r/btc • u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com • Mar 30 '19
Ross Ulbricht has served 6 years in federal prison.
Key Facts:
The 2 lead federal investigators of Ross Ulbricht are serving a combined 16 1/2 years in federal prison for crimes committed during and after the investigation of the Silk Road.
The corrupt actions of the federal agents were kept out of Ross’ trial and appeals.
Ross has no appeals left. Without clemency, he will die in prison.
Both federal agents were re-arrested after their their arrest and conviction. One, after his plea, stole millions in bitcoin from the US Government. The other was arrested for attempting to flee the country.
One federal judge told the corrupt Secret Service agent that his actions were a “betrayal of trust” and “among the worst of crimes”. He was the US Government's top expert on the anonymity protocol Tor. The other agent worked for the DEA.
The founder of Silk Road 2.0, a former SpaceX employee, was not prosecuted for his crimes.
7. Ross is a non-violent first-time offender. He holds a degree in physics and studied material sciences and engineering in a Masters program. He is best described as an idealistic naive hippie who launched a libertarian free market.
8. The younger generation views Ross’ case with overwhelming support. Clemency could garner and galvanize support for Republicans in the tech world which ideally could lead to more open access for conservatives in Silicon Valley companies.
9. Ross isn’t likely to re-offend. He currently teaches yoga in prison.
10. It is simply the right thing to do.
29
u/JerryGallow Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
What could realistically be done to help?
Not to sound pessimistic, but the law doesn't seem to care. They pinned it on him and they're satisfied. This reminds me of The Thin Blue Line where it took a critically acclaimed documentary to have anyone do anything about a man who was wrongly convicted and sentenced to death.
edit: This situation with Ross is really messed up. He shouldn't be in jail. The guy has a life he should be free to live, just like everyone else.
15
u/crypt0crook Mar 30 '19
Tbh, I'm surprised there hasn't been a blockbuster movie yet. It'll happen. Maybe on down the road but it'll happen.
11
8
u/gulfbitcoin Mar 30 '19
The guy has a life he should be free to live, just like everyone else.
The same could be said of the many (approximately 500,000 in the US) who are also incarcerated for drug-related offenses. (Unless it can be reasonably proven he never ran SR)
2
Mar 31 '19
You can't prove a negative. You can't prove that you never ran SR. Go on, try it. Try and convince everyone here that you never ran SR. Just as you can't prove you're not Santa Clause. Try proving that you don't dress up as the Easter bunny and hang out at parks late at night.
6
u/bunk3rk1ng Mar 31 '19
You can prove a positive though. Ross Ulbricht ran the silk road. That was proven in court.
1
u/gulfbitcoin Mar 31 '19
True. As the defense, you don't even have to prove anything - the burden is on the prosecution. You merely need to establish reasonable doubt as to the prosecution's assertions (which obviously he failed at)
3
u/demies Mar 31 '19
Craigslist has criminals, why isnt that shut down?
2
u/gulfbitcoin Mar 31 '19
Craigslist took active steps to remove categories from their website, as SR should have.
Look at what happened to Backpage.
5
u/TotesMessenger Mar 30 '19
2
2
0
32
u/lugaxker Mar 30 '19
Vices are not crimes. Free Ross.
-10
u/MetaBearJew Redditor for less than 60 days Mar 30 '19
You know how many people are murdered in the drug trade, right?
12
26
u/aint_no_telling68 Mar 30 '19
That’s because of prohibition. Making drugs illegal creates a black market and puts the drugs and money in the hands of cartels and gangs.
5
u/freshlysquosed Mar 30 '19
Do you know how many people are murdered in the Whiskey trade? None, or almost none because there's no prohibition.
-1
u/MetaBearJew Redditor for less than 60 days Mar 31 '19
Red herring.
1
u/freshlysquosed Mar 31 '19
I don't believe it is. I'm pointing out that when you say "drug trade" you mean drugs covered by prohibition, not merely drugs, because Whiskey is a drug and there's no violence at all there. It's the prohibition that's violent, not the selling of drugs.
0
u/MetaBearJew Redditor for less than 60 days Apr 01 '19
Look at OP in this thread. There was no discussion of prohibition. I did not respond to that, as that would be an entirely different discussion. Hence, your response to my comment is a red herring.
