r/btc • u/unstoppable-cash • Mar 16 '19
Quote LN Commentary from a guy that knows a thing or 2 about Bitcoin (Gavin Andresen-LEAD developer after Satoshi left in 2010)
71
u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Mar 16 '19
/u/gavinandresen we miss you! <3
38
u/jessquit Mar 16 '19
/u/gavinandresen we miss you! <3
33
u/where-is-satoshi Mar 16 '19
/u/gavinandresen we miss you! <3
9
u/wisequote Mar 16 '19
We miss you.
5
u/BitttBurger Mar 16 '19
We miss
1
Mar 16 '19
We
0
Mar 16 '19
We miss you Gavin, we do. We miss you Gavin, we do. We miss you Gavin, we do... Ooooh Gavin we miss you!
1
u/toorik Mar 16 '19
We do! We do miss you, Gavin. When are you coming back?
1
u/alwaysAn0n Mar 17 '19
Oi Gavin! Help us finish this amazing thing that you helped nurture and get off the ground. We're so close now.
-1
u/SyriaownsGermany Redditor for less than 60 days Mar 17 '19
When are you coming back?
Probably never cause he ruined his reputation and thinks CSW is satoshi, lol.
If I was a gullible moron who got finessed like Gavin did, I would hide in shame just like Gavin is doing.
2
u/toorik Mar 17 '19
Wow. Putting yourself above Gavin Andresen... Must feel good to be one of the smartest, well articulated developers out there. Aren't we lucky to have you.
→ More replies (0)
38
u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Mar 16 '19
#2 really grinds my gears as a software developer. It's unfortunately a common attitude where " we'll figure that out later" is used to ignore the hard issues.
3
u/0xHUEHUE Mar 16 '19
Yeah but then you're at the risk of focusing on the wrong hard issue. It's definitely a balance, but I prefer to ship early when it's "good enough" and get a feedback loop going.
4
u/cryptocached Mar 16 '19
It's unfortunately a common attitude where "we'll figure that out later" is used to ignore the hard issues.
Something everyone seems happy to overlook when discussing Avalanche preconsensus, too.
7
u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Mar 16 '19
People are blinded by the great promises if they manage to fix it.
It's the same story with proof-of-stake yet still the nothing at stake problem is still unsolved.
6
u/CatatonicAdenosine Mar 16 '19
Good point. BCH should implement double spend relays to prevent all but the miner bribe double spend. There’s no reason why Avalanche preconsensus development needs to block other improvements.
3
2
u/SILENTSAM69 Mar 16 '19
Considering Avalanche is only being discussed, and not actually worked on, I don't think that is the case.
2
u/cryptocached Mar 17 '19
Hopefully the discussion starts with the hard stuff, then. I'd hate to see anyone waste their time getting a proof of concept up and running on mainnet before at least figuring out if their goals are achievable without totally fucking the existing system, right? Save that kind of shit for Lightning Network.
0
Mar 16 '19
[deleted]
10
u/cryptocached Mar 16 '19
It really is best to ignore UI and focus on the underlying tech.
Unfortunately UI/UX and security are often at odds. This is especially true of Lightning Network where the UX challenge associated with peer selection has lead to claims that is effectively arbitrary and has no bearing on security.
4
u/BitttBurger Mar 16 '19
a lot of projects had amazing UI but pretty shitty economics and consensus.
No. It’s not good to ignore the UI.
Ever.
You do both.
Your example which goes to the other absurd extreme doesn’t prove that ignoring UI is a smart choice.
2
u/UpDown Mar 16 '19
But you can’t really fix the protocol as quickly, and some times it’s just too contentious. You can have 1000 UIs but only one protocol
2
25
Mar 16 '19
Gavin hits the nail on the head in the last frame. While the overarching concept of the Lightning network might be fairly simple, it's actual implementation is extremely complex. The devil, as they say, is in the details. For software and systems development (including financial systems), complexity is the enemy.
5
u/masterD3v Mar 16 '19
Gavin had every right to be Bitcoin’s BDFL, yet he understood that Bitcoin’s nature is decentralized both in operation and development. He rejected that path while others (Blockstream) were seeking power and control.
Power, control and centralization fails because the people in those positions are flawed, and make mistakes (the LN).
Bitcoin Cash is the original Bitcoin Gavin was working on, and he has said that clearly in a previous message.
