r/btc • u/unstoppable-cash • Apr 03 '19
It was SO simple... Satoshi had the answer to prevent full-blocks back in 2010!
9
29
3
Apr 03 '19
You know, someone should make a shirt with this on it. Just the code and the shirt should be the same color as that forum background.
3
u/phro Apr 04 '19
He should have just baked in a block size limit that moves like difficulty. Blocks could have been capped at a maximum size that is some high multiple of the average size of the last 100 blocks or so.
12
u/Neutral_User_Name Apr 03 '19
Everytime I read Satoshi, I cannot stop marvelling at how much his writing is similar to that of Craig "Faketoshi" Wright (sarcasm alert). Sorry if the evocation of that name triggers bad memories. Thanks god he is now playing by himself, in his own little sandpit.
1
2
u/FEDCBA9876543210 Apr 04 '19
Yes, but this answer friendly to BTCore developer's employer, whose business model is based on fees paid by customers to transact on Liquid - "it's not like we are going to build something for free forever"...
1
u/TotesMessenger Apr 03 '19
1
u/masixx Apr 04 '19
With the new findings about BTC origin: if satoshi was a group of good NSA guys and BTC got out of control then... what if blockstream is a group of bad NSA guys trying to sabotage Bitcoin?
1
Apr 04 '19
How about people mine whatever size blocks they like, and let it be sorted out through orphans ?!?
Telling all the miners to "collude" with a certain block size cap is just artificial stupidity.
1
u/outbackdude Apr 03 '19
so how do we alert the old chain that they need to upgrade?
3
u/324JL Apr 03 '19
Here, there, and everywhere. If you're a miner you should be paying attention to crypto news and/or social media anyway.
1
u/phro Apr 04 '19
How do we make sure that the people with hundreds, thousands, or millions of dollars at stake get the news? Hmmmm... it might be difficult.
-14
u/shazvaz Apr 03 '19
Everyone in Bitcoin knows this already. It's only if you go into controlled communication channels and listen to the manufactured echo chamber of a small number of paid infiltrators that you might get the impression we feel any different.
17
u/atroxes Apr 03 '19
So, when are bigger blocks being phased into Bitcoin Core?
-17
u/shazvaz Apr 03 '19
Whenever the community can come to its senses and build support for an alternate client.
22
Apr 03 '19
That was called Bitcoin XT, released 4 years ago...
It likely would have had broad support, except /bitcoin started censoring any talk of it as "altcoin" heresy (meanwhile, Blockstream was out gaslighting miners not to leave Core). This is literally what started this whole fucking fiasco that ended with the creation of /btc and later Bitcoin Cash.
Thanks for confirming that you really dont know your history, let alone "Everyone in Bitcoin knows this already" because clearly the current crowd of idiot trolls know as much as you do: nothing.
-6
u/shazvaz Apr 03 '19
I am aware of this and XT was exactly the fork we needed but at the time miners we're too complacent. These days we have a much more decentralized information flow across this subreddit and others. Also we have the benefit of actual objective data on how high fees can get when the blocks get full. I strongly believe that if an updated XT were released today we would be able to get traction and finally free BTC from its captors.
14
Apr 03 '19
I strongly believe that if an updated XT were released today we would be able to get traction and finally free BTC from its captors.
Yeah you're dreaming. This would just end with either being snuffed out, or another BCH-like split
-1
u/shazvaz Apr 03 '19
A BCH like split would be fine as long as the upgraded side won a majority of hash power out of the gate. Then it would take the BTC ticker and the Bitcoin name and we would finally be back on track. It's certainly within the realm of possibility.
11
Apr 03 '19
Well, this was already tried years ago and this is how it ended up. I highly doubt another attempt would end any differently, we just end up with a redundant BCH-like chain that would be buried under a mountain of gaslighting and FUD from buttcoiner attack dogs just like BCH was/still is.
