r/btc • • Feb 19 '19

[repost] a reminder on how r/btc and Bitcoin Cash came to be

I realized that many people in this sub still don't have the full history of how Bitcoin Cash came to be.

It goes back to all of the blocked attempts at onchain scaling that were made since 2014. Bitcoin was always supposed to get larger blocks: on that the record is very, very clear. (Edit: correct link here)

Blockstream employees working on the Bitcoin Core project blocked original Bitcoin team members from upgrading Bitcoin Core to support larger blocks, so the original devs created Bitcoin XT, Classic, and Bitcoin Unlimited. By spring/summer 2017, miner support for large blocks had exceeded 50%. Meanwhile, support for Segwit was stuck at around 30%, despite a massive, organized campaign to rid the Bitcoin ecosystem of "up to 90%" of us big block early adopters. Thus, rbtc was born.

When the small block community realized that Segwit was stuck at 30% signaling and big blocks were above 50% they launched UASF / BIP148 and then the subsequent New York bait-and-switch to get Segwit activated anyway. You will note that I and many others realized the NYA was a bait-and-switch from the start.

Activation of Segwit required us to preemptively fork BCH in order to preserve a Segwit-free fork of Bitcoin with full onchain scaling capability which Segwit degrades.

Unfortunately the mining majority went along with the fraudulent New York bait-and-switch and followed the 1MB4EVA chain, expecting that it would lead to the promised 2MB hardfork upgrade. By the time the majority realized that 2MB was never going to happen it was far too late.

Learn more about the tragic attack on Bitcoin scaling here.

150 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

5

u/Stashimi Feb 19 '19

That first link doesn’t seem to direct to the correct place...

7

u/Reelmo Feb 20 '19

Lol. You realize Segwit 2x was completely broken and would have brought the entire chain to a SCREECHING hault, right?

5

u/jessquit Feb 20 '19

Any Core dev was welcome to provide a better upgrade.

1

u/Reelmo Feb 20 '19 edited Feb 20 '19

They did. It's called Segwit. And Lightning.

Also, could you please point out which Blockstream employees blocked anyone from doing anything on Bitcoin...ever...and who they "blocked".

You realize that if such a claim were true (that the entire Bitcoin project could be co-opted by a couple of nobodies from a single company that no one outside of crypto has ever heard of) then Bitcoin is a complete failure anyway.

10

u/jessquit Feb 20 '19

You realize that if such a claim were true (that the entire Bitcoin project could be co-opted by a couple of nobodies from a single company that no one outside of crypto has ever heard of) then Bitcoin is a complete failure anyway.

Hahaha oh no don't worry, if the entire Bitcoin project gets co-opted by a couple of nobodies from a single company that no one outside of crypto has ever heard of, we can always fork the project.

Hahahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahahaha.

-1

u/Reelmo Feb 20 '19 edited Feb 20 '19

Suit yourself. You seem insane.

If it has consensus it's not co-opted. 🤔

Still waiting on those Blockstream employees names.

-1

u/wisequote Feb 20 '19

Just crawl back into a corner and flip upside down like a good cockroach.

2

u/Reelmo Feb 20 '19

That's usually what they say when they're logic breaks down into nonsense.

6

u/CirclejerkBitcoiner Feb 20 '19

Core had nothing to do with the NYA, they didn't agree in the first place.

5

u/scarybeyond Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 20 '19

The agreed with the SegWit part, and that is what they got mysteriously.

Core had nothing to do with it, aside several of them forming a private startup, subverted the Git, and disrupting Bitcoin since 2014 using propaganda and misdirection.

4

u/SatoshisVisionTM Feb 20 '19

Bitcoin was always supposed to get larger blocks

That is still part of the roadmap. Core just wants to exhaust the options of increasing block size by optimizing space usage in the current 1Mb. SegWit is part of that, as is Schnorr, BLS, MAST, etc.

Blockstream employees working on the Bitcoin Core project blocked original Bitcoin team members from upgrading Bitcoin Core to support larger blocks

Because consensus for increasing the block size was missing.

so the original devs created Bitcoin XT, Classic, and Bitcoin Unlimited.

Which would have gotten widespread, majority use, if a blocksize increase carried consensus. It didn't, and all those implementations remained minority versions.