-10
u/bakedpotatopiguy Mar 30 '19
A lot of his “vices” actually break federal interstate commerce law as defined in the constitution. His punishment was ridiculous, but people on here aren’t helping him by saying he was just an average guy with some problems. He’s a criminal who may even deserve prison, but he shouldn’t be sentenced to life.
7
u/SpiritofJames Mar 30 '19
Magic paper says it's wrong to trade plants for money. Lock him up!!
-8
u/bakedpotatopiguy Mar 30 '19
“Magic paper” that has control over all of our lives because we benefit from it as well. Don’t fall for the libertarian dream; it doesn’t exist.
3
u/SpiritofJames Mar 30 '19
Yes the paper has control! I'm sure that's accurate. Not only is it magic, but sentient and willing!
-10
Mar 30 '19
I mean people SSNs were being sold and CC#s along with many other things that are damaging. I’m not against the guy at all, but I mean what can you really expect? He made the most popular black market arguably ever. A key component of black markets is that they’re illegal. Part of his “job” was accepting the reality, of caught he may spend decades in prison. We can’t advocate to free criminals just because they use new age tech to commit crimes.
6
u/BTC_StKN Mar 30 '19
You are voicing support for the system keeping 2 Million locked away in the USA. This is how it is able to continue.
Not violent offenders should not be locked up in cages to suffer and die like animals.
4
u/beclon Mar 30 '19
...to add, willful crimes committed by law enforcers should not carry favorable sentences vs civilians upon conviction. one could plausibly defend the notion that convicted individual (acting in capacity as, or using privileges accessible only to enforcers) should carry heavier consequence, as it is amongst the grandest violations of a social contract.
-2
Mar 30 '19
I just want to make sure I understand you correctly. You’re saying under all circumstances non-violent offenders should never be jailed?
5
u/BTC_StKN Mar 30 '19
Yes.
There are other solutions to resolve non-violent offenses. Restitution, garnishments, judgements, community service, whichever.
The above is more productive for society and could better compensate for losses in fraud type cases which is an economic benefit for all involved.
Also a major issue is the damage incarceration inflicts on extended family members and permanent affects on children as they are raised without parents. This also has a negative affect on a country's economy. Plus all of the excessive incarceration and judicial costs are more waste.
4
Mar 30 '19
Considering the conditions in US prisons, I would say non-violent offenders should not be jailed.
1
2
u/BTC_StKN Mar 30 '19
Here's a good video that was linked below a Cash Shuffle Stat Tweet that addresses some of these issues.
4
u/beclon Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
curious you thoughts on the sentences of the federal agents? they arguably know better than any civilian the depth of Ross’s illegal activity; they were employed to fight it; they then attempted to collect on the full body of financial gains. That’s a crime-squared.
Ross, civilian, jailed for life. Federal agents, employees of an enforcement agency, finite sentences.
[edit: typo]
3
Mar 30 '19
I think that aspect is complete and utter bullshit. And it actually makes me mad. The feds always do shit like that and I hate it.
0
Mar 30 '19
[deleted]
2
Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
I used to use it back in the day and I swear they had SSNs and CCs live. But I do acknowledge that I may be wrong.
EDIT: I have now found archived listings of counterfeit money on the Silk Road which
A) goes against that rule, so I believe that rule was only active "When the Silk Road marketplace first began" and
B) Does cause harm to society and business owners
0
Mar 30 '19
[deleted]
-1
Mar 30 '19
He should without a doubt be allowed to mention everything that happened at his trial IMHO. But even if he did hand it off at least in my eyes he still shares in the responsibility for the system he created. If he is going to create a tool that operates outside of the law he has to understand the implications that come with that.
-9
Mar 30 '19
Vices are not crimes. Free Ross.
Are you saying "vices" as in illegal drugs, and the sale and transport of them across state and country borders, also utilizing the USPS (Mail fraud) is not a crime? Are you insane?
10
u/stan3666 Mar 30 '19
You know what else was a crime? Hiding Jews. Helping slaves escape the plantation. The argument that "well its illegal so he deserves to be caged" is a wholly stupid one.
2
u/gulfbitcoin Mar 30 '19
The argument that "well its illegal so he deserves to be caged" is a wholly stupid one.
