r/hiphopheads • . • Feb 27 '19

Gunna - Drip Or Drown 2 ALBUM REVIEW (Fantano)

https://youtu.be/wgU7-FzF5Xw
2.5k Upvotes

563 comments sorted by

4.2k

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Who in god's name is out here on HHH instantly buying reddit platinum and gold for Anthony Fantano review threads.

I really don't get it. Spend your money on something better. Smh.

45

u/ltrob . Feb 27 '19

This is the first one I’ve seen guilded in a while

57

u/Nolar2015 . Feb 27 '19

Guilded

47

u/ltrob . Feb 27 '19

Apparently my phone doesn’t like gilded

9

u/mechorive . Feb 27 '19

Silveradoed

2.2k

u/atomicbrett . Feb 27 '19

Someone on here must really hate Gunna lol

1.0k

u/Revolutionis_Myname . Feb 27 '19

Fat people dislike Gunna now

302

u/ticklemybuns . Feb 27 '19

He never answered :(

136

u/BidoofTheGod Feb 27 '19

Nah my fatass loves Gunna

50

u/ChthonicSpectre Feb 27 '19

you see what he say tho?

247

u/BidoofTheGod Feb 27 '19

Why would I care if he called someone else fat? Gunna fat too.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

35

u/BodakBlack Feb 27 '19

That shit is probably fake and he didnt wanna answer him

50

u/hufusa Feb 27 '19

HILARIOUS is what that shit was

52

u/IAmDarkridge r/iconasty mod Feb 27 '19

After what he did to me boy Mattmo... He'll never be forgiven.

17

u/Question-everythings Feb 27 '19

Why would they? I'm a little out of the loop, who is he?

134

u/_nannerB_ Feb 27 '19

gunna did an AMA on HHH. Whole thing was a shitshow. Gunna or whoever was answering questions was just giving pretty much troll answers to questions and a guy commented about how gunna insulted him for being fat at a show. other people who were there backed the guy up and the comment is one of the most upvoted on the thread.

75

u/-AestheticsOfHate- Feb 27 '19

No one else backed the guy up, in fact a few people did the opposite. Funny comment though

57

u/EPineapple Feb 27 '19

no one backed it up someone said they were there and it didnt happen

17

u/Question-everythings Feb 27 '19

Oh, okay, thanks, I'll look more into it there.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

352

u/YourDadIsFortyFour Feb 27 '19

Remember when his Kids See Ghosts review got more upvotes and gold than the actual Kids See Ghosts drop and reaction threads lol

104

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

It was a 10/10 tho. 10!!

15

u/TheWarInBaSingSe Feb 27 '19

Duh. How do i know if i should upvote an album, before he uploads my opinion on it?

91

u/Blocked99 . Feb 27 '19

Shit threw me off hard, I thought Fantano gave this album a 10 or something and people just lost their shit and decided to gild the post.

41

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

you didnt see the red flannel?

7

u/Blocked99 . Feb 27 '19

Was browsing on my phone, it didn't show the thumbnail until I went into the thread itself.

9

u/KanYeJeBekHouden Feb 27 '19

I saw the gold on the post without a thumbnail.

542

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

I feel like a large part of the appeal is that Fantano is looked at as almost an objective source for music critique. I was chilling with my friend in his basement and i said that Fantano used his reviews to pander to large groups of people, who he knows wants their opinions validated. My friend kicked me out, and I got mad so before I left I put the icing from my dunkaroos in his dog's asshole. I didn't think much of it until a week later when he told me in gym class that it had started to burn when he pees, so make of that what you will.

206

u/supadupakevin Feb 27 '19

I can’t with this fucking sub sometimes lmao

83

u/-AestheticsOfHate- Feb 27 '19

It's like r/NBA on steroids

47

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 27 '19

I'll never eat dunkaroos again without thinking about your dogs asshole

edit: your friend's dog's asshole

65

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

wasn't my dog's asshole it was my friend's

17

u/carlito_mas Feb 27 '19

o okay good

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

yeah me too

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ih8tea Feb 27 '19

fucking hell

2

u/brockbampton Feb 27 '19

What in the fuck

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Kitchen_Ur_Lies joe biden fucked my bitch Feb 27 '19

this was a gold laundering operation and you’re a part of it smh

2

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

I guess I was the better thing for people to spend money on

22

u/PregnantTaco . Feb 27 '19

Good to see people using money on reddit gold instead of buying the album

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TXCapita Feb 27 '19

imagine spending money just to put a little stamp on some dumbass internet post

13

u/RapWasBetterIn03 Feb 27 '19

He's the go-to source for people who still need validation from others

4

u/letsfuckinggo520 Feb 27 '19

Chill bro it's just klay Thompson, he can afford it

2

u/NewGuyCH Feb 27 '19

He himself surely

1

u/GoopHugger . Feb 27 '19

It doesn't cost money to give gold if you conserve your points.

