r/btc • Moderator • Feb 27 '19

Two Years™ is the new 18 Months™

Post image
141 Upvotes

113 comments sorted by

22

u/etherael Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 28 '19

Wasn't it 18 months ~36 months ago? So they're actually losing six months for every 36 months that pass? We can expect it to be 30 months in another 36 months? It's hilarious watching them fumble this shit when it's effectively just a broken clone of paypal. Maybe they could just license PayPal, or XRP, or some other shitty centralised payment network THAT AT LEAST ACTUALLY WORKS, they have the propaganda team adequate to convince the braindead herd that whatever they're doing is ok, no matter how absurdly obvious it is that it is otherwise, so that shouldn't be a problem.

19

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Feb 27 '19

I wonder at what point the people currently drinking the kool aid will realize they've been bamboozled and lose interest.

20

u/etherael Feb 27 '19

The people running the scam will run it as long as they can. /u/adam3us /u/nullc et al are never going to turn around and admit they were wrong/scamming/false flagging for the state and central banks, their paid shill brigades will keep hyping as long as they're paid, and the poor suckers left over are the real wildcard. The fact they are still in after everything the anti blockstream faction has been saying for almost five years now just keeps coming true week after horrifying week does not speak well to the critical faculties of those people.

But the old adage holds as always; the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.

10

u/pecuniology Feb 27 '19

[T]heir paid shill brigades will keep hyping as long as they're paid, and the poor suckers left over are the real wildcard.

When it all falls apart, they most likely will go silent—like MSM 'journalists' moving on to a new manufactured 'crisis'—and sneer at anyone with the temerity to remind them of any of it, "Are you still going on about that?"

2

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '19

My new favourite quote from that Black Monday show:

"Isn't that insider trading?" "We just call that trading."

-1

u/MrRGnome Feb 27 '19

I count 6768 public lightning nodes and an unknown number of private nodes, custodial and mobile users.

By comparison there are a total of 1649 public BCH nodes and it's shrinking every week, not growing like lightning.

With a total of 2.5% of the available SHA256 hashpower your coin is a whim away from being attacked - again.

By every measure BCH is shrinking in use. We are at the point the people drinking the kool aid have realized they've been bamboozled and they are leaving BCH by the day.

9

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Feb 27 '19

You have to run a node to use LN, so nodes = users.

BCH nodes have no bearing on the total number of people using it.

-3

u/MrRGnome Feb 27 '19

No you don't. Eclair users don't run full nodes, bluewallet users don't run full nodes, and any Neutrino users don't run full nodes. Most mobile wallets use a 3rd party's node or Neutrino. If you are going to be critical of something start by learning how it works. Instead you get your facts from drinking the kool aid around here, of course you are misinformed.

6

u/nootropicat Feb 27 '19

A node in ln means an identity with channels, not a bitcoin node with ln. Node topology is public for routing. Only custodial wallets aren't visible.

0

u/MrRGnome Feb 27 '19

So are you denying that most mobile wallets do not use their own lightning node? Most use a 3rd party like the examples I listed. Many users like wallets where they don't need to setup channels and that requires using someone else's lightning node.

5

u/nootropicat Feb 27 '19

Read it again. A node in ln means a node in the routing graph, not a bitcoin node + lnd. These are two different things that share a name. Many ln (graph) nodes (users) can use one network node

1

u/MrRGnome Feb 27 '19

As someone who runs both lnd and btc nodes you don't need to explain the difference to me, but it seems I need to explain the difference to you. Maybe you should reread.

-4

u/iambabyjesus90 Feb 27 '19

If you looked at your daily transactions you would realize this quite quickly lmao it’s hilarious how “Death to bitcoin, BCHABC maximalist are.” And bitcoin people don’t give a flying fuck about BCHABC. Hmm I wonder why? Is someone jealous ?

3

u/gold_rehypothecation Feb 27 '19

More incoherent rambling please.

Why are you posting here if you don't give a f***

7

u/TheCryptoNerd Feb 27 '19

By every measure BCH is shrinking in use.

Completely false. For example, transactions are clearly growing.

1

u/MrRGnome Feb 27 '19

Try the 6 month window or greater. Transactions are clearly falling and are entirely eclipsed by transactions on BTC.

3

u/TheCryptoNerd Feb 27 '19

You do realize there was a fork and attack on the network during that time? Either way, your statement is still false.

-1

u/MrRGnome Feb 27 '19

Yes I realize BCH is very vulnerable to attacks, and that my statement remains true. BCH use is dwindling while BTC continues to be the leader of the entire crypto market and the most secure offering available.

1

u/TheCryptoNerd Feb 27 '19

Nice trolling with a mixture of false and true statements -

" BCH is very vulnerable to attacks " --> False; how come it easily fended off the attack? how come no one attacks it constantly?

