r/btc • Roger Ver - Bitcoin Entrepreneur - Bitcoin.com • Mar 20 '19

Why I'm not a fan of the SV community: My recent bill for defending their frivolous lawsuit against open source software developers.

Post image
366 Upvotes

200 comments sorted by

43

u/Chris_Pacia OpenBazaar Mar 21 '19

My god the US really needs loser pays.

145

u/todu Mar 21 '19

Thank you for spending a lot of your own money to defend BCH for all of us Roger.

31

u/steve_m0 Mar 21 '19

DITTO!!!

One Up vote, not quite enough, felt I needed to be extra. Thanks RV!

65

u/uiuyiuyo Mar 21 '19

You can counter sue for legal expenses in many cases...

50

u/caveden Mar 21 '19

Seriously, it's absurd that somebody can make you burn money just by suing you like this. Loser must pay legal fees, specially if the lawsuit was initiated by the loser.

19

u/pyalot Mar 21 '19

They're probably suing from a jurisdiction where it's hard to claw back legal costs, and trough shell companies that'll be folded into bankruptcy in case they should lose.

What should happen is to have the lawsuits dismissed and then file counterclaims, include in the plaintiffs the discovery of the actual entities behind the shell companies, for abuse of process, fraud and any civil claim pertaining to frivolous lawsuits and tack on damages and legal costs.

Done right this might get really expensive for Calvin and Craig.

5

u/Zectro Mar 21 '19

They're probably suing from a jurisdiction where it's hard to claw back legal costs, and trough shell companies that'll be folded into bankruptcy in case they should lose.

The company doing the suing is a Miami-based company called "UnitedCorp," ever heard of them? Yeah me neither.

7

u/unitedstatian Mar 21 '19

It's very hard to fight someone who's aided by the state.

20

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

Law is more about making money from lawsuits.

The justice part beeing camouflage merely. There is no such thing as justice in front of a court, only making money for lawers.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

[deleted]

20

u/JonathanSilverblood Jonathan#100, Jack of all Trades Mar 21 '19

The problem isn't the people who work in the system, the problem is the incentive structures and faceless organizations that have created it.

I have full respect for all who pursue a profession out of passion and if it weren't for them working inside the system I would've had a much worse time being a part of it.

10

u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 21 '19

I’m a sellout and work in a firm

At least you're here representing us crypto critters.

You can appreciate the younger generation's cynicism about laws, they've watched corporations take over everything "legally".

2

u/whistlepig33 Mar 21 '19

Nobody is trying to argue that their intentions aren't good.

3

u/kecuoicap Mar 21 '19

This. It surprising to me how many just don't notice the shear amount of money that goes through the grinder in a lawsuit. Nothing comes cheap when it comes to lawyers and man don't they leave big holes in one's wallet.

3

u/andersrh Mar 21 '19

In my country the loser pays everything

7

u/cr0ft Mar 21 '19

That's the only sane way to do it.

That would make it far less easy for scumbags to target people for copyright infringement and threaten them with a lawsuit just to make them pay legal blackmail. People would gladly go to court and dare them to try to prove their guilt if there was a solid chance the accuser wound up holding the bag, financially.

When just the threat of a lawsuit is a weapon someone with more money and resources can use on someone less affluent, the system is broken. And boy howdy is the US system broken. Regulatory capture all over the place, and even the supreme court is now a Republican rubber stamp machine. Want a law that lets you abuse children and immigrants and put them in concentration camps? Sure thing, just order it from the supreme court, a la carte. The four sane progressives will vote no, and the right-wing lowlives will vote yes. The five right-wing lowlives.

3

u/cr0ft Mar 21 '19

Using the criminal justice system as a blunt instrument is a tried and true tactic. For most people, just getting sued can bankrupt them. That's why the Copyright Mafia and movie studios and whatnot can extort thousands out of people, even innocent people - it's less destructive for their lives to pay the blackmail than it is to go to court and pay 10, 20 times the blackmail. If they'd lose, they'd be even more screwed and even more bankrupt, and if they win they probably still have to pay the court costs. It's a lose-lose-lose.

Court costs should automatically be on the accuser who lost the lawsuit. For both parties. They were the one who started the ruckus and if they didn't have enough to win, they should be liable for all the court's costs.

-42

u/cryptoplane Mar 21 '19 edited Mar 21 '19

he didn’t post this for pity on lost funds. The narcissist in him just wants to show off how rich he is because you know, he’s like the greatest investor of all time.

Also, were the lawsuits against the corporation or the person? If business, it’s not exactly coming out of the mans pocket, would be written off come tax season

7

u/chainxor Mar 21 '19

I smell salt.

