r/btc • u/unstoppable-cash • Mar 14 '19
WOW! Peter R. Rizun: "LN User walks into a bank, says "I need a loan..."
28
Mar 14 '19
Gold:)
30
u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 14 '19
It's a dad joke, it perfectly illustrates the most fundamental stupidity of LN.
With this latest torch fiasco (they can't send it due to lack of liquidity) you can already see that LN nodes have the ability to control the flow of funds.
10
u/void_magic Mar 15 '19
Core Solution: Just let the bank handle all your accounts so you don't have to worry about liquidity.
18
u/Febos Mar 14 '19
I dont get it. Why would anyone need a loan to receive paychek?
Is it paycheck something in lightning? To me paycheck is deposit from someone usually your boss to your bank account. But then that makes no sense. why would he need a loan for that?
79
u/007_008_009 Mar 14 '19
You need liquidity to receive anything on LN, so if you have nothing, you need a loan to open a channel and fund it
24
8
u/James-Russels Mar 14 '19
Haha I thought it was a joke about not being able to get the funds off lightning due to high fees, but this is even better.
-1
u/Febos Mar 14 '19
Yes that makes sense. This opening channel is like a transaction fee, cost of it receiver and sender share? Or fee is still there paid by sender?
36
u/500239 Mar 14 '19
what your talking about is a separate issue. As you can see there's several issues with LN.
11
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
When you open a channel initially, you cannot be paid. You are providing the funds, not the other party. Thus if someone wants to pay you, there are no funds on the other side of the channel to pay you.
You can fix this by spending money or having them open a channel directly to you. But this is a stupid problem to have in the first place- people don't think this way, they don't spend their money this way, and they don't want to jump through hoops just to use their own money. LN is designed for the #CultOfCore, not for real people to use.
1
u/dontlikecomputers Mar 14 '19
so it can work with a direct link, I was wondering how it first worked if each user was forced to spend first....
3
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
It can because the direct link starts out with funds on the correct side(that wants to send) and the correct capacity(Chosen by the sender who opens the channel).
The entire idea of channel balances causing issues when users attempt to spend their money is a big pain point. It's just not how people think about money.
0
Mar 15 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 15 '19
While observably and quantifiably , the LN's growth is exponential and people all over the world are actually using it as you write.
https://twitter.com/iwearahoodie/status/1101157253455859712
https://www.coindesk.com/its-getting-harder-to-send-bitcoins-lightning-torch-heres-why
https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/apavdq/i_can_pay_invoices_on_my_mainnet_lnd_node_but/
Also Lightning has 3.9k active addresses. Bitcoin has 630k, Ethereum has 295k. Congrats on finding or misleading 3.9k Core fanatics into trying it out, even though many of them are discovering and complaining that it isn't working?
Meanwhile the other 99.7% of the world is using things that work.
but THEY ACTUALLY ARE USING IT.
Apparently it is working so well that all major exchanges... Well.. Some major exchanges... Well... No major exchanges... Well, at least some people that aren't core fanatics... Ok, nevermind. Literally just Core Fanatics like bitrefill and accept it. There's no major businesses or exchanges that aren't core fanatics that give two shits about LN.
0
Mar 15 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 15 '19
I am making hundreds of LN payments in the background.
If you're going to lie, you might as well try to make it a convincing lie. I don't even make a hundred credit card payments per month, and I've probably made less than a hundred BTC transactions even though I've been in it way longer than you have.
Meanwhile, Bcash (both of them), stagnating and slipping further into obscurity.
Is that why it was up 3% today when nothing else was? The only thing that's slipping is Bitcoin's dominance. What is it down to now, almost under 50% again?
There's about 20 of you left.
Actually there are 1,537 unique users that have posted on this subreddit in just the last 7 days.
1
u/JonathanSilverblood Jonathan#100, Jack of all Trades Mar 15 '19
Even Bitpay, which is openly bcash oriented, processes virtually no payments for BCH.
Can you source this statement for me, please?
10
20
u/tcrypt Mar 14 '19
A channel has 2 capacities, one in each direction. There's an amount of coins I can send you, and an amount you can send me. Transactions on the channel are just shifting this balance around.
If I make $5000/mo and want to get paid to a LN channel, the other end of the channel needs to put $5000 into the channel so they can pay me. If I spend the entire $5000 through that same channel over the course of the month then the next month they can send it back. Otherwise they need more capacity on their end at the start.
0
Mar 14 '19
[deleted]
10
u/tcrypt Mar 14 '19
To the best of knowledge there is not a way to add capacity to a channel, you must close it and open a new channel.
3
0
Mar 14 '19
[deleted]
1
u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Mar 15 '19
My recollection is that there's a way to (or a proposal for a way to) "top up" channels using only a single on-chain tx. So it's a little better than the two-tx scenario where you close a channel and then open a new one.
2
u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Mar 15 '19
Here's the real problem:
if your employer opens a LN channel with you to pay your wages, once that money is paid it will still be locked up in that channel with your employer. Meaning that you'll only be able to spend that money by either (a) sending it to your employer (easy, but probably not terribly useful as you probably don't have much cause to pay your employer) OR (b) by routing payments through your employer to all the different people you actually buy goods and services from. But wait, how good is your employer's connectivity and outbound liquidity? Your employer is in the business of selling widgets, not operating a LN banking hub. And if your employer is opening channels with all of his employees, he's going to need to tie up a LOT of capital on the other side to provide meaningful routing to allow all that money he's paying out to flow back through him and to the wider LN network.
