r/btc • • Apr 09 '19

Do you think Bitcoin needs to increase the block size? You're in luck! It already did: Bitcoin BCH. Avoid the upcoming controversial BTC block size debate by trading your broken Bitcoin BTC for upgraded Bitcoin BCH now.

I personally don't think BTC will ever attempt a hard fork block size increase. Here's why.

For years now, big blockers have been unwelcome in the BTC camp. There have been personal attacks, censorship, even "Scaling Bitcoin" conferences where nobody was allowed to talk about ways to increase the block size. Everyone really invested in the technology of onchain scaling left BTC between 2014-2018.

Meanwhile BTC is still the home for all the small block tribalists and will remain so. So the ratio of big blockers to small blockers within BTC is worse than ever.

So if a hard fork occurs,

  • all the small blockers

  • all the undecideds

  • and everyone who isn't paying attention

... follow the non-upgraded chain. Trying to hard fork an upgrade in these conditions is very very risky and is likely to produce just another minority spinoff like BCH. Regardless, any attempt to upgrade is sure to induce a nasty war and a coin split.

Plus you can't roll back Segwit. Not practically. So BTC's codebase remains clunky and encumbered by the legacy of the Segwit SF. And CTOR? Fuhgeddaboudit. There really isn't a practical way for BTC to somehow get on BCH's upgrade path. The two codebases are increasingly incompatible.

The good news is that if you support big block Bitcoin, you're in the right place. That's what BCH is: the Bitcoin that got the upgrade.

BCH has worked for the last 18 months to restore the scaling plan most of us thought we were signing up for before the Segwit guys got in charge: scaling up the protocol to support p2p ecash for casual transactions. With Graphene and xthinner coming online, we have two different block transmission technologies capable of approaching "Visa-like" scale. And clients like Flowee are already demonstrating the power of parallel validation (reports are that Flowee can validate the entire historical blockchain in just a few hours on modest hardware). Devs are already working on integrating these technologies into the various BCH clients. It's just a guess, but I think we'll be able to claim "Visa-like" scaling achievements within the year. And also IMO, I believe that to be able to credibly claim "Visa-like" scaling is the holy grail, the killer app.

BTC had a shot at its scaling plan. It had all the advantages: name recognition, political momentum, and a powerful social media astroturfing campaign. Nevertheless, it failed. BCH kept the original strategy of onchain scaling and is clearly winning the Bitcoin scaling war.

IMO it's just a matter of time before the markets start catching on that they've been betting on the wrong Bitcoin for the last 18 months.

So you can avoid the upcoming controversial BTC block size debate by trading your broken Bitcoin BTC for upgraded Bitcoin BCH now.

207 Upvotes

191 comments sorted by

19

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

You summarized all quite nicely.

TO me it make no doubt BTC will never its block size limit, the proof is that how violently the 2MB upgrade was rejected while it would have been the best time to do so and would have likely killed all momentum toward BCH.

It remain that Dev can found yet another convoluted SF to achieve something similar to an increase in capacity.. I am doubtful and BTC will start to become an incredible code mess (I guess that good for dev). ..

7

u/fiah84 Apr 09 '19

the proof is that how violently the 2MB upgrade was rejected while it would have been the best time to do so and would have likely killed all momentum toward BCH.

I wonder how long it will take before they realize what a monumental fuck up that was

7

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

I wonder how long it will take before they realize what a monumental fuck up that was

They think it was a great victory..

7

u/jzcjca00 Apr 09 '19

It wan only an error if you assume their goal to make Bitcoin succeed. Remember, bankers own Blockstream, so it is likely that their goal was to harm Bitcoin. They were very successful at that.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

It remain that Dev can found yet another convoluted SF to achieve something similar to an increase in capacity.. I am doubtful and BTC will start to become an incredible code mess (I guess that good for dev). ..

I'm curious why you think a soft fork to increase capacity is a bad thing. The segwit SF took me a while to understand, I'll admit, but it definitely increased capacity since most blocks are around 1.2MB and there have been some 1.6MB or more. What if we figure out a way to increase this to 3 or 4 MB with a soft fork? If the code works, why is it a problem? I hope you don't take this as negative, I'm genuinely curious why some people are against soft fork such as segwit. Thanks.

15

u/jessquit Apr 09 '19

https://www.yours.org/content/your--full-node--is-impotent-dfcca95e81ec

TLDR soft forks are coercive, can result in terrible code bloat, and sometimes are straight-up exploits against the existing rules.

-9

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

tldr soft forks are the only decentralized way to develop regardless of how much you believe them to be coercive or bloated.

2

u/jessquit Apr 09 '19

"decentralized"

15

u/wisequote Apr 09 '19

“Decentralized way to develop” lmao, when there’s a single entity (Blockstream) controlling a centralized repo after kicking out every dev with an on-chain vision? When you guys literally ban anyone who points out this centralization? When everything revolves around a single client “Bitcoin Core” managed by a bunch of bought-out developers with visions to create 300kb blocks and popping champagne when the failed “fee market” dynamics hit?

There’s more decentralization in my balls than there is in Blockstream’s BTC.