5

u/t9b Mar 21 '19

Really? This guy is paying on behalf of all of us. Look at it this way, if he didn't defend this, CSW would win by default and then who knows what he will try to assert over open source. So unless you want to contribute, you have no right to criticise.

3

u/cr0ft Mar 21 '19

If it doesn't come out of his pocket, that's sort of worse. Because in that case it's coming out of your pocket.

Or did you think tax writeoffs just happen and nobody has to pay taxes in the other end to make up for that? The government needs enough coming in to pay all the stuff going out. Sure, $70 grand in the grand scheme may not impact your wallet a lot, but now multiply that with the gazillions in other lawsuits...

10

u/bearjewpacabra Mar 21 '19

let me know how that works out for you...

4

u/uiuyiuyo Mar 21 '19

Uh, have you never counter sued for legal expenses? I have, quite successfully.

1

u/bearjewpacabra Mar 21 '19

You have sued someone for legal expenses in the hundreds of thousands of dollars?

2

u/uiuyiuyo Mar 21 '19

Hundreds? No. Tens, yes. In fact, it's very common for the prevailing party to get attorney fees recovered to some extent, often times significant amounts.

There is no cap on recovering attorney fees. If someone wants to start a frivolous lawsuit and lose, they can find up owing a lot of money.

3

u/bearjewpacabra Mar 21 '19

they can find up owing a lot of money.

Key word, 'can'. In Roger's case, he should not, neither should anyone... assume they are going to get their hundreds of thousands of dollars back. That would be a catastrophic assumption for someone who can't afford to lose it all or most of it.

1

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 21 '19

Not in all jurisdictions. In the U.S. in particular it can be difficult to recover legal expenses in most cases. (Basically it isn't allowed unless a law or a specific signed agreement allows it)

-9

u/Adrian-X Mar 21 '19

Assuming it's a frivolous law suite. The ABC developers destroyed BCH by insisting on hard forking.

8

u/tl121 Mar 21 '19

ABC developers protected BCH by sticking with the planned hard fork. Had they failed to do so nChain might have established a "no hard fork" precedent, which could well have been the first step to Core like capture and stagnation.

8

u/jessquit Mar 21 '19

That is in fact one of BSVs two goals:

  • lock down the protocol

  • kill BCH

5

u/masterD3v Mar 21 '19

This is correct. If planned upgrades are stalled BCH will be in a weak position. In such an early stage of Bitcoin's (BCH) life, hard forks are an important tool to upgrade the protocol. BitcoinCore can't fork - their protocol is dead - and I believe this was an attempt to remove hard forks as a viable upgrade path for BCH.

Forking despite the last-minute, unsubstantiated concerns would have been disaster.

The other benefit is that we've seen who the SV users are in Bitcoin Unlimited and other subreddit users here and now know who the wolfs in sheeps clothing are. BCH has enemies and they are here among us trying their best to stop peer-to-peer electronic cash for the world. These are powerful entities and they are trying new attacks and planning new ones as we speak.

8

u/jessquit Mar 21 '19

Assuming it's a frivolous law suite. The ABC developers destroyed BCH by insisting on hard forking.

Troll harder. You're better than this. This is lame.

There was developer consensus on the fork, including nchain developers, until immediately after code freeze.

Then BSV decided to fork off, and didn't even realize that what they were doing would split the coin. They kept repeating "no split!" even though it was patently apparent that their code would in fact split the chain.

It was an act of either astonishing ineptitude or an outright attack.

1

u/Adrian-X Mar 24 '19

ABC could have not proceeded with the fork or allowed their block to be orphaned by legacy BCH or BSV blocks. As it turned out both ABC and BSV abandoned BCH.

1

u/uiuyiuyo Mar 21 '19

Losing is losing, whether it frivolous or not. Attorney fees are often recoverable by the prevailing party.

26

u/hitforhelp Mar 20 '19

Can you elaborate on this situation at all?

26

u/jessquit Mar 21 '19

Nchain is trying to sue BCH devs so they'll quit working on BCH.

-16

u/5heikki Mar 21 '19

They must be terrified of all the non-progress Bitcoin ABC has been making during the last 18 months..

8

u/kilrcola Mar 21 '19

Yeah they must be so scared, they resort to threats of lawsuits.

10

u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 21 '19

no they're terrified that Craig's SV shitcoin might take over the world with Ryan X Charles /s /lol

4

u/cr0ft Mar 21 '19

Yeah, I don't know what happened to Charles. He seems like a mostly sane and reasonable person. Sure, ABC added some new functionality that didn't in any way weaken the coin as far as I can see, and possibly strenghtened it, and he still went with SV. I enjoyed his commentary and opinions on the whole BTC and Segwit and 1MB block thing, so it surprised me that he felt SV was the way to go. But I guess it's not inconsistent if he's a purist and maximalist, "original spec or die".