By spring/summer 2017, miner support for large blocks had exceeded 50%

Miners are only a subset of the bitcoin ecosystem. Other users like developers and economic/transacting users did not support large blocks.

Meanwhile, support for Segwit was stuck at around 30%, despite a massive, organized campaign to rid the Bitcoin ecosystem of "up to 90%" of us big block early adopters.

It was stuck because the voting mechanism was flawed. It used BIP-9 activation, meaning that miners had to set flags in the header of each block. SegWit also included a fix for covert AsicBoost, which gives a miner an unfair advantage over others. Since BitMain, the then-dominant mining pool operator, didn't want to see that revenue reduced, they suppressed the activation of SegWit.

Thus, rbtc was born

r/btc existed before all of this, it was effectively taken over and turned into an echo chamber of big block philosophy, mingled with a narrative that censorship in r/bitcoin was hyjacking bitcoin. As if a subreddit is the entirety of the bitcoin development...

When the small block community realized that Segwit was stuck at 30% signaling and big blocks were above 50% they launched UASF / BIP148

UASF was started by a pseudononymous user called shaolinfry. Even if that user was some BlockStream employee secretly paid to begin a campaign against bigger blocks, that still doesn't change the fact that a large amount of users embraced the project, willing to potentially sacrifice the short-term viability of the chain (risking a chainsplit) to preserve what they felt was an important part of the protocol.

and then the subsequent New York bait-and-switch

Core was never part of the New York Agreement. That was a closed-doors agreement by large players (spearheaded by Silbert if I recall correctly), and most of the community was outraged about it. Bitcoin doesn't have leaders.

Activation of Segwit required us to preemptively fork BCH in order to preserve a Segwit-free fork of Bitcoin with full onchain scaling capability which Segwit degrades.

If I recall correctly, BCH was initially going to softfork without a change in versionbyte, which would have risked funds of everyone transacting in just one of the two networks. To my knowledge, this was changed last-minute.

Unfortunately the mining majority went along with the fraudulent New York bait-and-switch

I thought you just mentioned bigger blocks had consensus. If so, why didn't the miners switch to BCH after the NYA turned out to be just what everyone already knew what it was?

By the time the majority realized that 2MB was never going to happen it was far too late.

Why? What reason would a miner have not switching to BCH, if bigger blocks are such an imperative? Switching is not very difficult, and no change in hardware is required. Why hasn't the majority of mining moved to BCH if bigger blocks are what the majority wants and SegWit is so flawed as this sub pretends?

During the first months, BCH used a mechanism of emergency difficulty adjustments to suppress the difficulty enough to prevent the chain from stalling. This was actively exploited by miners, who continually switched between both chains whenever the difficulty of the BCH chain was low enough for it to be lucrative. Why did those miners not stay if bigger blocks were so important? Why did the economic supermajority remain on the BTC chain if adoption was so much better/easier with bigger blocks?

The narrative that drips from your post shows not the past of bitcoin, only the misguided perception of it by the bagholders of BCH. Posts like yours only showcase this false narrative for what it is; misguided, disingenuous, and dishonest.

1

u/jessquit Feb 20 '19

Posts like yours only showcase this false narrative for what it is; misguided, disingenuous, and dishonest.

Oh really?

I think informed readers will consider the fact that your comment will stand here, while my comments would be removed from rbitcoin, and will agree with me that those with truth on their side don't have to censor and ban their opposition.

3

u/SatoshisVisionTM Feb 20 '19

I think anyone with half a brain knows that Bitcoin's future developments aren't in any meaningful sense given direction via r/bitcoin, which is nothing more than a meltingpot of price memes and pictures of lambos.

The Bitcoin dev mailing list, crypto Twitter, crypto podcasts, conferences, and hackatons are where the development happens. It is there where thought leaders gather. And it is the combined opinion of the entire userbase to decide what Bitcoin is and isn't.

2

u/xGsGt Feb 21 '19

the best post here.

41

u/lubokkanev Feb 19 '19

This is one of the most important pieces of information a cryptocurrency supporter (not a speculator) needs to know!

31

u/Egon_1 Bitcoin Enthusiast Feb 19 '19

Dude .... This is an excellent summary!!!

