for the last season kinda pushed him to do Tyler because the two have a big overlap in fans.
→ More replies (4)
734
u/kinkijou Apr 15 '19
What is this show? First time hearing about it