" BCH use is dwindling " --> False; I just showed it's not over a reasonable timeframe

" BTC continues to be the leader of the entire crypto market " --> Partially true; depends on how you define "leader"

"..." most secure offering available " -> True

1

u/MrRGnome Feb 27 '19

You just blamed the downtrend of transactions on an attack in the six month+ window, then in the next comment say BCH isn't vulnerable to attacks while continuing to deny the downward trend in the 6 month + window.

5

u/nootropicat Feb 27 '19

There are 3,585 non-custodial users with channels according to https://1ml.com/statistics

1

u/stale2000 Feb 28 '19

There are 100K merchants that accept BCH. That's pretty damn good, imo.

-9

u/adam3us Adam Back, CEO of Blockstream Feb 27 '19

Lightning daily growth rates and dev momentum with lightning apps, lightning network, wallets plus bitcoin protocol dev pace getting you down or something ? ;)

20

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Feb 27 '19

I thought this was another random troll comment, but oh hey, it's Blockstream CEO Adam Back.

By the way, after several years Lightning Network only has ~3,000 users (nodes). Next stop, world domination!

6

u/CityBusDriverBitcoin Feb 27 '19

You clearly triggered him 😂

0

u/adam3us Adam Back, CEO of Blockstream Feb 28 '19

you edited out your post tagging me, lols.

-5

u/iambabyjesus90 Feb 27 '19

Dude why are you fighting a battle you have already lost? BCHABC will never amount to bitcoin, end of story. It might have a nice run but it will NEVER take over bitcoin. Just be real with yourself. It’s open source for a reason if there is anything worth putting into the code they will once it’s been proven. You can’t just change bitcoins core without ramifications so they won’t until need be.

5

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Feb 27 '19

Bitcoin cash is a bitcoin and it works exactly how we expected it to and how bitcoin was supposed to.

It has very good run all the time. I'm very happy about it.

0

u/iambabyjesus90 Feb 27 '19

Why aren’t people using it?

4

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Feb 27 '19

They are.

0

u/iambabyjesus90 Feb 27 '19

Have you not looked at the 24 hour transactions lately? lol

5

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Feb 27 '19

No. I used bch several times in last 24 hours without problems though.

Bch has the same characteristics as bitcoin btc had before it got crippled. That's why I'm sure bitcoin cash will continue to function when btc will become obsolete. Btc is already almost speculation token anyway.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/Erumara Feb 27 '19

I know it's easy to forget these things when you're busy spewing feces out of both ends, but for a long time BTC had essentially zero transaction volume and yet it's still here.

→ More replies (0)

14

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Feb 27 '19

Destroying btc is getting me down. Fees we all witnessed at ath, got me really down.

The fact that you are still posting without shame after turning bitcoin into interconnected tab system amazes me.

7

u/nootropicat Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 27 '19

There are no 'lighting apps', it's not a platform. Adding a payment option to a site for X, like dogecoin, doesn't make it a 'dogecoin app'.

10

u/ericreid9 Feb 27 '19

Glad you killed BTC on-chain for it. Hope it was worth it ;)

5

u/scarybeyond Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 27 '19

FUCK. YOU.

1

u/stale2000 Feb 28 '19

How many merchants does the Lightning Network have?

Compare this to BCH, which was created around the same time, and has 100K + merchants.

The only metric that really matters is how many places I can spend my crypto at.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '19

The Lightning Network whitepaper was published in 2016. What are you talking about?

27

u/anothertimewaster Feb 27 '19

Shouldn’t the timeframe be shrinking not lengthening? Lol

8

u/ShadowOfHarbringer Feb 27 '19

Shouldn’t the timeframe be shrinking not lengthening? Lol

It's lengthening up to infinity. And beyond.

4

u/tjmac Feb 27 '19

Is Andreas an honest actor?

5

u/fiah84 Feb 27 '19

Not to his past self, not to the OG bitcoiners. I don't think he's a bad actor per se, but it's obvious to me that he stopped speaking out of conviction and instead now speaks only for his self interest (whatever that may be)

5

u/ShadowOfHarbringer Feb 27 '19

Is Andreas an honest actor?

I believe he hasn't been for the last 4 years.

Or they have something on him / Threatened his family. Guy kind of looks scared to me.

3

u/tjmac Feb 27 '19

Thanks. I agree.

2

u/CatatonicAdenosine Feb 27 '19

It's like AI and fusion power!

23

u/jonas_h Author of Why cryptocurrencies? Feb 27 '19

And the followers switch at the same time:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Monero/comments/atf3t1/if_youre_putting_a_lot_of_on_your_lightning/eh3hedz/

Almost like it's coordinated, or something.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Progress!!

4

u/-uncle-jimbo- Feb 27 '19

loool, im wondering would it be 2years or 18month in august when 6months has passed...