6
u/paoloaga Mar 14 '19
If you want to receive any value on the LN channel, you have to fund that channel with at least the same value as a warranty, so that if anything should go wrong, any party can close the channel.
6
0
u/RudiMcflanagan Mar 14 '19
Can you explain exactly how and why you need money to be able to receive payments via a LN channel?
8
u/BriefCoat Redditor for less than 6 months Mar 14 '19
When you open a channel it often has 100% of the funds owned by you. In order for you to receive money you need a channel where you don't have 100% of the funds. The only way to open such a channel is to convince someone else to open such a channel with you. You can't do it without using someone else's money
2
u/RudiMcflanagan Mar 15 '19
Yes but that doesn't require that you actually spend any of your own (or borrowed) money as suggested by this "I need to take out a loan to be able to receive my earned wages" quip.
Is there actually any real reason why your employer couldn't open a LN channel to pay you wages without requiring you to control any BTC of your own beforehand? I'm not aware of any such reason. If not, Rizun should fuck off with this disinformation.
8
u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Mar 15 '19 edited Mar 15 '19
Is there actually any real reason why your employer couldn't open a LN channel to pay you wages without requiring you to control any BTC of your own beforehand?
Yes, if your employer opens a LN channel with you to pay your wages, once that money is paid it will still be locked up in that channel with your employer. Meaning that you'll only be able to spend that money by either (a) sending it to your employer (easy, but probably not terribly useful as you probably don't have much cause to pay your employer) OR (b) by routing payments through your employer to all the different people you actually buy goods and services from. But wait, how good is your employer's connectivity and outbound liquidity? Your employer is in the business of selling widgets, not operating a LN banking hub. And if your employer is opening channels with all of his employees, he's going to need to tie up a LOT of capital on the other side to provide meaningful routing to allow all that money he's paying out to flow back through him and to the wider LN network.
EDIT: changed "inbound" to "outbound"
1
u/RudiMcflanagan Mar 17 '19
You nailed it. This is exactly correct and describes the problems with the lightning network. Best description and understanding I've seen so far.
The thing is, using the lighting network requires all users to solve a very complex, time-varying routing problem for every transaction. So all these other descriptions about how the lightning network works where everyone connects to a bunch of different other LN users, are incorrect. The real way the lightning network works, is that everyone opens a channel with one of a small group of very large, well connected, entities, and these entities do all the routing and coordinate the channel flows among themselves. Maybe some large Fortune 100 companies would be able to act as such entities themselves, but would probably would choose not to, as it would require a lot of money and resources and it would be cheaper and easier for them to just use one of the third-party services. A typical user would have only one channel that they receive and all their money on and make all their outbound payments on and the hub on the other end would do all the routing, which would probably be impossible for them to do anyway because they would have to be able to predict cash flow distributions across millions of members over long periods of time to a degree of accuracy necessary to initialize all the channel capacities. And even if by some miracle they were able to do this, they would still just be recreating the banking system we already have.
1
u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Mar 17 '19 edited Mar 17 '19
Yes, exactly. If the LN can work at all at scale (something I'm not at all convinced of), it's as a hugely-centralized network with a small number of massively-connected, massively-capitalized banking hubs.
https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/avewgl/why_the_lightning_network_is_not_a_scaling/
Also specifically re: the "loan" language, see this comment which I think provides some additional support for why that language is accurate: https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/b118hw/peter_r_rizun_ln_user_walks_into_a_bank_says_i/eikimmx/?context=3
4
u/BriefCoat Redditor for less than 6 months Mar 15 '19
Yes but that doesn't require that you actually spend any of your own (or borrowed) money as suggested by this "I need to take out a loan to be able to receive my earned wages" quip.
It doesnt matter, it is still a loan. I need you to lock up your money for my benefit
Is there actually any real reason why your employer couldn't open a LN channel to pay you wages without requiring you to control any BTC of your own beforehand?
This is a possible solution, but the employer might have all of his funds already locked up in a channel. Close his channel to pay you is inconvenient and possible expensive
I'm not aware of any such reason. If not, Rizun should fuck off with this disinformation.
These are valid concerns but feel free to stick your head back in the sand
2
u/jessquit Mar 15 '19
Is there actually any real reason why your employer couldn't open a LN channel to pay you wages without requiring you to control any BTC of your own beforehand?
A technical reason? No. It's possible. But there is a very powerful disincentive to doing so. So anyone smart enough to be your employer isn't going to do it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/av1a9e/lightning_factoid_5_in_channel_a_doesnt_have_the/
1
u/007_008_009 Mar 15 '19
Yes but that doesn't require that you actually spend any of your own (or borrowed) money
It does actually, just because you must be on LN, so you need to spend money for opening a channel (on chain TX + fee)
1
u/RudiMcflanagan Mar 17 '19
You don't need to spend or lock up any BTC receive money on the LN, only to have outbound capacity.
1
u/007_008_009 Mar 18 '19
do you mean it's possible to open a channel with zero funds? 0 BTC on chain transaction with 0 fee?
3
u/rev0lute Mar 14 '19
Something something liquidity something something nodes using each others funds for exchanges something something not entirely your funds anymore..
-2
14
u/BTC_StKN Mar 14 '19
Paying the bank to open a bank account.
Even worse than Legacy Banking.
2
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
As someone- Vinny Lingham maybe? Once said- a customer acquisition cost of $100 is unheardof.