16

u/bearjewpacabra Feb 19 '19 edited Feb 19 '19

I and many others realized the NYA was a bait-and-switch from the start.

Anyone without their head up their ass knew this... sadly, many had their head up their ass due to a bullshit narrative of 'working together' or 'anti tribalism'. Well, you see where that got everyone.

I'd like to remind all of the 'reach across the aisle' bullshit altruism pumping vote for the lesser of two evils folk of this quote... which inevitably becomes reality at some point in any civilizations history:

“Every normal man must be tempted, at times, to spit on his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats.”

― H.L. Mencken

There is an incredibly fine line between peaceful/productive collectivism and literal rape.

13

u/phro Feb 20 '19 edited Aug 04 '24

head combative compare quaint rock hobbies obtainable brave frighten dime

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

9

u/scarybeyond Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 20 '19

Well Greg and Adam and Luke came to "consensus", so SegWit was fine, not an altcoin. Removing Satoshi's temporary limit was an altcoin though, clearly.

8

u/SnowBastardThrowaway Feb 19 '19

When the small block community realized that Segwit was stuck at 30% signaling and big blocks were above 50% they launched UASF / BIP148 and then the subsequent New York bait-and-switch to get Segwit activated anyway

The small block community and the people who proposed segwit2x are not the same people. 50 corporations lied to everyone about segwit2x (or maybe thought it would actually work) in order to save face in a bull market. The miners who fell for it or anyone else who fell for it has only themselves to blame. "This guy Jeff Garzik is gonna code this thing up and we are all suddenly gonna come to a middle ground hardfork durrrrrrrrr..... surely these people who strongly oppose hardforks without overwhelming consensus will suddenly do this hardfork durrrrrrr"

By spring/summer 2017, miner support for large blocks had exceeded 50%.

So nowhere near the level needed for a hardfork. Hence the true hardfork not happening. This whole wanting to have your cake and eat it too argument form big blockers gets so old: "There was consensus for big blocks!" "We didn't get the fork we wanted!" Which is it?

Activation of Segwit required us to preemptively fork BCH in order to preserve a Segwit-free fork of Bitcoin

Ironically, this helped get Segwit activated as much as anything, but let's just ignore that.

Unfortunately the mining majority went along with

They are gonna go along with the market in the end, period. Code up your emergency difficulty adjustments, sue exchanges for not using the right tickers, whatever... miners are protocol security who get paid for their service. Their job is literally to mine the most profitable chain, not to determine the chain. UASF showed us all of this very clearly, or at least the miners never called the bluff.

6

u/stale2000 Feb 20 '19

What we are saying is that there was a better tactical decision that could have happened.

The better tactical plan would have been to refuse to activate segwit via the method that Core implemented, and ONLY do a fork that included both segwit and the 2X hardfork. IE, don't activate the segwit bit at all. Just leave it unactivated.

This would have forced old nodes to either follow the new chain, or follow the legacy chain that had neither segwit or the hardfork activated.

unfortunately people were dumb, and used the activation method that core was advocating for. It was a huge mistake to trust Core on this matter.

1

u/SnowBastardThrowaway Feb 20 '19

What we are saying is that there was a better tactical decision that could have happened.

The better tactical plan would have been to refuse to activate segwit via the method that Core implemented, and ONLY do a fork that included both segwit and the 2X hardfork. IE, don't activate the segwit bit at all. Just leave it unactivated.

This would have forced old nodes to either follow the new chain, or follow the legacy chain that had neither segwit or the hardfork activated.

unfortunately people were dumb, and used the activation method that core was advocating for.

Yes, the big block camp shoulda coded this up and made it happen then. Instead they made BCH and basically gave miners a reason to just go forward with BIP148 on BTC. Glad to see you guys taking some responsibility.

It was a huge mistake to trust Core on this matter.

Core never said they would do the 2x part. This is like the only point I'm trying to get across to you guys and you just refuse to acknowledge it. The NYA agreement folks did not include Core.

1

u/stale2000 Feb 20 '19

Core never said they would do the 2x part.

Some people on the Core side of the debate did, actually. It was a huge mistake to believe anything that these individuals said.

1

u/SnowBastardThrowaway Feb 20 '19

I don't think miners were counting on the 2x part coming through at all TBH. I think everyone pretending it might happen kind of saved face while segwit was activated. Once BCH was out there, miners had their bases covered for either scaling direction, so their businesses were secure. At that point, they were happy to enable segwit imo.