0
u/dfsoij Mar 16 '19
That was before BCH and BSV forked - has he posted anything about the fork since then? Would be curious to see any discussion from him. (I do recall that he said the checkpoints weren't a big deal, which I disagree with).
4
u/masterD3v Mar 16 '19
BSV has nothing to do with Bitcoin, BSV was a takeover attempt by nChain. Nobody uses BSV, nobody wants BSV.
0
u/dfsoij Mar 17 '19
I get that you think BSV is crap, but to say it has nothing to do with Bitcoin is a stretch... It's one of the Bitcoin forks! I use BSV, and I want BSV, along with others I know. Yours.org, the Satoshi doodles guy, and both of my top to favorite wallets decided to choose bsv over BCH (simply cash and handcash).
It's fine to say it's not used much (I agree it's not) but exaggerating so much seems a bit silly.
-5
u/typtyphus Mar 16 '19
0
8
u/pecuniology Mar 16 '19
For the sake of his next project, I hope that Gavin nominates a proper successor, before dropping the baton and walking away.
As /u/BitcoinXio says, we miss him, but... we shouldn't have to. The proximate cause of this entire BS/Core fiasco was a failure of management.
2
Mar 16 '19
this entire BS/Core fiasco was a failure of management
Wouldn't call Fascists a "management". They kill people, just doing that by censoring them online. So Cypherpunky.
4
u/pecuniology Mar 16 '19
I meant a failure on Gavin's part as a manager. He walked away with no succession plan. At the time, the apathetic and the anarcho-libertarian acted as if it all would sort itself out... because Murray Rothbard or somesuch.
It was like a scene from Star Trek with counterparts from the parallel universe where Spock has a beard and Kira wears a black catsuit. Gavin turned his back, and out came the long knives.
He knew who they were. He should have fired the lot and reformed the core team, making it clear that he planned to leave, so that the transition could have been smooth.
Anyway, it's all blood under the bridge now. Maybe he was getting death threats. Who knows?
6
u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 16 '19
Gavin walked away with no succession plan.
Gavin was forced out by Greg Maxwell and his sub-trolls. They literally took away his commit access. Gavin and Hearn tried to fork to XT when it was clear that Blockstream had taken over completely, but they couldn't get enough community support due to censorship and trolling.
3
u/pecuniology Mar 16 '19
By the time that Greg Maxwell pulled off his sleazy little coup, Gavin already had one foot out of the door.
Gavin should have fired Sr. Maxwell long before any of this came to a head.
3
u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 17 '19
Well back then the Core team was "decentralized", meaning quietly controlled by Blockstream, theymos, and Greg and his bullies... Gavin really had a tough run, that's why he won't publicly announce his re-entry into the space.
1
u/pecuniology Mar 17 '19
Ah, yup. All this is just analysis of the game, the day after it was played.
Elsewhere, I have described the bundle of cryptocurrency services as being like a set of fine china. Now, some plates and a few cups and a saucer are in a thrift shop, some other pieces are in a box in someone's attic, the sugar bowl is on someone's desk being used as a pencil holder, and the rest of the pieces are scatter here and there.
The pieces all exist, but the set will never be put back together, and the synergy is lost forever.
2
3
u/iwantfreebitcoin Mar 16 '19
Gavin stopped contributing to Core for almost a year before this. Having commit access without contributing is a security hole, and after backing CSW, many among the remainder of the Core team had reasonable suspicions that perhaps Gavin had been compromised in some way. At the very least, CSW provided a reminder of the fact that least privilege was not being followed, so they then followed it.
Gavin talked to Hearn about starting XT by July 2014.
4
u/juhannimata Mar 16 '19
I don't get it. I know this is a BCH sub, but why are you attacking other projects. Other subs are publishing lightning project updates and milestone goal reached posts, while we here continue to dig and analyse years old posts.
Lightning developed in directions, now foreseen, and a lot of research and progress has been done. I'd like to see the same for Bitcoin Cash.
4
u/BitttBurger Mar 16 '19
You’re right. You don’t get it. That’s painfully obvious from what you wrote.
2
0
u/gary_sadman Mar 16 '19
If LN fails it's no big deal, you can always try alternative layer 2 methods, or maybe achieve consensus to raise the block size. You don't realize BCH is not Bitcoin. Because Bitcoin can fork with consensus and make BCH irrelevant.