3

u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 21 '19

Ryan mumbled some stuff about using Craig's patented tech on Yours.org and he said "only one coin can win". He got brainwashed and then sold out completely. And now he has failed by choosing the wrong "coin".

3

u/500239 Mar 21 '19

lol business 101, sue not your competition rofl.

36

u/Anen-o-me Mar 21 '19

Nchain suing everyone over the chain split.

Basically public-freak-out, lawyers edition for CSW.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

[deleted]

12

u/TechCynical Mar 21 '19

one thing bitcoin and most cryptos allows is called a chain split. This occurs when someone moves from the original chain or transactions to another path from that point making a new chain but still allowing the past ones to be verified.

so basically bch is a split from btc and after aug first bch has its own new chain different from btc from the date aug 1st 2017. everything before that is the same on both chains.

recently csw made a chain split on bch however, instead of it being a "doesnt matter if we dont gain 100% support we will still drive as a community" type of thing. BSV the BCH fork treated it as a winner takes all plus more where one chain becomes 100% useless at least in CSW eyes. BSV did not win as csw tried to shout over and over and panicked and threw lawsuits around saying there was collusion to make me lose. He lost that fight to and is being a cry baby.

1

u/UnexpectedLemon Mar 22 '19

Oh wow, I’m glad he lost. He sounds horrible. Why did he even decide to split anyways?

3

u/TechCynical Mar 22 '19

Political thought in crypto. It's the same reason bch split had occurred. Csw thought that another way is the only way to scale bitcoin so he made a split.

0

u/Jo_Bones Apr 06 '19

He actually didn't. He kept the protocol the same as it was. He invented the protocol in the first place and everyone else kept changing it and stealing the bitcoin name. In the end he had to keep the same protocol going because it's the only one that is functional in the long term. It's very important that the chain remains the same in the long term. Anyway, people don't understand, don't 'believe' etc. There's a lot of misconceptions, misunderstanding and deception in Bitcoin.

1

u/UnexpectedLemon Apr 06 '19

Your account is less than 30 days old, and almost every single comment is in defense of that guy. Certainly seems pretty suspicious to me. Also that’s still not any excuse to sue everybody.

1

u/Jo_Bones Apr 07 '19

Yeah, I signed up a few days ago to Reddit. I had accounts in the past but not linked to these forums. You can treat it as suspicious if you want. You can treat anything as suspicious if you're a suspicious type. The reality is that you sue when someone fucks your shit up, and the Core Devs and Roger and Jihan both fucked with Craig Wright and his life's work. What you don't understand is that when you've spent 20 years developing something (1998 to 2017) and someone comes and takes that shit away from you out of ignorance, you're gonna go after them, especially when the stakes are so high, and brother, the stakes are very high here. Go have a read of his blog. BTW: I've been following this drama for 7 years now. New account, old hand. https://medium.com/@craig_10243

67

u/OsrsNeedsF2P Mar 21 '19

Goddamn Roger. My first impression of you was you quitting some guys stream and giving him the middle finger for saying "Bcash bcash bcash", but that must have been your absolute lowest because since then I've earned nothing but more respect for you.

You're really driving this community and holding it on your back, putting in way more blood and sweat than most of us. Keep it up :)

44

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

I've earned nothing but more respect for you.

Roger is legit. Plain simple.

And Core fascists are scumm. Censorshipwreck scumm, they are.

12

u/threesixzero Mar 21 '19

> absolute lowest

I guess I'm the only person in the world that thought that was cool AMA

12

u/Tomayachi Mar 21 '19

The host of that show was completely ignorant, pompous, and very rude to Roger throughout the interview. Roger had a right to be upset, but he over reacted and it got blown out of proportion. Roger even put out a sincere apology video for his behavior the next day. He's a class act.

7

u/MostPalone- Mar 21 '19

I prefer BTC than BCH, but Carvalho was an asshole. Triggering Roger was definitely intentional. I'm with Roger on that "debate".

3

u/Tomayachi Mar 21 '19

Yeah that behaviour shouldn't be tolerated or celebrated. Thanks for acknowledging that. I'm curious why you prefer btc?

1

u/WippleDippleDoo Mar 21 '19

Fuck that guy. Lowly Coretard scum.

7

u/JonathanSilverblood Jonathan#100, Jack of all Trades Mar 21 '19

Did you see the full stream? The response was highly provoked and while it wasn't a "professional" or "civil" of ver to act the way he did, it certaintly was justified.