That is not to say I wouldn't love to watch this happen all over again on BTC.
3
u/324JL Apr 03 '19
Well, this was already tried years ago and this is how it ended up. I highly doubt another attempt would end any differently, we just end up with a redundant BCH-like chain that would be buried under a mountain of gaslighting and FUD from buttcoiner attack dogs just like BCH was/still is.
It would be BCH with Segwit (for no reason) along with other unnecessary crap.
3
1
Apr 04 '19
>It would be BCH with Segwit (for no reason) along with other unnecessary crap.
Exactly, the original bitcoin protocol, without unnecessary block caps .... exists today. If people want to mine it, or build apps on it .... they can do so.
-2
1
Apr 04 '19
>It's certainly within the realm of possibility.
Unfortunately there is no much which can be done about SegWit.
1
u/shazvaz Apr 04 '19
Segwit could be removed, though the hard part is getting the network to adopt an alternate client first.
12
4
Apr 03 '19
Why would you need an alternate client? Just needs to be in the next version of the client. 'Starting at block x (which is much in the future), the blocks are now y sized'.
3
u/shazvaz Apr 03 '19
In this case it needs to be an alternate client because the core client is controlled by a group who refuse to upgrade the chain. It could (and probably would) be a fork of the existing client however and your solution would work fine.
2
u/knight222 Apr 03 '19
So never?
0
u/shazvaz Apr 03 '19
It'll definitely take a lot longer than it should now that all of you bunch are fighting against it so much.
2
u/knight222 Apr 04 '19
I support 300kb blocks.
0
u/shazvaz Apr 04 '19
It's sad because you started out by rightfully fighting against core but now it seems like statements such as 300k blocks come more from bch supporters. Just so sad to see both Blockstream and a majority of r/btc all working towards the destruction of Bitcoin. I wish humans weren't like this.
3
u/knight222 Apr 04 '19 edited Apr 04 '19
Bitcoin is just fine. We fixed it already and moved forward. Why are you so attached to the old ticker exactly?
0
u/shazvaz Apr 04 '19
I'm not, I'm attached to immutability and the 21M limit. If a divergent chain can become Bitcoin after the fact then nobodies funds are safe ever, since your chain might be deprecated randomly in the future. There also can't be more than one Bitcoin otherwise it effectively acts as a doubling of the total supply.
4
u/knight222 Apr 04 '19
There is only and always has been only one Bitcoin P2P ecash as described in the whitepaper. Everything else is a distraction by those raging a war on cash.
→ More replies (0)
-14
u/yellow_kid Apr 03 '19
It IS simple. Whenever the community starts leaning towards increasing the block size limit we can do just that: phase it in.
If a small cabal decides to cause a fork by putting up a bunch of new rules right away, no one will take it seriously. Look at bch.
21
Apr 03 '19
BCH actually increased the block size though, unlike Core. BCH wouldn't even exist today if Core would increase the blocksize.
1
Apr 04 '19
>BCH wouldn't even exist today if Core would increase the blocksize.
Of course it would. SegWit.
-3
u/yellow_kid Apr 03 '19
BCH actually increased the block size though
...in a sudden contentious fork decided by a small group, yes.
21
Apr 03 '19
It was not sudden, BCH was a final solution after years of trying to get the small group of Core obstructionists to raise the block size limit. There was wide support for this upgrade in 2014, and then we were censored and banned from our own sub by some dickhead kid called Theymos.
Do you think BCH would really exist as strong as it is without a large community built over years to get it off the ground? Most of us are 2009-2014 era Bitcoiners that supported the on-chain scaling update and fought hard for a long time over it.
-3
u/yellow_kid Apr 03 '19
It was not sudden, BCH was a final solution after years
No, it pretty much popped up when Bitmain called for it, in response to the threat segwit posed to their ASIC-boost edge.