1
u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Mar 15 '19
To be fair, you're only likely to need to pay the hub to open the account if they put up non-trivial funds on their side to provide initial inbound liquidity for you. If you fund all or most of the channel to allow yourself to make payments, that probably won't cost anything upfront (although you'll presumably still pay a per-transaction routing fee to the hub). But I'd also note the issue of borrowing liquidity (and needing to pay for it) isn't solely an issue with respect to the channel's initial funding. Let's imagine I initially fund my channel with a million dollars, but then I spend my balance way down to almost nothing and am not particularly active in receiving payments to rebalance that channel (which would at least generate some routing income for my channel partner). In that scenario, that huge pot of money that's now in the hub's favor starts to look very attractive to reharvest by closing the channel so that they can put those funds to more productive use elsewhere. And that's exactly what they're likely to do unless I'm paying them to keep it open!
3
u/Thann Mar 14 '19
All crypto "escrow" features require collateral, or else you could just walk away and the counterparty would have locked their funds for nothing
0
Mar 14 '19
[deleted]
14
u/Uejji Mar 14 '19
It's not just the transaction fee. The bank has to invest a sum of money into your channel that can only be used to route money to you through the bank. That is money that cannot be used for anything else unless the channel is closed. That is the money that is chiefly being loaned here.
4
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19 edited Mar 14 '19
Don't forget that 1% of each lightning channel is an unusable reserve, required to ensure attackers can't default with no risks. So 1.0 real BTC = 0.99 LNbtc
Edit: 1%, not 10%.
2
u/jessquit Mar 14 '19
Source on that?
3
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
I was mistaken, it is actually 1% that is suggested, but that seems too low to me (An attacker could abuse that in an attempt to find clients that aren't able to recover properly; The attacker only risks 1% of their funds).
Look for
channel_reserve_satoshishere: https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lightning-rfc/blob/master/02-peer-protocol.md1
u/RudiMcflanagan Mar 14 '19
If that's how bitcoin worked banks would defeat its purpose by only setting with coins the control and everyone else coins become worthless .
2
Mar 15 '19
They're way ahead of you there.
https://www.coindesk.com/jpmorgan-moving-its-in-house-crypto-to-real-world-trials-report
1
u/albinopotato Mar 14 '19
BTC is purposefully designed so tx fees hit hundreds of dollars or more...
Yes, in aggregate. What we have here is a debate and disagreement as to how that large aggregate value is obtained. Via a few large fee paying TXs, or thousands of low fee paying txs.
2
u/SpiritofJames Mar 14 '19
Thousands? More like tens or hundreds of thousands -- perhaps even millions in the long run -- of near-0 fee transactions.
1
0
Mar 14 '19
[deleted]
1
u/albinopotato Mar 14 '19
Which is why btc refuses to increase block size.
Well, they did change the term "blocksize" to "blockweight" and did effectively increase the blockweight, although poorly IMO.
Don't worry, we're on the same page. I just refuse to accept that Core has permanently fucked up Bitcoin's original P2P vision.
1
u/jessquit Mar 14 '19
Permanent is maybe a stretch but it's hamstrung that's for sure. I think BTC is headed for another serious split.
2
2
4
Mar 14 '19
Seriously, if this were a negligible factor, I would be able to just go to a hub and lock up their entire liquidity for eternity.
Peter is making an analogy which is being misinterpreted by some. You are indeed renting liquidity. Loans that people can run away with may have further associated costs, so there is a difference. Whether this is also a kind of loan is a useless semantic debate.
It is also interesting that the opportunity cost of hodling coins on LN, for leaf nodes, is determined by the channel size rather than the balance that belongs to you.
4
u/Etovia Mar 14 '19
This is nice when FUDers quickly show their absolute lack of understanding (or rather malicious attempts to lie about how competing, 30 times more popular, product works).
With LN you can send to someone who is not yet in LN - by funding the channel for both Alice and Bob.
So channel is between Alice and Bob's keys, with Alice and Bob's closing address, but only Alice is funding it, and while opening it she pushes e.g. all the money in it to Bob's side.
Really such obvious lies are why no one respects bcashers.
13
u/wcmbk Mar 14 '19
I've been using BTC since 2010. This is really some absurdly complex technobabble - no general user is ever going to go through that bullshit when easier options already exist.
If crypto is ever going to go mainstream it needs to have fewer barriers to entry than traditional banking, not more.
2
u/bitmegalomaniac Mar 14 '19
This is really some absurdly complex technobabble - no general user is ever going to go through that bullshit when easier options already exist.
This is exactly what people have been saying about cryptocurrency from day dot.
I will say to you what I say to them, just because you don't understand something it does not mean it does not work.
5
u/wcmbk Mar 14 '19
I'm not denying that it works. I'm saying that my mum will never use it. My local store will never open up a channel with me. My mates will never 'quickly set up a route' to pay me back for a beer.
It's functional - but it doesn't actually help anyone in the vast majority of use cases, therefore it doesn't help me.
1
u/bitmegalomaniac Mar 14 '19
I'm saying that my mum will never use it. My local store will never open up a channel with me. My mates will never 'quickly set up a route' to pay me back for a beer.
Exactly what those people say about cryptocurrencies.
I see no difference between you and those old time naysayers.
4
u/wcmbk Mar 14 '19
Here's the difference: I'll advocate for greater simplicity and accessibility, not make excuses for overly complicated processes that do nothing to improve adoption.
Remember when physical stores were starting to accept bitcoin? What happened to that?
2
u/bitmegalomaniac Mar 14 '19
Here's the difference: I'll advocate for greater simplicity and accessibility, not make excuses for overly complicated processes that do nothing to improve adoption.