4

u/cr0ft Mar 21 '19

Yeah, I'm sure Ver is sincere, and doing good work for BCH.

I don't really enjoy his crazed libertarian stance on everything but meh, his beliefs are his own I suppose.

23

u/BitcoinArtist Andreas Brekken - CEO - Shitcoin.com Mar 21 '19

7

u/Contrarian__ Mar 21 '19

Why'd you delete the Cult of Craig repo?

11

u/jessquit Mar 21 '19

Why not class action countersue chief scientist CSW for gross negligence in causing a split he repeatedly claimed would and could never happen and distribute the proceeds among all provable holders of BCH?

4

u/bcloud71 Mar 21 '19

Second this! The best defense is always offense!

2

u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 21 '19

class action countersue

Sun Tzu: in war, the way is to avoid what is strong and to strike at what is weak.

31

u/firesarise Redditor for less than 2 weeks Mar 21 '19

I hope all of you are able to counter-sue CSW into bankruptcy.

Shouldn't be hard to prove he's a malicious nutcase and a proven liar with no case to any judge with a brain considering he's left about 4 years of direct evidence of this laying around. This is just legal harassment and nothing more because this is what butthurt does when it has money.

36

u/LovelyDay Mar 21 '19

CSW has no money.

He is an employee.

10

u/jessquit Mar 21 '19

Sue his employer then. Follow the money.

3

u/firesarise Redditor for less than 2 weeks Mar 21 '19

I suppose I should have said "this is what butthurt does when it has access to money", not necessarily his

3

u/unitedstatian Mar 21 '19

That's right. He was very heavily in debt to the Aussie tax man.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

But calvin has money

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

[deleted]

13

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

CSW is a broke fraud.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

[deleted]

10

u/jessquit Mar 21 '19

You can buy a dozen Rolexes in Chinatown for $60.

12

u/todu Mar 21 '19

Hey /u/contrarian__. Can you offer your help to Roger and his lawyers with regard to these frivolous lawsuits? You know a lot about the scammer and patent troll Craig Wright and his accomplices.

15

u/jessquit Mar 21 '19

I for one think /u/Contrarian__ needs to be put on a stand as an expert witness against CSW. I'd pay good money to see that go down.

-13

u/Zarathustra_V Mar 21 '19

an expert witness

"I fully support core" contrarian.

Now he also supports the Bitcoin Cash fork of the North Corean miners.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

Thats all you got?

11

u/Zectro Mar 21 '19

You haven't been paying attention if you expected more from u/Zarathustra_V. He just kind of recites the same handful of slogans, blindly defends SV supporters like they're his family, and talks about how Craig Wright was the Steve Jobs of the Satoshi team and everyone who disagrees is in a cult.

-6

u/Zarathustra_V Mar 21 '19

and talks about how Craig Wright was the Steve Jobs of the Satoshi team and everyone who disagrees is in a cult

That's a lie, but no surprise coming from you.

-7

u/Zarathustra_V Mar 21 '19

blindly defends SV supporters like they're his family

another lie. CSW blocked me on twitter because what you are claiming is a lie.

4

u/Zectro Mar 21 '19 edited Mar 21 '19

It must have hurt a lot when your hero, who you've gone to bat for countless times, blocked you. My condolences.

Let me pay my respects.

F

0

u/Zarathustra_V Mar 22 '19

It must hurt a lot when your hero, the fake contrarian gets criticised.

-1

u/Zarathustra_V Mar 21 '19 edited Mar 21 '19

He's one of those countless anonymous heroes who obsessively attack real persons and the anonymous hero account u/zectro agitates as his shadow.

4

u/Zectro Mar 21 '19

He's one of those countless anonymous heroes

Who are you again? Do you really share the same name as an ancient Persian prophet? Are you seriously criticising anonymity from the confines of anonymity? Where does your hypocrisy end?

1

u/Zarathustra_V Mar 22 '19

Who are you again? Do you really share the same name as an ancient Persian prophet? Are you seriously criticising anonymity from the confines of anonymity? Where does your hypocrisy end?

Since you don't seem to be able to differentiate. I'm speaking about anonymous stalker accounts who are obsessively stalking non-anonymous persons.

-12

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

You need legal proofs, not contrarian level ones. They might work in a high school debate though.

6

u/Contrarian__ Mar 21 '19

Oh, PSP, how you amuse me!

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

All in good humor. Now you can call off your attack dogs. ;)

6

u/Contrarian__ Mar 21 '19

I don't control anyone or any account except this one.

This comment was particularly amusing to me!

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

Glad you liked it. :)

6

u/Contrarian__ Mar 21 '19 edited Mar 21 '19

I get a kick out of the excuses delusional people make when confronted with evidence.