500,000 are incarcerated for drug crimes. Let Ross go, let them go. And vice versa - justice should be fair.
I love how you equated saving lives to a wanna-be entrepreneur helping fentanyl fools getting their fix while making a profit.
I personally feel Ross was over-sentenced (a typical 5-10 felony sentence would be appropriate), but it's asinine how he's being portrayed as some sort of crypto freedom fighter after the fact.
1
u/stan3666 Mar 31 '19
Well isn't that a cute little straw man you built yourself there...No where in anything I've wrote here did I say he was a hero, nor did I equate what he did to saving lives. All I pointed out was that many of the laws are corrupt and that they are a horrible bases for deciding right and wrong. I then provided examples of some laws that are blatant examples of this.
2
1
u/newprofile15 Mar 31 '19
Lol nice non sequitir.
Me: "hey we should prosecute people for tax evasion, illegal weapons trafficking, illegal drug trafficking, hiring hitmen for murder, running a marketplace for murder and bribing federal officials"
You: "YOU'RE A NAZI AND A SLAVEOWNER!"
1
u/stan3666 Mar 31 '19
You are funny. Please, inform everyone reading where the straw man in my argument is. I bet you don't even know what that means do you? Just angry trying to defend your blind defense of the righteousness of the law by using the Same words I do.
I'd really like to see where I defended any of the other things you claim I am too while you are at it.
You're just trying to pull out any pathetic thing you can to save your clearly Shit position blindly defending the law as "right because its the law".
-2
Mar 30 '19
You know what else was a crime? Hiding Jews. Helping slaves escape the plantation. The argument that "well its illegal so he deserves to be caged" is a wholly stupid one.
Disagreement with the law isn't an excuse to be immune from consequences.
5
u/stan3666 Mar 30 '19
Where did I claim that it was? Defending corrupt laws just because "it's the law" makes you a piece of Shit though.
4
u/freshlysquosed Mar 30 '19
Of course it's a crime, he's saying he ought not to be.
2
u/gulfbitcoin Mar 30 '19
No, he literally said "Vices are not crimes". Probably shouldn't be, but as long as anyone is incarcerated for drug-related crimes (about 500,000 are currently in the US), anyone facilitating those sales should be subjected to the same standard of justice.
1
u/freshlysquosed Mar 31 '19
Yeah and the Jews should have been rounded up as they were
1
u/gulfbitcoin Mar 31 '19
"Hey, has anyone seen the playbook?"
"Which one?"
"The one you pull out when you're out of arguments!"
"Um, try that third shelf there"
Ahh, here it is... page 327: "When all else fails, compare them to Nazis"
Whew, glad I found it. That was a close call!
1
u/freshlysquosed Mar 31 '19
You know godwin's law isn't a logical fallacy? It's a very easy way of pointing out my issue with your position. So instead of whining, why not say why I'm wrong, or why you think it's right jews were rounded up?
1
u/gulfbitcoin Mar 31 '19
why you think it's right jews were rounded up
Well, setting up strawmen IS a logical fallacy.
But back to the original discussion: you've totally misrepresented my point. I never said he should be locked up just because it's illegal. My bigger point is that Ross is no one special. Yet no one is advocating for the release of the hundreds of thousands who are far more deserving than Ross. (I guess they're not white middle-class male enough to deserve such advocacy)
1
u/freshlysquosed Apr 01 '19
I never said he should be locked up just because it's illegal
I suppose you didn't, but your position then is even more stupid since you're not even appealing to the rule of law.
"as long as anyone is incarcerated for drug-related crimes (about 500,000 are currently in the US), anyone facilitating those sales should be subjected to the same standard of justice."
As long as jews are locked up, anyone being a jew should be subjected to the same standard of justice?
Yet no one is advocating for the release of the hundreds of thousands who are far more deserving than Ross.
Yeah they are. I think it was Ron Paul which every single libertarian seems to support advocates for releasing all non-violent drug offenders. It's a very common position. Plus Ross is getting more time than most, even more than murders and rapists.
1
u/DeathByFarts Mar 30 '19
also utilizing the USPS (Mail fraud) is not a crime?
What part of that was fraud? The closest you could get to it being fraud would be the fact that they didn't tell the USPS what was in the boxes.