1

u/ih8tea Feb 27 '19

Giving reddit money for any reason is probably the single worst use of a few dollars a person could spend

1

u/Sevenoaken Feb 27 '19

Am I too late to the gold party?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '19

Since they introduced these new medals I have seen the use of it rise way higher when it was just reddit gold. It really has always been kind of lame within Reddit culture as a waste of money. Which is why I think Reddit must be giving it out in some way or hiring users to guild shit. I don’t know how but I certainly feel they are tying to manipulate it’s use to make it more main stream. Blah blah tin foil hat and all that but I certainly feel there has been a wave of usage since this update came out.

→ More replies (20)

•

u/AutoModerator Feb 27 '19

REMINDER: Review thread guidelines:

  • Parent comments in review threads must be over 140 characters.

  • Comments that solely name the score or describe the clothing the reviewer is wearing are not allowed

  • Meta comments solely about how the subreddit will react to the review are also not allowed.

  • Comments that only compare the review to other scores by the publication or by other publications are not allowed.

  • If this is a Fantano review, visit r/fantanoforever for all low-effort comments

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/ltrob . Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 27 '19

Whomst the fuck is gilded this

3

u/maurypopovich Feb 27 '19

These dumb rules are killing this subreddit

→ More replies (4)

3.0k

u/ArtVandalo Feb 27 '19

Fantano really hates Gunna, every single video I've seen of him he always bashes Gunna. He probably was in his show and Gunna said "Look at this bald nigga dance".

435

u/BluePter0dactyl . Feb 27 '19

Gunna, when you opened up for Travis in Boston I was in the pit almost front row dancing and loving life then right after drip too hard you pointed at me and said “look at this bald nigga dance” and people around me laughed at me so I went home and gave your album a bad score in my review.... my question is why did you do that?

469

u/PXSHRVN6ER Feb 27 '19

That’s fresh pasta

0

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

[deleted]

80

u/chubbyurma Feb 27 '19

Less fresh but still good

→ More replies (1)

133

u/Aydosubpotato Feb 27 '19

Lmao

56

u/CaptnKnots Feb 27 '19

Can’t wait to see what r/nba does with this

9

u/LawlzBarkley Feb 27 '19

Most likely involving Klay

→ More replies (1)

70

u/170505170505 Feb 27 '19

It’s bc Gunna fucked Fantano’s mom. That lady’s breasts are covered with the same stubble as Fantano’s head. Saw it with my own 2 eyes. Was not pretty

33

u/whospepesilvia Feb 27 '19

Cam Newton really hates Kelvin Benjamin, every single video I've seen of him he always bashes Benjamin. He probably was near him at a buffet and Newton said "Look at this fat ass eat".

17

u/SlimeShit Feb 27 '19

Lmaoooooo

15

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

I hope this becomes a thing

1.4k

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Okay so the edgy comments on these videos get unoriginal sometimes but I gotta admit that i Iaughed at whoever commented “I can’t believe you said ‘Gunna should forget the drip and just drown. 0/10’ a little rough no?”

Yeah... I don’t really care for Gunna. The most surprising thing about this review is that it even exists

355

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Rap/hip hop reviews give him the most views. No fault to him if that’s the truth and he’s after the viewership. I still believe that he actually cares about hip hop a lot and spends time analyzing and breaking down the projects that he listens to (except MBDTF of course).

101

u/JGraham1839 . Feb 27 '19

I know this is true but if he reviewed Gunna he should review A Boogie. Boogie did massive numbers and has several songs still in the top 100 and his album was #1 for several weeks (even though it was a weak #1). I'm not defending A Boogie or anything but his last album was objectively a big commercial success, like him or not. And not like it was completely dogshit or anything like Total Xanarchy

32

u/StillFreeAudioTwo Feb 27 '19

He said he was sitting it out after he and PnB Rock got into that altercation with Lil B.

49

u/BleachedSkeleton Feb 27 '19 edited Oct 13 '24

squash gaping reminiscent retire zephyr deliver weary airport aware wine

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

12

u/JGraham1839 . Feb 27 '19

I wondered this myself actually. I knew from what I heard, for instance in WAKA with 6ix9ine Melon straight up called A Boogie's singing bad. And I thought, especially on that track, his vocals were really good. When I saw he didn't even include Hoodie SZN in YUNO review, I started wondering if he didn't just avoid A Boogie.