-8

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

complain about blockstream all you want, but miners can decide completely on their own to softfork whatever change they want, no matter who commits code to some random repo

3

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

complain about blockstream all you want, but miners can decide completely on their own to softfork whatever change they want, no matter who commits code to some random repo

That’s more centralised than a HF.

For an HF to pass it need both miner and node operators to approve the upgrade.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

no. it just needs an authority to tell the world which chain is the "real chain". the incumbent chain can be continued to be mined, or another hardfork could take place at the same time. this is where the central control takes place - deciding which chain is officially the "real chain".

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19

no. it just needs an authority to tell the world which chain is the «  real chai » ». the incumbent chain can be continued to be mined, or another hardfork could take place at the same time. this is where the central control takes place - deciding which chain is officially th«  « real chain ».

It is not.

SF are just as likely to create split, see segwit for example.

SF are coercive because they are activated only by miner and therefore make much easier to activate.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19

SF are just as likely to create split, see segwit for example.

softforks will cause splits if there is not concensus or mining power behind it. If the incumbent chain continues with the most hashpower the softfork fork will not be able to orphan it, and there wont be any doubt that the incumbent chain is still the real chain.

And segwit did not cause a fork.

SF are coercive because they are activated only by miner and therefore make much easier to activate.

Yes, softforks are much easier to activate, but they actually still require concensus, unlike hardforks where you just have a developer declare which chain is the real chain regardless of concensus.

Just a quick question: would you have called BSV BCH if BSV had had the most hashpower?

→ More replies (0)

4

u/wisequote Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

Haha, that’s not how it works, remember when miners were signalling for Segwit2X? Your arguments were quite different at the time, you even called it “User-Activated Soft-fork”, remember? when that “now idle sock puppet lol” Shaolinfry implemented banker code?

That was a single repo talking wasn’t it?

Edit: removed some needless words.

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

yes, users can also enforce additional rules. whether miners will also mine according to those rules is another question. with uasf this was successfull because a non negliable amount of miners also wanted to mine that potential fork.

4

u/knaekce Apr 09 '19

You aren't wrong. But they introduce huge technical debt and are way more complicated than hard forks. If BTC keeps introducing more changes via soft forks, I expect development speed to get slower and slower, because the code becomes so complicated and fragile that it is a nightmare to test and debug.

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

i dont think perceived "technical debt" is an argument for centrally controlling development through hardforks.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

tldr soft forks are the only decentralized way to develop regardless of how much you believe them to be coercive or bloated.

Can elaborate, what is your definition of decentralised here?

4

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

m curious why you think a soft fork to increase capacity is a bad thing. The segwit SF took me a while to understand, I’ll admit, but it definitely increased capacity since most blocks are around 1.2MB and there have been some 1.6MB or more. What if we figure out a way to increase this to 3 or 4 MB with a soft fork? If the code works, why is it a problem? I hope you don’t take this as negative, I’m genuinely curious why some people are against soft fork such as segwit. Thanks.

Well segwit took a massive amount of code (The biggest code change in bitcoin history)

Increasing block limit as an HF is merely a single parameter change.

Increasing complexity on critical is a bad idea and should be avoided.

23

u/cmajorlips Apr 09 '19

Hello, I’m new to all this and I’d like to convert some of my BTC to BCH, how can I do that with minimal fees?

19

u/CatatonicAdenosine Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

Any major exchange will do. Coinbase, Bitstamp, Kraken, Binance etc. if you download the bitcoin.com wallet you should also be able to do it in-app with sideshift, I believe.

Edit: scratch Binance and add CoinEx.

10

u/____jelly_time____ Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 09 '19

And note Binance still keeps BCH under the ticker BCHABC.

13

u/jessquit Apr 09 '19

Pro tip: an exchange that doesn't call a coin by its proper ticker is either incompetent or deceptive.

When BTC and BCH split i don't remember anyone listing the tokens as BTCcore and BTCcash. Nor did they do this when ETH split. It's only different this time, because this time it hurts BCH.

0

u/Giusis Apr 09 '19

Pro tip: an exchange that doesn't call a coin by its proper ticker is either incompetent or deceptive.

It's really not different than you calling the "Bitcoin Cash" "Bitcoin BCH" ..two weights two measures? :)

6

u/wisequote Apr 09 '19

That makes no sense, you make no sense.

His point was clear, exchanges should call it Bitcoin Cash BCH - the fact that it’s the real Bitcoin doesn’t need to be reflected in the name, when it’s damn well evident in utility.

Visa-scale, on-chain, dirt cheap transactions on Bitcoin Cash are coming in no time while you sit here and word play like an idiot.

We’re not going to scale, we already scaled and are scaling, there are no spam transactions on BCH, all transactions are welcome.

Good luck holding the BTC bags for your banker bros.

0

u/Giusis Apr 09 '19

Calling a crypto-currency with a different name it's exactly what the guy was criticizing: it's done for the solely purpose of deceiving people.

A cryptocurrency named "Bitcoin BCH" doesn't exist (as of today), there's the Bitcoin Cash and the Bitcoin, they are two different crypto-currencies. Stop trying to bend the reality to push your narrative.

Good luck holding the BTC bags for your banker bros.

You're so blind to not understand that this is true for every coin despite your beliefs. I own an equal amount of Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash "bags". See, I called them with their proper name, I must be a genius.