It's highly ironic, but I think BCH being created was the #1 factor that got segwit activated.

3

u/segregatemywitness Feb 20 '19

Liar with fake upvotes ^

3

u/etherael Feb 20 '19

The small block community and the people who proposed segwit2x are not the same people.

[You are full of shit.] (https://twitter.com/ErikVoorhees/status/928470570663997440)

So nowhere near the level needed for a hardfork.

[We can tell when you are lying, because your mouth moves.] (https://490z7i45htbb1f4tty9mdpi6-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Percentage-of-blocks-signalling-SegWit-Support.png)

UASF showed us all of this very clearly, or at least the miners never called the bluff.

[You are a disgusting lying sack of shit.] (https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*9PGe756Vv1y9B_aoyQQbWg.png)

2

u/SnowBastardThrowaway Feb 20 '19

What do you eric tweet prove? That he is happy we got segwit?

And a chart showing 36% segwit signalling is a counterpoint to me saying there wasn't consensus for a hardfork?

And lastly you show that segwit2x used Core's BIP 148 and that's supposed to prove what?

You quote me 3 times and provide links after those quotes that are not related to what you quoted at all.

0

u/etherael Feb 20 '19

You do not understand the concept of causality. Or you pretend not to, since in all three cases you got it backwards. Either way you're still wrong. The question is just if it's because you're an idiot or you're lying.

1

u/TheBTC-G Feb 20 '19

Thank you for trying to counter misinformation. In fairness to OP, I don’t think he intends to deceive but simply has a biased, skewed, and inaccurate view of past events.

6

u/where-is-satoshi Feb 20 '19

What misinformation?

What is skewed?

What bias?

What inaccurate view?

OP provided references, you provided your opinion.

-4

u/isrly_eder Feb 20 '19

I wonder what the BCH people think they can do here to reverse their fortunes? By literally every conceivable metric, BCH is in the dustbin. Block usage, txcount, tx value, active addresses, developer enthusiasm, commits, startups, enthusiasm on social media. It's totally moribund. Bitmain owned >11% of all outstanding BCH coins a few months ago and still has 600k to sell. Amazingly, BCH became recentralized in ownership, undoing all the hard work from actual bitcoiners. Not to mention aligning themselves with an obvious conman in an attempt to win short term hype from the total knuckledraggers who believed that CSW was telling the truth.

What have they accomplished in all this? All they've done is lose their own money, and the money of the dupes dumb enough to believe in the charade of endlessly large blocks.

3

u/throwawayo12345 Feb 19 '19

Ah yes. Extension Blocks. Basically the concept being pushed by Paul Sztorc to save BTC.

Not going to happen.

(Would be nice if we took his tech and had a privacy drivechain on BCH though)

3

u/segregatemywitness Feb 20 '19

Exactly how it went down. I love the blockstream astroturfers in the comments blatantly scrambling to gaslight things. Scumbags.

3

u/dnick Feb 19 '19

Why was it far too late? If segwit + 2x is what the majority legitimately wanted, what is stopping someone from branching with segwit and 2x blocksize?

Why the 'pre-emptive' fork if the majority seemed to want something different? If I had to guess it's because of the preemptive fork that made a fork afterwards unlikely to succeed, while doing nothing and then forking after segwit and simply adding a larger blocksize, against the wishes of the core team, would have likely succeeded easily, both in terms of technology and user sentiment.

4

u/stale2000 Feb 20 '19

Why was it far too late?

It was too late because segwit had already been activated.

The better solution would have been to join these 2 things together. IE, don't activate the segwit bit that was used by old nodes. That way old nodes would either have to follow the new chain, that had segwit and the hard fork, OR, they would have to follow a legacy chain that did not have segwit activated.