15
u/jessquit Apr 03 '19
The bitmain UAHF & ABC were the culmination of three-plus years of bad faith negotiations on the part of Bitcoin Core. If you think the timeline starts there you're very mistaken. The roots of the hard fork go back to Bitcoin XT and the roots of ABC itself are the 2016 "Satoshi's Bitcoin" MVF client.
0
u/yellow_kid Apr 03 '19
I've been paying close attention since 2016, don't try to throw sand in my eyes.
9
u/jessquit Apr 03 '19
I'm sorry, but despite your immense experience in the area, you're just wrong.
Bitcoin XT / BIP 101 was in 2015.
Bitcoin Classic and Unlimited came later.
The realization that we might have to create an emergency minority fork goes back to the Satoshi's Bitcoin project which later became the "MVF client" (minimum viable forking client) which later became Bitcoin ABC.
These things do not spring out of thin air. You don't happen to understand their history.
-1
u/yellow_kid Apr 03 '19
Yes the block size debate is a lot older than bch, in fact it's still an issue on bitcoin and probably won't be going away anytime soon.
But the rule change that resulted in the bch fork was decided behind the curtains, announced less than 2 months beforehand and pushed by bitmain.
6
u/segregatemywitness Apr 04 '19
Liar. It was what the community went with after Blockstream sponsored developers sabotaged Bitcoin and censored us for years.
What's it like seeing your lies burn down around you?
4
u/jessquit Apr 04 '19
I'm sorry even a brief googling reveals that this very sub was discussing the project I referred to. Note the post is highly upvoted.
https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/4d9z1z/a_100_bitcoin_solution_to_the_interrelated
You admittedly are a newcomer to the situation. Perhaps the problem is simply that you were unaware of events already well underway when you started paying close attention.
→ More replies (0)3
Apr 04 '19
>But the rule change that resulted in the bch fork
Which rule change?
Don't implement segwit
Don't implement RBF
Remember. Block cap isn't a rule change (the protocol doesn't specify block size). It's a suggestion in how to configure your node.
1
9
Apr 03 '19
It popped up as a possible plan if S2X failed, nothing to do with ASICboost nonsense
1
u/yellow_kid Apr 03 '19
Yes the fact that segwit was poised to take away bitmain's concealed edge had nothing to do with it. Bitmain doesn't like to have edges, it's a very altruistic company. /s
6
Apr 03 '19
lol "concealed edge" that everyone already knew about. Get a new narrative
0
u/yellow_kid Apr 03 '19
that everyone already knew about.
That's why I said concealed and not secret, also not the point.
4
u/phro Apr 04 '19
You're so off base here. I can't believe I'm still clarifying this today. ASICboost STILL works. You could simply neglect SW transactions and do it right now. Segwit only disrupted covert ASICboost. Overt ASICboost has always been possible.
1
u/yellow_kid Apr 04 '19
But that edge is decreasing as the % of segwit transactions increases no?
1
u/phro Apr 04 '19
A valid hash is a valid hash. Imagine if they patched out any other efficiency upgrade like the first GPU miner or the first ASIC. Core even has their own version of asicboost now. If ASICboost was as profitable as it was alleged it would have been done overtly and brazenly immediately after the fork and it would still be profitable to do right now when there are plenty of non segwit transactions to fill a block.
→ More replies (0)1
Apr 04 '19
>es the fact that segwit was poised to take away bitmain's concealed edge had nothing to do with it. Bitmain doesn't like to have edges
That's how it might seem and is certainly the way the debate was sold to a lot of people ... but there are other much much more important reasons why implementing segwit was a terrible idea which irreversibly broke the protocol.
Not that any of this matters now. Anyone running that protocol is totally broken long ago.
2
u/phro Apr 04 '19
Your own source sites the 80% hash power agreeing to NYA terms which included a 2MB fork. They were going to raise the block size. BCH was a means to avoid the segwit poison pill and hedged against the renege on 2x which ended up being completely justified.