1

u/loneystoney44 Apr 09 '19

Came here to say this dude's just an everyday cunt

0

u/Giusis Apr 09 '19

Ahah, tnx.

-4

u/aeroFurious Apr 09 '19

100% truth right here. He just called this whole subreddit incompetent or deceptive.

1

u/CatatonicAdenosine Apr 09 '19

Good point. Don’t use those arseholes.

2

u/mars128 Apr 09 '19

Or CoinEx as it has BCH pairs instead of just BTC/ETH/USDT etc.

1

u/CatatonicAdenosine Apr 09 '19

How could I forget!!

6

u/saddit42 Apr 09 '19

for something easy to use try: https://fairshift.io/ or https://sideshift.ai.

Otherwise just use https://pro.coinbase.com (might have slightly better rates)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Bitcoin.com will do it with one of their tools

-1

u/sixgears Apr 09 '19

Please educate yourself before you do this.

-5

u/Hakametal Apr 09 '19

13

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Apr 09 '19

Shapeshift is convenient but has a poor exchange rate...

Should really go to a large exchange, such as Kraken.

11

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Apr 09 '19

Or coinex. Not big, but decent.

3

u/lubokkanev Apr 09 '19

Also requires an account like https://changely.com

0

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

[deleted]

1

u/cmajorlips Apr 09 '19

what are the fees?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/cmajorlips Apr 10 '19

Heyyo what are your rates?

1

u/TypoNinja Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

I've heard about people being required to identify themselves on ChangeNow. Could you clarify what's your KYC policy?

Edit: typo.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/TypoNinja Apr 09 '19

That's reasonable, at least the funds are not on hold. Thanks for the clarification.

1

u/moleccc Apr 09 '19

you can request a refund if you decide not to disclose your identity.

Thanks for not taking peoples funds hostage. Should actually be "the norm" and no reason to be thankful, but too many exchanges go that route.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

Bitcoin is a chain with the most cummulative POW. I want bigger blocks, but i want it in Bitcoin. Let's be honest, globally it doesn't matter what i or you want. It matters what the majority thinks, or rather how they act. If the majority wanted bigger blocks, they would appreciate this chain more expensive than 1mb chain and hashrate would be on the side of bigger blocks.

11

u/jessquit Apr 09 '19

So you're saying Bitcoin BTC will always be the majority chain tomorrow simply because it was the majority chain yesterday?

Agreed to disagree.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

I said that i want bigger blocks in Bitcoin. Whether it will hard fork in the BTC network or changing the balance of power in favor of BCH. Intuitively, the first event seems more likely to me, but who know.

2

u/libertarian0x0 Apr 09 '19

The first thing already happened. It could happen again, but the big block chain will still be the minor one. BTC is the chain of small and tiny blockers (1 MB/300 KB), changing that could take years.

3

u/tofur99 Apr 09 '19

I mean it's not even close to being dethroned, I think that's everyone's point. You guys are living in pure hypothetical land because reality isn't even close to lining up.

8

u/Phucknhell Apr 09 '19

remember when BTC was 5 bucks, I do. nothing is forever, and the longer the Core devs treat their users like plebs, the more they will scatter for other coins..

-1

u/tofur99 Apr 09 '19

Too bad the ETF talk is all for bitcoin and not BCH..... something something security

3

u/jungans Apr 09 '19

Ironically the ETF could kill BTC as a viable medium of exchange for most people. These people will then be forced to move to BCH if they want to transact. So I see a BTC ETF as a catalyst of BCH's success.

-4

u/tofur99 Apr 09 '19

I mean, biggest thing I see in this shitstain of a sub (no offense) is the desire to see bitcoin("core") destroyed, go down in flames, and have their chosen one rise to the throne in it's place.

When in reality there is plenty of fiat floating around the global markets looking for a home that both can massively succeed simultaneously.

7

u/jungans Apr 09 '19

I just want Core to be honest and say BTC is not for the people. BTC is for bankers and wall street investors and speculators. There may be a use case there. Maybe to replace SWIFT. But BTC is no longer p2p cash.

-2

u/tofur99 Apr 09 '19

That's bullshit, so why would they say that? Just because those big money interests are finally showing up doesn't change the fact that anyone can own and use bitcoin.... just like they can own and use other cryptos.

Usage of something can change/evolve over time you know....bitcoin looks to be evolving into more of a anchor/home base for other cryptos. As in, have most of your wealth parked in it and shuffle it into a coin like nano for day to day use, have some in monero for privacy reasons, etc.

7

u/jungans Apr 09 '19

anyone can own and use bitcoin

Not true. Half the world lives on what costs to make a single transaction in BTC.

Usage of something can change/evolve over time you know

I don't have a problem with this. I just don't give a damn about what BTC is trying to become.

→ More replies (0)

21

u/CatatonicAdenosine Apr 09 '19

You’re speaking as if the experiment has already run its course. We’re just at the beginning.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

[deleted]

3

u/tippr Apr 09 '19

u/CatatonicAdenosine, you've received 0.00166261 BCH ($0.5 USD)!


^^How to use | ^^What is Bitcoin Cash? | ^^Who accepts it? | r/tippr
Bitcoin Cash is what Bitcoin should be. Ask about it on r/btc

3

u/CatatonicAdenosine Apr 09 '19

Thanks! It’s so good to see the tipping bots lighting up again after so long. I’ve just started back with chaintip too. There’s some great enthusiasm building in this sub!