12
u/earthmoonsun Mar 30 '19
How many years have the people spent in prison who got caught because Ross didn't encrypt personal data?
I don't think his sentence is ok at all and hope he is free asap but it's even worse for other SR victims who now serve time because Ross was arrogant, careless, and sophomoric.
6
u/bakedpotatopiguy Mar 30 '19
Thank you for seeing nuance in this. I feel like people on here want to make him into some saint. They aren’t making any good case for his innocence by denying what he actually did wrong. The best argument I see is to call out the political motives of the prosecutors and of the judge who sentenced him, because THAT is the real evil here.
2
2
u/beclon Mar 30 '19
Does this refer to info that was delivered to Ross encrypted, which he then saved unencrypted? Yah, that’s terrible and he exposed them.
Otherwise, bad OpSec by users doesn’t fall on him.
1
u/earthmoonsun Mar 30 '19
Does this refer to info that was delivered to Ross encrypted, which he then saved unencrypted? Yah, that’s terrible and he exposed them.
Yes. He had personal infos of SR admins unencrypted on his computer. Of course, it was also careless by those admins to give Ross their infos.
Otherwise, bad OpSec by users doesn’t fall on him.
Sure. That's not his fault. I didn't mean those guys.
1
u/freshlysquosed Mar 30 '19
Which personal data? Every vendor had PGP didn't they? Why would you give Ross/SR unencrypted data?
3
u/earthmoonsun Mar 30 '19
I'm not talking about vendors, of course. I'm talking about the admins. SR staff. They had to give a scan of their ID to Ross and they did. They probably sent them even encrypted. However, Ross kept them on his hard disk unencrypted. Hence, the admins got exposed.
3
u/sendmeyourprivatekey Mar 30 '19
Jesus fuck, what where they thinking...?
2
1
u/tophernator Mar 30 '19
I’m guessing Ross offered quite a bit of money for what was basically a mod position, while also pitching the idea that they weren’t technically committing a crime, just hosting a peer-to-peer site.
6
u/life036 Mar 30 '19
You had me until you brought your shitty political party bullshit into the conversation.
0
2
u/Deadbeat1000 Mar 31 '19
The Trump Administration just introduced new policies to review prisons cases. You should work with the government to review Ulrricht case.
3
Mar 30 '19
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vP4iY1TtS3s I think this is relevant to our time free ross
4
u/TrustThyself Mar 30 '19
I think #10 above is the most-important. And so is #7, if it were tweaked it to read, "Ross caused no victim. He harmed neither person nor their property." Which then implies who the real criminals are -- those who kidnapped and caged him.
0
u/capn_hector Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
all Ross did was try to hire someone to murder his co-conspirator, it's not really a big deal or anything.
it's practically a victimless crime! Not like it was violent or anything.
"but he'd never have gone through with it/he'd never have had to do it if..."
13
u/celtiberian666 Mar 30 '19
all Ross did was try to hire someone to murder his co-conspirator, it's not really a big deal or anything
He was never tried for that. He is innocent until proven guilty in a fair trial, and those charges were dropped.
5
u/capn_hector Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
This isn't a courtroom where we're putting him behind bars. He's already been determined to be the Dread Pirate Roberts as a plank (so to speak) of the charges against him. Beyond a reasonable doubt.
Now we're just discussing the messages that the Convicted Felon, Ross Ulbricht, the Dread Pirate Roberts (as determined by a jury) sent to a federal informant under his cryptographically strong identity. A jury hasn't found those to be intent to murder, beyond a reasonable doubt. But there is no reasonable doubt the messages were his. The jury did find that. He owned and controlled those crypto keys. We're just discussing whether his messages were intent to murder.
I dunno, it's pretty straightforward, he's hiring an assassin in those messages. He wants to kill a man who was getting in the way of his drug empire.
Some people think El Chapo is a hero too. Do you think El Chapo ever had anyone killed? Do you think El Chapo belongs in prison?
3
u/celtiberian666 Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
No, we are not discussing messages. We are discussing someone with a conviction for a victminless crime (run a marketplace).
Your first message here message implies his life sentence is somewhat OK because you think he did something bad. You can only do that if you're a psycho monster that don't care for individual rights, like the right to a fair trial. He was not tried for that, period.