For instance, I was talking with someone about Craig's recent post where he tried to write a piece of Script code that computes truncated subtraction. He failed miserably and hilariously. One of his minions then said, "he was drunk". When I asked where he got that idea, he said, "it's obvious"!

Similarly, you try to handwave the evidence away.

Have you seen the Netflix documentary about flat earthers? It's like that.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

I haven't actually.

Flat earthers are good at making arguments that sound plausible; but there is usually one fatal mistake, assumption or premise in their argument. They also tend to rely on the amount of "proofs" they have, as if the weight of multiple low quality "proofs" all add up to a high quality one. They don't seem to realize that all they'd need is one single water tight proof, but because the earth isn't actually flat, it is elusive to them.

6

u/Contrarian__ Mar 21 '19

I generally agree, and it's exactly the same with those who think Craig is Satoshi.

They also tend to rely on the amount of "proofs" they have, as if the weight of multiple low quality "proofs" all add up to a high quality one

Precisely the argument of Ian Grigg. Craig himself advocates for this method, as well (for obvious reasons).

They don't seem to realize that all they'd need is one single water tight proof [signature with PGP key or genesis block], but because he isn't Satoshi, it is elusive to them.

However, the amusement comes from their rationalizations when they're directly confronted with evidence.

I think you're trying to suggest that I'm guilty of the 'using multiple low quality proofs', but that's pretty absurd given the strength of the evidence. In fact, it's difficult to imagine stronger proof that he's not Satoshi than what we have now.

You're not one of those people who thinks it's impossible to prove a negative, are you?

→ More replies (0)

6

u/jessquit Mar 21 '19

It's called an "expert witness" genius.

-8

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

LOL. Then Contrarian is definitely the wrong guy. :)

8

u/jessquit Mar 21 '19

The idea of Contrarian taking the stand to debunk the hundreds of lies your boss has told must be really frightening.

-6

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

Firstly, "my boss"? Not sure what you are talking about.

Contrarian taking the stand isn't the slightest bit scary. I say bring it on!

I'd be rather more nervous if you took the stand though jessquit. Unlike Contrarian you actually have the capacity to generate valuable insights and make intellectually sound arguments. For some reason, however, you seem to flip from writing some genuinely inspired stuff (not joking in any way here), to regular Reddit level combativeness and bias. I'm not sure why that is.

-6

u/Zarathustra_V Mar 21 '19

u/contrarian__ himself is an "I fully support core" scammer.

2

u/Zyoman Mar 21 '19

> proven liar

Then how can we know he got money? Despite a few photo on the web, I only saw 2 dev in the SV team... I don't think he could afford more than that.

20

u/cryptos4pz Mar 20 '19

Ho--Lee--Crap

16

u/CatatonicAdenosine Mar 21 '19

Seriously, fuck those guys. Sorry you have to deal with this rubbish Roger, you deserve much better. Keep fighting the good fight!

8

u/DerSchorsch Mar 21 '19 edited Mar 21 '19

CSW and Calvin have threatened with legal action on multiple occasions, but there was never any outrage within the SV community, rather the opposite:

https://twitter.com/kurtwuckertjr/status/1108431194314735616

https://twitter.com/TweetyBirdbrain/status/1100261119145447424

https://twitter.com/CalvinAyre/status/1071316524533612544

This alone makes SV a red flag for me which I'd want no part of.

Perhaps the biggest irony is the fact that they are still complaining about rented hash rate (proof?), but led the whole hash war ad absurdum by splitting off with hash power minority themselves. All the whilst still claiming that "only miners decide".

BSV are the cognitive dissonance kings of crypto.

6

u/jessquit Mar 21 '19

BSV are the cognitive dissonance kings of crypto.

This x100

15

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

We can thank Roger by supporting and doing business with Bitcoin.com.

Thanks man for everything you do.

15

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

Keep it up Roger. It's a long road ahead of us, but in the same way Linux was build, in the same way the systems build to share music and video over bittorrent, eventually we will have over by the people,for the people, because of the people money system. The idea is good powerful to be stopped, can only be delayed!

All of this is just some powerful people trying to keep you to occupied to be able to build freedom stuff.

Keep fighting!

21

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19 edited Jun 16 '23

[deleted to prove Steve Huffman wrong] -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/

7

u/unitedstatian Mar 21 '19

The way in which BSV is fighting BCH using the government while at the same time making crypto as a whole seem like a bad idea is very telling indeed.

13

u/lucasmcducas Mar 21 '19

Give them hell Roger. We are with you.