→ More replies (3)

50

u/slashsecret Feb 27 '19

Real shit.. but middle of the road reviews don't get clicks. " 0/10 I hate gunna haha just s meme bro calm down " and " OMG KSG best rock album of all time 10/10" are the reviews that get some buzz, gotta sensationalize everything these days smh

118

u/Oilupto Feb 27 '19

Idk if intentional but I love the irony in this comment with how you sensationalized his reviews

31

u/Jmaaan Feb 27 '19

gotta sensationalize everything these days smh

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (10)

21

u/Pyrom9 Feb 27 '19

Same lol. I thought that was actually a good comment.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Omg that was my comment, this makes me more happy than it should lol

12

u/dealgordon Feb 27 '19

Why did you spell laugh with an i

6

u/_m0nk_ Feb 27 '19

He has to review it because of how big it is. Atlanta street rap isn’t a genre Anthony Is super knowledgeable on and I get why, the only reason I know what I do about it is because allot of the dudes I record want to make music like gunna. And for the most part Anthony’s right. Let me guess, the beat you sent me is gonna have a piano and some trap drums and a boomin bass and that’s pretty much it. Oh and you want me to auto tune the fuck outta your voice so no one can tell you actually suck at rapping so instead we just sound painfully average.

509

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 27 '19

Hahahaha Fantano really doesn’t like Gunna. I can see not enjoying this album since the songs definitely blend into each other and he’s not exactly versatile, but a 2’s pretty harsh. Always fun to see him rip into an album though.

184

u/CinnamonSwisher Feb 27 '19

I put on this album for the first time while reading comments and couldn’t really tell when songs changed

96

u/jkof300 Feb 27 '19

I put this album on while working out and I felt like no time goes by cuz i was still on the same song

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Janji44 Feb 27 '19

A 2 is not bad come on! Only 1 point behind house of balloons

87

u/Personarose1 Feb 27 '19

This album is more forgettable and middle of the road generic/mediocre then outright awful. Just another run of the mill trap project to pass time until the next larger one comes out. By track six I felt like screw drowning I had sunk to the ocean floor.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Honest. To me it wasn't bad per say, but holy God did it neither go hard or bring something new to the table. I got only 1 or 2 songs from this album

→ More replies (1)

57

u/RandyMuscle Feb 27 '19

At least it isn’t NAV-tier bad.

83

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Nav made nav ft nav prod by nav he doesn’t deserve this

37

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Actually, it was NAV by NAV prod. By NAV on NAV

7

u/iButtflap Feb 27 '19

any word on the cost of his shoes?

→ More replies (1)

18

u/3021Michael Feb 27 '19

I mean...

→ More replies (18)

18

u/lmpressivePlayer Feb 27 '19

I mean I don’t understand how anyone would buy or get into Walmart Young Thug. Literally brings nothing to the table

21

u/2Hard2PickAUsername . Feb 27 '19

Except songs that sound good, but I know what you’re sayin

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

2 is a lot TBH

→ More replies (1)

280

u/streetlightsglowing_ . Feb 27 '19

I can get the appeal of Lil Baby even though I am not a huge fan, don't understand the hype around Gunna at all. If he's on a feature he is tolerable for me and he has made some great songs, but a whole project of him is so. boring. No clever wordplay, no memorable bars, same nasally-autotune voice on damn near every track. Ok so he can use a catchy flow? Is that his only saving grace that people are attracted to?

Mediocre artist, think most people will have forgotten about him within a few years.

213

u/streetlightsglowing_ . Feb 27 '19

also Gunna should have told Young Thug that he couldn't give him a feature on this, because it made it that much easier to compare the two and see how much better Young Thug is than Gunna at his own style

→ More replies (9)

84

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Gunna is to Young Thug what Greta Van Fleet is to Led Zeppelin.

21

u/nimrodrool Feb 27 '19

My nathan

6

u/adamjm99 Phife Forever Feb 27 '19

Oh boy this is scorching, but I’m glad it’s finally been said

4

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

It’s been known.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/dak9877 Feb 27 '19

Totally agree. I honestly like some of lil baby’s stuff but forget it with gunna lol. Literally seems like the most generic trap artist in the game at the moment.

2

u/SavageToasters Feb 27 '19

Lil Baby is always brought up at the same time with Gunna, but I find Lil Baby way more enjoyable, given that he switches his flow up. He consistently outshines Gunna on songs they're on together

1

u/radwic Feb 27 '19

I'm the same here. I can listen to a Lil Baby project, I can listen to a Lil Baby feature. Really didn't like him on "Yes Indeed" but he grew on me. I can NOT listen to a Gunna project. It is all the same shit. He is an awesome feature though. "Never Recover," "Ready," "can't leave without it," etc - all awesome songs with great Gunna features. His albums are not good at all though.