5

u/mjh808 Apr 09 '19

The majority don't know much about what they invested in, they are just told that BCH is a scam.

8

u/SomeoneElse899 Apr 09 '19

Miners want money. They might want bigger blocks, but the people buying up Bitcoin probably don't understand most of how Bitcoin works, therefore they continue to pay for the Bitcoin name. At least that's my theory.

4

u/MillionDollarBitcoin Apr 09 '19

I also would have preferred it to be in BTC, and believed they would fix it eventually.

I only realized that BTC is broken once I paid a $50 transaction fee myself.

Maybe more people come to the same conclusion once they're actually paying those fees themselves, so I would not declare the competition over just yet.

2

u/jungans Apr 09 '19

You speak as if high fees are something new. A huge number of people have been burned by high fees already. They were silenced and banned from the community. There is no way of gaining momentum for a change against blockstream's interests in BTC. Your only hope is bs decides big blocks are the new goal. But they cannot profit from that so I don't believe it's ever going to happen.

2

u/MillionDollarBitcoin Apr 09 '19

My point is that all the people buying into the BTC "brand" might only see the problem once they actually have to pay those fees, instead of just talking about them.

And this will take time. I don't believe a lot of people paid those kind of fees yet.

3

u/jungans Apr 09 '19

Asolutely.

  1. Buy into "money of the future" BTC.

  2. Make transactions losing a huge % of their value in fees or alternatively get stuck for days in the mempool.

  3. Complaint about this and get silenced and/or get told to suck it up or GTFO.

  4. Go to some other project (maybe BCH if they are lucky) or give up crypto altogether.

This has been happening for too long already. There is no way new users could gather critical mass to generate a change on BTC while the censorship prevails.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

It matters what the majority thinks

That's a fallacy that's been propagated but is yet to be seen

4

u/Hakametal Apr 09 '19

The entire concept of 'money' relies on participants to believe that it has value. It's why people don't burn fiat cash, becasue they believe it has value. People follow value, they don't actually care what it it.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Last month people robbed a bank to scatter the paper money in the street just to make the point the money is worthless.

People don't burn fiat because it has purchasing power. That power is not backed by belief.

2

u/Hakametal Apr 09 '19

It is by the vast majority of the population.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

You speak for them?

3

u/Hakametal Apr 09 '19

Not at all. I'm simply pointing out reality. Why do you think people sell their crypto for fiat? Becasue fiat has more real world use. That's the reality of today.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Not at all. I'm simply pointing out reality

I don't think your perspective is reality for anyone but you.

1

u/Hakametal Apr 09 '19

Uhm, ok buddy. Cya!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Go stay there pls.

30

u/SeriousSquash Apr 09 '19

Huge miners that hold BCH but don't hold BTC have the incentive to permanently keep BTC at 1 MB.

5

u/_false_positive Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 09 '19

why?

16

u/ricardotown Apr 09 '19

As long as BTC is broken, people will continue to convert to BCH.

8

u/tr14l Apr 09 '19

It's why I did. BTC is unusable for any practical application. It's only good for speculation, and things that are good for speculation without having any sort of rooting in real world transactions eventually go away.

1

u/thegrandknight Apr 09 '19

Btc is worth 10 times at least bch

16

u/igobyplane_com Apr 09 '19

so what? i don't understand this logic. it is a point in time valuation. it doesn't mean BTC will be worth 10x BCH in a year. more importantly, it doesn't mean BTC is worth what it is trading at now. it is a simple observation, and justifies almost nothing at all. to assert that the price of x crypto being 10x the price of y crypto means it's 10x as useful or better or whatever, is just delirious thinking.

2

u/erydayimshufflin Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 09 '19

hey, its worth so much but I can't use it! Brilliant!

/u/tippr $1

When you got to spend a dollar to send a dollar on the BTC chain, that just screams justification for its valuation.../s

2

u/tippr Apr 09 '19

u/igobyplane_com, you've received 0.00336059 BCH ($1 USD)!


^^How to use | ^^What is Bitcoin Cash? | ^^Who accepts it? | r/tippr
Bitcoin Cash is what Bitcoin should be. Ask about it on r/btc

1

u/igobyplane_com Apr 11 '19

thanks so much!

10

u/FirebaseZ Apr 09 '19

Exactly, and BCH is 10 times more functional - cheaper, faster, already scaled... It's both a store of value (like BTC) and a means of exchange. So the space between BTC's price and BCH's capability is potential gain. Opportunity. Blue sky. In other words, what if you could buy a product that worked 10 times better for 10 times less? What if, because of branding, mispackaging, you could buy a Range Rover for 95% off? You can, because BTC is a brand, while BCH is a product. BTC is pretending to be BCH, and there's opportunity in that deception.