1
u/yellow_kid Apr 04 '19
I don't care about an agreement which I did not agree to.
1
u/phro Apr 04 '19
2 posts ago you were calling it a sudden contentious fork. It wasn't sudden. 80% of hash power was approving a block size increase.
0
u/yellow_kid Apr 05 '19 edited Apr 05 '19
80% of hash power was approving a block size increase.
Those miners were signaling for [segwit + 2x]. Not for [no segwit + 4x + replacing the difficulty algorithm with something made in the house of craig wright (aka professor scam)].
Still don't care. Miners aren't the boss of anyone.
-4
u/MarcBago Apr 03 '19
please use something other than ‘final solution’ next time, please. Solution by itself works just fine.
4
Apr 03 '19
I only meant to imply that BCH was the last stand for the original Satoshi project
1
u/MarcBago Apr 03 '19
I’m sorry. You seem like a nice enough person to get caught up in the crossfire. I’m a bitcoin core shill and was trying to derail your post with the last comment. I think I was somewhat successful, score!
2
u/324JL Apr 03 '19
I’m a bitcoin core shill and was trying to derail your post with the last comment.
At least you admit it, what about the rest of them?
1
Apr 04 '19
Changing the agreed block size cap is not a fork of the protocol. You are still "compatible", although you know that the others might not want your too big blocks (so it wouldn't be a good idea).
The chain called BCH was bitcoin, up until a new (different) protocol was introduced.
13
u/fiah84 Apr 03 '19
Whenever the community starts leaning towards increasing the block size limit
oh you mean like in 2015 when anyone with a transaction count chart and a ruler could see christmas 2017 coming from a few years away? It doesn't matter which way the community leans, Bitcoin Core has made that crystal clear
11
u/jessquit Apr 03 '19
oh you mean like in 2015 when anyone with a transaction count chart and a ruler could see christmas 2017 coming from a few years away?
😂😂😂
8
u/fiah84 Apr 03 '19
for real though, watching it play out exactly like half of
/r/bitcoinpredicted wasn't funny at all10
u/jessquit Apr 03 '19
[deleted]
5
u/324JL Apr 03 '19
[removed]
[banned]
"Fuck off alt-coin shill" - Core mods, regularly.
3
1
Apr 04 '19
>the community
LOL LOL LOL
This isn't a democracy. It is bitcoin. You only have to ask yourself.... Are you running bitcoin?.... or are you running something else?
Hint: Block size caps are not part of the protocol. They're just a setting in the node software. Anyone has always been able to mine any sized blocks they like, and still be compatible with the bitcoin protocol. It is only through the collusion of nodes who overtly limit the block size they will accept - is any type of "block size" on a chain enforced.
0
Apr 03 '19
[deleted]
38
u/lubokkanev Apr 03 '19
Censorship turned out to be the decision maker.
27
u/SoulMechanic Apr 03 '19
Theymos admitted to it years ago.
13
u/lubokkanev Apr 03 '19
This! They can't even pretend it's moderating. It's to manipulate the public.
60
Apr 03 '19
They banned everyone that disagreed with 1mb forever. That's how.
14
Apr 03 '19
The sad and simple truth right there.
The moment XT was released that dumbass punk kid Theymos laid the hammer down on censoring any mention of it as "altcoin discussion" and banning anyone who disapproved of the mod policy switch to "1984 the place". /bitcoin is now a shallow husk today that is basically a 4chan outpost now.
Its shocking how different history could have been if not for a few massive morons who happened to be in the right place and time to derail the whole project for the stupidest of reasons.
1
u/juddylovespizza Apr 04 '19
history could have been if not for a few massive morons who happened to be in the right place and time to derail the whole project
There are more communities on the web than just reddit or did Theymos take over other forums?