582

u/ThatGuyWhoIsCool . Feb 27 '19

I agree 100% with him. I just don’t see the appeal of Gunna. I found this album very boring and generic and Gunna really does not have any character to him. I was surprised to see so many hyping up this album when it first came out. Just my opinion, but I just can’t see what all the hype is about.

343

u/zachmichel . Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 27 '19

I’ve been saying this for a bit but Gunna is like Seasoning. He’s a really good feature. He can fit/blend into many styles. He can fit on many tracks. But on a track alone he’s just kind of boring.

No one eats grill mates alone without a steak

92

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Every current album is sprinkled with gunna and lil baby features. They are like salt and pepper

84

u/streetlightsglowing_ . Feb 27 '19

Lol why is this so accurate

25

u/zachmichel . Feb 27 '19

I was laughing my ass off writing this so I’m glad someone else likes the analogy 😂

45

u/JoonWick Feb 27 '19

this can be said about half the popular rappers right now thats not a good trait

3

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Depends on how you define popular, and even then I think that’s an extreme exaggeration

0

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

[deleted]

42

u/FN_Freedom Feb 27 '19

anderson paak a full course meal i could just ea-

nevermind

47

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Nah fam, continue

→ More replies (1)

14

u/K1787L12 Feb 27 '19

Holy shit bravo to you for this comment. Really nailed it. BJ the Chicago Kid is the R&B version of this imo

111

u/fraillimbnursery . Feb 27 '19

People are really spending money on your comment for posting a negative opinion of an album. Lol

138

u/FlyingLotus_Beats . Feb 27 '19

bro it's like $2 lol

199

u/fraillimbnursery . Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 27 '19

It’s a waste of $2 is my point

This post itself has diamond and multiple gold too. People really spend money on stuff like that?

75

u/ScHoolboyV Feb 27 '19

welcome to reddit - people will give gold to comments that literally say, "give me gold"

15

u/KanyeWest_KanyeBest . Feb 27 '19

give me head

→ More replies (62)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/Yung_Habanero Feb 27 '19

Feel ya. Just a discount thugger most of the time. Thugger has so much personality and gunna just makes me want to listen to thug every time

7

u/DFWTooThrowed Feb 27 '19

Yeah I don't get the appeal of him at all. There are plenty of super famous trap rappers out there that I don't like all that much but I get it - like whenever I hear their music come on at like parties I don't mind it at all. But I just don't understand the appeal of him and every other discount Young Thug I see posted on here all the time.

Like I don't really care about in depth lyrics or any of that shit when I listen to this kind of rap, I just don't wanna listen to someone who does absolutely nothing to set himself apart.

2

u/Chisae7 Feb 27 '19

Yea he’s a one year wonder at this point. He has no versatility and I don’t see him changing his sound. I honestly would be surprised if he isn’t going downhill from here.

2

u/WhirlStore Feb 27 '19

He's an extremely watered down young thug

2

u/DaveCerqueira Feb 27 '19

Well I havent seen a positive comment about Gunna itt but my 2 cents are that Gunna has a lot of potential, idk for how long he’s been in the game but it feels like he needs to just make more songs and find his sound. I really dig his voice and his flow, usually for me its the beat that turns me down but whennever I hear Gunna on a sick beat he always comes thru for me.

2

u/_SantaQuas44 Feb 27 '19

it’s great to play in the background when your boys are over

1

u/madvillain47 Feb 27 '19

I domt enjoy gunnas songs but I do enjoy a few of his features. Just can't listen to him for an entire song I guess

1

u/ProfessorNiceBoy Feb 27 '19

I agree and feel the same about Father Of 4. I do not see why everyone was jizzing their pants about it cementing him as the best Migo. The album was boring as fuck.

1

u/Pizzanigs . Feb 27 '19

Just ask the people on here who attack anyone who says Drip Season 3 wasn’t top 5 AOTY lol

168

u/kvng_icy223 Feb 27 '19

This was really predictable and not surprising at all melon hates gunna's music. Lol I know you shouldnt rate artist albums on the same scale but him giving pump a higher score than gunna and who you foolin has his worst track is blasphemous

Honestly if you liked gunna before this project you'll probably like this one and if you hated his music before you're going to hate this.

I enjoyed the project but it isnt as good as drip season 3 (his best album imo) but its still solid. Wit it, outstanding, who you foolin, same yung nigga, 3 headed snake fucking slap and are my standout tracks

Overall: 6/10

12

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

On a mountain slaps too

5

u/YizWasHere Feb 27 '19

Don't sleep on Yao Ming, honestly one of my favorite Gunna tracks to date

→ More replies (9)

22

u/xTotalSellout Feb 27 '19

Yeah I agree with ol melon here. I really don’t understand the hype around Gunna to be honest, this was probably the weakest project to drop out of the few that dropped last week

146

u/fraillimbnursery . Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 27 '19

Completely disagree with him here, but I saw this coming. He doesn’t get the appeal of Gunna at all. I really enjoyed this album, probably one of the better releases of the year so far in my opinion.