5

u/moleccc Apr 09 '19

once upon a time... myspace was worth more than facebook

5

u/tr14l Apr 09 '19

Yeah, and the macarena was huge. Doesn't mean it wasn't stupid af

-7

u/thegrandknight Apr 09 '19

That is literally the most retarded analogy ever. Just made me glad i dumped that bch trash when I did

14

u/tr14l Apr 09 '19

Cool. But without feasible real world application, you're betting on a terminal patient. Stocks only work because the companies USE the investment from third parties. Btc isn't usable for anything other than buying dips and selling peaks

-8

u/thegrandknight Apr 09 '19

Sure ok lol

11

u/tr14l Apr 09 '19

Solid come back. I concede.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/mayoayox Apr 09 '19

Will it go up 50% in a half hour like BCH did earlier last week? If you care about investing, rather than use case, it's about percentages and not value. Bch has way more room to grow than btc.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Down from 30x a few weeks ago. Store of value, indeed.

11

u/tralxz Apr 09 '19

BTC should upgrade their blocks to 300kb.

4

u/desA_diaw Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 09 '19

BTC is heading to its declining stage. BCH is rising. It is what it is.

12

u/HenryCashlitt Apr 09 '19

Bitcoin Cash (BCH): upgraded money for everybody!

u/chaintip

4

u/chaintip Apr 09 '19

u/jessquit, you've been sent 0.00337381 BCH| ~ 1.00 USD by u/HenryCashlitt via chaintip.


13

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Apr 09 '19

I think there is new propaganda coming from core side and it is - "we always wanted blocksize increase and we have no idea what this fuzz is all about. Bitcoin cash is unnecessary and rushed initiative. We are heading same direction anyway and always were as LN needs it".

It will be fun.

Edit: they realized they fucked up with small blocks?

12

u/libertarian0x0 Apr 09 '19

I think it's just a marketing strategy: they are telling to new comers "don't move to BCH, eventually we'll increase the block size".

8

u/cipher_gnome Apr 09 '19

No. Just stalling as usual.

1

u/niXta- Apr 09 '19

What are you talking about?

As far as I know BTC has had no ambitions to raise the block size unless a 2nd chain would need it to, for a long time. And there is no need for that right now. In the future? Probably.

The whole idea is to keep the block size tight to make the blockchain resilient and more secure (can’t be spammed efficiently).

BTC’s motives are also to keep the blockchain size down to make sure that as many as possibly can run nodes and mine (minimize storage and bandwith need), maximizing decentralization and security.

I don’t really see anyone working for BTC care about high fees or slow confirmations today/in the near future, because that’s not the goal, BTC isn’t finished and you should probably not use it yet. You should wait for a 2nd layer that will handle 99% of transactions on the chain.

BCH on the other hand stays with the original idea and I don’t see any scaling problems at all since day one.

As far as I can see it has a little less security overall, but not too concerning. 0-conf and high node/mining entry cost increasing centralization weakening security slightly, for example.

Either way you scale, you seem to increase centralization.

BCH’s biggest advantage is the easy and simple plan that worked since day one.

BTC's advantage is that a 2nd layer might work better than on chain at some point in the future, and slightly better security/centralization on chain. It does feel a bit risky and no one likes to wait. Especially as there are alternatives that are "finished" already.

3

u/CatatonicAdenosine Apr 09 '19

Hear hear! Well said.

u/chaintip

2

u/chaintip Apr 09 '19

u/jessquit, you've been sent 0.0003 BCH| ~ 0.09 USD by u/CatatonicAdenosine via chaintip.


3

u/abtcff Apr 09 '19

well said!

2

u/sq66 Apr 09 '19

This information should be stickied. Maybe a bit simpler and shorter version with link to more details. There are probably lots of people needing to find this out. "Don't get into an unnecessary fight about BTC blocksize, just use BCH."

1

u/tedand Apr 09 '19

It is not an information, it his an opinion.

7

u/jessquit Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

Much of what I wrote is my opinion, true.

What's not opinion is that in 2017 Bitcoin split due to a fundamental difference in values.

One group wished to pursue what it believed was the original scaling plan for Bitcoin where the block size limit was not intended to be an economic limiter.

The other group went the path of limiting the chain using the block size limit to force usage into second layers (Lightning).

The group that upgraded Bitcoin following the original scaling plan that maintained the block size limit well above the steady state transaction throughput and which rejected segwit is BCH.

The group that went a different way and rejected the original plan for Bitcoin is BTC.

BTC and BCH are now fundamentally different platforms, with BTC making sweeping changes to the codebase in order to implement segwit, and with BCH modifying the protocol in order ways ie CTOR. As such it is unlikely that BTC can ever get back onto the original (BCH) scaling plan.

As for the rest. Exchanges showed strong bias against BCH and relegated it to a diminutive name and ticker. At no time was BCH considered an equal contender to the Bitcoin name. One exchange listed it as bcash. That exchange lists it now as BAB. There has also been a terrific amount of community manipulation and disinformation about BCH. Do you think the market has accurately priced BCH? How could it?

My opinion as to which version of Bitcoin is proving itself to be the most viable cryptocurrency is indeed just my opinion, but I do think the evidence is all around us.

-3

u/witu Apr 09 '19

You're leaving a out some key details here, like Asicboost and Bitmain. BCH was not created out of some sort of altruistic love of the holy white paper.

6

u/sq66 Apr 09 '19

The information is that there was already a fight around this subject, and the resolution was a split into BTC and BCH. You may choose to use whichever you like. If you like to go the BCH route there is no need to try and bend the BTC-world to bigger blocks.