I don't get why you think the user experience would be any different:-
Get wallet
Receive funds
Use funds
Isn't that the same experience?
1
u/AgregiouslyTall Mar 19 '19
Those bullets? Yeah that’s basically how just about every major crypto works sans using the LN, so no it’s not the same experience. LN is a completely different experience from what you described.
Now if those bullets were really the user experience of LN you wouldn’t hear the gripes about setting up channels, locking funds, etc.
And you can sit on your high horse acting like the layman should understand this all but that’s not the case. Think about the average person, now remember that half the people out there are even stupider than them. For something to be adopted at scale it has to draw in the lowest common denominator (no-coin normies)
0
u/Etovia Mar 15 '19
This is really some absurdly complex technobabble - no general user is ever going to go through that bullshit when easier options already exist.
Same about Internet right? We have LAN and Ethernet that works just fine, no one will use this complex DNS queries, root DNS servers, TCP window scaling, BGP protocols etc.
And in reality, I just click bar.com in browser and it works.
I just click in LN wallet send or recevied and it will just work. Now it almost works, just need to first click to open channel.
3
u/wcmbk Mar 15 '19
Except much of what you just mentioned takes place through centralised systems.
The whole point of crypto is that it’s peer to peer and never needs to go through a system that isn’t controlled by users.
0
u/Etovia Mar 15 '19
LN is far more peer to peer then layer-1, in the important meaning that you do not need permission from miner for most operations.
Miners are elite group, mining is more or less centralized, but what we can surly agree on, is that you can not just take some silly 10,000$ and become a miner that mines own block even if other miners want to censor that block (because is have a transaction they do not like to see).
In LN how ever, I can for 10,000$ I can have a large node (even for 1000$ or 300$ I can do just fine), and there I need ANY peers (who also can be just some random people) to connect me.
Then in LN I can do millions of transactions without asking a miner.
Sure a miner can try to block channel open on close still, though that I need just sometimes.
If we imagine 95% of miners hate my shop, they will delay transactions for like 20 blocks at random. Each transaction.
With LN, I will do transactions instantly confirmed (in secure way, not like lol-0-conf), and only I will have to deal with miners delaying me for a day two times, when opening the channel, and months or years later once when closing it).
That gives users much higher independence and decentralization.
1
-1
u/alsomahler Mar 14 '19
It's a joke base on misinformation. Others can create channels to you based on the expectation of payment and because that creates new opportunities for them to route money.
https://mobile.twitter.com/lnbig_com/status/1105801755265241094
11
u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Mar 14 '19
Just like... a loan?
You lock up your balance in the hope of getting returns.
3
u/bitmegalomaniac Mar 14 '19
Just like... a loan?
Why would you think someone paying you your paycheck is getting a loan?
They owe you the money, if they open a channel to you with the money in it... I really don't get your reasoning, why do 6yyou thing that is a loan?
1
u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Mar 15 '19 edited Mar 15 '19
Your employer opening a channel with you to pay you is likely not a viable solution. As I wrote previously:
If your employer opens a LN channel with you to pay your wages, once that money is paid it will still be locked up in that channel with your employer. Meaning that you'll only be able to spend that money by either (a) sending it to your employer (easy, but probably not terribly useful as you probably don't have much cause to pay your employer) OR (b) by routing payments through your employer to all the different people you actually buy goods and services from. But wait, how good is your employer's connectivity and outbound liquidity? Your employer is in the business of selling widgets, not operating a LN banking hub. And if your employer is opening channels with all of his employees, he's going to need to tie up a LOT of capital on the other side to provide meaningful routing to allow all that money he's paying out to flow back through him and to the wider LN network.
why do 6yyou thing that is a loan?
Consider the following argument:
When you deposit funds into a LN channel you are essentially loaning those funds to an entity that will exercise shared control over them. And as with any loan, there is a risk of default. It’s just that, in the case of the LN, there are these built-in remedy mechanisms that LN enthusiasts think will be sufficient to (mostly) deter default, and adequately compensate the innocent party in the (hopefully) rare case where one actually occurs. I think a channel partner becoming non-cooperative can be pretty clearly viewed as a default. After all, if you knew ahead of time that your channel partner were going to stop cooperating (at least early in the channel’s lifetime before you’ve accrued much benefit from it), you never would have opened it. The remedy for this situation is your ability to do a unilateral channel close. And that seems pretty good, but note that it doesn’t make you completely whole. You get your money back, but you’re not compensated for having had your funds tied up for some length of time, or for the fact that you wasted an on-chain tx fee on opening the channel (and will now incur additional tx fees to close the channel and establish a new one) -- and as Peter notes, that on-chain tx fee may be significant in comparison to (or even greater than!) your remaining channel balance. Another case of default occurs when your channel partner attempts to steal from you by publishing an old channel state in which you have a lower balance. Here the built-in remedy is your ability to publish a penalty transaction claiming all of the funds in the channel. That sounds like it should be a more-than-adequate remedy for the default, and actually provide a windfall to the innocent party. But that’s not necessarily the case. If the channel is unbalanced such that the amount forfeited by the would-be fraudster is small, the innocent party might not consider it adequate compensation for the expense of now having to open a new channel with a (hopefully more honest) party. And of course, if the dishonest channel partner’s attempt at theft actually succeeds (perhaps because a period of extreme on-chain congestion prevents you from getting your penalty transaction confirmed in time), then you obviously won’t have been adequately compensated for the default.