Probably gonna get trashed for going against the prevailing opinion but that’s to be expected here

33

u/JayReyd Feb 27 '19

It’s February

12

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Thank god lol

207

u/Yung_Habanero Feb 27 '19

Idk I just don't see it either. Literally just a super generic sounding thugger half the time. Nothing original at all, just super derivative and his voice is just boring

19

u/legendguy123 Feb 27 '19

I'm not exactly a gunna fan and in fact I didn't like this album aside from 2 or 3 songs but I do see his appeal. Yeah he sounds similar to thugger but he does have a more chill relaxing vibe to his voice than thugger whereas thugger is a lot more energetic and charismatic with his voice.

3

u/Ghost51 . Feb 27 '19

Exactly bro just listen to Thugger, my favourite thing about Thugger is just focusing on his bizarre inflections and voices every 30 seconds so I dont get the appeal of just one voice spread over an album.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

18

u/BidoofTheGod Feb 27 '19

Drip Season 3 was way better but I’m enjoying this so far. Just classic Gunna not really much to get if people are still looking to get him. He’s just a chill vibe rapper and I enjoy his voice a lot. It’s nothing special and nothing crazy but I just enjoy listening to it while I work or do some chores.

People keep saying he’s a discount Thug and yea that’s why I like listening to him. I enjoy the melo trap sound and I want to listen to more music like that. Gunna is just a Thug offspring and that’s why I enjoy him.

35

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

What is the appeal of him though?

43

u/BidoofTheGod Feb 27 '19

For me I just like the style of hip hop. I enjoy the melodic street trap sound. All those guys that are influenced by Thug and Future. For Gunna personally I really enjoy his voice and the beats he’s on. There’s really nothing to get cus he’s just a chill vibe rapper that’s all about voice, flow and beats. Usually the lyrics are nonsense but to me it sounds good. If you don’t like the style, then you might not be into it at all.

→ More replies (6)

48

u/fraillimbnursery . Feb 27 '19

Speaking for myself:

I really like the production and a lot of the beats on this project are pretty unique. I like his flow on tracks like Baby Birkin and Who You Foolin. He has the same appeal as early 21 Savage imo, he’s pretty monotone but that’s why I like it

6

u/kendollamar Feb 27 '19

21 Savage actually had some pretty entertaining lyrics, which Gunna does not.

57

u/streetlightsglowing_ . Feb 27 '19

You know an artist's garbage when the first thing somebody has to say about the album is how they liked the production (unless they are heavy into handling their own production like Ye, which Gunna is obviously not)

111

u/fraillimbnursery . Feb 27 '19

Or, y’know, I thought the production was worth noting and didn’t put it first for any specific reason. I also noted things I liked about Gunna specifically later.

You guys really can’t let me enjoy Gunna, can you?

→ More replies (12)

6

u/Yung_Habanero Feb 27 '19

eh I like migos but that's also true a lot of the time. Culture 1 just had top notch production and that's just somewhat a genre trait with modern trap, the beats carry it a lot of the time

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

17

u/Bartolious_Clout Feb 27 '19

Gunna is one of the few artists that just effortlessly vibes out on a beat. Sure he needs good production, but his overall sound is hypnotic and relaxing. His voice is pleasant on the ears and his flow (though repetitive) is catchy.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/_SantaQuas44 Feb 27 '19

it’s great to throw on when you’re chillin with your boys and you aren’t trying to play dense, lyrical music

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/Messiahhh Feb 27 '19

I'm with you, I've already got about 6 listens. The album is called Drip Season and people still don't expect him to rap about his drip for the entirety of the album. Gunna's flow sounds, like you said, so good over the production. Three headed snakes with Thugger on CONSTANT repeat. Definitely my favorite release of the week.

4

u/mki401 Feb 28 '19

Definitely my favorite release of the week

pretty low bar

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Look_Behind_You__ Feb 27 '19

I mean there has been like 5 albums released so not saying much

2

u/Smeermalloot Feb 27 '19

Gunna is cancer lmao

1

u/Pizzanigs . Feb 27 '19

I never got this take. Just because someone doesn’t like something doesn’t mean they “didn’t get it”. He didn’t like it

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/KGeedora Feb 27 '19

In hip hop, I think I only agree with this guy when it comes to something that is clearly amazing. As in..madvillainy, aquemini etc etc. Everything that falls under the top shelf, it's either he loves/I can't stand (Brockhampton, Ab-Soul) or I really like or atleast enjoy, he dislikes (Baby/Gunna) or is lukewarm about (DS2 for example).