He is innocent of that, until proven guilty in a fair trial. And of course this is not fucking courtroom, neither a trial, that's why what you think about it, what you think is proof or any assessment of that evidence by anyone here have zero value. You either bring him to court to answer for the crimes you're accusing him of and get him convicted, or you don't. There are people well paid to do that, people with much more experience than you or me, people with much more information about the case than you or me, and they CHOOSE NOT TO BRING IT TO COURT, they only do that when they think the accused didn't do it, when it was just bogus claims to bolster the case or when the case is just too weak to win in court, that is what happened, that's the facts, that's the only information of value in this whole matter.
But if you want to play, I'll do just one move, not to you, but to everyone reading to think about.
What is more probable?
That a case full of problems run by corrupt agents had those charges put in just to bolster the case and push the judge to deny bail, like it is done in many cases?
That 5 hired murders occurred but magically there are no corpses, no weapons, no names, no witnesses, no assassins, just bits and bytes with messages.
If the answer is 1, what would happen? Charges dropped.
What happened? Charges dropped.
As self-appointed r/btc judge, I declare: case closed. Thanks for trying.
This is my last message here, unless you did somewhat managed to reopen the case to persecute him for those charges. It is the right think to do if you really think there are 5 corpses out there unnacounted for. Good luck.
4
u/capn_hector Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
Ah yes, the "this conviction is an indictment of the whole system! maybe even justice itself!" approach.
Dude, Ross tried to hire a murderer. He used crypto keys that were traced back to him and proved by a jury to belong to him. Yeah, drugs should be legal, yeah he wouldn't have hired someone to murder his friend if drugs were legal. That's the thing though, it's not entrapment if the circumstances encourage you to commit the crime on your own. If you willingly ask the undercover cop to murder someone for you, you did that on your own.
In the grand scheme of things, Ross Ulbricht falls into the category we'd describe as "violent drug offenders". He's not someone who got locked up with a half pound of weed. He hired a murderer to kill an associate to keep his drug profits safe, using those same crypto keys.
8
u/xcsler_returns Mar 30 '19
Even if you assume he is guilty of murder for hire his sentence is far in excess of actual murderers.
-3
Mar 30 '19
If I rent someone a house that I know will be used to grow pot, I’m not a landlord. I am a conspirator in the trafficking of marijuana.
Ross isn’t just a free market website manager. If someone asks you where you can get a kilo of coke and you say George has one, you just committed a crime of conspiracy to distribute coke and that can be 10 years, because you hooked up a buyer and a seller. That’s what he did, connected buyers with sellers, thousands of times. People who say that he just ran a website are fooling themselves. He facilitated many many drug deals by being the landlord of the house.
2
u/celtiberian666 Mar 30 '19
I am a conspirator in the trafficking of marijuana.
Victimless crime.
you just committed a crime of conspiracy to distribute cok
No real crime was commited. A crime is not defined by words written on a paper. A crime is an attack on life or property. Moving goods is neither, it's just commerce.
-1
u/bakedpotatopiguy Mar 30 '19
I was with the Ross defenders until this comment. A crime literally is “defined by words written on paper.” To think otherwise is some libertarian fantasy detached from reality. Whether the law is just or unjust is irrelevant, even though that’s the point you’re arguing. “Just commerce” in your legal framework, could allow the most extreme examples, e.g. giving nuclear material to ISIS. He did something wrong. Your argument should be that no one deserves anywhere near the sentence he got for committing those crimes.
-2
Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 31 '19
If no real crime was committed then why did you use the words “victimless crime”?
And yes when people become addicted to coke, crack, meth or junk, there are tens of thousands of victims. Most are children who end up in foster care and lose their parents. They end up sleeping in shitholes and eating cereal three times a day. Users end up on public medical service because their heart or liver or kidneys stopped functioning, and every single one of us has money stolen from our wallets every payday to pay for their medical treatments.
Victimless? Your delusional if you think trafficking is victimless.
EDIT: WOW silver on a downvoted comment!! That is a first for me!! Thank you person with conscious!
4
u/phro Mar 30 '19
They never even charged him with that after publicly claiming that he hired hitmen. They did it so that low info idiots like yourself would parrot it forever.
7
Mar 30 '19
Got proof?