Also, see this tweet which highlights a real-life example of a service that charges you, what is in effect interest, to open a channel with their hub. Not surprisingly the fee is larger the more in-bound liquidity you borrow. https://twitter.com/PeterRizun/status/1106281572007727104
I think it's clear that the market for channel liquidity will become more developed and more obvious if and when the LN ever develops into something more than a toy for hobbyists. Right now, people playing with the network might be happy to put small amounts into channels with random partners without regard to how well connected those channel partners are, or how much they're funding their channels with. For now, when both sides fund a channel the implicit borrowing of liquidity that occurs is being done on what is effectively a barter basis. "I get some value from the funds you put up, and you get some value from the funds I put up." But that will change if LN becomes more than a toy. Note that there's an asymmetry in terms of the value two channel partners receive from the tied-up funds.
The value to me of funds I put up (or hold in my balance) as a typical end user comes from the fact that it enables me to make my own payments. The value to me of the funds my hub partner puts up (or holds in his balance) is that they enable me to receive payments. The primary value of both sets of funds to my hub partner is that they enable the hub to earn routing income from the payments they enable me to make and receive. I suppose there's also some benefit to the hub in the form of increased network effect. My being able to send and receive payments through that particular hub may make it more attractive for others to connect to that hub so they can send/receive payments to/from me.
I also think it's worth pointing out that cost of borrowing liquidity isn't just an issue with respect to the channel's initial funding. Let's imagine I initially fund my channel with a million dollars, but then spend my balance way down to almost nothing and am not particularly active in receiving payments to rebalance that channel (thereby generating routing income for my hub partner). In that scenario, that huge pot of money in the hub's favor starts to look very attractive to reharvest by closing the channel so that they can put those funds to more productive use elsewhere. And that's exactly what they're likely to do unless I pay them to keep it open!
1
u/bitmegalomaniac Mar 15 '19
Your employer opening a channel with you to pay you is likely not a viable solution.
It is.
it will still be locked up in that channel with your employer.
Close your channel if that is a problem for you. But if you wanted it on chain you should have chose that to start with instead of a LN channel.
Consider the following argument:
Your argument is flat out bullshit. No matter how you twist the meaning of words, your paycheck is not your employer loaning you money. Step back, take a deep breath and come back to reality.
1
u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Mar 15 '19
It is.
That's not an argument. That's contradiction.
Close your channel if that is a problem for you.
Sure, but in that case you've obtained ZERO benefit from the use of the LN.
But if you wanted it on chain you should have chose that to start with instead of a LN channel.
You don't want it on chain. Presumably you'd like those funds in a LN channel, but in a usable form which a channel connection with your employer is unlikely to provide for the reasons previously outlined.
our argument is flat out bullshit.
Once again, that's not an argument.
Step back, take a deep breath and come back to reality.
Step back, take a deep breath and attempt to actually address my arguments.
1
u/bitmegalomaniac Mar 15 '19
That's not an argument. That's contradiction.
Your 'argument' is that someone might not want to do that because of reasons.
However, someone may wish to do it because of reasons.
Just because you have reasons, it does not override their reasons. It is a valid option, despite your reasons.
Therefore, it is. Better?
Sure, but in that case you've obtained ZERO benefit from the use of the LN.
Again, if you don't want the benefit, don't do it like that.
You don't want it on chain. Presumably you'd like those funds in a LN channel
Then use it.
Once again, that's not an argument.
If you read past the first sentence it is.
actually address my arguments.
I did, you did not like it. I have slightly expanded now, do you like it now?
1
u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Mar 15 '19
Your 'argument' is that someone might not want to do that because of reasons.
However, someone may wish to do it because of reasons.
My argument is that you're very likely not to want to do that for the very good reason that it will provide no benefit.
Again, if you don't want the benefit, don't do it like that.
Again, my point is that there's likely to BE no benefit.
Then use it.
You omitted a key portion of my sentence with your quote. You'd like those funds in a LN channel, but in a usable form which a channel connection with your employer is unlikely to provide for the reasons previously outlined.
I have slightly expanded now, do you like it now?
I do not.
1
u/bitmegalomaniac Mar 15 '19
My argument is that you're very likely not to want to do that
My argument is that you can. Start arguing against my argument and tell me why you can't, not about your feelings about the subject.
Again, my point is that there's likely to BE no benefit.
Again, just because you don't think there is a benefit, it does not mean that others don't see LN beneficial.
You omitted a key portion of my sentence with your quote.
I don't care about your feelings, that is why. They are not a valid argument to me.
I do not.
Here is again:-
No matter how you twist the meaning of words, your paycheck is not your employer loaning you money.
1
u/Capt_Roger_Murdock Mar 16 '19 edited Mar 16 '19
My argument is that you can.
But I don't think I've ever disputed that. Obviously the employer could open a channel with his employee for the exact amount of the paycheck and assign the initial channel balance entirely to the employee.
Again, just because you don't think there is a benefit, , it does not mean that others don't see LN beneficial.
My point is not that the LN is not beneficial (although as an aside, I don't believe that it will be very useful given the severity and intractability of many of its issues). My point is that a LN channel connection with a poorly-capitalized and poorly-connected channel partner is not beneficial. Again, your employer is unlikely to have the connectivity and outbound liquidity needed to allow his entire payroll to flow back out through him and to the wider LN network. (Although it’s possible. Maybe you work for a LN bank.)
I don't care about your feelings, that is why.
Oh, you don't need to worry about my feelings. I was just pointing out that when you quoted only the first part of my sentence, you omitted pretty essential context.
your paycheck is not your employer loaning you money.