14
Apr 04 '19
/bitcoin and bitcointalk.org were the first big communities and were both run by the same group under Theymos, as such they both became censored on certain topics, moreso on /bitcoin. Im not as familiar with the earliest days of these communities as others here, hopefully those who know more can chime in for a history lesson.
8
u/phro Apr 04 '19
Theymos or that same cartel ran the main bitcoin message board, bitcoin.org, and /r/bitcoin. Core members also flew to China and met with every prominent miner agreed on 2MB and never delivered.
0
4
u/UpDown Apr 04 '19
1984. Making people disappear. Thought police. This stuff is way easier when people have digital identities moreso than physical ones because you can kill people easily online and make them “disappear” without raising any eyebrows by simply deleting or shadow banning their comments. If people only know you by your digital presence, have you not been killed?
13
u/etherael Apr 03 '19 edited Apr 03 '19
They didn't win.
They are stuck at 50ish percent of the market and have been for a long time. Every time their chain operated according to their actual full block design it lost dominance at a rate of twenty percent per month, and it only actually operated that way two months out of its entire history. Not to mention that when fees finally skyrocketed to the point the useless assholes who imposed that plan were popping champaign (sic) over, the worst bear market in years consumed the entire space and everybody spent years paying for core's idiotic hubris.
Their short sighted manipulation of an extremely straight forward argument where they are and always have been unquestionably on the wrong side has saddled them with a sabotaged design that flatly can't deliver the original promise of the project, and an unthinking brainwashed clueless cult who have been fed nothing but lies since inception and have no idea how to actually think critically themselves or what the ecosystem needs to proceed.
They're completely doomed, and in the grand scale of this journey we're on, we're barely past the first lap and most people in the world don't even understand there's a race, letalone the difference between the vehicles on the track.
3
u/horsebadlydrawn Apr 04 '19
full block design
It's an oxymoron, similar to "constant gridlock design".
unthinking brainwashed clueless cult who have been fed nothing but lies
I noticed this week that the cult members don't even know that the BTC chain is useless right now. They simply ignore this elephant in the room. And the lambo moonboy traders don't know about scaling at all, to them "Bitcoin" is just their balances on exchanges.
4
u/etherael Apr 04 '19
It's an oxymoron, similar to "constant gridlock design".
Absolutely, but that is the design that utter ignorant fuckhead /u/nullc [saddled the system with] (https://i.imgur.com/k77HfH8_d.jpg?maxwidth=640&shape=thumb&fidelity=medium), and it is directly contrary to the original reasonable working design.
I noticed this week that the cult members don't even know that the BTC chain is useless right now.
The problem with tailoring your strategy to unthinking mindless twats is that you end up with a following of unthinking mindless twats. I guess /u/theymos didn't think that far ahead with his ridiculous lies.
2
u/horsebadlydrawn Apr 04 '19 edited Apr 04 '19
tailoring your strategy to unthinking mindless twats
Oh I'm fully woke, I've been part of the scaling war since '14. I'm just amazed that this "extend and pretend" strategy continues to fool people for five years now. And as others have said, the whole saga is a testament to the fact that censorship works. I share your disgust.
1
u/etherael Apr 04 '19
If one could have a god's eye view of this entire event, I'd love to know just how much of the consent in this particular brew is actually manufactured. I just can't believe it can really all be genuine stupidity throwing billions upon billion dollars after the proposition that the network is limited to speeds that were considered fast when acoustic couplers were still in widespread use. Either way you look at it, if the people controlling the money really are that fucking stupid, then cryptocurrencies are desperately needed, and even if they're not and it's all just manipulation and fakery, the very fact that much money can be put behind a transparently false proposition also indicates hard currencies not subject to such manipulation are desperately needed.
2
u/horsebadlydrawn Apr 04 '19
"Only two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.” - Einstein
I think we'll slowly see more people migrating over to BCH as the tide lowers and we see who is not wearing pants... but it is maddening watching fools argue for their own demise...