1

u/James-Russels Apr 09 '19

Wasn't there a post just the other day showing all the cost calculations for a full node, and Visa-level transaction volume requires something like 1GB blocks? You see that happening within a year?

6

u/jessquit Apr 09 '19

I think we'll be most of the way there, yes. Close enough to claim that we're competitive. Once we're safely producing 500MB blocks I don't think there will be much question that "Visa scale" is doable. Maybe we'll start by claiming "Mastercard scale" and go from there. We've already hit PayPal scale.

1

u/James-Russels Apr 09 '19

I'm skeptical but hope you're right!

RemindMe! One Year

1

u/RemindMeBot Apr 09 '19

I will be messaging you on 2020-04-09 22:59:25 UTC to remind you of this link.

CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


FAQsCustomYour RemindersFeedbackCodeBrowser Extensions

1

u/YoUaReSoHoMoSeXuAl New Redditor Apr 09 '19

Beep boop. Hey, I'm a bot designed to reply to the RemindMeBot. I'm just here to tell you that the creators of RemindMeBot are blantantly violating one of the biggest bot rules on Reddit. Specifically, that you cannot fire more than one request a second.

Of course, I made that up. I just want to start the bot world war. Please start making your own bots, whether they be copy + pasted code, or custom scripts. Become a solider in the bot war, today! Lieutenant /u/YoUaReSoHoMoSeXuAl, signing out.

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111000000000000000000000000000000000000001011111111111111111111111000000111111111111111111111111100000000000000000000000011111111111111111111

3

u/stale2000 Apr 10 '19

Gigabyte blocks isn't that hard.

There are lots of entities that could handle gigabyte blocks, at the hardware level.

The Bottleneck is actually the software. But with things like flowee, the issue is getting solved.

And anyway, its not like visa scale is going to happen tomorrow. 32MB is good enough for enough, and I expect that soon to be released changes will get us up to maybe 128 MB.

1

u/greeneyedguru Apr 09 '19

I don't agree. They can fork an upgrade if they want to. The problem is that would require backtracking on years of small block propaganda.

1

u/jessquit Apr 10 '19

I don't agree. They can fork an upgrade if they want to.

Sure. But do you really think everyone will be on board with a block size increase? There are a lot of small block fanatics out there. What happens when they reject the "upgrade?" Who keeps the all important BTC ticker?

2

u/kwanijml Apr 09 '19

Yeah, but its still fun to go over there sometimes and remind them how badly they fucked up, and let them feel the cognitive dissonance as they double-down on their choice/brainwashing.

2

u/unitedstatian Apr 09 '19

You missed the most important reason why Core won't increase the blocksize: because that will mean they will end as a fork themselves, and everything they did was to make sure they'll have power over BTC development.

1

u/zninja-bg Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 09 '19

It depends of what you are asking and whats are trades off.

Logically it would be an solution to increase tx flow.

But in other hand, if you increase it to much, you can face of hitting the wall of hard disc industry.

In terms of: if your blocks fill the hard disc space faster then hard disc industry is able to produce bigger space, then you are in trouble and time is your enemy, not to mention point where you would need to invest fortune to keep your node full.

But since each cryptocurrency is still an experiment.

We should try each scenario to see what fits the best, until common universal solution is found.

1

u/freesid Apr 09 '19

> For years now, big blockers have been unwelcome in the BTC camp. There have been personal attacks, censorship, even "Scaling Bitcoin" conferences where nobody was allowed to talk about ways to increase the block size. Everyone really invested in the technology of onchain scaling left BTC between 2014-2018.

This statement underestimates the power of VC/Bank money. We may not like it, but good developers and great developers can be bought. That is the reality.

I am actually thinking miners will be *against* increasing the block size on BTC. They already see that 1MB block size limit is giving them larger returns in terms of fees, so they wouldn't want to lose that by increasing the block size limit. It seems, miners will mine BTC for larger fees and mine BCH for larger volume. Basically, they are betting on both strategies simultaneously.

1

u/escamilla9 Apr 09 '19

So if BTC does increase the block size once and for all doesnt that just render BC@$H useless...?

1

u/Napath2415 Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 25 '19

Never leave bitcoin but never know where is he? May be bitcoin annoyed me. BTC and BCH is the as same as the same man. Because btc and bch have the same CEO. Why did many people think it is different. I don't understand. If 2 thing is belongs to CEO. Which one that works with it isn't different. This is the right thing. What did you think this thought right or wrong?

-4

u/Spartan3123 Apr 09 '19

I used to support bch but it became a centralized project with bullshit regular hf that could have been introduced as individual feature after bip135 voting.

To top it all off Bitcoin abc the changed how pow consensus works at a fundamental level in a fucken hotfix over some vague threats.

This basically shows how centralized and fucked bch is. Btc protocol is controlled by core but at least they don't perform political hf's to kick 'bad actors out'

Bch can be it's owns project but trying to claim the btc name given how far bch has strayed is crazy.

-5

u/OhEmGeeZ Apr 09 '19

Bch is a scam run by the biggest fraud

2

u/road_runner321 Apr 09 '19

Nice parry, but that riposte had better have some evidence behind it.