Well, not exactly. The loan is better characterized as being to the channel entity whose members (you and your employer) exercise shared control over the funds (e.g., to move the funds immediately via a channel close or updated channel state, both parties must authorize the transfer). Your employer initializing the channel with all of the funds being in your balance means that you are assigned as the beneficial owner of the loan.
3
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
So we need an on chain transaction to solve the problem of being unable to utilize the off-chain system?
You don't say...
2
u/alsomahler Mar 14 '19
Obviously you need to receive a transaction in order to receive the bitcoins. If that transaction is a new Lightning channel, then you can immediate use that to spend the money everywhere where they accept LN transactions.
4
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
then you can immediate use that to spend the money everywhere where they accept LN transactions.
If and only if the person who opened the channel with you has enough liquidity available going elsewhere to actually make use of it. And if you do that, now their channel with you is probably useless unless you, too, have liquidity going somewhere they want.
Obviously you need to receive a transaction in order to receive the bitcoins.
The whole point of lightning is that you aren't supposed to need it. Newbies are being mislead into thinking this is magic; It isn't, it has a whole shitload of hoops they have to jump through and be aware of in order to simply use the damn thing.
2
0
1
-1
u/jackomah Mar 14 '19
I like to think I'm not on either side of the btc or bch fence and i lurk alot in both subs - but isn't this a little disingenuous. LN is at an early stage of beta and is being worked on, with issues being addressed and developed - just in a different direction than bch agrees with.
This comment reminds me of when the inventor of the ethernet standard said something along the lines of the 'internet couldn't possibly scale and would go spectacularly supernova and in 1996 collapse'. I have a feeling this comment might age just as well as that if they get it right.
4
u/phillipsjk Mar 14 '19
Payment channels are designed for reoccurring payments, small enough that both sides don't mind locking funds into a payment channel for a time.
Standard payments should really be done on-chain.
6
u/unstoppable-cash Mar 14 '19
Standard payments should really be done on-chain.
And who is going to do that when on-chain fees are $50... $100... $1,000 as many CORE/Blockstream people say is the goal/marker for "success"?
But yes, general idea of pmt channel may have some use cases, but NOT to the exclusion/crippling of the base-layer/on-chain tx's!
6
Mar 14 '19
If LN was implemented on BCH for this purpose I dont think anyone would bat an eye. There could be a narrow use case for such a thing as a high-frequency sidechain. This to me is more what the LN whitepaper writers had in mind (one of which, Joseph Poon, built a similar thing on Ethereum called Plasma)
It is the part where BTC's base layer was deliberately crippled to drive most traffic off chain aside a few big LN hubs who have the money to pay the extremely expensive settlement fees that RBF and SegWit create. BTC is being bastardized to re-create centralized banking for the very middlemen Bitcoin was originally built to destroy.
2
u/bill_mcgonigle Mar 14 '19
How do we get 4 billion people on LN at 14TPS?
2
18
u/jessquit Mar 14 '19
This comment reminds me of when the inventor of the ethernet standard said something along the lines of the 'internet couldn't possibly scale and would go spectacularly supernova and in 1996 collapse'. I have a feeling this comment might age just as well as that if they get it right.
This is just loaded with juicy, dripping irony, although I'm quite sure you don't see it.
"that can't possibly scale" is how we got Lightning foisted on Bitcoin to begin with. Bitcoin Core / rbitcoin is the camp who thinks blockchain "can't possibly scale". The whole reason rbtc, and BCH, exist, is because we're the ones that thought blockchain scaling was possible, and we were told "that can't possibly scale."
7
Mar 14 '19
Its always circular logic with these idiots.
'LN is amazing! Massive growth! Adoption! Totally ready I use it all the time'
'LN is alpha, its going to have some issues, just wait it will get better'
Which one is it? Goalposts move faster than transactions do for BTC these days
1
u/iwantfreebitcoin Mar 14 '19
I disagree with your perspective, but upvoted this because I think this is a pretty clever line:
Goalposts move faster than transactions do for BTC these days
6
u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 14 '19
we were told "that can't possibly scale."
Their only retort is, "yeah but nobody is using Bcash". Which is not a refutation.
6
u/bloody-chiclitz Mar 14 '19
A common retort floating around on Twitter from the Core shills is that if BCH had the same volume as BTC, it would be slow with high fees. They either don't get it, or have just bought one some other LN / NO2X shill told them without thinking critically. BCH can handle a volume larger than BTC and still have no mem-pool backlog and tx fees would still be very low.
1
Mar 15 '19
err.. its still nothing but a claim that bcash can handle the amount of tx you say it will, and for low fees.
3
u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 15 '19
Well the blocks can be 16x the size of BTC's, as proven by multiple stress tests. Making the capacity roughly 8x that of BTC. But I guess that's an inconvenient fact for you Core-mongers.
1
Mar 15 '19 edited Mar 15 '19
Well the blocks can be 16x the size of BTC's, as proven by multiple stress tests
the test only did this for a pretty short time. being able to handle tx sent with the lowest fee possible does not equl beibg able to handle that amount of tx sent by real users calculating real fees. keep a test running 27/7/365 and get back to me.
But I guess that's an inconvenient fact for you Core-mongers.
lol you wish. better put your head in the sand and yell "muh stress test". it might deafen my voice pointing out the inconvenient fact that the test didnt show anything else than the network doesnt completely break in a 24h timeframe
1
u/horsebadlydrawn Mar 15 '19
the network doesnt completely break in a 24h timeframe
as opposed to the BTC network which has been proven to completely break for 2 weeks when the mempool gets over 200MB, which represents 1/10 of the transactions the THREE BCH stress tests processed.