1
u/FEDCBA9876543210 Apr 04 '19
They did (for now). They have managed to steal the Bitcoin name and the BTC ticker... The coin doesn't even have its own whitepaper...
1
u/etherael Apr 04 '19
And everyone who actually knows what the purpose of the device was simply forked away. All they got is people too stupid to figure it out, and those who were just hopping on for the ride.
4
u/nithronium Apr 03 '19
The problem was Bitcoin at first was really P2P digital decentralized community money. The soft-cap was working well because it was small, and the people who were there were like a family, so they didn't try to walk around the limits and they obeyed the soft cap. Now, BTC is too big and mined industrially. So, we could not have soft limit. Think of it like, when you set a rule in your family, you do not explicitly state everything. You just say it and that's it. But when it is a law for everyone in the city, the borders of the law must be made clear well, because, you know, when something involves too many people, it is no more a sincere environment and some will try to walk around the rules.
0
Apr 04 '19
[deleted]
2
u/nithronium Apr 04 '19
I do not agree with you. And I also think majority of the miners don’t care what is going on. As long as they make the profit, they are good to go. For smaller projects, what you said might be true. But in a huge project like bitcoin, even if the majority of the miners do not act greedily, there will be some being greedy. And they will make more money compared to others, by doing the same job. Then the newbies will join the greedy one because, why not make more when you can make more? Thus, the majority behaviour will swap to being greedy, instead of building trust.
In fact, which already happened back then and soft cap limit got removed.
Do you really think, at this point in Bitcoin mining (actually in a technical way, this is the only thing that matters) is done for supporting the network? Or is it being done by decentralized individuals? We have passed that point way too long ago.
1
u/Lord_Mat Apr 04 '19
Do you really think, at this point in Bitcoin mining (actually in a technical way, this is the only thing that matters) is done for supporting the network?
It was, in the earlier days. But yeah, we have passed that point long ago. Sure, there may be some altruistic guys out there who will always prioritise the common good. However, I believe they hold only a small percentage of hashrate. The vast majority are industrial and commercial ops whose main concerns centre around trying to make a profit from their operation. And to maximise this. They'd pay attention to the common good only when it's beneficial to their bottomline.
0
Apr 04 '19
[deleted]
1
u/nithronium Apr 04 '19
You are forgetting one thing. Bigger block size != more mining rewards. Until certain extent, yes, it is true. But look at Bitcoin Cash, do their miners get more reward per block or not, compared to Bitcoin? That is why the block size stays as it is. If time comes and BTC transactions will start getting unconfirmed even in normal days (i mean the days without huge price difference or rumours), then it’s viable to increase from miners’ perspective.
1
u/a17c81a3 Apr 04 '19
How in the fuck the 1mb forever crowd won out in the end still makes my head hurt.
Jews -> Rothschild family -> Bilderberg group/Henri de Castries -> AXA Group/Henri de Castries -> Blockstream.
Check the links if you think I'm crazy.
0
Apr 04 '19
[deleted]
1
u/a17c81a3 Apr 04 '19
Most of them have more important shit to so than trying to boss around some billionaire family.
Indeed they are so busy with such things as being 95% of Soviet leadership, starting the Frankfurt school and running USA media corporations.
So every Jewish person
Naxalt fallacy.
Have you ever met a Jewish person?
Yes.
0
27
u/ftrader Bitcoin Cash Developer Apr 03 '19
Well, it would have been that simple then, but in 2017 it required u/deadalnix to remove a bunch of cruft (Segwit, RBF) that Core had already added.
And also put some thought into other aspects of how putting many more transactions into blocks would impact the system (e.g. max allowed sighash counts, network message size limits etc).
Not to mention had it been done early, with consensus, one could have avoided having to change Bitcoin's difficulty algorithm and there wouldn't have been a need for replay protections against the other side of the HF.
So, in general, it turned out a little more complicated than Satoshi would've probably liked. But the general idea is correct.