r/btc • u/unstoppable-cash • Feb 18 '19
Quote FreeTrader: "Decentralization is dependent on widespread usage..."
40
u/pecuniology Feb 18 '19
The economic naiveté of those who support making the temporary blocksize cap kludge permanent is mind-crushing.
-34
u/rogver Feb 18 '19
The economic naiveté of those who support making the temporary blocksize cap kludge permanent is mind-crushing.
The main problem with increasing the blocksize further on Bitcoin BTC, is that fewer people will be able to run a full node that verifies transactions and thereby increases security of the blockchain.
Decentralization is dependent on security of Bitcoin BTC blockchain, which depends on node count, not blocksize! Node count on BTC chain, has increased to over 10,000 nodes,
This is why BTC transaction volume are approaching all time highs of Dec 2017 again, as investors show, that they trust BTC.
Successful Layer 2 solutions, like Lightning Network and Liquid, will enable millions of transactions per second, whilst keeping Layer 1 free for people that want the extra security and are willing to pay higher fees for moving BTC!
17
u/ricardotown Feb 18 '19
Can you point to a single person who is capable of both effectively mining BTC and incapable of setting up a computer decent enough to run a node?
You said yourself it needs to be a full node. If you can show me a raspberry pi that has successfully found a block on the BTC chain in the last 2 years, I'll concede my argument. But a raspberry pi hanging out by itself without mining is not a full node.
32
u/segregatemywitness Feb 18 '19
No, dumbass. It's two intersecting curves.
If the difficulty of running a node is 10x in order to increase the amount of adoption 100x, you have 100x more users, and even though it's 10x harder to run a node, you still end up with 10x more nodes being run, because you have 100x more users.
There's a point where increasing the blocksize becomes a centralization issue, but we are no where CLOSE to that with 1MB blocks.
You are what the OP is talking about. Your idiocy is unbelievable. I believe it's not idiocy, but malice.
13
9
u/SILENTSAM69 Feb 18 '19
Yes, but it is a myth to think that raising the blocksize will make it too hard to run a node. Increasing the blocksize would have little to jo impact on the node count at all.
Also the node count does not make a blockchain decentralized either. Miners make the system decentralized. Non-minig nodes make no difference in decentralisation.
Non-mining nodes are more about self confirming that a transaction was broadcast to the network. Not confirming the transaction itself though, as that is again gone by the miners.
2
u/pecuniology Feb 19 '19
The main problem with increasing the blocksize further on Bitcoin BTC, is that fewer people will be able to run a full node that verifies transactions and thereby increases security of the blockchain.
That's not why the temporary 1 MB blocksize cap kludge was implemented.
Successful Layer 2 solutions, like Lightning Network and Liquid, will enable millions of transactions per second...
All statements made in the future tense are hypotheses, and not facts.
2
u/Adrian-X Feb 19 '19
The real problem with increasing the 1MB limit is it could stop people using BCH and BSV.
When I ask my friends why they don't run a node they never say because it's too expensive. They have no need to run a node.
There is no need to have users run a node. Users just need SPV.
22
u/phro Feb 18 '19 edited Aug 04 '24
fuzzy fall memorize vase pen wipe overconfident summer far-flung scale
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
22
u/hapticpilot Feb 18 '19
Both BTC and BCH are tiny right now. A single government can easily amass enough PoW to bring them both down via 51% attacks.
For BCH or BTC to survive governments (something it needs to be able to survive), it must get much more highly valued so that it attracts much more hash rate. To do this, it must get much more popular. To get much more popular... it needs MUCH BIGGER BLOCKS.
... and no... the LN obviously isn't a substitute for bigger blocks.
IIRC one of the two guys that first created the LN (J. Poon) said that BTC would need at least 130 MB blocks to be able to handle a large load. Even that isn't sufficient though; the LN design has a very poor UX, so it would never get to the point of saturating 130MB blocks to begin with because average people wouldn't want to use it.
15
u/Erumara Feb 19 '19
It's also important to remember that the paper's co-author Rusty Russell printed his expectations for the current model and with 1M users the typical Lightning Node will require over 100GB/day in bandwidth just for basic connectivity.
That means that there will never be a real mobile wallet (only SPV or custodial, destroying any argument that it's an improvement over BCH) and 95%+ of the world will never have the resources to run their own full LN node at all.
How can you have a decentralized network when only the richest and most privileged 5% of humanity can actually create their own channels? You can't.
Edit: forgot the link
https://medium.com/@rusty_lightning/lightning-routing-rough-background-dbac930abbad
4
u/horsebadlydrawn Feb 19 '19
A single government can easily amass enough PoW to bring them both down via 51% attacks.
Are you sure about that? I think they tried that with SV. And they failed spectacularly.
2
5
u/shevchou Feb 19 '19
Im not a core troll but look at Google products, they are very widespread but very centralized.
0
u/unstoppable-cash Feb 18 '19
0
2
u/a17c81a3 Feb 19 '19
Decentralization of nodes matters however Bitcoin Cash is nowhere near being run on a single large data center and likely never will be.
3
u/oceaniax Feb 18 '19
There's different kinds of decentralization. You can have every single person in the world using it, but if few run full nodes and everyone relies on the mining efforts of a concentrated group, the masses are not protected from the shenanigans of a few bad actors.
I'll pass.
12
u/jessquit Feb 18 '19
How many different actors, each in different locations /jurisdictions, do you think Bitcoin needs in order to maintain its primary value of censorship-resistance?
4
u/segregatemywitness Feb 18 '19
I don't think it's about the number of actors. The expense of running the full node is what is important.
As long as a group of 1st world income hobbyists can get together in a "club" and run a full node, we're totally safe.