7
u/capn_hector Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
Oops, if only Silk Road hadn't been built around cryptographic strength user authentication. I guess maybe someone bugged his crypto passphrases, stole Ross's laptop, logged into his Silk Road admin account, and sent messages under his name. Could have happened /s
And no, there is no reasonable doubt that Dread Pirate Roberts, the person who tried to order a hit on a snitch, is Ross Ulbricht. While they never prosecuted murder, proving that DPR was Ross was a necessary staple of the drug charges.
pseudonymity != anonymity. When someone manages to link your high-profile silk road account to your RL identity, you're going to have a bad time. Especially if you then go on to ask a federal informant to murder someone for you.
15
u/jessquit Mar 30 '19
I'm sorry, your "proof" appears to have been collected by demonstrably corrupt agents and you have no provable chain of custody.
So your "evidence" is pure-D bullshit. If you throw out all the heavily tainted evidence from this case, will there be any evidence left? Doubtful.
3
u/capn_hector Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
I thought the whole point of crypto was that it was immune to that weak fleshy stuff?
Are you claiming that Federal agents somehow got to Ross and sent messages using his crypto keys before the bust started? Or literally the whole investigation, all the agents who saw messages from Ross at the time of the crime, were corrupt? Or that the whole mathematical basis for modern cryptography is broken? (lol)
Again, this isn't like "sprinkle some crack" territory here. Forging crypto keys is mathematically impossible. Either Ross sent it, or someone who Ross authorized sent it. You can imagine duress/etc but his defense failed to prove (or even allege) any of that.
Again, to emphasize: if you don't want to end up in federal prison, don't give the Feds a cryptographically strong proof of your intent to commit murder.
This is the Al Capone situation - maybe he would have gotten a shorter sentence before, but he demonstrated enough evidence of higher crimes that the prosecutors came down like a ton of bricks on the charges they had him dead to rights on, and were satisfied with the life sentence they got. And really there is no doubt they could have gotten the attempted murder charges if they wanted. Math proves it, that's the point of crypto.
9
u/jessquit Mar 30 '19
Or literally the whole investigation, all the agents who saw messages from Ross at the time of the crime, were corrupt?
Yes, this. I'm glad you understand.
6
u/jessquit Mar 30 '19
You have no evidence whatsoever to suggest the keys couldn't have leaked.
All of the evidence you have comes from a poisoned well. And you're right, we're not talking about sprinkle some crack levels of corruption. We're talking about stealing millions of dollars of Bitcoin and framing someone for murder.
2
u/jbrev01 Mar 30 '19
I find it strange how people throw all logic out the window when it comes to defending a moral position. They don't care about the logical facts, they just want their side to win and be right.
Ross knew 100% in his mind he was ordering people tortured and killed. Fortunately, none of those ever happened in real life, he was tricked on both accounts. But if he had kept his anonymity and Silk Road it would only be a matter of time before someone was really tortured and killed.
Regardless, I still don't think 2 life sentences is appropriate. If it were up to me he'd be out after the trial for time served. The possibility of him re-offending are nil at that point.
2
u/b1daly Mar 31 '19
I don’t know about that, he demonstrated a coldness and carelessness about the life and health of other human beings. That’s the sign of a personality disorder, or some kind of autistic spectrum disorder.
The that doesn’t mean he will reoffend, but the personality that allowed him to think he would be justified murdering someone will remain. He showed no genuine remorse. The arrogance to think it’s OK to run an international drug market is breathtaking.
Aside from the conspiring to murder thing, people who think this is a victimless crime are fooling themselves. The whole underground drug economy creates by criminals of different types. SR enabled some of the most ruthless people in the world to gain money. He facilitated the distribution of drugs with no regulations on quality. How many people OD’d? How many people slid into junkiedom that much faster by doing heroin laced with fentanyl? How many people stole from their families or missed days of their life to oblivion. The pushing of opiates by Purdue Pharma is an outrage, and the dark market dealers threw fuel onto an already alarming health crisis that was created knowingly. I hope some of those executives wind up in prison with Ross, they can compare notes.
1
Apr 03 '19
he demonstrated a coldness and carelessness about the life and health of other human beings
where did he do that?
2
u/b1daly Apr 04 '19
In his emails when he was trying to arrange the murder of his perceived enemies.