12

u/garoththorp Mar 21 '19

We're blessed to have you. Probably, this whole BCH resistance movement would have failed without your steadfast morality

6

u/knight222 Mar 21 '19

I guess lawsuits is what you do when you can't code.

10

u/toorik Mar 21 '19

Thank you, Roger!

9

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

The suit is so retarded, it will easily get rejected, this is open source software and anyone can choose whatever software they want to run. If they had problems with the new software update, they could have just moved to BSV or kept mining on old blockchain consensus rules. Anyway, this suing company has no meaning in the crypto space, its a shell company, it doesnt do anything and doesnt claim to do anything either, its a total bullshit thing where a (fake) business is unhappy others are existing and alive. Business doesn't work this way where business sue other businesses for just existing, lol. Tbh its quite hilarious this lawsuit because it will get rejected immediately as total BS because the suing company is a nobody, not even a human or consumer.

Most here in r/btc follow BCH software, some moved to BSV software. No harm was done as coin values on blockchain are decided by normal supply & demand market forces and not by a malicious actor, since it’s decentralized after all.

BSV is pure evil, as they are using a shell company with no revenue as a front for pedophile money launderer Calvin Ayre and fraud and tax convict Craig Wright for the lawsuit, making it harder to recover legal costs when the defendants have won.

I am so glad I sold all my BSV sometime ago and bought all BCH with it.

2

u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 21 '19

The suit is so retarded, it will easily get rejected,

Hmm, I hear it's cheap to "buy a judge" in South Florida... this might go on for years...

8

u/stewbits22 Mar 21 '19

Huge respect to you Roger, I wish developers who are 'neutral' would rally behind the ABC developers.

4

u/buy_the_fucking_dip Mar 21 '19

First of all, thank you Roger, for everything that you do.

Second, this lawsuit has no merit. scammers are great at subverting the legal system and fooling laymen into thinking that figures of authority granted legitimacy to their claims.

Finally, the Kleiman lawsuit is a similar sham lawsuit, designed to lend credibility to The Fraud.

Best bet is to ignore as much of this as possible, defend aggressively against bullshit claims made against our people. Thanks again for standing by the BCH devs.

4

u/Lunarghini Mar 21 '19

There was a reason Satoshi stayed anonymous.

All the egos in this space are reaping what they sowed.

7

u/Leithm Mar 21 '19

Thank you Roger.

9

u/BitcoinIsTehFuture Moderator Mar 21 '19

I’m sorry you had to be the receiving end of such hateful attacks. They are designed to destroy the influencers in the BCH space.

6

u/chainxor Mar 21 '19

Thank you Roger. You are a true renaissance man!

3

u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 21 '19

Lawsuits have no place in the crypto community. And no relevance

3

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

Next time, subpoena CSW and trick him to perjure himself. Things should be quiet for .... oh 5 to 20 years.

3

u/JayPeee Mar 21 '19

Dude, Roger, you’re awesome.

3

u/tralxz Mar 21 '19

Thank you Roger for defending these developers.

5

u/Lonsmrdr Mar 21 '19

Thanks for fighting for a case for all humanity Roger!

8

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

Someone give this man some BCH (I would but my balance is at 0 at the moment)

5

u/____jelly_time____ Redditor for less than 60 days Mar 20 '19

wow!

2

u/mander1555 Mar 21 '19

Pretty cool how you are involved in the community. It makes me wonder if 10 or 20 years from now, people will go back and look at some of these posts for historical/documentary reasons.

2

u/yourliestopshere Mar 21 '19

Is there anything we can do?

3

u/steve_m0 Mar 21 '19

Many multiples of that many lost in this split.

1

u/mrreddit Mar 21 '19

Perhaps put up a donation address on bitcoin.com so rest of us can pitch in. u/chaintip

-1

u/ithanksatoshi Mar 21 '19

SV community? Which entity is that?

Silly statement.

I could make statements just as silly like "I do not like the BCH community for conspiring with exchanges about a ticker symbol before any Nakamoto Consensus had played out".

Of course, I know it were just a few power-hungry individuals without any integrity. So why point fingers at a community?

2

u/Helvetian616 Mar 21 '19

This is the most honest and balanced comment here. So of course it's downvoted.

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

Wonder if the redirection of hashpower last year came into play?

14

u/Big_Bubbler Mar 21 '19

The redirection to protect BCH from a hostile take-over?

-6

u/ValiumMm Mar 21 '19

BCH, which was/is bitcoin is about hashrate keeping the chain safe. I think 10 block re org by ABC/exchanges put in at the last minute is more of a hostile takeover. But huuurrr duuuurrr, i hate CSW that means BSV chain is bad... if only people just looked at the code/maths and not people.
Would it really have been that bad if the hashrate went to BSV and the chain didnt split, we would have a lot more going for BCH. All the awesome stuff unwriter has done on BSV would of been awesome on BCH.