It's about nodes being cheap enough to run where it's not cost effective for any one state actor, or bank sponsored entity to try and control all of the nodes.
I put the bar around the cost of a high-end consumer PC.
Nodes are far less of a centralization risk than mining. It's unbelievable that BTC proper has a 1MB blocksize limit in 2019.
6
u/SILENTSAM69 Feb 18 '19
Technically even BCH with mostly full blocks is very easy for individuals in developed nations to run. BTC wants nodes to be cheap enough for the world poorest people to be able to run.
Which is absurd since high fees already make the world poorest priced out using BTC in the first place. It makes no sense to have a network cheap enough to be supported by people who can not afford the fees of that network.
2
u/horsebadlydrawn Feb 19 '19
It's about nodes being cheap enough to run
This is the kind of crap that gets you believing assholes like Greg and Luke...
I am running FIVE different nodes simultaneously on a single VPS which is $10 per month. That's literally a fraction of the total amortized cost of running several Raspberry Pies on my home Internet connection. Forget about cost of running a node - it's nominally zero for anyone serious about crypto. It does require some technical skill which not everyone has. But somebody can easily sell nodes as a service.
3
u/segregatemywitness Feb 19 '19 edited Feb 19 '19
Don't equate what I wrote with those assholes.
What you are running today is completely irrelevant.
I'm talking about running a full node on an optimized bitcoin client with much larger blocks and orders of magnitude more users/transactions.
And don't feed me that CSW bullshit about only "mining nodes" mattering. There are legitimate reasons to have a full node available to power users/businesses etc that aren't necessarily mining at a non-astronomical price point using today's hardware.
3
u/oceaniax Feb 18 '19
That's a great question, I wish I had an answer. Perhaps the best wisdom with a nascent technology with many unknowns would be to err on the side of caution.
5
u/segregatemywitness Feb 18 '19
Way too vague a response. This vagueness is the excuse that blockstream core is using to keep it at 1MB.
I think as long as the cost is a very high-end PC, say 2500/y in today's USD, that's totally acceptable and makes it economically infeasible to "regulate" every node all over the world.
The cost could even be higher than that pretty safely. We could easily have 50MB blocks right now and not have centralization. With pruning, much much larger.
3
u/oceaniax Feb 18 '19
> Way too vague a response.
Would you rather I lie? Neither you or I know how much decentralization is "too much". What I CAN say is if you want people to feel secure in storing their money on the chain and using it for significant transactions more is better than less, particularly with something so new.
When you come up with a magic tool that can assure everyone in this space and the public at large how much security is enough, let me know.
1
u/dnick Feb 18 '19
So what would the blocksize be with that high end pc and the average US bandwidth.
1
u/Zer000sum Feb 19 '19
It's trivial to run a BTC node with $1000 PC and 1 TB SSD. Unlimited bandwidth is pretty standard at < $100 per month. So you could double block size easy for foreseeable future.
5
u/SILENTSAM69 Feb 18 '19
You seem confused on this issue. Even if every person in the world ran a node it would still only be the miners who verify transactions. Only miners matter when it comes to decentralisation.
Non-mining nodes only verify a transaction was broadcast to the network. They do not verify the transaction itself. Non-mining nodes offer now protection from bad actors other than letting you see the actions. Non-mining nodes should really be called observers. You have miners, and observers. Both are nodes, but only miners do any work.
All crypto minig relies on the efforts of miners. As long as we can see that there are various mining groups competing with one a other we can see the system is decentralized.
1
1
u/jaykujawski Feb 19 '19
But power generation was once decentralized until there was so much widespread usage that individual factories stopped generating their own power and power companies rose to provide more efficient power.
1
u/FlipDetector Feb 19 '19
That is what I'm talking about. A Decentralised distributed network means if they destroy parts of it, there will still be route to connect any peer to any other peer. Storing a local raw DB doesn't serve the purpose! In IT these local backups are nothing more than a lab where you can test things. Your soft wallet stores the last few blocks anyway to see if your output is unspent. That doesn't need to be the whole chain. If you think it is a good idea, just read the white paper specifically this part:
7. Reclaiming Disk Space
"Once the latest transaction in a coin is buried under enough blocks, the spent transactions before it can be discarded to save disk space. To facilitate this without breaking the block's hash, transactions are hashed in a Merkle Tree [7][2][5], with only the root included in the block's hash. Old blocks can then be compacted by stubbing off branches of the tree. The interior hashes do not need to be stored."
1
u/Shichroron Feb 18 '19
The USD is probably one of the most widely spread currencies, does it make it decentralized?
3
Feb 19 '19
I think that's a strawman. Theres other qualifiers, usage is like a multiplier
3
u/Shichroron Feb 19 '19
Well the title says Decentralization is dependent on widespread usage. Of course is not the only factor, but if the title still stands it worth asking what about the USD
2
-2
u/HashCatchEm Feb 18 '19
Visa is decentralized!
3
4
-1
u/FlipDetector Feb 19 '19
Visa is not Centralised. It is a single payment processor, they can freeze your card any time. If you bomb the city where they have their servers it will stop working. That is not a distributed system like the internet. A distributed system has to keep working in an event of a disaster even though it doesn't really have a disaster recovery plan with lots of unused resources.
0
u/Big_Bubbler Feb 19 '19
Real decentralization will require both wide use and nerdy basement-type solutions. Arguing one part against another is always somewhat true I suppose.
0
u/KnowMyself Feb 19 '19
If you are sick of economically naive guys, crypto is not the space for you.
-1
-1
0
-4
24
u/deadalnix Feb 18 '19
/!\ I do not think this is /u/freetrader who helped creating Bitcoin Cash.