1
u/bloody-chiclitz Mar 23 '19
Not trying to revive an old argument here, but I'm truly curious: do you not agree that BTC is more limited in on-chain capacity than BCH, considering BTC has only a 1 MB block-size data limit? Even with Seg-wit it's not much higher than 1 MB, so would you not agree that it makes BTC more susceptible to mempool backlogs and thus much higher tx in periods of higher volume?
1
Mar 23 '19 edited Mar 23 '19
would you not agree that it makes BTC more susceptible to mempool backlogs
sure but the discussion is about the bcash stress test. there is no evidence that the network can handle that amount of tx continually and definately not at that fee level.
tell me this: given that eth has pretty high tx fees also, why would bcash not? eth does 500,000 tx per day (lets say 2.5 mb?) at 0.1$. why would bcash do better? i know eth tx are harder to process but use whatever factor you want. do you think fees stay the same? scale linearly? exponentially?
1
2
u/jackomah Mar 14 '19
I totally see your point and can also relate to the bch side on this, I think personally the solution is both layer 1 scaling AND layer 2 solutions. But maybe that's my background in networking and watching internet scaling over the last 20 years in a professional capacity.
Are you of the opinion the solution is layer 1 only and are shut to everything else? LN, or a similar layer 2 is wrong no matter what?
2
4
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
This isn't a fixable problem. If opposing channel liquidity becomes easily accessible, an attacker can simply lock up the available liquidity until the providers are forced to start charging or make it hard to get.
LN has many problems. Some of them are fixable. But many of them are fundamental to the design of the system. Fundamentally lightning isn't designed for users, it's designed for core fanatics.
1
u/CONTROLurKEYS Mar 14 '19
Well actually what would likely happen is the company would directly open channels with their employees and pay them incrementally like hourly or daily. That is the point of LN small repeatable cheap payments. If I'm directly connected to the company there is no inbound balancing problem. If the company depletes their end of the channel they can close the channel and reopen in another single onchain tx. The company can close the channel as part of the termination process as well. If the company insists on paying every 2 weeks well then they pay all employees in a couple batched transactions for one low fee on layer 1. This isn't that complicated and I question the intellectual integrity of op.
5
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
Well actually what would likely happen is the company would directly open channels with their employees and pay them incrementally like hourly or daily.
Dude you live in a fantasy world. Are you that disconnected from reality?
Businesses are not going to restructure their payroll processes. Not in the next decade. And not for some shitty product.
Why the hell are core fanatics so confused about how the world works? PRODUCTS obey USERS demands. USERS DO NOT OBEY PRODUCT DEMANDS. EVER. They simply go fucking use something else.
If the company insists on paying every 2 weeks well then they pay all employees in a couple batched transactions for one low fee on layer 1.
"low fee" rofl. December 2017 says hi! Also you might want to have a conversation with the numerous core developers who have all stated that >$100 or even >$1000 fees are either likely or are a goal.
Batching has done basically nothing for transaction throughput. Go look at txout per tx and txin per tx graphs if you don't believe me.
This isn't that complicated and I question the intellectual integrity of op.
Lol, you have no intellectual integrity.
1
u/CONTROLurKEYS Mar 14 '19
Dude you live in a fantasy world. Are you that disconnected from reality?
Businesses are not going to restructure their payroll processes. Not in the next decade. And not for some shitty product.
Why the hell are core fanatics so confused about how the world works? PRODUCTS obey USERS demands. USERS DO NOT OBEY PRODUCT DEMANDS. EVER. They simply go fucking use something else.
you do know that Peter R. Rizun your crypto godking started with this assumption in the OP? Why don't you ask him this question? Its literally the entire premise of this thread, getting paid by a company on LN. If we are assuming they are already doing this they would do it the right way (direct channels) and not the retard way.(Whatever Rizun said)
"low fee" rofl. December 2017 says hi! Also you might want to have a conversation with the numerous core developers who have all stated that >$100 or even >$1000 fees are either likely or are a goal.Batching has done basically nothing for transaction throughput. Go look at txout vs txin ratio graphs if you don't believe me.
You do know that pay roll is not free no matter what you use right? ADP gets paid hundreds of millions or billions for this service. I think A company paying $100 fee is not a big deal.
https://twitter.com/MITBitcoinClub/status/1104463925087748097 says your wrong about batching. Maybe you should goto MIT and debate them?
4
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
If we are assuming they are already doing this they would do it the right way (direct channels) and not the retard way.
No, that's fantasyland talking again. Payroll has an established process for more than 50 years. People are not going to walk around with their dicks poking out just because Core says that's what they should do, and they're not going to restructure their entire payroll process just because Core can't figure out what it is they want.
There's no point in talking about hypotheticals that cannot possibly happen. Businesses won't adopt crypto unless crypto fits within their existing structure. Full stop. After 50 years of using crypto, some businesses in some situations might use it the way you're imagining. But we'll never get there because they're never going to adopt something that doesn't serve their needs.
You do know that pay roll is not free no matter what you use right? ADP gets paid hundreds of millions or billions for this service. I think A company paying $100 fee is not a big deal.