1

u/dnick Feb 20 '19

Right, but 'its far to late' in the sense that we have a handful of miners deciding things, not because the protocol is difficult to change or organize. If it was thousands of people deciding this, any one of the previous, or any new, software could be decided by decentralized consensus...the way it is now, you would personally need to fly to china, get an appointment with the owner of one of the mining firms, say pretty or ugly things to convince him to go along with your idea, rinse and repeat 5 times, and then come back to this forum and tell us how it went. Right now there aren't many people or platforms with that kind of pull.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '19

[deleted]

1

u/dnick Feb 20 '19

Every big decision like this seems to come back to 5-6 people in blockstream...and it's because every big decision like this only relies on convincing 5-6 other people to agree with them. Take blockstream out of the picture and it's 5-6 other people doing the convincing, but the same 5-6 people that need to be convinced. Whatever you might think about that 'other' group of people pulling the strings, the fact that we're talking about that scale of involvement at all is the devastating part...the blocksize issue is practically irrelevant next to it and basically is just shining a spotlight on an issue that will probably otherwise be ignored.

2

u/saddit42 Feb 19 '19

great summary!

1

u/phro Feb 20 '19

Is there still a way to view signalling history over time? I suppose one could analyze the blocks directly, but is there a working tool that does it as cleanly as coindance did?

1

u/qEAQNC3 Feb 20 '19

Please sticky

0

u/saggy777 Feb 19 '19

It's confusing. Isn't bitcoin core a wallet??

2

u/scarybeyond Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 20 '19

Bitcoin Core is technically an enterprise client, as are most, meant to be run on professional grade hardware and networking. They do have wallet functionality technically but are not usually used for that as a day to day user, end users would use wallets using SPV(Simplified Payment Verification) that does not require hosting the entire blockchain.

Quit downvoting legitimate questions you hethens

1

u/-Erick_ Feb 19 '19

what do you mean?

-13

u/rogver Feb 19 '19

A reminder of how Bitcoin Cash came to be.

ViaBTC was founded in May 2016, in China, & raised around ¥20 million (approx $3 million) in a Series A round led by Bitmain, also from China.

Asked about the other investors, CCN was told by ViaBTC, that “besides Bitmain, there’s a couple of private investors who are not ready to reveal themselves now.”

SegWit was activated on Bitcoin BTC on August 23, 2017. At roughly the same time, the launch of a Bitcoin clone - Bitcoin Cash (without Segwit) was announced by the Chinese bitcoin exchange and mining pool ViaBTC.

This fork with an expanded block size limit was first described by hardware manufacturer Bitmain in June 2017 as a "contingency plan".

Leaked documents from Bitmain’s pre-IPO investor deck show that, as of March 31, 2018, Bitmain owns more than 1 Million bitcoin cash (BCH)!

14

u/wisequote Feb 19 '19

Yes, BCH didn’t swallow the poison-pill soft-forked Segwit; we’re old school and on chain and we will dominate your collective asses Blockstream fanbois.

-4

u/jakesonwfw Feb 19 '19

SegWit bad CTOR good right.

9

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Feb 19 '19

1.) Segwit was activated on August 24, that's when I turned off my node and backed ledger for sentimental purposes. Not 23 I think.

2.) ViaBTC was created. Ok

3.) ViaBTC has couple of anonymous private investors and Bitmain.

4.) ViaBTC listed BCH. Or do you mean something else?

5.) Bitmain said few months after BCH was created that BCH is contingency plan (I call it hope, but anyway)

6.) Bitmain owns over 1000000 BCH.

I have made points to understand better your message. Can you please correct me if I have made a mistake and after that, tell me how does it relate to Bitcoin Cash creation?

-9

u/rogver Feb 19 '19

tell me how does it relate to Bitcoin Cash creation?

An economic minority, led by Haipo Yang of ViaBTC created the Bitcoin Cash fork at block height 478559. This created a new chain with a permanent incompatible rule change against the original Bitcoin network.

Source: https://medium.com/@jcliff/the-bitcoin-cash-story-e55b277491f9

12

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Feb 19 '19 edited Feb 19 '19

Do you have any proof that ViaBTC created Bitcoin Cash?

I thought it was BU and ABC devs.

Edit: I read the article. Full of shit. No proof to claim that ViaBTC created BCH though.

1

u/cheekbut_on_a_stick Feb 19 '19

Amaury thanks Jihan in the conferences held at the beginning of the movement. I guess that's the financial backer.

1

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Feb 19 '19

Financial backer. Very broad meaning. Doesn't say he is in any way creator. Maybe he joined as soon as he notice how awesome bitcoin cash is and backed it up? Who knows?