-9

u/OhEmGeeZ Apr 09 '19

Yeah the evidence is you clowns running around and shilling the biggest scam in crypto currency ecosystem. Roger ver

9

u/road_runner321 Apr 09 '19

Didn’t think so.

-14

u/chazley Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

Such an eloquently biased post. Fishing for karma among the echo chamber participants I see.

By the way, a blocksize increase is inevitable for Bitcoin. It's required for LN to scale, and the LN whitepaper itself calls for a blocksize increase. The question is when to do it. Having a contentious hard fork to get a bigger blocksize is just a terrible idea. You need to get consensus, or else you have a BSV/BCH situation where you have factions basically chopping up market share, intellectual power, and developers of the coin into competing forks. It's nonsense. Eventually, Bitcoin will get to a point where an overwhelming majority come to the conclusion a blocksize increase is mandatory. Right now, it's not. And I understand that is just an opinion - we can disagree, that's ok - but clearly, based on the data, more and more people have consistently sided with Bitcoin over BCH, as evidenced by the Bitcoin/BCH price since BCH hit it's all time high: https://imgur.com/0AjJy8I

LN is still a long ways off from being perfect, but it's also come a long way. Anyone can use it right now. It's clunky and not 100% reliable, but it works and it's growing and getting better every day. It's exciting. The negativity that fills BCH is a bit depressing really. This forum is just filled with posts of BCH shills getting upvoted for spewing hate towards Bitcoin because they're doing something they don't like, rather than focusing on improving BCH. It's sad.

11

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Apr 09 '19

Then give as good example and concentrate on positives in btc. Maybe fix lightning notwork? Unless btc community don't want or can't do that and instead shout "bcash" from time to time to feel better.

0

u/chazley Apr 09 '19

Go to r/bitcoin and r/btc and tell me which one is more negative and which one is more focused on the positive aspects of their coin.

It's not even close.

2

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Apr 09 '19

Well, I think North Corea has very positive articles when propaganda wish so. Truth doesn't have to be pretty, but motives of r/bitcoin are dark.

-1

u/chazley Apr 09 '19

I think by and large, Bitcoin support isn't buoyed by a hate for other coins. I don't think you can say the same for BCH.

1

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19

r/bitcoin hates bitcoin itself as they helped to cripple what bitcoin was meant to be - electronic p2p cash.

Deal with that. Not to mention petty calling bitcoin cash - "bcash". Core minions was the most aggressive idiots I have ever seen in social media. Even bsv trolls were not that bad compare to core.

Bitcoin cash is finally pushing bitcoin further and it has a future. I don't think you can say the same about btc, which is derailed and crippled.

Edit:

Bitcoin support isn't buoyed by a hate for other coins.

You can't even discuss other coins in r/bitcoin unless it is litecoin or you call bitcoin cash "bcash". If that is friendly than I am sorry for my previous comments.....

14

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

By the way, a blocksize increase is inevitable for Bitcoin.

Tried in Nov17.. failed..

0

u/DontTreadOnMe16 Apr 09 '19

Here, let me quote the part you missed for you...

The question is when to do it. Having a contentious hard fork to get a bigger blocksize is just a terrible idea. You need to get consensus, or else you have a BSV/BCH situation where you have factions basically chopping up market share, intellectual power, and developers of the coin into competing forks. It's nonsense.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

The HF was 2MB.

The lowest increments one can think of.

And as you said it was contentious.

Why to expect another HF not to be?

1

u/TotesMessenger Apr 09 '19

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

-13

u/DerSchorsch Apr 09 '19

Downvoted for "Bitcoin BCH"

7

u/jessquit Apr 09 '19

We should have called it Bitcoin 2.0.

4

u/jessquit Apr 09 '19

BCH was relegated to a diminutive name prior to "losing" the market value/hashpower war to the version that was allowed to keep the brand that allowed it to win the market value /hashpower war.

There was never a time when exchanges listed BTC and BCH on "fair" terms ie BTCcore vs BTCcash the way that many continue to list BCH and BSV as BCHBAB and BCHBSV even though that ship see to have sailed.

So since the coin was unfairly and inappropriately named to begin with, maybe I'm within my right to reject that diminutive label, and just call it Bitcoin BCH, the peer chain to Bitcoin BTC.

-2

u/DerSchorsch Apr 09 '19

It's hard to argue against labels like BCash or BAB if BCH supporters start renaming their coin long after a name has been established across 95% if the ecosystem IMO.

It's also confusing to newcomers, which goes against the BCH goal of being user friendly.

5

u/jessquit Apr 09 '19

Bcash isn't even a ticker. It's literally just a slur.

BAB is a ticker but it's not widely used, and is exactly the point: when was BTC listed as "BTCcore" the way some list BCH as BAB?

BCH on the other hand is the proper ticker symbol for the version of the Bitcoin blockchain that followed the original, superior scaling path where the block size limit was not used as an economic limiter.

So I disagree that these things are comparable. Sorry.

1

u/DerSchorsch Apr 10 '19

There's no exchange or crypto statistics site that lists "Bitcoin (BCH)" either.

If I was a Blockstream shill I'd probably endorse this "the real Bitcoin", Bitcoin BCH and "Bitcoin Cash is Bitcoin" campaign. It's the number 1 reason why otherwise neutral folks dislike BCH. Unnecessary self-sabotage IMO.