Ah, yes, the company won't mind paying a few hundred dollars to run payroll, even though they weren't paying that before. But wait, just one problem! Now the company is creating 20,000 new outputs every two weeks for their employees, all of whom need to actually spend those outputs on-chain (And CAN'T batch them, they only have their own outputs!) to pay bills. At a $100 fee. It's ok, since you don't live in the real world, you don't have to worry about anything else, you can handwave their objections away!
https://twitter.com/MITBitcoinClub/status/1104463925087748097 says your wrong about batching. Maybe you should goto MIT and debate them?
Ah yes, the same MIT that employs the lead Core developer. Again, I can't help it if Core fanatics don't live in the real world. In the real world, batching ain't done shit: https://i.imgur.com/i5SeZID.png. The real world also doesn't care about debates at MIT, it cares about real world results.
0
u/CONTROLurKEYS Mar 14 '19
No, that's fantasyland talking again. Payroll has an established process for more than 50 years.
Then what the fuck is your boy Rizun going on about? He literally started this conversation. Why is everyone frothing at the mouth in this thread if its a pointless and stupid hypothetical? Why hasn't anyone said, Hey rizun this is a pointless and stupid hypothetical instead of slobbering on his knob through the thread? oh wait, thats the entire point, so you can circlejerk all over each other. SPLOOSH! gg /r/btc
<snip> MIT shit talking <snip>
cringe
3
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
Then what the fuck is your boy Rizun going on about? He literally started this conversation.
By talking about things that Core pretends they are going to actually be able to do.
Why is everyone frothing at the mouth in this thread if its a pointless and stupid hypothetical?
Because it is hilarious and true.
Why hasn't anyone said, Hey rizun this is a pointless and stupid hypothetical instead of slobbering on his knob through the thread?
Because Core supporters like yourself have not realized how unbelievably shitty the user experience on Lightning is going to end up being. And anyone who says anything even remotely negative on any medium where a Core fanatic has "moderation" power ends up being banned and having their content deleted.
Don't worry though, users who your boy Theymos has mislead for years are eventually going to realize how ridiculous this all is.
<snip> MIT shit talking <snip>
Oh, right, I forgot. Once you namedrop MIT, graphs don't mean anything anymore. And neither do facts. Great comeback btw, you are clearly the intellectually honest one with the facts and graphs.
1
u/CONTROLurKEYS Mar 14 '19
I'm glad you at least admit it's a frothy circle-jerk
Did your graph prove MIT batch wasn't real? Or that batching doesn't work? I mean even Bitcoin cash users can batch their transactions, it exists
3
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Mar 14 '19
Did your graph prove MIT batch wasn't real? Or that batching doesn't work? I mean even Bitcoin cash users can batch their transactions, it exists
I never said it doesn't work. It's obviously more byte-efficient because it's the same way spammers bloated the UTXO set with un-spendable outputs (Gratz on Core for claiming that spamming the UTXO set is a scaling solution though!)
I said it hasn't DONE anything. Existing isn't sufficient. Lightning being cool tech isn't sufficient. None of it means anything if people don't use it. People aren't using batching, it hasn't made any significant difference in Bitcoin scaling.
People aren't going to use lightning because it isn't designed to function the way they want to use their money. When fees rise (Core's misguided attempt to force human behavior into the boxes they want) they're simply going to leave Bitcoin instead, and maybe all of Crypto. Aka... Steam.
→ More replies (0)3
u/loomenaughty Mar 14 '19 edited Mar 14 '19
At the very heart of the Lightning Network are the bi-directional channels through which payments are routed. If the customer already has money tied up in the Lightning Network, but the payee does not have any open channels, either the customer must close channels and re-open a new one to the payee (incurring fees on the base layer for each channel closure & opening), or the merchant must ask/pay someone ahead of time to open a channel with them for the amount of the expected payment. Even if this is automated by the wallet, the user will see a large fee for doing such and will likely cancel the payment. You can't get around this, this how the Lightning Network functions.
1
u/jackomah Mar 14 '19
So with those limitations, is there any reason the client side software couldn't carry out those actions automatically as LN develops?
Say my phone monitors my LN wallet and my channels each time its online in the background - thats obviously assuming i wouldn't just use a custodial wallet that can already do that for me.
4
u/loomenaughty Mar 14 '19
Yes, a client wallet can automatically close & open channels, but the fee for doing such must come from somewhere. Even with a custodial wallet (which I would argue is not P2P cash at all), the fees for opening the new channel must be payed by someone. Unless the custodian sees value in paying to open the channel with the merchant for fees from future payments, they will almost certainly pass the fee for opening a new channel along to the consumer. The mining fees must come from somewhere.
1
1
1
-1
u/CONTROLurKEYS Mar 14 '19 edited Mar 14 '19
Why wouldn't the company just open a channel with them so they can pay them hourly or daily? Problem solved.
Operationally what would likely happen is the company would directly open channels with their employees and pay them incrementally like hourly or daily. That is the point of LN small repeatable cheap payments. If I'm directly connected to the company there is no inbound balancing problem. The company can close the channel as part of the termination process. If the company insists on paying every 2 weeks well then they pay all employees in a couple batched transactions for one low fee on layer 1.(this is less private though) This isn't that complicated and I question the intellectual integrity of op.
-1
Mar 14 '19
Yeah, that's the case if you're a dumb fuck who can't manage his money and lives from paycheck to paycheck.
-1
u/dominipater Mar 15 '19
It's the type of absurd scenario this sub thrives on
Great mental anesthesia too
0
-2
Mar 15 '19
This is really stupid. The employer can open the channel for you and pay you on that channel all at once. Why would you need a loan?
1
28
u/unstoppable-cash Mar 14 '19
Source