1
1
u/capn_hector Mar 30 '19 edited Mar 30 '19
Yup.
It should have been the other way around (he's in prison for a decade or two for attempted murder, not the drug trafficking), but that's not the way the justice system works. Al Capone spent the rest of his life in prison for tax evasion.
And of course our sentences are way too high in general. No debate there. And that our prisons suck. No debate there.
But if you believe the concept of cryptography, there is not any reasonable doubt that Ross ordered a murder. Seriously, drugs should be legal and Ross Ulbricht should be in jail for attempted murder, these are orthogonal concepts here.
By the time a federal prosecutor charges you, you are 100% going to jail. Any lawyer will tell you that. Period the end. Hell, by the time they talk to you. They will have been rolling up your case for a year or two at that point, minimum. Rolling up accomplices like the one Ross tried to murder, physical evidence, whatever. They'll get you on record trying to murder a federal informant, even.
Once they have a surefire case that is going to send you to jail, they dump every charge they can reasonably put on you, and let you plea down to the ones they can 100% nail you on. There is still a 95% chance that Ross would go to jail for attempted murder, but they have a 100% chance of nailing him on drug trafficking, and he still gets 2 life sentences anyway. Why turn it into a 3 ring circus over murder when he will die in prison just from the trafficking charge? They can always bring the murder charges later if they need.
Just how it works. And yeah, it needs reform too, but it's not unique to Ross. And even if this system didn't exist, Ross would be in prison for attempted murder. Because he, or whoever held those keys (hurr hurr who can tell, maybe it was just a coincidence they slapped his laptop closed and he had the keys loaded) did absolutely attempt to commit murder, with cryptographic certainty. That's not the prosecutor saying that, that's anyone who understands the mathematical concept of cryptographic identity or cryptographic keys saying that.
3
1
u/KayRice Mar 31 '19
Don't listen to /u/capn_hector I heard he tries to murder for hire people. I'll retract this allegation in 4 years.
2
u/newprofile15 Mar 31 '19
Here's to another several decades of Ulbricht in prison until his death. Ulbricht is an attempted murderer, drug kingpin, money launderer who committed countless felonies and caused the deaths of many people. Fuck Ross Ulbricht.
1
1
u/marinesouths Mar 30 '19
I love ulbricht Ross he still remain a hero, I pray God remove him from that hell hole called federal prison.
1
u/gulfbitcoin Mar 30 '19
idealistic naive hippie who launched a libertarian free market
Not entirely "free", and definitely not "naive". The site had categories that were added by site admins, not vendors. Categories that were reasonably expected to contain illegal items. It's not like I can open up a flea market with an area marked "Cocaine" and claim ignorance.
I have always been of the opinion that he's not innocent - as long as illegal drug sales sends people to prison, he should be accountable. His life sentence is unreasonable; a 10 year felony sentence seems appropriate.
1
u/the_antonious Mar 31 '19
Plain and simple.. and example is being made.. I truly believe this is the basis behind the harsh punishment.
You let him go, new people capable of creating something to this caliber now have an out if they do create it and get caught, especially non-violent, first time offenders.
You don’t budge, and leave him in for a life sentence.. perhaps that deters some people from creating something like the Silk Road in the future.
It’s all bullshit.. punishment was unreasonably harsh.. but there were crimes committed.
1
u/demies Mar 31 '19
Man, these guys went all out against him, wanting to destroy him and they did. The law is still the law, and he got the worse of it. Did the agents go so hard after him to make sure no one would figure out their theft? Just an idealistic geek with an idea to give the world something new. People always complain about the negative but any market in the world has its dark ways, I mean banks are the biggest crooks of all, but it's the small guy that eats it.
1
1
u/CrazyBarnacle Mar 31 '19
Clemency could garner and galvanize support for Republicans in the tech world which ideally could lead to more open access for conservatives in Silicon Valley companies.
lmao
-2
u/DrunkPanda Mar 30 '19
For all the people who aren't sure, go read or listen to American kingpin. I lost all sympathy for him when I did.
1
1
u/HalfBakedPotato84 Mar 30 '19
Is the tech world really that hard on Republicans?
Edit: serious question
2
-5
0
-1
Mar 30 '19
But he wasn't even arrested until October 2013, convicted in 2015. How could he have already served 6 years (March 30, 2013) ?