2

u/Chimblz Feb 27 '19

Was just talking about DS2 the other day.

Music doesn't always have to be a boombap with lyrical miracle spiritual. While i love Earl, Pusha T and other spitters, i gotta take time and appreciate a good banger project.

104

u/Awhile2 . Feb 27 '19

> claiming gunna has mediocre beat selection when he has some of the best production rn

. > claiming his flows arent special when the sold out date flow (aka the flow gunna overuses admitedly) has been one of the most copied flows in the past year

. >claiming the second half of the album is unmemorable when its got 3 headed snake, on amountain, syn, and who ya foolin, all of which are more memorable than anything on the first half of the album bar richard millie plain and outstanding

idk man i never disagree with fantano as much as i do when he talks about baby or gunna

85

u/fraillimbnursery . Feb 27 '19

Same. I constantly hear from him that they sound identical to Young Thug but I just don’t hear it. They’re cut from the same cloth but not to the point where it’s a burden.

It’s his opinion and all, but it’s crazy to see him trashing Baby and Gunna when nearly every other reviewing outlet rated their album positively

30

u/Awhile2 . Feb 27 '19

Tbf my first few listens of gunna and baby I thought the same but literally after listening to more than a couple songs from them t becomes apparent they sound pretty different from young thug. You’d think given that fantanos definetly listened to full projects by them multiple times to do reviews he would realize that by now tho

5

u/ThePaperZebra Feb 27 '19

Yeah I remember when I first heard oh okay I thought lil baby didn’t have a verse cuz of the way he sounds and it’s placement in the song

→ More replies (1)

12

u/ColePug Feb 27 '19

It’s a lazy comparison and I don’t hear it either. Obviously they have similar vibes they’re both YSL. It’s like saying QC rappers all have the migo flow (damn 2013 called)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/fraillimbnursery . Feb 27 '19

Lol ikr, the production on Pump's latest album was so mediocre compared to this.

5

u/decentusername123 Feb 27 '19

He bashed the production on Harverd Dropout too. It was only on self-titled that he praised it

13

u/Blackassnigga17 Feb 27 '19

Who else uses the “Sold out Dates” flow besides Gunna himself?

17

u/Awhile2 . Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 27 '19

Awhile ago I made a comment listing like 10 songs that did it. I’ll find it in the morning and edit this. Servin H by Kevin Gates is the first one that comes to mind for me though

e: found it

kevin gates - servin h

moneybagg yo - fallin down

kodak black - calling my spirit

rylo rodriguez - bmf

trendz luciano - die 4 the clout

88 mo - bag talk

lil gotit - superstar

also the 88glam song other people already mentioned

3

u/AstroFIJI Feb 27 '19

88GLAM - Purple Baguettes

3

u/MarzDaMonsta Feb 27 '19

That “88” group off of XO Listen to their intro on their most recent project Tory lanes also. his first song off of his most recent project

→ More replies (5)

6

u/pokemonizepic Feb 27 '19

fantanos doesnt really understand trap, he gave savage mode a NOT GOOD, only started dickriding 21 after he became more popular

23

u/wrungle . Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 27 '19

he was one of the first to praise Rodeo and he quite loved Trap Lord, Shadow of a Doubt, Culture, Without Warning and other trap albums from previous years, not to mention Lil Boat, Die Lit, Taboo which is the highest rated trap album on fucking rym lmao; id say he understands it much better than sites like Pitchfork which just slap sevens on everything with 808s on it

→ More replies (10)

2

u/see_four Feb 27 '19

thanks for mentioning richard millie plain. Love that song and no one seems to talk about it

1

u/Favorable Feb 27 '19

You're 100% correct, I also really like the song "idk why" on this project.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

I'll be honest, to me, having an 808 hit and fade over a quarter note with some high hats and a clap or a snare on either the next up or down beat is the sound pretty much all of the songs have. All that happens on top of this is there's another instrument layered on top with a simple cord progression.

Like yes it doesn't sound fuzzy so I guess that's good, but it's the type of best you could write in FL studio after taking 1 music class.

I'm not saying it's awful, and it has a couple songs that did stand out, but I found most of the production uninspired and not at all creative compared to what a lot of people are doing now

1

u/JoeyBrickz . Feb 28 '19

He has some of the most popular producers now but the beats are super mediocre. Nothing stands out about them at all. They all have hard 808s and just super forgettable melodies with no creativity whatsoever. The only beat that sticks out to me is the song ft. Carti but even that was kinda weak.