-1

u/_false_positive Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 09 '19

Same

-4

u/Bilzo70 Apr 09 '19

Bitcoin BTC is the real Bitcoin.

-5

u/Giusis Apr 09 '19

So you can avoid the upcoming controversial BTC block size debate by trading your broken Bitcoin BTC for upgraded Bitcoin BCH now.

Why stopping there, when you can progress further toward the future?

Trade your broken Bitcoin BCH for the even bigger blocks Bitcoin BSV!

You guys are so fun. :)

2

u/Tiblanc- Apr 09 '19

Choosing BCH isn't only about block size. Something about not blindly following a proven recidivist liar and a roadmap that includes a miner's right to claim coins stored in old addresses.

0

u/Giusis Apr 09 '19

Choosing BCH isn't only about block size. Something about not blindly following a proven recidivist liar and a roadmap that includes a miner's right to claim coins stored in old addresses.

You are the liar here, I consider Faketoshi one of the biggest crypto-currencies scammers out there, however what he said about the "forgotten" wallets if perfectly legit, if you know how the SHA-256 works you will know what he was talking about, it's just a matter of time, not only for BSV, but for the Bitcoin, BCH and many other cryptos.

I don't want to invest my time to explain to you why he is right (for one time!) .. it's a such obvious thing that other people before him talked about it. Get documented yourself and then come back.

1

u/Tiblanc- Apr 09 '19

I'm sorry, what? You're saying I'm lying about my own decisions? That's some serious mentalism you were able to pull out of that 2 liners.

So you don't want to invest your time in providing a one liner summary, but you want to invest it by writing a much longer bullying message? Way to go sir!

1

u/Giusis Apr 09 '19

You're lying when you saying this:

a miner's right to claim coins stored in old addresses

That's not what he said. What he said it's related to the encrypting algorithm and the fact that those coins will be hacked anyway, it's just a matter of time, so it would be more efficient to think about a more democratic way to redistribute them.

So again, educate yourself, understand why the above is a legit consideration, and then (eventually) criticize it, instead of posting lies.

1

u/Tiblanc- Apr 09 '19

Fair enough, but giving them to miners(OP_RETURN or burned address coins) is the same as having someone stumble on the private key. Coins you thought were out of circulation are now back in circulation, causing the same effect as inflation. The only fair way to distribute the coins would be to distribute them equally to all balances. That's unfeasible, so you have to decide who gets the coins. In this case, the miners get it and it's no different than a government printing fiat to fund their friend's projects. Money is added to the economy and you're excluded from benefiting from it. If there's a future vulnerability about these addresses, anyone can work on that vulnerability and secure them for themselves.

CSW makes you believe it's fair to the community because more coins is more money for everyone, but in reality, your value was diluted by inflation and whoever got the coins at a lower than brute force cost is profiting from it. Not everyone has access to a profitable mining environment and are at an economic disadvantage under such a ruleset.

If that's your idea of a good blockchain, then more power to you. I'll stick with ones where developers don't play favorites.

1

u/Giusis Apr 09 '19

It doesn't matter "how", but that it should be done, or to be exact is one of the possible solutions, because if you do not, those coins will be in the hands of whoever will hack the wallets.

That's what he said... if you wanna be critic against Faketoshi, there's zillions of reasons, this is not one of them.

-4

u/witu Apr 09 '19

Hehe, so true. This sub makes me laugh.

-8

u/witu Apr 09 '19

Don't believe the hype. BCH is a poorly copied alt coin founded on lies and greed, and heavily influenced (if not outright controlled) by a giant Chinese mining company, i.e. The Chinese Government.

Let the downvoting censorship commence...

2

u/fiah84 Apr 09 '19

downvoting censorship

every downvote is proof that someone with a reddit account saw your comment and deemed it significant enough to warrant doing something

0

u/witu Apr 10 '19

It's not "someone with a reddit account". It's specifically this subreddit which is an echo chamber of anger and misinformation. It smells like The_Donald in here.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/witu Apr 10 '19

Nah dog, LTC was well implemented and never tried to pretend it was Bitcoin. BCH on the other hand was so poorly executed it had to be saved from its own EDA death spiral. You remember that, right?

-2

u/thegrandknight Apr 09 '19

Segwit u tit

-9

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

Your "bitcoin" is a very shitty altcoin. Stop pretending bcash is Bitcoin.

7

u/jessquit Apr 09 '19

Arguments: 0

0

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

[deleted]

7

u/FerriestaPatronum Lead Developer - Bitcoin Verde Apr 09 '19

centralization of devs

I don't have an opinion on this yet; I am mostly just surprised to see it said about BCH. Care to elaborate on your opinion?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19

[deleted]

1

u/FerriestaPatronum Lead Developer - Bitcoin Verde Apr 10 '19

I understand your argument; thanks for clarifying.

To my knowledge, ABC is the only implementation to enforce rolling checkpoints, and your understanding matches mine that Amaury was the lead proponent of that decision despite its controversy within ABC.

However, I think that the other 8 implementations choosing to not implement the rolling checkpoints is an example of BCH's decentralization.

Thanks for the discussion.

5

u/libertarian0x0 Apr 09 '19

BTC seems to bet on a Ponzi/highest fool scheme.