3

u/mrcrypto2 Feb 27 '19

I think it makes sense for Blockstream to either watch BTC burn or for LN to succeed. If LN fails, BTC should fail with it (ie. stay small blocks). If I was around that space and suspect in my heart that this small block business really isn't working out, I would load up on sub-$150 BCH and secretly hope for BCH to become Bitcoin.

It makes no sense to make BTC become big-blocks and try to compete with BCH - just take the coins you have in BTC, multiply it by 20 by moving over to BCH - and you are golden.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

If they hired Josh from BFL they could get that time frame down to ~2 weeks™

1

u/jcrew77 Feb 27 '19

Those were the good ol' days. Though they were just as bitter, it seems. This whole space has been filled with vitriol for some time.

2

u/ErdoganTalk Feb 27 '19

Every month before lightning come to general use, kill a kitten and sell a coin.

2

u/deineemudda Feb 27 '19

is AA more of a big blocker?

6

u/Erumara Feb 27 '19

AA is a fascinating character.

You can go back into his talks a few years and he goes on at length about possibilities for scaling and speaking against fiat currency and the banking cartels with a really respectable passion.

But

Shortly before the actual BCH split he stops talking about actual scaling and starts skirting the issue while trying desperately not to actually lie about off-chain nonsense while also trying to keep his talks and interviews technical and unbiased. If you watch some of the recent ones there are some really painful questions and watching him weigh his answer is honestly fun to watch.

Most likely: he was paid off (or blackmailed?) but has managed to keep from being an outright bullshit artist (like Tone Vays, Jimmy Song, and Samson Mow) which you kind of have to respect him for. I won't link any of his videos, but I will leave you with one of the weirdest things I ever saw happen in the crypto space.

https://qz.com/1151233/andreas-antonopoulos-got-1-5-million-in-bitcoin-donations-after-roger-ver-bitshamed-him/

2

u/deineemudda Feb 27 '19

so he got some donations. does that make him a puppet? or do i missunderstand your post. donations could also have been in bch? so im wondering what his stance is today. does he believe in LN? if not what does he see as technical solution nowadays? sorry have been a little out of the loop recently and thx for your answer!

3

u/Erumara Feb 27 '19

These are all good questions, and the truth is that there are no definitive answers and that is why it's so fascinating.

Don't misunderstand and think I dislike or do not agree with AA, as I have never come across him actually spreading falsehoods or manufactured narratives. Just that it's strange he stopped talking about actual scaling entirely and most often avoids the topic of BCH.

I'm merely providing you with facts and offering my personal conclusions. Perhaps you disagree and that is perfectly reasonable as well.

1

u/stale2000 Feb 28 '19

It is more subtle than that.

I don't think Andreas has been bribed or blackmailed or whatever.

Instead, he obviously knows what is the hand that feeds him.

If he had not dropped his support for scaling and big blocks, he would have made a lot of people on the core side very mad. And we all know what happens when you don't toe the party line.

He get banned from all major Bitcoin platforms and driven out of the community. Andreas makes all his money by giving talks at conferences. So it would be no surprise that he doesn't want to rock any boats.

1

u/random043 Feb 27 '19

2 years for "average non-technical mass-adoption" of LN?

dishonest or delusional, you decide

1

u/Mvm321 Feb 27 '19

May 2020

1

u/BOMinvest Redditor for less than 90 days Feb 27 '19

Thank goodness that litecoin is around to offload the transactions!

-3

u/Hernzzzz Feb 27 '19

It's been 18 months since the BCH fork, hows that working out?

20

u/Calm_down_stupid Feb 27 '19

Well enough that you feel the need to be here everyday trolling Hernzzzz.

Any actual comment on the subject of the post or the Andreas tweet?

7

u/pecuniology Feb 27 '19

It took me a few moments to parse that. I initially thought that he was saying that ever since the BCH fork, LN has been 18 months™ away... because, it was.

Lightning Network is the technology of the future, and it always will be!

2

u/500239 Feb 27 '19

Well enough that you feel the need to be here everyday trolling Hernzzzz.

this is good, /u/hernzzzz is going to need to visit the burn unit. As well as the irony department as well.

-1

u/Hernzzzz Feb 27 '19

Still writing fan fiction? I hope you're looking forward to the Hernz AMA!

5

u/phro Feb 27 '19

You're still here, so we must be fine. Otherwise, why are you still wasting time on a coin that you think can't win?

14

u/SILENTSAM69 Feb 27 '19

Quite well.

-8

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Feb 27 '19

Currently trading at prices not seen in bitcoin in 6 years, and significantly fewer transactions than dogecoin. It’s doing great, lol.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

10x the daily volume of Doge despite recovering from the biggest attack any cryptocurrencies have ever faced..

Schnorr coming in few months, token, etc..

But I know exchange rate is very important for small blocker!