Also your point about Gunnas glow being one of the most copied flows doesn't help your case. If Gunna invented that flow and made it his own then maybe, but he didn't.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/WhenItsHalfPastFive . Feb 27 '19

I liked Outstanding, One Call, Yao Ming, and Speed it Up. A couple other tolerable songs here and there, but that’s about it. It was a fairly mediocre album, if not a bad album.

Gunna really needs to change up his flow a bit. He sounds way different in interviews, not sure why he’s rapping like he’s underwater on this (maybe with the theme of the drip or drown lol)

I always have this inner debate about who’s better, Gunna or Lil Baby, and honestly Lil baby has had more versatility, and probably even more creativity. Pure Cocaine is better than every track on this album.

7

u/Parrotflies_ Feb 27 '19

People gotta understand he shits on a lot of trap/spacey rnb style stuff because they’re both two of the biggest genres rn and he probably sifts through a shit ton of it. If your actual job was to listen to as much of that stuff as possible you’d probably get tired of it too.

The genre I’ve listened to the most in my life is punk/hardcore, been into it for 15+ years now, so I’m insanely picky about that shit, I don’t wanna listen to some band that’s copying a copy of another band for the 10th time, that shits boring to me. Code Orange won a Grammy and kids new to the genre go ape shit over them, but I think they’re complete ass just because it’s a rip of bands ripping off Disembodied with some industrial elements, it’s just boring for me.

But if I said that to a fan they’d probably just say I’m being too fucking picky or that I only like it when bands are underground or whatever.

Same shit here pretty much I’m sure. It doesn’t mean Gunna’s straight awful music, he’s just heard it enough and Gunna just so happened to be the last straw I think. Same with NAV. I don’t have a problem with Gunna but I’m not putting him on anywhere either, it’s just not my bag. Y’all can still like the shit and it’s valid tho

1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '19

I mean, that might be part of it, but I don't sift through very much in that genre and I think Gunna and Nav are both horribly generic

30

u/Nolar2015 . Feb 27 '19

Ive had it on repeat. Fantano just does not like Baby or Gunna. I thought it had some heat, like insta-main playlist level stuff. Like most rap albums it was too long but im not sure its worth the Red Flannel

I do agree with him saying gunna is hella average tho

5

u/lingolingolingo Feb 27 '19

He gave savage mode a not good lol, idk why people go to him for trap reviews

10

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

I cant really say if i agree or not because as a whole this album is forgettable as fuck but i listen to Who You Foolin, Out the Hood, and Richard Millie Plain constantly

14

u/jlubow224 Feb 27 '19

You didn’t like 3 headed snake?

10

u/_yari_ Feb 27 '19

Uninteresting album, boring, didn’t even notice the Lil Baby feature, who you foolin is heavily overproduced with an underwhelming performance, did have some ok production, 3/10

→ More replies (1)

5

u/TerdSandwich Feb 27 '19

I wish he wouldn't review so many obvious dud hip-hop albums. I like Fantano when he finds artists I haven't heard of or tackles albums of actual quality. I don't need him to spend 10-12 minutes telling me a Gunna or Lil Pump album is going to be trash.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Deistus Feb 27 '19

I personally loved most of what he had on the album. Some just won't click with the simple yet beautiful production and memorable flows that make Gunna's sound. Music is music dawg and opinions are opinions. 8/10

10

u/Meeqohh . Feb 27 '19

and opinions can be bad

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Matt8910 Feb 27 '19

Who the fuck is spending all this gold? Anyways, I actually agree with Fantano on this one. Gunna just sounds wayyyyyy too generic on this. The beats all the sound pretty meh. I don’t even mind Gunna sometimes too. I thought Space Cadet and Lesbian were some of smoothest songs on Metro’s album. He clearly didn’t capture that with this record.

2

u/Loads_of Feb 27 '19

Someone said Gunna like seasoning. Them songs with Carti and Thug go hard. I really liked the Asian flavor on Who You Feelin too. Gunna ain’t all that & the production really has to compliment and carry him more than some other artists imo

2

u/Noself_ Feb 28 '19

I've never really got the appeal of Gunna.

He seems like a Low level B or C-Tier rapper who got big off one song, yet exemplifies everything i don't like/care much in the current landscape of hiphop. To me, he sounds like something i'd listen to if i were really looking for some Thugger music.

4

u/Matt_Stafford Feb 27 '19

I would consider myself a pretty big gunna fan, I absolutely adore drip season 3 front to back, but with that being said this project and his collab album with lil baby have honestly turned me off of gunna as of late. There’s just no soul/spark to the music he’s been making as of late and it’s really disappointing.