1

u/cheekbut_on_a_stick Feb 19 '19

The actual creator of this iteration of Bitcoin is Amaury. It started as a pet project of him and afterwards it developed in a full project. He says that himself.

Given that he goes to that lenght of publicly thanking Jihan, we can assume with a higher degree of certainty who is the financial backer.

2

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Feb 19 '19

Ok, who is the backer. There is plenty of backers. Financially too.

It looks like all my respondents today can't give me the proof that viaBtc or bitmain created bitcoin cash, but all jump to conclusion.

Quality of argument seems to be very weak then. Most likely to slander bitcoin cash and its creation hence purpose.

Noughty.

1

u/cheekbut_on_a_stick Feb 19 '19 edited Feb 20 '19

Fiancial backers have been and probably still are Jihan and Roger.

Dev backer and actual creator is Amaury

Edit: Also Amaury was mainly talking about Bitcoin Cash at conferences held by Coingeek as the official sponsor. We know where Coingeek stands in present day. The history is very gray, not even remotely black or white.

2

u/MarchewkaCzerwona Feb 20 '19

So why those comments about it being created by bitmain or viaBtc if there is no proof?

Malicious behaviour, don't you think?

→ More replies (0)

6

u/Licho92 Feb 19 '19

in China

also from China

I don't give a fuck about your American prejudice. I'm from Europe and this economic war of yours is petty from my perspective. Bitcoin is global, not American and it is for every one. American, African, European, Asian, Australian, Antarctican and Atlantisian.

-10

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '19

Definitely accurate but we left out a couple of key points. Operation dragon slayer was designed to break Bitcoin and replace it with bcash. You see Roger and Jihan think the majority of the crypto Community are nothing but gamblers and they want to exploit and use you. Step one was controlling the majority of the coins and hashrate. Step 2 was supposed to be flippening Bitcoin. That obviously never happened and now they are trying to recover money by drawing in as many people as possible to hold their bags as they slowly exit. I'm fairly sure if their plan had been successful after 5 years or so they would have found some problem with bch and Forked again which of course would enhance their wealth and give a new narrative for people to buy into

Currently, you may notice that almost every Post in here is made by someone with a four-year-old account. It's a little suspect that they are all the same age within a couple of months and even more suspect that they are the majority of the communication. There are no new people. There is no actual adoption. It's all marketing

3

u/taipalag Feb 19 '19

Dragonslayer was a prank and play on the Dragon Den’s nonsense from the Blockstream side.

Jeez, you guys are so gullible and naïve.

-3

u/rogver Feb 19 '19

Definitely accurate but we left out a couple of key points.

Thanks for filling in the additional key points. I remember how excited everyone in r/btc was about Operation Dragon Slayer!

Operation Dragon Slayer failed massively. At the height of the excitement (pump and dump?), BCH was worth 0.2BTC, and even higher on 1 exchange, and now BCH is worth 0.03BTC.

The dragon (BTC) hasn't been slain. Bitcoin is stronger then ever, and ready for the next bull run!

Currently, you may notice that almost every Post in here is made by someone with a four-year-old account.

I hadn't noticed. Reminder to self, pay more attention!

0

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '19

[deleted]

-6

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '19

Dude your entire Post history is marketing bcash and you even have a fake flare. Your account age is not less than 6 months old. This one was created around the time of the btc/bch fork. Maybe it's part of the new batch?

Seriously, every single thing coming out of your account is about Bcash

Every. Single. Thing.

You guys have one shot at an exit scam. Fake enough traffic and pump up enough hype that some naive investors buy into this and let you get out without a collapse.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '19

[deleted]

2

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Feb 19 '19

It’s fixed.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '19

[deleted]

1

u/BitcoinXio Moderator - Bitcoin is Freedom Feb 20 '19

Done.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '19

[deleted]

-2

u/isrly_eder Feb 20 '19

They just sold half of their BCH and are holding the rest at a loss hoping they can liquidate them, but there's no volume, because no one wants to buy Bcash. They made their bet, recentralizing ownership (they owned 11% of all of the 9m BCH that were ever activated at one point), and now they're dumping their stash trying to stave off bankruptcy. If you think a failing ASIC manufacturer is going to be your savior youre in for a rough time.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '19

[deleted]

-2

u/BOMinvest Redditor for less than 90 days Feb 19 '19

Why is it racist?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '19

[deleted]

-2

u/BOMinvest Redditor for less than 90 days Feb 20 '19

I just see it as a statement of fact. I read it as descriptive text along with the rest of the descriptive text, describing that ViaBTC operates within the same country as Bitmain.