6
u/GeorgAnarchist Mar 16 '19
We tried to compromise for years, but they were backstabbing it. Good luck for you, but as long as the current people have access to bitcoin core guthub repo there will never be a blocksize increase.
1
u/gary_sadman Mar 16 '19
That's irrelevant, anyone can fork and attempt to achieve consensus. BCH is a failed attempt.
4
u/BitttBurger Mar 16 '19
It’s cute that you actually believe bitcoin isn’t controlled by handful of developers with commit access.
It’s also cute that you actually believe miners are going to jump ship to a non-profitable alternative just because of their ideology.
Jihan Wu proved to everyone that he cares more about his income than doing the right thing for BTC. So unfortunately reality doesn’t match that cheesy cliché anymore.
-2
4
u/BitttBurger Mar 16 '19
You’re kidding right? Start all over again after we wait 4 years for LN to finish?
Bitcoin was ready to go on day one. A completed product that just needed to be scaled as usage increased.
The entire problem here is that we’re waiting years with a crippled base layer and merchants are dropping Bitcoin in droves.
How are you guys so unaware of this stuff?
1
u/gary_sadman Mar 17 '19
Whatever needs to happen will happen, you can always fork and make an altcoin.
1
u/onedeadnazi Mar 17 '19
With all the projects likely to fail why do you keep focusing on this one repeatedly?
-6
u/BigJim05 Mar 16 '19
Gavin Andresen thought Craig Wright was Satoshi.
13
u/BTC_StKN Mar 16 '19
So did I for a bit.
CSW is a fraud and a douchebag.
Fraudsters take advantage of human nature's instinct to give someone the the benefit of the doubt when you first meet them.
8
u/jessquit Mar 16 '19
So did I, or at least, I entertained the possibility for a while that he could have been involved, until it was clearer to me that it was unlikely he had anything to do with it. Gavin was, after all, a victim of a rather elaborate set up if you recall. Making him out to be a moron is really unfair and it's also what's called "blaming the victim."
8
Mar 16 '19
is really unfair and it's also what's called "blaming the victim."
Right on spot. Crypto community (Fraudsters mostly) got that habbit of blaming their victims.
Some are victims themselfes.
-1
u/SyriaownsGermany Redditor for less than 60 days Mar 17 '19
Gavin was, after all, a victim of a rather elaborate set up if you recall
Gavin still think CSW is satoshi.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=11&v=pNZyRMG2CjA
In that video gavin says craig is satoshi "beyond a reasonable doubt"
Still, Andresen believes that Craig Wright is Satoshi Nakamoto citing Wright’s possession of the private key from the first bitcoin block as cryptographic proof. He added: It’s possible that I’m wrong [about Craig Wright], but I don’t think I am.
https://www.ccn.com/gavin-andersen-craig-wright-blog-mistake/
Making him out to be a moron is really unfair and it's also what's called "blaming the victim."
Hes only the victim of his own stupidity, he is a moron and he has never admitted he is wrong or got fooled.
0
Mar 17 '19
[deleted]
0
u/SyriaownsGermany Redditor for less than 60 days Mar 17 '19
Old video and article.
Find me a more current one where he recants it then. I'm not even trolling, gavin is certified gullible.
Gavin initially gives craig credibility here, https://www.ccn.com/breaking-bitcoin-creator-revealed-craig-wright and that is on 2/5/2016
The CNN article I posted was 04/05/2016. Since then gavin has said or done nothing about the situation he helped create. He knows his rep is killed and hes too ashamed to show face here anymore given how he was made to look like an idiot over CSW and big blocks
2
0
0
u/where-is-satoshi Mar 16 '19
So did I for way longer than I should have despite CSW being a clear douchebag. I think I was clinging to the notion that Satoshi might be Australian. Satoshi may yet be Australian, just not the obvious fraud, conman AND douchebag CSW.
-5
u/jakesonwfw Mar 16 '19
No such thing as a lead developer in Bitcoin. That is a centralized shitcoin thing. Bcash for example.
4
-1
0
u/paoloaga Mar 16 '19
Gavin come back! Nobody has ever filled the gap you left when they dismissed you!
8
u/sdlex34 Mar 16 '19
Soo when can we start saying openly that Bitcoin was co-opted by 'dark forces' to stagnate its development???