Where did the Gunna from Car Sick, Top Off and Pedestrian go? He’s just squandering his potential with this lackluster shit.

3

u/v12a12 . Feb 27 '19

Goddamn with the amount of gold on this post I thought Fantano was gonna give this shit a 10 or something. Good Lord.

Anyway, I mostly agree with Fantano. I think Gunna does come through with an original sound at times. However, I agree that songs on this are strictly worse that those on Drip Harder and Drip Season 3.

9

u/mcdudas Feb 27 '19

I get that he doesn’t like Gunna but this review is just lazy imo. He keeps pushing this narrative that Gunna is just another Thug copycat since he blew up and it’s just not accurate. Was he influenced by Thug? Yes, a lot of artists are. But Gunna has clearly made his own lane by now. Saying his voice is indistinguishable?? His voice is literally one of the best of this new wave in the trap genre and he has made some of the best melodies on several hits this past year. I just can’t understand Fantano’s reasoning.

Also lol at the part where he says Gunna is blatantly copying Beautiful Thugger Girls when he literally was in the project and had an amazing feature?

9

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

I mean he deff sounds and feels like a young thug junior. Just not nearly as creative, all his shit more or less sounds the same honestly

2

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

You understand that having a feature in BTG means nothing right? Having a country/ ballads inspired trap album was Thug's doing, and the sound was tailored towards his style, Gunna having a feature back then doesn't excuse from the fact that he is trying to do the same Thug did back then. Not that hard to understand man.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

There’s only 2 ways you swing when you hear Gunna.

You either love it

Or you hate it

These comments show this exactly.

Personally I love gunna and I can’t explain why, I just do. He’s like an instrument to the beat, it’s amazing to listen to.

13

u/decentusername123 Feb 27 '19

I think Gunna is actually one of the least polarizing artists out right now. In order to be polarizing, you have to be taking risks and doing things different. Gunna is just too generic to get the “love it or hate it” attitude.

The love for the album in the thread just shows the people who like trap and “vibe” music, and the hate for it shows the people who like more lyrically substantial music. There’s not much else to it imo

2

u/Chimblz Feb 27 '19

/discuss

This sums up hip hop conversations anymore.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

I actually enjoyed the album I thought it was relaxing to listen to and it showed off all the different bests gunna could get ahold of.

isn’t that what’s it’s all about now, having the best beats and flow?

6

u/Blankface888 Feb 27 '19

Yes. But he isn't top 100 for either

4

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '19

Ok then who is top 100 and why do u have such a hate boner for gunna, I understand not enjoying him but it gets weird when u all over this thread hating on the man with the same generic reply

→ More replies (2)

2

u/H4SHT4GPlatapus Feb 27 '19

Drip or Drown 2 never should’ve been made. Gunna sounds the exact fucking same on every track and the only thing that saves it is the features. If it was just straight gunna, I might have lost my shit halfway through the album. Drip or Drown 2 is Gunna be on its way to the garbage can. This album had about as much effort put into it as his AMA did.

2

u/theguyfromuncle420 Feb 27 '19

Y’all niggas keep giving this ham gold for these shitty reviews. Please save your money and invest it into something else. In other news; this album fire. Top to bottom. Gunna and baby arrived really out of nowhere and now they everywhere.

1

u/sidTHAkid Feb 27 '19 edited Feb 27 '19

I’m unphased knowing that this dude has no sense of the appeal of Gunna whatsoever. In my honest opinion he has a jaded view of the trap / melodic trap sub genre and that’s ok, but I know for a fact I’m not going to him for a review on a trap tape. Dude praises Lil Pump (I know he just gave his album a 4/10) coining phrases like “this is so ignorant and I love it”. I’m excited to see how fast the discussion thread is filled with “Gunna’s album was dry and every song sounds the same” because it almost certainly happens to many albums after Fantano reviews them. DOD2 wasn’t exactly the greatest piece of music released, but it was NO where near a 2/10.

With highs in Yao Ming, Baby Birkin, and Three Headed Snake; lows in Speed It Up and On a Mountain, I found myself giving this album a high 6. Gunna introduces some grimey, interesting lyricism that rolls off the tongue like:

Constantly dodging the grave, the world is a cage, the planet of apes

Gotta keep the family straight, we know what it takes, the slimiest snakes

I just don’t find how you can call this album “devoid of character” with a track like 3 Headed Snake in there, giving me possibly one of the best first impressions out of any trap track I’ve heard in a WHILE.

1

u/grass_cloud Feb 27 '19

DoD2 was honestly a virtually flawless album. If u were a fan of gunna before (drip season 3, etc.) this is exactly the album u were looking for. 10/10 no cap

I’d honestly say Slime music is a genre of its own