9

u/FEDCBA9876543210 Mar 21 '19

Calvin and Craig are malicious actors and are the sole BSV miners. They own BSV. I certainly do not trust narcissists and bullies, nor do I finance them. My choice. Risk. Finance.

> BCH, which was/is bitcoin is about hashrate keeping the chain safe.

If hashrate means anything, BCH has won the hashwar - by a large margin, still increasing everyday.

> 10 block re org

Reorg protection has been used since Satoshi himself. The fact that the code was available and that Craig's team did nonetheless try to reorg the BCH chain, not to mention them self reorging their own chain, says a lot about the competence involved.

> Would it really have been that bad if the hashrate went to BSV and the chain didnt split

Yes. This would have meant the end of Bitcoin as far as I am concerned.

> All the awesome stuff unwriter has done on BSV

is open source and can be ported to BCH.

15

u/deadalnix Mar 21 '19

BCH, which was/is bitcoin is about hashrate keeping the chain safe

You must be mistaken. It's about peer to peer digital cash.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

stuff unwriter has done on BSV

I'm glad unwriter is out.

0

u/ValiumMm Mar 21 '19

Great attitude...

1

u/Big_Bubbler Mar 22 '19

Bitcoin is not about " hashrate keeping the chain safe". It is about bringing peer-to-peer electronic cash to the world. BSV is not trying to do that the way Bitcoin was intended to. Rich people tried to steal the top contender for bringing peer-to-peer electronic cash to the world. ABC saved BCH again from the evil attacks meant to destroy peer-to-peer electronic cash for the people. I am not aware of any great stuff unwriter has done since the split. If any, I'd guess it is open source and BCH can add it if we like it, or, if closed source or patented novel new ideas it shows they are planning to do stuff that is bad for the world.

1

u/ValiumMm Mar 22 '19

BSV is trying to. This is just your opinion or do you have facts? They literally had the protocol exactly like BCH just increasing blocksize to 128MB.

1

u/Big_Bubbler Mar 23 '19

Maybe you are out of touch with their public statements and current testing of big blocks. We know just supersizing the blocksize does not work. BSV people say great things sometimes, but, they appear to be devious and amoral people. Plus those untrustworthy people control the development of BSV like a dictatorship. I hear the plan is to make BSV 'government friendly' which would not be good for the people of the world. That's just a few problems.

1

u/ValiumMm Mar 23 '19

Why should cryptos be anti government. Seriously wake up. It's transparency

1

u/Big_Bubbler Mar 23 '19

Not anti-Gov you tool. Gov-neutral and privacy friendly.

-16

u/selectxxyba Mar 21 '19

We could have avoided this entire mess by simply omitting op_dsv and CTOR, allowing bitcoin to remain bitcoin. But instead you had to throw other people's hashpower (with no consent) behind these contentious additions to the protocol.

You made the call to split the community over those two additions, enjoy the fruits of your own labour.

14

u/CatatonicAdenosine Mar 21 '19

It wasn't up to Roger to make that decision. The Nov hard fork had been planned for months and the features had been agreed to for months by a number of different contributors. It was only days before the feature freeze that the alternative proposals were made, and a conference failed to resolve the disagreement, with CSW walking out and Calvin refusing to attend. So we had two competing proposals at the fork date, and that's why there was a split. The economic majority have chosen to follow one of those proposals. No point whinging about it.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

with CSW walking out and Calvin refusing to attend.

However Calvin seems to be excused according to his own Twitter Photo stream he has some pedophile bussiness to do at Cuba.

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

god damn hes such a creep

-9

u/selectxxyba Mar 21 '19

Only one of those proposals was adding contentious features and had no intention of compromising. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xOhZ-n_tlTg&amp=&feature=youtu.be

And what's been done with CTOR and op_dsv since, nothing. Totally worth it. The whole BCH community collectively shot it self in the foot to force in features that only a minority wanted.

10

u/CatatonicAdenosine Mar 21 '19

The whole split was political. It was about forcing division and seizing control of development.

-10

u/excalibur0922 Redditor for less than 60 days Mar 21 '19

Agreed. Roger is reaping what he sowed.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

[deleted]

-6

u/selectxxyba Mar 21 '19

Next time you're down in Melbourne hit me up, happy to interview as a supporter of BSV.

-8

u/rationalinfo Mar 21 '19

not an argument bro

0

u/CryptoSigmund Mar 21 '19

It might be a open software, but you made a Business out of it with bitcoin cash, bitcoin.com and your other investments. So don't come out like this.