-1

u/Spartacus_Nakamoto Feb 27 '19

It’s never a good sign when you’ve got to spin data to make your coin look better than doge.

Remember when /r/btc was excited about the flippening? Is that dream dead to you now that you’re arguing that the price doesn’t matter?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '19

It’s never a good sign when you’ve got to spin data to make your coin look better than doge.

Checked now, BCH 232millons dollars and doge 50millions on coin gecko.

Remember when /r/btc was excited about the flippening? Is that dream dead to you now that you’re arguing that the price doesn’t matter?

Personally it doesn’t matter so much The flippening.. what matter is the original experiment can continue..

But ultimately over the long term it is unavoidable.. there is only so much you can do with small block,

Maybe BTC will remain an high value speculative asset.. but why do I care?

I have no love for tulip,

1

u/stale2000 Feb 28 '19

Well we have 100k+ merchants. So that metric is going pretty well.

This is in comparison to the lighting network which has a couple thousand nodes, not even merchants. Those nodes are likely just users.

0

u/TheBTC-G Feb 27 '19

Downvote away but this is a textbook example of moving the goalposts. It was 18 months until lighting is functional, not 18 months until lightning has wallets built for your average joe. And as someone using LN (who isn’t very technical), I can assure you it’s running. Development takes time. If this space has taught me anything over the past 6.5 years it’s that patience pays off.

6

u/Bagatell_ Feb 27 '19

And as someone using LN

Can you tell us what for? I have yet to see a convincing use case for Lightning.

1

u/TheBTC-G Feb 27 '19

Right now I’m simply playing around because I find it fascinating as I did Bitcoin when I first discovered it. The primary current use case is near instant and near free transactions on top of the most robust blockchain around.

But what interests me the most is the potential opportunities for services that could run on micropayments. I’m talking fractions of a fraction of a cent to pay per minute for services versus monthly subscriptions for example. And who knows what other use cases might be found. Ever since I first got into bitcoin years ago that was one of the most attractive potential use cases because it’s impossible to do such microtransactions with other payment methods, particularly in a decentralized way. Maybe micropayments will turn out to not really find many use cases people actually want to use, but I can only imagine there are dozens upon hundreds of such use cases I can’t even imagine in the way I could’ve never imagined years ago the range of mobile phone apps that have been developed today.

3

u/ChristianCarbide Feb 27 '19

They never said anything of 36 or 60 months... that's lying by omission

-7

u/Actuallyconscious Feb 27 '19

15

u/BeijingBitcoins Moderator Feb 27 '19

Remember when LN was 6 months away back in 2015? lol

14

u/fiah84 Feb 27 '19

people who were actually bitcoin believers back in 2015 remember

8

u/scarybeyond Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 27 '19

They're still around, and they are Bitcoin Cash supporters today.

2

u/lubokkanev Feb 27 '19

So 6m away in 2015, 18m away in 2017, 24m away in 2019.

We can expect it to stabilize at 100m away from 2050 onward.

-6

u/Actuallyconscious Feb 27 '19

Remember this FUD about internet?

https://www.newsweek.com/clifford-stoll-why-web-wont-be-nirvana-185306

Development requires patience. If you don't have it then it is not the space for you.

Especially tech of high magnitude.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Development requires patience. If you don't have it then it is not the space for you.

I'm glad you've decided we don't really need your permissionless money.

Until the new solution is ready. Right?

9

u/chainxor Feb 27 '19

The difference here is that there is always better solutions than LN.

-6

u/Actuallyconscious Feb 27 '19

The difference here is that there is always better solutions than LN.

You can imply this sentence basically on everything so I do not understand your point.

Tech keeps developing and better solutions are "always" found.

6

u/chainxor Feb 27 '19

Among the better solutions are almost any major chain's on-chain tx (except BTC), and LN will likely not improve to be better in any significant way compared to the competition.

1

u/Actuallyconscious Feb 27 '19

Please be more concrete.

any major chain's on-chain tx (except BTC)

Can you give me some examples?

and LN will likely not improve to be better in any significant way compared to the competition.

You've been roaming on this sub for way too long...

7

u/chainxor Feb 27 '19

"Can you give me some examples?"

ETH, BCH, Dash, (even) LTC, ADA...enough?

"You've been roaming on this sub for way too long..."

No, I actually just tried LN several times and it is still crap.

1

u/stale2000 Feb 28 '19

Well, there is one coin that is accepted by 100k merchants and has low fees, and the devs are working on stuff like 0 conf, and massive scaling on chain.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

We have the wheel. Don't really need your square. But thanks.

4

u/Richy_T Feb 27 '19

I guess the internet just needed some watchtowers.

4

u/hawks5999 Feb 27 '19

So you’re saying that LN is basically the visigoths?

0

u/Talktothecoin Feb 27 '19

We found out if the market agrees.