I might suggest that you read it with a certain sensitivity to such things.

-4

u/isrly_eder Feb 20 '19

You know Bitcoin (the real, and only Bitcoin) blocks are well over 1mb now and have been for a while right? How do you square that with your narrative?

Also... Bcash blocks are a miserable, well, 30kb on average these days. What do you need that block space for, exactly?

4

u/scarybeyond Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 20 '19

There it is, another "bcash" trolltard for RES.

Who's sock are you?

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '19

Marketing man. Bcash is the real bitcoin after all. 12 out of 6 people agree. Give roger your money and help him unload his bags

-6

u/xGsGt Feb 20 '19

Segwit is over 50% and increasing, Satoshi is not Jesús and the whitepaper is not the gospel, this is software and it evolves

5

u/scarybeyond Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 20 '19

Wow 50% in 1.5 years, impressive...

-2

u/xGsGt Feb 20 '19

compared to the increased of bcash transactions is a lot, amount of transactions in 2017 8k average, 10k now in 1.5years rofl

5

u/scarybeyond Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 20 '19

Nice straw man but why don't we stay on topic of how SegShit is still 50% away from the 100% adoption you same idiots kept saying was required for SegWit transactions to have a full scaling effect.

Why does the BTC ecosystem not give a shit about using SegWit?

-3

u/xGsGt Feb 20 '19

hahaha get owned :) get triggered much.

5

u/scarybeyond Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 20 '19

So you have nothing useful to say and are another fuckstick "bcash" troll in here, thanks for the confirmation that I can downvote all of your future posts with extreme prejudice.

1

u/xGsGt Feb 20 '19

right same ppl that said "segshit" and calling idiots in the same post is asking for some "respect" the increase of segwit transactions does implies that the ecosystem is caring, is not dropping and its increasing :) good post redditor from 60days ago, get triggered snowflake

-13

u/mccoyster Feb 19 '19

"Here's the weekly propaganda post guys!"

15

u/ShadowOfHarbringer Feb 19 '19

"Here's the weekly propaganda post guys!"

When it's the truth, it cannot be propaganda.

Go back to Wikipedia or dictionary and stop wasting our time with useless shit.

-7

u/mccoyster Feb 19 '19

Funny, my thoughts exactly. : )

9

u/ShadowOfHarbringer Feb 19 '19

Funny, my thoughts exactly. : )

Funny, you are full of shit :)

2

u/JerryGallow Feb 20 '19

The only people who think this is propaganda are those people who weren’t here to see it happen. OP seems to have accurately summed up the events as recall them happening.

0

u/tomjodh Feb 21 '19

This just tells me you're a poor loser.

-11

u/mqpickens Feb 19 '19

Several narcissistic opportunists that's how how it happened.

12

u/LovelyDay Feb 19 '19

Wrong. Unless you are talking about some Blockstream founders, who should get a little credit for causing the fork.

-1

u/mqpickens Feb 19 '19

Not wrong. I was there. Witnessed everything.

7

u/Jamocrypto Feb 19 '19

Compelling argument, I guess I'll just have to take your word for it against all the facts presented in the opening post.

-3

u/mqpickens Feb 19 '19

Cheery picked and misconstrued "facts". FTFY

2

u/LovelyDay Feb 20 '19

I was also there, since the XT days, and the hard fork attempts (actually, just to upgrade the blocksize limit) were sincere and no scams.

The people asking for them were no scammers, to call them such is dishonest.

-6

u/BCoina Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 20 '19

BEWARE WARNING PSA

Tell us again what to think.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '19 edited Feb 20 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/segregatemywitness Feb 21 '19

So your plan is to pretend like the censorship, manipulation, lies, take-over of all the social media channels, and usurping of the development team working on bitcoin-qt didn't happen, because it has the longest chain?

It's fine to acknowledge that BTC has more proof of work, but pretending like history doesn't exist because of that fact is sheer idiocy.