Can you do a lawsuit against bitcoin?

-2

u/Pust_is_a_soletaken Mar 21 '19

I'm glad you idiots are bleeding each other dry tbh

-2

u/TonesNotes Mar 21 '19

The price you'll have to pay for acting like a moron is just beginning to add up Roger.

There are more important stakes at play here than your imagined "better life without the law".

-1

u/tenderloinCash Mar 21 '19

I wish you would leave your hatred for the judiciary system behind and use its full force against those scammers.

You do pay taxes even if you don't agree with them.

Why not use the existing, non-private judiciary system even though you know it to be corrupt at its core?

You're only empowering trolls this way.

1

u/Bagatell_ Mar 21 '19

your concern is noted.

0

u/jvhoffman Mar 22 '19

No sympathy

-18

u/excalibur0922 Redditor for less than 60 days Mar 21 '19

To be fair it's pretty bad what you did. Violating your own libertarian principles

-12

u/gjgjhyyt77645tyydhg5 Redditor for less than 60 days Mar 21 '19

Roger, if someone else rented hashpower and took control of the BCH protocol, what would you think?

4

u/Zectro Mar 21 '19 edited Mar 21 '19

u/fookingroovin, I'm going to channel you* and ask: what proof do you have that Roger rented hashpower?

*I realise this isn't really channeling you since you combine extreme skepticism for all claims that contradict your CSW-truther worldview with extreme child-like credulity towards all claims that reinforce your worldview.

1

u/selectxxyba Mar 21 '19

Roger himself said that he financially reimbursed those that provided hash power to the btc pool when he redirected it to the bch pool.

3

u/Zectro Mar 21 '19

How is directing the hash people had in his pool towards mining BCH exclusively "renting hash." The TOS people agreed to allowed him to do that. Don't mine in his pool if that's a problem.

-2

u/selectxxyba Mar 21 '19

Any proof that the TOS specified that this could happen, got a feeling not all users agreed to that, particularly the older crowd who were mining before bch was even a thing.

-4

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

well... he actually announced it somewhere. maybe butcoin.com and was reposted here by someone... thought this was pretty uncontroversial. do you feel it would be controversial for roger to do that?

2

u/Zectro Mar 21 '19 edited Mar 21 '19

Not really. I don't really see using the hashpower people directed to his pool to mine BCH exclusively as renting hashpower but whatever. I thought there was speculation that the additional hashpower that his pool had around that time was rented hash, that I am skeptical of since it's more likely that was from Bitmain than anything else. Doesn't matter much to me either way though.

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19

i think the "rented" part refers to him directing the hashpower regardless of profitability and covering the losses. doesnt really matter though.

however, the real question is: what if sv had more hashpower than bcash?

2

u/Zectro Mar 21 '19

I mentioned before the split that under no circumstances would I want anything to do with BSV.

-12

u/okstib Mar 21 '19

Consider a portion of the block reward to go to BCH devs/lawyers etc

-2

u/sharkbaas Mar 21 '19

https://www.ccn.com/why-a-little-known-crypto-mining-firm-is-suing-bitcoin-cashs-biggest-backers

UnitedCorp is a mining pool that sued Roger Ver, Jihan Wu, Bitmain, Bitcoin.com, and Kraken exchange.

The bill is probably the result from that lawsuit. Stop spreading hate and start working on BCH.

Please first do some research before supporting a crypto influencer. There is not even a story attached to this picture.

-23

u/SYD4uo Mar 21 '19

you still think CSW is satoshi?

edit: could you pls also elaborate who you paid and against what threats made to whom?

11

u/markblundeberg Mar 21 '19

He definitely doesn't anymore: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OZ85CIDF6eM

-1

u/SYD4uo Mar 21 '19

Hi /u/markblundeberg, from what i've read in this sub you seem to be one of the more level headed guys and not as crazy as the majority here. Can you answer any of the questions above? Please be aware that i couldn't watch the linked video atm but afaik roger ver never says explicitly that he personally thinks craig wright is not satoshi, pls link to the timestamp if he does. thanks!

1

u/markblundeberg Mar 21 '19

I suspect you're right, I don't recall him explicitly saying it.

14

u/Big_Bubbler Mar 21 '19

No humans think CSW is Satoshi.

-5

u/HoneyNutsNakamoto Mar 21 '19

Roger, a sincere thank you for focusing so much of your time and money on defending against BSV attacks.

It will allow BTC, Bitcoin Core, to fucking crush your pathetic fork known as Bitcoin Cash. Good news is you can copy and paste again if needed.

Keep up the great work. I'm a longtime fan!