1
-2
Mar 30 '19
If Ross Ulbricht would have been black and gay they would have just dismissed everything. He's in prison because he's white and straight. Shame on him for having the wrong genetics!
-5
u/numen-lumen Mar 30 '19
Yes black tar heroin and fentanyl are exactly the same as cars and alcohol. Solid logic.
2
-7
-2
u/tiffanylan Mar 30 '19
I agree with all of this but what about the evidence that Ross hired a hitman to kill a witness? That is actually one of the main reasons he’s in prison for life.
-19
u/fyfiul7 Mar 30 '19
Deserved it! He single handedly delayed the adoption of Bitcoin by decades and killed countless babies.
0
Mar 31 '19
[deleted]
1
u/fyfiul7 Mar 31 '19
He made it popular for 2 years and delayed its adoption for decades. Wake up, that's the reality.
-7
u/numen-lumen Mar 30 '19
While some drugs may seem like victimless crimes I’m guessing parents of kids that died overdosing from drugs bought off The Silk Road would most likely think otherwise. It wasn’t just weed and magic mushrooms being bought and sold.
4
u/freshlysquosed Mar 30 '19
Would those people have been safer buying from the streets?
Would they have been safer buying from a Chemist?
Ross made the situation safer, the state made it less safe, as far as I can see.
1
u/CrazyBarnacle Mar 31 '19
Would those people have been safer buying from the streets?
Most of them woudn't have bought at all you idiot.
1
-2
u/numen-lumen Mar 30 '19
How’d he make it safer? It gave everyone access to any drug possible. That seems unsafe.
4
u/freshlysquosed Mar 30 '19
He made it safer by implementing the reputation system and having a market where testing of drugs was not only possible but paid for by him (see Doctor X, I think).
As for giving people more access to drugs, that's neither here nor there when discussing how he made taking drugs safer. As far as that goes, I'd like to point out that they are really easy to come by anyway.
What do you think about my questions?
4
u/eDOTiQ Mar 30 '19
Do you fault your car dealer if your kid steals your car keys and dies driving said car,
Do you hold beverage companies accountable when people drunk drive?
0
Mar 30 '19
[deleted]
33
u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Mar 30 '19
Drug laws destroy far far more lives than drugs.
19
u/htvwls Redditor for less than 60 days Mar 30 '19
Sadly, I feel like this applies to countless other laws too.
0
11
u/freshlysquosed Mar 30 '19
What does it matter if he facilitated the drugs? Overall, Silkroad made buying drugs way safer. Prohibition is what makes fraudulent/cut drugs (these are the ones which overwhelmingly kill people) a thing in the first place.
10
u/Postal2Dude Mar 30 '19
Those drugs can save lives sometimes. They don't tell you that in the indoctrination camps.
1
u/jparcus56 Redditor for less than 2 weeks Mar 30 '19
I really don't know that much about this to be playing with someone life
0
0
Mar 30 '19
[deleted]
4
u/artful-compose Mar 30 '19
It is very naive to think people can govern themselves
So people aren’t capable of governing themselves, but if you group a bunch of those same people together they’ll be capable of governing everybody else?
Perhaps if you give a bunch of those people silly uniforms they’ll be great at controlling everybody else, even though you said people can’t even govern themselves?
3
u/jonald_fyookball Electron Cash Wallet Developer Mar 31 '19
Roger you think people should just be allowed to ingest whatever drugs they want to, but this can hurt peoples’ lives
I think I should be allowed to ingest whatever drugs I want. It's my body.
1
u/CrazyBarnacle Mar 31 '19
I don't think you should be allowed to do that, I don't want drugged-out creeps around me.
1
u/jonald_fyookball Electron Cash Wallet Developer Mar 31 '19
That's the difference between us. I believe people should be 'allowed' to do whatever they want as long as they aren't stepping on others' rights.
1
u/CrazyBarnacle Apr 02 '19
Yes, and at the same time you fail to realize that "being a drugged out creep waving their guns at the neighbors' kids while ranting about ron paul" is stepping pretty heavily on others' rights.
56
u/MemoryDealers Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com Mar 30 '19
The above is from an email someone sent me. I thought it was worth sharing.